JP2020025370A - Adjustment force monitoring device and method - Google Patents

Abstract

To provide an adjustment force monitoring device which supports propriety determination of adjustment force necessary for maintaining the system frequency of an electric system.SOLUTION: An adjustment force monitoring device according to the invention comprises a variable period for monitoring adjustment force necessary for an electric system, a data input part for inputting a monitor time interval for monitoring the necessary adjustment force, a prediction demand database for storing a power demand prediction value for each monitor time interval, a necessary adjustment force calculation part for calculating the necessary adjustment force with the power demand prediction value as input, and a response time dependent adjustment force calculation part for calculating a deviation between the calculated necessary adjustment force and a plan adjustment force for each variable period.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1

Description

  The present invention relates to a technique for monitoring power (hereinafter referred to as “adjusting power”) required when performing frequency control and supply / demand balance adjustment of an electric power system.

  As a technique related to the adjusting force, there is a technique described in Patent Document 1, for example.

  Patent Document 1 states that “the power system monitoring and control apparatus 10 calculates the demand in the designated area using the system measurement data D1, the system equipment data D2, and the setting data D3, and calculates the calculated demand data D7 and setting data D3. Is used to estimate the demand fluctuation width in the designated fluctuation cycle, and the correlation between the fluctuation cycle and the demand fluctuation width is estimated using the calculated demand fluctuation width estimation result data D8 and the setting data D3, and the calculated correlation is calculated. An adjustment force is determined using the estimation result data D9, the system equipment data D2, and the adjustment force data D4, and one of the calculation result of the demand of the designated area, the demand fluctuation width estimation result, the correlation estimation result, and the adjustment force determination result. Or a plurality is displayed on the screen. "

JP 2016-86461 A

  By 2020, a market that can procure and trade flexible coordination power (supply / supply adjustment market) is being created, and studies are under way to more efficiently secure coordination power. Under the new licensing scheme, the current electric power company will be a general electric power company that controls the frequency of power supply areas and adjusts supply and demand. When procuring necessary coordination power (short-term supply and demand adjustment capacity), it is important for general electric utilities to procure coordination power through public offering because it is important to avoid preferential treatment for specific power sources and avoid excessive cost burdens. I have.

  At present, power companies secure coordination at the planning stage based on the results of demand forecasting. However, when a large amount of renewable energy is connected to the power grid, the output fluctuation of renewable energy changes every moment due to weather changes, so the grid frequency at the time of actual supply and demand is maintained with the adjustment power secured at the planning stage It is unknown whether it can be done.

  According to the technique described in Patent Literature 1, even when the correlation between the fluctuation period and the demand fluctuation width changes, it is possible to determine the lack of the adjusting power in a specific fluctuation period. However, there is no disclosure of a technique for determining the ability to follow the adjusting force at each time due to the restriction on the output change speed of the generator constituting the adjusting force at each time.

  The present invention has been made in view of the above circumstances, and an object of the present invention is to provide an adjusting force monitoring device that supports determination of whether or not an adjusting force necessary for maintaining a system frequency of an electric power system.

  In order to solve the above-mentioned problem, an adjusting force monitoring device according to the present invention includes a data input unit for inputting a fluctuation cycle for monitoring a required adjusting force of a power system, a monitoring time interval for monitoring the required adjusting force, A predicted demand-supply database that stores predicted power demand values for each time interval, a required adjustment force calculation unit that calculates a required adjustment force using the predicted power demand value as an input, and a change cycle of the calculated required adjustment force and the planned adjustment force And a response time adjustment force calculating unit for calculating a deviation of

  Advantageous Effects of Invention According to the present invention, it is possible to provide an adjusting force monitoring device that supports determination of whether or not an adjusting force required for maintaining a system frequency of an electric power system.

FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a functional configuration of an adjustment force monitoring device 1000 according to the first embodiment. FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of an adjustment force monitoring device 1000 according to the first embodiment. 5 illustrates the stored contents of a program database 60 according to the first embodiment. FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of a processing flow of the adjustment force monitoring device 1000 according to the first embodiment. FIG. 5 is a conceptual diagram illustrating a change in demand L with respect to time t according to the first embodiment. FIG. 4 is a conceptual diagram of each control region with respect to a demand fluctuation cycle according to the first embodiment. FIG. 9 is a diagram illustrating an example of a processing flow of a response time-based adjusting force calculation unit 1090 according to the first embodiment. FIG. 4 is a conceptual diagram of a plan adjustment force according to the first embodiment. FIG. 7 is a conceptual diagram of a necessary adjustment force P ₀ 701 for each fluctuation period T502 of a time t0 (403) according to the first embodiment. FIG. 7 is a conceptual diagram of a necessary adjustment force P ₀ 701 for each variation period T502 of a time t1 (404) according to the first embodiment. FIG. 9 is a conceptual diagram comparing a required adjustment force P ₀ 701 and a planned adjustment force P ₁ 601 at a time period t1 (404) according to the first embodiment for each variation period T502. FIG. 9 is a conceptual diagram showing a numerical result and a determination result for each of the fluctuation periods T502 of a time t1 (404) according to the first embodiment on a result display unit 1100. Generator output GA01 (1102) and the generator B of the generator A is the content of the required adjustment force _P 0 01 time t0 (403) of the T2 (602) from the fluctuation period T1 of Example 1 (601) (702) generator output of GB01 (1103), time t1 (404) of the required adjustment force _P 0 11 (801) the generator output of the generator B and the generator output GA11 (1104) of the generator a is the content of GB11 (1105 FIG. FIG. 7 is a conceptual diagram showing a monitoring result of an adjusting force according to the first embodiment on a result display unit 1100. FIG. 8 is a conceptual diagram showing an evaluation result of a necessary adjustment force at a time t1 (404) according to the first embodiment on a result display unit 1100. FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating an example of a flow for calculating a necessary adjustment force corresponding to a demand forecast value according to the first embodiment.

  Hereinafter, examples of the present invention will be described. It should be noted that the following is merely an example of the embodiment, and is not intended to limit the invention itself to the following specific contents.

  The adjusting force monitoring device according to the present embodiment, as described later, determines that the adjusting force necessary for maintaining the frequency of the power system is secured by the adjusting force procured at the time of planning (hereinafter, referred to as a planned adjusting force). It is possible to fulfill the duty of maintaining the frequency of the electric power system by checking every fluctuation cycle of the power system, and to reduce the load of supply and demand balance adjustment.

  Embodiment 1 of the present invention will be described below.

  FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating an example of a functional configuration of the adjustment force monitoring device 1000. The adjustment power monitoring device 1000 includes, for example, an initial data DB 1010, a predicted supply and demand DB 1020, a required adjustment power DB 1030, a planned adjustment power DB 1040, an actual supply and demand DB 1050, an adjustment power determination result DB 1060, a data input unit 1070, a necessary adjustment power calculation unit 1080, and a response. An hourly adjustment force calculation unit 1090, a result display unit 1100, and a communication unit 1200 are provided.

  The initial data DB 1010 stores data such as a future monitoring period, a monitoring time interval, and a monitoring fluctuation cycle (hereinafter referred to as a monitoring cycle), which are initial data for comparing and evaluating the necessary adjustment power and the planned adjustment power.

  The predicted supply-demand DB 1020 stores a predicted power demand value (hereinafter simply referred to as a “demand predicted value”) and a predicted renewable energy (sunlight, wind power) at each monitoring time interval in the future monitoring period. The calculation of the demand forecast value and the renewable energy forecast value uses, for example, a demand forecast value system or a renewable energy forecast system of another system.

  The necessary adjusting force DB 1030 stores the necessary adjusting force calculated by the required adjusting force calculating unit 1080 using the demand forecast value stored in the predicted demand and supply DB 1020.

  The plan adjustment force DB 1040 stores the currently procured plan adjustment force for each monitoring fluctuation cycle set in the initial data DB 1010.

  The actual supply and demand DB 1050 stores measurement data obtained from the communication unit 1200 of the adjustment force monitoring device 1000 via the communication network 3000. The measurement data includes connection information of transmission and substation equipment constituting the power system 4000 collected and stored by the power system monitoring system 2000, active power P and reactive power Q of the transmission line, voltage V and current I of the power supply and load. , Power factor φ, active power P and reactive power Q of a power supply connected to the power system 4000, frequency of the power system, and the like.

  The adjustment force determination result DB 1060 includes a required adjustment force, a planned adjustment force, a deviation between the planned adjustment force and the required adjustment force, a determination result as to whether the required adjustment force can be secured by the planned adjustment force, and a time change amount of the required adjustment force. For the determination result of the followability based on the output change speed of the generator, a value for each of the time t and the fluctuation period T is stored. Here, in the present embodiment, the term “generator” is used to mean a device that generates power using thermal power, hydroelectric power, nuclear power, solar light, wind power, batteries, biomass, etc. Not limited. The stored data is stored for each monitoring cycle at monitoring time intervals up to a future monitoring period.

  When a future monitoring period, monitoring time interval, and monitoring period, which are initial data for comparing and evaluating the necessary adjustment power and the planned adjustment power, are input from a pointing device such as a keyboard and a mouse, the data input unit 1070 receives the initial data. Stored in the DB 1010.

  If the future monitoring period is set to a time several minutes ahead of the monitoring, for example, 30 minutes, the necessary adjustment necessary for the demand from now to 30 minutes ahead based on the demand forecast value up to 30 minutes ahead The force is predicted, and it is determined whether the necessary adjustment force can be secured by the planned adjustment force.

  The monitoring time interval is a time interval for monitoring whether or not the necessary adjustment power can be secured by the planned adjustment power during the future monitoring period. For example, if the monitoring time interval is set to 1 minute and the future monitoring period is set to 30 minutes, it is monitored that the required adjusting power is secured by the planned adjusting power every 30 minutes for the future monitoring period of 30 minutes.

  A plurality of conditions can be set for the fluctuation cycle (monitoring cycle) for monitoring the necessary adjustment force. For example, when the monitoring time interval is set to 1 minute and the future monitoring period is set to 30 minutes, it is determined whether or not the required adjusting power for each fluctuation cycle can be secured every 30 minutes in the future monitoring period every 1 minute. To monitor.

  The necessary adjustment power calculation unit 1080 calculates the necessary adjustment power based on, for example, the demand prediction value and the renewable energy prediction value stored in the predicted supply and demand DB 1020.

  The response time-based adjustment force calculation unit 1090 reads the required adjustment force stored in the required adjustment force DB 1030 and the planned adjustment force stored in the planned adjustment force DB 1040, and monitors the monitoring cycle ( For each (variation cycle), the planned adjustment power and the necessary adjustment power are compared and evaluated. Further, the evaluation result is stored in the adjustment power determination result DB 1060.

  The result display unit 1100 displays the data stored in the adjustment power determination result DB 1060.

  The communication network 3000 connects the adjustment power monitoring device 1000, the power system monitoring system 2000, and the power system 4000.

  FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of the adjustment force monitoring device 1000. The adjustment power monitoring device 1000 includes a CPU 10, a memory 20, an input unit 30, a communication unit 40, a display unit 50, a program DB 60, an initial data DB 1010, a predicted supply and demand DB 1020, a necessary adjustment power DB 1030, a planned adjustment power DB 1040, an actual supply and demand DB 1050, and adjustment. It can be configured as a computer device including a force determination result DB 1060 and the like.

  FIG. 3 is a diagram illustrating the program DB 60. The program DB 60 stores a necessary adjustment force calculation program P61, a response time-based adjustment force calculation program P62, and an adjustment force evaluation program P63. Other computer programs may be stored as needed. The adjusting force monitoring apparatus 1000 can realize the various functions shown in FIG. 1 by a computer executing a predetermined computer program.

  FIG. 4 is a diagram illustrating an example of a processing flow of the adjustment force monitoring device 1000.

  In the processing step S1, a future monitoring period, a monitoring time interval, a monitoring cycle, and a monitored change, which are initial data for comparing and evaluating the required adjustment power and the planned adjustment power, from a pointing device such as a keyboard and a mouse from the data input unit 1070. The cycle is input and stored in the initial data DB 1010.

  In the processing step S2, the necessary adjusting power calculating unit 1080 calculates the necessary adjusting power using the demand forecast value and the renewable energy forecast value stored in the forecast demand / supply DB 1020. Specifically, for example, in the following processing steps S21 to S24, the necessary adjusting force corresponding to the demand forecast value is calculated. FIG. 16 shows a flow for calculating the necessary adjusting force corresponding to the demand forecast value.

  In the processing step S21, the demand forecast value and the renewable energy forecast value are read from the forecast demand-supply DB 1020.

  In the processing step S22, the calculation condition of the necessary adjustment amount is read from the initial data DB 1010. As the calculation condition of the necessary adjustment amount, for example, a numerical value of a ratio of a demand forecast value or a residual demand forecast value (a value obtained by subtracting a renewable energy forecast value from a demand forecast value) is set. For example, the calculation condition of the necessary adjustment amount is set to 3%.

  In processing step S23, a necessary adjustment force is calculated. The remaining condition forecast value (= demand forecast value−renewable energy forecast value) calculated from the demand forecast value and the renewable energy forecast value read in the processing step S11 and the calculation condition of the necessary adjustment power 3 read in the process step S22 are 3 The necessary adjusting force is calculated by integrating the%.

  In the processing step 24, the necessary adjustment force calculated in the processing step 23 is stored in the required adjustment force DB 1030.

  In the processing step S3, the adjustment force calculating unit 1090 for each response time reads the necessary adjustment force from the required adjustment force DB 1030 and the planned adjustment force from the planned adjustment force DB 1040, respectively. Then, the necessary adjusting force and the planned adjusting force are compared and evaluated for each fluctuation cycle, and it is determined whether the required adjusting force can be secured by the planned adjusting force based on the evaluation result.

  First, the fluctuation period will be described.

  FIG. 5 is a conceptual diagram showing the relationship between the power demand L401 and the time t402. The demand at t0 (403) is L0 (405), the demand at t1 (404) is L1 (406), and the demand L401 also changes as time t402 elapses.

  FIG. 6 is a conceptual diagram of each control region with respect to the fluctuation cycle of the demand L401.

The GF 503 responds to a load fluctuation (a cycle of several seconds to several minutes) and a supply / demand mismatch (power loss, etc.) that cannot be followed by the LFC 504.
The LFC 504 responds to a load fluctuation (a period of several minutes to about several tens of minutes) or a supply-demand mismatch that makes it difficult to predict the demand.
The ELD 505 corresponds to a relatively long-term load change (a period of about ten minutes to several hours).

  Next, a specific example of the processing step S3 will be described. FIG. 7 shows a processing flow of the adjustment force calculating unit 1090 for each response time.

  In the processing step S31, the monitoring cycle is read from the initial data DB 1010.

  In the processing step S32, the planned adjustment power according to the future monitoring period is read from the planned adjustment power DB 1040.

FIG. 8 shows a conceptual diagram of the planned adjustment force. 8, the vertical axis planned adjustment force _P 1 601, the horizontal axis as the fluctuation period T502, planning adjustment force _P 1 1 when the variation cycle T1 (602) ~T2 (603) , fluctuation period T2 (603) ~ T3 planning adjustment force _P 1 2 when the (604) shows a plan adjustment force _{P 1} 3 when the variation cycle T3 (604) to T4 (605). A to M shown in the planned adjustment force of each fluctuation cycle indicate generators that procure the adjustment force.

  In processing step S33, the necessary adjusting force according to the future monitoring period is read from the necessary adjusting force DB 1030.

FIG. 9 shows a conceptual diagram of the necessary adjustment force at the present time t0 (403). 9, necessary adjustments force on the vertical axis _P 0 701, the horizontal axis as the fluctuation period T502, required adjustability _P 0 01 when the fluctuation period T1 (602) ~T2 (603) , fluctuation period T2 (603) ~ The required adjusting force P ₀ 02 at the time of T3 (604) and the required adjusting force P ₀ 03 at the time of the fluctuation period T3 (604) to T4 (605) are shown.

FIG. 10 shows a conceptual diagram of the necessary adjustment force at time t1 (404). 10, the vertical axis should adjust power _P 0 701, and necessary adjustment force when the fluctuation period when the horizontal axis and the variation period T502 T1 (602) ~T2 (603 ) P 0 11 (801), T2 ( 603) to T3 need adjustment force _P 0 12 (802 in the case of (604)) shows the T3 (604) to T4 (necessary adjustments force when the _{605) P 0 13 (803)} .

  In the processing step S34, the necessary adjustment force and the planned adjustment force at the time t1 (404) are evaluated for each change cycle. FIG. 11 is a conceptual diagram thereof.

First, by comparing the required adjustment force _P 0 11 (801) and the planned adjustment force _P 1 1 (606) when the fluctuation period T1 (602) ~T2 (603) , plan adjustment force _P 1 1 (606) required The deviation of the adjusting force P ₀ 11 (801) is calculated. As a result, from the required adjustment force _P 0 11 (801), plan adjustment force _P 1 1 (606) is large, or if the same condition is satisfied, so that the necessary adjustments force is ensured in the planning adjustment force. A similar process is executed for the fluctuation periods T2 (603) to T3 (604) and the fluctuation periods T3 (604) to T4 (605). As a result, when the planned adjustment force P ₁ (601) is larger than or equal to the required adjustment force P ₀ (701) in all the fluctuation periods T502, the required adjustment force at time t1 (404) is changed to the planned adjustment force. It is determined that it is secured by force. This result is stored in the adjustment force determination result DB 1060. FIG. 12 shows an example of the evaluation result of the time t1 (404) stored in the adjustment force determination result DB 1060.

On the other hand, it is determined that than the required adjustment force _P 0 11 (801), if the planned adjustment force _P 1 1 (606) is small, necessary adjustments force is not ensured in the planning adjustment force.

  The processing step S35 determines the generator having the necessary adjusting power at the time t1 (404). First, the generator information of the operating generator at the time t0 (403) or the time close to the time t0 (403) is acquired from the actual supply and demand DB 1050, and the generator of the planned adjustment power at the time t1 (404) is further obtained from the information. Only (A to M) are extracted. The generator to be adjusted or operated to satisfy the required adjusting force of t1 (404) is selected from the generators extracted from the generators having the planned adjusting force. The generator selection condition at t1 (404) gives priority to the generator running at t0 (403), and then selects the generators in ascending order of unit price until the required adjusting force is satisfied.

  In the processing step S36, based on the result of the processing step 25, the output change speed constraint of the generator operated at t0 (403) and t1 (404) is confirmed in all the fluctuation periods. FIG. 13 shows a generator having the necessary adjustment force of t0 (403) and t1 (404) during the fluctuation period T1 (602) to T2 (603).

  First, the amount of change in generator output when generator A changes from t0 (403) to t1 (404) is the deviation between GA11 (1104) and GA01 (1102). Similarly, for generator B, the amount of change in the generator output when it changes from t0 (403) to t1 (404) is the deviation between GB11 (1105) and GB01 (1103).

  The amount of change in the generator output of generator A (difference between GA11 (1104) and GA01 (1102)) when the above-described change from t0 (403) to t1 (404) is smaller than the output change speed of generator A In this case, the generator A complies with the output change speed constraint. Similarly, for the generator B, the amount of change in the generator output of the generator B (difference between GB11 (1105) and GB01 (1103)) when changing from t0 (403) to t1 (404) is the same as that of the generator B. When the condition that is smaller than or equal to the output change speed is satisfied, it means that the generator B has complied with the output change speed constraint.

Similar processing is executed for the fluctuation periods T2 (603) to T3 (604) and the fluctuation periods T3 (604) to T4 (605). As a result, the condition that the change amount of the output of the generator is smaller than the output change speed in all the fluctuation periods T502 and the planned adjustment force P ₁ (601) is greater than or equal to the required adjustment force P ₀ (701). Is satisfied, it is determined that the planned adjustment force is secured when the necessary adjustment force changes from t0 (403) to t1 (404). This result is stored in the adjustment force determination result DB 1060. FIG. 13 shows an example of the evaluation result at the time change from t0 (403) to t1 (404) stored in the adjustment force determination result DB 1060.

  In the processing step S37, a final determination process is performed.

  If both the evaluation result of the necessary adjustment force and the planned adjustment force at t1 in the processing step S34 and the evaluation of the output change speed constraint of the generator operated at t0 and t1 in the processing step S36 are OK, It is determined that the necessary adjustment power can be secured by the planned adjustment power. The result is stored in the adjustment power determination result DB 1060.

  In processing step S4, the monitoring result of the adjusting force is extracted from the adjusting force determination result DB 1060 and displayed on the result display unit 1100. FIG. 14 shows an example of the display result. In FIG. 14, the result of the time t <b> 1 (404) in which the adjustment force is monitored is indicated by a white circle 1201. In the case where the necessary adjustment force and the planned adjustment force at t1 in the processing step S34 are NG in the evaluation for each variation cycle, the black circle 1203, the output of the generator operating at the time t0 (403) and the time t1 (404) in the processing step S36 If the evaluation of the change speed constraint is NG, a black diamond 1204 is displayed.

  When the white circle 1201 is selected with a pointing device such as a mouse, the necessary adjustment force and the planned adjustment force at t1 in the processing step S34 are evaluated at the evaluation result (FIG. 11) for each change cycle, and the operation is performed at t0 and t1 in the processing step S36. The evaluation result (FIG. 13) of the output change speed constraint of the generator to be executed is displayed.

  In the above description, a case has been described as an example in which it is determined whether or not the necessary adjustment force can be secured for each of the fluctuation periods (GF, LFC, ELD). It may be determined whether the necessary adjustment force can be secured by the planned adjustment force. For example, in addition to the fluctuation cycles corresponding to GF, LFC, and ELD, it is also possible to confirm that the adjustment power is secured for other fluctuation cycles set by the operator (for example, LFC low speed, LFC medium speed, and LFC high speed). . As a result, the operator can appropriately set the fluctuation cycle required for operation and check whether the necessary adjustment power can be secured.

  The fluctuation cycle to be monitored is the power supply configuration (thermal power, hydraulic power, renewable energy, etc.) storing the fluctuation cycle stored in the initial data DB 1010 in the actual supply and demand DB, and the load configuration (DR, storage battery, EV). The width or interval of the fluctuation cycle to be automatically monitored may be changed according to the change in the ratio or the connection state of the power system.

  The effect of this embodiment will be described.

  The adjusting power monitoring device according to the present embodiment compares the required adjusting power calculated based on the power demand forecast value at each monitoring time interval with the procured planned adjusting power, and calculates these deviations. It can be determined at each monitoring time interval whether the necessary adjustment force can be secured by the planned adjustment force. Thus, for example, even when the output fluctuation of the generator changes every moment, the necessary adjusting force can be monitored by following the time change of the output fluctuation of the generator, and the system frequency of the power grid can be monitored. It is possible to reduce the burden of determining whether or not the adjustment force required for maintenance is possible.

  In addition, for the calculated necessary adjustment force and the planned adjustment force, by calculating a deviation for each change cycle, for example, a large amount of renewable energy, such as solar power generation, is interconnected, and output fluctuation of the generator is reduced. Even if it changes every moment, it is possible to reduce the burden of judging the necessity of the adjustment force necessary for maintaining the system frequency of the power system.

  Note that the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and includes various modifications. For example, the above-described embodiments have been described in detail for easy understanding of the present invention, and are not necessarily limited to those having all the configurations described above. Further, a part of the configuration of one embodiment can be replaced with the configuration of another embodiment, and the configuration of one embodiment can be added to the configuration of another embodiment. Further, for a part of the configuration of each embodiment, it is possible to add / delete / replace another configuration.

1010 Initial data DB
1020 Forecast supply and demand DB
1030 Required adjustment power DB
1040 Plan adjustment power DB
1050 Actual supply and demand DB
1060 Adjustment force judgment result DB
1070 Data input unit 1080 Required adjustment force calculation unit 1090 Response time adjustment force calculation unit 1100 Result display unit 1200 Communication unit

Claims (7)

A data input unit for inputting a fluctuation cycle for monitoring a required adjusting force of the power system and a monitoring time interval for monitoring the required adjusting force;
A predicted supply and demand database that stores a predicted power demand value for each monitoring time interval,
A plan coordination power database for storing the values of the procured plan coordination power,
With the power demand forecast value as an input, a necessary adjusting force calculating unit that calculates a necessary adjusting force,
For the calculated required adjustment force and the planned adjustment force, a response time-based adjustment force calculation unit that calculates a deviation for each of the fluctuation cycles,
An adjustment force monitoring device comprising:   When the planned adjustment force is larger than the calculated required adjustment force, the response time-based adjustment force calculation unit determines that the required adjustment force can be secured, and the planned adjustment force is smaller than the calculated required adjustment force. The adjusting force monitoring device according to claim 1, wherein it is determined that a necessary adjusting force cannot be secured in the case. The apparatus further includes a result display unit that displays a result output from the response time-based adjusting force calculation unit,
3. The adjustment force monitoring device according to claim 1, wherein the result display unit displays a determination result indicating that the necessary adjustment force cannot be secured and displays a warning. 4.   4. The method according to claim 1, wherein the response time-based adjustment force calculation unit determines whether the required adjustment force can be secured by the planned adjustment force using a plurality of determination methods. 5. Adjustment force monitoring device.   The adjustment power monitoring according to claim 4, wherein the plurality of determination methods include a method of determining based on the deviation and a method of determining based on a time change amount of a generator output constituting a necessary adjustment force. apparatus.   The adjusting force according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the response time adjusting force calculating unit determines a generator to be operated and an output based on the calculated necessary adjusting force. Monitoring device. Calculating the required regulating power based on the predicted power demand value at each monitoring time interval for monitoring the required regulating power of the power system;
For the calculated necessary adjustment force and the procured planned adjustment force, a step of calculating a deviation for each fluctuation cycle for monitoring the required adjustment force,
An adjusting force monitoring method, comprising:

Images