EP0783384B1

EP0783384B1 - Method and apparatus for joining sheet material and joint formed therein

Info

Publication number: EP0783384B1
Application number: EP94925111A
Authority: EP
Inventors: Xinrong Wu
Original assignee: BTM Corp
Current assignee: BTM Corp
Priority date: 1994-07-22
Filing date: 1994-07-22
Publication date: 2002-10-02
Anticipated expiration: 2014-07-22
Also published as: AU7514794A; JPH10503427A; EP0783384A1; DE69431490T2; DE69431490D1; EP0783384A4; WO1996003232A1

Description

The present invention relates generally to a joint formed between at least a first sheet of material and a second sheet of material, as well as to a method and an apparatus for forming said joint (see for example JP-A-63 192 524).
It is common within the metal forming industry to join pieces of sheet metal by punching or otherwise deforming them to cause an interlocking relationship in a localized area. However, these traditional joints have typically required shearing of the sheet material. Thus, these joints tend to leak and also have their corrosion resistant coatings destroyed.
More recently, an apparatus has been used for joining two or more sheets of material together by creating a leakproof and secure joint. These improved conventional joints are created by use of a punch acting against an anvil to produce what is known as a TOG-L-LOC® joint therebetween. Such a leakproof joint is disclosed in U.S. Patent Nos. 5,267,383 and 5,177,861, both of which are entitled "Apparatus for Joining Sheet Material" and issued to Sawdon.
The conventional TOG-L-LOC® leakproof joints consist of two or more sheets of material having a button or joint formed therebetween by a uniformly cylindrical punch forcibly pushing a punch side sheet of material into interlocking engagement with a die side sheet of material. These conventional leakproof joints have seen tremendous commercial success for use in varied applications such as steel microwave ovens and aluminium automotive bodies. While these leakproof joints hae proven reliable and inexpensive, it would be desirable to have an even stronger leakproof joint.
WO-A-94/22613 forms part of the state of the art under Article 54(3) EPC and discloses a method and apparatus for joining two sheets of material. A stepped punch acts against a coaxially movable anvil in a fixed die. A two stage punching action is used. In the first punch, the punch and die move in the same direction to punch a recess. During the second punch, the anvil is locked in a predefined position, so that the movement of the punch causes lateral extrusion of material of both sheet members.
According to a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a joint formed between at least a first sheet of material and a second sheet of material created by a single moving stepped punch acting against a die assembly having a fixed anvil and a set of laterally movable die blades, said joint comprising: nominal segments of said first and second sheets of material; recessed segments of said first and second sheets of material formed in said nominal segments; and a stepped segment of said first sheet of material formed along at least a portion of said recessed segment of said first sheet of material by movement of said stepped punch, the comer of said stepped segment being coplanar with the contacting surfaces of the segments of said first and second sheets of material; whereby said stepped punch, fixed anvil and die blades serve to increase material in the joint while interlocking said first sheet of material with said second sheet of material.
According to a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of forming a joint having a button diameter between at least a first sheet of material and a second sheet of material by using a longitudinally movable punch and a fixed anvil, said method comprising: (a) compressing segments of said first and second sheets of material between said movable punch and said fixed anvil; (b) creating an abruptly stepped segment in said first sheet of material closest to said punch; (c) forcibly displacing material from said stepped segment of said first sheet of material toward a further recessed segment in the same punching action as used in step (b) forming all of said stepped segment laterally inside the button diameter of said joint, the corner of said stepped segment being coplanar with the contacting surfaces of the first and second sheets of material; (d) outwardly expanding a segment of said first sheet of material; (e) interlocking an expanded segment of said first sheet of material with an adjacent segment of said second sheet of materia; and (f) withdrawing said sheets of material from between said punch and said fixed anvil.
According to a third aspect of the present invention, there is provided an apparatus for joining sheets of material, said apparatus comprising: a punch movable along a longitudinal axis, said punch having a cylindrical first portion at the distal end and a longitudinally adjacent, cylindrical, second portion, the first portion having a smaller lateral dimension relative to the second portion; a lateral step located between said first and second portions of said punch, at least a section of said step being curved; a set of laterally movable die blades located adjacent a surface of sheets of material opposite said punch; said punch being operatively movable against said sheets of material to forcibly deform and interlock together said sheets of material in. a leakproof manner forming a joint having a button diameter, said step of said punch being movable to forcibly create a step in at least one of said sheets of material, said step created by said step of said punch having a diameter less than the button diameter of the joint; and a stripper located adjacent said punch, said stripper not substantially deforming said sheets of material during advancing movement of said punch.
In accordance with the present invention, an improved apparatus for joining sheet material provides a stepped punch. This stepped punch serves to strengthen a joint between two or more sheets of material by creating a stepped segment in at least one of these sheets of material. During formation of this stepped segment, material is forcibly displaced toward another. segment of material that is outwardly expanded to interlock with the adjacent sheet of material.
The punch and joint of the present invention are advantageous over conventional punches and joints by achieving a surprisingly stronger leakproof joint. Furthermore, the joint of the present invention has improved wall thickness that is more resistant to fracture as compared to conventional leakproof joints. The punch, joint and method of the present invention thus reduce scrap during the joint forming process. Additional advantages and features of the present invention will become apparent from the following description given by way of non-limitative example with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
FIG. 1 is a side elevational view, partially in section, of a preferred embodiment apparatus for joining sheet material of the present invention, shown in its retracted position;
FIG. 2 is a side elevational view, partially in section, of the preferred embodiment apparatus of the present invention of FIG. 1, shown in its advanced position;
FIG. 3 is an enlarged side elevational view, partially in section and taken from within circle 3-3 of FIG. 2, of the preferred embodiment apparatus of the present invention;
FIG. 4 is a graph comparing the shear strength of a joint in aluminum created by the preferred apparatus of the present invention of FIG. 3 as compared to a conventional leakproof joint without a step therein;
FIG. 5 is a graph comparing the peel strength of a joint in aluminum created by the preferred apparatus of the present invention of FIG. 3 as compared to a conventional leakproof joint without a step therein;
FIG. 6 is a graph comparing the shear strength of a joint in steel created by the preferred apparatus of the present invention of FIG. 3 as compared to a conventional leakproof joint without a step therein;
FIG. 7 is a graph comparing the peel strength of a joint in steel created by the preferred embodiment of the present invention apparatus of FIG. 3 as compared to a conventional leakproof joint without a step therein;
FIG. 8 is a graph optimizing the anvil depth of a joint created by the preferred embodiment of the present invention apparatus of FIG. 3; and
FIG. 9 is a graph optimizing the button diameter of a joint created by the preferred apparatus of the present invention of FIG. 3.
It has been found that a conventional interlocking leakproof joint is strong and inexpensively formed. Such a conventional leakproof joint is formed by using a substantially constant diameter punch to draw a punch side sheet of material downward into interlocking engagement with a die side sheet of material. The punch side sheet of material has a cylindrical recessed cup internally formed therein while the lower peripheral external section of the punch side sheet of material is outwardly expanded. This expanded section of the punch side sheet of material interlocks with the adjacent section of the die side material and serves to outwardly expand the adjacent section thereof thereby defining an external button or joint immediately adjacent the anvil. An increase of fracture resistance in the necking area of the side wall will lead to a reduction of pullout strength in the interlocking of the button and vice versa. Although an optimum joint's strength can be obtained by carefully selecting appropriate tooling parameters, the carrying load of this conventional joint is limited because of the transformation of failure mechanisms (i.e., the maximum joint strengths cannot exceed the intersecting point of a fracture resistance curve and pullout strength curve as will be later discussed herein).
Based on the discussion above, an effort has been made to raise both fracture and pullout strengths of a joint at the same time. Consequently, a stepped punch of the present invention was developed. The idea to use the stepped punch of the present invention is to bring more material from somewhere in the sheet metal on the punch side to the joint element, and to increase simultaneously both thickness of the thinned side wall and locking volume in the interlocking expanded segment of the joint. Higher strengths for both shear and peel tests are expected if a stepped punch is appropriately designed.
Thus, the conventional joint has been surprisingly strengthened to a significant extent by forcibly deforming a step within the punch side sheet of material. This added step has provided a joint with tremendously improved strength while being relatively simple to create. The improved apparatus and joint is described hereinafter.
Referring to FIGS. 1 and 2, a preferred embodiment of an apparatus of the present invention is comprised of a punch assembly 10 and a die 12. Punch assembly 10 and die 12 serve to form a joint or button 14 between a first sheet of material 16 and an adjacent second sheet of material 18.
Punch assembly 10 has a punch holder 30, a stripper can 32, a stripper tip 34, a stripper spring 36 and a punch 38. As can best be observed in FIG. 3, punch 38 is defined by a distal drawing end 50, a cylindrical first drawing portion 52, a somewhat frusto-conical step 54, a cylindrical second drawing portion 56, a frusto-conical carrying portion 58 and a punch support shank 60. A longitudinal axis runs the length of punch 38. A first radius 70 is disposed on the peripheral edge of first drawing portion 52. First radius 70 is preferably 0.5mm (0.02 inches). A 0.25mm (0.01 inch) radius defines a fillet 72 disposed at the theoretical intersection between first drawing portion 52 and step 54. First drawing portion 52 has a slight draft angle between radius 70 and fillet 72 in order to remove punch 38 from joint 14. A corner 74 is located on the peripheral edge of second drawing portion 56. Alternately, corner 74 may have a radius thereupon.
Ideally, the punch length and diameters are adjustable depending on the thickness of the sheet material employed for joint 14. For example, when first and second sheets of material, 16 and 18, respectively, are each 2 mm thick aluminum, the longitudinal length of first drawing portion 52 is 2.5mm (0.095 inches). First drawing portion 52, proximate to its theoretical intersection with distal drawing end 50, has a diameter of 5mm (0.19 inches). By way of contrast the constant diameter drawing portion of the conventional leakproof joint punch without a step is 4.5mm (0.18 inches). Second drawing portion 56, proximate to its theoretical intersection with step 54, has a diameter of 0.53mm (0.21 inches). It has been found that it is preferable to depress punch 38 into the sheets of material 16 and 18 a sufficient depth such that the comer between step 54 and second drawing portion 56 is coplanar with the contacting surfaces between first and second sheets of material, respectively 16 and 18. The drawing depth can be roughly calculated as follows: dt = T1 + T2
dt is defined as the total depth of punch between a surface of first sheet of material 16 immediately adjacent stripper tip 34 to distal drawing end 50;
T₁ is defined as the thickness of the first sheet of material 16; and
T₂ is defined as the thickness of the second sheet of material 18.
It may also be desirable to add up to 0.38mm (0.015 inches) to the right side of the preceding equation to allow for any margin of error.
Referring now to FIGS. 2 and 3, die 12 has a substantially cylindrical anvil 90 surrounded by a set of die blades 92 which are laterally movable away from anvil 90 during formation of joint 14. Anvil 90 preferably has a flat face which mirrors the flat shape of distal punching end 50 of punch 38. Die blades 92 are retained to die 12 by an elastomeric band 98. Elastomeric band 98 is expandable to allow die blades 92 to pivot away from anvil 90 during formation of joint 14. Elastomeric band 98 then serves to move die blades 92 back toward anvil 90 upon removal of joint 14 from die 12. Elastomeric member 98 can alternately be replaced by a canted spring, compression spring, leaf spring or the like.
As can best be observed in FIG. 3, joint 14 between first sheet of material 16 and second sheet of material 18 is defined by nominal segments 100, recessed or side wall segments 102, outwardly expanded segments 104, and bridging segments 106. Additionally, recessed segment 102 of first sheet of material 16 has an inside surface 120. A stepped segment 122 of first sheet of material 16 is located along inside surface 120 proximate with a bend 124 thereof.
The leakproof joint of the present invention and the apparatus used to create the joint of the present invention provide surprisingly significant advantages over conventional joints. The stepped portion of the present invention punch acts to create a stepped segment within the joint, thereby moving otherwise unuseful material toward the expanded segment of the joint.
The stepped punch 38 employs two different diameters acting on a particular region of the joint. This punch 38 brings two punch penetrations to the material sheets 16 and 18 in a single press stroke. It overcomes the problem that the side wall can be thickened only at the expense of a reduction in the interlocking. During the process of forming a stepped joint, the first drawing portion 52 with a smaller diameter acts just like the regular punch, drawing material towards the die opening to form a joint. The second drawing portion 56 with a bigger diameter acts like a second punch that extrudes and pushes down some material in the side wall of the punch side so as to create a cup-shaped inner recess therein. As a matter of fact, the first drawing portion squeezes the sheet metal on the bottom of the cup (bridging segments 106 between the punch and die), and the second portion of punch 38 squeezes the material in the side wall of the cup. The final joint 14 is then removed from the die and punch.
The action of the bigger second drawing portion is expected to obtain the following effects: increasing material volume in the joint element; thickening the cup-shaped wall in the joint; squeezing the material right below the cup-shaped wall outward to increase the interlocking; increasing the hardening of material in the thinned wall and interlocking by bringing more deformation to the material. The second effect will increase the fracture strength, while the third effect will result in a better resistance to a pullout failure. The last effect will benefit both fracture and pullout strengths.
There is a difference in the thickness of the thinned region and shape of the interlocking between the stepped and conventional leakproof joints. For the joint made by a stepped punch, the cup shaped recessed wall is thicker and the material in the interlocking expanded segment, especially in the gap between die blades, moves outward more than in conventional joints. They contribute to the increase of both fracture and pullout resistance. That is why a higher load carrying ability is observed for the present invention joint made by a stepped punch.
As can be seen in FIG. 8, the effect of anvil depth (AD) on peel strength and failure mode can be optimized. FIG. 8 discloses peel test forces versus anvil depth for two sheets of material made from steel grade A366. Each sheet of steel had a thickness of 1.5mm (0.060 inches) while the punch diameter was 5mm (0.190 inches) and the button diameter (BD) measured 7.2mm (0.285 inches). Curve 200 schematically charts the failure by pullout test results while curve 202 schematically depicts the failure by fracture test results. The intersection of 204 of these two curves provides the optimum anvil depth for the present invention joint.
Referring to FIG. 9, the effect of button diameter (BD) based on peel strength and failure mode is shown. This test employs two sheets of steel, grade A366, each having a thickness of 1.5mm (0.060 inches). The punch used for this test had a first drawing portion diameter of 0.190 inches while the anvil depth (AD) measured 1mm (0.040 inches) Curve 250 depicts the pullout failure results while curve 252 depicts the side wall fracture failure results. The intersection 254 between curves 250 and 252 demonstrates the optimum button diameter. Of course, additional trial and error may be required to adjust the various punch and anvil dimensions based upon individual sheet material batch thicknesses and differing material types.
Test results demonstrating the significant improvement in the present invention joint can be observed in FIGS. 4 and 5. FIG. 4 graphically represents a sheer strength test comparing conventional leakproof joints 140, without a step, to the present invention leakproof joints 142 having a stepped segment therein. Both joints were formed using 5mm (0.190 inch) diameter first drawing portions. An 8000 series Instron machine was used to perform these tests. Each test was performed twice. It will be noted that the present invention joint shown in FIG. 4 has significantly improved shear strength over the conventional joint without a step.
FIG. 5 graphically depicts a peel strength test comparing the present invention leakproof joint 144 to a conventional leakproof joint 146 without a step. Again, two tests were conducted for each type of joint. It will be noted that the present invention joint 144, having a step therein, has significantly improved peel strength over the conventional joint 146. Aluminum grade 5754, having a thickness of 2 mm, was used for each material sheet for the above shear and peel strength tests. For the conventional joint, the button had a diameter of 7.5mm (0.298 inches) (BD) while the present invention joint had a button diameter of 8.2mm (0.323 inches). The anvil depth (AD) of joint was 1mm (0.040 inches) for the conventional joint and 1,1mm (0.045 inches) for the present invention joint.
Shear strength testing results for two steel sheets of material are shown in FIG. 6. Fourteen gauge, grade A366 steel was used. The stepped punch had an anvil depth (AD) of 1.3mm (0.050 inches) and created a button diameter (BD) of 8.1mm (0.320 inches) while the conventional punch had an anvil depth (AD) of 1,1mm (0.045 inches) and created a button diameter (BD) of 7.7mm (0.305 inches). The results for the stepped punch are shown with the solid lines 300 and the results for the conventional joint, without a step therein, are shown with the dashed lines 302. The stepped present invention joint 300 test was repeated twice while the conventional joint 302 test were repeated three times. FIG. 7 graphically represents the peel strength test results for the same sized steel, punch apparatus and joint as that of FIG. 6. The stepped joint of the present invention is shown by the solid lines 350. The test was repeated five times for the present invention joint 350 and twice for the conventional joint 352.
While the preferred embodiment of this apparatus and joint has been disclosed, it will be appreciated that various modifications may be made without departing from the present invention. For example, the punch of the present invention may have multiple stepped portions thereof between three or more differing diameter drawing portions. Furthermore, while the punch of the present invention has been disclosed as having cylindrical portions thereon, these drawing portions may alternately have ovular, starred, polygonal or other shapes thereto. The distal drawing end of the punch or the anvil face of the die may also take on a variety of curved, slotted or angular configurations. Moreover, alternate die constructions may be provided in combination with the present invention punch or joint. Either of the sheets of material can be metallic vinyl, polymeric, composite, or any other deformable material. Of course, three or more sheets of material may also be used consistent with the present invention. The stepped configuration of the present invention can also be used in a TOX® joint wherein a die blade is fixed around and partially extends above an anvil with a trough therebetween. The TOX® joint is defined by a die-side second material sheet forced to expand downwardly into the trough when a first punch side material sheet is outwardly expanded to interlock with the second material sheet. Various materials and dimensions have been disclosed in an exemplary fashion, however, a variety of other materials and dimensions may of course be employed. It is intended by the following claims to cover these and any other departures from the disclosed embodiments which fall within the scope thereof.

Claims

A joint formed between at least a first sheet of material (16) and a second sheet of material (18) created by a single moving stepped punch (38) acting against a die assembly (12) having a fixed anvil (90) and a set of laterally movable die blades (92), said joint comprising:

nominal segments (100) of said first and second sheets of material (16,18);

recessed segments (102) of said first and second sheets of material (16,18) formed in said nominal segments (100); and

a stepped segment (122) of said first sheet of material (16) formed along at least a portion of said recessed segment of said first sheet of material (16) by movement of said stepped punch, the corner of said stepped segment (122) being coplanar with the contacting surfaces of the segments of said first and second sheets of material (16, 18);

whereby said stepped punch, fixed anvil and die blades serve to increase material in the joint while interlocking said first sheet of material (16) with said second sheet of material.
A joint according to claim 1, wherein an inside surface (120) of said recessed segment (102) of said first sheet of material (16) is substantially cylindrical in shape.
A joint according to claim 2, wherein said stepped segment (122) is disposed along at least a portion of said inside surface of said first sheet of material (16) proximate with a bend between the recessed and nominal segments (100,102) of the first sheet of material (16).
A joint according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising

an outwardly expanded segment (104) of said first sheet of material (16), extending from said recessed segment (102) thereof and interlocking with said second sheet of material (18); and

bridging segments (106) spanning between said outwardly expanded segment (104) of said first sheet of material (16) and an outwardly expanded segment (104) of said second sheet of material (18).
A joint according to claim 4, wherein said bridging segments (106) of said first and second sheets of material (16,18) are substantially flat and parallel to said nominal segments (100) thereof.
A joint according to any one ofthe preceding claims, wherein formation of said stepped segment (122) causes material to be displaced toward said outwardly expanded segment (104) of said first sheet of material.
A method of forming a joint having a button diameter between at least a first sheet of material (16) and a second sheet of material (18) by using a longitudinally movable punch (38) and a fixed anvil (90), said method comprising:

(a) compressing segments (106) of said first and second sheets of material (16,18) between said movable punch (38) and said fixed anvil (90);

(b) creating an abruptly stepped segment (122) in said first sheet of material (16) closest to said punch;

(c) forcibly displacing material from said stepped segment (122) of said first sheet of material (16) toward a further recessed segment (102) in the same punching action as used in step (b) forming all of said stepped segment (122) laterally inside the button diameter of said joint, the comer ofsaid stepped segment (122) being coplanar with the contacting surfaces of the first and second sheets of material (16, 18);

(d) outwardly expanding a segment of said first sheet of material (16);

(e) interlocking an expanded segment of said first sheet of material (16) with an adjacent segment of said second sheet of material (18); and

(f) withdrawing said sheets of material from between said punch (38) and said fixed anvil (90).
A method according to claim 7, further comprising expanding said adjacent segment of said second sheet of material (18) adjacent to said expanded segment of said first sheet of material (16).
An apparatus for joining sheets of material, said apparatus comprising:

a punch (38) movable along a longitudinal axis, said punch (38) having a cylindrical first portion (52) at the distal end and a longitudinally adjacent, cylindrical, second portion (56), the first portion (52) having a smaller lateral dimension relative to the second portion (56);

a lateral step (54) located between said first and second portions (52,56) of said punch, at least a section of said step being curved;

a set of laterally movable die blades (92) located adjacent a surface of sheets of material opposite said punch (38);

said punch (38) being operatively movable against said sheets of material (16,18) to forcibly deform and interlock together said sheets of material (16,18) in a leakproof manner forming a joint having a button diameter, said step (54) of said punch (3 8) being movable to forcibly create a step in at least one of said sheets of material (16,18), said step created by said step (54) of said punch (38) having a diameter less than the button diameter of the joint; and

a stripper (34) located adjacent said punch, said stripper not substantially deforming said sheets of material (16,18) during advancing movement of said punch (38).
An apparatus according to claims 9, further comprising a fillet (72) disposed on said punch (38) at an intersection of said first portion (52) and said step (54) thereof.
An apparatus according to claim 9 or 10, further comprising a radius (74) disposed on said punch (38) at an intersection between said step (54) and said second portion (56) thereof.
An apparatus according to any one of claims 9 to 11, further comprising a radius (70) disposed on said punch at an intersection between said distal end and said first portion (52) thereof.
An apparatus according to any one of claims 9 to 12, further comprising:

an anvil (90) coaxially aligned with said first and second portions of said punch (38), said anvil (70) having a face thereon defined as a substantially mirror image shape coincidental with said distal end of said punch (38), said set of die blades (92) substantially surrounding said anvil (90) and being laterally movable away from said anvil (90) during forcible deformation of said sheets of material (16,18); and

means (98) for retaining said set of die blades (92) to said anvil (90) and for returning said set of die blades (92) against said anvil (90) upon removal of said sheets of material (16,18).
An apparatus according to claim 13 wherein upon said forcible deformation of said sheets of material (16,18) between said punch (38) and said anvil (90), a first segment of said sheets of material (16,18) proximate with said intersection between said distal end and said first portion (52) of said punch (38) are laterally expanded so as to interlock with one another, and said step (54) and said second portion (56) of said punch (38) further deform and push a second segment of at least one of said sheets (16,18) of material toward said first segment of said sheets of material (16,18).
An apparatus according to any one of claims 9 to 12, further comprising an anvil (90), said set of die blades (92) being stationarily disposed about said anvil (90) and at least partially extending there above and a trough being disposed between said anvil (90) and said die blades (92).
An apparatus according to any one of claims 9 to 15, wherein said step (54) is disposed with 1²/₃ nominal thicknesses of one of said sheets of material (16,18) from said distal end of said punch (38).