CN115327890B - Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm - Google Patents
Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm Download PDFInfo
- Publication number
- CN115327890B CN115327890B CN202211119376.5A CN202211119376A CN115327890B CN 115327890 B CN115327890 B CN 115327890B CN 202211119376 A CN202211119376 A CN 202211119376A CN 115327890 B CN115327890 B CN 115327890B
- Authority
- CN
- China
- Prior art keywords
- individual
- algorithm
- search
- steam pressure
- main steam
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Active
Links
- 238000000034 method Methods 0.000 title claims abstract description 43
- 230000008569 process Effects 0.000 claims abstract description 20
- 238000009826 distribution Methods 0.000 claims abstract description 19
- 230000007246 mechanism Effects 0.000 claims abstract description 5
- 230000006870 function Effects 0.000 claims description 69
- 230000033228 biological regulation Effects 0.000 claims description 20
- 238000010845 search algorithm Methods 0.000 claims description 19
- 238000012546 transfer Methods 0.000 claims description 18
- 238000005457 optimization Methods 0.000 claims description 17
- 239000000446 fuel Substances 0.000 claims description 14
- 230000003044 adaptive effect Effects 0.000 claims description 12
- 230000004044 response Effects 0.000 claims description 12
- 230000035772 mutation Effects 0.000 claims description 11
- 238000012360 testing method Methods 0.000 claims description 10
- 239000013598 vector Substances 0.000 claims description 9
- 230000009471 action Effects 0.000 claims description 5
- 230000008859 change Effects 0.000 claims description 4
- 230000006872 improvement Effects 0.000 claims description 4
- 238000010276 construction Methods 0.000 claims description 3
- 238000005070 sampling Methods 0.000 claims description 3
- 238000004088 simulation Methods 0.000 claims description 3
- 230000000694 effects Effects 0.000 claims description 2
- 230000006399 behavior Effects 0.000 claims 11
- 241000764238 Isis Species 0.000 claims 1
- 241001081179 Litsea Species 0.000 claims 1
- 235000012854 Litsea cubeba Nutrition 0.000 claims 1
- 230000003247 decreasing effect Effects 0.000 claims 1
- 239000011664 nicotinic acid Substances 0.000 claims 1
- 230000003449 preventive effect Effects 0.000 claims 1
- 238000012938 design process Methods 0.000 abstract description 2
- 238000004519 manufacturing process Methods 0.000 abstract description 2
- 238000010586 diagram Methods 0.000 description 4
- 230000003068 static effect Effects 0.000 description 4
- 238000013461 design Methods 0.000 description 3
- 230000014509 gene expression Effects 0.000 description 3
- 238000012935 Averaging Methods 0.000 description 2
- 230000007423 decrease Effects 0.000 description 2
- 238000011161 development Methods 0.000 description 2
- 238000010298 pulverizing process Methods 0.000 description 2
- 101000827703 Homo sapiens Polyphosphoinositide phosphatase Proteins 0.000 description 1
- 102100023591 Polyphosphoinositide phosphatase Human genes 0.000 description 1
- 101100012902 Saccharomyces cerevisiae (strain ATCC 204508 / S288c) FIG2 gene Proteins 0.000 description 1
- 238000007664 blowing Methods 0.000 description 1
- 239000003245 coal Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000002485 combustion reaction Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000008030 elimination Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000003379 elimination reaction Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000012432 intermediate storage Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000012804 iterative process Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000005065 mining Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000012986 modification Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000004048 modification Effects 0.000 description 1
- 239000002245 particle Substances 0.000 description 1
- 238000012545 processing Methods 0.000 description 1
- 230000001105 regulatory effect Effects 0.000 description 1
- 238000006467 substitution reaction Methods 0.000 description 1
- 238000010998 test method Methods 0.000 description 1
Classifications
-
- G—PHYSICS
- G05—CONTROLLING; REGULATING
- G05B—CONTROL OR REGULATING SYSTEMS IN GENERAL; FUNCTIONAL ELEMENTS OF SUCH SYSTEMS; MONITORING OR TESTING ARRANGEMENTS FOR SUCH SYSTEMS OR ELEMENTS
- G05B11/00—Automatic controllers
- G05B11/01—Automatic controllers electric
- G05B11/36—Automatic controllers electric with provision for obtaining particular characteristics, e.g. proportional, integral, differential
- G05B11/42—Automatic controllers electric with provision for obtaining particular characteristics, e.g. proportional, integral, differential for obtaining a characteristic which is both proportional and time-dependent, e.g. P. I., P. I. D.
-
- Y—GENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
- Y02—TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
- Y02P—CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION TECHNOLOGIES IN THE PRODUCTION OR PROCESSING OF GOODS
- Y02P90/00—Enabling technologies with a potential contribution to greenhouse gas [GHG] emissions mitigation
- Y02P90/02—Total factory control, e.g. smart factories, flexible manufacturing systems [FMS] or integrated manufacturing systems [IMS]
Landscapes
- Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
- General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
- Feedback Control In General (AREA)
Abstract
Description
技术领域Technical Field
本发明属于火电机组热工控制技术领域,具体涉及一种改进型人群搜索算法优化PID控制火电深度调峰机组的主汽压力的方法。The invention belongs to the technical field of thermal control of thermal power units, and specifically relates to a method for optimizing PID control of main steam pressure of a thermal power deep peak regulation unit using an improved crowd search algorithm.
背景技术Background technique
为提高新能源消纳率和系统调节灵活性,火电机组将更多地承担电网调峰调频任务。火电机组主汽压力本身具有的大滞后、大惯性和非线性等控制特性在深度调峰工况下表现得尤为明显,由此带来的主汽压力控制响应慢、动态偏差大等问题严重制约了火电机组调峰爬坡速率,也不利于机组安全稳定运行。In order to improve the consumption rate of new energy and the flexibility of system regulation, thermal power units will take on more tasks of peak load and frequency regulation of the power grid. The large hysteresis, large inertia and nonlinear control characteristics of the main steam pressure of thermal power units are particularly obvious under deep peak load conditions. The resulting problems such as slow response of main steam pressure control and large dynamic deviation seriously restrict the peak load ramp rate of thermal power units and are not conducive to the safe and stable operation of the units.
目前,火电机组普遍采用以锅炉跟随为基础的协调控制系统,即锅炉调节主汽压力,汽轮调节负荷。锅炉主控采用PID调节器,并设计主汽压力偏差的微分前馈、机组负荷指令前馈等。对亚临界火电机组而言,锅炉主控PID生成燃料主控调节指令并送往燃料主控,燃料主控PID负责生成燃料指令并作为给煤机(直吹式制粉系统)或给粉机(中储式制粉系统)。燃料主控PID多为一快速随动调节器,参数整定简便,调节品质一般均能满足燃料量调节精度要求;而锅炉主控PID的被调量为锅炉主汽压力,其调节参数的设置对主汽压力的调节品质起到决定性作用。现场试验发现,深度调峰工况下,由于锅炉燃烧特性和汽轮机流量特性的改变,采用常规负荷段的主汽压力控制PID调节器参数设置适用性较差,无法满足调节品质要求,需采用先进优化算法对主汽压力控制系统进行优化。At present, thermal power units generally adopt a coordinated control system based on boiler following, that is, the boiler adjusts the main steam pressure and the turbine adjusts the load. The boiler master control adopts a PID regulator, and designs the differential feedforward of the main steam pressure deviation and the unit load command feedforward. For subcritical thermal power units, the boiler master control PID generates the fuel master control adjustment command and sends it to the fuel master control. The fuel master control PID is responsible for generating fuel instructions and serves as a coal feeder (direct-blowing pulverizing system) or a pulverizer (intermediate storage pulverizing system). The fuel master control PID is mostly a fast follow-up regulator, with simple parameter setting, and the regulation quality can generally meet the requirements of fuel quantity regulation accuracy; while the regulated quantity of the boiler master control PID is the boiler main steam pressure, and the setting of its regulation parameters plays a decisive role in the regulation quality of the main steam pressure. Field tests have found that under deep peak-shaving conditions, due to changes in boiler combustion characteristics and turbine flow characteristics, the parameter setting of the main steam pressure control PID regulator in the conventional load section has poor applicability and cannot meet the regulation quality requirements. It is necessary to use advanced optimization algorithms to optimize the main steam pressure control system.
发明内容Summary of the invention
本发明要解决的技术问题是提供一种改进型人群优化算法优化PID控制火电机组深度调峰工况下主汽压力的方法,基于改进型人群搜索算法(Seeker OptimizationAlgorithm,SOA)优化PID控制参数的方法来控制火电机组主汽压力,使得主汽压力跟踪设定值的性能好,且具有很好的鲁棒性。The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a method for optimizing PID control of main steam pressure under deep peak regulation conditions of thermal power units using an improved crowd optimization algorithm, and to control the main steam pressure of thermal power units using a method for optimizing PID control parameters based on an improved crowd search algorithm (Seeker Optimization Algorithm, SOA), so that the main steam pressure has good performance in tracking the set value and has good robustness.
本发明提供的技术方案:一种改进型人群搜索算法优化PID控制火电深度调峰机组的主汽压力的方法,包括如下步骤:The technical solution provided by the present invention is a method for optimizing PID control of main steam pressure of a thermal power deep peak regulation unit by using an improved crowd search algorithm, comprising the following steps:
(1)建立基于现场试验数据的主汽压力辨识传递函数模型;(1) Establish a main steam pressure identification transfer function model based on field test data;
(2)基于人群搜索算法的PID参数优化;(2) PID parameter optimization based on crowd search algorithm;
(3)采用反向差分进化机制和自适应t分布策略对原始人群搜索算法进行联合改进,对主汽压控制PID进行参数优化,将优化得到的控制参数在现场DCS组态中置入,通过定值扰动试验检验控制效果。(3) The reverse differential evolution mechanism and the adaptive t-distribution strategy are used to jointly improve the original population search algorithm, optimize the parameters of the main steam pressure control PID, insert the optimized control parameters into the on-site DCS configuration, and verify the control effect through a constant value disturbance test.
进一步的,步骤(1)中基于现场数据的主汽压力辨识建模。对某深度调峰火电机组稳态运行工况进行试验建模,阶跃改变入炉燃料量,获取主汽压力响应曲线,通过最小二乘方法辨识得到主汽压力传递函数模型。主汽压力为一典型有自平衡能力热工过程,模型结构可选择为式(1),得到如式(2)的传递函数模型。Furthermore, in step (1), the main steam pressure identification modeling based on the field data is carried out. The steady-state operation condition of a deep peak-shaving thermal power unit is experimentally modeled, the amount of fuel entering the furnace is changed stepwise, the main steam pressure response curve is obtained, and the main steam pressure transfer function model is obtained by least square method identification. The main steam pressure is a typical thermal process with self-balancing ability. The model structure can be selected as formula (1), and the transfer function model as formula (2) is obtained.
公式中:k-主汽压力传递函数静态增益;n-传递函数阶次;τ-延迟时间;s-拉普拉斯算子。In the formula: k is the static gain of the main steam pressure transfer function; n is the order of the transfer function; τ is the delay time; s is the Laplace operator.
进一步的,步骤(2)中基于人群搜索算法优化主汽压力PID控制参数。Furthermore, in step (2), the main steam pressure PID control parameters are optimized based on a crowd search algorithm.
由式(2)可知,火电机组在深度调峰工况下的主汽压力模型为二阶惯性加纯迟延对象,现场整定PID多采用依据经验的试凑法,调试过程耗时长,调节过程动态指标不易达到精度要求。It can be seen from formula (2) that the main steam pressure model of the thermal power unit under deep peak regulation conditions is a second-order inertia plus pure delay object. The on-site PID adjustment mostly adopts the trial and error method based on experience. The debugging process is time-consuming and the dynamic indicators of the adjustment process are not easy to meet the accuracy requirements.
目前国内外主流DCS控制系统内置PID模块均采用并联式PID,根据输入值rin(t)和输出值yout(t)的偏差e(t)构成如式(3)的控制规律。式(5)为PID的传递函数形式,其中Kp为比例系数,Ti为积分时间常数,Td为微分时间常数,三者为待优化整定参数。At present, the built-in PID modules of mainstream DCS control systems at home and abroad all adopt parallel PID, which forms the control law as shown in formula (3) according to the deviation e(t) between the input value rin(t) and the output value yout(t). Formula (5) is the transfer function form of PID, where Kp is the proportional coefficient, Ti is the integral time constant, and Td is the differential time constant. The three are the parameters to be optimized.
e(t)=rin(t)-yout(t) (3)e(t)=rin(t)-yout(t) (3)
公式中e(t)-系统输出与期望输出的偏差;u(t)-PID的控制输出信号。In the formula, e(t) is the deviation between the system output and the expected output; u(t) is the control output signal of PID.
选择合适的采样周期,将PID控制器和被控对象进行离散化处理,在使用matlab进行算法编程仿真时,可采用其内置函数c2d进行离散化。Select a suitable sampling period and discretize the PID controller and the controlled object. When using MATLAB for algorithm programming simulation, you can use its built-in function c2d for discretization.
参数编码:将PID的三个参数作为一个搜索个体,则每个个体的位置矢量的维数为D=3,定义种群P中有S个个体,所以种群P可用式(6)表示:Parameter encoding: The three parameters of PID are taken as a search individual, and the dimension of the position vector of each individual is D=3. It is defined that there are S individuals in the population P, so the population P can be expressed by formula (6):
适应度函数的选取:适应度函数是搜索优化过程中评价个体优劣的唯一指标,也是SOA算法与控制系统结合的纽带,指导着算法朝控制目标不断进化。选取原则如下:为了获取优良的调节动态特性,采用误差绝对值的时间积分性能指标作为最小目标函数;为了防止控制器输出量能过大损坏现场设备,引入控制输入平方项;为了避免超调现象,采用适度的惩罚控制,将超调量作为指标的一项。如此,目标函数如式(7)所示。其中,各项权值的取值一般为:ω1=0.999,ω2=0.001,ω3=100。Selection of fitness function: The fitness function is the only indicator for evaluating the quality of individuals in the search optimization process. It is also the link between the SOA algorithm and the control system, guiding the algorithm to evolve towards the control target. The selection principles are as follows: In order to obtain excellent dynamic characteristics of regulation, the time integral performance index of the absolute value of the error is used as the minimum objective function; in order to prevent the controller output from being too large and damaging the field equipment, the control input square term is introduced; in order to avoid overshoot, moderate penalty control is used, and the overshoot is used as an indicator. In this way, the objective function is shown in formula (7). Among them, the values of each weight are generally: ω 1 = 0.999, ω 2 = 0.001, ω 3 = 100.
搜索步长的确定:SOA的不确定推理行为是利用模糊系统的逼近能力,模拟人的智能搜索行为,用以建立目标函数值和步长之间的联系。采用高斯隶属函数表示搜索步长模糊变量。Determination of search step length: The uncertain reasoning behavior of SOA uses the approximation ability of fuzzy systems to simulate the intelligent search behavior of people to establish the connection between the objective function value and the step length. The Gaussian membership function is used to represent the search step length fuzzy variable.
上式(8)中,uA为高斯隶属度;x为输入变量;u、δ为隶属函数参数。当输出变量超出[u-3δ,u+3δ]时,若隶属度小于0.0111,则可忽略,故设定umin=0.0111,同时为了获得较快的收敛速度,设定umax=0.95。In the above formula (8), u A is the Gaussian membership; x is the input variable; u and δ are the membership function parameters. When the output variable exceeds [u-3δ, u+3δ], if the membership is less than 0.0111, it can be ignored, so u min = 0.0111 is set, and in order to obtain a faster convergence speed, u max = 0.95 is set.
采用线性隶属度函数,在最佳位置有最大隶属度umax=1,最差位置有最小隶属度umin=0.0111,在其他位置u<1.0,如式(9)所示。Using a linear membership function, the best position has a maximum membership u max = 1, the worst position has a minimum membership u min = 0.0111, and u < 1.0 at other positions, as shown in formula (9).
上式(9)中,uij为j维搜索空间目标函数值i的隶属度;αij为j维搜索空间的搜索步长;δij为高斯隶属函数参数,其值由式(10)和(11)确定:In the above formula (9), u ij is the membership degree of the objective function value i in the j-dimensional search space; α ij is the search step size in the j-dimensional search space; δ ij is the Gaussian membership function parameter, and its value is determined by formulas (10) and (11):
ω=(itermax-iter)/itermax (11)ω=(iter max -iter)/iter max (11)
上式中,xmin和xmax分别是同一种群中的最小和最大函数值的位置;ω是惯性权值,随进化代数的增加从0.9线性递减至0.1;iter和itermax分别是当前迭代次数和最大迭代次数。In the above formula, x min and x max are the positions of the minimum and maximum function values in the same population, respectively; ω is the inertia weight, which decreases linearly from 0.9 to 0.1 with the increase of evolutionary generations; iter and iter max are the current and maximum iteration numbers, respectively.
搜索方向的确定:通过对人的利己行为、利他行为和预动行为的分析和建模,得到三种行动方向的表达式如式(12)-(14):Determination of search direction: Through the analysis and modeling of people's selfish behavior, altruistic behavior and pre-action behavior, the expressions of three action directions are obtained as shown in equations (12)-(14):
综合以上因素,采用三个方向随机加权几何平均确定搜索方向,如式(15):Taking the above factors into consideration, the search direction is determined by randomly weighted geometric averaging of three directions, as shown in formula (15):
其中,和分别为中的最佳位置;为第i个搜寻个体所在邻域的集体历史最佳位置,为第i个搜寻个体到目前为止经历过的最佳位置;sign(*)为符号函数;和为[0,1]内的常数;ω是惯性权值。in, and They are The best position in is the collective best historical position of the neighborhood of the i-th search individual, is the best position experienced by the i-th search individual so far; sign(*) is the sign function; and is a constant in [0,1]; ω is the inertia weight.
个体位置的更新:根据上述分析,可根据搜索方向和步长进行个体位置更新,如下式所示。Update of individual position: Based on the above analysis, the individual position can be updated according to the search direction and step size, as shown in the following formula.
Δxij(t+1)=αij(t)dij(t) (16)Δx ij (t+1) = α ij (t) d ij (t) (16)
xij(t+1)=xij(t)+Δxij(t+1) (17)x ij (t+1) = x ij (t) + Δ x ij (t+1) (17)
其中,Δxij(t+1)为第i个搜寻个体在j维搜索空间下一时刻的位置变化量,xij(t)为t时刻第i个搜寻个体在j维搜索空间的位置。Among them, Δx ij (t+1) is the position change of the i-th search individual in the j-dimensional search space at the next moment, and x ij (t) is the position of the i-th search individual in the j-dimensional search space at moment t.
进一步的,步骤(3)中人群搜索算法的改进:标准人群搜索算法依赖于经验梯度方向和不确定推理行为之间的相互配合,在整个迭代过程中广泛地进行全局搜索,进而为挖掘全局最优解积累丰富的先验知识。然而,以模糊步长为导向的位置更新方式容易诱发算法陷入局部最优,从而导致搜索偏离最优解;人群缺乏信息交流易降低人群多样性,将进一步限制算法的开发范围。针对上述问题,采用反向差分进化机制和自适应t分布策略对原始人群搜索算法进行联合改进,进一步增强其脱离局部最优的能力。Furthermore, the improvement of the crowd search algorithm in step (3): The standard crowd search algorithm relies on the mutual coordination between the empirical gradient direction and the uncertain reasoning behavior, and conducts extensive global search in the entire iterative process, thereby accumulating rich prior knowledge for mining the global optimal solution. However, the position update method guided by the fuzzy step size can easily induce the algorithm to fall into the local optimum, thereby causing the search to deviate from the optimal solution; the lack of information exchange among the crowd can easily reduce the diversity of the crowd, which will further limit the scope of algorithm development. In response to the above problems, the reverse differential evolution mechanism and the adaptive t distribution strategy are used to jointly improve the original crowd search algorithm to further enhance its ability to escape from the local optimum.
对于任意个体xij,其反向解定义为For any individual x ij , the inverse solution is defined as
xi'j=ubj+lbj-xij (18)x i ' j = ub j + lb j - x ij (18)
上式中,ubj和lbj分别为第j维搜索空间的上限和下限。为进一步增强人群多样性,提出采用差分进化(Differential Evolution Algorithm,DE)对人群位置进行更新,通过变异、交叉和选择策略来寻找优质个体,加强个体之间的信息交。In the above formula, ub j and lb j are the upper and lower limits of the j-th dimension search space, respectively. In order to further enhance the diversity of the population, it is proposed to use differential evolution algorithm (DE) to update the position of the population, find high-quality individuals through mutation, crossover and selection strategies, and strengthen the information exchange between individuals.
对于人群中每个个体向量xi,随机选择三个不同的个体向量进行结合,产生变异个体:For each individual vector xi in the population, three different individual vectors are randomly selected and combined to generate mutant individuals:
vi(t+1)=xr1(t)+F(xr2(t)-xr3(t)) (19)上式中,r1,r2,r3为[1,0.5N]内三个不同差分个体的编号,其中,缩放因子F为[0,1]范围内的随机数。 vi (t+1)= xr1 (t)+F( xr2 (t) -xr3 (t)) (19) In the above formula, r1 , r2 , r3 are the numbers of three different differential individuals in [1,0.5N], and the scaling factor F is a random number in the range of [0,1].
采用交叉操作构造试验个体uij(t+1),构造方法为:The crossover operation is used to construct the test individual u ij (t+1), and the construction method is:
其中,rand产生[0,1]之间的随机数,交叉概率因子CR的范围在[0,1]之间。f(*)为适应度函数,计算经交叉操作产生后新个体的适应度值,如果新个体的具有更优的适应度,则对原始个体进行替换:Among them, rand generates random numbers between [0,1], and the range of the crossover probability factor CR is between [0,1]. f(*) is the fitness function, which calculates the fitness value of the new individual after the crossover operation. If the new individual has a better fitness, the original individual is replaced:
采用以迭代次数i为系统参量的变异因子对全局最优位置进行自适应更新,基于贪婪选择算法推选出质量更高的位置并参与下轮迭代。自适应t分布是融合高斯分布与柯西分布优点随机参数组,当其作为变异因子对可行解进行扰动时,可使算法具有一定的局部随机搜索能力以避免陷入局部最优。最优个体的自适应变异过程如下公式所示:The global optimal position is adaptively updated using a mutation factor with the number of iterations i as the system parameter. A higher quality position is selected based on the greedy selection algorithm and participates in the next iteration. The adaptive t distribution is a random parameter group that combines the advantages of Gaussian distribution and Cauchy distribution. When it is used as a mutation factor to perturb the feasible solution, it can enable the algorithm to have a certain local random search ability to avoid falling into the local optimum. The adaptive mutation process of the optimal individual is shown in the following formula:
xbest(t+1)=xbest(t)+xbest(t)*trnd(t) (22)x best (t+1)=x best (t)+x best (t)*trnd(t) (22)
上式中,trnd为自适应t分布参量函数,可由matlab函数库调用;xbest(t)为当前最优解,xbest(t+1)为自适应t分布变异后的新解。In the above formula, trnd is the parameter function of the adaptive t distribution, which can be called by the MATLAB function library; xbest (t) is the current optimal solution, and xbest (t+1) is the new solution after the adaptive t distribution is mutated.
综上所述,人群搜索算法SOA按照以上分析流程对主汽压控制PID进行参数优化。为验证所得调节系统的稳态、动态性能,采用设定值阶跃信号对设计好的闭环控制系统进行激励。In summary, the crowd search algorithm SOA optimizes the parameters of the main steam pressure control PID according to the above analysis process. In order to verify the steady-state and dynamic performance of the obtained regulation system, the set value step signal is used to excite the designed closed-loop control system.
本发明的优点:相较于其他智能寻优算法,本发明所采用的改进型SOA算法在整定PID参数过程中涉及的适应度函数、寻优步长及方向、个体位置迭代更新等设计过程意义明确、参数设置简单,且本发明可直接采用现场实际数据进行建模,使设计得到的PID控制器对生产过程的针对性更强,更具有工程实用价值。Advantages of the present invention: Compared with other intelligent optimization algorithms, the improved SOA algorithm adopted in the present invention has clear meanings and simple parameter settings in the design process of fitness function, optimization step size and direction, individual position iterative update, etc. involved in the process of adjusting PID parameters. In addition, the present invention can directly use actual on-site data for modeling, so that the designed PID controller is more targeted to the production process and has more engineering practical value.
附图说明BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
图1是本发明的控制原理示意图;Fig. 1 is a schematic diagram of the control principle of the present invention;
图2是本发明实施例中主汽压力辨识建模曲线图;FIG2 is a main steam pressure identification modeling curve diagram according to an embodiment of the present invention;
图3是本发明的算法流程图;Fig. 3 is an algorithm flow chart of the present invention;
图4是本发明实施例中PID参数变化曲线;FIG4 is a PID parameter variation curve in an embodiment of the present invention;
图5是本发明实施例中SOA优化过程中适应度函数变化曲线图;5 is a curve diagram showing changes in the fitness function during SOA optimization in an embodiment of the present invention;
图6是本发明实施例中主汽压设定值阶跃扰动响应曲线图;FIG6 is a graph showing a step disturbance response curve of a main steam pressure setting value in an embodiment of the present invention;
图7是本发明实例中主汽压设定值阶跃响应综合比较曲线图(SOA与改进型SOA);7 is a comprehensive comparison curve diagram of the step response of the main steam pressure setting value in the example of the present invention (SOA and improved SOA);
图8是采用本发明算法的某火电机组深调工况主汽压力调节过程曲线。FIG8 is a main steam pressure regulation process curve of a thermal power unit in deep regulation condition using the algorithm of the present invention.
具体实施方式Detailed ways
下面结合附图,以某660MW深度调峰火电机组作为实施对象,按本发明的技术方法对主汽压力控制系统进行参数优化,详细说明基于人群搜索优化智能算法在火电机组主汽压力控制系统中的应用。基于本发明中的实施例,本领域普通技术人员在没有做出创造性劳动前提下所获得的所有其他实施例,都属于本发明保护的范围。In conjunction with the accompanying drawings, a 660MW deep peak-shaving thermal power unit is taken as an implementation object, and the parameters of the main steam pressure control system are optimized according to the technical method of the present invention, and the application of the intelligent algorithm based on crowd search optimization in the main steam pressure control system of the thermal power unit is described in detail. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
参照图1,对本发明的整体控制原理进行介绍。图中的主汽压-燃料控制对象包含了燃料指令和实际燃料量控制的广义控制对象,在燃料主控控制参数一定的情况下,可使得主汽压力的建模更加简便。考虑到人群搜索算法的复杂性和计算量,在DCS原有控制逻辑和PID控制器结构基本保持不变的情况下,采用离线参数整定的方案。在离线情况下,对辨识得到的主汽压力传递函数被控对象进行控制系统设计,通过人群搜索算法不断迭代计算已合理构造的适应度函数,获得一组最佳PID控制参数值。Referring to Figure 1, the overall control principle of the present invention is introduced. The main steam pressure-fuel control object in the figure includes the generalized control objects of fuel command and actual fuel quantity control. When the fuel main control parameters are constant, the modeling of the main steam pressure can be made simpler. Considering the complexity and computational complexity of the crowd search algorithm, an offline parameter setting scheme is adopted while the original control logic of the DCS and the PID controller structure remain basically unchanged. Under the offline condition, the control system design is carried out for the controlled object of the identified main steam pressure transfer function, and the fitness function that has been reasonably constructed is continuously iterated and calculated through the crowd search algorithm to obtain a set of optimal PID control parameter values.
基于人群搜索优化算法(SOA)的火电机组深度调峰工况下的主汽压力控制方法具体包含如下步骤:The main steam pressure control method under deep peak regulation conditions of thermal power units based on crowd search optimization algorithm (SOA) specifically includes the following steps:
(1)采用现场阶跃扰动试验法,基于系统辨识原理,建立主汽压力对象的传递函数模型。将机组锅炉主控、汽机主控均切为手动状态,阶跃改变燃料主控指令(5%),获取主汽压力响应曲线,并对数据进行坏值剔除、零均值处理。选取如式(1)所示的典型有自平衡能力的热工过程已知结构表达式,只需辨识其中的参数即可,辨识算法可采用最小二乘、粒子群优化算法等。所得燃料量-主汽压力过程的传递函数为式(2)形式,辨识结果曲线如图2所示。(1) Using the on-site step disturbance test method, based on the system identification principle, the transfer function model of the main steam pressure object is established. The unit boiler master control and steam turbine master control are both switched to manual mode, and the fuel master control instruction is changed stepwise (5%) to obtain the main steam pressure response curve, and the data is subjected to bad value elimination and zero mean processing. Select the known structural expression of a typical thermal process with self-balancing ability as shown in formula (1), and only need to identify the parameters therein. The identification algorithm can adopt the least squares, particle swarm optimization algorithm, etc. The transfer function of the obtained fuel quantity-main steam pressure process is in the form of formula (2), and the identification result curve is shown in Figure 2.
公式中:k-主汽压力传递函数静态增益;n-传递函数阶次;τ-延迟时间;s-拉普拉斯算子。In the formula: k is the static gain of the main steam pressure transfer function; n is the order of the transfer function; τ is the delay time; s is the Laplace operator.
(2)基于人群搜索算法优化主汽压力PID控制参数。(2) Optimize the main steam pressure PID control parameters based on the crowd search algorithm.
由式(2)可知,火电机组在深度调峰工况下的主汽压力模型为二阶惯性加纯迟延对象,现场整定PID多采用依据经验的试凑法,调试过程耗时长,调节过程动态指标不易达到精度要求。It can be seen from formula (2) that the main steam pressure model of the thermal power unit under deep peak regulation conditions is a second-order inertia plus pure delay object. The on-site PID adjustment mostly adopts the trial and error method based on experience. The debugging process is time-consuming and the dynamic indicators of the adjustment process are not easy to meet the accuracy requirements.
本工程案例中机组主控DCS采用并联式PID,根据输入值rin(t)和输出值yout(t)的偏差e(t)构成如式(3)的控制规律。式(5)为PID的传递函数形式,其中Kp为比例系数,Ti为积分时间常数,Td为微分时间常数,三者为待优化整定参数。In this project case, the unit master control DCS adopts parallel PID, and the control law is formed according to the deviation e(t) between the input value rin(t) and the output value yout(t) as shown in formula (3). Formula (5) is the transfer function form of PID, where Kp is the proportional coefficient, Ti is the integral time constant, and Td is the differential time constant. The three are the parameters to be optimized.
e(t)=rin(t)-yout(t) (3)e(t)=rin(t)-yout(t) (3)
选择合适的采样周期,将PID控制器和被控对象进行离散化处理,在使用matlab进行算法编程仿真时,可采用其内置函数c2d进行离散化。Select a suitable sampling period and discretize the PID controller and the controlled object. When using MATLAB for algorithm programming simulation, you can use its built-in function c2d for discretization.
参数编码:将PID的三个参数作为一个搜索个体,则每个个体的位置矢量的维数为D=3,定义种群P中有S个个体,所以种群P可用式(6)表示:Parameter encoding: The three parameters of PID are taken as a search individual, and the dimension of the position vector of each individual is D=3. It is defined that there are S individuals in the population P, so the population P can be expressed by formula (6):
适应度函数的选取:适应度函数是搜索优化过程中评价个体优劣的唯一指标,也是SOA算法与控制系统结合的纽带,指导着算法朝控制目标不断进化。选取原则如下:为了获取优良的调节动态特性,采用误差绝对值的时间积分性能指标作为最小目标函数;为了防止控制器输出量能过大损坏现场设备,引入控制输入平方项;为了避免超调现象,采用适度的惩罚控制,将超调量作为指标的一项。如此,目标函数如式(7)所示。其中,各项权值的取值一般为:ω1=0.999,ω2=0.001,ω3=100。Selection of fitness function: The fitness function is the only indicator for evaluating the quality of individuals in the search optimization process. It is also the link between the SOA algorithm and the control system, guiding the algorithm to evolve towards the control target. The selection principles are as follows: In order to obtain excellent dynamic characteristics of regulation, the time integral performance index of the absolute value of the error is used as the minimum objective function; in order to prevent the controller output from being too large and damaging the field equipment, the control input square term is introduced; in order to avoid overshoot, moderate penalty control is used, and the overshoot is used as an indicator. In this way, the objective function is shown in formula (7). Among them, the values of each weight are generally: ω 1 = 0.999, ω 2 = 0.001, ω 3 = 100.
搜索步长的确定:SOA的不确定推理行为是利用模糊系统的逼近能力,模拟人的智能搜索行为,用以建立目标函数值和步长之间的联系。采用高斯隶属函数表示搜索步长模糊变量。Determination of search step length: The uncertain reasoning behavior of SOA uses the approximation ability of fuzzy systems to simulate the intelligent search behavior of people to establish the connection between the objective function value and the step length. The Gaussian membership function is used to represent the search step length fuzzy variable.
上式(8)中,uA为高斯隶属度;x为输入变量;u、δ为隶属函数参数。当输出变量超出[u-3δ,u+3δ]时,若隶属度小于0.0111,则可忽略,故设定umin=0.0111,同时为了获得较快的收敛速度,设定umax=0.95。In the above formula (8), u A is the Gaussian membership; x is the input variable; u and δ are the membership function parameters. When the output variable exceeds [u-3δ, u+3δ], if the membership is less than 0.0111, it can be ignored, so u min = 0.0111 is set, and in order to obtain a faster convergence speed, u max = 0.95 is set.
采用线性隶属度函数,在最佳位置有最大隶属度umax=1,最差位置有最小隶属度umin=0.0111,在其他位置u<1.0,如式(9)所示。Using a linear membership function, the best position has a maximum membership u max = 1, the worst position has a minimum membership u min = 0.0111, and u < 1.0 at other positions, as shown in formula (9).
上式(9)中,αij为j维搜索空间的搜索步长;δij为高斯隶属函数参数,其值由式(10)和(11)确定:In the above formula (9), α ij is the search step size of the j-dimensional search space; δ ij is the Gaussian membership function parameter, and its value is determined by formulas (10) and (11):
ω=(itermax-iter)/itermax (11)ω=(iter max -iter)/iter max (11)
上式中,xmin和xmax分别是同一种群中的最小和最大函数值的位置;ω是惯性权值,随进化代数的增加从0.9线性递减至0.1;iter和itermax分别是当前迭代次数和最大迭代次数。In the above formula, x min and x max are the positions of the minimum and maximum function values in the same population, respectively; ω is the inertia weight, which decreases linearly from 0.9 to 0.1 with the increase of evolutionary generations; iter and iter max are the current and maximum iteration numbers, respectively.
搜索方向的确定:通过对人的利己行为、利他行为和预动行为的分析和建模,得到三种行动方向的表达式如式(12)-(14):Determination of search direction: Through the analysis and modeling of people's selfish behavior, altruistic behavior and pre-action behavior, the expressions of three action directions are obtained as shown in equations (12)-(14):
综合以上因素,采用三个方向随机加权几何平均确定搜索方向,如式(15):Taking the above factors into consideration, the search direction is determined by randomly weighted geometric averaging of three directions, as shown in formula (15):
其中,和分别为中的最佳位置;为第i个搜寻个体所在邻域的集体历史最佳位置,为第i个搜寻个体到目前为止经历过的最佳位置;sign(*)为符号函数;和为[0,1]内的常数;ω是惯性权值。in, and They are The best position in is the collective best historical position of the neighborhood of the i-th search individual, is the best position experienced by the i-th search individual so far; sign(*) is the sign function; and is a constant in [0,1]; ω is the inertia weight.
个体位置的更新:根据上述分析,可根据搜索方向和步长进行个体位置更新,如下式所示。Update of individual position: Based on the above analysis, the individual position can be updated according to the search direction and step size, as shown in the following formula.
Δxij(t+1)=αij(t)dij(t) (16)Δx ij (t+1) = α ij (t) d ij (t) (16)
xij(t+1)=xij(t)+Δxij(t+1) (17)x ij (t+1) = x ij (t) + Δ x ij (t+1) (17)
其中,Δxij(t+1)为第i个搜寻个体在j维搜索空间下一时刻的位置变化量,xij(t)为t时刻第i个搜寻个体在j维搜索空间的位置。Among them, Δx ij (t+1) is the position change of the i-th search individual in the j-dimensional search space at the next moment, and x ij (t) is the position of the i-th search individual in the j-dimensional search space at moment t.
人群搜索算法的改进:以模糊步长为导向的位置更新方式容易诱发算法陷入局部最优,从而导致搜索偏离最优解;人群缺乏信息交流易降低人群多样性,将进一步限制算法的开发范围。针对上述问题,采用反向差分进化机制和自适应t分布策略对原始人群搜索算法进行联合改进,进一步增强其脱离局部最优的能力。Improvement of crowd search algorithm: The position update method guided by fuzzy step size can easily induce the algorithm to fall into local optimality, thus causing the search to deviate from the optimal solution; the lack of information exchange among the crowd can easily reduce the diversity of the crowd, which will further limit the scope of algorithm development. In response to the above problems, the reverse differential evolution mechanism and the adaptive t distribution strategy are used to jointly improve the original crowd search algorithm to further enhance its ability to escape from the local optimality.
对于任意个体xij,其反向解定义为For any individual x ij , the inverse solution is defined as
xi'j=ubj+lbj-xij (18)x i ' j = ub j + lb j - x ij (18)
上式中,ubj和lbj分别为第j维搜索空间的上限和下限。为进一步增强人群多样性,提出采用差分进化(Differential Evolution Algorithm,DE)对人群位置进行更新,通过变异、交叉和选择策略来寻找优质个体,加强个体之间的信息交。In the above formula, ub j and lb j are the upper and lower limits of the j-th dimension search space, respectively. In order to further enhance the diversity of the population, it is proposed to use differential evolution algorithm (DE) to update the position of the population, find high-quality individuals through mutation, crossover and selection strategies, and strengthen the information exchange between individuals.
对于人群中每个个体向量xi,随机选择三个不同的个体向量进行结合,产生变异个体:For each individual vector xi in the population, three different individual vectors are randomly selected and combined to generate mutant individuals:
vi(t+1)=xr1(t)+F(xr2(t)-xr3(t)) (19) vi (t+1)= xr1 (t)+F( xr2 (t) -xr3 (t)) (19)
上式中,r1,r2,r3为[1,0.5N]内三个不同差分个体的编号,其中,缩放因子F为[0,1]范围内的随机数。In the above formula, r 1 , r 2 , r 3 are the numbers of three different differential individuals in [1, 0.5N], and the scaling factor F is a random number in the range of [0, 1].
采用交叉操作构造试验个体uij(t+1),构造方法为:The crossover operation is used to construct the test individual u ij (t+1), and the construction method is:
其中,rand产生[0,1]之间的随机数,交叉概率因子CR的范围在[0,1]之间。f(*)为适应度函数,计算经交叉操作产生后新个体的适应度值,如果新个体的具有更优的适应度,则对原始个体进行替换:Among them, rand generates random numbers between [0,1], and the range of the crossover probability factor CR is between [0,1]. f(*) is the fitness function, which calculates the fitness value of the new individual after the crossover operation. If the new individual has a better fitness, the original individual is replaced:
采用以迭代次数i为系统参量的变异因子对全局最优位置进行自适应更新,基于贪婪选择算法推选出质量更高的位置并参与下轮迭代。自适应t分布是融合高斯分布与柯西分布优点随机参数组,当其作为变异因子对可行解进行扰动时,可使算法具有一定的局部随机搜索能力以避免陷入局部最优。最优个体的自适应变异过程如下公式所示:The global optimal position is adaptively updated using a mutation factor with the number of iterations i as the system parameter. A higher quality position is selected based on the greedy selection algorithm and participates in the next iteration. The adaptive t distribution is a random parameter group that combines the advantages of Gaussian distribution and Cauchy distribution. When it is used as a mutation factor to perturb the feasible solution, it can enable the algorithm to have a certain local random search ability to avoid falling into the local optimum. The adaptive mutation process of the optimal individual is shown in the following formula:
xbest(t+1)=xbest(t)+xbest(t)*trnd(t) (22)x best (t+1)=x best (t)+x best (t)*trnd(t) (22)
上式中,xbest(t)为当前最优解,xbest(t+1)为自适应t分布变异后的新解。In the above formula, x best (t) is the current optimal solution, and x best (t+1) is the new solution after the adaptive t distribution mutation.
按照上述步骤,实现改进型人群搜索算法SOA对主汽压力PID控制器的参数优化,迭代过程中参数变化曲线如图4所示,最终寻优得到的参数为Kp=8.32、Ki=0.01、Kd=52.1。结合现场DCS控制器结构,并转换为实际微分形式,将参数序列置入现场DCS逻辑组态,可获得较为优良的控制品质。由图7所示,是本发明实例中主汽压设定值阶跃响应综合比较曲线,可知传统SOA算法得到的控制参数在控制输出条件约束下的阶跃响应输出调节时间较长,且静态偏差较大;而本文提出的改进型SOA算法得到的控制参数在设定值阶跃响应过程中动态响应快、静态偏差小、精度更高、收敛更快,验证了改进型算法的优越性。如图8所示,采用本发明方法的某超临界机组深度调峰工况下协调变负荷试验过程中,实际主汽压力跟踪设定值的性能良好,控制系统指标能够满足相关行业技术标准。According to the above steps, the improved crowd search algorithm SOA is implemented to optimize the parameters of the main steam pressure PID controller. The parameter change curve during the iteration process is shown in Figure 4. The parameters finally obtained by optimization are Kp=8.32, Ki=0.01, and Kd=52.1. Combined with the structure of the on-site DCS controller, and converted into actual differential form, the parameter sequence is placed in the on-site DCS logic configuration, and a relatively good control quality can be obtained. As shown in Figure 7, it is a comprehensive comparison curve of the step response of the main steam pressure set value in the example of the present invention. It can be seen that the control parameters obtained by the traditional SOA algorithm have a long step response output adjustment time under the control output condition constraint, and the static deviation is large; while the control parameters obtained by the improved SOA algorithm proposed in this paper have fast dynamic response, small static deviation, higher accuracy, and faster convergence in the set value step response process, which verifies the superiority of the improved algorithm. As shown in Figure 8, during the coordinated variable load test under the deep peak regulation condition of a supercritical unit using the method of the present invention, the actual main steam pressure has good performance in tracking the set value, and the control system indicators can meet the relevant industry technical standards.
以上所述仅为本发明的具体实施方案的详细描述,并不以此限制本发明,凡在本发明的设计思路上所作的任何修改、等同替换和改进等,均应包含在本发明的保护范围之内。The above is only a detailed description of a specific implementation scheme of the present invention, and does not limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions and improvements made on the design concept of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims (4)
Priority Applications (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
CN202211119376.5A CN115327890B (en) | 2022-09-14 | 2022-09-14 | Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
CN202211119376.5A CN115327890B (en) | 2022-09-14 | 2022-09-14 | Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm |
Publications (2)
Publication Number | Publication Date |
---|---|
CN115327890A CN115327890A (en) | 2022-11-11 |
CN115327890B true CN115327890B (en) | 2024-07-16 |
Family
ID=83930285
Family Applications (1)
Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
---|---|---|---|
CN202211119376.5A Active CN115327890B (en) | 2022-09-14 | 2022-09-14 | Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm |
Country Status (1)
Country | Link |
---|---|
CN (1) | CN115327890B (en) |
Families Citing this family (2)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
CN118011783B (en) * | 2024-04-09 | 2024-06-04 | 天津仁爱学院 | Construction environment PID control method based on improved barrel jellyfish algorithm |
CN118732630B (en) * | 2024-09-02 | 2024-12-13 | 朔韦茨环境科技(江苏)有限公司 | Method and system for optimizing nano film preparation process |
Citations (2)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
JP2010266967A (en) * | 2009-05-12 | 2010-11-25 | Fuji Electric Systems Co Ltd | PID adjustment device and PID adjustment program |
CN110308649A (en) * | 2019-07-11 | 2019-10-08 | 东南大学 | A PID parameter optimization method based on PSO-SOA fusion algorithm |
-
2022
- 2022-09-14 CN CN202211119376.5A patent/CN115327890B/en active Active
Patent Citations (2)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
JP2010266967A (en) * | 2009-05-12 | 2010-11-25 | Fuji Electric Systems Co Ltd | PID adjustment device and PID adjustment program |
CN110308649A (en) * | 2019-07-11 | 2019-10-08 | 东南大学 | A PID parameter optimization method based on PSO-SOA fusion algorithm |
Also Published As
Publication number | Publication date |
---|---|
CN115327890A (en) | 2022-11-11 |
Similar Documents
Publication | Publication Date | Title |
---|---|---|
Huang et al. | Data-driven model identification of boiler-turbine coupled process in 1000 MW ultra-supercritical unit by improved bird swarm algorithm | |
Khooban et al. | A new intelligent online fuzzy tuning approach for multi-area load frequency control: Self Adaptive Modified Bat Algorithm | |
Ghoshal | Application of GA/GA-SA based fuzzy automatic generation control of a multi-area thermal generating system | |
Wang et al. | Stochastic combined heat and power dispatch based on multi-objective particle swarm optimization | |
Chen et al. | Application of multi-objective controller to optimal tuning of PID gains for a hydraulic turbine regulating system using adaptive grid particle swam optimization | |
CN115327890B (en) | Method for optimizing main steam pressure of PID control thermal power depth peak shaving unit by improved crowd searching algorithm | |
CN102129259B (en) | Neural network proportion integration (PI)-based intelligent temperature control system and method for sand dust environment test wind tunnel | |
Kubalík et al. | Symbolic regression methods for reinforcement learning | |
CN116755409B (en) | A coordinated control method for coal-fired power generation system based on value distribution DDPG algorithm | |
Boroushaki et al. | An intelligent nuclear reactor core controller for load following operations, using recurrent neural networks and fuzzy systems | |
Vidyarthi et al. | A modified tilt controller for AGC in hybrid power system integrating forecasting of renewable energy sources | |
Nayak et al. | Adaptive fuzzy approach for load frequency control using hybrid moth flame pattern search optimization with real time validation | |
CN114909706A (en) | Secondary network balance regulation and control method based on reinforcement learning algorithm and pressure difference control | |
Prasanth et al. | A hybrid technique to control superheater steam temperature in power plants using multi modeling and predictive sliding mode control | |
CN117784852A (en) | Multi-mode sensor temperature control method based on fish scale bionic optimization algorithm | |
Zheng et al. | Data-driven based multi-objective combustion optimization covering static and dynamic states | |
Zhao et al. | An intelligent multi-step predictive control method of the Small Modular Reactor | |
CN115289450A (en) | Full-load dynamically-adjusted boiler staged combustion real-time control method and system | |
Liu et al. | Strategy dynamics with feedback control in the global climate dilemma games | |
CN118494790B (en) | Ammonia working medium thruster thrust stability control method and system | |
Guan et al. | Interval Optimal Controller Design for Uncertain Systems Based on Interval Neural Network | |
Abo-Al-Ez et al. | Comparative study for combined economic and emission dispatch problem considering valve point effect | |
CN114529208B (en) | Dynamic Optimal Scheduling Method for Electric-Thermal Coupling System Considering Rapid Ramp Capability Constraints of CHP Units | |
Chen et al. | The “regulation resonance” phenomenon in control systems and optimization schemes | |
Suganya et al. | Model reference adaptive controller using MOPSO for a non-Linear boiler-turbine |
Legal Events
Date | Code | Title | Description |
---|---|---|---|
PB01 | Publication | ||
PB01 | Publication | ||
SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
GR01 | Patent grant | ||
GR01 | Patent grant |