CA1325420C - Lubricating oil composition - Google Patents

Abstract

LUBRICATING OIL COMPOSITIONS
Abstract Lubricant compositions comprising a major amount of an oil of lubricating viscosity and a minor amount of a cosulfurized blend comprising (a) a carboxylic acid ester material and either (b) an ester, amide, ester-amide, or fatty amine derivative which contains at least one polar substituent group, wherein said ester, amide or ester-amide derivative is derived from an organic acid selected from dialkyl phosphorus acids, dialkyl thiophosphorus acids, and alkylsulfonic acids or (c) an amide derived from a fatty acid and a polyamine.

Description

~32~2~

, ..
Case EI-5783-B

LUBRICATING OIL COMPOSITION
.`.' .
This invention relates generally to lubricant oil compositions which contain additives to reduce friction ; ., , "
and wear and inhibit deterioration of the oil and more specifically to such compositions which contain cosul-furized blends of certain organic esters, amines and amides which contain at least one and preferably two polar substituent groups.
The performance requirements for lubricants used in 1 10 various applications such as internal combustion engine ..j lubrication, gear lubrication, and functional fluids such . ,:
:1~ as hydraulic and automatic transmission fluids are con-stantly being made more stringent by the manufacturers of , products using these lubricants. For example, the smaller :t ~: 1S engines in use today require motor oils of higher over-all '~ performance, such as with respect to reducing sludge for-.... .
mation. One problem associated with formulating such high performance oils is the precipitation of inyredients due to a lack of compatibility of the various additives, espe-2~ cially in the additive package concentrates which are used in making the finished oils. Tha invention provides high performance lubricants with excellent friction, anti-wear and/or anti-sludge properties while minimizing such pre-cipitation.

....
' , ,,;

-,;,~ ;

;;' : ' ,:

2 ~ ~2~2~
In accordance with this invention, there is provided a lubricant . :
composition comprising a major amount of an oil of lubricating viscosity and a minor amount of a cosulfurized b}end comprising (a) a carboxylic acid ester and either (b) an ester, amide, ester-amide or ~t~ amine derivative which contains at least one polar substituent group, wherein said ester, amide or ester-amide derivative is derived from ":i .
- an organlc acid selected ~rom dialkyl phosphorus acids, diallyl thiophosphorus acids, - .
and alkylsulfonic acids or (c) an amide derived from a fatty acid and polyamine.
;..
Preferably, the derivative contains two or more polar groups selected from hydroxyl and .
primaly or secondaIy amil20 including combinations thereof.
` 10Also provided are methods for reducing wear and/or sludge using the above compositions.
....... .
iAlso provided are novel cosulfurized blends which are useful in forming , . ~, . . .
~1the above composltlons which blends include a carboxylic acid ester material and an ,~. ., ~.ester, amide, ester-amide or fatty amine derivative which contains at least one polar .- ., group and which is selected from the group consisting of:

a fatty acid amide of a polyamine of the formula:

NH2(CH2)n~(NH(CH2~n)m~NH2 wherein n = 2 or 3, and m is O to 10;
~ .,.` .
,.,,~

,.,, i .~

` `''7 ': ' .. ..

"':., .' ' ' ':,`
' ,, .
. ~ ~`!, h ' ..j .: :~ : .
:: . ` ., '; ' .: ` ' . i ~
:" ,', ~ . : ' ,:

~^~
i ' _ 3 _ ~ 3 2 r ~L-% ~3 B. a phosphoramide, of an oxy- or thio-alkyl phos- -~, phorous acid with an oxyalkylated amine or a .'~ 1 polyamine;

.:
C. an ester of an oxy- or thio-alkyl phosphorous S acid with an oxyalkylated anline or a polyhydric alcohol;
..
"
D. an ester-amide of an oxy- or thioalkyl phos-phorous acid with an oxyalkylated amine;
:.,.;.,~
....
.... .
;.`,; E. a sulfonamide of an alkyl~ulfonic acid with an ~'~' 10 oxyalkylated amine or a polyamine;
`~1 ;,' F. an ester of an alkylsulfonic acid with a poly-,.~
~ hydric alcohol;
,:, ..'~
, ~
, G. a compound of the formula:
:','1 :
. . ~, l .
``.1 X
RX ~ ¦¦ ~R"O (R' ' ' -O) n~H
~ P -- CH2 - N
R ' X R ' ' ' ' ' .' .-.`.~
.~ wherein X is selected from sulfur and oxygen including various combinations thereof; R and ~.~ 20 R' are independently selected from hydrocarbyl ;.~3 radicals containing from about 4 to 20 carbons;

, .,;~
" i ~
:: 3~ ;
, .; .

' :, . . , ~ .

`.'~ . - , ~ 4 ~ ~3~ ~2~

' . ~ R" and R''~ are divalent aliphatic hydrocarbon ,~ radicals containing 2-4 carbon ~toms, n is an ., integer from O to 20 and R'''' is selected from i hydrogen and the group -R'70(R'''O)n-H.
.:J
~j , .~.. S H. a fatty amine derivative which contains at least one ~ree hydroxyl group.
' * Carboxylic acid ester materials suitable for prepar-~;~3~ ing the cosulfurized blends include Cl-C~O al~yl ,.. ~, :
,`.3J esters of C8-C24 unsaturated fatty acids such as palmitoleic, oleic, ricinoleic, petroselinic, vaccenic, linoleic, linolenic, oleostearic, licanic, paranaric, tariric, gadoleic, arachidonic, and cetoleic. Other fatty acid ester materials obtained from animal fats and veget-able oils, such as tall oil, linseed oil, olive oil, castor oil, pea~ut oil, rope oil, fish oil, sperm oil, coconut oil, lard oil, soybean oil and mixtures thereof, can also be used in the present invention.
Exemplary fatty esters include lauryl tallate, methyl oleate, ethyl oleate, lauryl oleate, cetyl oleate, cetyl linoleate, lauryl ricinoleate, oleyl linoleate, oIeyl stearate, and alkyl glycerides. The fatty esters `~ can contain oth~r substituents such as hydroxyl or sulfo ~;..'5 ~ which ca~ be natural}y occurring, for example ricinoleic .~ . , (12-hydroxyoleic) acid or introduced into the carbon chain ~ 25 such as by reaction with sulfur trioxide.
,, ,~.

~3 _ 5 _ ~3~2~

....
Sulfurized fatty acid ester materials can also be used in preparing the blends. The sulfurized fatty acid ester materials are prepared by reacting sulfur, sulfur monochloride, and/or sulfur dichloride with the fatty -~ 5 ester under elevated temperatures. A specific example of .
~ a useful sulfurized carboxylic acid ester material : .
, ~.;
comprises sulfurized, transesterified, triglycerides derived from fatty acids and fatty oils ~e.g., oils : . ~
....... .
; selected from coconut, lard, tallow, palm, soybean, and ,:, ., -~ 10 peanut oils and mixtures thereof). Examples of such material are disclosed in U. S. patent 4,380,499. The acid moiety of the triglycerides disclosed in the patent consists of an acid mixture having no morP than about 65 . .
mole % unsaturated acids, mainly mono-unsaturated, and no less than about 35 mole % saturated aliphatic acids. Of ' i the total acid moiety, less than about 15 mole % are saturated acids having 18 or more carbon atoms and more than about 20 mole % are saturated acids having 6 to 16 ,~
i~ carbon atoms including more than about 10 mole ~ saturated ,' 20 aliphatic acids having 6 to 14 carbon atoms. Less than .~
~ about 15 mole % are poly-unsaturated acids and more than , .......... .
' about 20 mole % are mono-unsaturated acids Solubilizing .~, ., ;~ agents such as unsaturated esters and olefins can be incorporated in the material. Such materials are commer-cially available, for example, from Xeil Chemical Div;-....
sions of Ferro Corporation under the trademark SU~-PERM~
;~ 307.
.... ~ . ~

. . "
. . "., : .
. .~, , -''.,: '~,.
., . ~ .
i'''. :.;. ., :
., -~, , . ...... .

.
.

- 6 - ~2 ~ ~ 2 :' ' .
.. ' The term "organic acid" as used herein indudes aliphatic car~oxylic acids, organic phosphorus acids, and `, organic sulfur acids.
~ Examples of the types of organic acid ester, amide ;:, and ester-amide derivatives suitable for use in conjunc-tion with the carboxylic acid ester material to form the '' cosulfurized blends includ~:
. ~ .
.'~
A. fatty acid esters, fatty acid amides and fatty ~:~ acid ester-amides of an oxyalkylated amine or mixtures ^ 10 thereof, said amine having the formula:
' 1~
RO(R~-O)n-H

:l H-N
~i \
r.~ ~ R"
?: j ' `3~ wherein R is a divalent aliphatic hydrocarbon radical - l .
~ ~ 15 containing 1-4 carbon atoms, R' is a divalent aliphatic .~J hydrocarbon radical containing 1-4 carbon atoms (pre~er-r ably 2-4), n is an integer from 0 to 20, prPferably O to -;i 10, and R" i5 selected from hydrogen and the group -,, -RO(R'O)n~~
`:,i 20 Optionally, the fatty acid moiety can be ~!
sulfuriz d. Such sulfurized compounds can be made by reacting a sulfurized fatty acid with an oxyalkylated ~ : amine (e.gO l diethanolamine~ as disclosed, for examplel in j~r,; U~ S ~ patent 4,201,684. Sulfurized fatty acids can be made .~
:
. .
'~,i .

. ' .... ., :
.; '' ~': ' ~ ' ,' ;

` ' ' ~: ' ', ; ~. . ' ' ' .
.,, ~ . ' , . . .

~ 7 ~ ~32~20 ,.. j .
by heating a mixture of fatty acid with elemental sulfur . ~
- at temperatures o~ from 100 to 250C. with or without a catalyst such as 2,5-dimercapto 1,3,4,thiadiazole (DMTD~
` as known in the art.
Another method is to first make the fatty acid ester, amide or ester-amide by reacting a fatty acid with an oxyalkylated amine (e.g., diethanolamine) as disclosed, ~ ., for example, in U.S. patent 4,208,293, and then reacting that intermediate with elemental sulfur at elevated .
temperature (e.g., 100 to 250C.) with or without a catalyst such as DMTD.
;;~ The ester, ester-amide, and amide components can be ; ~ separated by distillation and used separately in lubricat-ing oil compositions or they can be used as mixtures.
~;~i 15 When egual mole mixtures of fatty acid and dialkanolamine ," ~
~- are reacted, very little ester-amide forms and the product :~ contains mainly amide because of the greater reactivity of , '. ., ~ the HN< group. However, when over one mole of fatty acid . ~ ....
is reacted with a mole o~ dialkanolamine increased amounts of ester-amide can form.
....j~
-, ~
' . .~1 The preferred amines used to make the compounds are alkoxylated amines such as methanolamine, ethanolamine, --~ dimethanolamine, diethanolamine, 2-isopropanolamine and !
`~ the like. As stated previously, these can be reacted to form both amides, esters and ester-amides. Using di-athanolamine as an example, sulfurized oleic acid, (S)oleic reacts as follows:

: . .' .'"'~
.: .,-,.1 , .,~, ~' -~'''`' `~. '`' " ~ . ,. ' . ;','~ ' ' ' --' '', ', ' ~ ' ' ' '. ~ :' . ' ".'~' ,: ' ' .- ': ' " . , ' ~ ~
. i ~

,~ ~ 8 - ~3~2~
.. . ..
~ (S)oleic + HN -(-C2H40H)2 ~>
,::
, .
~ (S)oleyl-N-(~C2H40H)2 : .
~ Amide '`'!.;,.': S (S) oleyl-O-C2H4-NH-C;~H40H
~: Ester +
(S) oleyl~N~C2H40-oleyl (S) 1,...~
,~""~ 2H4H
f 10 Ester-Amide ~r. .j ~ The compounds can be further reacted with alkylene oxide as describPd in U. S. 4,201,684 to ~orm a polyoxy-alkylene chain [(R'~O)n as defined above in the formula , . 1 .:~ for the amine where R' contains 2-4 carbons n>l]. Pre-ferred fatty acids used in making the a~ide, ester, ester-amide compounds ~are ~those containing 8-20 carbon atoms. Examples of~these are hypogeic acid, oleic acid, : linoleic acid, elaidic acid, abietic acid, dihydroabietic 3: acid, dehydroabiet~c acid, tall oil ~atty acids, erucic acid, brassidic acid, oaprylic acid,~ pelargonic acid, capric acid, undecylic acid, lauric acid, tridecoic acid, myristic acid, palmitic acid, stearic acid, arachidic acid and mixtures thereof.
Most preferably, the fatty acid component is a mixture o~ acids derived from coconut oil.
'I, ' !~ 'i~ ~
""':~,i: ::: :

'` -: `~' .`',' ~'~".`."
.~ .
i' :""
:'. .' ': ' , :. . ' `' . ': , ", : ' , ' ' :

"',, . : , .'., ~ ~ ' . ' , :
'j'. ~ ' ' ,! ! ~ '' ' 11 32~420 g :
B. ~atty acid amides o~ polyamines represented by the formula:
NH2(CH2)n~(NH(CH2)n~m-NH2 where n = 2 or 3 and m is 0 to 10. Specific examples o~
suitable amines include ethylene diamine, diethylene triamine, triethylene tetramine, tetraethylene pentamine, ; and pentaethylene hexamine. Preferred fatty acids ar~
those described in (A) abovs which can be sulfurized. The fatty acid amides can be prepared hy reacting the fatty acid with the amine as known in the art. For example, ~ oleic acid with diethylene triamine as follows:
Oleic acid + NH2(CH2)2-NH-(CH2)2NH2 -->
oleyl NH(CH2)2NH(CH2)2NH2 C. Fatty acid partial esters of polyhydric ~5 15 alcohols which pre~erably contain 2 to 4 free hydroxyl groups. Suitable polyhydric alcohols for forming the ,~
esters contain 3 to 6 hydroxyl groups and include, for ~,~ example, glycerol, diglycerol, pentaerythritol, trimethyl-.. , olethane, trimethylolpropane, 1,2,4-butanetriol, 1,2,6-~i 20 hexanetriol, sorbitol and mannitol and the like. The esters are formed by reacting the polyhydric alcohol with a fatty acid such as described in (A) above at mole ratios to provide a partial ester which contains at least one and ;; .
preferably two or more free hydroxyl groups. A preferred ester is glycerol monooleate which is commercially avail-able. The glycerol esters can also be obtained by partial saponification of fatty oils. Oxyalkylated derivatives .:,, ....

,~.,' .

.

, , ', ' ' ' ', ' ,, -lo- ~3~2a :
can also be used such as are formed by the reaction of 1~;
glycerol monooleate with ethylene oxide.
D. Phosphoramides, esters and amine derivatives of oxy- and thio-alkyl phosphorus acids with (1) oxyalkylated amines as described in (A) above, (2) polyamines as described in (B~ above, and (3) polyhydric alcohols as described in (D) above. The amide and ester compounds can be ~ormed, for example, by reacting the amine or alcohol with an acid chloride of a dialkyl phosphorus acid of the ~, 10 formula:

, .
~
'' X X
'R'X~¦¦ R'X~¦¦

PX~I or/ PH
R"X R'IX
,, ~, r .

where R' and R" are independently selected from hydro-carbyl radicals containing from 4 to 29 carbons and X is ~' selected from oxygen and sulfur including various combina-;~,!
tions thereof. The hydrocarbyl group is preferably ~i~ selected ~rom C8-C20 alkyl or alkenyl to provide oil ~; 20 solubility. As in the case of the Class A materials, the reaction of the acids and oxyalkylated amines ~orms not .....
~ only amides but esters and ester-amides. The dialkyl ~ :;
" phosphorus acids can be prepared, for example, by reacting c one or more alcohols, containing 4 to 20 carbons, such as ,: :;,.
,. :-, . -. .
. .
. . .:
"~

. .

, .
:~, . .. .
' ,:
~ , - 11 - 13~2~

- n-butanol, isobutanol, t-butanol, 2-butanol, pentanol, hexanol, cyclohexanol r 2-ethylhexanol, l-decanol, i-do-; decanol, cetyl alcohol, and stearyl alcohol with an inorganic phosphorus acid anhydride such as phosphorus pentoxide or phosphorus pentasulfid~s as is known in the .
art. The acid chlorides can be prepared by reaction of the acid with chlorine as known in the art, for example:
- ~ .
<
, O O

(C2H5O)2PH + C12 > (C2H5O)ZP-cl + HCl :.~
~ 10 The amine derivatives which can also be considered , . ` .
as being esters of the phosphorus acid can be prepared by ' ~J reacting a dialkylphosphate with formaldehyde and a di-., ~ alkanol amine, for example, as follows:
~:~
: i `~., O
~ 3 15 C8H17`ll ll OC8H17 `3 ~ + CH~O ~ HN(C2H40H)2 ~ H40H)21N-CH2 P~ + H20 .,. I
~ E. Sulfonamides and esters of alkylsul~onic acids : ~, .''~':f with (1) oxyalkylated amines as described in ~A) above, ~. (2) polyamines as described in (B) above, and (3) poly-j .~
~:` 20 hydric alcohols as described in (D) above. The alkyl ~.1 group of the sulfonic acid generally contains from ~ to 50 carbons, and preferably at least 8 carbons for oil solu-bility, and can be a straight or branched chain. Suitable , ~ alkyl groups include polyalkenes such as polyisobutylene :' i' ,' .
,~
~' ;

i ... . .

: : .

~ ~, ' ., ~ -' ,: . .

"
- 12 - 13 ~ ~2a . ~
. (PIB) having a molecular weight, Mn~ f from 250 to :, 5000. Sulfonamides can be formed by reacting the corre-. .,~
.f sponding sulfonyl chloride with the amine or alcohol for ~<~ example as ~ollows:
.~ . .
~ 5 0 ~, , C8H17H + SOC12 - > C8H170SC1 + HCl . .
:?
'~' :
o O
.~:, 11 11 8 17 Cl + HN(C~2CH20H)2 > C~Hl7osN(cH2cH2oH)2 + HCl .~
Other derivatives can be prepared by reacting alkylenes or alcohols with sulfur trioxide to form a sulfonic acid intermediate which is then reacted with an amine, for example as follows:

polyisobutylene ~PIB) + S03 ~ > PIB-S03H
3~ + HN(CH2CH2H)2 - > PIB-so2N(cH2cH2oH)2 C8H170H ~ S03 > C8H170S03H
,, ~ C$H170S03H + HN(cH2cH2oH)2 ---> C8H:L7oso2N(cH2cH2oH)2 ~.., . ., .`l As in the case of the Class A materials the reac-tion of the sulfuric acid derivative and oxyalkylated :.
:.I amines forms not only amides but esters and ester-amide~
.. ~

'~.'; .
. .
,,,~
,, . .

:.,, , :

. . :
; .:, . . .

;- - 13 - ~325~20 by reaction of the acid with the hydroxyl groups on the .~, .
; amine.

; Suitable fatty amines for use in the invention . .
include fatty amines of the formula:
.

;-~ 5 R'O(R"-O)n-H

- R - N
.~,.. , ~
R''' , . , wherein R is an aliphatic hydrocarbon group containing 12-36 carbon atoms, R' is a divalent aliphatic hyclrocarbon 10radical containing 1-4 carbon atoms, R" is a divalent . !
aliphatic hydrocarbon radical containing 1-4 carbon atoms (preferably 2-4), n is an integer from 0 to 20, preferably 10, and R''' is selected from hydrogen and the group : , R~o~R"-O)n-H Examples of such amines are described, ;~ 15for example in U. S. patent 4,231,883. Such amines include N,N-bis(2-hydroxyethyl)-oleylamine~ N,N-bist2-hydroxyethoxyethyl)-1-methyl-undecylamine, and N-~2-hydroxyethyl)-N-(2-hydroxyethoxyethyl)-n-dodecylamine.
Other similar esters and amides of the organic 20acids which contain at least one polar substituent group : .
can also be used provided they have sufficient solubility in oils when cosulfurized with the fatty acid ester materials. The derivatives can be sulfurized prior to cosulfurization but this is not nece~sary.

. . , - ~ 25The materials which are useful in forming the -~ cosulfurized blends with fatty acid esters and especially : :, . ...
.. .
.~. .
" '.'~
, ~, . ...~ .
:: . , , ~ , `
' ~: . , . ' ', ' :;
, ' , ' , '- ;,~' ~ " ' . ,' ~ ' ' ' ' ' .. ~ : ' . : ' ' ' :
- 14 - ~ 325~2 ';
the diol containing materials can be further reacted with : a boronating agent such as boron acids, e.g., ~I3P03, and boron oxides, e.g., B203, and such boronated . materials are considered to be within the scope of this . 5 invention.
-, In order to ~orm the cosulfurized prsducts, the carboxylic acid ester material and the fatty amine, organic acid ester, amide and ester-amide derivative are ;' mixed in proportions of ~rom 20 to 80 percent by weight of . , .
carboxylic acid ester material and from 80 to 20 percent . by weight of the fatty amine, organic ester and/or amide derivative (preferably in a range of 40-60 percent of each .i component) based on the weight of the mixture, and then heated with from 1 to 10 percent by weight of elemental .~
, 15 sulfur based on the total weight of mixture at a tempera-;' ture of from 100 to 250C. and preferably from 140 to -: ' -,. 180C. with or without a catalyst for from 1~2 to 2 hours. Suitable catalysts as known in the art include `l 2,5-dimercapto- 1,3,4-thiadiazole DMTD and alkyl amines ,~; 20 such as PRIMENE~ 81-R (RC(cH312N~2 where R is ! C12-Cl~). The cosulfurized mixtures preferably contain from 2 to 10 percent by weight sulfur and most , . .
preferably from 5 to 7 percent by weight with the amount of elemental sulfur in the reaction belng adjusted to provide the desired sulfur content.
- A composition according to the Class A compounds is ~s commercially available, It contains about 6 weight ., . ,~ .
.: ."
,. .
-., :~.
.i :, .
:, . . .

,' , .,. . ~ ,, .
: . . .

:;
: ' - 15 - ~2~2~

percent sulfur, and consists essentially of a high tempera-ture blend having a common sulfur linkage of sulfurized ~ esters of mixed animal and vegetable oils comprising - transesterified triglycerides containing a mixture of ` 5 saturated and mono- and polyunsaturatled monobasic acids in ;~ which mo~t of the free acid has been esterified with mono-alcohols (approximately 60% by weight) as disclosed :-. in U.S. 4,380,499 (Keil SP307) and the reacti~n product of ~.i diethanolamine and fatty acids derived from selected acids : 10 and oils including coconut oil (approximately 40% by weight) (Keil KDP 55-271 whose iodine number is 7.3 centi-;' grams I2 per gram of fatty product which indicates a largely saturated product) is available from the Keil Chemical Division of Ferro Corporation under the trademark "SUL-PERM~ 60-93".
The cosul~urized blends can be used in mineral oi~
.^; or in synthetic oils of suitable viscosity for the desired .~ lubricant application. Crankcase lubricating oils have a :~1 viscosity up to about 80 SUS at 210F.
Preferred crankcase lubricating oils for use in the . ~ invention have a viscosity up to about SAE 40. Sometimes such motor oils are given a classification at both 0 and :. 210F., such as SAE lOW or SAE 5W30.
.,~, : ~ Mineral oils include those of suitable viscosity refined from crude oil from all sources including Gulf coasts, midcontinent, Pennsylvania, California, Ala~ka and .;~ the like. Various standard refinery operations can be / ~
.-- used in processing the mineral oil.

' :
, ' ~' ' , , ~ ; . ' , -, , . :, ` . , , ; ` , ` ' .. . , ~ , .

- 16 - ~2~2~

Synthetic oil includes both hydrocarbon synthetic oil and syntheti~ esters. Useful synthetic hydrocarbon oils include pol~mers of alpha-olefins having the proper viscosity. Especially useful are the hydrogenated liquid . , oligomers of C6_12 alpha-olefins such as alpha-decene trimer. Likewise, alkylbenzenes of proper viscosity can ~' be used, such as didodecylbenz~ne.
: ,'~,, Useful synthetic esters include the esters of both ~ monocarboxylic acid and polycarboxylic acid as well as ~~ 10 monohydroxy alkanols and polyols. Typical examples are didodecyl adipate, trimethylol propane tripelargonate, pentaerythritol tetracaproate, di-(2-ethylhexyl)adipate, dilauryl sebacate and the like. Complex esters prepared ` from mixtures of mono- and dicarboxylic acid and mono- and ' 15 polyhydroxyl alkanols can also be used.
~. .
~ Blends of mineral oil with synthetic oil are also . ~ . .
~ .~
useful. For example, blends of 5-25 wto % hydrogenated ' alpha-decene trimer with 75-95 wt.% 150 SUS (100~.) mineral oil. ~ikewise, blends of 5-25 wt.% di-(2~
ethylhexyl)adipate with mineral oil of proper viscosity results in a useful lubricating oil. Also, blends of :,, ~` synthetic hydrocarbon oil with synthetic esters can be î~ used. Blends of mineral oil with synthetic oil are useful ;~ when preparing low viscosity oil (e.g. SAE 5W30) since ',",!,25 they permit these low viscosities without contributing i excessive volatility.
.. ..
.,:.
.:
,:
: ~, : ~, ~7`
. . ~
" ' ", '`,`
'`1: . .

j ~' `' ! , , . :.' :
;''~";'', . .
. . ' '.. : ~
.:' ' .

;, ~ ' ; - 17 - 132~4 `
The amounts of cosulfurized blend in the lubricat-ing oil generally range from 0.05 to 6.0 percent by weight for crankcase applications ~preferred .3 to 3.5) based on the total weight of lubricating oil composition althouqh lar~er amounts can be used depending upon the application, - ~
;` ,3 e.g. up to about 20 percent by weight.
The lubricating oil compositions of the present , invention for crankcase use preferably contain an over-based alkaline earth metal sulfonate, zinc dithiophosphake ~, 10 and an ashless dispersant. They can also contain any of ~- the other additives conventionally added to such composi-:; tions such as, for example, wear-inhibiters, friction reducers, viscosity index improvers, antioxidants, dispersants, detergent~ such as neutral alkaline earth metal sulfonates, antifoam agents, pour point deprassants and the like provided, of course, that the presence of such additional additives in the compositions does not ~ .
significantly interfere with the benefits provided by the ~`' additives of the present invention.
.i -~; 20 A combination of overbased alkaline earth metal ~ sulfonate and zinc dihydrocarbyl dithiophosphate along `-' with the cosulfurized materials provide enhanced anti-wear `~ properties. The combination of an ashless dispersant and -~j the cosulfurized blends of the invention provide synergis-~;i tic anti-sludge properties.
Suitable overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonates have a base number of at least 100, more preferably at -~ "
..:
,'."' ,; A, , ' `:
: '';

t . . ' ' ' ,',` ' . ' '~ ': `, .- , , '.`,',' ~ ' ': ' .,; . .

,r~
~ ï8 - ~L 3 2 ~ 0 least about 300. The "total base number" (TBN) also referred to as "base number" is a measure of the alkaline reserve in the product in terms of its stoichiometric . -, .
~` equivalent o~ mg KOH per gram of product (ASTM D2896).
Overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonates are derived from sulfonic acids, particularly from petroleum sulfonic acids, polyalkylene sulfonic acids or alkylated :,, .
-~ benzene sulfonic acids. Useful sulfonic acids from which , the overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonates are prepared $
!~`i;10 ha~e an average molecular weight o~ 250-5000, more pre-~f ferably 400-1100, and most preferably 440~600. Examples ; ~ of specific sulfonic acids include mahogany sulfonic ", acids, petrolatum sulfonic acids, aliphatic sul*onic acids 3 and cycloaliphatic sulfonic acids~ In a highly preferred 15embodiment, the sulfonic acids are alkaryl sulfonic acids i such as alkylbenzene or alkylnaphthalene sulfonic acids.
, Suitable alkyl groups contain from 10 to 30 carbon atoms ~. or more. Likewise, higher molecular weight alkyls derived ''''..t from alkyIation with polyolefin (e.g., polybutenes) having `~1 20molecular weights up to about 2000 can be used to give ;i hydrocarbyl sulfonic acids somewhat above the preferred ?,~ range, but still useful.
ii Preferred sulfonic acids are the alkaryl sulfonic ~ acids also referred to as alkylbenzene sulfonic acids.
., ,.' 'j .~ 25Alkaryl sul~onic acids can be made by conventional ;j/ methods such as by alkylating benzene, toluene or naphtha-~,;,--,!~ lene or aromatic mixtures with olefins containing lQ-30 . ,,.:~
... .
r ,'.....

, ;, . ..
,,'/', , ~ ~ . :
:,~ . , . ;
-:, j , - 19 - ~325~20 : ,~
~ carbon atoms or more (e.g., with polyolefin). The most , ., -j suitable olefins are cracked-wax olefins, propylene trimers and tetramers and olefin mixtures derived from . . .
- aluminum alkyl chain growth. Alkylation is effected using a Friedel-Crafts (e.g., AlCl3 or BF3) catalyst. The `- alkylaromatic mixture contains predominantly mono- and ~ di-alkyl products. These alkyl aromatics are then -i sulfonated by known methods such as by reaction with `` sulfuric acid, oleum, sulfur trioxide and the like.
, . A
;! 10 Thus, pre~erred sulfonic acids include octadecyl-` benzene sulfonic acid, didodecylbenzene sulfonic acid, docosylbenzene sulfonic acid, triacontylbenzene sulfonic acid, dodecyloctadecyl-benzene sulfonic acid, didecylben-....
zene sulfonic acid, dodecylnaphthalene sulfonic acid, ;~ 15 hexadecylnaphthalene sulfonic acid, dinonylbenzene .
sulfonia acid and mixtures thereof and the like.
; The hydrocarbyl sul~onic acids preferably have an .:-, ~` average molecular weight of 250-5000. More preferred are the alkylbenzene sulfonic acids havlng an average molecular weight of 400-llO0 and most preferably 440-600.
The overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonates are produced by neutralizing the sulfonic acid with an ~;i alkaline earth metal base to form an alkaline earth metal '.~ sulfonate salt and then overbasing the alkaline earth , tl:
~t, 25 metal ~ulfonate with the corresponding alkaline earth metal carbonate. The process is conducted to give a total base number of at least 100, more preferably at least , . ~ .

,;:~ :i, ,~'`.''~,'. ' ' ' ' ' ~ -., .

.,,~ . .
,' ',. . ' :~ ,i . ~ . ~ - .
. ,:
:

:l`' ~ - 20 - ~32~2~
.'`": .
300. Ther~ is no real maximum on total base number, but .
for practical purposes they seldom exceed about 550.
~ Overbased calcium petroleum sulfonates or alkaryl -:- (e.g., alkylbenzene) sulfonates are especially preferred.
These are prepared by neutralizing the corresponding - petroleum sulfonic acid or alkylated benzene sulfonic acid ,;, with a calcium base to form a calcium sulfonate salt and then overbasing the calcium sulfonate with calcium carbonate generally by passing carbon dioxide through a ;. ~, mixture of the neutral calcium sulfonate, mineral oil, ~: lime and water.
Such additives are available commercially. For example, an overbased calcium sulfonate produced from a ... - synthetic benzene sulfonic acid having a TBN of 310 can be obtained from Ethyl Petroleum Additives, Inc. under the ~:l designation HiTEC~ 611.
`;~ Useful zinc dihydrocarbyldithiophosphates (ZDDP) .`l include both zinc dialkyldithiophosphates and zinc dialkaryldithiophosphatas as well as mixed alkyl-aryl ~ 20 ZDDP. A typical alkyl-type ZDDP contains a mixture of :
~ isobuty7 and isoamyl groups. Zinc dinonylphenyldithio-. ~
',~ phosphate is a typical aryl-type ZDDP.
Preferred zinc dithiophosphate components are .~ represented by the formula:
'"'.c~
. :,~ i;
. ~;
. ,., ,~
J

. ' ~

. ~ .
,.,2 ' J, : :
;:,. ' j'.,",' ,, ;
,,.. i : .
,:"'. ' ' ,:
' ' :~`; ' :`
. .
.: .

: : f ` ` ~3~2~

. ' ;~
~ RO S
, . \"
P-S- Zn RO
_ 2 ~,'', .
in which R is a hydrocarbyl radical having from 3 to 12 carbon atoms. ~he most preferred zinc dithiophosphates are those in ; which R represents an alkyl radical having from 3 to 8 carbon ; atoms ~uch as isopropyl, isobutyl, isoamyl and 2-ethylhexyl.
Examples of suitable compounds include zinc isobutyl 2-ethyl-hexyl dithiophosphate, zinc di(2-ethylhexyl)dithiophosphate, zinc isopropyl 2-ethylhexyl dithiophosphate, zinc isoamyl 2-ethylhexyl dithiophosphate and zinc dinonylphenyldithio-.- j phosphate.

Such additives are also available commercially. ;~
Por example, a mixed 2-ethylhexyl, ~-methylpropyl, iso-propyl ester of phosphorodithioic acid, zinc salt can be obtained from Ethyl Petroleum Additives, Inc. under the i designation HiTEC~ 685.
Most preferred crankcase oils also contain an , 20 ashless dispersant such as the po~yolefin-~ubstituted succinamides and suocinimides of polyethylene polyamines such as tetraethylenepentamine. The polyolefin succinic . ;i~
substituent is preferably a polyisobutene group having a number average molecular weight of from 800 to 5,000 and '; .,~,t .~,'i ' ,~, ' ',..~
~
.
. .. ~ /;

. ` i! . , :

'.'',, "' , ' : , , ~: , . .

' ,' ~ ' ' ' ~ ~ '' , ', '''; ' ' ' ~ : ~: . ' /~-- 22 - ~323~2~

preferably from 1,000 to 2,000. Such ashless dispersants are more fully described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,172,892, U.S.
Pat. No. 3,219,666 and U.S. Pat. No. 4,234,435.
Another use~ul class of ashless dispersants are the :J, 5 polyolefin succinis esters o~ mono-and polyhydroxyl alcohols containing 1 to about 40 carbon atoms. Such dispersants are described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,381,022 and ` U.S. Pat. No. 3,522,17g.
, (~
Likewise, mixed ester/amides of polyo~efin sub-- 10 stituted succinic acid made using alkanols, amines and/or `~! aminoalkanols represent a useful class of ashless dis-persants.
:1 The succinic amide, imide and/or ester type ashless dispersants may be boronated by reaction with a boron compound such as boric acid. Likewise, the succinic . J
~i amide, imide and/or ester may be oxyalkylated by reaction 3~ with an alkylene oxide such as ethylene oxide or propylene oxide. ~ ~
Other useful ashless dispersants include the ;;; 20 Mannich condensation products o~ polyolefin-substituted S¦ phenols, formaldehyde and polyethylene polyamine. Pre '.`1, ~
erably, the poly olefin phenol is a polyisobutylene-~`~ substituted phenol in which the polyisobutylene group has a molecular weight of from about~800 ~o 5,000. The pre-~erred polyethylene polyamine is te~raethylene pentamine.
. ~ . .j, ~ Such Mannich ashless dispersants are more fully described ',$3~ ~ in U.S. Pat. No. 3,368,972; U.S. Pat. No. 3,413.347: U.S.
,,.,,~ .

~J
; -. . ,1 ~
; i: ,, .
. . ;:: ~ . . . .

~,:s ' , , , , . . , : - ~ , ~ : -..:
. ,.. : : . , .: :~
.: .

.: ~,-. : , :, :
.,, ,, :
,:

~3~20 .'. ~
Pat. No. 3,442,808; U.S. Pat. NoO 3,448,047; U.S. Pat. No.
3,539,633; U.S. Pat. No. 3,591,598; U.S. Pat. No.
3,600,372; U.S. Pat. No. 3,634,515; U.S. Pat. No.
3,697,574; U.S. Pat. No. 3,703,536; U.S. Pat. No.
` 5 3,704,308; U.S. Pat. No. 3,725,480; U.S. Pat. No.
3,726,882: U.S. Pat. No. 3,736~357; U.S. Pat. No.
. ::
`~ 3,751,365; U.S. Pat. No. 3,756,953; U.S. Pat. No.
3,793,202; U.S. Pat. No. 3,798,165; U.S. Pat. No.
3,798,247; and U.S. Pat. No. 3,803,039.
- 10 The above Mannich dispersants can be reacted with ~-; boric acid to form boronated dispersants having improved corrosion properties.
Viscosity lndex improvers can be included such as ;l the polyalkylmethacrylate type or the ethylene-propylene ~ 15 copolymer type including graft copolymers with an N-allyl ., - àmide such as diallyl formamide. Likewise, styrene-diene ; . ' .
^~ VI improvers or styrene-acrylate copolymers can be u~ed.
Alkaline earth metal salts of phosphosulfurized polyiso-butylene are useful.
,~ 20 Con~entional blending equipment and techni~ues may l be used in preparing the lubricating oil compositions of ;;~ the present invention. In general, a homogeneous blend of the foregoing active components is achieved by merely blending the components separately, together or in any combination or sequence with the lubricating oil in a ,~ determined proportion su~ficient to provide the lubricat-.,.~.;, ~ ing oll composition with the desired properties. This is ",,: i, .: ~

' i ; ,~j '' . , .

, . .
',i, . "' ' ~ .

- 24 - ~ 2~
:.
normally carried out at ambient temperature to 70C. The selection of the particular base oil and components, as well as the amounts and ratios of each depends upon the ., - contemplated application of the lubricant and the presence :
~ 5 o~ other additives. In general, however, the amount o~
.~
overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonate in the lubricat-~ I
ing oil can vary from 0.5 to 5.0, and usually ~rom 0.75 to 2.5 weight per~ent based on the weight of the final com-. ::''.
position. The amount o~ zinc dihydrocarbyl dithiophos-phate in the lubricating oil can vary from 0.5 to 3.0, and usually from 1.0 to 2.0 weight percent based on the weight of the final composition. The amount of ashless disper-sant in the lubricating oil can vary from 2 to 8, and ;~ usually from 3 to 6 weight percent based on the weight of .~:
,'i 15 the final composition. The amount of cosulfurized blend i~ in the lubricating oil can vary from 0.05 to 6.0, and usually from 0.3 to 3.5 weight percent based on the weight j~ of the final composition.
"i In many cases, a preferred way to add the additives ; , 20 to lubricating oil is in the form of an additive package.
;,;~
These are concentrates dissolved in a diluent such as mineral oil, synthetic hydrocarbon oils and mixtures thereof which, when added to a base oil, will provide an ......
: ,. f effective concentration of the present additives and other ......
~ 25 known conventional additives such as those listed above.
.: 1 ~ The various additives are present in a proper ratio such .......
f that when a quantity of the concentrate is added to ' I lubricating oil the various additives are all present in : ~ .

,~
., .

1, . , ~ ~ . i ,:
; . .
:, ~

`
- 25 - ~32~

the proper concentration. For example, if the desired use level of a particular additive component is 0.2 wt.% and the final formulated oil is made by adding 10 parts of the additive package to 90 parts of base lubricating oil, then the additive pack will contain 2.0 wt.% of that particular ~ additive component. Usually the concentrate will be 95.0 ; to 99.9 percent by weight additive composition and from 5.0 to 0.1 percent by weight lubricating oil diluent.
Preferably, the additive composition comprises 97 to 99 percent by weight of the lubricating oil additive concen-trate. This concentrate is diluted with additional lubri-cating oil before use such that the finished lubricating oil product contains ~rom 5.0 to 25.0 percent by weight of concentrate. Accordingly, typical amounts of ashless , ., dispersant in a concentrate would range from 40 to 60 weight percent of total concentrate and typical amounts of i Z~DP or overba~ed alkaline earth metal sulfonate would ~ ) ;~ range from 10 to 20 weight percent of total concentrate.
: ,j The following examples illustrate the preparation of cosulfurized blends for use in lubricants.
... .
;~ Example 1 ~5~ A mixture of 60 grams of coconut oil fatty acid ;.. ~
'`7 diethanol amide tSchercomid~ SC0 - extra), 90 grams o~
soybean oil, 9.57 grams of sulfur and 0.80 gram of 2,5-dimercapto-1,3,4-thiadiazole ~DMTD) as catalyst are heat~d ~ at about 160C. for 30 minutes with stirring while :; ~
''1 , :, . :, ::, ": , ~:
. . ~., :-.:, . :
"~

:, :
,, ~
. . ~ , - 26 - 1 3 2 5 ~ 2 ,,; ` `
allowing water vapor to escape and then cooled to avoid side reactions. The product contains 6% by weight sulfur.

' Exam~le 2 A mixture of 60 grams of glycerol monooleate, 90 ,~. .
grams of coconut oil, 9.57 grams of sulfur and 0.80 gram of DMTD as catalyst are heated at about 160C. for about 2 hours with stirring. About 159 grams of product is recovered and filtered to remove a small amount of dark ' precipitate.
,,, ~ .
"~.,;i Exam~le 3 A mixture of 60 grams of glycerol monooleate, 90 .i:`
grams of soybean oil, 9.57 grams of sulfur and 0.80 gram of DMTD as catalyst are heated at about 160C. for 30 minutes with stirring. About 157 grams o~ product is recovered.
..,. ~
:' '.
', 1:
~, Example 4 ,l A reaction product of glycerol monooleate and ethylene oxide is prepared by mixing 3.0 grams of catalyst ~`~ (Amberlyst~ 15 Mallinckrodt) and 150 grams of glycerol ",`.320 monooleate in a flask equipped with a stirrer, gas inlet ~:,j tube, dry ice-isopropyl alcohol condenser and thermometer :: .
~"A~ and heated to lOO-C. Ethylene oxide is fed to the reac-tion mixture throu~h the gas inlet tube for about 3 hours at temperatures o~ ~rom about 40 to 107C. The weight ~',', ' .
,::
: ,, ,, , ; :, ::
...

: - , ," '.: .
:, ~f~
- 27 - ~32~20 increase of the reaction mixture is about 5.2 grams indicating the combination of that amount of ethylene oxide with the glycerol monooleate. The product is filtered and cosulfurized with soybean oil according to the following procedure.
A mixture of 60 grams of the glycerol monooleate-ethylene oxide product prepared above, 90 grams oP soybean oil, 9.57 grams of sulfur and 0.80 gram of DMTD is heated with stirring at ~rom about 158 to 167C. for 30 minutes , ~
,. 10 to prepare a cosulfurized blend of the soybean oil and ,~ glycerol monooleate-ethylene oxide product.
, ., ~
:.' Example 5 , To 100 grams (0.327 mole) of di-2-ethylhexyl phos-,~ phonate in 100 ml CC14 solvent is bubbled in 99~6 grams of chlorine to form di-2-ethylhexyl phosphorochloridate :;~., .
,.~. with HCl off-gas removed in a scrubber. Th~ reaction is ',~ exothermic and the temperature ri~es to from about 43 to ',~"r,~ 56C. The solYent is stripped (vacuum ~ 530Cj to prQvide'., ;i :~' 113.34 grams of product (111.3 theory). Equimolar por-~ 20 tions of the chloridate product and diethylanolamine can .^i then be reacted at re~lux in 100 ml tetrahydrofuran '`1 ;~ solvent to form the amide. The HCl is either evolved or ,.;', removed by washing the product with base.

The di 2-ethylhexylphosphorodiethanol amide can ~;~ 25 then be reacted with a fatty oil such as soybean or '.... ''!' coconut oil and elemental sulfur as described in the : .., ~ oreyoing examples to ~orm a cosulfurized blend.
" .,i ,.......
.,,.. ~ .

. .
~,, . ., : :i .... . .

- : :
. .

. . ~--~
- 28 ~ ~ ~ 2~2 0 . ~
Similarly, the sulfur analog, di-2-ethylhexyl-di-thiophosphorochloridate, can be prepared, reacted with diethanol amine to form the amide and then cosulfurized , with soybean or coconut oil.
.~:
: ~ .
Example 6 .~
Equimolar portions of 2-ethylhexyl alcohol (100 ~:; gms, 0.775 mole) and thionyl chloride (92.2 grams, 0.775 . .
mole) are reacted by slowly adding the thionyl chloride to , ~ the alcohol with removal of HCl. The 2-ethylhexyl chloro-: ~
sulfite product (100 grams, 0 473 mole) can then be i~ treated with (49.6 grams, 0.473 mole) of diethanolamine with HCl removal to provide the amide product which is ,~1 cosulfurized with soybean or coconut oil in accordance ~i with the process described in the foregoing examples.
".'i'l ~ , Example 7 ~; A reaction product of amine and fatty acid can be : ~;'1: .
-~ prepared by heating (180-200C) a mixture of 100 grams, , ~ ~
i .538 mole, of coconut oil fatty acid and 55.4 grams, .538 .~
~ mole of diethylene triamine. The product is expected to ~,, be a mixture of primary and secondary amides. The product can then be cosulfurized by reaction with sulfur and soybean or coconut oil following the procedures de~cribed in the foregoing examples.
The following formulation illustrates a typical additive mixture within the scope of this invention.
Parts are by weight.
., . ' ., ~ :.
,~ .
.

~ - 29 _ 1 32~2 ~
Zinc dialkyldithiophosphate: 0.5-3.0 parts Overbased calcium alkylbenzene sul~onate (TBN
310). 0.5-5.0 parts SUL-PE~M0 60-93: 0.05-6.0 part:sO
S The lubricity or wear properti.es of the lubricating ~, oil compositions of the present invention were determined in the 4-Ball Wear Test. This test is conducted in a - device comprising four steel balls, three of which are in contact with each other in one plane in a ~ixed triangular ~;, 10 position in a reservoir containing the test sample. The `` fourth ball is above and in contact with the other three.
In conducting the test, the upper ball is rotated while it ";~ is pressed against the other three balls while pressure is ~i applied by weight and lever arms. The diameter of the ' ; 15 scar on the three lower balls is measured by means of a 'l low power microscope, and the average diameter measured in ~' two directions on each of ~he three lower balls is taken ; as a measure of the anti-wear charackeristics of the oil.
A larger scar diameter means more wear. The balls were :~. " ~
~'~ 20 immersed in base lube oil containing the test additives.
Applied load was 40 kg and rotation was at 1,800 rpm for 30 minutes at 130F. Tests wexe conducted both with base . ~ J~` oil alone (Exxon 100 neutral low pour base stock mineral oil) and with lube oil blends having the following compositions:
.^ ~
r~e~
'~.., , ; -.';

, :~

' :~-,:, ' : ' ' ' `

, ,: ; , : , .. . .
:,"' . :
:

- 30 - ~3 .
.
;i~ Blend A = Base oil containing 1.2 w~.% zinc ~. dialkyldithiophosphate (HiTEC~ 685).
., i Blend B = Base oil containing 1.3 wt.% overbased calcium alkylbenzene sulfonate, TBN 310 (HiTEC~ 611).

~ 5 Blend C = Base oil containing 0.5% wt.% SUL-PERM~ 60-93.
,,.~,~
-; Blend D = Ba~e oil containing 1.2 wt.% zinc dialkyldithiophosphate (HiTEC~ 685) ~ 0.5 wt.%
SUL-PERM~ 60-93.
.... .
.`, Blend E = Base oil containing 1.2 wt.% zinc ~, 10 dialkyldithiophosphate (HiTEC~ 685) + 1.3 wt.%
~-~ overbased calcium alkylbenzene sulfonate, TBN
;.i 310 (HiTEC~ 611).
, .~
., Blend F = Base oil containing 1.3 wt.~ overbased calcium alkylbenzene sulfonate, TBN 310 (HiTEC~ 611) +
0. 5 wt. % SUL-PERM~ 60-93 .
~3 , r I Blend G = Base oil containing 1.2 wt~% zinc .)~ dialkyldithiophosphate (HiTEC~ 685) ~ 1.3 wt.%
.' overbased calcium alkylbenzene sulfonate, TBN
;~l 310 (HiTEC~ 611) ~ 0.5 wt.% SUL-PERM~ 60-93.

., :
.,;j, ,;~
:" .~; :

. '~!j `'~, :':` ,';1 .3 ``i`
::-j . . .
"

. . .' `
, . î

~ f~' ' ` ' '`~`,' ' ~ .
' ' ~, , ~ . . ' "'~'~.,~ ` ' : " ~

; - 31 - ~32~2~
:..
,.
Results are given in the following table.
. ,.

, Oil Formulation Sca:. Diameter ,~mm) -~. Base Oil 1.47 *
~,..
- Blend A 0.633 ,. . ;i Blend B 0.6Ri8 ;-~ Blend C 00527 '.J:.'i ~;iJ
-~i Blend D 0.483 ~`, Blend E 0.544 ....
~:, Blend F 1.658 ;:' 10 Blend G 0.352 ,.:ii .. i .~,;: * The run was terminated after 5 seconds due to excessive vibrations and noise at which time the scar diameter was 1.47 mm.

The results in the tabl:e show that Blend G contain-ing all three of the above components gave a scar diameter :;;.t~, significantly less than the other blends.
~`A
In addition to providing engine wear reduction : properties to lubricating oil com~ositions formulated for : use in engine crankcases, the additive combinations of the :;~
... ,., ~
2~ present invention are also deemed to impart detergency properties to lubricating oils cont~ining same so as to inhibit sludge formation.

~;.~,''~ :

.; ', : ,i ,: ",, 'r ' ~. : .: ' ' : ~ , . ~: .

:

Accordingly, the presence of the cosulfurized .
blend, has been found to provide a compatible lubricant oil additive package which significantly reduces engine sludge formation as determined by laboratory bench and engine testing. Generally, suitable amounts of the blend to inhibit sludge range from 0.05 t;o 6 percent by weight based on the total weight of lubric~ating oil composition (preferred 0.3 to 3.5 weight percent). Additive concen-trates generally contain from 2 to 25 percent by weight of ~ .
, 10 such high temperature blend.
Four oil blends were tested in the VE engine test . , - with and without the presence of 0.5 weight % of the SUL-PERM~ 60-93 additive. Blends A', B', and C' are fully formulated 5W30 oils made by combining a base oil with zinc dialkyldithiophosphate ester (ZDDP) antiwear, neutral and overbased calcium sulfonate detergen~s, alkenylsuccin-,,, imide ashless dispersant, antioxidants, antifoam agent ~ ~ pour point depressant, viscosity index (VI) improver and, ; `1 in Blend C' a rust inhibitor. Blend D' is a fully .;,,~ , formulated SAE 30 oil which is made from a base oil ~, containing the above additives except for the ~I improver and rust inhibitor.

~, jf.
,.-..:'.;~
~ ~ The results are reported in the following table.
. - .-..
, :.,~, ... .
... . .
~ -.

.'', :r,~,.
',: ' ' '~.
' .' '.!j '''',~' ',' ";~

; r.
; . ~ ,;
,. - , `~'~
~:
.'.`' . ~ :' ~' " ' ' ' ' :. ' , ' ~' ' - 33 - ~ 32~ ~2 0 VE Sludge Ratingl VE Sludge Rating :. BlendW hout Additive With Additive Effiect .~
`~ A' 7.79 9.15 ~1~36 , B' 7.32 9.02 +1.70 .,. 5 C' 6.67 8.79 +2.12 ~ .. -~
. D' 5.9B 8.9;8 ~3.00 . . , , _ ~
, 1Rating Scale: 10 is a perfectly clear (sludge free) :. engine .~ 9 is a "pass".
.~, i . .:,;
",iI
;
:~, 10 The results in the table show that the presence of `l the additive significantly improved the sludge rating of ~ all four oil blends. The function of the two ingredients '~ f~ of the sulfurized blend is not exactly underskood except ~ ''3 jd ~ that fatty acid diethanol amides (Nippon Cooper FRM-213 or Keil KDP55-271 additives), provided improved four-ball, ',`. ;3 ~ and laboratory VE sludge bench test results but the addi-~ 3~
~ tive packages became hazy after istanding for 1 day at both . ,,~
-.; room temperature (RT~ and at 70C which indicated a lac~
-. of additive ingredient compatibility which could lead to ;i 20 performance problems due to the precipitation ~rom the . concentrate or finished oil of additive material. In ; .,d ~ontrast, the cosulfurized mixtures of sulfurized fatty acid and diethanolamide (Keil SP60-93 or cosulfurized Keil .l XDP55-271 and Keil SP307 additives) provided packages : ,.. ..

~ 25 which remained clear after, respectively, 6 and 3 days.
., .~
~rr~ r~ -,,.~ .
/~ ~

.;, ~ ~ ~ .: , : . ~ , , - .
.. . . . .
... : ' ~ . ~ , .

;: . . \ , .i .. , . . ~. . ..
; .

~ - 34 ~ ~32~ ~2 ~

~ The co-sulfurized mixture of Schercomid SC0-extra and , . ,; , j , .~: soybean oil showed only a trace of haze after 28 days at ~, ^~ room temperature and was clear at 70C after 28 days. The data are recorded in the following table in which the ~ ~, ,~ 5 parenthetical amounts represent the weight percent addi-. ~
tive.

T~~ ar~
. .

:'~
,: ,i : l : .
''',''`.~,~

. ., : ,,, ,.
,~,~,, ~: I

";, ~;
; ''~

,.

, :, . . .

, ~, ....
, .......... :
,"~
., , ,~j:

, ,-~ ",~
. ' , ,, ':, , - :

,,.,' : ~ , -:
. . ' 1 ' ' ' .. . .

.~3 132~20 . ` .
,r ' 4 ~all Wear VE Sludge 6 (FullBench ComDatibility ~dditive ~3-Com~3 Pack~4 ~ ,5 ~2 70-C
Coconut Oil Fatty acid 0.344mm 0.369 67.3 Med Haze Med ~aze diethanol- ~.2~) ~.2%) ~.2%~ (1 day) (1 day) '' amide (~eil ~;' RDP55-271) .:, ~ Oleyl Fatty " 10 acid die-~' thanolamide 0.363~m 0.369 63.2 Med Haze ~ed ~aze ;~ (PR~-213 (-3%) (-5%J (.2%) (1 day) (~ aay 'I Nippon Cooper) ~' 15 Cosul~urized ~ fatty acid '~','',',! ester (Xeil0.358mm 0.340 76.5 Clear Clear i sn 07) and (.5%) (.5%) (.5%) (3 days) (3 days) ;i fatty acid ` ~ diethanol-,i, amide ~XDP55-,, 271)~
~ Cosul~urized 6i' ratty acid ;~3 2~ ester and 0.365mm 0.369 67.1 Clear Clear atty acid ~.5%) ~.5%~ ~.5%) ~6 days) ~6 days) diethanol-l amine (Reil ;,~ SP60-93) i d Cosul~ur ze u coconut oil ;:~ ~atty acid 0.367mm 0.342 46.87 Trace Clear ~ diethanol- ~.5%) (.5%) t-5%) ~aze (28 ', amide ~Scher- (~8 day~) 3 comld SCO- days) e~tra) and ~; soybean oil2 , ., ~` Control 0.544mm 0.413 98.5 _~ t 0%) ( 0% ) ( % ) , .~ ,.,.~
,:, ,i. .
:~ .
' : ' '`.

. .
~ .

.. . .
" ;, ;r:~
: ',~, ` ' I

~ ! ' .1; " ' ~., ;':

' `'.~'' ,' ,' , "'',, ' . ' ~ '~ ' ' ,, `' ''`' ' ' ' ' '`. , ' ' ' ~ . :' : '' ' ; ' ' , ' ' ~ ' , ~, i; ':
,. ". , ' ' , . '~''~
., `.'' , ' :
.',, ~ ' ' . .: ' .
,"' , , . ' . ' .
r "', ' ` : ' ' :' ~:; .''~; ' ,, ` : .
,, ` ` ~ " ~ .,,; . . . .
-, ' :

- 36 _ ~ 32~42~
.. . .
Prepared by heating a mixture o~ 120 grams sul-furized fatty acid ester, 80.0 grams amide, and 4.6~ grams of elemental sulfur with 1 gram of 2,5-dimercapto-1,3,4-- thiadiazole as catalyst (DMTD) at 160C for 2 hours.
2Prepared by Example 1.
3Similar to Blend G above except with substitution of the listed additive.
4Fully formulated SAE 5W30 oil made by adding to -, base oil, succinimide dispersant, ZDDP antiwear, neutral and overbased calcium sulfonate detergents, antioxidants, ~` antifoam agent, pour point depressant and VI improver.
~, ; 5After 22-30 hours HOOT ~Hot Oil Oxidation Test) ~` the change in dielectric constant is determined. The oxidized oil is mixed with a known amount of standard 3 15 oxidized oil (a laboratory preparation) and diluted with a hydrotreated baseqtock. Turbidity measurements are then taken. The dielectric constant measurement, HOOT time and turbidity data are combined into a single number ~or reporting and comparison purposes. A lower number i 20 indicates better anti-sludge properties.
;1 6Compatibility of the listed additive with a,!, conventional additive package used by oil blenders to prepare finished lubricating oils. The package used contains the same additives as the full pack of note 4 y 25 except that no VI improver or pour point depressant is ~, present.
,J 7This test was run on a different date from the ;~ others. The control gave a value of 77.6 and the run with ~ KeilSP60-93 gave a value of 51.7 indicating a milder `~ 30 test.
, ~ :, ; An oil blend corresponding to Blend G above was ~ formulated except that the SUL-PERM0 60-93 was replaced by ,.','"!, O. 5 weight percent of the cosulfurized glycerol monooleate ~ - soybean oil product prepared according to the process t ~' 35 described in Example 3. When tested in the 4-ball wear .....
test, the oil blend gave a wear scar diameter of 0.383 mm. An oil additive concentrate was made which contained ., ,~

:,'.,' ~ .
., ' :.~

", , ....... ..
,, ~ , , ~ , .
.: ~

, : . ': .
' `: .

:: :

` - 37 - ~32~20 . . .

5% by weight of the cosulfurized blend prepared according :
to Example 3 and also, besides the ZDDP anti-wear agent, :- neutral and overbased calcium sulfonate detergents, anti-~.:
oxidants, anti foam agent and process oil, about 60% by weight of a 1500 molecular weight succinimide dispersant.
- .~
- ~ Samples Xept at different temperatllres for 12 weeks were . . .
-` periodically examined for haze and precipitates. Also, .;., .
fully formulated 5 w 30 oils prepared from the concentrate additive (10% by weight concentration which also contained a pour point dispersant and a viscosity index improver ~ wera tested for haze and precipitate~ and also ~or sludge : .
; in the VE sludge bench test. The results are reported below where 0 indicates a clear solution, 1 a trace of precipitates or haze, 2 a light precipitate or haze, 3 a -~ 15 medium precipitate or haze, and 4 a heavy precipitate or ~ haze.

. ,, . ~ . !

-~ Concentrate ComPatibility .:
~; 70C Room TemPerature C
Time _ Haze PPT Haze PPT Haze PPT
~' .
; 20 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 - 4 weeks 0 0.5 0 0 0 8 weeXs 0 0.5 0 0.5 0 0 12 weeks 0 1.0 0 0.5 0 0 ~. ~
., ., i"''",''.' . `
.
' , ;'.'` ', ' ~. ' : . ~ ; ,';' ` ; .
.
., , ' '' ~

.. '', .

- 38 - ~25~2~3 FU11Y Formulated Oil Com~atibility , :"
Room VE Sludge 70C Temperature C _ B~nch -^- Time Haze ~ Haze PPT Haze PPT Test 0 0 0 0 0 55.6 4 weeks - 2.0 0 2.0 0 1.0(.5%) ~` 8 weeks 0 2.0 0 1.5 0 1.0(control 77.6) 12 weeks 0 2.5 0 1.5 0 1.5 , _ _ J
, All of the solutions were haze free. The concen-~ .
trates had no more than a trace of precipitates after 12 weeks with the fully formulated oil giving a trace to a light percipitate after ~our weeks which did not appreci-ably increase after 12 weeks. A significant improvement in sludge was obtained ~55.6 versus 77.6 for the control~.
An oil blend corresponding to Blend G above was formulated except that the SUL-PERM~ 60-93 was replaced by -j~ 0.5 gram of the cosulfurized blend of glycerol monooleate-~ ethylene oxide and soybean oil prepared accordi~g to the ,~ process described in Example 4. When tested in the 4-ball !''';''''i'': 20 wear test, the oil blend gave a wear scar diameter of O.371 mm. A fully formulated oil which contained .5% by ~:.
weight of the cosulfurized blend in place of the blend of '`. Example 3 was tested in the VE sludge test and gave a ~' result of 58.1 compared to 77.6 for the control.
" ;:

: ,^", ,.~ .
,.
,, }
. 1, '~'' , :

. ~ .

Claims (10)

1. A lubricant composition comprising a major amount of an oil of lubricating viscosity and a minor amount of a cosulfurized blend comprising (a) a carboxylic acid ester material and either (b) an ester, amide, ester-amide or fatty amine derivative which contains at least one polar substituent group, wherein said ester, amide or ester-amide derivative is derived from an organic acid selected from dialkyl phosphorus acids, dialkyl thiophosphorus acids, and alkylsulfonic acids, or (c) an amide derived from a fatty acid and a polyamine.

2. A composition according to claim 1 where the ester derivative according to (b) is derived from said organic acid and a compound selected from an oxyalkylated amine or a polyhydric alcohol, the amide derivative according to (b) is derived from said organic acid and an amine selected from an oxyalkylate amine or a polyamine, the ester-amide derivative according to (b) is derived from said organic acid and an oxyalkylated amine, and the fatty amine derivative is an oxyalkylated amine.

3. A composition of claim 1 which also contains a minor amount of an ashless dispersant.

4. A composition of claim 1, 2, or 3, which also contains minor amounts of an overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonate having a total base number of at least 100 and a zinc dihydrocarbyl dithiophosphate.

5. An additive concentrate adapted for addition to a lubricating oil to provide a formulated lubricating oil suitable for use in the crankcase of an internal combustion engine said concentrate comprising a diluent oil and from about 2.0 to about 25 percent by weight, based on the total weight of concentrate, of a cosulfurized blend comprising (a) a carboxylic acid ester material and either (b) an ester, amide, ester-amide or fatty amine derivative which contains at least one polar substituent group, wherein said ester, amide or ester-amide derivative is derived from an organic acid selected from dialkyl phosphorus acids, dialkyl thiophosphorus acids, and alkylsulfonic acids, or (c) an amide derived from a fatty acid and a polyamine.

6. The concentrate of claim 5 which also contains from 40 to 60 percent by weight based on the total weight of concentrate of an ashless dispersant.

7. The concentrate of claim 5 which also contains from 10 to 20 percent by weight based on the total weight of concentration of an overbased alkaline earth metal sulfonate having a total base number of at least 100 and from 10 to 20 percent by weight based on the total weight of concentrate of a zinc dihydrocarbyl dithiophosphate.

8. A method of reducing sludge in an internal combustion engine said method comprising (a) adding to a lubricating oil composition a sludge inhibiting amount of a cosulfurized blend according to claim 1, and (b) placing said lubricating oil in the crankcase of an internal combustion engine.

9. A composition comprising a cosulfurized blend of a carboxylic acid ester material and an organic acid ester, amide, or ester-amide derivative which contains at least one polar group and which is selected from the group consisting of:
A. a fatty acid amide of a polyamine of the formula:
NH2(CH2)n-(NH(CH2)n)m-NH2 wherein n = 2 or 3, and m is 0 to 10;
B. a phosphoramide, of an oxy- or thio-alkyl phosphorus acid with an oxyalkylated amine or a polyamine;
C. an ester of an oxy- or thio-alkyl phosphorus acid with an oxyalkylated amine or a polyhydric alcohol;
D. an ester-amide of an oxy- or thio-alkyl phosphorus acid with an oxyalkylated amine;
E. a sulfonamide of an alkylsulfonic acid with an oxyalkylated amine or a polyamine;
F. an ester of an alkylsulfonic acid with a polyhydric alcohol;
G. a compound of the formula:

wherein X is selected from sulfur and oxygen including various combinations thereof; R and R' are independently selected from hydrocarbyl radicals containing from about 4 to 20 carbons; R'' and R''' are divalent aliphatic hydrocarbon radicals containing 1-4 carbon atoms, n is an integer from 0 to 20 and R'''' is selected from hydrogen and the group -RO(R'''O)n-H.

10. A composition comprising a cosulfurized blend of a carboxylic acid ester material and a fatty amine derivative which contains at least one polar group.