CN116486949A - Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam - Google Patents

Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN116486949A
CN116486949A CN202310431335.8A CN202310431335A CN116486949A CN 116486949 A CN116486949 A CN 116486949A CN 202310431335 A CN202310431335 A CN 202310431335A CN 116486949 A CN116486949 A CN 116486949A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
thickness
oxide layer
resistant steel
inner layer
pressure steam
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN202310431335.8A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
王学
杜琮昊
黄斌
张哲轩
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Zhejiang Kaiyuan Metal Technology Co ltd
Wuhan University WHU
Original Assignee
Zhejiang Kaiyuan Metal Technology Co ltd
Wuhan University WHU
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Zhejiang Kaiyuan Metal Technology Co ltd, Wuhan University WHU filed Critical Zhejiang Kaiyuan Metal Technology Co ltd
Priority to CN202310431335.8A priority Critical patent/CN116486949A/en
Publication of CN116486949A publication Critical patent/CN116486949A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G16INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR SPECIFIC APPLICATION FIELDS
    • G16CCOMPUTATIONAL CHEMISTRY; CHEMOINFORMATICS; COMPUTATIONAL MATERIALS SCIENCE
    • G16C60/00Computational materials science, i.e. ICT specially adapted for investigating the physical or chemical properties of materials or phenomena associated with their design, synthesis, processing, characterisation or utilisation
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06FELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING
    • G06F17/00Digital computing or data processing equipment or methods, specially adapted for specific functions
    • G06F17/10Complex mathematical operations
    • GPHYSICS
    • G16INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR SPECIFIC APPLICATION FIELDS
    • G16CCOMPUTATIONAL CHEMISTRY; CHEMOINFORMATICS; COMPUTATIONAL MATERIALS SCIENCE
    • G16C20/00Chemoinformatics, i.e. ICT specially adapted for the handling of physicochemical or structural data of chemical particles, elements, compounds or mixtures
    • G16C20/10Analysis or design of chemical reactions, syntheses or processes
    • GPHYSICS
    • G16INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY [ICT] SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR SPECIFIC APPLICATION FIELDS
    • G16CCOMPUTATIONAL CHEMISTRY; CHEMOINFORMATICS; COMPUTATIONAL MATERIALS SCIENCE
    • G16C20/00Chemoinformatics, i.e. ICT specially adapted for the handling of physicochemical or structural data of chemical particles, elements, compounds or mixtures
    • G16C20/30Prediction of properties of chemical compounds, compositions or mixtures

Abstract

The invention discloses a method for calculating the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer of a martensitic heat-resistant steel component under high-pressure steam. The method is characterized in that a formula is subjected to mathematical correction by means of a metal oxidation kinetic model and combining a large amount of actual operation of a power plant and laboratory simulation experiment data, and a method for calculating the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer of 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam is obtained by using linear fitting, curve fitting and other methods. According to the invention, the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam can be conveniently and rapidly calculated according to the steam pressure and the running time, the result is accurate, the residual life of the high-temperature part can be evaluated without pipe cutting and measuring in the actual power plant running, the safe running of a unit is ensured, the cost is reduced, and the method has important industrial application value.

Description

Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam
Technical Field
The invention belongs to the technical field of martensitic heat-resistant steel, and particularly relates to a method for calculating the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam.
Background
The martensitic heat-resistant steel comprises 9-12% Cr heat-resistant steel such as T/P91, T/P92, E911, T/P93 (9 Cr-3W-3 Co), T/P122, etc. The martensitic heat-resistant steel has excellent high-temperature creep strength, good heat conductivity and low linear expansion coefficient, and is widely applied to manufacturing important high-temperature parts such as main steam pipes, headers, superheaters, reheaters and the like of super (supercritical) units. With the increase of the working steam pressure of the unit, the high-temperature and high-pressure steam oxidation resistance of the martensitic heat-resistant steel becomes one of key factors affecting the service life of high-temperature components. In the long-term operation process of the high-temperature component, the effective wall thickness of the pipe wall is reduced due to the increase of the thickness of the oxide layer, and the stress of the pipe wall is correspondingly increased; meanwhile, the oxidation layer causes the heat conduction performance of the pipe wall to be poor, so that the average running temperature of the pipe wall is improved, the pipe wall is in an overtemperature service state for a long time, and when the pipe wall is developed to a certain degree, the pipe explosion accident finally occurs. Therefore, the service life of the part is estimated, early warning is achieved, and in order to reduce accidents, it is very necessary to predict the thickness of oxide layers of the parts serving under high-temperature and high-pressure steam, such as a superheater, a reheater and the like.
The oxide layer thickness is calculated by means of an oxidation kinetics model of heat-resistant steel under high-temperature high-pressure steam. The current steam oxidation kinetic model of the martensitic heat-resistant steel is mostly obtained based on experimental results of an oxidation weight increasing method, and the thickness of an oxide layer cannot be directly calculated. While there are few documents reporting a model of the high pressure steam oxidation kinetics of martensitic heat-resistant steel based on the increase in thickness of the oxide layer, the oxide layer comprises an inner layer and an outer layer, and these documents do not distinguish between the thickness of the outer layer and the thickness of the inner layer. The applicant found that only an increase in the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer resulted in a reduction in the wall thickness of the tube, affecting the life of the tube, and therefore the prediction of the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer was of more practical value.
Another major disadvantage with respect to oxidation kinetics of heat resistant steels is that current research is limited to the effect of time variation on oxide layer thickness at a fixed vapor pressure, without taking into account the effect of vapor pressure variation. In practice, the steam pressure in the superheater and reheater sections of the unit varies greatly, and there is a large difference in oxidation rate. Therefore, if the influence of the steam pressure variation is not considered, the accuracy of the prediction result will be seriously affected.
Disclosure of Invention
The invention aims to solve the problems in the prior art, and provides a method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel pipe, which can conveniently and rapidly calculate the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to the operation time and the pressure, has accurate results, can realize the evaluation of the residual life of a high-temperature part without pipe cutting and measurement in the actual power plant operation, ensures the safe operation of a unit, reduces the cost and has important industrial application value.
In order to achieve the above purpose, the technical scheme provided by the invention is as follows:
the method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam is provided, wherein the martensitic heat-resistant steel is 9% Cr heat-resistant steel, and the calculation formula of the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer under high-pressure steam is as follows:
Y=a+bt+cp+dt 2 +hpt+ip 2
wherein Y is the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer, and the unit is mu m; p is steam pressure in MPa; t is time, and the unit is h; a, b, c, d, h, i are fitting coefficients.
According to the scheme, the steam pressure range under the high-pressure steam is 5.0-25.0 MPa.
According to the scheme, the operation time under the high-pressure steam ranges from 1,000 to 150,000 hours.
According to the scheme, the temperature range of the high-pressure steam under the high-pressure steam is 550-650 ℃.
According to the scheme, the value of the fitting coefficient a is 22.21.
According to the scheme, the value of the fitting coefficient b is 0.0009334.
According to the scheme, the value of the fitting coefficient c is-0.8198.
According to the scheme, the value of the fitting coefficient d is-7.655×10 -10
According to the scheme, the fitting coefficient h has a value of 1.79×10 -5
The fitting coefficient i has a value of 0.1152 according to the scheme described above.
The application of the calculation method in the aspect of evaluating the service life of the martensitic heat-resistant steel pipe operated under high-pressure steam in a power plant is provided.
The thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel of the high-temperature component can be calculated through the formula, so that the oxidation corrosion thinning degree of the inner wall of the high-temperature component can be reflected, the residual service life of the component can be evaluated, and the safe operation of a unit can be ensured.
The invention has the beneficial effects that:
1. the thickness of the inner layer of the oxidation layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under the condition of supercritical (ultra) high-pressure steam is researched firstly, the thickness of the oxidation layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel with 9 percent Cr under the condition of high-temperature high-pressure steam can be conveniently and rapidly calculated according to the operation time and the steam pressure, the practical value is higher, the result is more accurate, the pipe cutting measurement is not needed in the actual power plant operation, the cost is saved, and the thickness of the inner layer of the oxidation layer of the pipe is calculated under the condition of not influencing the operation; the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer can reflect the oxidation corrosion thinning degree of the inner wall of the martensitic heat-resistant steel pipe so as to evaluate the residual life of the component, ensure the safe operation of the unit and have important industrial application value.
2. The calculation method provided by the invention takes account of two factors of steam pressure and operation time, which have great influence on the thickness of the oxide layer, and the error can be controlled within 8%, so that the calculation result has high accuracy and important reference value.
Drawings
FIG. 1 is a graph of the thickness Y of the inner layer of the oxide layer versus the selected pressure p and time t in an embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a three-time fitting prediction graph of the actual data of the thickness Y of the inner layer of the oxide layer and the selected pressure p and time t in the embodiment of the invention.
Detailed Description
The technical scheme of the invention is further explained by the specific examples.
Relationship between oxide layer inner layer thickness Y and vapor pressure p
In order to explore the influence of pressure p and time t on the formation of a high-temperature heating surface oxide layer of a power station boiler, experimental data of the inner layer thickness of the 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel oxide layer under different times t and different pressures p are screened, and the results are shown in the following table:
TABLE 1 inner layer thickness of 9% Cr martensitic heat resistant steel oxide layer at different times and different steam pressures
Time t/h Steam pressure p/Mpa Thickness of inner layer of oxide layer Y/. Mu.m
1169.916 5.0 35.422
1466.175 15.0 48.916
1767.934 20.0 69.157
1228.343 25.0 107.108
10018.521 5.0 42.169
10031.581 15.0 58.193
10048.766 20.0 79.277
10084.509 25.0 123.133
50267.199 5.0 75.060
50004.621 15.0 102.892
50034.178 20.0 139.157
50081.607 25.0 197.349
100222.328 5.0 117.229
100264.946 15.0 169.518
100308.250 20.0 222.651
100064.232 25.0 273.253
150177.458 5.0 159.398
150242.071 15.0 238.675
150270.941 20.0 274.096
122611.575 25.0 287.590
The data are plotted to obtain a plot of the thickness Y of the oxide layer inner layer shown in fig. 1 versus the selected pressure p and time t.
It can be found that a binary quadratic function relationship exists between the thickness Y, the pressure p and the time t, and the following formula is obtained through three-dimensional nonlinear surface fitting:
Y=a+bt+cp+dt 2 +hpt+ip 2 (1)
step 1: solving coefficients i, h and c containing p terms
When a specific time t is selected, the term containing t is a constant value, the equation (1) is converted into a parabolic equation about p, and the coefficients i, h and c containing p terms can be obtained by fitting after substituting data.
i=0.1152±0.03315
h=1.79×10 -5 ±4.74×10 -6
c=-0.8198±1.0842
Step 2: solving for coefficients d, b containing t terms
Similarly, when a specific pressure p is selected, the term containing p is a constant value, the equation (1) is converted into a parabolic equation about t, and the coefficient d and b containing the term t can be obtained by fitting after substituting the data.
d=-7.655×10 -10 ±7.7735×10 -10
b=0.0009334±0.0001543
Step 3: after 5 coefficients are determined, the coefficient a is finally determined. Substituting the obtained coefficient into formula (1), and substituting all data into the obtained product to perform three-dimensional nonlinear surface fitting to obtain a coefficient a=22.21±9.65. Therefore, formula (1) is rewritten as:
Y=22.21 + 0.0009334t + (-0.8198p)+(-7.655×10 -10 t 2 )+1.79×10 -5 tp+ 0.1152p 2 (2)
step 4: the fitting was repeated for fig. 1, and the error rate of each coefficient in equation (2) was verified. And (3) constructing a curved surface graph by using the expression of the formula (2), substituting all data into the graph, and if the data points basically fall on the curved surface, basically conforming the predicted result of the formula (2) to the actual result. As each coefficient value has a certain fluctuation range, 3 times of fitting are performed, so that the accuracy is improved, and the error is reduced. Finally, a three-time repeated fitting prediction graph of the actual data shown in fig. 2 is obtained. It can be found that the data points under different working conditions basically fall on 3 predicted curved surfaces (boundaries), the average error rate is 5%, and the relation between the thickness Y and the pressure p and the time t under the actual working conditions basically accords with the function change rule described by the formula (2), and then each coefficient is determined as follows:
a=22.21
b=0.0009334
c=-0.8198
d=-7.655×10 -10
h=1.79×10 -5
i=0.1152
finally, the fitting formula of the thickness Y of the inner layer of the oxide layer and the steam pressure p is obtained as follows:
Y=22.21 + 0.0009334t + (-0.8198p)+(-7.655×10 -10 t 2 )+1.79×10 -5 tp+ 0.1152p 2 (3)
in the above formula, the unit of time t is h, the unit of vapor pressure p is MPa, and the unit of thickness Y of the oxide layer inner layer is μm.
Example 1
The calculation method related by the invention is compared with the T91 oxidation experimental result.
After the T91 steel is oxidized for about 1,457 hours under the steam pressure of 25MPa and measured by Nishimura et al, the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer is about 71 mu m, experimental conditions are substituted into a formula (3) provided by the embodiment of the invention, the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer is about 75.7171 mu m, and the error percentage is 6.6%.
Example 2
The calculation method related by the invention is compared with the T92 oxidation experimental result.
The Muraki et al measured that the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer was about 119 μm after oxidizing the T92 steel for about 31,010h at a steam pressure of 25MPa, and calculated by substituting experimental conditions into the formula (3) provided in the embodiment of the present invention, the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer was about 115.8006 μm, and the error percentage was 2.6%.
Example 3
The calculation method is applied to an actual power plant environment.
The steam pressure of an ultra-supercritical unit used in a certain power plant is 19.2MPa, a pipeline is made of T91 material, the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer in the pipeline is measured to be 65 mu m after the pipeline runs for about 8 and 911h, and the running parameters are substituted into a formula (3) provided by the embodiment of the invention to calculate the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer to be 60.2564 mu m, and the error percentage is 7.2%.
Example 4
The calculation method is applied to an actual power plant environment.
A certain power station boiler superheater pipeline is made of a T91 material, the steam pressure is 10MPa, the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer in a pipe is measured to be about 32 mu m after the operation is carried out for about 4,000 hours, the operation parameters are substituted into a formula (3) provided by the embodiment of the invention, the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer is calculated to be about 29.9694 mu m, and the error percentage is 6.3%.
The above examples all show that the thickness of the inner layer of the 9% Cr martensitic steel oxide layer calculated by the method of the invention is in good agreement with the actual measurement result, and the error is within 8%.
The technical scheme of the invention is not limited to the embodiments, and all technical schemes obtained by adopting equivalent substitution modes fall within the scope of the invention.

Claims (10)

1. A method for calculating the thickness of an inner layer of an oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam is characterized by comprising the following steps: the martensitic heat-resistant steel is 9% Cr heat-resistant steel, and the calculation formula of the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer under high-pressure steam is as follows:
Y=a+bt+cp+dt 2 +hpt+ip 2
wherein Y is the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer, and the unit is mu m; p is steam pressure in MPa; t is time, and the unit is h; a, b, c, d, h, i are fitting coefficients.
2. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the steam pressure ranges from 5.0MPa to 25.0MPa, and the time ranges from 1,000 h to 150,000h.
3. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the temperature range of the high-pressure steam is 550-650 ℃.
4. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the value of the fitting coefficient a is 22.21.
5. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the value of the fitting coefficient b is 0.0009334.
6. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the value of the fitting coefficient c is-0.8198.
7. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the value of the fitting coefficient d is-7.655 multiplied by 10 -10
8. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the value of the fitting coefficient h is 1.79×10 -5
9. The method for calculating the thickness of the inner layer of the oxide layer of the martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam according to claim 1, characterized in that: the fitting coefficient i value is 0.1152.
10. Use of the calculation method of claim 1 for assessing the life of martensitic heat-resistant steel components operating under high pressure steam in a power plant.
CN202310431335.8A 2023-04-20 2023-04-20 Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam Pending CN116486949A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202310431335.8A CN116486949A (en) 2023-04-20 2023-04-20 Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202310431335.8A CN116486949A (en) 2023-04-20 2023-04-20 Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN116486949A true CN116486949A (en) 2023-07-25

Family

ID=87213264

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN202310431335.8A Pending CN116486949A (en) 2023-04-20 2023-04-20 Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN116486949A (en)

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN109992825B (en) Boiler four-tube real-time service life assessment method considering wall thickness reduction and overheating influence
CN105760936A (en) Boiler 'four tubes' failure evaluation method based on field state inspection parameters
JP7161656B2 (en) Calculation Method of Oxide Film Thickness of Martensitic Heat-Resistant Steel in Supercritical High-Temperature Steam
CN104268383A (en) Safety evaluation method for high-temperature pressure pipeline containing crack defects
CN116504342A (en) Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxidation layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel in steam environment
Ma et al. Effects of crack position on fatigue life of large seamless storage vessels made of 4130X for hydrogen refueling station
CN116486949A (en) Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-pressure steam
Guo et al. Life prediction for stress corrosion behavior of 316L stainless steel elbow of nuclear power plant
Kim et al. Evaluation of Creep Properties of Alloy 690 Steam Generator Tubes at High Temperature Using Tube Specimen
JP2022027670A (en) Estimation method for high-chromium steel creep residual life
Kumar et al. Effect of steamside oxidation and fireside corrosion degradation processes on creep life of service exposed boiler tubes
CN116486951A (en) Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of oxide layer of martensitic heat-resistant steel under high-temperature steam
CN116486950A (en) Calculation method for inner layer thickness of pearlite heat-resistant steel oxide layer in steam environment
CN116486952A (en) Method for calculating thickness of inner layer of bainite heat-resistant steel oxide layer in steam environment
Salifu et al. Numerical simulation of stress relaxation and creep response of X20 steam piping under diverse operating conditions
JP4831624B2 (en) Graphitization damage diagnosis method for carbon steel and Mo steel for boilers
Salifu et al. Determination of the dominant failure mechanism of P92 steam piping subjected to daily operational cycle using finite element (FE) technique
Wang et al. Theoretical Evaluation Methods for Remaining Strength of Seawater Pipelines with Corrosion Defects
Salim et al. Study of the reliability of corroded pipeline by the ASME B31G method
CN113591348B (en) Method for calculating three-dimensional stress of weld joint of steam-water pipeline in service of thermal power plant
Dewees Grade 11 High Temperature Steam Header Case History and Benchmark
Kalu et al. Effect of defect geometry of localized external erosion on failure of boiler tubes
Bi et al. Reliability Analysis of Oil and Gas Pipelines Based on Step-Down-Stress Testing in Corrosive Environments
Buchheim et al. Failure investigation of a low chrome long-seam weld in a high-temperature refinery piping system
Sun et al. Analysis of Elbow Stress Intensification Factors for Piping System

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination