CN112883495B - Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof - Google Patents

Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN112883495B
CN112883495B CN202110291706.8A CN202110291706A CN112883495B CN 112883495 B CN112883495 B CN 112883495B CN 202110291706 A CN202110291706 A CN 202110291706A CN 112883495 B CN112883495 B CN 112883495B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
satellite
bus
vector
incident wave
wave
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Active
Application number
CN202110291706.8A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN112883495A (en
Inventor
范才智
李春雷
罗青
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
National University of Defense Technology
Original Assignee
National University of Defense Technology
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by National University of Defense Technology filed Critical National University of Defense Technology
Priority to CN202110291706.8A priority Critical patent/CN112883495B/en
Publication of CN112883495A publication Critical patent/CN112883495A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN112883495B publication Critical patent/CN112883495B/en
Active legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06FELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING
    • G06F30/00Computer-aided design [CAD]
    • G06F30/10Geometric CAD
    • G06F30/15Vehicle, aircraft or watercraft design
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06FELECTRIC DIGITAL DATA PROCESSING
    • G06F30/00Computer-aided design [CAD]
    • G06F30/20Design optimisation, verification or simulation

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Theoretical Computer Science (AREA)
  • Geometry (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Evolutionary Computation (AREA)
  • General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Computer Hardware Design (AREA)
  • Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
  • Aviation & Aerospace Engineering (AREA)
  • Computational Mathematics (AREA)
  • Mathematical Analysis (AREA)
  • Mathematical Optimization (AREA)
  • Pure & Applied Mathematics (AREA)
  • Aerials With Secondary Devices (AREA)

Abstract

The invention discloses a directional broadband high-stealth satellite and a top end shape design method thereof
Figure DDA0002982877990000011
Forming gradient difference, and the projection areas of surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, the satellite body is shaped as a rotating body, and the generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotating body is that z is-a rho 2 + c, z is a bus variable and represents the z-axis coordinate of the point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, and ρ is a bus variable and represents the distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis. The invention aims to solve the problems that the stealth effect of the existing satellite stealth appearance in the key direction is insufficient, and the echo wave crest is too close to the tip direction, so that the high-strength echo exists in the key threat area and the satellite position is easily exposed, and the related satellite top appearance has the advantage of good stealth effect.

Description

Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof
Technical Field
The invention relates to a spacecraft structure design technology, in particular to a satellite top end shape design method with directional broadband and high stealth performance and a satellite.
Background
At present, the satellite technology is developed rapidly, and plays an important role in the aspects of communication, navigation, positioning, meteorological monitoring and the like. In modern war, the satellite is also responsible for key tasks such as information communication, battlefield monitoring, fire early warning, etc. However, the satellite system has the characteristics of fixed orbit and load signal release, is easy to be found and tracked by detection equipment, and further attacked by various anti-satellite weapons, and is difficult to normally function in wartime. Aiming at the threat faced by the satellite, in order to guarantee the survival capability of the satellite in the space, the satellite needs to be invisibly designed. At present, the design of the stealth of the satellite is mainly started from two aspects, namely the stealth of materials and the stealth of appearance. The stealth material refers to that special materials with wave absorption performance, such as ferrite materials and nano materials, are used on the outer surface of the satellite to absorb electromagnetic waves received by the surface of the satellite and reduce echoes. The appearance stealth means that the direction of a scattered electromagnetic wave crest is controlled through appearance design, so that the echo intensity is reduced, and the purpose of electromagnetic stealth is achieved. The material stealth and the appearance stealth are mutually matched, and the stealth performance of the satellite is improved together.
In the aspect of the appearance stealth technology, a key threat direction is firstly determined when a stealth satellite is designed. When a satellite is in a stealth state, the top (direction with better stealth performance) of the satellite is generally required to face a key threat direction. Therefore, when the stealth appearance of the satellite is designed, the appearance design of the top end of the satellite is important. The top of the stealth satellite is generally designed into a conical shape, a pyramid shape, an ellipsoid shape and the like. The top ends of the cone and the pyramid can obviously reduce the electromagnetic echo in the direction of the cone top, and the ellipsoidal shape can effectively reduce the size of the electromagnetic echo in a large range of directions.
However, if the objective of directional stealth is to provide stealth, the shapes of stealth satellites, such as conical, pyramidal and ellipsoidal shapes, have their own disadvantages. The conical shape and the pyramid shape have good hiding effect in the direction of the pointed top, but when the volume is larger, larger echo still exists in the direction of the pointed top. And echo wave crests exist in some directions close to the spires, so that the positions of the satellites are easily exposed, and the stealth of the satellites is not facilitated. Although the ellipsoid shape has no prominent echo maximum value in each direction, the stealth direction has no focus and pertinence, and the stealth capability is not correspondingly improved for the focus threat direction. In the application of stealth satellites, the top end appearance has room for improvement.
Disclosure of Invention
The technical problems to be solved by the invention are as follows: the invention aims to solve the problems that the stealth effect of the existing stealth appearance in the key direction is insufficient, and the echo wave crest is too close to the spire direction, so that a high-strength echo exists in a key threat area and the position of a satellite is easily exposed, and the related satellite top appearance has the advantage of good stealth effect.
In order to solve the technical problems, the technical scheme adopted by the invention is as follows:
a directional broadband satellite with high stealth performance comprises a satellite body, wherein the phase term of the top outline surface element of the satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000021
Forming gradient difference, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, wherein j is an imaginary number unit,
Figure BDA0002982877970000022
is a wave vector, and the wave vector is,
Figure BDA0002982877970000023
is the satellite surface point position vector.
Optionally, the upper part of the satellite body is a parabolic tip, and the lower part of the satellite body is an ellipsoidal base.
Optionally, the shape of the satellite body is a rotating body, and the function expression of the generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotating body is as follows:
z=-aρ 2 +c 0≤ρ≤R (1)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis, and R is a maximum radius of the rotating body.
In addition, the invention also provides a top end shape design method of the satellite with the directional broadband and the high stealth performance, which comprises the following steps:
1) obtaining a relational function expression of the current and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current according to a Maxwell equation; obtaining the surface equivalent current by using the phase estimation condition of the surface equivalent current under the high-frequency condition and the approximate condition of the projection area such as the current
Figure BDA0002982877970000024
The function approximation expression of (a);
2) equivalent current of surface
Figure BDA0002982877970000025
Substituting the function approximate expression into a relation function expression of the current and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current, and simplifying to obtain the position vector of any scattering target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000026
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000027
The function of (a) expresses:
Figure BDA0002982877970000028
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure BDA0002982877970000029
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000210
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure BDA00029828779700000211
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA00029828779700000212
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane is k, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000213
for Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface;
3) according to the surface equivalent current
Figure BDA00029828779700000214
Function approximation expression of (1) determining an arbitrary dispersionPosition vector of shooting target point
Figure BDA00029828779700000215
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA00029828779700000216
Projected area d tau in incident wave direction from surface element d tau projection And the phase term of the surface element d tau
Figure BDA00029828779700000217
Determining, thereby determining, a phase term for a top surface element of the satellite body
Figure BDA00029828779700000218
Forming gradient difference, and when the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA00029828779700000219
And the minimum is obtained, so that the condition that the top end appearance of the satellite body meets the requirement of directional broadband high stealth performance is as follows: phase term of top profile surface element of satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000031
Gradient difference is formed, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal.
Optionally, the relational function expression of the current obtained in step 1) and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current is as follows:
Figure BDA0002982877970000032
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure BDA0002982877970000033
as a scattering target point position vector
Figure BDA0002982877970000034
The intensity of the echo electric field at the position corresponding to the target point, j is an imaginary unit, omega is an angular frequency, mu is medium permeability, k is an incident wave vector, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is an incident wave wavelength,
Figure BDA0002982877970000035
in order to be the Nabla operator, the operation,
Figure BDA0002982877970000036
is the equivalent current of the surface,
Figure BDA0002982877970000037
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA0002982877970000038
is the satellite surface point position vector, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
Optionally, the surface equivalent current obtained in step 1)
Figure BDA0002982877970000039
The approximate function expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA00029828779700000310
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure BDA00029828779700000311
for the current generated by incident waves perpendicularly impinging on a plane, d τ projection Is the projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction, d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface, j is an imaginary unit,
Figure BDA00029828779700000312
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000313
is the satellite surface point position vector.
Optionally, the echo electric field intensity obtained in step 2)
Figure BDA00029828779700000314
The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA00029828779700000315
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure BDA00029828779700000316
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000317
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure BDA00029828779700000318
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA00029828779700000319
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane is k, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000320
for Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
Optionally, the simplification in step 2) refers to considering a distance term under far-field conditions
Figure BDA00029828779700000321
The distance term under far field condition is not greatly changed
Figure BDA00029828779700000322
Regarded as constant, thereby the echo electric field strength
Figure BDA00029828779700000323
Further reducing the function expression of (A) to obtain an arbitrary scattering target point position vector shown in the formula (2)
Figure BDA00029828779700000325
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA00029828779700000324
Is used for the functional expression of (1).
Optionally, step 3) is followed by a step of determining a generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotator if the satellite body is shaped as the rotator:
s1) establishing a rectangular coordinate system by taking the satellite top end direction as the z axis, taking the key direction of the satellite facing the greatest threat as the top end direction to emit the electromagnetic wave, and then taking the wave vector
Figure BDA0002982877970000041
Wherein
Figure BDA0002982877970000042
The unit vector is oriented to the positive direction of the z axis, and the influence of the dark surface of the surface which cannot be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave on the intensity of the electric field echo is small, so that the equiphase area distribution of the top end of the satellite which is taken as the bright surface of the satellite at the moment is obtained only by considering the bright surface of the surface which can be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave at the moment; planes perpendicular to the z-axis are made on the z-axis at prescribed intervals dz, respectively, and the planes divide the satellite surface into a plurality of annular regions, and when the intervals dz are sufficiently small, the currents in the i-th annular region are considered to have a common phase value
Figure BDA0002982877970000043
S2) selecting two adjacent annular regions, and respectively calculating to obtain corresponding projection areas tau according to the geometric relationship 1 And τ 2
S3) calculating the area difference of the two adjacent selected annular regions:
τ 12 =(2ρ 2 21 23 2 )π (6)
s4) describing the shape of the rotator bus of the satellite profile by a quadratic polynomial expressed by the following formula;
z=-aρ 2 +bρ+c (7)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, and ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis; determining (p) at the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Equations at three points;
s5) since the annular region is cut at equal intervals, there are:
dz=z 2 -z 1 =z 3 -z 2 (8)
the (rho) on the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Substituting the equations at the three points to obtain:
Figure BDA0002982877970000044
when b is 0, i.e. z is-a ρ 2 + c, the difference of the projected areas of two adjacent annular regions is:
τ 12 =2ρ 2 23 21 2 =0 (10)
s6) the satellite adopts a quadratic polynomial z ═ a ρ since the two adjacent annular regions are arbitrarily obtained 2 When + c is the shape of the rotator of the bus, the projection areas of all the phase intervals are equal, so that the stealth performance of the satellite in the key direction can be greatly improved by the shape, and the functional expression of the bus control equation of the rotator of the satellite is determined as shown in the formula (1).
Optionally, calculating a corresponding cast in step S2)Shadow area tau 1 And τ 2 The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA0002982877970000051
in the above formula, τ 1 Denotes the projected area, τ, of the 1 st of the two adjacent annular regions 2 Represents the projected area, rho, of the 2 nd annular region of two adjacent annular regions 1 Is the radius of the edge circle in the 1 st annular region, p 2 The outer edge radius of the 1 st annular region is equal to the inner edge radius, rho, of the 2 nd annular region 3 The radius of the outer edge circle of the 2 nd annular region.
Optionally, step S4) determines (ρ) at the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) The functional expression of the equation at three points is:
Figure BDA0002982877970000052
in the above formula, z 1 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 1 st annular region, z 2 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 2 nd annular region, z 3 Is the z coordinate of the outer edge of the 2 nd annular region.
Compared with the prior art, the invention has the following advantages: the invention provides a phase term of a surface element of the top end appearance of a satellite body aiming at the top end appearance of the satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000053
Form the gradient poor, and be in the characteristic that the surface element of same phase equals at the projection area of incident wave direction, through above-mentioned characteristic, can solve the stealthy not enough problem of effect of the key direction of current satellite stealth appearance to and the echo crest is too close to the pinnacle direction, lead to having the echo of heavy intensity in the key threat zone, expose the problem of satellite position easily, the satellite top appearance that relates to has stealthy effectual advantage.
Drawings
Fig. 1 is a schematic diagram of a satellite body side view equiphase area division in the embodiment of the present invention.
Fig. 2 is a schematic diagram of the partition of the satellite body into the top view equal phase regions according to the embodiment of the present invention.
Fig. 3 is a schematic view of a bus shape and a curve of a satellite body according to an embodiment of the invention.
Fig. 4 shows simulation results of RCS for directions of tops of parabolic satellites with different heights according to an embodiment of the present invention.
Fig. 5 shows the RCS simulation results of different directions for the same size cone and parabola satellites according to the embodiment of the invention.
Fig. 6 shows the RCS simulation results of different frequencies and tip directions of the same-sized cone and parabola satellites according to the embodiment of the invention.
Fig. 7 shows the results of RCS simulation in different directions for an example of a parabolic satellite tip profile according to an embodiment of the present invention.
Detailed Description
The embodiment provides a directional broadband satellite with high stealth performance, which comprises a satellite body, and a phase term of a surface element on the top outline of the satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000054
Forming gradient difference, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, wherein j is an imaginary number unit,
Figure BDA0002982877970000055
the wave vector is the wave vector,
Figure BDA0002982877970000056
is the satellite surface point position vector. The present embodiment provides a phase term of a surface element of the top end profile of the satellite body for the top end profile of the satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000061
The characteristics that the gradient difference is formed and the projected areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal are formed, and the resolution is possible by the characteristicsThe problem of the stealthy effect of the key direction of stealthy appearance of current satellite is not enough to and the echo crest is too close to the pinnacle direction, leads to having the echo of high strength in the key threat region, exposes the satellite position easily is solved, the top appearance of satellite that relates to has the effectual advantage of stealthy. With reference to figures 1 and 2 of the drawings,
Figure BDA0002982877970000062
As vector of incident wave, p i Is an arbitrary ith point (x) i ,y i ) The distance to the z-axis is determined by making planes perpendicular to the z-axis at intervals dz, the planes dividing the satellite surface into a plurality of annular regions, and when dz is sufficiently small, the currents in any ith annular region have a common phase value
Figure BDA0002982877970000063
τ i Phase term representing projected area of i-th annular region and top surface element of satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000064
Gradient difference is formed, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal.
As an alternative embodiment, the satellite body in this embodiment has a parabolic tip at the upper portion and an ellipsoidal base at the lower portion, as shown in fig. 3.
In order to further improve the stealth effect of the satellite, in this embodiment, the shape of the satellite body is a rotator, and the function expression of the generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotator is as follows:
z=-aρ 2 +c 0≤ρ≤R (1)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis, and R is a maximum radius of a rotator. In an alternative embodiment, in this embodiment, the bus control parameter a is 1/0.16, the bus control parameter c is 0.4, and the maximum radius R of the rotating body is 0.4 m.
Referring to fig. 3, the function expression of the bus control equation of the ellipsoidal base at the lower part of the rotating body in this embodiment is:
Figure BDA0002982877970000065
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, d and b are bus control parameters, ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis, and R is a maximum radius of the rotating body.
Since the pyramid and cone have similar scattering properties, a cone apex profile of the same size, the same base and a parabolic apex are used as a comparison. The scattering characteristics of the satellite are analyzed, and the parabolic stealth satellite has the following advantages:
(1) the parabolic satellites with different parameters have good stealth characteristics, the appearance of the top parabola is kept, the height value of the satellite is changed between 0.3 meter and 1.1 meter, the RCS value of the top direction of the satellite under 4GHz incident wave frequency is analyzed in a simulation mode, and the RCS value is compared with a cylinder with the same cross section area and height, so that data shown in the figure 4 can be obtained.
(2) Analysis shows that as long as the satellite shape is designed into a parabolic shape, compared with a cylindrical shape without stealth design, the electromagnetic echo reduction effect of at least 25db can be achieved in the top end direction of the satellite, and the electromagnetic stealth effect is obvious.
(3) The position of the echo peak is more deviated from the apical direction than the conical shape.
At the incident wave frequency of 8GHz, the scattering characteristics of the conical and parabolic satellites with the same size are simulated and analyzed. As shown in fig. 5, the single station RCS peak of the parabolic stealth satellite profile is at a position 57 degrees off the vertex. The single station RCS peak of the cone-top satellite is at 45 degrees. The position of the parabola outline wave crest is farther away from the top end direction, so that the parabola outline wave crest is more difficult to be discovered by detection equipment in a key threat angle, and the parabola outline wave crest is more suitable for the design of the invisible satellite outline.
(4) The tip direction RCS values are lower at different frequencies relative to the conical shape.
The results of simulation tests on the RCS values in the tip direction of the parabolic satellite and the conical tip satellite having the same height and the cross-sectional area in the tip direction are shown in fig. 6, which are performed at different incident wave frequencies. The parabolic satellites have lower tip direction RCS values at most frequencies, and other frequencies are substantially equal to those of the cone-tipped satellites. The parabolic satellite vertices make better use of the destructive interference of surface currents, and have better stealth effects than the conical shape at most frequencies.
In this embodiment, the distribution of single station RCS at the top of a parabolic satellite is shown in fig. 7. As is clear from FIG. 7, when the radius of the cross-sectional circle is 0.4m, the RCS value in the distal direction is-3 dBsm or less under irradiation with an incident wave having a frequency of 4GHz, and the excellent stealth performance is obtained. The main peak of the RCS of a single station is at 74 degrees, the RCS values are all below-3 dBsm within an angle of 0-60 degrees, the top end of the parabolic satellite has a large stealth angle, and the method is suitable for satellite stealth design.
The embodiment further provides a method for designing a top end shape of the directional broadband high stealth satellite, which includes:
1) obtaining a relation function expression of the current and the strength of the electric field of the echo excited by the current according to a Maxwell equation; obtaining the surface equivalent current by using the phase estimation condition of the surface equivalent current under the high-frequency condition and the approximate condition of the projection area such as the current
Figure BDA0002982877970000071
A function approximation expression of (a);
2) equivalent current of plane
Figure BDA0002982877970000072
Substituting the function approximate expression into a relation function expression of the current and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current, and simplifying to obtain the position vector of any scattering target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000073
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000074
The function of (a) expresses:
Figure BDA0002982877970000075
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure BDA0002982877970000076
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA0002982877970000077
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure BDA0002982877970000078
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA0002982877970000079
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000710
for Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface;
3) according to the surface equivalent current
Figure BDA00029828779700000711
Determining the position vector of any scattering target point by using the function approximation expression
Figure BDA00029828779700000712
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000081
Projected area d tau in incident wave direction from surface element d tau projection And the phase term of the surface element d tau
Figure BDA0002982877970000082
Determining, thereby determining, a phase term for a top surface element of the satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000083
Forming gradient difference, and when the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000084
And the minimum is obtained, so that the condition that the top end appearance of the satellite body meets the requirement of directional broadband high stealth performance is as follows: phase term of top profile surface element of satellite body
Figure BDA0002982877970000085
Gradient difference is formed, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal.
In this embodiment, the relational function expression of the current obtained in step 1) and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current is as follows:
Figure BDA0002982877970000086
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure BDA0002982877970000087
as a scattering target point position vector
Figure BDA0002982877970000088
The intensity of the echo electric field at the position corresponding to the target point, j is an imaginary unit, omega is an angular frequency, mu is medium permeability, k is an incident wave vector, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is an incident wave wavelength,
Figure BDA0002982877970000089
in order to be the Nabla operator, the operation,
Figure BDA00029828779700000810
is the equivalent current of the surface,
Figure BDA00029828779700000811
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA00029828779700000812
Is the position vector of the satellite surface point, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
In this example, the surface equivalent current obtained in step 1) was obtained
Figure BDA00029828779700000813
The approximate function expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA00029828779700000814
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure BDA00029828779700000815
for the current generated by incident waves perpendicularly impinging on a plane, d τ projection Is the projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction, d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface, j is an imaginary unit,
Figure BDA00029828779700000816
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000817
is the satellite surface point position vector.
In this embodiment, the strength of the echo electric field obtained in step 2)
Figure BDA00029828779700000818
The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA00029828779700000819
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure BDA00029828779700000820
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000821
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure BDA00029828779700000822
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure BDA00029828779700000823
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane is k, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure BDA00029828779700000824
for Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
In this embodiment, the simplification in step 2) refers to considering the distance term under far-field condition
Figure BDA00029828779700000825
The distance term under far field condition is not greatly changed
Figure BDA0002982877970000091
Regarded as constant, thereby measuring the echo electric field strength
Figure BDA0002982877970000092
Further reducing the function expression of (A) to obtain an arbitrary scattering target point position vector shown in the formula (2)
Figure BDA0002982877970000093
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure BDA0002982877970000094
Is used for the functional expression of (1). Therefore, the phase terms of the surface elements of the top end appearance of the satellite body are provided for the top end appearance of the satellite body in the embodiment are finally determined
Figure BDA0002982877970000095
The characteristic that the projection areas of surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal and the design principle of the electromagnetic stealth appearance of the top of the satellite are formed.
According to the design principle, a satellite top end shape can be designed. If the phase of the satellite surface current has gradient difference, the profile of the satellite needs to have depth in the electromagnetic wave irradiation direction, so that a large number of planes vertical to incident electromagnetic waves are avoided. Surface element projection area d tau if different phase value is required projection If the two are equal, the satellite top profile is subjected to parameter analysis aiming at a specific incidence direction. Therefore, in this embodiment, step 3) is followed by the step of determining the generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotator when the satellite body is in the shape of the rotator:
s1) establishing a rectangular coordinate system by taking the satellite top end direction as the z axis, taking the key direction of the satellite facing the greatest threat as the top end direction to emit the electromagnetic wave, and then taking the wave vector
Figure BDA0002982877970000096
Wherein
Figure BDA0002982877970000097
The unit vector is oriented to the positive direction of the z axis, and the influence of the dark surface of the surface which cannot be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave on the intensity of the electric field echo is small, so that the equiphase area distribution of the top end of the satellite which is taken as the bright surface of the satellite at the moment is obtained only by considering the bright surface of the surface which can be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave at the moment; planes perpendicular to the z-axis are made at prescribed intervals dz on the z-axis, respectively, and the planes divide the satellite surface into a plurality of planesAnnular zones, the currents in the i-th annular zone being considered to have a common phase value when the separation dz is sufficiently small
Figure BDA0002982877970000098
In the present embodiment, the distribution of the equiphase region of the satellite top as the satellite bright face at this time is obtained as shown in fig. 1 and 2, where ρ i Is an arbitrary ith point (x) i ,y i ) Distance to z-axis and having:
Figure BDA0002982877970000099
planes perpendicular to the z-axis are made on the z-axis at intervals dz, respectively. The plane divides the satellite surface into a number of annular regions, and when dz is sufficiently small, the currents in the i-th annular region can be considered to have a common phase value
Figure BDA00029828779700000910
Available tau i The projected area of the i-th annular region is shown.
S2) selecting two adjacent annular regions, and respectively calculating to obtain corresponding projection areas tau according to the geometric relationship 1 And τ 2
S3) calculating the area difference of the two adjacent selected annular regions:
τ 12 =(2ρ 2 21 23 2 )π (6)
S4) describing the shape of the rotator bus of the satellite profile by a quadratic polynomial expressed by the following formula;
z=-aρ 2 +bρ+c (7)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, and ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis; determining (p) at the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Equations at three points;
s5) since the annular region is cut at equal intervals, there are:
dz=z 2 -z 1 =z 3 -z 2 (8)
the (rho) on the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Substituting the equations at the three points to obtain:
Figure BDA0002982877970000101
when b is 0, i.e. z is-a ρ 2 + c, the difference of the projected areas of two adjacent annular regions is:
τ 12 =2ρ 2 23 21 2 =0 (10)
s6) the satellite adopts a quadratic polynomial z ═ a ρ since the two adjacent annular regions are arbitrarily obtained 2 When + c is the shape of the rotator of the bus, the projection areas of all the phase intervals are equal, so that the stealth performance of the satellite in the key direction can be greatly improved by the shape, and the functional expression of the bus control equation of the rotator of the satellite is determined as shown in the formula (1).
Due to tau 1 、τ 2 The two equal-phase regions are arbitrarily selected, so when the satellite adopts a rotator shape with a quadratic polynomial shown in formula (1) as a bus, the projection areas of all phase regions are equal, and the appearance can greatly increase the stealth performance of the satellite in the key direction. The satellite with the shape has excellent stealth effect under different frequencies because the phase gradient difference exists even if the frequency of the incident wave changes.
In this embodiment, step S2) calculates the corresponding projection area τ 1 And τ 2 The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure BDA0002982877970000102
in the above formula, τ 1 Denotes the projected area, τ, of the 1 st of the two adjacent annular regions 2 Represents the projected area, rho, of the 2 nd annular region of two adjacent annular regions 1 Is the radius of the edge circle in the 1 st annular region, p 2 The outer edge radius of the 1 st annular region is equal to the inner edge radius, rho, of the 2 nd annular region 3 The radius of the outer edge circle of the 2 nd annular region.
In this embodiment, (ρ) at the boundary between two adjacent annular regions is determined in step S4) 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) The functional expression of the equation at three points is:
Figure BDA0002982877970000103
in the above formula, z 1 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 1 st annular region, z 2 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 2 nd annular region, z 3 Is the z coordinate of the outer edge of the 2 nd annular region.
As will be appreciated by one skilled in the art, embodiments of the present application may be provided as a method, system, or computer program product. Accordingly, the present application may take the form of an entirely hardware embodiment, an entirely software embodiment or an embodiment combining software and hardware aspects. Furthermore, the present application may take the form of a computer program product embodied on one or more computer-readable storage media (including, but not limited to, disk storage, CD-ROM, optical storage, and the like) having computer-usable program code embodied therein. The present application is directed to methods, apparatus (systems), and computer program products according to embodiments of the application wherein instructions, which execute via a flowchart and/or a processor of the computer program product, create means for implementing functions specified in the flowchart and/or block diagram block or blocks. These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable memory that can direct a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to function in a particular manner, such that the instructions stored in the computer-readable memory produce an article of manufacture including instruction means which implement the function specified in the flowchart flow or flows and/or block diagram block or blocks. These computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer or other programmable apparatus to produce a computer implemented process such that the instructions which execute on the computer or other programmable apparatus provide steps for implementing the functions specified in the flowchart flow or flows and/or block diagram block or blocks.
The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention, and the protection scope of the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and all technical solutions belonging to the idea of the present invention belong to the protection scope of the present invention. It should be noted that modifications and embellishments within the scope of the invention may occur to those skilled in the art without departing from the principle of the invention, and are considered to be within the scope of the invention.

Claims (8)

1. The directional broadband satellite with high stealth performance comprises a satellite body and is characterized in that the phase term of the surface element of the top outline of the satellite body
Figure FDA0003664843800000011
Forming gradient difference, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal, wherein j is an imaginary number unit,
Figure FDA0003664843800000012
is a wave vector, and the wave vector is,
Figure FDA0003664843800000013
the satellite body is a rotator, and the function expression of a bus control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotator is as follows:
z=-aρ 2 +c 0≤ρ≤R (1)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis, and R is a maximum radius of the rotating body.
2. The method for designing the top profile of a directional wideband high stealth satellite according to claim 1, comprising:
1) obtaining a relational function expression of the current and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current according to a Maxwell equation; obtaining the surface equivalent current by using the phase estimation condition of the surface equivalent current under the high-frequency condition and the approximate condition of the projection area such as the current
Figure FDA0003664843800000014
A function approximation expression of (a);
2) equivalent current of plane
Figure FDA0003664843800000015
Substituting the function approximate expression into a relation function expression of the current and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the current, and simplifying to obtain the position vector of any scattering target point
Figure FDA0003664843800000016
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure FDA0003664843800000017
The function of (a) expresses:
Figure FDA0003664843800000018
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure FDA0003664843800000019
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure FDA00036648438000000110
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure FDA00036648438000000111
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure FDA00036648438000000112
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane is k, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure FDA00036648438000000113
for Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface;
3) According to the surface equivalent current
Figure FDA00036648438000000114
Determining the position vector of any scattering target point by using the function approximation expression
Figure FDA00036648438000000115
Corresponding to the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure FDA00036648438000000116
Projected area d tau in incident wave direction from surface element d tau projection And the phase term of the surface element d tau
Figure FDA00036648438000000117
Determining, thereby determining, a phase term for a top surface element of the satellite body
Figure FDA00036648438000000118
Bin in phase forming gradient differenceWhen the projection areas in the wave emitting directions are equal, the intensity of the echo electric field at the position of the target point
Figure FDA00036648438000000119
And the minimum is obtained, so that the condition that the top end appearance of the satellite body meets the requirement of directional broadband high stealth performance is as follows: phase term of top profile surface element of satellite body
Figure FDA00036648438000000120
Gradient difference is formed, and the projection areas of the surface elements in the same phase in the incident wave direction are equal.
3. The method as claimed in claim 2, wherein the relational function expression of the currents obtained in step 1) and the strength of the echo electric field excited by the currents is as follows:
Figure FDA0003664843800000021
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure FDA0003664843800000022
as a scattering target point position vector
Figure FDA00036648438000000221
The intensity of the echo electric field at the position corresponding to the target point, j is an imaginary unit, omega is an angular frequency, mu is medium permeability, k is an incident wave vector, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is an incident wave wavelength,
Figure FDA0003664843800000023
In order to be the Nabla operator, the operation,
Figure FDA0003664843800000024
is the equivalent current of the surface,
Figure FDA0003664843800000025
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure FDA0003664843800000026
is the satellite surface point position vector, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
4. The method as claimed in claim 3, wherein the surface equivalent current obtained in step 1) is the same as the surface equivalent current obtained in step 1)
Figure FDA0003664843800000027
The approximate function expression of (a) is:
Figure FDA0003664843800000028
in the above formula, the first and second carbon atoms are,
Figure FDA0003664843800000029
for the current generated by incident waves perpendicularly impinging on a plane, d τ projection Is the projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction, d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface, j is an imaginary unit,
Figure FDA00036648438000000210
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure FDA00036648438000000211
is the satellite surface point position vector.
5. The method as claimed in claim 4, wherein the echo electric field strength obtained in step 2) is the same as that of the directional broadband high stealth satellite
Figure FDA00036648438000000212
The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure FDA00036648438000000213
in the above formula, j is an imaginary unit, ω is an angular frequency, μ is a dielectric permeability,
Figure FDA00036648438000000214
in order to be the wave vector of the incident wave,
Figure FDA00036648438000000215
is a vector of the position of the satellite surface points,
Figure FDA00036648438000000216
as a position vector of the scattering target point,
Figure FDA00036648438000000217
the current generated by the incident wave vertically irradiating on the plane is k, k is the wave vector of the incident wave, k is 2 pi/lambda, lambda is the wavelength of the incident wave,
Figure FDA00036648438000000218
For Nabla operator, d τ projection The projection area of the satellite surface area infinitesimal d tau 'in the incident wave direction is shown, and d tau' is the area infinitesimal of the satellite surface.
6. The method as claimed in claim 1, further comprising, after the step 3), a step of determining a generatrix control equation of the parabolic tip at the upper part of the rotator when the satellite body is shaped as the rotator:
s1) establishing a rectangular coordinate system by taking the satellite top end direction as the z axis, taking the key direction of the satellite facing the greatest threat as the top end direction to emit the electromagnetic wave, and then taking the wave vector
Figure FDA00036648438000000219
Wherein
Figure FDA00036648438000000220
The unit vector is oriented to the positive direction of the z axis, and the influence of the dark surface of the surface which cannot be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave on the intensity of the electric field echo is small, so that the equiphase area distribution of the top end of the satellite which is taken as the bright surface of the satellite at the moment is obtained only by considering the bright surface of the surface which can be directly irradiated by the electromagnetic wave at the moment; planes perpendicular to the z-axis are made on the z-axis at prescribed intervals dz, respectively, and the planes divide the satellite surface into a plurality of annular regions, and when the intervals dz are sufficiently small, the currents in the i-th annular region are considered to have a common phase value
Figure FDA0003664843800000031
S2) selecting two adjacent annular regions, and respectively calculating to obtain corresponding projection areas tau according to the geometric relationship 1 And τ 2
S3) calculating the area difference of the two adjacent selected annular regions:
τ 12 =(2ρ 2 21 23 2 )π (6)
s4) describing the shape of the rotator bus of the satellite profile by a quadratic polynomial expressed by the following formula;
z=-aρ 2 +bρ+c (7)
in the above formula, z is a bus variable and represents a z-axis coordinate of a point on the bus, a is a bus control parameter, c is a bus control parameter, and ρ is a bus variable and represents a distance from the point on the bus to the z-axis; determining (p) at the boundary of two adjacent annular regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Equations at three points;
s5) since the annular region is cut at equal intervals, there are:
dz=z 2 -z 1 =z 3 -z 2 (8)
two adjacentAt the boundary of the annular region (p) 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) Substituting the equations at the three points to obtain:
Figure FDA0003664843800000032
when b is 0, i.e. z is-a ρ 2 + c, the difference of the projected areas of two adjacent annular regions is:
τ 12 =2ρ 2 23 21 2 =0 (10)
s6) the satellite adopts a quadratic polynomial z ═ a ρ since the two adjacent annular regions are arbitrarily obtained 2 When + c is the shape of the rotator of the bus, the projection areas of all the phase intervals are equal, so that the stealth performance of the satellite in the key direction can be greatly improved by the shape, and the functional expression of the bus control equation of the rotator of the satellite is determined as shown in the formula (1).
7. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein the step S2) of calculating the corresponding projection area τ is performed by using the method 1 And τ 2 The functional expression of (a) is:
Figure FDA0003664843800000033
in the above formula, τ 1 Denotes the projected area, τ, of the 1 st of the two adjacent annular regions 2 Represents the projected area, rho, of the 2 nd annular region of two adjacent annular regions 1 Is the radius of the edge circle in the 1 st annular region, p 2 The outer edge radius of the 1 st annular region is equal to the inner edge radius, rho, of the 2 nd annular region 3 The radius of the outer edge circle of the 2 nd annular region.
8. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein the step S4) is performed to determine the value of (p) at the boundary between two adjacent ring regions 1 ,z 1 )、(ρ 2 ,z 2 )、(ρ 3 ,z 3 ) The functional expression of the equation at three points is:
Figure FDA0003664843800000041
in the above formula, z 1 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 1 st annular region, z 2 Is the z coordinate of the edge in the 2 nd annular region, z 3 Is the z coordinate of the outer edge of the 2 nd annular region.
CN202110291706.8A 2021-03-18 2021-03-18 Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof Active CN112883495B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202110291706.8A CN112883495B (en) 2021-03-18 2021-03-18 Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN202110291706.8A CN112883495B (en) 2021-03-18 2021-03-18 Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN112883495A CN112883495A (en) 2021-06-01
CN112883495B true CN112883495B (en) 2022-07-29

Family

ID=76041282

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN202110291706.8A Active CN112883495B (en) 2021-03-18 2021-03-18 Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN112883495B (en)

Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2015180196A1 (en) * 2014-05-27 2015-12-03 中国空间技术研究院 Multidisciplinary optimization-based system for determining satellite overall plan, and implementation method
CN107443750A (en) * 2017-04-01 2017-12-08 南京航空航天大学 A kind of integrated configuration designing method for satellite
CN107798170A (en) * 2017-09-25 2018-03-13 上海卫星工程研究所 The in-orbit information emulator method of satellite based on three-dimensional environment
CN109188384A (en) * 2018-08-31 2019-01-11 西安电子科技大学 The Electromagnetic Simulation method of extraterrestrial target echo dynamic observation

Patent Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
WO2015180196A1 (en) * 2014-05-27 2015-12-03 中国空间技术研究院 Multidisciplinary optimization-based system for determining satellite overall plan, and implementation method
CN107443750A (en) * 2017-04-01 2017-12-08 南京航空航天大学 A kind of integrated configuration designing method for satellite
CN107798170A (en) * 2017-09-25 2018-03-13 上海卫星工程研究所 The in-orbit information emulator method of satellite based on three-dimensional environment
CN109188384A (en) * 2018-08-31 2019-01-11 西安电子科技大学 The Electromagnetic Simulation method of extraterrestrial target echo dynamic observation

Non-Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
一种实现光学隐身的卫星构型设计;朱冬骏等;《空间控制技术与应用》;20170228;第61-66,72页 *

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN112883495A (en) 2021-06-01

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN114781190B (en) Radar detection capability simulation method and device
Neng-Jing Radar ECCMs new area: anti-stealth and anti-ARM
CN111025249B (en) Method for judging interference effect of foil strip interference in simulation environment
CN110031801B (en) Detection method and system for high-speed near space vehicle
CN110531331B (en) Plasma cladding target radar echo modeling simulation method
CN115128555A (en) Broadband echo signal simulation generation method based on scattering
CN112883495B (en) Directional broadband high-stealth satellite and top end shape design method thereof
CN115063544A (en) Radar detection power range calculation method for accompanying support interference
CN108535704A (en) A kind of signal Pre-sorting method based on self-adaption two-dimensional cluster
Hao et al. Research on the shape stealth design of infantry Fighting vehicle
CN112859027A (en) Bait array interference efficiency analysis method based on one-dimensional range profile
CN109558568B (en) Target RCS calculation method based on CUDA
CN106628192A (en) Icing detector outline with small radar cross section (RCS)
CN110244267A (en) The tangential Forward-looking SAR three-dimensional imaging model performance analysis method of missile-borne millimeter wave
US4939523A (en) Aircraft radar antenna
Li et al. Characterization of complex corner reflectors in polarimetric rotation domain
CN112149277B (en) Modeling method and device for air defense weapon target threat
CN111915959A (en) Method and device for simulating RCS (Radar Cross section) of airplane by using RCS of target drone
JP6896318B2 (en) Radar reception signal processing equipment, programs and methods
Du et al. Passive Millimeter-wave Radiation Imaging Simulation of complex three-dimensional Target
Šarolić Wind Turbine Radar Cross Section for Air Traffic Control Secondary Surveillance Radar
CN113406581B (en) Foil cloud semi-physical radio frequency simulation triple feed coefficient determination method
Yijin et al. Anti-Multipath Interference Method using Brewster Effect and Modified Proportional Navigation
Hua et al. High-frequency method for terahertz radar cross section of conductive targets in free space
KR101958469B1 (en) Target aiming apparatus and method thereof

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
PB01 Publication
PB01 Publication
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
GR01 Patent grant
GR01 Patent grant