GB2106246A

GB2106246A - Rate of temperature change detectors

Info

Publication number: GB2106246A
Application number: GB08218734A
Authority: GB
Inventors: David John Andrews; William Barrie Hart
Original assignee: Chubb Fire Security Ltd
Current assignee: Chubb Fire Ltd
Priority date: 1981-07-14
Filing date: 1982-06-29
Publication date: 1983-04-07
Also published as: EP0070137A1; AU8591582A; GB2106246B; CA1166717A; NZ201202A

Description

1

GB 2 106 246 A 1

SPECIFICATION

Rate of temperature change detectors, and fire alarm and fire extinguishing systems using such detectors

5 The present invention relates to rate of temperature change detectors particularly though not exclusively for use as "rate of rise" fire detectors, and to fire alarm and fire extinguishing systems employing such detectors. 10 Detectors in accordance with the invention include so-called shape memory effect (SME) elements. An SME element is made from a material, usuaelly an alloy, which undergoes a transformation in its crystallographic structure 15 when heated or cooled through a particular temperature range, this transformation being accompanied by significant change in elastic modulus. By appropriate thermal and mechanical treatment of an element made from such material, 20 the element can be arranged to exhibit a first stable shape at temperatures below the appropriate transformation range and a different stable shape at temperatures above that range, the element being capable of changing 25 reversibly between its low and high temperature shape conditions which heated and cooled through the transformation range. In other words the element behaves in a manner indicative of retaining a "memory" for either shape. 30 Such elements are know, examples of alloys which exhibit the shape memory effect including certain nickel-titanium and copper-zinc-aluminium alloys.

An important application for a rate of 35 temperature change detector according to the invention is as a so-called "rate of rise" fire detector. Such devices must be capable of responding primarily to specified rates of increase in ambient temperature in the region monitored, 40 as opposed to the absolute (ie instantaneous)

value of temperature, although it is desirable that they shall also respond to a predetermined maximum ambient temperature irrespective of the rate of change of temperature at that time. For 45 example, the relevant European Standard EN54: Part 5 (= BS 5445: Part 5:1977) lays down various response times for such devices at different rates of rise of air temperature commencing from a standard temperature of 50 25°C, ranging from a response time of between 29 minutes and 45 minutes 40 seconds at a rate of rise of 1 °C/minute (for the intermediate response grade 2) to a response time of between 15 seconds and 1 minute 34 seconds at a rate of 55 rise of 30°C/minute. Additionally, with rates of rise less than 1 °C/minute the detector must not. operate at an air temperature below 54°C but must operate between 54°C and 70°C. The specified upper limits of response time to the 60 given rates of rise of temperature are of course intended to ensure that detectors respond sufficiently quickly to a fire, while a lower limit of response time is also specified in order to minimise the incidence of false alarms due to changes in the ambient temperature where no fire has occurred. The upper and lower limits to the absolute temperature to which detectors must respond under "static" conditions (ie with a rate of rise less than 1 °C/minute) are specified for similar reasons.

With the foregoing in mind, the invention provides in one aspect a rate of temperature change detector comprising two shape memory effect elements each one of which is adapted to respond to specified changes of temperature within a region wherein the detector is, in use, disposed; the response exhibited by a first said element tending to provide an output from the detector; the second said element being coupled to the first element whereby the response exhibited by the second element opposes the response of the first element; and the arrangement being such that the two said elements respond at different effective rates to the same change of temperature in the region.

With a detector in accordance with the invention, the response of the first SME element tending to provide an output while the response of the second SME element opposes the first element, the time taken for an output to be provided when the monitored region exhibits a given rate of change of temperature is therefore determined by the relative effective rates of response of the two elements, which can be chosen to confer upon the device characteristics appropriate to a "rate of rise" fire detector or to such other use as may be required. Preferably, at least when used in fire detection, means are also provided for limiting the response which can be exhibited by the second element in opposition to the first element, so that any further change of temperature which occurs after that response of the second element will result in an effective response by the first element only, leading inevitably to the provision of an output when a certain absolute temperature is reached and thereby ensuring the requisite "static" operation of the detector.

The different effective rates of response of the two SME elements could be achieved by employing elements with different inherent thermomechanical properties, such as-with different alloy compositions. It is generally more convenient, however, to employ two similar elements and to provide for the different rates of response by arranging that temperature changes occurring in the monitored region are transmitted to the first element more rapidly than to the second element, such as by surrounding the second element with structure of a lower thermal transmissivity than that (if any) surrounding the first element and/or by coating the second element with heat insulative material.

The form of the SME elements comprised in a detector according to the invention is open to considerable variation. One preferred form comprises a cylindrical coil of shape memory effect material which element tends to expand axially when heated through the transformation

65

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

2

GB 2 106 246 A 2

temperature range of the material. A second preferred form comprises a flat spiral of the material which tends to expand in part-conical form when heated through the transformation 5 temperature range, and a third preferred form is in effect the opposite, namely a part-conical spiral of the material which tends to contract towards a flat spiral form when heated through the transformation range.

10 Generally, each such SME element will be fixed in position at one location upon the respective element while another location upon that element is capable of displacing relative to the one location upon change of temperature of the element 15 through the transformation range. However, substanital spatial movement of part of an element need not always be an essential operation of a detector according to the invention where, for example, the element is constrained against 20 movement and the variation in force applied to the constraining means by the element as it undergoes its crystallographic transformation in the appropriate temperature range is detected. In practice a two-stage type of response may be 25 exhibited, where for example the aforesaid first element must first overcome a biasing load as it transorms under change of temperature and thereafter deflects by a small distance to provide an output from the detector.

30 The output from a detector as defined above may be used to exert a control and/or to give an indication as appropriate to the use to which the detector is put. As previously indicated such a device is particularly useful in fire detection and in 35 a second aspect the invention resides in a fire alarm system comprising at least one detector according to the first aspect of the invention sensitive to the rate of increase of temperature within a respective region and means responsive 40 to the output of the or any such detector to indicate the existance of an alarm condition.

In a third aspect the invention resides in a fire-extinguishing system comprising at least one detector according to the first aspect of the 45 invention sensitive to the rate of increase of temperature within a respective region, and means responsive to the output of the or any such detector to initiate the delivery of a fire extinguishing agent into the respective region. . 50 Three illustrative embodiments of fire detectors made in accordance with the invention will now be more particularly described with reference to the accompanying schematic drawings in which: Figure 1 is a sectional view of the first detector; 55 Figure 2 is a sectional view of the second detector;

Figure 3 is a plan view of the form of SME element employed in the detector of Figure 2, in its low-temperature condition;

60 Figure 4 is an elevation of the SME element of Figure 3, in its unconstrained high-temperature condition; and

Figure 5 is a sectional view of the third detector.

65 With reference to Figure 1, the illustrated detector is assumed to be mounted to the ceiling of a room and to be one of a plurality of fire detectors distributed throughout a building, all connected electrically to a central control station

(not shown). It comprises a plastics casing 1

within which is mounted a cup-shape plastics sleeve member 2 which in turn serves for the mounting of a cylindrical coil 3 of SME alloy and other parts of the mechanism to be described below. The two or so turns at the centre of the coil

3 are held rigidly by the member 2 and play no part in the actual operation of the device.

However, the portions 4 and 5 of the coil 3 to either side of this central portion are not rigidly restrained and are appropriately treated such that s below a particular temperature they exhibit a compressed form but when heated through the jr transformation temperature range of the alloy

(preferably a brass) of which the coil is made they *

increase in stiffness and thereby extend axially.

Since the coil portions 4 and 5 are parts of the same continuous element 3 and since they receive identical treatment during the manufacture of that element, their thermomechanical properties are substantially the same, which means that (in the absence of external constraints) when they are heated to the same temperature portion 4 will tend to extend upwardly from the central coil portion by the same distance as portion 5 extends downwardly.

The free end of the upper SME coil portion 4 engages a flange 6 towards the upper end of a sleeve 7 disposed within the coil 3. A further sleeve 8 is disposed in telescoping relationship with the sleeve 7 and these two components are coupled together resiliently through an ordinary (ie non-SME) coil spring 9 compressed between webs 10 and 11 at the respective lower ends of the sleeves 7 and 8. The free end of the lower SME coil portion 5 engages the head 12 of a rod 1 3 which extends upwardly through the two sleeves 7 and 8 and carries at its upper end a smaller head, defined by a snap ring 14 fast with the rod, which is disposed in telescoping ^

relationship within the upper sleeve 8. This rod 13 is coupled resiliently to the sleeve 8 through an ordinary coil spring 15 equivalent to the spring 9 and compressed between the web 11 and ring 14.

It will be appreciated from the above that the sleeve 8 is effectively suspended, by means of the two springs 9 and 15, acting on opposite sides of its web 11, between the web 10 of sleeve 7 and the ring 14 fastened to rod 13, and that the position of the sleeve 8 with respect to the fixed structure of the detector is thereby determined at all times by the relative portions of the rod 13 and sleeve 7. The sleeve 7 carries an electrical contact 1 6 which is normally spaced from a fixed contact 1 7 mounted to the member 2, but if the sleeve 8 is moved downwardly through an appropriate distance the two contacts are brought together to complete an electrical circuit and this event is detected at the control station, via suitable leads (not shown), as an indication of fire. The alignment between the two contacts during

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

130

3

GB 2 106 246 A 3

this movement is maintained by a pair of cheeks 22 (of which one is seen in the Figure) provided on the member 2 and extending to either side of the contact 16.

5 It will be further appreciated that the tendency of extension of the lower SME coil portion 5 is to move the rod 13 downwards, thereby tending also to move the sleeve 8 and contact 16 downwards by further compression of the springs 9 and 1 5. 10 On the other hand, the tendency of extension of the upper SME coil portion 4 is to oppose the extension of portion 5, through the resilient coupling provided by springs 9 and 15. It has been indicated that the response of the two SME coil 15 portions 4 and 5 to equivalent temperatures is to extend by equal amounts; their response to thermal conditions outside the detector structure is not, however, the same, and this can be explained by considering the relative dispositions 20 of the two coil portions with respect to the external ambience. Thus, the upper coil portion 4 is surrounded by structure 1,2 of low thermal transmissivity. The lower coil portion 5, on the other hand, is surrounded by a thin, thermally 25 transmissive sheath 18, of copper or aluminium for example. The casing 1 may be extended, as shown, as a series of "claws" 19 in the vicinity of the sheath 18 to provide impact protection for that area of the device, but these claws are spaced 30 apart and well ventilated such that they do not significantly impair heat transmission from the surrounding environment to the sheath. It follows that any fluctuations in the air temperature of the region in which the detector is sited will be 35 transmitted to the lower SME coil portion 5 more rapidly than they are transmitted to the upper coil portion 4.

In use of the device, at temperatures below the transformation range of the SME coil 3 (the lower 40 limit of which is, say, 23 °C) both coil portions 4 and 5 remain in their compressed condition, as illustrated, and the contact 16 remains spaced from the contact 17. In the event that the ambient temperature rises above that lower limit both coil 45 portions 4 and 5 will begin to extend, but as the lower coil portion 5 has a quicker response to rising temperature in the monitored region, as explained above, its extension will lead the extension of portion 4. Due to this differential 50 extension of the two SME coil portions there is a net movement of the sleeve 8 and contact 16 in the downward direction. This movement will continue so long as the ambient temperature continues to rise at a significant rate until the 55 point is reached where the extension of coil portion 5 exceeds the extension of coil portion 4 sufficiently to bring the contact 16 into abutment with the contact 17. The signal produced thereby is detected at the control station as an indication 60 of fire and functions automatically to raise the alarm and, if fitted, to initiate the discharge of fire extinguishing agent into the monitored region eg through an associated C02, sprinkler or the like system.

65 It will be appreciated that the greater the rate of rise of temperature in the monitored region, the sooner will the differential extension between the SME coil portions 4 and 5 reach the value required to close the contacts 16/17, and the device can 70 thus exhibit the characteristics specified for a "rate of rise" type o.f fire detector as previously indicated. At rates of rise of ambient temperature less than about 1 °C/minute, however, the effects of the lag in response of the coil portion 4 behind 75 that of the coil portion 5 become less significant so that while both coil portions continue to extend (assuming, of course, that the temperature continues to rise) they remain more or less in balance, and there is thus little or no net 80 movement of the contact 16. This is of importance in ensuring that false alarms are not given due to slow moving environmental temperature changes even when these give rise to relatively high ambient temperatures (eg where the detector is 85 used in foundries or the like locations where heat-producing industrial processes are carried out). It is also important, however, that the device should react if the ambient temperature rises to a certain maximum temperature, at whatever rate it is 90 reached, and this can be ensured in the "static" temperature condition by the provision of an additional component 20. This is a ring which is screwed into the member 2 and has a flange 21 which lies in the path of movement of the flange 6 95 of sleeve 7 when the upper SME coil portion 4 extends. After the coil portion 4 has extended by an amount to bring the flange 6 into abutment with the flange 21 further extension of that portion is physically prevent; there is, however, no 100 additional restraint on the further extension of coil portion 5 so that a further increase in temperature will result in extension of that portion only, with a resultant movement of the contact 16 towards the contact 17. It can thus be ensured that the 105 extension of coil portion 5 will cause closure of the contacts 16/17 when a specified absolute temperature pertains in the monitored region,

even if that temperature is reached at a slow rate which does not in itself cause activation of the 110 device.

In the illustrated embodiment two means of adjustment are provided which enable devices of this type to be accurately calibrated notwithstanding certain variations in the thermal 115 transmissivities of the detector structures and in the performance of SME coils 3 (particularly in the precise temperature at which transformation commences). Thus the contact 16 is in threaded engagement with the sleeve 8 so that relative 120 rotation of these two parts adjusts their relative axial positions. In effect this provides a means of setting the initial spacing of the contact 16 from the contact 17 to ensure appropriate "rate of rise" response times from the device. Secondly, the ring 125 20 can be screwed in or out of the member 2 to adjust the distance through which the upper SME coil portion 4 extends before its movement is terminated, thereby to ensure appropriate "static" response from the device.

130 Turning to Figure 2, this shows a rate of rise fire

4

GB 2 106 246 A 4

detector comprising two separate SME elements 23 and 24 of different form to the "elements" 4 and 5 in the Figure 1 embodiment. In this case each element is formed and heat treated to have a 5 flat spiral shape at temperatures below the transformation range, as more clearly seen in Figure 3, and to expand progressively in part-conical helical form with rise of temperature through that range, the unconstrained high-10 temperature form of these elements being indicated in Figure 4. In the low temperature condition of the device shown in Figure 2 the element 23 is held flat against the base of a thermally conductive sheath 25 of eg copper or 15 aluminium, by a plastics spacer 26 engaging its outermost turn (the spacer comprising two rings 26A interconnected by a series of webs 26B), and by a plastics moulding 27 held in the centre of the element. The sheath 25 is held in plastics casing 20 28 which may, as in the case of Figure 1, be extended downwardly around the sheath in a series of protective but ventilated "claws" 29. A platform 30 is held in the casing 28 by an upper housing member 31 screwed into the casing, and 25 in the illustrated low temperature condition of the device the second SME element 24 is held flat against this platform, above and spaced from the element 23, by the spacer 26 engaging its outermost turn and by a plastics moulding 32 held 30 in the centre of the element. The two mouldings 27 and 32 are biased apart by an ordinary coil spring 33.

The moulding 32 has an integral stem part 34 which is slidably borne in a central bore 35 of the 35 platform 30. A rod 36 is in turn slidably borne by the moulding/stem 32/34 and seats at its lower end in a recess 37 in the moulding 27. At its upper end the rod 36 carries a metal cap 38 which functions as a moving electrical contact, normally 40 spaced from a stationary (but adjustable) contact 39 screwed into the housing member 31. A further ordinary coil spring 40 is compressed between the cap 38 and the housing member 31.

The two elements 23 and 24 are identical in 45 manufacture and, as has been indicated, their tendency when heated through the relevant transformation temperature range is to expand in a part-conical form. Element 23 is mounted with its outer turn fixed in position by spacer 26 and is 50 arranged to expand upwards so that its central part carries the moulding 27 upwards when such expansion occurs. Element 24 is mounted in opposition to element 23 with its outer turn fixed in position by spacer 26 and is arranged to expand 55 downwards so that its central part carries the moulding 32 downwards when such expansion occurs. As will be appreciated, the axial position of the rod 36 and cap 38 is determined by the position of the central part of the element 23, the 60 cap 38 being moved to close the electrical contact gap between itself and contact 39 when the element 23 has expanded through a predetermined distance.

Element 23 is in heat conductive relationship 65 with the sheath 25 so that temperature fluctuations occurring in the region where the detector is sited are very quickly transmitted to that element. The element 24 is, however, relatively isolated from temperature changes 70 outside the detector and its own temperature will not rise so rapidly as that of element 23 when a detectable rate of increase in ambient temperature occurs. It will be noted, though, that element 24 is biased towards its flat condition by the load in 75 spring 33, whereas element 23 is biased towards its flat condition by both the load in spring 33 and the load in spring 40. The net effect of these measures in that when the detector is subject to a rate of temperature increase to which it is 80 intended to react, although the element 23 heats up more rapidly than element 24, element 24 begins to expand befored element 23, because the element 23 must overcome a greater biasing load before the force generated by its crystallographic 85 transformation results in any change of shape. Of course, the expansion of element 24 itself adds further to the biasing load on element 23 by compression of the spring 33 and the extent to which the expansion of element 24 delays 90 expansion of element 23 through the distance required to close the contacts 38/39 is a function of the temperature difference between the two elements. By this means the device can be arranged to exhibit the characteristics specified for 95 a "rate of rise" type of fire detector as previously indicated.

In addition, to ensure that the device reacts appropriately to a specified maximum ambient temperature under "static" conditions a nut 41 is 100 threaded on to the end of the stem 34, which nut comes into abutment with the platform 30 to prevent further expansion of element 24 after it has moved through a predetermined distance and thereby limits the bias applied to element 23 by 105 element 24. Calibration of the device as appropriate for its "rate of rise" and "static" response can be achieved by adjusting the position of the contact 39 in the housing member 31 and adjusting the position of the nut 41 along 110 the stem 34, respectively.

The detector of Figure 5 has much in common with the embodiment of Figure 2 and once again makes use of two separate SME elements which are capable of undergoing a transformation 115 between a flat spiral form and an expanded part-conical form. In this case, however, the low and high-temperature forms of the elements are reversed so that, as shown in the Figure, at temperatures below the transformation range the 120 two elements 42 and 43 are in the part-conical form. In the illustrated condition of the device the lower element 42 is held in contact with a thermally conductive sheath 44 of complementary shape, by a plastics spacer ring 45 engaging its 125 outermost turn and by a plastics moulding 46 held in the centre of the element. The upper element 43 is held against a platform 47 and complementary backing member 48 by the spacer ring 45 engaging its outermost turn and by a 130 plastics moulding 49 held in the centre of the

5

GB 2 106 246 A

element. The mouldings 46 and 49 are each provided with a circumferential series of inclined figures 46A and 49A which support the respective elements 42/43 internally.

5 The moulding 49 has an integral stem part 50 which is slidably borne in the platform 47. Also provided are a spring 51, rod 52, cap 53, contact 54, further spring 55 and nut 56, functionally equivalent to the components 33, 36, 38, 39,40 10 and 41 respectively of the Figure 2 detector. The operation of this detector is therefore completely analogous to that of the Figure 2 embodiment, in this case the SME elements 42 and 43 tending to contract towards the flat form to displace the 15 respective mouldings 46 and 49 when heated through the transformation range.

In any of the above-described embodiments the thermally-conductive sheath 18, 25 or 44 may be fluted (eg as indicated at44A in Figure 5) or 20 otherwise augmented (eg with one or more fins as indicated at44B in Figure 5) to increase the surface area of the sheath available for heat-collection from the enviroment. As a further modification, the various biasing springs in any 25 embodiment may have negative rates such that the electrical contact gap is closed by a snap action rather than the more progressive action which occurs with positive rate springs.

Claims

30 1 • A rate of temperature change detector comprising two shape memory effect elements each one of which is adapted to respond to specified changes of temperature within a region wherein the detector is, in use, disposed; the 35 response exhibited by a first said element tending to provide an output from the detector; the second said element being coupled to the first element whereby the response exhibited by the second element opposes the response of the first element; 40 and the arrangement being such that the two said elements respond at different effective rates to the same change of temperature in the region.
2. A detector according to Claim 1 wherein the two said elements are arranged such that, in use,

45 temperature changes occurring in the said region are transmitted to the first element more rapidly than to the second element.
3. A detector according to claim 2 wherein the first element is in heattransmissive relationship

50 with a sheath of thermally conductive metal exposed, in use, to the environment within said region, while the second element is surrounded by structure of relatively lower thermal transmissivity.
4. A detector according to any preceding claim 55 comprising means for limiting the response which can be exhibited by the second element in oppositin to the first element.
5. A detector according to any preceding claim wherein each said element is fixed in position at

60 one location upon the respective element, while another location upon that element is capable of displacing relative to the one location upon change of temperature of that element through the transformation range.

65
6. A detector according to claim 5 wherein the said other locations of the two elements are coupled together through a resilient coupling which biases such locations against said displacement.

70
7. A detector according to claim 6 wherein a further resilient bias is applied against displacement of said other location of the first element.
8. A detector according to claim 5 or claim 6

75 wherein an output member is resiliently coupled between the said other locations of the two elements.
9. A detector according to claims 5, 6 or 7 wherein an output member is directly coupled to

80 the said other location of the first element.
10. A detector according to claim 8 or claim 9 wherein said output member comprises the moving member of a pair of electrical contacts.
11. A detector according to any one of claims 5

85 to 10 comprising a mechanical stop for limiting the distance through which the said other location of the second element can displace.
12. A detector according to any preceding claim wherein each said element comprises a

90 cylindrical coil of shape memory effect material which element tends to expand axially when heated through the transformation temperature range of the material.
13. A detector according to claim 12 wherein

. 95 both elements are constituted by different portions of a single continuous coil.
14. A detector according to claim 13 wherein an intermediate portion of said single coil is held in fixed position and the two end portions of the coil

100 can expand in opposite axial directions.
15. A detector according to any one of claims 1 to 11 wherein each said element comprises a flat spiral of shape memory effect material which element tends to expand in part-conical form

105 when heated through the transformation temperature range of the material.
16. A detector according to any one of claims 1 to 11 wherein each said element comprises a part-conical spiral of shape memory effect c

110 material which element tends to contract towards a flat spiral form when heated through the transformation temperature range of the material.
17. A detector according to claim 15 or claim

16 wherein the two elements are juxtaposed with

115 their respective outer portions held in fixed position while their respective inner portions can displace towards one another.
18. A rate of temperature change detector substantially as hereinbefore described with

120 reference to Figure 1, Figures 2 to 4 or Figure 5 of the accompanying drawings.
19. A fire alarm system comprising at least one detector in accordance with any preceding claim sensitive to the rate of increase of temperature

125 within a respective region, and means responsive to the output of the or any such detector to indicate the existance of an alarm condition.
20. A fire extinguishing system comprising at least one detector in accordance with any one of

6

GB 2 106 246 A 6

claims 1 to 18 sensitive to the rate of increase of temperature within a respective region, and means responsive to the output of the or any such detector to initiate the delivery of a fire 5 extinguishing agent into the respective region.

Printed for Her Majesty's Stationery Office by the Courier Press, Leamington Spa, 1983. Published by the Patent Office, 25 Southampton Buildings, London, WC2A 1AV, from which copies may be obtained.