CN106532940A - Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation - Google Patents

Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN106532940A
CN106532940A CN201610990100.2A CN201610990100A CN106532940A CN 106532940 A CN106532940 A CN 106532940A CN 201610990100 A CN201610990100 A CN 201610990100A CN 106532940 A CN106532940 A CN 106532940A
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
protection
information
action
alarm
logic
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Pending
Application number
CN201610990100.2A
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Inventor
任浩
王伟
窦仁晖
姚志强
许歆
任辉
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
State Grid Corp of China SGCC
China Electric Power Research Institute Co Ltd CEPRI
State Grid Tianjin Electric Power Co Ltd
Original Assignee
State Grid Corp of China SGCC
China Electric Power Research Institute Co Ltd CEPRI
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by State Grid Corp of China SGCC, China Electric Power Research Institute Co Ltd CEPRI filed Critical State Grid Corp of China SGCC
Priority to CN201610990100.2A priority Critical patent/CN106532940A/en
Publication of CN106532940A publication Critical patent/CN106532940A/en
Pending legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • HELECTRICITY
    • H02GENERATION; CONVERSION OR DISTRIBUTION OF ELECTRIC POWER
    • H02JCIRCUIT ARRANGEMENTS OR SYSTEMS FOR SUPPLYING OR DISTRIBUTING ELECTRIC POWER; SYSTEMS FOR STORING ELECTRIC ENERGY
    • H02J13/00Circuit arrangements for providing remote indication of network conditions, e.g. an instantaneous record of the open or closed condition of each circuitbreaker in the network; Circuit arrangements for providing remote control of switching means in a power distribution network, e.g. switching in and out of current consumers by using a pulse code signal carried by the network
    • H02J13/00001Circuit arrangements for providing remote indication of network conditions, e.g. an instantaneous record of the open or closed condition of each circuitbreaker in the network; Circuit arrangements for providing remote control of switching means in a power distribution network, e.g. switching in and out of current consumers by using a pulse code signal carried by the network characterised by the display of information or by user interaction, e.g. supervisory control and data acquisition systems [SCADA] or graphical user interfaces [GUI]
    • H02J13/0013
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y02TECHNOLOGIES OR APPLICATIONS FOR MITIGATION OR ADAPTATION AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE
    • Y02EREDUCTION OF GREENHOUSE GAS [GHG] EMISSIONS, RELATED TO ENERGY GENERATION, TRANSMISSION OR DISTRIBUTION
    • Y02E60/00Enabling technologies; Technologies with a potential or indirect contribution to GHG emissions mitigation
    • YGENERAL TAGGING OF NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS; GENERAL TAGGING OF CROSS-SECTIONAL TECHNOLOGIES SPANNING OVER SEVERAL SECTIONS OF THE IPC; TECHNICAL SUBJECTS COVERED BY FORMER USPC CROSS-REFERENCE ART COLLECTIONS [XRACs] AND DIGESTS
    • Y04INFORMATION OR COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES HAVING AN IMPACT ON OTHER TECHNOLOGY AREAS
    • Y04SSYSTEMS INTEGRATING TECHNOLOGIES RELATED TO POWER NETWORK OPERATION, COMMUNICATION OR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES FOR IMPROVING THE ELECTRICAL POWER GENERATION, TRANSMISSION, DISTRIBUTION, MANAGEMENT OR USAGE, i.e. SMART GRIDS
    • Y04S10/00Systems supporting electrical power generation, transmission or distribution
    • Y04S10/16Electric power substations

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Human Computer Interaction (AREA)
  • Power Engineering (AREA)
  • Supply And Distribution Of Alternating Current (AREA)

Abstract

The invention relates to an alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of an intelligent substation. On the basis of normalizing monitoring information and achieving filtering and classification of the monitoring information through modeling on the basis of IEC61850, an association relationship between a power element and a protection and circuit breaker is analyzed through substation system configuration file analysis and network topology analysis, and an alarm event chain is built on the basis of an action logic between alarm information; an alarm information time sequence constraint is introduced into the event chain to achieve bidirectional reasoning of the action logic and a time sequence logic of an alarm signal; a credible alarm and an error alarm can be judged to achieve fast and efficient processing of a monitoring alarm signal of the intelligent substation; and meanwhile, the analyzed and processed alarm information is transmitted to a dispatching terminal, so that the workload of a dispatcher is reduced, the alarm analysis accuracy and the monitoring efficiency are improved, and the alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method has important practical significance in safe and stable operation of a power system and improvement of the power supply reliability.

Description

A kind of alarm signal action of intelligent substation and temporal and logic relation analysis method
Technical field
The present invention relates to Substation Automation System field, and in particular to a kind of alarm signal action of intelligent substation with Temporal and logic relation analysis method.
Background technology
With the expansion and the propulsion of " big to run " System Construction of electrical network scale, large number quipments monitoring information is linked into control Center, shows in chronological order, does not do any layering and reasoning and judging is processed, and operations staff's monitor task is heavier, it is easy to Significant alarm signal is missed, delay is processed and caused the accident.When there is accident, semaphore is more, roll screen brush screen phenomenon occurs, Operations staff is even more dazzled, at a loss as to what to do, it is difficult to concentrate on crucial points, affects the correct process to accident.Simultaneously as electrical network The method of operation is changeable, and when an error occurs, protection, breaker may occur malfunction, tripping, and warning information can in transmitting procedure Can lose, distort, these factors complicate will failure, operations staff may be difficult to make correct in the short time again Judgement.
At present transformer station's alert mode adopts single dimension, the classification side such as such as switch changed position, protection signal, remote measurement be out-of-limit Formula, it is clear that be not enough to carry out specific warning information accurate and sufficient description, while conventional alarm pattern is uniaxially Offer suppresses/enables, the function such as confirm based on the push away picture, isolated warning information of measuring control point attribute definition.Alarm mode phase To dullness, information is informed operations staff by the way of tiling simply, lack Consumer's Experience, including user interaction and customizable Deng.And excessive information is provided, and is fatal thing for operations staff, in so various warning information, operation Personnel can not rapidly hold keynote message.And as monitoring data lacks efficient preprocessing means, invalid alarm and time Alert and take place frequently, cause main website further to analyze and lack reliable and stable data basis, although alarm direct transfers technology in part Area is applied, and achieves positive effect, but which is substantially or emphasis solves the problems, such as Modulation recognition and transmission optimization, fails Effectively solving core information refines problem, not yet fundamentally alleviates main website monitoring processing pressure.
Additionally, existing monitoring system of electric substation does not have the function of intelligent inference substantially, it is impossible to which the relevance of information is done Go out to judge, and corresponding improvement is simply made in terms of information aspect, classification.Meanwhile, SCADA receive warning information also exist with Lower problem:The signal of semantic meaning or extension repetition, dither signal interference, order are chaotic, useless to operation monitoring and analysis Information, information change are too fast, have little time from display picture to run through, bright, the wrong report information that confeuses the parimary with secondary, information dispersion, name are not advised Model, the power system nomenclature scheme of different geographical still suffer from some differences.Also, with the popularization of intelligent substation, intelligence becomes The warning information that power station provides is more more complicated, by these information without scheduling is sent in process directly, can cause the announcement of scheduling Alert intractability is bigger, and workload is more.
At present, with regard to intelligent substation warning information analysis and processing method include expert system, artificial neural network, The intelligent algorithms such as Petri network, information fusion.Expert system intelligent substation warning information process application in, although precision and Efficiency improves a lot, but the defect for exposing is yet suffered from, and mainly has the construction of knowledge base under complex fault pattern inadequate Complete, the factor such as alert mode of huge knowledge base and complexity constrains the diagnosis speed of expert system, the method for operation, protection The change of configuration correspond to the adjustment of knowledge base rule causes maintenance workload very big, and protection device or breaker misoperation are easy Cause to judge by accident or so that solution does not restrain so that its fault-tolerant ability is poor;Artificial neural network does not need construction knowledge base and reasoning Machine, but the premise applied need to obtain enough sample sets in advance for its training, when electrical network is larger or connects more complicated, The complete alarm sample set of acquisition is relatively difficult, and Algorithm Convergence is unreliable in addition, explains itself behavior and output result ability It is very poor;The alert analysis processing method of Petri network is primarily present that fault-tolerant ability is poor, large scale electric network modeling has multiple shot array and asks Topic, wrong report can not be recognized and fail to report information, there may be many solutions, and topological structure of electric and relaying configuration change situation; The completeness and redundancy of the mainly information that information fusion technology is relied on, next to that multi-source information feature extraction and fusion method Improvement, the precision of alert analysis process can be improved in theory and the diagnostic result of the overall situation, but in actual applications, letter can be obtained The complete and redundancy of breath is difficult to obtain.
The content of the invention
To solve above-mentioned deficiency of the prior art, it is an object of the invention to provide a kind of alarm signal of intelligent substation Action and temporal and logic relation analysis method, mainly include four parts, respectively the monitoring information based on IEC61850 classify, Alarm action logic analysis, the analysis of warning information temporal characteristicses, the abduction based on temporal characteristicses are analyzed.
The purpose of the present invention is realized using following technical proposals:
The present invention provides a kind of alarm signal action of intelligent substation and temporal and logic relation analysis method, and which improves it Place is that the analysis method comprises the steps:
(1) the intelligent substation monitoring information based on IEC61850 is classified;
(2) alert action logic analysis;
(3) warning information temporal characteristicses analysis;
(4) abduction based on temporal characteristicses is analyzed.
Further, in the step (1), the monitoring information foundation in SCD file is configured by parsing transformer substation system Alarm source database, by the monitoring information after parsing according to automation, protection, direct current, once, fire-fighting security protection and other information Six classes are stored in different word banks respectively, realize the subseries to monitoring information, for the announcement in the monitoring information of real-time reception Alarming information, filters other unrelated category informations by differentiating with the comparison for automating and protecting class monitoring information base;The alarm letter Breath points out monitoring personnel scene to have the signal that exception, accident or failure occur in referring to monitoring information, is the subset of monitoring information;
Which is carried out on the basis of a subseries priority ratio compared with, carry out secondary classification according to the grade of warning information, It is divided into five class of A, B, C, D, E;Wherein A classes alarm:Cause the accident tripping operation information, B class alarms:It is be described it is middle band exception, alarm, Warning, broken string, locking, reduction and interruption need the information for taking measures, C class alarms:More limit information, D class alarms:All masters Become, the positional information of switch, and distant place information on the spot, E class alarms:All disconnecting link dolly positional informations, alarm start involution Information.
Further, in the step (2), including element and protection and switch room logical relation and suspicious correlating event collection Determination and action logic rule.
Further, in element with protection and switch room logical relation, including main protection, nearly back-up protection, remote standby Protection and breaker fail protection;Wherein:
1) logical relation of main protection includes:
If rkFor equipment sjMain protection, if equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1, then main protection rkAction, main protection rk Action logicFor:
2) nearly back-up protection:
If riFor equipment sjNearly back-up protection, if equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1 and its main protection rkDo not move, then riAction, its action logicFor:
3) remote back-up protection:
If ri' it is equipment sjRemote back-up protection, be also s in its protection domainjNeighbor devices skThere is provided remote standby to protect Shield, has two kinds of situations ri' action:
1. equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1 and its main protection rkWith nearly back-up protection riDo not move;
2. equipment sk∈Z(ri, sj) break down, and ri' arrive skAssociated path on all breakers be in closure State, Z (ri, sj) it is s in protection domainjThe set of nearby device, p (ri, sk) refer to along supply path from protection riInstallation place To equipment skThe set of all breakers at place.
Remote back-up protection ri' action logicFor:
Wherein:I represents the mark of nearly back-up protection example, and j represents the mark of device instance, and k represents main protection example Mark,Represent that breaker is not operating and be in closure state, Z (ri') represent protection ri' in the range of sjClose to the set of equipment, p(ri', sk) represent along supply path from protection riInstallation place is to equipment skThe set of all breakers in place's associated path;
4) breaker fail protection:
It is any to drive breaker ciThe protection r of tripping operationjIf action, breaker ciTrip, its action logic is:Wherein R (ci) breaker c can be driven for alliThe protection set of tripping operation, the protection assembling operation of tripping operation LogicFor:
In the determination of suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C }, S takes the set of all electric network elements in new power supply interrupted district, C takes all of breaker in power supply interrupted district and border, and R takes that element fault orders about the protection of generation action and breaker failure is protected The union of shield;
In order to determine R, first define:RFor the set of all protections in system, and introduce S × ROn binary crelation
Re-define:C (r)=c | r action drives c trip, c ∈ C };
r∈R, it is the set for protecting r to drive the breaker of tripping operation;
OrderR2=r | r is the failure protection of c, c ∈ C, r ∈ R};
Then
So far, suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C } all determines and finishes.
Further, alarm action logic rule in, traversal region in suspicious alarm element, set up element, protection and The action logic rule of switch room;Element is obtained by the parsing to transformer substation system configuration file SCD and with reference to power network topology With protection, protection and the incidence relation of switch room, opening relationships database is stored in this incidence relation in corresponding data table, closes Connection relation corresponds to (S, R) and (R, C) respectively;By the corresponding action logic rule of the call establishment to database each element Then;Canbe used on line process is S in referred to as traveling through M { S, R, C }, by corresponding protection information is obtained in (S, R), by obtaining in (R, C) The breaker information being associated with protection is taken, and action logic rule is set up further according to action logic.
Further, in the step (3), the analysis of warning information temporal characteristicses includes the time response of protection act information With the analysis of the time response of switch motion information.
Further, wherein:
<1>The time response of protection act information includes:
The moment of protection act by protection device adjust time delay and protection triggering time delay determine;If the action of adjusting of protection is prolonged When be τ, protection device action triggers time delay isThen for the alarm for betiding the t0 moment, protection act Time instant τaOccur inIn interval;Respectively protection device action triggers when The minimum of a value prolonged and maximum;
<2>The time response of switch motion information:
Switch motion is driven by protection signal, its time delay of actionIf τaFor protection act when Carve, then the switch motion time instant τ being driven by itcOccur inIn interval,Represent respectively The minimum of a value and maximum at the switch motion moment of driving.
Further, the abduction analysis based on temporal characteristicses of the step (4) comprises the steps:
1>The complete protection information model of system is obtained by parsing transformer substation system configuration file, realizes that action logic is advised Modeling then and retrieval;
2>Parsing transformer substation system configuration file obtain element and protection, the related information R (R, S) of protection and breaker and R (R, C);
3>For the warning information for receiving, suspicious source event collection S and breaker collection C are determined by topological analysis, according to announcement Alert action logic analysis method determines protection collection R, so that it is determined that suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C };
4>With suspicious source event collection S as search starting point, by calling to R (R, S) and R (R, C), determine that the action of S is patrolled It is F0 to collect rule set, and all of event chain with S as source event is included in F0;
5>Analyzed according to above-mentioned temporal characteristicses, rule time-constrain being incorporated in F0 is defined as F;Traversal real-time alert Information, carries out abduction analysis by above-mentioned rule and method;
For each event chain, between element and protection, time-constrain is Δ tr, protection is Δ t with switch room time-constrainc, As there is the real-time alert information with abduction rule match, i.e. Δ t 'r∈Δtr、Δt′c∈ΔtcMeet simultaneously, then sentence The fixed warning information related to event chain is true;As time-constrain is unsatisfactory for, then alarm corresponding with abduction rule is judged There is mistake in information, wherein:S takes the set of all electric network elements in new power supply interrupted district, and C takes in power supply interrupted district and institute on border Some breakers, R take element fault and order about the protection of generation action and the union of breaker fail protection.For the reality to disclosing There is a basic understanding in terms of applying some of example, shown below is simple summary.The summarized section is not extensive overview, It is not intended to identify key/critical component or describes the protection domain of these embodiments.Its sole purpose is to use simple shape Formula is presented some concepts, in this, as the preamble of following detailed description.
Compared with immediate prior art, the excellent effect that the technical scheme that the present invention is provided has is:
The present invention proposes a kind of alarm signal action logic and sequential logic for the process of intelligent substation warning information Relationship analysis method, is being standardized to monitoring information based on IEC61850 modelings and is being realized the filtration of monitoring information and classified On the basis of, obtained between force device and protection and breaker by parsing transformer substation system configuration file and Network topology Incidence relation, and with the action logic between warning information as rely on build alarm event chain, warning information temporal constraint is drawn In incoming event chain, realize that the abduction to alarm signal based on temporal characteristicses is analyzed, and judge that credible alarm and mistake are accused It is alert, the process to intelligent substation monitoring alarm signal rapidly and efficiently is realized, while will send on the warning information after analyzing and processing Dispatching terminal, mitigates the workload of dispatcher, improves the accuracy and monitoring efficiency of alert analysis, to power system safety and stability Operation, improves power supply reliability and has important practical significance.
Description of the drawings
Fig. 1 is the supervisory control of substation information two-stage classification process chart based on IEC61850 that the present invention is provided;
Fig. 2 is the alarm action logic analysis method schematic diagram that the present invention is provided;
Fig. 3 is the time response schematic diagram of a certain element warning information that the present invention is provided;
Fig. 4 is the abduction analysis schematic diagram based on temporal characteristicses that the present invention is provided;
Fig. 5 is the test example wiring diagram of the specific embodiment that the present invention is provided;
Fig. 6 is the final alert analysis result figure that the present invention is provided.
Specific embodiment
Below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings the specific embodiment of the present invention is described in further detail.
The following description and drawings fully illustrate specific embodiments of the present invention, to enable those skilled in the art to Put into practice them.Other embodiments can include structure, logic, electric, process and other changes.Embodiment Possible change is represented only.Unless explicitly requested, otherwise individually component and function are optional, and the order for operating can be with Change.The part of some embodiments and feature can be included in or replace part and the feature of other embodiments.This The scope of bright embodiment includes the gamut of claims, and all obtainable equivalent of claims Thing.Herein, these embodiments of the invention individually or generally can be represented with term " invention " that this is only For convenience, and if in fact disclosing the invention more than, it is not meant to automatically limit the scope of the application to appoint What single invention or inventive concept.
Carry out the intelligent substation monitoring information based on IEC61850 first to classify.By parsing transformer substation system configuration Monitoring configuration information in SCD file sets up alarm source database, by the monitoring information after parsing according to automation, protection, straight Stream, once, fire-fighting security protection and six class of other information be stored in different word banks respectively, realize the subseries to monitoring information, For the warning information of real-time reception, other unrelated classes are filtered by differentiating with the comparison for automating and protecting class monitoring information base Information;Priority ratio is carried out to which on the basis of a subseries compared with secondary classification being carried out according to the grade of warning information, be divided into Five class of A, B, C, D, E, the wherein alarm of A classes:Can be caused the accident breaking information, B class alarms:Be described middle band exception, alarm, report Police, broken string, locking, reduction, interruption etc. need the information for taking measures, C class alarms:More limit information, D class alarms:All main transformers, The positional information of switch, and distant place information on the spot, E class alarms:All disconnecting link dolly positional informations, alarm start involution letter Breath.Supervisory control of substation information two-stage classification handling process based on IEC61850 is as shown in Figure 1.
Next carries out alerting action logic analysis, including element and protection and switch room logical relation, suspicious correlating event The determination of collection and action logic rule, as shown in Figure 2.It is in element with protection and switch room logical relation, point main protection, near Back-up protection, remote back-up protection and breaker fail protection introduce its action logic.
(1) main protection
If riFor equipment sjMain protection, if equipment sjBreak down (sj=1), then protect riShould action, its action LogicFor:
(2) nearly back-up protection
If riFor equipment sjNearly back-up protection, if equipment sjBreak down (sj=1) and its main protection rkDo not move, then ri Action is answered, its action logicFor:
(3) remote back-up protection
If ri′For equipment siRemote back-up protection, be also s in its protection domainiNeighbor devices skThere is provided remote standby to protect Shield, has two kinds of situations riShould action:
1)sjBreak down (sj=1) and its main protection (rx) and nearly back-up protection (ry) do not move;
2) equipment sk∈Z(ri, sj) break down, and all breakers in the associated path of ri to sk are in closure State.Z(ri, sj) be sj nearby devices in protection domain set, p (ri, sk) refer to along supply path from protection ri installation places The set of all breakers at equipment sk.
Therefore, remote back-up protection riAction logicFor:
Wherein:I represents the mark of nearly back-up protection example, and j represents the mark of device instance, and k represents main protection example Mark,Represent that breaker is not operating and be in closure state, Z (ri') represent protection ri' in the range of sjClose to the set of equipment, p(ri', sk) represent along supply path from protection riInstallation place is to equipment skThe set of all breakers in place's associated path;
(4) breaker fail protection
It is any to drive breaker ciThe protection r of tripping operationjIf action, breaker ciShould trip, its action logic For:Wherein R (ci) breaker c can be driven for alliThe set of the protection of tripping operation, its action logic For:
In the determination of suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C }, S takes the set of all electric network elements in new power supply interrupted district, C takes all of breaker in power supply interrupted district and border, and R takes that element fault orders about the protection of generation action and breaker failure is protected The union of shield.
In order to determine R, first define:RFor the set of all protections in system, and introduce S × ROn binary crelation
Re-define:C (r)=c | r action drives c trip, c ∈ C },
r∈R, it is the set for protecting r to drive the breaker of tripping operation;
OrderR2=r | r is the failure protection of c, c ∈ C, r ∈ R}
Then
So far, suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C } all determines and finishes.
In alarm action logic rule, suspicious alarm element in traversal region sets up the dynamic of element, protection and switch room Make logic rules;Element can be obtained with protection, guarantor by the parsing to transformer substation system configuration file SCD and with reference to power network topology The incidence relation of shield and switch room, opening relationships database are stored in this incidence relation in corresponding data table, incidence relation point (S, R) and (R, C) is not corresponded to;By the corresponding action logic rule of the call establishment to database each element.It is online real Existing process is S in being referred to as traveling through M { S, R, C }, by corresponding protection information is obtained in (S, R), by acquisition in (R, C) and protection phase The breaker information of association, sets up action logic rule further according to action logic.
Warning information temporal characteristicses analysis, including the time response and switch motion information of protection act information are carried out again Time response analysis.
(1) time response of protection act information
The moment of protection act mainly by protection device adjust time delay and protection triggering time delay determine.If adjusting for protection is dynamic Make time delay for τ, protection device action triggers time delay isThen for the alarm for betiding the t0 moment, protection Action moment τaIt is only possible to occur inIn interval.
(2) time response of switch motion information
Switch motion is driven by protection signal, its time delay of actionIf τaFor protection act when Carve, then the switch motion time instant τ being driven by itcIt is only possible to occur inIn interval.
The time response of a certain element warning information is as shown in Figure 3.Wherein 1,3,5 represent main protection, nearly standby respectively protects Shield and remote back-up protection;2nd, 4,6 it is respectively the breaker corresponding to main protection, nearly back-up protection and remote back-up protection;τi(i= 1,2,3,4,5,6) represent protection or breaker actuation time delay;tj(j=1,2,3,4,5, when 6) representing protection or breaker actuation Carve;The time delay of action that Δ tr0, Δ tr1, Δ tr2 are respectively main protection, nearly back-up protection and remote back-up protection is interval;Δ tc is Breaker actuation time delay is interval.
Finally carry out the abduction based on temporal characteristicses to analyze as shown in figure 4, its analysis process is as follows:
(1) the complete protection information model of system is obtained by parsing transformer substation system configuration file, realize action logic The modeling of rule and retrieval.
(2) parsing transformer substation system configuration file obtains the related information R (R, S) of element and protection, protection and breaker With R (R, C).
(3) for the warning information for receiving, suspicious source event collection S and breaker collection C are determined by topological analysis, according to announcement Alert action logic analysis method determines protection collection R, so that it is determined that suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C }.
(4) with suspicious source event collection S as search starting point, by calling to R (R, S) and R (R, C), determine that the action of S is patrolled It is F0 to collect rule set, and all of event chain with S as source event is included in F0;
(5) analyzed according to above-mentioned temporal characteristicses, rule time-constrain being incorporated in F0 is defined as F;Traversal is alert in real time Notify breath, abduction analysis is carried out by above-mentioned rule and method.
For each event chain, between element and protection, time-constrain is Δ tr, protection is Δ t with switch room time-constrainc, As there is the real-time alert information with abduction rule match, i.e. Δ t 'r∈Δtr、Δt′c∈ΔtcMeet simultaneously, then may be used Judge the warning information related to this event chain as true;As time-constrain is unsatisfactory for, then it is right with abduction rule to can determine that There is mistake in the warning information answered.
Embodiment
Below with example verifying the correctness and feasibility of the method, Fig. 5 is the system wiring figure for testing example.By guarantor Protection information is divided into main protection, nearly back-up protection and remote back-up protection by shield configuring condition.Protect based on information action time delay difference Shield 10~40ms, nearly 310~340ms of back-up protection, remote 510~540ms of back-up protection, breaker actuation 20~40ms of time delay.
The warning information produced in certain failure process is as follows:
The warning information produced in table 1 certain failure process
In table 1, main protections of the B1m for bus B1, back-up protections of the L2Rs and L4Rs for circuit L2 and L4, at the same time as It is the corresponding markers of warning information in the remote back-up protection of B1, bracket.
The suspected fault element gone out by breaker alarm example Jing topological analysis has:B1, B2, L2, L4, corresponding to S= [s1, s2, s3, s4];Power supply interrupted district breaker has:CB4, CB5, CB6, CB7, CB8, CB9, CB10, CB12, CB27, corresponding to C =[c1, c2, c3, c4, c5, c6, c7, c8, c9];Corresponding protection has:B1m、B2m、BSL、L2Sm、L2Rm、L4Sm、L4Rm、L2Sp、 L4Sp、L2Rp、L4Rp、T1s、T2s、L2Rs、L4Rs, corresponding to R=[r1, r2, r3, r4, r5, r6, r7, r8, r9, r10, r11, r12, r13, r14, r15]。
It is analyzed by taking B1 elements as an example, italic overstriking character represents the event of tripping, the corresponding action logic events of B1 Chain is as follows:B1:{ B1, B1m, CB4 }, { B1, B1m, CB5 }, { B1, B1m, CB6 }, { B1, B1m, CB7 }, { B1, B1m, CB9 }, { B1, B1m, CB6, BSL, CB8 }, { B1, B1m, CB6, BSL, CB10 }, { B1, B1m, CB6, BSL, L2Ss, CB12 }, B1, B1m, CB6, BSL, L4Ss, CB27 }.
Correspondence abduction rule is described as follows:
BSLFor breaker fail protection during CB6 trippings, it is the nearly back-up protection of bus B1, it is dynamic that F7 corresponds to nearly back-up protection Inference rule when making.F10, F11 are as CB6 and BSLReasoning during tripping, during remote as the B1 back-up protection actions of L2Ss and L4Ss Rule.
Abduction is analyzed as follows:
(1) find the corresponding offspring's information of source event B1 first from inference rule, analysis is with target offspring during alarm Information, according to the corresponding time interval that source event B1 is determined based on the abduction analysis method of temporal characteristicses.B1 offspring's information B1m (50ms), L2Rs (563ms), L4Rs (575ms), analysis correspondence time-constrain, draw t0∈ [35,40] ms.
(2) explain that CB4 (85ms), the above-mentioned B1 of correspondence calculate time t0With CB4 rules of correspondence F2, it is computed meeting the time about Beam condition, that is, it is true to correspond to warning information CB4.It is also true that CB5, CB7, CB9 warning information can be explained in the same manner.
(3) CB6 (120ms) is explained, finds correspondence CB6 rules of correspondence F4 and event B1m (50ms), verify the time of F4 ConstraintThat is F4 reasonings are false, and judge CB6 and alert for breakpoint.
(4) CB12 (585ms) is explained, finds correspondence CB12 rules of correspondence F12 and event L2Rs (563ms), be computed Meet time constraint condition, i.e. CB12 alarms are true;CB27 (600ms) is explained, correspondence CB27 rules of correspondence F13 and thing is found Part L4Rs (575ms), is computed meeting time constraint condition, i.e. CB27 alarms are true.Be explained further L2Rs (563ms), L4Rs (575ms) and rule F10, F11, Jing analysis F10, F11 meet time-constrain, therefore push away to obtain the tripping of event CB6, hiding thing Part BSLTripping.
(5) there is logic with L2Rs, L4Rs, CB12 and CB27 in the analysis result drawn in above-mentioned steps (4), CB6 trippings On it is inconsistent, judge CB6 for exception warning information.The warning information analysis result of description failure generating process is drawn finally As shown in fig. 6, wherein,For make an exception warning information,For tripping warning information.
The present invention provides a kind of alarm signal action logic and sequential logic for the process of intelligent substation warning information Relationship analysis method, is being standardized to monitoring information based on IEC61850 modelings and is being realized the filtration of monitoring information and classified On the basis of, obtained between force device and protection and breaker by parsing transformer substation system configuration file and Network topology Incidence relation, and with the action logic between warning information as rely on build alarm event chain, warning information temporal constraint is drawn The bidirection reasoning of action logic and sequential logic to alarm signal in incoming event chain, is realized, and judges credible alarm and difference Mistakenly complain is warned, and realizes process to intelligent substation monitoring alarm signal rapidly and efficiently, while by the warning information after analyzing and processing On send dispatching terminal, mitigate the workload of dispatcher, improve the accuracy and monitoring efficiency of alert analysis, to power system security Stable operation, improves power supply reliability and has important practical significance.
Above example is only to illustrate technical scheme rather than a limitation, although reference above-described embodiment pair The present invention has been described in detail, and those of ordinary skill in the art still can enter to the specific embodiment of the present invention Row modification or equivalent, these any modification or equivalents without departing from spirit and scope of the invention, in application Within the claims of the pending present invention.

Claims (8)

1. a kind of alarm signal action of intelligent substation and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that the analysis Method comprises the steps:
(1) the intelligent substation monitoring information based on IEC61850 is classified;
(2) alert action logic analysis;
(3) warning information temporal characteristicses analysis;
(4) abduction based on temporal characteristicses is analyzed.
2. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 1 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that the step (1), in, the monitoring information configured in SCD file by parsing transformer substation system sets up alarm source database, by the prison after parsing Control information according to automation, protection, direct current, once, fire-fighting security protection and six class of other information be stored in different word banks respectively, it is real The existing subseries to monitoring information, for the warning information in the monitoring information of real-time reception, by with automation and protect The comparison of class monitoring information base differentiates filters other unrelated category informations;The warning information points out monitor in referring to monitoring information There is the signal that exception, accident or failure occur at member scene, and is the subset of monitoring information;
Priority ratio is carried out to which on the basis of a subseries compared with secondary classification being carried out according to the grade of warning information, be divided into Five class of A, B, C, D, E;Wherein A classes alarm:Cause the accident tripping operation information, B class alarms:Be described middle band exception, alarm, report Police, broken string, locking, reduction and interruption need the information for taking measures, C class alarms:More limit information, D class alarms:All main transformers, The positional information of switch, and distant place information on the spot, E class alarms:All disconnecting link dolly positional informations, alarm start involution letter Breath.
3. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 1 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that the step (2) in, including element and protection and the determination of switch room logical relation and suspicious correlating event collection and action logic rule.
4. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 3 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that element with In protection and switch room logical relation, including main protection, nearly back-up protection, remote back-up protection and breaker fail protection;Wherein:
1) logical relation of main protection includes:
If rkFor equipment sjMain protection, if equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1, then main protection rkAction, main protection rkIt is dynamic Make logicFor:
2) nearly back-up protection:
If riFor equipment sjNearly back-up protection, if equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1 and its main protection rkDo not move, then riIt is dynamic Make, its action logicFor:
3) remote back-up protection:
If ri' it is equipment sjRemote back-up protection, be also s in its protection domainjNeighbor devices skRemote back-up protection is provided, is had Two kinds of situations ri' action:
1. equipment sjBreak down, i.e. sj=1 and its main protection rkWith nearly back-up protection riDo not move;
2. equipment sk∈Z(ri, sj) break down, and ri' arrive skAssociated path on all breakers be in closure state, Z(ri, sj) it is s in protection domainjThe set of nearby device, p (ri, sk) refer to along supply path from protection riInstallation place is to equipment skThe set of all breakers at place.
Remote back-up protection ri' action logicFor:
Wherein:I represents the mark of nearly back-up protection example, and j represents the mark of device instance, and k represents the mark of main protection example,Represent that breaker is not operating and be in closure state, z (ri') represent protection ri' in the range of sjClose to the set of equipment, p (ri', sk) represent along supply path from protection ri' installation place is to equipment skThe set of all breakers in place's associated path;
4) breaker fail protection:
It is any to drive breaker ciThe protection r of tripping operationjIf action, breaker ciTrip, its action logic is:Wherein R (ci) breaker c can be driven for alliThe protection set of tripping operation, the protection assembling operation of tripping operation LogicFor:
In the determination of suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C }, S takes the set of all electric network elements in new power supply interrupted district, and C takes All of breaker in power supply interrupted district and border, R take protection and the breaker fail protection that element fault orders about generation action Union;
In order to determine R, first define:RFor the set of all protections in system, and introduce S × ROn binary crelation
Re-define:C (r)=c | r action drives c trip, c ∈ C };
r∈RΣ, it is the set for protecting r to drive the breaker of tripping operation;
OrderR2=r | r is the failure protection of c, c ∈ C, r ∈ R};
Then
So far, suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C } all determines and finishes.
5. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 3 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that dynamic in alarm Make in logic rules, suspicious alarm element in traversal region, set up the action logic rule of element, protection and switch room;Pass through Parsing to transformer substation system configuration file SCD is simultaneously obtained element with reference to power network topology and is associated with switch room with protection, protection Relation, opening relationships database are stored in this incidence relation in corresponding data table, incidence relation correspond to respectively (S, R) and (R,C);By the corresponding action logic rule of the call establishment to database each element;Canbe used on line process referred to as travels through M It is S in { S, R, C }, by the corresponding protection information of acquisition in (S, R), by the breaker letter for obtaining in (R, C) and protection is associated Breath, sets up action logic rule further according to action logic.
6. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 1 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that the step (3), in, the analysis of warning information temporal characteristicses includes the time response of the time response and switch motion information of protection act information Analysis.
7. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 6 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that wherein:
<1>The time response of protection act information includes:
The moment of protection act by protection device adjust time delay and protection triggering time delay determine;If the action delay of adjusting of protection is τ, protection device action triggers time delay isThen for the alarm for betiding the t0 moment, the protection act moment τaOccur inIn interval;Respectively protection device action triggers time delay Minimum of a value and maximum;
<2>The time response of switch motion information:
Switch motion is driven by protection signal, its time delay of actionIf τaFor the protection act moment, then The switch motion time instant τ being driven by itcOccur inIn interval,Biao Shi not drive The minimum of a value and maximum at switch motion moment.
8. alarm signal action as claimed in claim 1 and temporal and logic relation analysis method, it is characterised in that the step (4) the abduction analysis based on temporal characteristicses comprises the steps:
1>The complete protection information model of system is obtained by parsing transformer substation system configuration file, action logic rule is realized Modeling and retrieval;
2>Parsing transformer substation system configuration file obtain element and protection, protection and breaker related information R (R, S) and R (R, C);
3>For the warning information for receiving, suspicious source event collection S and breaker collection C are determined by topological analysis, it is dynamic according to alarm Make analytics and determine protection collection R, so that it is determined that suspicious correlating event collection M { S, R, C };
4>With suspicious source event collection S as search starting point, by calling to R (R, S) and R (R, C), the action logic rule of S are determined Then integrate as F0, in F0, include all of event chain with S as source event;
5>Analyzed according to above-mentioned temporal characteristicses, rule time-constrain being incorporated in F0 is defined as F;Traversal real-time alert letter Breath, carries out abduction analysis by above-mentioned rule and method;
For each event chain, between element and protection, time-constrain is Δ tr, protection is Δ t with switch room time-constrainc, such as deposit In the real-time alert information with abduction rule match, i.e. Δ t 'r∈Δtr、Δt′c∈ΔtcSimultaneously meet, then judge with The related warning information of event chain is true;As time-constrain is unsatisfactory for, then warning information corresponding with abduction rule is judged There is mistake, wherein:S takes the set of all electric network elements in new power supply interrupted district, C take in power supply interrupted district and on border it is all of Breaker, R take element fault and order about the protection of generation action and the union of breaker fail protection.
CN201610990100.2A 2016-11-10 2016-11-10 Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation Pending CN106532940A (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201610990100.2A CN106532940A (en) 2016-11-10 2016-11-10 Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN201610990100.2A CN106532940A (en) 2016-11-10 2016-11-10 Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN106532940A true CN106532940A (en) 2017-03-22

Family

ID=58350877

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN201610990100.2A Pending CN106532940A (en) 2016-11-10 2016-11-10 Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN106532940A (en)

Cited By (13)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN107644304A (en) * 2017-11-06 2018-01-30 国网辽宁省电力有限公司大连供电公司 A kind of intelligent substation secondary network equipment data holographic analysis shows method
CN108563652A (en) * 2017-12-20 2018-09-21 海南电网有限责任公司 Reference information sorting technique based on brute-force searching algorithm
CN108710912A (en) * 2018-05-21 2018-10-26 郑州大学 Sequential logic approximate model detection method and system based on the study of two sorting machines
CN108933780A (en) * 2018-06-15 2018-12-04 南京南瑞继保电气有限公司 A kind of multiprotocol network message association analysis methods of exhibiting based on business chain
CN109103856A (en) * 2018-10-12 2018-12-28 国网江苏省电力有限公司 A kind of switching value circuit check method based on message timing
CN109218288A (en) * 2018-08-01 2019-01-15 北京科技大学 A kind of Network Intrusion Detection System for industrial robot control system
CN109861178A (en) * 2018-12-06 2019-06-07 国网天津市电力公司 220kV power grid complicated protection action determination method based on SCADA steady state information
CN110412428A (en) * 2019-08-29 2019-11-05 南方电网科学研究院有限责任公司 A kind of power distribution network time representation method based on temporal constraint network
CN110609210A (en) * 2019-09-25 2019-12-24 广东电网有限责任公司 Power grid fault diagnosis and alarm method based on multi-source data fusion
CN110752673A (en) * 2019-11-04 2020-02-04 国网浙江省电力有限公司嘉兴供电公司 System and method for realizing intelligent linkage processing of main and auxiliary control of transformer substation based on event chain
CN112132491A (en) * 2020-11-25 2020-12-25 中国电力科学研究院有限公司 Power grid monitoring and alarming system and method based on power grid topology analysis
CN113447744A (en) * 2021-06-28 2021-09-28 国网福建省电力有限公司福州供电公司 Equipment abnormity alarm event synthesis method of power monitoring system based on signal analysis
CN115294736A (en) * 2022-10-09 2022-11-04 深圳曼顿科技有限公司 Alarm message control method, device, terminal equipment and storage medium

Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102231567A (en) * 2011-06-23 2011-11-02 许继集团有限公司 Correlated signal judging method of intelligent alarm expert system for substation

Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN102231567A (en) * 2011-06-23 2011-11-02 许继集团有限公司 Correlated signal judging method of intelligent alarm expert system for substation

Non-Patent Citations (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Title
于丽雅: ""智能变电站在线智能警报处理系统研究"", 《中国优秀硕士学位论文全文数据库(电子期刊)》 *

Cited By (20)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN107644304A (en) * 2017-11-06 2018-01-30 国网辽宁省电力有限公司大连供电公司 A kind of intelligent substation secondary network equipment data holographic analysis shows method
CN108563652A (en) * 2017-12-20 2018-09-21 海南电网有限责任公司 Reference information sorting technique based on brute-force searching algorithm
CN108710912A (en) * 2018-05-21 2018-10-26 郑州大学 Sequential logic approximate model detection method and system based on the study of two sorting machines
CN108710912B (en) * 2018-05-21 2021-04-02 郑州大学 Time sequence logic approximate model detection method and system based on two-classification machine learning
CN108933780B (en) * 2018-06-15 2020-10-16 南京南瑞继保电气有限公司 Service chain-based multi-protocol network message correlation analysis display method
CN108933780A (en) * 2018-06-15 2018-12-04 南京南瑞继保电气有限公司 A kind of multiprotocol network message association analysis methods of exhibiting based on business chain
CN109218288A (en) * 2018-08-01 2019-01-15 北京科技大学 A kind of Network Intrusion Detection System for industrial robot control system
CN109103856A (en) * 2018-10-12 2018-12-28 国网江苏省电力有限公司 A kind of switching value circuit check method based on message timing
CN109861178A (en) * 2018-12-06 2019-06-07 国网天津市电力公司 220kV power grid complicated protection action determination method based on SCADA steady state information
CN110412428B (en) * 2019-08-29 2020-08-04 南方电网科学研究院有限责任公司 Power distribution network time representation method based on time sequence constraint network
CN110412428A (en) * 2019-08-29 2019-11-05 南方电网科学研究院有限责任公司 A kind of power distribution network time representation method based on temporal constraint network
CN110609210A (en) * 2019-09-25 2019-12-24 广东电网有限责任公司 Power grid fault diagnosis and alarm method based on multi-source data fusion
CN110609210B (en) * 2019-09-25 2020-09-25 广东电网有限责任公司 Power grid fault diagnosis and alarm method based on multi-source data fusion
CN110752673A (en) * 2019-11-04 2020-02-04 国网浙江省电力有限公司嘉兴供电公司 System and method for realizing intelligent linkage processing of main and auxiliary control of transformer substation based on event chain
CN112132491A (en) * 2020-11-25 2020-12-25 中国电力科学研究院有限公司 Power grid monitoring and alarming system and method based on power grid topology analysis
CN112132491B (en) * 2020-11-25 2021-02-09 中国电力科学研究院有限公司 Power grid monitoring and alarming system and method based on power grid topology analysis
CN113447744A (en) * 2021-06-28 2021-09-28 国网福建省电力有限公司福州供电公司 Equipment abnormity alarm event synthesis method of power monitoring system based on signal analysis
CN113447744B (en) * 2021-06-28 2024-05-10 国网福建省电力有限公司福州供电公司 Equipment abnormal alarm event synthesis method based on signal analysis for power monitoring system
CN115294736A (en) * 2022-10-09 2022-11-04 深圳曼顿科技有限公司 Alarm message control method, device, terminal equipment and storage medium
CN115294736B (en) * 2022-10-09 2023-02-10 深圳曼顿科技有限公司 Alarm message control method, device, terminal equipment and storage medium

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN106532940A (en) Alarm signal action and time sequence logic relationship analysis method of intelligent substation
CN113283704B (en) Intelligent power grid fault handling system and method based on knowledge graph
CN103001328B (en) Fault diagnosis and assessment method of intelligent substation
CN106597231B (en) GIS fault detection system and method based on Multi-source Information Fusion and deep learning network
CN106908690A (en) Distributed intelligence warning system and its method for diagnosing faults between boss station
CN112910089A (en) Transformer substation secondary equipment fault logic visualization method and system
CN106340818B (en) Intelligent substation relay protection device maintenance peace arranges assistant analysis method for early warning
CN102035202B (en) Network reconfiguration system
CN102497024B (en) Intelligent warning system based on integer programming
CN104753178A (en) Power grid fault handling system
CN103679293A (en) Intelligent substation warning and aid decision making system
CN104657913A (en) Intelligent warning system based on all-data model
CN103700031A (en) Electric power warning information publishing method in regulation and control integration mode
CN109557414A (en) Integrated power system fault diagnosis alarming processing system and method
CN107294089A (en) A kind of intelligent association analysis and evaluation method towards grid event
CN107644304A (en) A kind of intelligent substation secondary network equipment data holographic analysis shows method
CN106451384B (en) Power grid self-healing DSS based on scheduling emergency preplan
CN102820706B (en) Method and device for realizing intelligent alarm and auxiliary decision of intelligent transformer substation
CN105158647A (en) Single station end fault diagnosis and auxiliary decisionmaking method based on power supply monitoring system
CN107947356A (en) Electrified railway digital traction substation automated system
CN111049266A (en) Intelligent second-level power restoration method and system for regulation and control service
CN104134973A (en) Automatic fault comprehensive analysis method based on panoramic data of substation
CN110348690A (en) Result queries menu power grid accident aid decision-making system and method based on tree search
CN106451789A (en) Power system monitoring method, communication management equipment and power system monitoring system
CN104166941B (en) A kind of warning information method for visualizing and its system for electric network current diagram

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
CB02 Change of applicant information
CB02 Change of applicant information

Address after: 210003 Nan Rui Road, Drum Tower District, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, No. 8

Applicant after: CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE Co.,Ltd.

Applicant after: State Grid Corporation of China

Address before: 210003 Nan Rui Road, Drum Tower District, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, No. 8

Applicant before: China Electric Power Research Institute

Applicant before: State Grid Corporation of China

TA01 Transfer of patent application right
TA01 Transfer of patent application right

Effective date of registration: 20180629

Address after: 210003 Nan Rui Road, Drum Tower District, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, No. 8

Applicant after: CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE Co.,Ltd.

Applicant after: STATE GRID TIANJIN ELECTRIC POWER Co.

Applicant after: State Grid Corporation of China

Address before: 210003 Nan Rui Road, Drum Tower District, Nanjing, Jiangsu Province, No. 8

Applicant before: CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE Co.,Ltd.

Applicant before: State Grid Corporation of China

SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
CB02 Change of applicant information
CB02 Change of applicant information

Address after: Nan Shui Road Gulou District of Nanjing city of Jiangsu Province, No. 8 210003

Applicant after: CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE Co.,Ltd.

Applicant after: STATE GRID TIANJIN ELECTRIC POWER Co.

Applicant after: STATE GRID CORPORATION OF CHINA

Address before: Nan Shui Road Gulou District of Nanjing city of Jiangsu Province, No. 8 210003

Applicant before: CHINA ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE Co.,Ltd.

Applicant before: STATE GRID TIANJIN ELECTRIC POWER Co.

Applicant before: State Grid Corporation of China

RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication
RJ01 Rejection of invention patent application after publication

Application publication date: 20170322