GB2526786A - Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets - Google Patents

Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets Download PDF

Info

Publication number
GB2526786A
GB2526786A GB1409442.9A GB201409442A GB2526786A GB 2526786 A GB2526786 A GB 2526786A GB 201409442 A GB201409442 A GB 201409442A GB 2526786 A GB2526786 A GB 2526786A
Authority
GB
United Kingdom
Prior art keywords
tyre
bales
gabion
basket
gabion basket
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Withdrawn
Application number
GB1409442.9A
Other versions
GB201409442D0 (en
Inventor
Alan Lofthouse
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Individual
Original Assignee
Individual
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Individual filed Critical Individual
Priority to GB1409442.9A priority Critical patent/GB2526786A/en
Publication of GB201409442D0 publication Critical patent/GB201409442D0/en
Publication of GB2526786A publication Critical patent/GB2526786A/en
Withdrawn legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • EFIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
    • E02HYDRAULIC ENGINEERING; FOUNDATIONS; SOIL SHIFTING
    • E02DFOUNDATIONS; EXCAVATIONS; EMBANKMENTS; UNDERGROUND OR UNDERWATER STRUCTURES
    • E02D29/00Independent underground or underwater structures; Retaining walls
    • E02D29/02Retaining or protecting walls
    • E02D29/0208Gabions
    • EFIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
    • E02HYDRAULIC ENGINEERING; FOUNDATIONS; SOIL SHIFTING
    • E02BHYDRAULIC ENGINEERING
    • E02B3/00Engineering works in connection with control or use of streams, rivers, coasts, or other marine sites; Sealings or joints for engineering works in general
    • E02B3/04Structures or apparatus for, or methods of, protecting banks, coasts, or harbours

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Civil Engineering (AREA)
  • Environmental & Geological Engineering (AREA)
  • Structural Engineering (AREA)
  • General Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
  • Paleontology (AREA)
  • Mining & Mineral Resources (AREA)
  • Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
  • Ocean & Marine Engineering (AREA)
  • Mechanical Engineering (AREA)
  • Revetment (AREA)
  • Pit Excavations, Shoring, Fill Or Stabilisation Of Slopes (AREA)

Abstract

A gabion basket designed for use with bales of discarded tyres. The gabion baskets may feature a partition 3E, which divides the container into two separate compartments. The first compartment 1E is of an appropriate size to accommodate tyre bales. The second compartment 2E is filled with a decorative secondary filler material which is more aesthetically pleasing. The second compartment may extend along one or two adjoining sides so that when multiple gabions are placed together, the second compartments create a facade covering and obscuring the inner fill material. A method of using the gabion basket for housing discarded tyres is also disclosed.

Description

PATENT APPLICATION
OF
ALAN LOFTHOUSE
FOR
IMPROVEMENTS TO TYRE BALE USE AS INFILL FOR GABION BASKETS
Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to the new use of EA approved PAS 108 tyre bales within gabion baskets as an infill therein.
Background
The use of gabion baskets filled with rubble or similar aggregate is known and is widely used throughout the world as a method for creating structural masses for land works and weather retainers. A gabion (from Italian gabbione meaning "big cage"; from Italian gabbia and Latin cavea meaning "cage") is a cage, cylinder, or box filled with rocks, concrete, or sometimes sand and soil for use in civil engineering, road building, and military applications. For erosion control, caged riprap is used. For dams or in foundation construction, cylindrical metal structires are used. In a military context, earth-or sand-filled gabions are used to protect artillery crews from enemy fire.
Leonardo da Vinci designed a type of gabion called a Cotheille Leonard ("Leonardo basket") for the foundations of the San Marco Castle in Milan. The most common civil engineering use of gabions is to stabilize shorelines, stream banks or slopes against erosion. Other uses include retaining walls, temporary floodwalls, silt filtration from runoff, for small or temporarylpermanent dams, river training, or channel lining. They may be used to direct the force of a flow of flood water around a vulnerable structure.
Gabions are also used as fish barriers on small streams.
A gabion wall is usually a retaining wall made of stacked stone-filled gabions tied together with wire. Gabion walls are usually battered (angled back towards the slope), or stepped back with the slope rather than stacked vertically. Gabion baskets have some advantages over loose riprap because of their modularity and ability to be stacked in various shapes; they are also resistant to being washed away by moving water. Gabions also have advantages over more rigid structures because they can conform to ground movement, dissipate energy from flowing water, and drain freely.
Their strength and effectiveness may increase with time in some cases, as silt and vegetation fill the interstitial voids and reinforce the structure. They are sometimes used to keep stones which may fall from a cutting or cliff from endangering traffic on a thoroughfare.
The life expectancy of gabions depends on the lifespan of the wire, not on the contents of the basket. The structure will fail when the wire fails. Galvanized steel wire is most common, but PVC-coated and stainless steel wire are also used. PVC-coated galvanized gabions have been estimated to survive for 60 years. Some gabion manufacturers guarantee a structural consistency of 50 years.
In the United States, gabion use within streams first began with projects completed from 1957-1 965 on North River, Virginia and Zealand River, NH. More than 150 grade-control structures, bank revetments and channel deflectors were constructed on the two U.S. Forest Service sites. Eventually, a large portion of the in stream structures failed due to undermining and lack of structural integrity of the baskets. In particular, corrosion and abrasion of wires by bed load movement compromised the structures, which then sagged and collapsed into the channels. Other gabions were toppled into channels as trees grew and enlarged on top of gabion revetments leveraging them towards the river channels.
Gabions have also been used in building, as in the Dominus Winery in Napa Valley, California by architects Herzog & de Meuron, constructed between 1995-97. The exterior is formed by modular wire mesh gabions containing locally quarried stone; this construction allows air movement through the building and creates an environment of moderate temperatures inside.
There are various special designs of gabions to meet particular functional requirements and some special terms for particular forms have come into use. For example: Bastion, a gabion lined internally with a membrane, typically of nonwoven geotextile to permit use of a granular soil fill instead of rock. Mattress: a form of gabion with relatively small height relative to the lateral dimensions; commonly very wide. For protecting surfaces from wave erosion and similar attack, rather than building or supporting high structures.
Trapion: a form of gabion with a trapezoidal cross section, designed for stacking to give a face that is sloping rather than stepped. The term is in wide usage, but in contexts related to gabions at least, appears to be a trademark registered by Beta fence Limited.
The present invention aims to change the infill of the gabion with the use mainly of worn or damaged tyres instead of the aforementioned materials. These tyres would have been baled or tied together under regulations and standards approved by EA PASIOS and adhere to this guide and regulation. These tyre filled gabion baskets may then be used with or without added aggregate or similar materials for all known projects currently or emerging. The invention herein will offer an alternate opportunity to recycle a discarded product, being a number of the estimated 46 million vehicle tyres thrown away annually in the UK. The lifetime of the tyre bale being extended to an expectancy of 50-100 years, dependent on basket construction variables. Subject to EU (European Union) and EA (Environment Agency) regulations the use of PAS 108 tyre bales on construction projects is the only legally authorized method of disposal of used vehicle tyres with the UK and Europe.
The use of this system would have a cost saving implication in areas such as fly tipping clearance costs, savings on tipping charges and tax and aggregate charges and taxation. It will also offer a new opportunity for the UK to deal with its own waste problems and reduce the amount exported to third world countries for their disposal.
Tyre bales allow approximately 60% free drainage of retained water so suitable uses would include area such as riverbank stabilisation, canal side stabilisation, ground stabilisation, sea defences, flood defences, semi-permanent access road sub-base structure.
Prior Art
Accordingly patent applications have been filed to provide general solutions, including the following: United States patent ref: US 5472297 (HESELDEN) Discloses a caging method for stone or similar irifihl that is of an angled form that may be connected together forming raised enclosures for aggregate infihl.
World Patent Publication ret WO 0040810 (HESELDEN) Discloses a structural method for use of aggregate, stones, sand, rocks, ballast to be housed within connected cage wall partition structures that are ground mounted to form temporary barriers or similar defence wall structures.
United States patent ref: US 5647695 (HILFIKER) Discloses a wire cage group of rectangular containers that may be soil filled and ground mounted to form a land retainers or planting housing for garden or similar land assemblies.
Summary of the invention
According to the present invention there is provided a gabion basket, having variations in size and format to provide solutions for their use in commercial land, structural, thoroughfare and marine environments, aé depicted in this descriptive presentation and accompanying elucidation.
The gabion baskets are made of adjoining panels and these vary to suit the purpose of the function to which they are being applied. The formed basket has means to be connected to the proceeding basket and so on. This invention relates broadly to the art of gabion systems. More particularly the invention relates to a gabion system incorporating wire grid works forming inter connected baskets. More particularly the invention relates to a series of gabion baskets having separator walls defining chambers which may be filled with flat elements to impart structure and improved appearance to the exterior walls of the gabion baskets. Gabion systems are containers or cages filled with ballast or similar but it is suggested that used vehicle tyres that are presented as bales may undertake all or most of the baskets infill.
They may have dividers or baffles or partitions to separate the area to be filled with hard durable material or ballast. Usually these cages are interconnected to retain earth and control soil erosion and floods. The common feature for most gabion systems is a basket filled with rocks. The basket serves to hold the rocks in place and the combination of the basket and rock serves as a means for preventing erosion or as a liner for various purposes. Gabion systems are substituted commonly for concrete facings and are superior in some respects because the gabion system acts as a natural filter as opposed to a barrier. Gabion systems may improve drainage and provide related benefits. Gabions may be made of steel wire (of square, rectangular, hexagonal or other shaped mesh. Different types of wire include galvanized steel, PVC coated, gallin steel and stainless steel wire. The baskets may also be made of plastic. The most common types of filler or ballast are crushed stone or gravel. Other materials are slag or broken concrete. The main property of ballast is that the material be of sufficient weight to act as ballast. Because of the great weight of the fill material or ballast, and the methods of dumping fill, the installer invariably deforms the gabion basket and creates unsightly and aesthetically displeasing appearances. In extreme cases this deformation can cause structural failure. Gabion installation is typically labour intensive compared to certain concrete construction.
Manufacture material will vary in size according to the internal and external loadings applied thereon to the full basket. We can however suggest averages of 4mm diameter for the wire based on a 75mm square mesh, as seen in the Figures. As in the traditional manner the differing baskets are of a cuboid variant form made up of meshed panels held together to form the finished shape using a lacing wire type or helicoil springs and have an opening section that allows infill to be inserted and housed. Corrosion is attended by moreover coating the wire with either fused PVC, Galvanising or Galfin coating, they may also be manufactured from a stainless steel or other known or emerging technology composite.
The mesh panels shall be constructed to form a box container basket with a free internal volume comprising of 1X base section, 4X side sections and a corresponding top section, although this may vary depending on required shapes for planned projects.
For example, a basket may be required with a protruding area to the portion that is visible externally to provide a step' onto which a decorative item could be placed externally and thus they would be stacked in a way to determine this. The top section is fitted after the basket has had the internal volume filled with a suitable infill of tyre bales and I or aggregate, including variations from sand to demolition debris to purpose crushed stone.
This invention relates to the use of PAS 108 tyre bales as the principle bulk infill material used inside gabion baskets. The aim is to use only approved tyre bales as guided by the EA (Environment Agency) regulation and reports. Being a PAS 108 full sized tyre bale and EA approved PAS 108 reduced size tyre bale. The internal dimensions may vary slightly but we can recommend that the gabion baskets to accommodate full size tyre bales should be as follows: Figure 1, Basket A would have dimensions of 1580 x 1429 x 905mm.
Figure 2, Basket B would have an additional compartment to one facing side to house decorative facing material with dimensions of 1429 x 1955 x 905mm. If required an internal mesh partition can be provided to offer extra support therein Figure 3, Basket C to accept a full size PAS 108 tyre bale with two adjacent compartments to accept decorative facing material on to adjacent side faces. Basket dimensions 1805 x 1955 x.905mm. If required two internal mesh partitions can be provided to offer extra support.
The internal dimensions of the gabion baskets to accommodate and house the PAS 108 reduced size tyre bales are as follows: Figure 4, Basket D would have dimensions of 1580 x 755 x 905mm.
Figure 5, Basket E would have an additional compartment to one facing side to house decorative facing material with dimensions of 1580 x 1205 x 755 mm. If required an internal mesh partition can be provided to offer extra support therein.
Figure 6, Basket F to accept a reduced size PAS 108 tyre bale with two adjacent compartments to accept decorative facing material on to adjacent side faces. Basket dimensions 1805 x 1205 x 755 mm. If required two internal mesh partitions can be provided to offer extra support.
The facing partition elements to these gabion designs are to allow tyres to contribute the majority of the infill and to provide a more acceptable visual look of stone or rock (if these are used) to the facing sides. This is provided for frontal and corner areas of constructions, as mentioned in the previous basket proposals.
As with known gabion baskets these can all be interconnected to form a required shape or size of supporting or retaining structure to suit a similar or disparity of constructed masses.
Brief description of figures
Figures 1 show a full size basic tyre bale gabion basket.
Figures 2 show a full size tyre bale gabion basket with a single decorative facing partition.
Figures 3 show a full size tyre bale with two decorative facing partitions.
Figures 4 show a reduced size basic tyre bale gabion basket.
Figures 5 show a reduced size tyre bale gabion basket with a single decorative facing partition.
Figure 6 show a reduced size tyre bale gabion basket with two decorative facing partitions.
Detailed description of figures.
A typical embodiment of the invention is illustrated in Figure 1. The tyre infill gabion basket is structurally calculated and made of none-corrosive material from individual vertical and horizontal bars or strips of metal or similar composite, forming a connective lattice mesh of mostly proportionately equal sides, one of which opens to receive infill of tyres and I or facing materials.
Figure 1 shows a gabion basket to receive a standard size tyre bale, 1. Figure 2 shows a gabion basket to receive a standard size tyre bale lÀ, with a forward located partition 3A which provides an enclosure for facing material 2A.
Figure 3 shows a gabion basket to receive a standard size tyre bale I B, with a sectional positioned L' shaped partition 3B which provides an L' shaped or corner enclosure for facing material 2B. This partitioned enclosure section is of a portion of the entire internal capacity and its wall or divider is connectively assigned to the facing sides of the basket being of the exacting mesh derivative and is of interconnected vertical stance.
Figure 4 shows a gabion basket to receive a reduced size tyre bale IC.
Figure 5 shows a gabion basket to receive a reduced size tyre bale 1 D, with a forward located partition 3D which provides an enclosure for facing material 2D.
Figure 6 shows a gabion basket to receive a reduced size tyre bale 1E, with a sectional positioned 1' shaped partition 3E which provides an V shaped or corner enclosure for facing material 2E, such as rocks or aggregate types. This partitioned enclosure section is also a portion of the entire internal capacity and its wall or divider is connectively assigned to the facing sides of the basket being of the exacting mesh derivative and is of interconnected vertical stance.
These gabion baskets once filled with used tyre bales and facing material, where required, may be suitably arranged, stacked and linked together tQ form desired ensembles for ground or marine architectonics.

Claims (8)

  1. Claims 1. A gabion basket for tyre bales encloses discarded used tyres.
  2. 2. A gabion basket for tyre bales wherein used tyre bales are placed and enclosed within gabion baskets.
  3. 3. A gabion basket for tyre bales as claimed in claim 2 wherein tyre bales are enclosed within gabion baskets, multiples of which may be then linked or stacked to form ground or marine architectonics.
  4. 4. A gabion basket for tyre bales may house used tyre bales and aggregate or mineral materials together.
  5. 5. A gabion basket for tyre bales as claimed may, in more than one of its presentations, house used tyre bales and aggregate or mineral materials together, which are installed into separate partitions therein.
  6. 6. A gabion basket for tyre bales as claimed wherein, aggregate or more aesthetically pleasing material can be displayed in facing partitions within versions of the gabion baskets, with tyre bales being concealed from view by this.
  7. 7. A gabion basket for tyre bales as claimed in all previous claims is a method to house and use discarded tyres that have been baled together under regulation for their continued use in multiple numbers when stacked or linked together in advantageous environmental and industnal developments, whilst providing an option to conceal said bales from view once in place by way of partitions within the baskets that are filled with more aesthetically pleasing material.AMENDMENTS TO CLAIMS HAVE BEEN FILEDAS FOLLOWSClaims 1. A wire gabion basket manufactured to enclose tyre bales that are either full or reduced in size, via their compression to EA specification PAS1O8.2. A wire gabion basket wherein used compressed tyre bales are placed within gabion baskets to offer a longer operational service life.3. A wire gabion basket filled with compressed tyre bales as claimed in claim 2 wherein enclosed within wire gabion baskets, multiples of which may be then linked or stacked to form ground architectonics.4. A wire gabion basket filled with compressed tyre bales may contain both tyre bales and aggregate or other mineral materials together.5. A wire gabion basket filled with compressed tyre bales may in more than one of its presentations, house compressed tyre bales and aggregate or other mineral materials together, which are installed into separate partitions therein.6. A wire gabion basket filled with compressed tyre bales as claimed wherein forms of aggregate or a more aesthetically pleasing material can be displayed in facing partitions within versions of the gabion basket with compressed tyre bales being concealed from view by this.(\J 7. A wire gabion basket is filled with compressed tyre bales which adhere to EA PAS 108 specification will consist of typically 100 used vehicle tyres compressed to form the tyre bale, secured inside the gabion basket will require a considerable O greater number of used vehicle tyre than a similar size gabion basket filled with loose filled used tyres.
  8. 8. A wire gabion basket wherein the purpose of the manufactured gabion basket is to offer longer service life of the structure in the harsh environment the product will be used with the PAS 108 compressed tyre bale offering mass and stability.10. A wire gabion basket wherein the compressed tyre bale located inside the designed wire cage offers easier free surface water drainage from behind the assembled structure due to prevention from collapse due to the protective wire cage protection and restriction of drainage water flow, due to infill material blockages.11. A wire gabion basket for compressed tyre bales as claimed in all previous claims is a method to house and use discarded vehicle tyres that have been baled together under regulations for their continued usage in multiple numbers stacked or linked together in advantageous environmental and industrial developments, whilst providing an option to conceal the said compressed bales from view once in place by way of partitions within the baskets that are filled with more aesthetically pleasing material.
GB1409442.9A 2014-05-28 2014-05-28 Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets Withdrawn GB2526786A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
GB1409442.9A GB2526786A (en) 2014-05-28 2014-05-28 Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
GB1409442.9A GB2526786A (en) 2014-05-28 2014-05-28 Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
GB201409442D0 GB201409442D0 (en) 2014-07-09
GB2526786A true GB2526786A (en) 2015-12-09

Family

ID=51177550

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
GB1409442.9A Withdrawn GB2526786A (en) 2014-05-28 2014-05-28 Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets

Country Status (1)

Country Link
GB (1) GB2526786A (en)

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US11959259B1 (en) * 2023-09-11 2024-04-16 King Saud University Fog and rain collector

Families Citing this family (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN110453653A (en) * 2019-08-28 2019-11-15 广东水利电力职业技术学院(广东省水利电力技工学校) A kind of landscape water pond and its construction method

Citations (6)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
GB2221941A (en) * 1988-08-16 1990-02-21 David Deacon Crash barrier
JPH1077620A (en) * 1996-09-03 1998-03-24 Gason:Kk Bulkhead construction method
FR2850685A1 (en) * 2003-01-31 2004-08-06 Dimitri Papachristou Reinforcing or filtering component e.g. for dyke or embankment comprises wire cage filled with side walls from used motor vehicle tires
US20050262794A1 (en) * 2003-10-03 2005-12-01 France Gabion Civil engineering structure, individual construction element and method for reinforcing such a structure
FR2920449A1 (en) * 2007-09-04 2009-03-06 Joseph Golcheh Retaining wall i.e. gabion wall, forming method, involves mechanically filling remaining volume of central compartment having mass function to ensure stability of wall, with unscreened coal materials
EP2772588A1 (en) * 2013-02-27 2014-09-03 Rapid'Gabions Gabion with various supporting rows

Patent Citations (6)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
GB2221941A (en) * 1988-08-16 1990-02-21 David Deacon Crash barrier
JPH1077620A (en) * 1996-09-03 1998-03-24 Gason:Kk Bulkhead construction method
FR2850685A1 (en) * 2003-01-31 2004-08-06 Dimitri Papachristou Reinforcing or filtering component e.g. for dyke or embankment comprises wire cage filled with side walls from used motor vehicle tires
US20050262794A1 (en) * 2003-10-03 2005-12-01 France Gabion Civil engineering structure, individual construction element and method for reinforcing such a structure
FR2920449A1 (en) * 2007-09-04 2009-03-06 Joseph Golcheh Retaining wall i.e. gabion wall, forming method, involves mechanically filling remaining volume of central compartment having mass function to ensure stability of wall, with unscreened coal materials
EP2772588A1 (en) * 2013-02-27 2014-09-03 Rapid'Gabions Gabion with various supporting rows

Cited By (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US11959259B1 (en) * 2023-09-11 2024-04-16 King Saud University Fog and rain collector

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
GB201409442D0 (en) 2014-07-09

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US7425107B2 (en) Civil engineering structure, individual construction element and method for reinforcing such a structure
US6695544B2 (en) Environment resistant retaining wall planter block and methods of use thereof
US20130149037A1 (en) Retaining wall construction system for preventing tsunamis and flood damages and construction method thereof
CN2911014Y (en) Plantable ecological wall
CN109750689A (en) A kind of Study on Reinforced Embankments Using soil blocking component afforested and its construction method
GB2526786A (en) Improvements to tyre bale use as infill for gabion baskets
Margottini Engineering geology in shaping and preserving the historic urban landscapes and cultural heritage: Achievements in UNESCO World Heritage Sites
US20050158122A1 (en) Method for contructing check dam or fire prevention dam using gear-type block
US20160312427A1 (en) Embankment Support
KR200486017Y1 (en) Eco vegetation block
Lelli et al. Innovative reinforced soil structures for high walls and slopes combining polymeric and metallic reinforcements
KR20060108900A (en) Slope-protect weight block for prevent degradation
RU2797999C1 (en) Reinforced soil cone of temporary bridge abutment with gabion retaining wall
KR100603920B1 (en) Sound proof type retaining wall with built-in flower bed
CN216865028U (en) Ecological slope protection brick and ecological slope protection structure
CN218438421U (en) Anti-aging reinforcing structure for building construction foundation
KR100515503B1 (en) installation structure of protective wall using Recycled polyolefine
CN218757544U (en) Slope supporting construction
RU2540180C1 (en) Barrier to protect objects from rockfalls and protection system using it
KR20140080597A (en) Precast fabric form for assembling in field, and method for constructing planted slope protection using the same
CN207017221U (en) Suitable for the gabion subgrade protection structure of karst area
KR100414658B1 (en) The method of restorer for a mode of life in city river
RU178536U1 (en) GABION DESIGN
CN101024948A (en) Cup jointing type sand bag and sand-barrier dam, sand obstacle and sand high bank
JP2023127771A (en) Embankment reinforcement wall and construction method for embankment reinforcement wall

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
WAP Application withdrawn, taken to be withdrawn or refused ** after publication under section 16(1)