GB2379698A

GB2379698A - Composite cutting element with arcuate table to substrate interfaces

Info

Publication number: GB2379698A
Application number: GB0228581A
Authority: GB
Inventors: Arthur A Chaves
Original assignee: Baker Hughes Inc
Current assignee: Baker Hughes Holdings LLC
Priority date: 1998-06-25
Filing date: 1999-06-16
Publication date: 2003-03-19
Anticipated expiration: 2019-06-16
Also published as: GB0228581D0; GB0228580D0; GB2379696B; GB2379698B; GB2379695B; GB2379696A; GB0228578D0; GB2379697A; GB2379697B; GB0228579D0; GB2379695A

Abstract

A cutting element of a drill bit for drilling subterranean formations including a superhard table formed on an end face of a cylindrical supporting substrate, there being an interface between the table and the end face of the substrate defined by at least one annular surface with an arcuate topography when taken in radial cross section longitudinally parallel to the centre line, the substrate table interface being sufficient to accommodate resultant loading of the cutting edge of the cutter throughout a variety of angles with vectors normal to the surface at a variety of angles such that at least one normal vector is aligned substantially parallel to the resultant loading on the cutting edge. A number of different shapes to the end face are disclosed.

Description

St)PlE 3 ' ASlVE C T Tr?p N7y'lI ARCtlAT T.;CE- -SUBSil TE {I\TI:El<EACl.

S TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates generally to rotary bits for drilling subterranean formations and, more specifically, to superabrasive cutters suitable for use on such bits, particularly of the so-called fixed cutter or "drag" bit variety.

BACKGROUND ART

Fixed-cutter, or drag, bits have been employed in subterranean drilling for many decades, and various sizes, shapes and patterns of natural and synthetic diamonds have been used on drag bit crowns as cutting elements. Polycrystalline diamond compact 15 (PI)C) cutters comprised of a diamond table formed under ultra-high temperature, ultra-

high pressure conditions onto a substrate, typically of cemented tungsten carbide (WC), were introduced into the market about twenty-five years ago. PDC cutters, with their diamond tables providing a relatively large, twodimensional cutting face (usually of circular, semi-circular or tombstone shape, although other configurations are known), 20 have provided drag bit designers with a wide variety of potential cutter deployments and orientations, crown configurations, nozzle placements and other design alternatives not previously possible with the smaller natural diamond and polyhedral, unbacked synthetic diamonds previously: employed in drag bits. The PDC cutters have, with various bit designs, achieved outstanding advances in drilling efficiency and rate of penetration 25 (ROP) when employed in soft to medium hardness formations, and the larger cutting face dimensions and attendant greater extension or "exposure" above the bit crown have afforded the opportunity for greatly improved bit hydraulics for cutter lubrication and cooling and formation debris removal. The same type and magnitude of advances in drag bit design in terms of cutter robustness and longevity, particularly for drilling rock 30 of medium to high compressive strength, have, unfortunately, not been realized to a desired degree.

State of the art substrate-supported PDC cutters have demonstrated a notable susceptibility to spelling and fracture of the PDC diamond layer or table when subjected to the severe do. nhole environment attendant to drilling rock formations of moderate to higl1 compressive strength; on the order of nine to twelve!;psi and above, unconfined.

5 Engagement of such formations by the PDC cutters occurs under high weight on bit (WON) required to drill such formations and high impact loads from torque oscillations.

These conditions are aggravated by the periodic high loading and unloading of the cutting elements as the bit impacts against the unforgiving surface of the formation due to drill string flex, bounce and oscillation, bit whirl and wobble, and varying WOB.

10 High compressive strength rock, or softer formations containing stringers of a different, higher compressive strength, thus may produce severe damage to, if not catastrophic failure of, the PDC diamond tables. Furthermore, bits are subjected to severe vibration and shock loads induced by movement during drilling between rock of different compressive strengths, for example, when the bit abruptly encounters a moderately hard 15 strata after drilling through soft rock.

Severe damage to even a single cutter on a PDC cutter-laden bit crown can drastically reduce efficiency of the bit. If there is more than one cutter at the radial location of a failed cutter, failure of one may soon cause the others to be overstressed and to fail in a "domino" effect. As even relatively minor damage may quickly 20 accelerate the degradation of the PDC cutters, many drilling operators lack confidence in PDC cutter drag bits for hard and stringer-laden formations.

It has been recognized in the art that the sharp, typically 90 edge of an unwom, conversational PDC cutter element is usually susceptible to damage during its initial engagement with a hard formation, particularly if that engagement includes even a 25 relatively minor impact. It has also been recognized that pre-beveling or pre-chamfering - of the PDC diamond table cutting edge provides some degree of protection against cutter damage during initial engagement with the formation, the PDC cutters being demonstrably less susceptible to damage after a wear flat has begun to form on the diamond table and substrate.

30 U.S. Patents Re 32,036, 4,109,737, 4,987,800, and 5,016,718 disclose and illustrate beveIled or chamfered PDC cutting elements as well as alternative modifications such as rounded (radiused) edges and perforated edges which fracture into

_ _ a challlfer-like configuration U. S. Patent 5,437,343, assigned to the assignee of the present application and incorporated herein by Ellis reference, discloses and illustrates a multiple-chamfer PDC diamond table edge configuration whicll, under some conditions, exhibits even greater resistance to impact-induced cutter damage. U.S. Patent 5 5,706,906, assigned to the assignee of the present application and incorporated herein by this reference, discloses and illustrates POC cutters employing a relatively thick diamond table and a very large chamfer, or so-called "rake land", at the diamond table periphery However, even with the PDC cutting element edge configuration modifications employed in the art, cutter damage remains an all-too-frequent occurrence when drilling 10 formations of moderate to high compressive strengths and stringer-laden formations Another approach to enhancing the robustness of PDC cutters has been the use of variously-configured boundaries or "interfaces" between the diamond table and the supporting substrate. Some of these interface configurations are intended to enhance the bond between the diamond table and the substrate, while others are intended to 1 modify the types, concentrations and locations of stresses (compressive, tensile) resident in the diamond tables and substrates after the cutter is formed in an ultra-high pressure, ultra-high temperature process, as is known in the art. Still other interface configurations are dictated by other objectives, such as particularly desired cutting face topographies.

Additional interface configurations are employed in so-called cutter "inserts" used on the 20 rotatable cones of rock bits. Examples of a variety of interface configurations may be found, by way of example only, in U.S. Patents 4,109,737, 4,858,707, 5,351,772, 5,460,233, 5,484,330, 5, 486,137, 5,494,477, 5,499,688, 5,544,713, 5,60S,199,

5,657,449, 5,706,906 and 5,711,702.

While cutting faces have been designed with features to accommodate and direct 25 forces imposed on PDC: cutters, see, for example, abovereferenced U.S. Patent 5,706,906, state-of-the-art PDC cutters have, to date, failed to adequately accommodate such forces at the diamond tableto-substrate interface, resulting in a susceptibility to spelling and fracture in that area. While the magnitude and direction of such forces might, at first impression, seem to be predictable and easily accommodated, based upon 30 cutter back rake and WOB, such is not the case, due to the variables encountered during a drilling operation, previously noted herein. Therefore, it would be desirable to provide a PDC cutter having a diamond table/substrate end face interface able to accommodate

Al - -

the wide sv\dngs in both magnitude and direction of forces encou,.lered by PDC cutters during actual drilling operations, particularly in drilling formations of medium-to-high compressive strength rock, or containing stringers of such rock while at the same time providing a s superior mechanical connection between flee diamond and substrate and 5 sufficient diamond volume across the cutting Lice for drilling an extended borehole interval. DISCLOSURE OF INVENTION

The present invention addresses the requirements stated above, and includes 10 PDC cutters having an enhanced diamond table-to-substrate interface, as well as drill bits so equipped.

The cutters of the present invention, while having demonstrated utility in the context of PDC cutters, encompass any cutters employing superabrasive material of other tripes, such as thermally stable PDC material and cubic boron nitride compacts.

15 The inventive cutters may be said to comprise, in broad terms, cutters having a superabrasive table formed on and mounted to a supporting substrate. Again, while a cemented WC substrate may be usually employed, substrates employing other materials in addition to, or in lieu of, WC may be employed in the invention.

The inventive cutter comprises a table comprising a volume of superabrasive 20 material and exhibiting a two-dimensional, circular cutting face mounted to an end face of a cylindrical substrate. An interface between the end face of the substrate and the volume of superabrasive material includes at least one annular surface of substrate material which is defined, in cross-section taken across and parallel to the longitudinal axis of the cutter, by an arc. The annular surface is preferably a spherical, or spheroidal, 25 surface of revolution about the longitudinal axis of the cutter, or a portion of a toroid transverse to and centered on the longitudinal axis. If a spherical surface of revolution is employed, the center point thereof lies coincident with the longitudinal axis or centerline of the cutter. The surface of revolution may or may not extend at its outer periphery to the side of the substrate and is bounded at its inner periphery by another surface of 30 revolution. The center of the substrate end face lying within the annular surface of revolution may exhibit a variety of topographic configurations. The superabrasive table formed over the substrate end face conforms thereto along the interface, while the

- ! - 5 exterior surface of the table may be provided with features such as charr,fers as are conventional and known in the art.

I The aima]ar surface of the suioStrate end face, by virtue of its arcuate cross sectional configuration, provides an interface designed to address nulti-directional 5 resultant loading of the cutting edge at the periphery of the cutting face of the superabrasive table. In general, resultant loads at the cutting edge are directed at an angle with respect to the longitudinal axis or centerline of the cutter which varies between about 20 alla about 70 . The arcuate surface is designed so that a normal vector to the substrate material will lie parallel to, and opposing, the force vector 10 loading the cutting edge of the cutter. Stated another way, since the angle of cutting edge loading varies widely, the arcuate surface presents a range of normal vectors to the resultant force vector loading the cutting edge so that at least one of the normal vectors will, at any given time and under any anticipated resultant loading angle, be parallel and in opposition to the loading. Thus, at the area of greatest stress experienced at the 15 interface, the superabrasive material and adjacent substrate material will be in compression, and the interface surface will lie substantially transverse to the force vector, beneficially dispersing the associated stresses and avoiding any shear stresses.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS

20 FIG. 1 is a side elevation of a first embodiment of a superabrasive cutter according to the present invention; FIG. 2 is a side elevation of a second embodiment of a superabrasive cutter according to the present invention; FIG. 3A is a side half-sectional elevation of a supporting substrate having utility 25 in a third embodiment of a superabrasive cutter according to the present invention, FIG. 3B is a side elevation of the substrate of FIG. 3A, FIG. 3C is a top elevation of the substrate of FIG. 3A, and FIG. 3D is an enlarged cross-sectional detail of Area D in FIC'.

3A; FIGS. 4 through 16 depict, in side sectional elevation, additional embodiments of 30 substrates having utility with superabrasive cutters according to the present invention; and

(' - 6 FIG. 17 is a side perspective view of a rotary dray bit equipped v; i,il cubers according to the present invention.

5 BES 1 MODE(S) FOR CARP YING OUT THE INVENTION

Referring to FIG. i of the drawings. a first embodiment 10 of the inventive cutter will be described. Cutter I O includes a substrate 12 having an end face 14 on which a superabrasive table, such as a polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) table 16, is formed. Substrate 12 is shown in side elevation with table 16 thereon shown as 10 transparent (rather than in cross-section, with hatching) for clarity in explaining the structure and advantages of the invention in detail, although those of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that the superabrasive material, such as a PDC, is opaque.

Substrate 12 is substantially cylindrical in shape, of a constant radius about centerline or longitudinal axis L. End face 14 of substrate 12 includes annular surface 15 20 comprising a spherical surface of revolution of radius R having an inner circular periphery 22 and an outer circular peripheral 24, the center point of the sphere being located at 26, coincident with centerline or longitudinal axis L. The inner periphery 22 abuts a flat annular surface 28 extending transverse to centerline or longitudinal axis L, while the concave center 30 of substrate end face 14 comprises another spherical surface 20 of revolution of radius Rat about center point 32, again coincident with centerline or longitudinal axis L. Superabrasive table 16 overlies end face 14 and is contiguous therewith, extending to side wall 34 of substrate 12 and defining a linear exterior boundary 36 therewith. Cylindrical side wall 38 of table 16, of the same radius as substrate 12, lies above boundary 36 and extends to inwardly-tapering frustoconical 25 sidewall 40, which terminates at cutting edge 42 at the periphery of cutting face 44. As shown, cutting edge 42 is chamfered at 46 as known in the art, although this is not a requirement of the invention. Typically, however, a nominal 0.254 rum (0.010 inch) depth, 45 angle chamfer may be employed. Larger or smaller chamfers may also have utility, depending upon the relative hardness of the formation or formations to be drilled 3 0 and the need to employ chamfer surfaces of a given cutter or cutters to enhance bit stability as well as cut the formation. Cutter 10 is shown in FIG. I oriented with respect to a formation 50, as it would be conventionally oriented on the face 52 of bit 54

i i ll -7 (both shown in broken lines for clarity) during drilling, with cutting face 44 oriented ! _ generally transverse to the direction of cutter travel as the bit rotates and the cutter traverses a shallow, helical path as the bit drills ahead into tile formation. Also as is conN!en.ior al, cutter I O is oriented so that the cutting fare 4exhibits a negative back 5 rake toward formation 50, leaning backward will; respect to the direction of clatter travel from a line perpendicular to the path P of cutter travel tl -ough the formation:0.

As cutter 10 travels ahead and engages the formation to a depth of cut (DOC) dependent upon WOB and formation characteristics, cutter l0 is loaded at cutting edge 49 by a resultant force FR, which is dependent upon WOB and torque applied to the drill 10 bit, the latter being a function of bit rotational speed, DOC and formation hardness. As previously mentioned, instantaneous WOB, rotational speed and DOC may fluctuate widely, resulting not only in substantial changes in magnitude of PR, but also in the angle a thereof, relative to longitudinal cutter axis L. As noted above, under most drilling conditions and even under the widest variation in drilling parameters and cutter 15 back rakes, angle varies in a range between an a, of about 20 and an a2 of about 70 . As can readily be seen in FIG. 1, annular surface 20, comprising the aforementioned spherical surface of revolution, lies in an area where forces acting on the cutter I O are greatest and presents an annular surface orientation facing FR SO that normal vectors to surface 20 are oriented over a range VN} through VN2, within which 20 range there is at least one normal vector VNP, which is parallel to and coincident with, or only minutely offset from, FR at any given instant in time This load- accommodating topography of annular surface 20 thus distributes FR in an area of substrate end face 14 substantially perpendicular to FR It is also notable that the area of end face 14 lying within annular surface 20 is configured with annular surface 28 and concave center 3 0 to 25 provide a substantial superabrasi e material depth for table 16 and also an effective mechanical interlock along the interface between table 16 and substrate 12. Moreover, the presence of annular surface 20, dictating an increasing depth of superabrasive material as the table 16 approaches its periphery, generates a beneficial residual (from fabrication) compressive stress concentration in the area of the table periphery where 30 cutter loading is greatest and provides a large volume of superabrasive material in the area of contact with the formation to minimize cutter wear.

ll Referring to FIG hi, another embodiment i I O of the cutter of the invention will be described. Features of cutter- I O also incorporated in cutter 1 10 are identi.f ed by the same reference nur lerals for clarify. Cutter 10 i!:cludes a substrate 1 12 having an end face 114 on which a supefabrasive table, such as a polycrystallir e diamond compact 5 (P:DC) table 1 16, is formed. Subsifate 1 12 is shown in side elevation with table 1 16 thereon shown as transparent (rather than in cross-section, with hatching) for clarity in explaining the structure and advantages of the invention in detail, although those of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that the superabrasive material, such as a PDC, is opaque. 10 Substrate 1 12 is substantially c:,;lindrical in shape, of a constant radius about longitudinal axis or centerline L. End face 1 14 of substrate 1 12 includes annular surface 120 comprising a spherical surface of revolution of radius if, having an inner circular periphery 122 and an outer circular periphery 124, the center point of the sphere being located at 126, coincident vvith longitudinal axis or centerline L. The ironer periphery 15 122 abuts another annular surface 128 comprising a spherical surface of revolution of radius R4 the center point of the sphere being located at 13 O. coincident with longitudinal axis or centerline L The inner periphery 132 of annular surface 128 abuts yet another arcuate, spherical surface of revolution 134, of radius Rs about center point 136, coincident with longitudinal axis or centerline L. It should be noted that the 20 uppermost portion of spherical surface of revolution 134 is at the same elevation as inner periphery 122 of Granular surface 120, although this is not a requirement of the invention. Superabrasive table 116 overlies end face 114 and is contiguous therewith, extending to side wall 34 of substrate 112 and defining a linear exterior boundary 36 25 therewith. Inwardly-tapering frustoconical side wall 40 of table 116 commences adjacent boundary 36 and is ofthe same radius as substrate 112, extending above boundary 36 to cutting edge 42 at the periphery of cutting face 44. As shown, cutting edge 42 is chamfered at 46 as known in the art, although this is not a requirement of the invention. 30 As with cutter 10, it will be readily appreciated that annular surface 120 of end face 1 14 of substrate 1 12 of cutter 1 10 will provide a range of normal vectors sufficient to accommodate the range of orientations of resultant force loads acting on cutter 1 10

.: - - proximate CU tii1g edge 42 during a drilling operatio and distribute the n over an area of end face 1 4 Lang substantially transverse to the loads. Again as with cutter 10 it will be appreciated that a substantial depth of superabrasive material is retained for table I 16, and that;1 mechar icailv, effccti;;, sy rnn c- ric l interlocking; arra: gem?nt is prodded 5 at the interface between table 116 and substrate 11 a.

FIG. 3A shows yet ar1otller substrate end face configuration for a cutter according to the present invention in cross-section, while FIG. 3B shows substrate 212 in side elevation and FIG. 3C is a top elevations of end face 214. As with the other embodirnents substrate 212 is substantially cylindrical and includes a number of 10 contiguous, annular surfaces surrounding a circular central surface on end face 214.

From the side exterior of substrate 219 inwardly; an armular lip or shoulder 240 extends inwardly from side wall 934, meeting annular surface 242, which comprises a spherical surface of revolution. Annular, arcuate surface 244 lies inwardly of annular surface 242, within which lies arcuate surface 246, within which lies a central surface of revolution 15 248. Surfaces 242, 244 and 246 are substantially coincident at their mutual boundaries, while the transition between lip 240 and annular surface 242 comprises a small, but measurable, radius 250 (see enlarged detail in FIG. 3J)). Similarly, the transition between surface 246 and central surface of revolution 248 comprises a small, but measurable, radius 252.

20 FIGS. 4 through 16 illustrate a number of other substrate end face configurations according to the invention, it being understood that superabrasive tables such as PDC tables, when formed thereon, will provide cutters according to the invention.

FIG. 4 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 312 having an end face 314 comprising a plurality of mutually adjacent spherical 25 surfaces of revolution 320,322, 324,326 and 328, the center points of which all lie coincident with the centerline or longitudinal axis L of the substrate 312. In this and subsequent figures, extensions of the actual end face spherical surfaces of revolution in the plane of the paper have been shown in broken lines for a better appreciation of the spherical nature thereof.

30 FIG. 5 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 412 having an end face 414 comprising a single, outer, spherical, annular surface of revolution 420 surrounding an upwardfacing conical surface of revolution 422, the

-10 center points of both surfaces of revolution 1 'ing on the centerline or!ongitudirlal axis I of the substrate 12.

FIG. 6 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 12a 76.a ing an end face 'Ida cornprisi- lg a single, outer. soncrical, aiUlUt?.t su.rt^3ce (if 5 revolution 420 surrounding an upwardcino hustoconical surface of revolution 424, which in turn surrounds a convex, spherical surface of revolution 42G. All three surfaces of revolution have center points coincident with the centerline or longitudinal axis I, of substrate 412a.

FIG. 7 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 10 412b having an end face 414b comprising a single outer, spherical, annular surface of revolution 420 surrounding an up ard-facing frustoconical surface of revolution 424, which in turn surrounds a central, circular surface 428. Both surfaces of revolution have center points coincident with the centerline or longitudinal axis L of substrate 412b.

FIG. 8 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 15.412c having an end face 414c comprising; a single, outer, spherical, annular surface of revolution 420 surrounding a plurality of concentric annular grooves 430 having ridges 432 therebetween, the end face features being cer tered about centerline or longitudinal axis L. FIG. 9 depicts a side sectional elevation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 20 512 having an end face 514 comprising a central hemispherical surface 522 contiguous with and surrounded by a concave annular surface 520 comprised of a portion of a torrid of circular cross- section centered about the centerline or longitudinal axis L o substrate 512.

FIG. 10 depicts a side sectional ele; ation of a substantially cylindrical substrate 25 512a similar to substrate 512, having an end face 514a comprising a central hemispherical surface 522 contiguous with and surrounded by an annular surface 520 comprised of a portion of a toroid of circular cross-section. hemispherical surface 522, however, is intersected by a smaller, spherical surface of revolution 524 defining a central recess or concavity therein.

30 Other combinations of substrates exhibiting end faces comprised of various combinations of spherical, toroidal and linear surfaces of revolution are depicted in FIGS. I 1 through 15. As with the preceding f IGS. 4 through 10, spherical surfaces of

revolution; arid toroids, pays of which comprise substrate surfaces, have been shown, i part in most instarAces' in broken lines for clarity, as l. ave center points of certain features. Spherical surfaces of revolution have beer designated with act -.S',.,.croids v.;i.-h a"T, 5 and linear surfaces of revolution with an ' LS" It will also be understood that spherical surfaces of revolution may be replaced, as noted above, by spheroidal surfaces of revolutior, as depicted in FIG. 16 showing a substrate 612 having ellipsoidal surface of revolution E on its end face 614. Other non linear, or arcuate, surfaces of revolution may also be employed, as desired, in a similar 10 or transverse orientation to that shown in FIG. 16.

FIG. 17 depicts a rotary drag bit equipped with cutters C in accordance with the present invention.

It will be understood that the reference to "annular" surfaces herein is not limited to surfaces defining a complete annulus or ring. For example, a partial annulus in the 15 area of the substrate end face oriented to accommodate r exultant loading on the cutting edge is contemplated as included in the present invention. Similarly, a discontinuous or segmented annular surface is likewise included. Moreover, an "arcuate" surface topography includes surfaces which curve on a constant radius, such as spherical surfaces of revolution and toroids of circular cross- section as well as spheroidal 20 surfaces as those which include components from, for example, two distinct radii about center points, and further include surfaces which are non-linear but curve on varying or continuously or intermittently variable radii.

While the present invention has been disclosed in terms of certain exemplary embodiments, those of ordinary skill in the art will understand and appreciate that it is 25 not so limited. Many additions, deletions and modifications to the invention as disclosed herein may be effected, as well as combinations of features from the various disclosed embodiments, without. departing from the scope of the in ventioI; as defined by the claims.

Claims

( CLAIMS

1. A cutter for drilling a subterranean formation, comprising: a substrate having a longitudinal centerline and a substantially circular end face, the end face comprising, as taken in radial cross-section longitudinally parallel to the centerline, a non-sinusoidal, non- periodically repeating topographic configuration including at least one annular surface exhibiting an arcuate shape and comprising a spherical surface of revolution having a center point coincident with the centerline and the end face further including a second spherical surface of revolution having a smaller radius than the spherical surface of revolution and the same center point; and a volume of superabrasive material disposed over the end face and having a two-dimensional cutting face spaced from the substrate end face, the cutting face having a peripheral cutting edge.

2. A drill bit for drilling a subterranean formation, comprising: a bit body having a face at one thereof and structure at an opposing END thereof for connecting the bit to a drill string; at least one cutter according to claim 1 mounted to the bit body over the bit face.