EP1657322B1

EP1657322B1 - Plasma spray apparatus

Info

Publication number: EP1657322B1
Application number: EP20050256848
Authority: EP
Inventors: Donn Blankenship; Paul H. Zajchowski; Gary C. Shubert
Original assignee: United Technologies Corp
Current assignee: RTX Corp
Priority date: 2004-11-04
Filing date: 2005-11-04
Publication date: 2013-10-30
Anticipated expiration: 2025-11-04
Also published as: EP1657322A3; EP1657322A2

Description

The present disclosure generally relates to a plasma spray coating apparatus, such as a microplasma spray coating apparatus.
Plasma coating methods and apparatus are known. For example, one such method and apparatus for plasma flame spray coating material onto a substrate by means of passing a plasma forming gas through a nozzle electrode, and passing an arc forming current between the nozzle electrode and a rear electrode to form a plasma effluent. The method includes introducing coating material into the plasma effluent, passing the plasma effluent axially through a wall shroud extending from the exit of said nozzle electrode, and forming a flame shroud for the plasma effluent. The coating is thereby applied to the substrate.
RU 2039613-C1 discloses a plasma spraying apparatus for depositing coatings made from the powder of refractory material.
JP 61-210170 discloses an apparatus for applying a ceramic film to a component.
EP-A-0342388 discloses a plasma spray apparatus having an electrode with a frustoconical tip.
One area where such technology is particularly advantageous is in connection with coating various components, particularly aerospace components like gas turbine engines and their components. For example, the blade roots of compressor blades can be coated with material to meet dimensional tolerance requirements for sealing the compressor blade with the compressor wheel and the like. Metallic coatings consisting of copper-nickel, aluminium-copper, and other similar composition materials have been applied in this regard using various conventional plasma spray coating processes. Typically, the coating process requires the workpiece to be masked in areas where the material transfer is not required and/or not desired. Furthermore, the workpiece is typically coated in a dedicated facility such as a gas turbine engine manufacturing plant or repair shop. Prior art methods and apparatus required masking the workpiece and applying the coating in dedicated facilities because the coating equipment was large and not portable and the spray pattern was too wide to accurately control the coating process. It would be desirable to improve the accuracy of spray coating devices so that masking and the like would not be required, as well as permitting hand spray coating repairs in the field.
In accordance with an aspect of the present invention there is provided a plasma spray apparatus as claimed in claim 1. The apparatus can be used for coating at least a portion of a workpiece such as a gas turbine compressor blade
The electrode extending from a cathode housing and terminating at a tip includes a substantially circular cross section along at least a portion of a lengthwise axis. In the present invention, the angled surface extending from the tip toward the cathode housing is formed on the electrode. A substantially flat edge having a predetermined height defines a forward edge of the tip.
Other applications of the present invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art when the following description of a preferred embodiment of the invention is read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

Fig. 1 is a schematic representing one embodiment of a microplasma spray apparatus and a workpiece of the present disclosure;
Fig. 2 is an exploded, perspective view of one embodiment of a microplasma spray apparatus constructed in accordance with the teachings of the disclosure;
Fig. 3 is an enlarged view of an electrode depicted in Fig. 2.
Fig. 4 is an assembled perspective view of the microplasma spray apparatus of Fig. 1, applying a coating to a workpiece; and
Fig. 5 is a flowchart describing one embodiment of a process for plasma spray coating a workpiece.
While the following disclosure is susceptible to various modifications and alternative constructions, certain illustrative embodiments thereof have been shown in the drawings and will be described below in detail. It should be understood, however, that there is no intention to limit the disclosure to the specific forms disclosed, but on the contrary, the intention is to cover all modifications, alternative constructions, and equivalents falling within the scope of the disclosure as defined by the appended claims.

Referring now to Fig. 1, one embodiment of a plasma spray apparatus 10 schematically represented by the dashed box outline is depicted. In generalized terms, the plasma spray apparatus 10 includes a plasma gun 12 having an arc gas emitter 14, an anode 16, and a cathode 18. An electric arc 20 is generated between the anode 16 and cathode 18. A plasma stream 21 is formed when arc gas is injected from the arc gas emitter 14 and passes through the arc 20. A powdered material injector 22 dispenses powdered material into the plasma stream which transports the powdered material to the workpiece 24 to form a coating thereon. The size of the plasma stream 21 created by the device and/or the power used by the device determines whether the device is considered a microplasma spray apparatus. When the plasma stream 21 is small and/or the power used by the device is low, the device is considered a microplasma spray device. Fig. 1 displays a microplasma spray device.
For example, the powdered material can form a solid coating with a thickness of approximately 0.0015 to 0.006 inches (0.038 mm to 0.152 mm) in a desired location on the workpiece 24. The coating material may be virtually any metallic, non-metallic or intermetallic powder, including the materials described above and ceramic-based materials.
In operation, an electric arc 20 is generated between the anode 16 and cathode 18 of the plasma gun 12. Arc gas such as, but not limited to argon, is emitted into the electric arc 20 formed between the anode 16 and the cathode 18. It should be understood that in practice the arc gas can be emitted prior to generating the electric arc. The electric arc 20 ionizes the gas to create the plasma gas stream 21. The ionization process removes electrons from the arc gas, causing the arc gas to become temporarily unstable. The arc gas heats up to approximately 20,000°F to 30,000°F (11097°C to 16426°C) as it re-stabilizes. The plasma stream cools rapidly after passing through the electric arc.
While a number of different embodiments and structural variations can be constructed to practice such an invention, the following describes one possible embodiment. Referring now to Fig. 2, an exploded view of such a plasma spray apparatus is again referred to by reference numeral 10. As will be described in detail below, the plasma spray apparatus 10 is operable for coating a workpiece, including, but not limited to at least a portion of a compressor blade 72 in a gas turbine engine (not shown). However, it is to be understood that the teachings of disclosure can be used to coat myriad other surfaces, including those on aircraft, land-based vehicles, weapons, sea-faring vessels and the like.
In the depicted embodiment, the plasma spray apparatus 10 includes the aforementioned plasma gun 12 having an anode 16 and a cathode 18. The cathode 18 is further depicted to include an insulated body 26 with an electrode 28 extending therefrom. The cathode 18 can also include threads 30 for threadingly engaging the plasma gun 12. The cathode 18 can also include an O-ring seal 32 to seal the leak path that is created at the interface between the cathode 18 and the plasma gun 12.
A powdered material injector 22 injects powdered material 34 into the plasma gas stream 21. The powdered material 34 is heated and super plasticized in the plasma stream 21 and is deposited on the compressor blade 72 (see Fig. 4) where it cools and re-solidifies to form the coating. The powdered material injector 22 includes a powder hopper 36 for holding and feeding the powdered material 34 into the plasma stream 21. The hopper 36 can be connected to the plasma gun 12 through a conduit 38 such as a flexible hose or the like. The conduit 38 can be connected via a threaded fitting 39 to a powder injector nozzle 40. The powder injector nozzle 40 can extend through an aperture 42 formed in the anode 16. The powder injector nozzle 40 can threadingly connect to the anode 16 via threads 43.
Conventional anodes are typically formed from a copper-tungsten alloy and provide very limited service life of approximately 10 to 20 minutes in a plasma spray apparatus 10. Copper and other similar metals have melting temperatures that are lower than the anode operating temperature. These metals can melt and cause the edge of the anode 16 to become molten and initiate cavitation erosion along an upper edge of the anode. In order to produce high quality coatings, the edge of the anode must remain relatively sharp. To achieve this, a commercially pure sintered tungsten material has been developed to produce a more robust anode. Test results using anodes made from sintered tungsten material has shown marked improvements in the erosion resistance over prior art anodes. Utilizing commercially pure tungsten in the anode 16 has increased the service life of the anode 16 to approximately between 10 and 20 hours.
A nozzle shroud 46 positioned on a forward wall 48 of the plasma gun 12 holds a nozzle insert 50 and permits the electrode 28 to extend through a center aperture 52 formed in the nozzle shroud 46. The nozzle insert 50 can be threadingly attached to an end of the nozzle shroud 46. A shield gas cap 54 is positioned over the nozzle shroud 46. An insulator 56 is positioned between the shield gas cap 54 and the nozzle shroud 46 to electrically isolate the shield gas cap 54 from the nozzle shroud 46. The shield gas cap 54 can be pressed fit onto the nozzle shroud 46 and over the insulator 56. The shield gas cap 54 includes a plurality of through apertures 58 for permitting shield gas to flow therethrough and shield the arc gas from ambient atmosphere. A center aperture 60 formed in the shield gas cap 54 permits high velocity arc gas to pass through and into the electric arc.
Cooling fluid, such as water or the like, can be utilized to cool the plasma gun 12. The cooling fluid is delivered to the plasma gun 12 via a cooling fluid hose 62. The cooling fluid traverses through internal passages (not shown) in the plasma gun 12 and flows through an inlet passage 64, into an anode holder 66 and back through an outlet passage 68. The cooling fluid reduces the temperature of the anode 16 during operation of the plasma gun 12. The cooling flow rate may be approximately 0.1 to 1.0 gallons per minute. A second conduit 70 can be connected to the plasma gun 12. The second conduit may be operable for providing electrical power, arc gas, and/or shield gas to the plasma gun 12.
Referring now to Fig. 3, the electrode 28 of the cathode 18 is shown in an enlarged view. The electrode 28 can have a circular cross-section, for example, of approximately 1/16^th inch (1.59 mm) in diameter, although other dimensions are certainly possible. The electrode 28 includes a tip 65 that is tapered, for example, by machining at an angle A, to form a substantially flat upper surface 67. The angle A can range between 0 and 90 degrees, but in one embodiment the angle A ranges between approximately 8 and 10 degrees. A distal end of the tip 65 can then be machined flat to a desired height B. In one embodiment the height B can range from .008 to .010 inches (0.2 mm to 0.25 mm). For variably sized electrodes, the height B can be defined as approximately between 10% and 20% of a diameter or a width of the electrode. The electrode can be formed from any electrically conductive material such as a copper alloy, but has been found to be advantageously formed from thoriated tungsten.
Referring now to Fig. 4, it is shown that a localized area of the compressor blade 72, such as a blade root 74, can be spray coated with powdered material 34. The plasma gas stream 21 is directed toward the portion of the compressor blade 72 to be coated. The plasma gun 12 is operated at a relatively low power range of between approximately 0.5 Kilowatts and 4 Kilowatts. The low power output of the plasma gun 12 significantly reduces the heat flow into the compressor blade 72 over that of conventional coating methods. The maximum surface temperature of the compressor blade 72 caused by the coating process is approximately 200°F (93°C). Such low power output and resulting low temperature on blade 72 allows the plasma gun 12 to apply powdered material 34 to a thin wall area of the compressor blade 72 without distorting the compressor blade 72 because the localized stresses caused by high thermal gradients do not exist.
The plasma gun 12 can apply coating material in narrow strips of, for example, about 0.5 to about 5 mm in width. This permits accurate surface coating even with a hand held device. The narrow strips of coating substantially eliminate the need for masking or otherwise covering the compressor blade.72 in areas where the coating is unwanted. The narrow spray pattern is controlled by the nozzle opening size. The hand held version of the plasma gun 12 can spray coatings on components even while they remain in an installed condition, such as in an engine or the like.
The arc gas flow rate of the plasma apparatus 10 may be between approximately0.5 and 3 liters per minute, although other rates are certain possible.
As stated above, the arc gas and shield gas are typically argon, but any suitable inert gas can be utilized as is known to those skilled in the art. The shield gas flow rate could range between approximately 2 and 8 liters per minute for a typical application.
The powder hopper 36 holds the powdered material 34 prior to being injected into the plasma gas stream 21 by the powder injector 22. Powdered material 34 can be transferred to the workpiece from between approximately 1 to 30 grams per minute. The plasma gun 12 can typically apply the coating from distances ranging from approximately 1.5 inches to 8 inches (38 mmto 203 mm) to the workpiece, but can vary depending on the coating application requirements. The plasma spray gun 12 provides unlimited angles of orientation relative to the workpiece because the pressurized powder feed system uses carrier gas to entrain and deliver the powdered material 34 to the plasma stream 21 and does not rely on gravitation as prior art systems did.
Compressed carrier gas, such as an inert gas, flows through the powder injector 22. Powdered material 34 can be entrained with the carrier gas as is known to those skilled in the art. The carrier gas will flow through the powder injector 22 at any angle of orientation and thus does not rely on gravitational forces to deliver powdered material 34 to the plasma stream 21. The plasma stream 21 provides a venturi effect with respect to the powder injector 22. The high velocity flow rate of the plasma stream 21 across the powder injector 22 generates a low pressure region which augments the flow rate of the carrier gas and the powdered material 34 through the powder injector 22.
The plasma spray gun 12 generates a relatively low noise level that ranges from between 40 and 70 decibels due to the low power output, thereby making the apparatus 10 suitable for hand held application. Current U.S. government regulations require hearing protection when environmental noise reaches 85 decibels. The plasma spray apparatus 10 can be hand held or alternatively held in a fixture (not shown) such as one that is computer controlled.
In one embodiment, a residual amount of electric current is transmitted from the anode 16 to the powder injector 22. This residual current can cause preheating of the powdered material 34 to occur which facilitates softening of the powdered material 34 prior to entering the plasma stream 21.
Referring now to Fig. 5, a block diagram generally describing the operation of the plasma spray apparatus 10 and the plasma spray coating process is illustrated. Initially, at block 80, arc gas is emitted from the nozzle insert 50. An electric potential is generated between the anode 16 and the cathode 18 of the plasma spray gun 12 and is directed through the arc gas, as described in block 82. Arc gas is directed through the electric potential to create the plasma stream 21. At block 84, powdered material 34 is injected into the plasma stream 21. At block 86, the plasma stream heats the powdered material 34 to a "super plasticized" condition such that the powdered material 34 is malleable when it is applied to a workpiece. At block 88, the powdered material 34 is applied to an unmasked substrate. The powdered material 34 then cools and solidifies as a hard coating on the substrate.
While the preceding text sets forth a detailed description of certain embodiments of the invention, it should be understood that the legal scope of the invention is defined by the claims set forth at the end of this patent. The detailed description is to be construed as exemplary only and does not describe every possible embodiment of the invention since describing every possible embodiment would be impractical, if not impossible. Numerous alternative embodiments could be implemented, using either current technology or technology developed after the filing date of this patent, which would still fall within the scope of the claims defining the invention.

Claims

A plasma spray apparatus for coating a workpiece, comprising:
an anode (16), a cathode (18), and arc generator generating an electric arc (20) between the anode (16) and cathode (18);

a nozzle to emit arc gas into the electric arc (20), the electric arc operable for ionizing the gas to create a plasma gas stream (21); and

a feeder providing powered material (34) into the plasma gas stream (21);

wherein the cathode (18) includes an electrode (28) extending from a cathode housing and terminating at a tip (65) which includes a substantially flat forward edge, the electrode (28) being operable for conducting electric current;

characterised in that:
the electrode (28) includes a substantially flat angled upper surface (67) extending from the tip (65) toward the cathode housing; in that it further comprises a cathode shroud (46) surrounding a portion of the cathode (18) and a shield gas cap (54) substantially encompassing the shroud (46), the shield gas cap operable for providing shielding gas as a barrier between the arc gas and an ambient atmosphere.
The plasma spray apparatus of claim 1, wherein the angle of the surface (67) is between 8 and 10 degrees.
The plasma spray apparatus of claim 2 wherein the angle of the surface (67) is 10 degrees
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the substantially flat forward edge has a height between 10% and 20% of a width of the electrode.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the electrode (28) includes a substantially circular cross-section along at least a portion of a lengthwise axis.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the plasma spray apparatus (10) is a microplasma spray apparatus.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the feeder is configured to use a carrier gas to entrain the powdered material (34) through the anode (16).
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, further including a powder hopper (36) for holding the powdered material (34) prior to the powdered material being injected into the plasma gas stream (21).
The plasma spray apparatus of claim 8, wherein the powder hopper (36) and feeder are combined in one apparatus.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, further including a powder injector nozzle connected to the feeder, the powder injector nozzle extending through the anode (16) and injecting powdered material into the plasma gas stream (21).
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the plasma apparatus operates at a power range of between 0.5 kilowatts and 4 kilowatts.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein a maximum surface temperature of the workpiece caused by the coating process is 200 °F (93 °C).
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the plasma apparatus is arranged to apply the coating material in widths of 0.5 mm to 5 mm to the workpiece.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the powdered material (34) is a metal alloy.
The plasma spray apparatus of any of claims 1 to 13, wherein the powdered material (34) is a ceramic based coating.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, further including a cooling system for cooling the plasma apparatus.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the plasma apparatus is operable for spray coating a workpiece at any angle of orientation.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the plasma apparatus generates a noise level of between 40 and 70 decibels.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the nozzle is positioned in a receiving aperture formed in the cathode shroud (46).
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, further including a shield cap insulator (56) positioned between the shield gas cap (54) and the cathode shroud (46).
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the anode (16) is formed from a commercially pure tungsten material.
The plasma spray apparatus of any preceding claim, wherein the anode (16) is formed from sintered tungsten material.
The plasma spray apparatus of any of claims 1 to 20, wherein the electrode (28) is formed from thoriated tungsten.