CN115146880A

CN115146880A - Intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation method and device for coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme

Info

Publication number: CN115146880A
Application number: CN202211079921.2A
Authority: CN
Inventors: 刘见中; 刘彦青; 李阳; 舒龙勇; 郭建行; 霍中刚; 季文博; 雷毅
Original assignee: CCTEG China Coal Research Institute
Current assignee: CCTEG China Coal Research Institute
Priority date: 2022-09-05
Filing date: 2022-09-05
Publication date: 2022-10-04
Anticipated expiration: 2042-09-05
Also published as: CN115146880B

Abstract

The application provides an intelligent aid decision evaluation method and device for a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme. The method comprises the following steps: according to the coordinated development conditions of the target mine, discretized segmented value processing is carried out on the expected intervals of the time-space constraint condition parameters to obtain a plurality of groups of different time-space constraint condition parameter combinations, three-level effect evaluation index values corresponding to the different time-space constraint condition parameter combinations are obtained through solving, a secondary effect evaluation index and a primary effect evaluation index are sequentially calculated, and finally a comprehensive evaluation index is obtained. And determining the optimal solution of the scheme by comparing a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes. The method realizes intelligent aid decision-making, improves the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development efficiency, establishes a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme optimization decision-making process which takes an optimal development scheme as a target solution and realizes solution by a computer programming language, realizes intellectualization and automation in the decision-making process through a computer, and reduces the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development and popularization difficulty.

Description

Intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation method and device for coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme

Technical Field

The application relates to the technical field of coal bed gas and coal co-mining, in particular to an intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation method and device for a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme.

Background

The method comprises the steps of entering a stage of simultaneously exploiting and utilizing two resources of coal and coal bed gas, forming a multi-form coal and coal bed gas coordinated development technology for improving the coal bed gas exploitation efficiency and the gas extraction efficiency, wherein the occurrence conditions of the coal bed gas and the coal resources in each mining area have certain differences, and the coal bed gas exploitation technology and the coal exploitation technology are selected according to the characteristics of each mining area. At present, respective coal and coal bed gas development technology systems are formed, and because the coal mining engineering and the gas production engineering have a mutual restriction relationship in time and space, how to reasonably arrange the coal mining engineering and the gas production engineering and realize safe and efficient coordinated development of coal and coal bed gas is a scientific problem faced by all mining areas.

Aiming at the problems of incongruity, mutual interference and mutual restriction existing for a long time in the development of coal and coal bed methane, the coordinated development of coal and coal bed methane in a coal mine area forms a plurality of coordinated development modes, summarizes a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development technical system, and lays an important foundation for the coordinated development of coal and coal bed methane. However, most of the above results are developed in typical mine research of demonstration engineering, and cannot adapt to the production conditions of all mines in coal mining areas.

Therefore, it is particularly urgent to optimize the key technology for the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gas to meet the actual demand of production. The coordinated development of the coal and the coal bed gas is a complex system engineering, a reasonable coordinated development mode is selected and optimized, the optimal development technology and process are adopted and designed to popularize and apply the coordinated development technology of the coal and the coal bed gas, and the optimized decision evaluation is carried out on the coordinated development scheme of the coal and the coal bed gas through a systematic and scientific method, so that the key for realizing the coordinated development, popularization and application of the coal and the coal bed gas is realized. At present, no mature and practical method exists in the aspect of auxiliary decision evaluation of a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme.

Disclosure of Invention

The application provides an intelligent aid decision evaluation method and device for a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme, so that a reasonable coordinated development mode can be selected. The technical scheme of the application is as follows:

in a first aspect, an embodiment of the present application provides an intelligent aid decision evaluation method for a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme, including:

establishing a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision index system, wherein the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision index system comprises a coordinated development condition index A1, a space-time constraint condition index A2 and an effect evaluation index A3;

determining index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to a plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 based on the obtained index parameter values of the coordinated development condition index A1 of the target mine;

obtaining a plurality of groups of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to a plurality of indexes of the time-space constraint condition index A2;

calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each group of the space-time constraint condition index parameter combination; until a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained;

and obtaining an optimal evaluation result based on the plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes.

In some embodiments, the obtaining a plurality of different sets of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations based on the index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to the plurality of indexes of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index A2 includes:

discretizing and segmenting index parameter expected intervals corresponding to a plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 to obtain a plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals;

forming a plurality of groups of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each discretized index parameter expected interval; and each group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combination corresponds to a plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2.

In some embodiments, the obtaining an optimal evaluation result based on the plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes includes:

comparing the multiple comprehensive evaluation indexes to obtain the maximum value of the comprehensive evaluation indexes;

obtaining an optimal evaluation result based on the maximum value of the comprehensive evaluation index; and the optimal evaluation result is a space-time constraint condition index parameter combination corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive evaluation index.

In some embodiments, the effect evaluation index A3 includes a comprehensive evaluation index, a primary effect evaluation index U, a secondary effect evaluation index, and a tertiary effect evaluation index, the comprehensive evaluation index is a comprehensive evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, each index of the primary effect evaluation index U correspondingly includes a plurality of the secondary effect evaluation indexes, and each index of the secondary effect evaluation indexes correspondingly includes a plurality of the tertiary effect evaluation indexes.

In some embodiments, the calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameters of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations includes:

calculating an index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index based on each group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combination;

standardizing the calculated actual index values of the three-level effect evaluation indexes to obtain evaluation indexes of the three-level effect evaluation indexes, and determining weight values of the three-level effect evaluation indexes;

calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index and the corresponding weight value;

calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index;

and calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U.

In some embodiments, the co-ordinated development conditions indicator A1 comprises raw coal bed gas content

Coal face gas content

Coal face advancing speedV _sc Average coal thickness of coal seamhLength of coal faceLDensity of coal ρ, ground well arrangement densityρ _gh Ton coal gas drilling amount of coal mining face coal seamρ _kt-yc Coal face stoping roadway arrangement modem _hc ；

The space-time constraint condition index A2 comprises the coal face recovery timeT _sc1 Length of production from surface wellT _gh2 Duration of succession phase for conversion from planning zone to development zoneT _gh-kt Pre-pumping standard-reaching time of extraction areaT _kt2 Time length of succession phase for switching from development area to production areaT _kt-sc ；

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which respectively represent coal mining resource benefits E ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level effect evaluation indexes, namely miningBenefit of gas resources E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ (ii) a The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas mining amount to coal mining amountQW(ii) a The coal mining safety benefit E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Gas content of coal at beginning of production areaC _sc (ii) a The gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt Production area coal bed gas exploitation amountQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ(ii) a The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region long development area ration _kt Three-zone time duration production zone proportionn _sc Length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of gas production volume of three areasQGH。

In some embodiments, the normalizing the calculated actual value of the index of the three-level effect evaluation index to obtain the evaluation index of the three-level effect evaluation index includes:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the index has positive benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data which is subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following first formula:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gas has negative benefits, the finger is usedSign boardx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data which is subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following second formula:

wherein:

x _i denotes the firstiIndex actual value of the item three-level effect evaluation index;

a _i is shown asiThe lower limit value of the critical value of the item three-level effect evaluation index can be an unallowable value according to a relevant standard, an evaluation object mean value or a sample measured value;

b _i denotes the firstiThe upper limit of the critical value of the evaluation index of the third-level effect can be expected according to the relevant standard, the mean value of the evaluation object or the actual measurement value of the sample.

In some embodiments, said calculating an evaluation index of said secondary effectiveness evaluation index based on an evaluation index of said tertiary effectiveness evaluation index and said corresponding weight value comprises:

calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index by a third formula based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index and the corresponding weight value, wherein the third formula is expressed as follows;

wherein:

E _j is shown asjThe evaluation index of the item secondary effect,j =1，2…m；

W _i is shown asiThe weight value of the evaluation index of the three-level effect,i=1，2…n；

X _i is shown asiEvaluation index of tertiary effect of item.

In some embodiments, the calculating an evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation indicator U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation indicator includes:

calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U by a fourth formula based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index, wherein the fourth formula is represented as follows:

wherein:

U _k is shown askThe evaluation index of the first-level effect evaluation index,k =1，2；

E _j is shown asjThe evaluation index of the item secondary effect evaluation index,j =1，2…m。

in some embodiments, the calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U includes:

based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index through a fifth formulaDThe fifth formula is expressed as follows:

wherein:

Dthe comprehensive evaluation index represents the coordinated development level of the coal and the coal bed gas;

Trepresents the coordination index of the coal mining system and the coal bed gas development system,

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

wherein:α、bexpressed as a preset coefficient, since coal mining and coal bed gas development are considered to be equally important, consideration can be given toα=b=0.5。

In some embodiments, the forming a plurality of different spatio-temporal constraint index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expectation intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each of the discretized index parameter expectation intervals comprises:

and forming a plurality of groups of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each discretized index parameter expected interval based on an interval quantitative discrete group lifting method.

In a second aspect, an embodiment of the present application provides an intelligent aid decision evaluation device for a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme, including:

the system comprises an index system determining module, a decision-making index system and a data processing module, wherein the index system determining module is used for establishing a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision-making index system, and the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision-making index system comprises a coordinated development condition index A1, a space-time constraint condition index A2 and an effect evaluation index A3;

the constraint index interval acquisition module is used for determining index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to a plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 based on the acquired index parameter values of the coordinated development condition index A1 of the target mine;

an index parameter combination obtaining module, configured to obtain multiple different sets of time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to multiple indexes of the time-space constraint condition index A2;

the effect evaluation index calculation module is used for calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combination; until a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained;

and the evaluation result acquisition module is used for obtaining an optimal evaluation result based on the plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes.

In some embodiments, the index parameter combination obtaining module is specifically configured to:

discretizing and segmenting the index parameter expected intervals corresponding to the indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 to obtain a plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals;

In some embodiments, the evaluation result obtaining module is specifically configured to:

In some embodiments, the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameters of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of the spatiotemporal constraint condition index parameter combinations, is configured to:

And the coal face mining and falling gas content

Coal face advancing speedV _sc Average coal thickness of stoping coal seamhLength of coal faceLDensity of coal ρ, ground well arrangement densityρ _gh Ton coal gas drilling amount of coal mining face coal seamρ _kt-yc Coal face stoping roadway arrangement modem _hc ；

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which respectively represent the coal mining resource benefitsE ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 secondary effect evaluation indexes which are respectively gas production resource benefits E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ (ii) a The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas production to coal productionQW(ii) a The coal mining safety benefit E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Gas content of coal at beginning of production areaC _sc (ii) a Said gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt Production area coal bed gas exploitation amountQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ(ii) a The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region long development area ration _kt Three zones long production zone ration _sc Length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of gas production volume of three areasQGH。

In some embodiments, the effect evaluation index calculation module, when normalizing the calculated actual value of the index of the third-level effect evaluation index to obtain the evaluation index of the third-level effect evaluation index, is configured to:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the indexes have negative benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (2)X _i The data which is subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following second formula:

wherein:

In some embodiments, the effect evaluation indicator calculation module, when calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation indicator based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation indicator and the corresponding weight value, is configured to:

calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index through a third formula based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index and the corresponding weight value, wherein the third formula is expressed as follows;

wherein:

E _j is shown asjEvaluation of Secondary Effect of itemThe evaluation index of the price index is,j =1，2…m；

X _i denotes the firstiEvaluation index of the third-level effect.

In some embodiments, the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index, is configured to:

based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index, calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U through a fourth formula, wherein the fourth formula is represented as follows:

wherein:

in some embodiments, the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, is configured to:

wherein:

Da comprehensive evaluation index representing the coordinated development level of coal and coal bed gas;

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

In some embodiments, the index parameter combination obtaining module is specifically configured to, when a plurality of different sets of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations are formed based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discrete values of each discretized index parameter expected interval, perform:

In a third aspect, an embodiment of the present application provides an electronic device, including: at least one processor; and a memory communicatively coupled to the at least one processor; the memory stores instructions executable by the at least one processor, and the instructions are executed by the at least one processor to enable the at least one processor to execute the intelligent aid decision evaluation method for coal and coal bed methane coordination development scheme according to the embodiment of the first aspect of the present application.

In a fourth aspect, embodiments of the present application provide a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium storing computer instructions for causing a computer to execute the intelligent aid decision-making evaluation method for a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme according to the embodiments of the first aspect of the present application.

In a fifth aspect, the present application provides a computer program product, which includes computer instructions, and when executed by a processor, the computer instructions implement the steps of the intelligent aid decision-making evaluation method for a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme described in the first aspect of the present application.

The technical scheme provided by the embodiment of the application at least has the following beneficial effects:

the method comprises the steps of determining an expected interval of a time-space constraint condition index according to a coordinated development condition of a target mine, taking values according to different intervals, forming a plurality of groups of coal and coal bed gas coordinated development schemes, establishing a multi-stage effect evaluation index for coal and coal bed gas coordinated development quantification, pre-evaluating coordinated development effects of different schemes to obtain a plurality of evaluation results, and realizing intelligent auxiliary decision by comparing and analyzing the plurality of evaluation results, thereby improving the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development efficiency. In addition, by establishing the optimal development mode as a target solution and realizing the optimized decision-making process of the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme solved by a computer programming language, the decision-making process realizes intellectualization and automation by a computer, and the method has the advantages of simple use, high accuracy and small manual interference, and reduces the difficulty in coal and coal bed gas coordinated development and popularization.

It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory only and are not restrictive of the application.

Drawings

The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate embodiments consistent with the present application and, together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the application and are not to be construed as limiting the application.

FIG. 1 is a flow chart illustrating a method for intelligent aid decision-making evaluation of a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scenario, according to an exemplary embodiment.

Fig. 2 is a flowchart illustrating a method of calculating a composite evaluation index of an effectiveness evaluation index according to an exemplary embodiment.

FIG. 3 is a block diagram illustrating an intelligent aid decision-making evaluation apparatus for a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scenario, according to an example embodiment.

FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating an electronic device in accordance with an example embodiment.

Detailed Description

In order to make the technical solutions of the present application better understood by those of ordinary skill in the art, the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present application will be clearly and completely described below with reference to the accompanying drawings.

It should be noted that the terms "first," "second," and the like in this application are used for distinguishing between similar elements and not necessarily for describing a particular sequential or chronological order. It will be appreciated that the data so used may be interchanged under appropriate circumstances such that embodiments of the application described herein may be implemented in sequences other than those illustrated or described herein. The embodiments described in the following exemplary embodiments do not represent all embodiments consistent with the present application. Rather, they are merely examples of apparatus and methods consistent with certain aspects of the present application, as detailed in the appended claims.

Fig. 1 is a schematic flow chart illustrating a method for intelligent aid decision evaluation of a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme according to an exemplary embodiment, which may include steps S101-S105.

In step S101, a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development mode optimization decision index system is established, wherein the coal and coalbed methane coordinated development mode optimization decision index system includes a coordinated development condition index A1, a spatiotemporal constraint condition index A2, and an effect evaluation index A3. The coordinated development condition index A1 and the space-time constraint condition index A2 both comprise a plurality of indexes, and the effect evaluation index A3 comprises a plurality of stages of evaluation indexes with progressive relation.

In step S102, an index parameter expectation interval corresponding to each of the plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 is determined based on the index parameter value of the obtained coordinated development condition index A1 of the target mine.

That is to say, the index parameter value of the coordinated development condition index A1 of the target mine is obtained, and the index parameter expectation interval corresponding to each of the multiple indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2 is determined based on the index parameter value of the coordinated development condition index A1.

In this embodiment, the index parameter values corresponding to the coordinated development condition indexes of the target mine may be counted according to practical experience and mine production requirements, and the index parameter expectation interval of the index parameters of the space-time constraint condition indexes is determined.

In step S103, a plurality of different sets of space-time constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained based on the index parameter expectation sections corresponding to the plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2.

Optionally, the method for obtaining a plurality of different combinations of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameters includes:

forming a plurality of groups of different space-time constraint condition index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each discretized index parameter expected interval; and each group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combination corresponds to a plurality of indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2.

It can be understood that a group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combinations are formed by taking values from a plurality of index parameter expectation intervals and taking out one value, and a plurality of values are taken for each index parameter expectation interval and combined, so that a plurality of groups of different space-time constraint condition index parameter combinations can be obtained.

Optionally, a plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are formed based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each discretized index parameter expected interval based on an interval quantitative discrete clustering method.

In step S104, a comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3 is calculated based on each group of spatiotemporal constraint condition index parameter combinations; until a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained.

That is, the step S103 is repeated for each of the index parameter segments to obtain a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the index parameter segments.

In step S105, an optimal evaluation result is obtained based on the plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes.

Optionally, obtaining an optimal evaluation result includes:

According to the method, the expected interval of the time-space constraint condition index can be determined according to the coordinated development condition index of the target mine, values are taken for different intervals to form a plurality of groups of coal and coal bed gas coordinated development schemes, the coordinated development effects of different schemes are pre-evaluated according to the established multi-level effect evaluation index to obtain a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes, and intelligent auxiliary decision is realized by comparing and analyzing the plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes, so that the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development efficiency is improved.

In some embodiments, for step S104, calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameters of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations, the method may include the following steps:

s201, calculating an index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index based on each group of space-time constraint condition index parameter combination.

S202, standardizing the index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index to obtain an evaluation index of the three-level effect evaluation index, and determining the weight value of the three-level effect evaluation index.

It should be noted that, determining the weight value of each index is to determine the contribution degree of each index to the element layer (belonging index grading) and each element layer to the target layer (comprehensive evaluation index), and the reasonability of determining the index weight will have a direct influence on the evaluation result of the index system. The method for determining the index weight mainly comprises a subjective weighting method and an objective weighting method. The subjective weighting method adopts a qualitative method of comprehensive consultation scoring to determine the weight, and the objective weighting method determines the weight of the indexes by analyzing the degree of relation among the indexes, the degree of relation and the information quantity provided by the indexes according to original information from objective environment, so that the deviation caused by subjective factors is avoided to a certain extent.

Optionally, the weight values of multiple indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexes are determined by using a variation coefficient method, so that the objectivity is relatively strong.

S203, calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index and the corresponding weight value.

And S204, calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index.

And S205, calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U.

In this embodiment, according to the index level correspondence relationship among the comprehensive evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3, the primary effect evaluation index U, the secondary effect evaluation index, and the tertiary effect evaluation index, the comprehensive evaluation index of the highest-level comprehensive evaluation index is obtained from the tertiary effect evaluation index step by step upward.

Coal face gas content

Coal face advancing speedV _sc Average coal thickness of stoping coal seamhLength of coal faceLDensity of coal ρ, ground well arrangement densityρ _gh Ton coal gas drilling amount of coal mining face coal seamρ _kt-yc Coal face stoping roadway arrangement modem _hc 。

The space-time constraint condition index A2 comprises the coal face extraction timeT _sc1 Length of production from surface wellT _gh2 Duration of succession phase for conversion from planning zone to development zoneT _gh-kt Pre-pumping standard-reaching time of extraction areaT _kt2 Time length of succession phase for switching from development area to production areaT _kt-sc 。

In step S103, a plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are formed based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each discretized index parameter expected interval based on an interval quantitative discrete clustering method; namely, the index parameter expectation interval of the 5 space-time constraint condition indexes is subjected to value taking.

The effect evaluation index A3 comprises a comprehensive evaluation index, a primary effect evaluation index U, a secondary effect evaluation index and a tertiary effect evaluation index, the comprehensive evaluation index is the comprehensive evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, the overall level of coordinated development of coal and coal bed gas in a coal mine area is reflected, and the overall level of coordinated development is higher if the numerical value is larger.

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ ；

Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which are respectively coal mining resource benefits E ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ ；

The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas production to coal productionQW；

Safety benefit of coal mining E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Gas content per ton coal at the beginning of production areaC _sc ；

Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 secondary effect evaluation indexes which are respectively gas production resource benefits E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ ；

The gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt Production area coal bed gas exploitation amountQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ；

The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region long development area ration _kt Three-zone time duration production zone proportionn _sc Coal bed gas exploitation amount and three-zone duration and ratioQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of gas production volume of three areasQGH。

The first-level effect evaluation index U, the second-level effect evaluation index and the third-level effect evaluation index and the corresponding relation are shown in the table 1.

Table 1:

in step S201, an index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index is calculated based on each set of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations.

That is, based on space-time constraints5 indexes of the Condition index A2 (coal face extraction time)T _sc1 Duration of production from ground wellsT _gh2 And the duration of the succession phase of the conversion from the planning area to the development areaT _gh-kt Pre-pumping standard-reaching time of extraction areaT _kt2 Time length of succession phase for switching from development area to production areaT _kt-sc (ii) a ) And calculating the actual index value of the three-level effect evaluation index according to the following calculation formula:

coal mining volumeMscThe formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（1）

wherein,T _sc1 in order to achieve the recovery time of the coal face,V _sc the coal face is the advancing speed of the coal face, m/d; (ii) ahIn order to recover the average coal thickness of the coal seam,Lrho is the coal density for the coal face length.

Coal bed gas exploitation amount of planned areaQ _gh The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（2）

wherein,ρ _gh arranging density for the surface well; a. b, c are the coefficient values of the extraction efficiency curve of the ground well, and are obtained by fitting according to the coal bed methane exploitation amount field data, and the relationship between the coal bed methane exploitation amount of the ground well and the exploitation time meets a quadratic parabolic function;T _gh2 the drainage and production time of the ground well is long,T _gh-kt the time length of the succession phase for the transition from the planning region to the development region.

Exploitation amount of coal bed gas in exploitation areaQ _kt The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（3）

wherein,ρ _kt-yc the ton coal gas drilling amount of a coal mining layer of a coal face is expressed as m/t;

expressed as a coal face coal mining equipment deployment time;n _bc the coefficient is expressed as a coal face stoping roadway (coal roadway) tunneling speed coefficient, the coefficient is 2 for a double-roadway tunneling mode, and the coefficient is 1 for a single-roadway tunneling mode; v _hc Tunneling speed of mining roadway (coal roadway) of the coal face, m/d;

expressed as a coal face mining roadway arrangement mode, the coefficient is 2 for a ventilation system of a 'one-in one-back' type, and the coefficient is 3 for a ventilation system of a 'two-in one-back' type;m、nfitting the coefficient value in the relation function between the coal bed gas exploitation amount and the time in the exploitation region stage according to the field data of the coal bed gas exploitation amount to obtain the coefficient value, wherein the quantitative relation between the coal bed gas exploitation amount and the exploitation time meets the negative exponential function; e is a natural constant having a value of about 2.718281828459045;T _kt-sc the take-over phase time for the transition from the exploitation area to the production area.

Production area coalbed methane exploitation amountQ _sc The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（4）

wherein,T _sc1 the time for coal face extraction, d,ρ _kt-yc and drilling holes for ton coal gas of a coal seam mined on a coal face in m/t.

Reduction rate of gas content in planned areaC _gh The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（5）

gas content at the beginning of the development areaC _kt The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（6）

gas content per ton coal at the beginning of production areaC _sc The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（7）

plan area ratio in three areasn _gh The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（8）

wherein,T _gh1 representing the construction and debugging duration of the ground well;T _gh2 representing the drainage and production time of the ground well;T _gh-kt representing the time length of a succession stage of the conversion from the planning area to the development area;T _kt1 the duration of a drilling construction stage of the underground gas production project is shown;T _kt2 expressed as the pre-pumping standard time of the extraction area,T _kt3 Indicating the excavation time of a mining roadway;T _kt4 representing a coal face coal mining equipment arrangement;T _kt-sc representing the time length of a succession phase for the conversion from an exploitation area to a production area;T _sc1 representing the recovery time of the coal face;T _sc2 the sealing stage duration of the coal face is d;T _sc the coal production zone duration, d;T _sc =T _sc1 +T _sc2 。

three-region long development area ration _kt The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（9）

long production zone ratio in three zonesn _sc The formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（10）

coal bed gas productionQThe formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（11）

ratio of coal bed gas exploitation amount to coal exploitation amountQWThe formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（12）

length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTThe formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（13）

gas production volume ratio of three-zone gas production volume planning zoneQGHThe formula of the calculation method is as follows:

（14）

the index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index can be obtained through the calculation formula.

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the index has positive benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation of the Individual index of (1)Index of refractionX _i The data which is subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following first formula:

wherein:

x _i is shown asiIndex actual value of the item three-level effect evaluation index;

b _i is shown asiThe upper limit of the critical value of the evaluation index of the third-level effect can be expected according to the relevant standard, the mean value of the evaluation object or the actual measurement value of the sample.

In some embodiments, said calculating an evaluation index of said secondary effectiveness evaluation indicator based on an evaluation index of said tertiary effectiveness evaluation indicator and said corresponding weight value comprises:

wherein:

W _i denotes the firstiThe weight value of the evaluation index of the three-level effect,i=1，2…n；

X _i is shown asiEvaluation index of tertiary effect of item.

wherein:

wherein:

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

According to the intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation method for the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme, the expected interval of the time-space constraint condition index can be determined according to the coordinated development condition of the target mine, values are taken for different intervals, a plurality of groups of coal and coal bed gas coordinated development schemes are formed, the multi-level effect evaluation index for coal and coal bed gas coordinated development quantification is established, the coordinated development effects of different schemes are pre-evaluated to obtain a plurality of evaluation results, the plurality of evaluation results are contrastively analyzed, the intelligent auxiliary decision is realized, and therefore the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development efficiency is improved. In addition, by establishing the optimal development mode as a target solution and realizing the optimized decision-making process of the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme solved by a computer programming language, the decision-making process realizes intellectualization and automation by a computer, and the method has the advantages of simple use, high accuracy and small manual interference, and reduces the difficulty in coal and coal bed gas coordinated development and popularization.

Corresponding to the embodiment of the above intelligent aid decision-making evaluation method for a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme, the embodiment of the present application further provides an intelligent aid decision-making evaluation device for a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme, as shown in fig. 3, the intelligent aid decision-making evaluation device for a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme may include: an index system determining module 301, a constraint index interval obtaining module 302, an index parameter combination obtaining module 303, an effect evaluation index calculating module 304 and an evaluation result obtaining module 305.

Specifically, the index system determining module 301 is configured to establish a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision index system, where the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision index system includes a coordinated development condition index A1, a spatio-temporal constraint condition index A2, and an effect evaluation index A3, the coordinated development condition index A1 and the spatio-temporal constraint condition index A2 both include multiple indexes, and the effect evaluation index A3 includes a multi-stage evaluation index having a progressive relationship;

a constraint index interval obtaining module 302, configured to determine, based on the obtained index parameter value of the coordinated development condition index A1 of the target mine, an index parameter expected interval corresponding to each of the multiple indexes of the space-time constraint condition index A2;

an index parameter combination obtaining module 303, configured to obtain multiple different sets of time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to multiple indexes of the time-space constraint condition index A2;

an effect evaluation index calculation module 304, configured to calculate a comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each group of spatiotemporal constraint condition index parameter combinations; until a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained;

an evaluation result obtaining module 305, configured to obtain an optimal evaluation result based on the multiple comprehensive evaluation indexes.

In some embodiments of the present application, the index parameter combination obtaining module 303 is specifically configured to:

In some embodiments of the present application, the evaluation result obtaining module 305 is specifically configured to:

In some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index A3 includes a comprehensive evaluation index, a primary effect evaluation index U, a secondary effect evaluation index, and a tertiary effect evaluation index, where the comprehensive evaluation index is a comprehensive evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, each index in the primary effect evaluation index U correspondingly includes a plurality of the secondary effect evaluation indexes, and each index in the secondary effect evaluation index correspondingly includes a plurality of the tertiary effect evaluation indexes.

In some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, when calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameter of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of spatiotemporal constraint index parameter combinations, is configured to:

and calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U.

In some embodiments of the present application, the co-ordinated development conditions index A1 comprises raw coal bed gas content

Coal face gas content

Coal face advancing speedV _sc Average coal thickness of coal seamhLength of coal faceLDensity of coal ρ, ground well arrangement densityρ _gh And the hole drilling amount per ton of coal gas of the coal seam mined on the coal mining working faceρ _kt-yc Coal face stoping roadway arrangement modem _hc ；

The space-time constraint condition index A2 comprises the coal face extraction timeT _sc1 Length of production from surface wellT _gh2 Duration of succession phase for conversion from planning zone to development zoneT _gh-kt Pre-pumping standard-reaching time of extraction areaT _kt2 Time length of succession phase for switching from development area to production areaT _kt-sc ；

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ (ii) a The coal mining system has comprehensive benefits U ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which respectively represent coal mining resource benefits E ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 secondary effect evaluation indexes which are respectively gas production resource benefits E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ (ii) a The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas production to coal productionQW(ii) a The coal mining safety benefit E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Ton coal at beginning of production areaGas contentC _sc (ii) a The gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt Production area coal bed gas exploitation amountQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ(ii) a The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region duration development area proportionn _kt Three zones long production zone ration _sc Length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of three gas production volumesQGH。

In some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, when performing a normalization process on the calculated actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index to obtain an evaluation index of the three-level effect evaluation index, is configured to:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the indexes have negative benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data which is subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following second formula:

wherein:

In some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, when calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index and the corresponding weight value, is configured to:

wherein:

E _j denotes the firstjThe evaluation index of the item secondary effect evaluation index,j =1，2…m；

X _i is shown asiEvaluation index of tertiary effect of item.

In some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, when calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index, is configured to:

wherein:

E _j is shown asjThe evaluation index of the item secondary effect,j =1，2…m。

in some embodiments of the present application, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, when calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, is configured to:

wherein:

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

In some embodiments of the present application, the index parameter combination obtaining module 303 is specifically configured to, when a plurality of different sets of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations are formed based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discrete values of each discretized index parameter expected interval:

According to the intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation device for the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme, the expected interval of the time-space constraint condition index can be determined according to the coordinated development condition of the target mine, values are taken for different intervals, a plurality of groups of coal and coal bed gas coordinated development schemes are formed, the multi-level effect evaluation index for coal and coal bed gas coordinated development quantification is established, the coordinated development effects of different schemes are pre-evaluated to obtain a plurality of evaluation results, the plurality of evaluation results are contrastively analyzed, the intelligent auxiliary decision is realized, and therefore the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development efficiency is improved. In addition, by establishing the optimal development mode as a target solution and realizing the optimized decision-making process of the coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme solved by a computer programming language, the decision-making process realizes intellectualization and automation by a computer, and the method has the advantages of simple use, high accuracy and small manual interference, and reduces the difficulty in coal and coal bed gas coordinated development and popularization.

According to an embodiment of the present application, an electronic device and a readable storage medium are also provided.

Fig. 4 is a block diagram of an electronic device of a method for intelligent aid decision evaluation of a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme according to an embodiment of the present application. Electronic devices are intended to represent various forms of digital computers, such as laptops, desktops, workstations, personal digital assistants, servers, blade servers, mainframes, and other appropriate computers. The electronic device may also represent various forms of mobile devices, such as personal digital processing, cellular phones, smart phones, wearable devices, and other similar computing devices. The components shown herein, their connections and relationships, and their functions, are meant to be examples only, and are not meant to limit implementations of the present application that are described and/or claimed herein.

As shown in fig. 4, the electronic apparatus includes: one or more processors 401, memory 402, and interfaces for connecting the various components, including high-speed interfaces and low-speed interfaces. The various components are interconnected using different buses and may be mounted on a common motherboard or in other manners as desired. The processor may process instructions for execution within the electronic device, including instructions stored in or on the memory to display graphical information of a GUI on an external input/output apparatus (such as a display device coupled to the interface). In other embodiments, multiple processors and/or multiple buses may be used, along with multiple memories and multiple memories, as desired. Also, multiple electronic devices may be connected, with each device providing portions of the necessary operations (e.g., as a server array, a group of blade servers, or a multi-processor system). In fig. 4, one processor 401 is taken as an example.

Memory 402 is a non-transitory computer readable storage medium as provided herein. Wherein the memory stores instructions executable by the at least one processor to cause the at least one processor to perform the method for intelligent aid decision-making evaluation of coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme provided herein. A non-transitory computer readable storage medium of the present application stores computer instructions for causing a computer to perform the method of intelligent aid decision-making evaluation of a coal and coal bed gas harmonized development scheme provided herein.

The memory 402 is a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium, and can be used to store non-transitory software programs, non-transitory computer-executable programs, and modules, such as program instructions/modules corresponding to the method for intelligent aid decision evaluation of coal and coalbed methane harmonization development scheme in the embodiment of the present application (for example, the index system determination module 301, the constraint index interval acquisition module 302, the index parameter combination acquisition module 303, the effect evaluation index calculation module 304, and the evaluation result acquisition module 305 shown in fig. 3). The processor 401 executes the non-transitory software programs, instructions and modules stored in the memory 402 to execute various functional applications and data processing of the server, that is, to implement the method for intelligent aided decision evaluation of the coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme in the above method embodiment.

The memory 402 may include a storage program area and a storage data area, wherein the storage program area may store an operating system, an application program required for at least one function; the storage data area can store data created according to the use of electronic equipment for intelligent auxiliary decision evaluation of the coal and coal bed gas coordination development scheme and the like. Further, the memory 402 may include high speed random access memory, and may also include non-transitory memory, such as at least one magnetic disk storage device, flash memory device, or other non-transitory solid state storage device. In some embodiments, the memory 402 may optionally include memory remotely located from the processor 401, and such remote memory may be connected over a network to an electronic device for intelligent aid decision-making evaluation of coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scenarios. Examples of such networks include, but are not limited to, the internet, intranets, local area networks, mobile communication networks, and combinations thereof.

The electronic device of the method for intelligent assistant decision evaluation of coal and coal bed gas coordinated development scheme further comprises: an input device 403 and an output device 404. The processor 401, memory 402, input device 403, and output device 404 may be connected by a bus or other means, as exemplified by the bus connection in fig. 4.

The input device 403 may receive input numeric or character information and generate key signal inputs related to user settings and function controls of the electronic device for intelligent aid decision-making evaluation of coal and coal bed methane coordinated development plans, such as a touch screen, a keypad, a mouse, a track pad, a touch pad, a pointer, one or more mouse buttons, a track ball, a joystick, and the like. The output devices 404 may include a display device, auxiliary lighting devices (e.g., LEDs), and haptic feedback devices (e.g., vibrating motors), among others. The display device may include, but is not limited to, a Liquid Crystal Display (LCD), a Light Emitting Diode (LED) display, and a plasma display. In some implementations, the display device can be a touch screen.

Various implementations of the systems and techniques described here can be realized in digital electronic circuitry, integrated circuitry, application specific ASICs (application specific integrated circuits), computer hardware, firmware, software, and/or combinations thereof. These various embodiments may include: implemented in one or more computer programs that are executable and/or interpretable on a programmable system including at least one programmable processor, which may be special or general purpose, receiving data and instructions from, and transmitting data and instructions to, a storage system, at least one input device, and at least one output device.

These computer programs (also known as programs, software applications, or code) include machine instructions for a programmable processor, and may be implemented using high-level procedural and/or object-oriented programming languages, and/or assembly/machine languages. As used herein, the terms "machine-readable medium" and "computer-readable medium" refer to any computer program product, apparatus, and/or device (e.g., magnetic discs, optical disks, memory, programmable Logic Devices (PLDs)) used to provide machine instructions and/or data to a programmable processor, including a machine-readable medium that receives machine instructions as a machine-readable signal. The term "machine-readable signal" refers to any signal used to provide machine instructions and/or data to a programmable processor.

To provide for interaction with a user, the systems and techniques described here can be implemented on a computer having: a display device (e.g., a CRT (cathode ray tube) or LCD (liquid crystal display) monitor) for displaying information to a user; and a keyboard and a pointing device (e.g., a mouse or a trackball) by which a user can provide input to the computer. Other kinds of devices may also be used to provide for interaction with a user; for example, feedback provided to the user can be any form of sensory feedback (e.g., visual feedback, auditory feedback, or tactile feedback); and input from the user can be received in any form, including acoustic, speech, or tactile input.

The systems and techniques described here can be implemented in a computing system that includes a back-end component (e.g., as a data server), or that includes a middleware component (e.g., an application server), or that includes a front-end component (e.g., a user computer having a graphical user interface or a web browser through which a user can interact with an implementation of the systems and techniques described here), or any combination of such back-end, middleware, or front-end components. The components of the system can be interconnected by any form or medium of digital data communication (e.g., a communication network). Examples of communication networks include: local Area Networks (LANs), wide Area Networks (WANs), the internet, and blockchain networks.

The computer system may include clients and servers. A client and server are generally remote from each other and typically interact through a communication network. The relationship of client and server arises by virtue of computer programs running on the respective computers and having a client-server relationship to each other.

In an exemplary embodiment, a computer program product is also provided, in which instructions, when executed by a processor of an electronic device, enable the electronic device to perform the above-described method.

Other embodiments of the present application will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice of the invention disclosed herein. This application is intended to cover any variations, uses, or adaptations of the invention following, in general, the principles of the application and including such departures from the present disclosure as come within known or customary practice within the art to which the invention pertains. It is intended that the specification and examples be considered as exemplary only.

It will be understood that the present application is not limited to the precise arrangements described above and shown in the drawings and that various modifications and changes may be made without departing from the scope thereof. The scope of the application is limited only by the appended claims.

Claims

1. An intelligent aid decision evaluation method for a coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme is characterized by comprising the following steps:

calculating a comprehensive evaluation index of a multi-level evaluation index of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each group of the space-time constraint condition index parameter combination; until a plurality of comprehensive evaluation indexes corresponding to the plurality of different time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations are obtained;

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the obtaining a plurality of different sets of spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations based on the index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to the indexes of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index A2 comprises:

3. The method of claim 1, wherein obtaining an optimal evaluation result based on the plurality of composite evaluation indices comprises:

4. The method according to claim 1, wherein the effect evaluation index A3 comprises a comprehensive evaluation index, a primary effect evaluation index U, a secondary effect evaluation index and a tertiary effect evaluation index, the comprehensive evaluation index is a comprehensive evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, each index in the primary effect evaluation index U correspondingly comprises a plurality of the secondary effect evaluation indexes, and each index in the secondary effect evaluation index correspondingly comprises a plurality of the tertiary effect evaluation indexes.

5. The method according to claim 4, wherein the calculating of the comprehensive evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameters of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations comprises:

6. The method of claim 4, wherein the coordinated development condition index A1 comprises raw coal bed methane content

Coal face gas content

Coal face advancing speedV _sc Average coal thickness of coal seamhLength of coal faceLDensity of coal ρ, ground well arrangement densityρ _gh And the hole drilling amount per ton of coal gas of the coal seam mined on the coal mining working faceρ _kt-yc Coal face mining roadway arrangement modem _hc ；

The space-time constraint condition index A ₂ Including coal face extraction timeT _sc1 Length of production from surface wellT _gh2 Duration of succession phase for conversion from planning zone to development zoneT _gh-kt Pre-pumping standard-reaching time of extraction areaT _kt2 Time length of succession phase for switching from development area to production areaT _kt-sc ；

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ (ii) a The coal mining system has comprehensive benefits U ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which are respectively coal mining resource benefits E ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 secondary effect evaluation indexes which are respectively gas production resource benefits E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ (ii) a The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas mining amount to coal mining amountQW(ii) a Safety benefit of coal mining E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Gas content per ton coal at the beginning of production areaC _sc (ii) a The gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt Production area coal bed gas exploitation amountQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ(ii) a The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region long development area ration _kt Three zones long production zone ration _sc Length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of gas production volume of three areasQGH。

7. The method according to claim 5, wherein the normalizing the calculated actual value of the index of the tertiary effect evaluation index to obtain the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index comprises:

indexes among the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the indexes have positive benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to a first formula as follows:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the indexes have negative benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to the following second formula:

wherein:

a _i denotes the firstiThe lower limit value of the critical value of the item three-level effect evaluation index can be an unallowable value according to a relevant standard, an evaluation object mean value or a sample measured value;

8. The method of claim 5, wherein calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation indicator based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation indicator and the corresponding weight value comprises:

wherein:

E _j is shown asjThe evaluation index of the item secondary effect evaluation index,j =1，2…m；

X _i is shown asiEvaluation index of the third-level effect.

9. The method according to claim 5, wherein the calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index comprises:

wherein:

U _k denotes the firstkThe evaluation index of the first-level effect evaluation index,k =1，2；

10. the method according to claim 5, wherein the calculating of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U comprises:

wherein:

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

wherein:α、bexpressed as a preset coefficient, the coal mining and the coal bed gas development are considered to be equally importantα=b=0.5。

11. The method of claim 2, wherein the forming a plurality of different spatio-temporal constraint index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expectation intervals and a plurality of discretized values of each of the discretized index parameter expectation intervals comprises:

12. An intelligent aid decision evaluation device for coal and coalbed methane coordinated development scheme is characterized by comprising:

the system comprises an index system determining module, a coal and coal bed gas coordinated development mode optimization decision index system and a result evaluation module, wherein the index system comprises a coordinated development condition index A1, a space-time constraint condition index A2 and an effect evaluation index A3;

an index parameter combination obtaining module, configured to obtain multiple different sets of time-space constraint condition index parameter combinations based on index parameter expectation intervals corresponding to respective multiple indexes of the time-space constraint condition index A2;

13. The apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the index parameter combination obtaining module is specifically configured to:

14. The apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the evaluation result obtaining module is specifically configured to:

15. The apparatus according to claim 12, wherein the effect evaluation index A3 comprises a comprehensive evaluation index, a primary effect evaluation index U, a secondary effect evaluation index and a tertiary effect evaluation index, the comprehensive evaluation index is a comprehensive evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, each index of the primary effect evaluation index U correspondingly comprises a plurality of the secondary effect evaluation indexes, and each index of the secondary effect evaluation index correspondingly comprises a plurality of the tertiary effect evaluation indexes.

16. The apparatus according to claim 15, wherein the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the composite evaluation index of the multi-level evaluation index parameters of the effect evaluation index A3 based on each set of the spatio-temporal constraint condition index parameter combinations, is configured to:

standardizing the index actual value of the three-level effect evaluation index to obtain an evaluation index of the three-level effect evaluation index, and determining a weight value of the three-level effect evaluation index;

17. The device of claim 15Wherein the index of the coordinated development conditions A1 includes the original coal bed gas content

Coal face gas content

The primary effect evaluation index U comprises comprehensive benefits U of the coal mining system ₁ And gas production system comprehensive benefit U ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₁ Correspondingly setting 2 second-level evaluation indexes which respectively represent coal mining resource benefits E ₁ Coal mining safety benefit E ₂ (ii) a Comprehensive benefit U of coal mining system ₂ Correspondingly setting 2 secondary effect evaluation indexes which are respectively gas production resource benefits E ₃ Safety benefits of gas production E ₄ (ii) a The coal mining resource benefit E ₁ Comprises 2 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely coal mining amountMscRatio of coal bed gas mining amount to coal mining amountQW(ii) a Safety benefit of coal mining E ₂ Comprises 3 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the reduction rate of the gas content in the planning areaC _gh Gas content at the beginning of development areaC _kt 、Production area start timeGas content per ton coalC _sc (ii) a The gas production resource benefit E ₃ Comprises 4 three-level effect evaluation indexes which are respectively the coal bed gas exploitation amount of a planning areaQ _gh Coal bed gas exploitation amount of exploitation areaQ _kt And the coal bed gas exploitation amount of the production areaQ _sc、 Coal bed gas productionQ(ii) a The gas production safety benefit E ₄ Comprises 5 three-level effect evaluation indexes, namely a planning region occupation ratio n in three regions _gh Three-region duration development area proportionn _kt Three zones long production zone ration _sc Length and ratio of coal bed gas production to three zonesQTGas production volume ratio of planning area of gas production volume of three areasQGH。

18. The apparatus according to claim 16, wherein the effect evaluation index calculation module, when normalizing the calculated actual index value of the tertiary effect evaluation index to obtain the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation index, is configured to:

indexes in the three-level effect evaluation indexesx _i When the indexes have positive benefits on the coordinated development of coal and coal bed gasx _i Evaluation index of the individual index of (1)X _i The data subjected to the standardization processing for the actual value of the index is calculated according to a first formula as follows:

wherein:

19. The apparatus of claim 16, wherein the effect evaluation indicator calculation module, when calculating the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation indicator based on the evaluation index of the tertiary effect evaluation indicator and the corresponding weight value, is configured to:

wherein:

X _i is shown asiEvaluation index of the third-level effect.

20. The apparatus according to claim 16, wherein the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U based on the evaluation index of the secondary effect evaluation index, is configured to:

wherein:

21. the apparatus according to claim 16, wherein the effect evaluation index calculation module, when calculating the comprehensive evaluation index of the comprehensive evaluation index based on the evaluation index of the primary effect evaluation index U, is configured to:

wherein:

Dindicating coal and coal seamComprehensive evaluation index of qi coordination development level;

wherein,T=αU ₁ +bU ₂ ；

22. The apparatus of claim 13, wherein the index parameter combination obtaining module is configured to combine a plurality of different sets of spatiotemporal constraint index parameter combinations based on the plurality of discretized index parameter expected intervals and a plurality of discrete values of each of the discretized index parameter expected intervals; for:

23. An electronic device, comprising:

at least one processor; and

a memory communicatively coupled to the at least one processor; wherein,

the memory stores instructions executable by the at least one processor to cause the at least one processor to perform the method for intelligent aid decision evaluation of coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scheme of any of claims 1 to 11.

24. A non-transitory computer readable storage medium storing computer instructions for causing a computer to perform the intelligent aid decision-making evaluation method for a coal and coal bed methane coordinated development scenario of any one of claims 1 to 11.

25. A computer program product comprising a computer program, characterized in that the computer program realizes the steps of the method of any one of claims 1 to 11 when executed by a processor.