EP0020549A1

EP0020549A1 - Method of preparing monoesters

Info

Publication number: EP0020549A1
Application number: EP79901447A
Authority: EP
Inventors: James H. Babler
Original assignee: Individual
Current assignee: Individual
Priority date: 1978-10-25
Filing date: 1980-05-07
Publication date: 1981-01-07
Also published as: WO1980000837A1

Abstract

Des monoesters d'acides dicarboxyliques symetriques et de diols symetriques sont prepares avec de hauts rendements par la reaction d'un diacide ou d'un diol avec un alcool monohydrique ou un acide monocarboxylique, respectivement, en solution aqueuse. Le monoester resultant est extrait de la solution aqueuse immediatement apres sa formation par extraction continue avec un solvant non-polaire.Monoesters of symmetrical dicarboxylic acids and symmetrical diols are prepared in high yields by the reaction of a diacid or a diol with a monohydric alcohol or a monocarboxylic acid, respectively, in aqueous solution. The resulting monoester is extracted from the aqueous solution immediately after its formation by continuous extraction with a non-polar solvent.

Description

DESCRIPTION

METHOD OF PREPARING MONOESTERS

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention relates generally to monoesters of dicarboxylic acids and monoesters of dihydric alcohols and, more particularly, to monoesterification of symmetrical, dicarboxylic acids and diols respectively with monohydric alcohols and monocarboxylic acids to effect excellent yields (>90%, usually >95%) .

Because monoesters of dicarboxylic acids or dihydric alcohols have both a reactive ester and acid or alcohol functionality, they are of value as intermediates in the synthesis of many types of useful chemicals. Such compounds are useful in the manufacture of fine organic chemicals, as starting materials for preparing ω-amino acids, in the synthesis of certain types of nylon, as precursors to macrocyclic ketones and lactones valued in perfumery, and as intermediates in the synthesis of insect pheromones. As one example, monoethyl sebacate prepared according to the present invention may be used as a starting material in the following synthesis of traumatic acid -- a material useful both as a detergent additive (U.S. Patent No. 3,523,636), and as an anti-viralagent ( .S. Patent No. 3,542,826):

Monoesters of a, ω-diacids prepared in accordance with the present invention can also be utilized as starting materials in the preparation of nylon in a process suggested by C.S. Rondestvedt, Jr. [J. Org. Chem. , 42, 3118 (1977)].

Similarly, the monoacetate derivative of 1,8-octanediol can be used to prepare the attractant of the Oriental fruit moth:

BACKGROUND ART

Although monoesters of dicarboxylic acids and di hydric alcohols are useful intermediates, a problem which has hindered prior art efforts to synthesize such compounds is the occurrence of esterification at both reactive sites. The result is the formation of a large quantity of diester as an undesired reaction product. These diesters are typically difficult to separate from the reaction mixture.

One prior art approach to the preparation of such monoesters has been to start with the unwanted diester and, via selective hydrolysis, to convert one ester function to an alcohol or acid function. For example: With the notable exception of the diester of terephthalic acid [Rondestvedt, J. Org . Chem. , 42, 3118 (1977)] , this approach suffers from moderate yields (generally in the range of 40-70%) of the desired monoester, as well as some difficulty in separating the desired monoester from the reaction mixture, [i.e.. Organic Synthesis, Collective Vol. 4, p. 635 (1963)] .

Other approaches to the problem can be found in the literature, viz. , J. Am. Chem. Soc. , 70, 364, 3206 (1948); J. Org. Chem., 29, 1252 (1964); Org. Syn. Coll. Vol. 2, pp. 276-77 and references therein. All of these procedures present poor yields of the monoester and difficulty in eliminating the diester from the reaction product.

Of substantial interest to the background of the invention is the fact that the prior art uniformly suggests that esterification reactions should be run under essentially anhydrous reaction conditions. Indeed, since the process of ester formation from an acid and an alcohol is reversible, the reaction is generally performed under conditions providing for the water to be removed from the reaction mixture as soon as it is formed. This is necessary since water in the presence of a strong acid catalyst is known to effect the reverse process -- i.e., hydrolysis of an ester.

DISCLOSURE OF INVENTION

According to the present invention monoesters of diacids and monoesters of diols are prepared in exceptionally high yields accompanied by the substantial reduction of diester products. The method of the invention, in contrast to the methods of the prior art, requires the presence of a substantial amount of water. The method can be illustrated by the following examples:

[wherein R is an alkyl group (-CH₂)_n and R' is an alkyl group or H.]

Although the exact amount of water employed may vary with the solubility of the diacid or diol in the water-alcohol or water-acid reagent mixture, the molar concentration of water should always be at least equal to the molar concentration of the monohydric alcohol or monocarboxylic acid (II or IV) . Indeed, it has been found that for a given diacid or diol, the more water used (consistent with solubility limits of the reactants) , the better the results. If less water is used, the desired monoesterification is virtually impossible to accomplish in even moderate yield.

In the case of both the diacid and diol starting materials, the reaction proceeds at room temperature. A strong acid catalyst (Ka>10^-2) such as sulfuric acid greatly aids the reaction. In its absence, esterification can still occur -- albeit quite slowly. The process of selective monoesterification depends upon the use of a technique of continuous extraction of the reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent such as a liquid alkane, a cycloalkane, an aromatic hydrocarbon, a halide derivative of a hydrocarbon, or mixtures thereof. These nonpolar solvents are, of course, essentially insoluble in the aqueous reaction mixture. In a preferred method the solvent is heated to boiling, condensed, and the condensate passed through the aqueous reaction mixture by using, for example, a continuous extraction apparatus employing a reflux condenser.

Suitable solvents include hexane, heptane, cyclohexane, benzene, toluene, xylene, and carbon tetrachloride. Cyclohexane, in particular, works quite well. As a rule, starting material diols and diacids should be soluble in the aqueous reaction mixture yet virtually insoluble or of very low solubility in the nonpolar solvent used for the continuous extraction process. The resultant monoester product, however, is very soluble in the nonpolar solvent being passed through the reaction mixture. Thus, as soon as the less polarmonoester product has formed, it is extracted out of the reaction mixture. The presence of a large amount of water (always >50% on a molar basis) permits this extraction to occur more readily and greatly retards the likelihood of diester formation.

A diacid or a diol suitable for use in the practice of the present invention must be symmetrical and have some appreciable solubility in a water-alcohol or water-acid mixture. Thus, while diacids and diols containing from 2 to 12 carbon atoms are particularly suitable, the process should also be useful for larger molecules having some degree of solubility in a water-alcohol or a water-acetic acid (for diols) mixture.

The symmetrical diols employed in processes according to the invention may be either primary or secondary acyclic or alicyclic compounds. Particularly useful compounds can be represented by formulae 1 through 3,

(1) HO-CH₂(CH₂)nCH₂-OH wherein: n has a value of from 0 to 10 inclusive wherein: x has a value of from 0 to 4; y has a value of from 0 to 8; and 2x + y <8

wherein m has a value of from 1 to 2. The process fails for dihydric phenols such as resorcinol (4).

Symmetrical diacids useful in practice of the inven tion include acyclic diacids of the general structural formula, 5, wherein R represents a chemical bond or a straight chain alkylene having up to ten carbons, and the cyclic diacid, 1,4-cyclohexanedicarboxylic acid, of formula 6. The process is unsuccessful both with terephthalic acid, 7, since it is insoluble in water-alcohol, and with phthalic acid, 8, since it readily forms the corresponding anhydride, 9.

Monohydric alcohols useful in the esterification of diacids according to the invention include both methanol and ethanol. It has been found that higher molecular weight, water-soluble alcohols, such as n-propanol and isopropanol, are unsatisfactory. Despite their solubility in water, such higher monohydric alcohols tend to be soluble in the nonpolar organic solvent used in the continuous extraction process. Moreover, when the nonpolar solvent "picks up" the higher alcohol, this mixture very quickly extracts over the starting diacid making it virtually impossible to carry out the esterification reaction in the aqueous layer. More significantly, the reaction vessel containing the refluxing nonpolar organic solvent will, when higher monohydric alcohols are employed, build up an appreciable concentration of the alcohol and an esterification reaction can occur in the organic solvent mixture, leading to the formation of the undesired diester.

Similar problems arise upon attempted use of propionic or higher water-soluble acids to monoesterify diols. These higher acids are sufficiently soluble in the nonpolar solvent to prevent their use in the continuous esterification process. Thus the only monocarboxylic acids useful for the monoesterification of diols are alkanoic acids having up to two carbon atoms. Of this group, acetic acid is the preferred monocarboxylic acid, although formic acid can be used -- if the selected diol is soluble in an aqueous formic acid mixture.

The procedure employed to isolate the desired monoester from the starting reactants can vary depending on the nature of the starting diacid or diol. Gas chromatographic analysis ("GC") of the products derived from reaction involving low molecular weight, non-crystalline diols such as ethylene glycol did not indicate the presence of any starting diol. Thus no further isolation is necessary, save removal of the nonpolar solvent by distillation.

The C-2 through C-12 diacids, as well as the C-6 through C-12 diols, are all highly crystalline and virtually insoluble in the nonpolar solvent used for the continuous extraction process. As soon as the extraction solvent is allowed to cool to room temperature, the diacid (or diol) that has been extracted over (if any at all) by the nonpolar organic solvent can be removed by simple filtration and may be recycled. As the number of carbons in the diacid or diol becomes larger (i.e., 10 or more carbons), this process of recycling the starting material becomes more desirable.

After removal of any starting diacid or diol by filtration, the nonpolar solvent can be removed by distillation (under reduced pressure, if one so desires) and the purity of monoester so obtained is >95% in most systems examined. If one desires even higher purity, recrystallization of the monoesters from a suitable solvent may be easily performed since many of the monoesters are solids at room temperature. Alternatively, in the case of diacid derived products, the monoester is still acidic and can be separated from any diester by extraction into an aqueous phase using a weak base such as sodium bicarbonate. Subsequent acidification of the aqueous layer containing the acid salt allows recovery of the desired monoester.

BEST MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION

The following examples illustrate in greater detail practice of the present invention.

Example I 1,10-decanediol monoacetate

A solution of 4.36 g (25 mmoles) of 1,10-decanediol in 100 ml (1.77 moles) of glacial acetic acid was mixed with 130 ml (7.22 moles) of H₂O containing 0.25 ml (4.5 mmoles) of cone. H₂SO₄. This mixture, itself at room temperature, was then extracted continuously for two days using refluxing cyclohexane. The cyclohexane layer was then cooled to room temperature and 0.78 g (18% recovery) of crystalline 1,10-decanediol was recovered by simple filtration of this nonpolar organic phase. The cyclohexane was then removed from the filtrate under reduced pressure, affording 4.28 g (approximately 79% yield -- 97% based on recovered starting material of product. GC analysis showed the presence of less than 2% starting diol; the ratio of monoester to diester was 20 to 1. Hence the desired monoester was approximately 95% pure.

Example II

In a procedure similar to that of Example I, a solution of 4.25 g (24.4 mmoles) of 1,10-decanediol and 0.25 ml of conc. H₂SO₄ in 200 ml (3.53 moles) of glacial acetic acid and 30 ml (1.66 moles) of H₂O was extracted continuously with cyclohexane for 20 hours. The cyclohexane layer was then cooled to room temperature and the solvent was removed under reduced pressure using a rotary evaporator leaving behind 5.52 g of crude product. GC analysis indicated the presence of 3% diol, 41% monoester, and 56% of the diester — 1,10-decanediol diacetate. Since this procedure used only ~33% H₂O (on a molar basis) , the need for water (to minimize formation of the undesirable diester) is established. In the previous Example I, the aqueous layer was ~80% H₂O and ~20% acetic acid on a molar basis.

Example III Monoethyl sebacate

A solution of 3.093 g (15.3 mmoles) of sebacic acid in 100 ml (1.63 moles) of 95% ethanol was mixed with 120 ml of H₂O (6.94 moles H₂O, total) containing 1 ml (18 mmoles) of cone. H₂SO₄. [This aqueous solution is approximately 81% H₂O and 19% ethyl alcohol on a molar basis.] This solution was extracted continuously for two days using refluxing cyclohexane. The cyclohexane layer was then cooled to room temperature and 0.74 g (24% recovery) of sebacic acid was recovered by simple filtration of this nonpolar organic phase. After filtering off the sebacic acid, the cyclohexane layer was washed 15 times with 1M aqueous NaHCO₃ solution (15 x 10 ml) in order to effect separation of monoethyl sebacate from any diethyl sebacate, which remained in the organic layer. Each of these sodium bicarbonate washes was added to an Erlenmeyer flask containing 100 ml of ice-cold 2M aqueous HCl solution. The cyclohexane layer was then dried over anhydrous magnesium sulfate and filtered. Removal of the cyclohexane by evaporation at reduced pressure afforded 103 mg (0.40 mmole, 2.6% yield) of diethyl sebacate. The monoester was recovered from the aqueous hydrochloric acid mixture by thorough extraction with ethyl ether. The combined extracts were washed with 10% sodium chloride solution, dried over anhydrous magnesium sulfate, and filtered. Removal of the ether by evaporation at reduced pressure yielded 2.25 g (9.78 mmoles, 64% yield) . of monoethyl sebacate . The ratio of monoester to diester in this procedure was therefore 64 to 2.6 or approximately 25 to 1. Since the purity of monoethyl sebacate without separating it from any diester is >96%, there appeared to be no substantial need for the sodium bicarbonate washes and the rest of the workup procedures.

Example IV

A procedure similar to that of Example III was carried out by mixing a solution of 3.09 g (15.3 mmoles) of sebacic acid in 150 ml (2.44 moles) of 95% ethanol with 20 ml of H₂O (1.53 moles H₂O, total) containing 0.75 ml (13.5 mmoles) of cone. H₂SO₄. This solution was then extracted continuously with refluxing cyclohexane for 27 hours. The reaction products were isolated as described in Example III. Results: 617 mg (20% recovery) of sebacic acid which can be re-cycled in this monoesterification process; 753 mg (2.92 mmoles, 19% yield) of diethyl sebacate; and 1.72 g (7.48 mmoles, 49% yield) of monoethyl sebacate. The ratio of monoester to diester in this procedure was therefore 49 to 19 or approximately 2-1/2 to 1. It is noteworthy that the aqueous solution in this procedure was approximately 38% water on a molar basis and the concentration of H₂SO₄ was approximately 0.08M. In Example III, the concentration of sulfuric acid was approximately 0.08M and the aqueous solution was 81% water on a molar basis.

Example V Monoethyl adipate

A solution of 4.00 g (27.4 mmoles). of adipic acid in 30 ml of absolute ethanol (514 mmoles) was mixed with 180 ml (10 moles) of water containing 4 ml (72 mmoles) of cone. H₂SO₄. This solution was then extracted continuously for five days using benzene. The benzene layer was then cooled to room temperature and trace amounts of crystalline adipic acid were removed by filtration prior to isolation of the reaction products. After filtration, the benzene layer was washed thoroughly with 1M aqueous sodium bicarbonate solution, each wash being added to a flask containing sufficient aqueous hydrochloric acid to neutralize all of the NaHCO₃, in order to liberate monoethyl adipate from its salt. Dilute aqueous Na₂CO₃ solution, but not dilute aqueous NaOH, can be used in lieu of the sodium bicarbonate solution. If one uses aqueous sodium hydroxide to effect conversion of monoethyl adipate to a water-soluble salt, a substantial amount of hydrolysis of the monoester occurs while it is dissolved in the the aqueous NaOH solution. The benzene layer (containing diethyl adipate) was then dried over anhydrous magnesium sulfate and filtered. Removal of the benzene by evaporation at reduced pressure afforded 206 mg (1.02 mmoles, 3.7% yield) of diethyl adipate: bp (bath temperature) 55-65° at 0.2mm. The monoester was recovered from the aqueous hydrochloric acid mixture by thorough extraction with ethyl ether. The combined extracts were washed with 10% sodium chloride solution, dried over anhydrous magnesium sulfate, and filtered. Removal of the ether by evaporation at reduced pressure yielded 4.16 g (87.5% yield) of monoethyl adipate as a low melting solid, mp (after one recrystallization from ether-pentane) : 28-30°C.

Since the ratio of monoester to diester was approximately 96:4, there seems to be no substantial need for the sodium bicarbonate washes for the purification of the monoester via formation of a water-soluble carboxylate salt. Simple removal of the benzene should yield a product that is 96% pure. If greater purity is desired, the monoester can be recrystallized.

Example VI Monoethyl dodecanedioate

A solution of 4.616 g (20.1 mmoles). of dodecanedioic acid in 150 ml (2.44 moles) of 95% ethanol was mixed with 80 ml (4.44 moles) of H₂O containing 1 ml (18 mmoles) of conc. H₂SO₄. The mixture was not homogeneous at this point; as much as 50% of the starting diacid precipitated out of solution when the water was added to the ethanol containing this C-12 diacid. As the reaction proceeded, however, the diacid slowly re-dissolved in the aqueous layer and the reaction was able to be completed within the normal period of time.

This mixture was extracted continuously for 2-1/2 days using cyclohexane. The cyclohexane layer was then cooled to room temperature and 1.40 g (30% recovery) of dodecanedioic acid was recovered by simple filtration of this nonpolar organic phase. After filtering off this solid diacid, the monoester was separated from any diester in the cyclohexane layer by thorough extraction with 1M aqueous NaHCO₃ solution. The exact procedure followed has previously been described in Example III. Results : The yield of diethyl dodecanedioate was only 63 mg (0.22 mmole, 1% yield); the recovery of monoethyl dodecanedioate was 3.58 g (13.9 mmoles, 69% yield) . The mp of this monoester (after recrystallization from ethanol-H₂O) was 37-38°C. Since the ratio of monoester to diester was 69:1, there is no need for the lengthy workup procedure involving NaHCO₃. After filtering off any recovered starting diacid, the cyclohexane can be removed by evaporation under reduced pressure and the monoester should at that point be >98% pure. In a separate procedure, only 2 g of dodecanedioic acid was used and the rest of the reagents were kept the same. In this latter procedure, the aqueous layer remained homogeneous but the final results (product ratios, etc.) were the same as the first procedure. Hence it is not necessary that the diacid be totally dissolved in the aqueous layer.

Example VII 1,8-octanediol monoacetate

A solution of 1.987 g (13.7 mmoles) of 1,8-octanediol in 25 ml (441 mmoles) of glacial acetic acid was mixed with 200 ml (11.11 moles) of H₂O containing 4 ml (72 mmoles) of cone H₂SO₄. This mixture was extracted continuously for 40 hours using hexane. The monoester is not very soluble in hexane and hence a mixture of hexane-cyclohexane (in which the monoester, but not the starting diol, is soluble) should be recommended if one is interested in developing this process for 1,8-octanediol. After cooling the hexane to room temperature, ether was added to make the organic layer homogeneous . The ether-hexane layer was then dried over anhydrous potassium carbonate and filtered. Removal of the solvent under reduced pressure afforded 2.38 g (~92% yield) of product, GC analysis of which indicated the presence of 2% starting diol and 4% diester. The purity of the desired monoester was therefore 94%.

Example VIII When selected diacids and diols are reacted with aqueous solutions of a monohydric alcohol or a monocarboxylic acid in the presence of a strong acid catalyst, monoesters can be isolated as illustrated in Table I.

Claims

1. A method of preparing a monoester which comprises: preparing a reaction mixture selected from the group consisting of

(a) an alkanoic acid having up to 2 carbons, an acid catalyst, an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alkanoic acid, and a symmetrical diol soluble in the alkanoic acid-water mixture, and

(b) an alcohol having up to 2 carbons, an acid catalyst, an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alcohol, and a symmetrical dicarboxylic acid soluble in the alcohol-water mixture, continuously extracting the reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent which is essentially insoluble in the reaction mixture and in which the reactants have no more than slight solubility, to form a monoester, of the reactants of (a) or (b) , soluble in the nonpolar solvent, separating the nonpolar solvent containing the monoester from the reaction mixture, and isolating the monoester from the nonpolar solvent.

2. A method of preparing a monoester which comprises: preparing a reaction mixture comprising an alkanoic acid having up to 2 carbons, an acid catalyst, an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alkanoic acid, and a symmetrical diol soluble in the alkanoic acid-water mixture, continuously extracting the reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent which is essentially insoluble in the reaction mixture and in which the reactants have no more than slight solubility, to form a monoester of the reactant alkanoic acid and symmetrical diol, soluble in the nonpolar solvent, separating the nonpolar solvent containing the monoester from the reaction mixture, and isolating the monoester from the nonpolar solvent.

3. A method of preparing a monoester which comprises: preparing a reaction mixture comprising a monohydric alcohol having up to 2 carbons, an acid catalyst, an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alcohol, and a symmetrical dicarboxylic acid soluble in the water-alcohol mixture, continuously extracting the reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent which is essentially insoluble in the reaction-mixture and in which the reactants have no more than slight solubility, to form a monoester of the reactant monohydric alcohol and symmetrical dicarboxylic acid, soluble in the nonpolar solvent, separating the nonpolar solvent containing the monoester from the reaction mixture, and isolating the monoester from the nonpolar solvent.

4. A method of preparing a monoester which comprises: preparing a reaction mixture selected from the group consisting of

(a) a symmetrical diol having 2 to 12 carbons, an alkanoic acid having up to 2 carbons and an acid catalyst in an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alkanoic acid, and

(b) an alcohol having up to 2 carbons, a symmetrical dicarboxylic acid selected from the group consisting of 1,4-cyclohexanedicarboxylic acid and diacids of the formula

wherein R represents a chemical bond or a straight chain alkylene having up to 10 carbons, and an acid catalyst in an amount of water at least equal to the molar concentration of the alcohol, continuously extracting the reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent which is essentially insoluble in the reaction mixture and in which the reactants have no more than slight solubility, to form a monoester, of the reactants of (a) or (b) , soluble in the nonpolar solvent, separating the nonpolar solvent containing the monoester from the reaction mixture, and isolating the monoester from the nonpolar solvent.

5. A method for synthesis of monoesters of symmetrical diols, said method comprising:

(a) forming an ester-forming reaction mixture of (i) a symmetrical diol selected from among those of the formulae

HOCH₂(CH₂)_nCH₂OH wherein n has a value of from 0 to 10, inclusive, wherein x has a value of from 0 to 4, y has a value of from 0 to 8, and 2x + y≤8,

wherein m has a value of from 1 to 2;

(ii) a monocarboxylic acid selected from the group consisting of acetic acid and formic acid,

(iii) water in an amount at least equal to the concentration of the monocarboxylic acid, and

(iv) a strong acid catalyst;

(b) continuously extracting said reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent; and

(c) isolating a monoester from said nonpolar solvent.

6. A method for synthesis of monoesters of symmetrical dicarboxylic acids, said method comprising:

(a) forming a reaction mixture of

(i) a symmetrical dicarboxylic acid selected from among the group 1,4-cyclohexanedicarboxylic acid and diacids of the formula wherein R represents a chemical bond or a straight chain alkylene having up to 10 carbons

(ii) a monohydric alcohol selected from the group consisting of ethanol and methanol

(iii) water in an amount at least equal to the concentration of the monohydric alcohol; and

(iv) a strong acid catalyst; (b) continuously extracting said reaction mixture with a nonpolar solvent; and

(c) isolating a monoester from said nonpolar solvent.

7. The improvement of claim wherein said nonpolar solvent is an alkane, a cycloalkane, an aromatic hydrocarbon, or a halide derivative of hydrocarbon.

8. The improvement of claim 4 wherein the alcohol having up to 2 carbons is ethanol.

9. The improvement of claim 4 wherein the alkanoic acid having up to 2 carbons is acetic acid.

10. The improvement of claim 5 wherein the nonpolar solvent is selected from the group consisting of hexane, heptane, cyclohexane, benzene, toluene, xylene and carbon tetrachloride.

11. The improvement of claim 6 wherein the nonpolar solvent is selected from the group consisting of hexane, heptane, cyclohexane, benzene, toluene, xylene and carbon tetrachloride.