CA1072282A - Method of rotationally molding plastic articles - Google Patents

Abstract

Abstract of the Disclosure A method of rotationally molding blends of polymers of good flow to produce articles of high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, smooth surfaces, and the absence of ex-cessive warpage in which the blend is placed in a rotational mold which is then biaxially rotated about two perpendicular axes while heating the mold and contents and then cooling the mold and contents to about room temperature while maintaining this biaxial rotation followed by removing the resulting article. The disclosure also includes the rotationally molded shaped structures resulting from this method with these structures having high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, smooth surface and the absence of excessive warpage.

Description

METHOD OF ROTATIONALLY MOLDING PLASTIC ARTICLES

Background of the Invention This invention relates to a process of rotationally molding and ~e resulting product or article in which a blend ~ ~;
of high density polyethylene or ethylene-alkene copolymer and an~:; ethylene-propylene copolymer or terpolymer with diene or a mixture of these two with an EVA copolymer is used.
.. .. .
The most pertinent prior art of which applicants are aware are the following: -U. S. patent 3,647,922 discloses polyethylene blended ~
with an ethylene-propylene copolymer. However, the blends of -, this invention and the structures produced therefrom have advantages that are not achieved with the blends of this ;~
patent. Thus in this patent the copolymers are block ;-~
copolymers while the on~s here~are '''.','.''-: .' ~'; ,:' -1- ' . ' ~';

` ';' ' ., '; '

2~

essentially random as produced via transition metal catalysts.
Also the ethylene content of the reference coPolymer is low while in the present invention it is high. Additionally, the blends of the reference have low amounts of polyethylene while the blends of this invention have high amounts of polyethylene.
U.S. Patent 3,261,889 discloses a blend of a low density polyethylene and an ethylene-prooylene-diene terpolymer to improve environmental stress crack resistance (ESCR). (A table of abbre-viations is presented at the end of this s~ecification.) The three component blends of this invention especially have the ESCR
improvement significantly above that achieved via a two component blend due to the unexpected synergism of the blend components chosen.
In the conventional rotational molding methods using resins and blends it is customary to use polyethylene of narrow molecular weight distribution and with low melt flow to achieve high impact stren~th. These prior res:ins are difficult to process and it aPpears to be due to their high apparent melt viscosity and they are generally not warp resistant. It has been known to blend EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer) with polyethylene in oxder to im~rove the impact strength of the resin. However, polyethylene-EVA copolymer blends are not nearly as effective -~
as ethylene-propylene copolymer or ethylene-propylene-diene texpolymer in improving the impact resistance of rotomolded structures. In addition, these prior and conventional rotational molding blends containing Polyethylene do not have the above -advantages of the blends of this invention.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The invention in its broader aspect as claimed pertains to the method of rotationally molding articles of high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, with smooth surfaces and an absence of excessive warpage. The method comprises ~' ' '.

Z~

placing in a rotational mold a blend comprising a three component blend o~ (1) 60-80 wt.% of a member of a first class consisting of high density polyethylene and high density ethylene-alkene copolymers containing 4 to 6 carbon atoms in the alkene group blended with (2l 5-20 wt.% of a member of a second class consist-ing of ethylene-pro~ylene essentially random copolymer and an essentially random terpolymer of ethylene-pro~ylene-monomer in which the monomer is selected from the group consisting of 1,4-he~adiene,5-ethylidine-2-norbornene and 5~methylene-2-norbornene and (3) 5-30 wt~% of a copolymer of ethylene-vinyl acetate for a total of 100%, biaxially rotating the mold about two perpendicular axes while heating the mold and contents within the range of about 40~-9qaF., cooling said mold to about room tem~erature while maintaining the coaxial rotation and removing the resulting rotationally molded article.
In one aspect the component of the second class prefer- -ably consists essentially of an ethylene-propylene copolymer -~
- ' containing 40-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5-60 wt.% of propylene for a total of 100%, and the copolymer of ethylene-vinyl acetate ~ -preferably contains 65-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5-35 wt.~ of ;, `
vinyl acetate for a total of 100%.
In another aspect the component of the second class preferabl~ consists essentially of a ter~olymer containing 40-95 wt.% of ethylene, 5-60 wt.% of pro~ylene and 1-8 wt.% of the --~
group monomer for a total of 100%, and the ethylene-vinyl acetate -copolymer contains 65-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5 35 wt.% of vinyl acetate for a total of 100%.
~, .
Description of the Preferred Embodiments The blends of this invention all of which contain poly-30 ethylene blended with certain specified copolymers of either two or three monomers have characteristics that make them highly : .
useful for rotational molding to produce molded shaped structures.
' Thus the blends of this invention have good processability, high - ~
~ _ 3 - -' '. ' " '.' ". ' ' ~ . ' ' ~ 8~

impact strength, produce smooth surfaces in the rotationally molded structures with a virtual absence of warpage in the structures, have easy flow during the rotational molding and the structures produced have a high resistance to environmental stress cracking.
The blends of this invention generally contain 50-95 wt.% of high density polyethylene (HDPE) with a preferred composition range of 60-90 wt.%, and either ethylene-propylene copolymer, a terpolymer of ethylene-propylene and a monomer that is either 1,4-hexadiene, 5-ethylidine-2-norbornene or 5-methylene-2-norbornene or either of these copolymers further blended with EVA.
To obtain maximum improvement in the impact strength and ESCR of the blend, the preferred elastomer component, i.e.
ethylene-propylene copolymer and ethylene-propylene-diene ter-polymer, should have a high molecular weight as measured by the -Mooney viscosity and a narrow molecular weight distribution as measured on the Gel Permeation Chromatograph. Tests have shown that the blend properties improve with increasing Mooney -viscosity and narrowing molecular weight distribution of the elastomer component of this invention. Furthermore, the blend properties also improve with increasing elastomer content up to the concentration disclosed in this invention.
The following blends of polymers of this invention ; result in molding resins that have superior rotational molding qualities as discussed above.
1. A blend of 70-95 wt.% of HDPE with 5-30 wt.% of ethylene-propylene copolymer containing 40-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5-60 wt.% of propylene in an essentially random copolymer with a Mooney viscosity (ML1+4/250F.) of 30 to 100 or in some instances even higher.

' . .

~ s~2~

2. A blend of 70-95 wt.% of HDPE with 5-3Q wt.% of a terpolymer of 40-95 wt.% of ethylene, 5-60 wt.% of propylene and 1-8 w-t.% of a termonomer that is either 1,4-hexadiene, 5-ethy-lidine-2-norbornene or 5-methylene-2-norbornene or blends of these monomers.

3~ Blend 1 above further blended with 5-40 wt.~ of a copolymer of 65-95 wt.% of ethylene with 5-35 wt.% of vinyl acetate and of an ~I range of 0.3 to 30.

4. Blend 2 above further blended with the ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer of blend 3 in an amount of 5-40 wt.% of a copolymer of 65-95 wt.% of ethylene with 5-35 wt.% of vinyl acetate and of an MI range of 0.3 to 30.
The blends of this invention may be prepared with any desired mixer or blender so long as the resulting blends are homogeneous and therefore uniform. Thus the mixers may be either roll mills, banburies, kneaders or extruders or the like and the mixing temperatures are prefera~ly above the softening point of the ingredients and, for example, may be within the range of 175-500F. The blends of this invention are processed in the normal manner in the thermoplastic range of the particular blend to produce shaped structures that are themselves homogeneous and that have desired improved characteristics including those specifically noted above.
Certain values which are important for the proper pro-cessing of the blends of this invention are standard procedures that are customarily used in this art. Thus the test for en-vironmental stress cracking of ethylene containing plastics is the test designated D1693-70 of A.S.T.M. The test for impact resistance of plastics is designated as ASTM Method A of D256-56.

The standard method used for testing tensile-impact energy to break plastics is designated as ASTM D 1822-68 with the actual .
, : , . :
. ..

test specimen being that shown in Fi~ure 4~ of the paper en-titled "Test for Tensile-Impact Energy to Break Plastics" at page 590. Mooney viscosity data i5 obtained according to ASTM-D1646, Viscosity and Curing Characteristics of Rubber By The Shearing Disc Viscometer.
The high density polyethylene used in this invention incl~des ethylene homopolymers as well as ethylene butene-l and ethylene hexene-l copolymers preferably with an annealed density range of 0.940 to 0.970. These high density poly-ethylene resins can be produced by Ziegler or modified Zieglercatalysts~ chromium oxide catalysts, molybdenum oxide catalysts or any of the available processes for producing essentially linear crystalline polyethylene. The EVA copolymers used in this invention can be produced by free radical catalysts at high pressures. The vinyl acetate content in these copolymers can range from 5% to 35%. The ethylene-propylene copolymers and ethylene-propylene-diene terpolymers used in this invention are essentially random copolymers that can be produced via the transition metal catalyst. The preferred compound should have ~0 an ethylene content above 40~ with high molecular weight and narrow molecular weight distribution. Where an ethylene-alkene copolymer is used in the blend the alkene content may be up to 10 wt.% of the ethylene-alkene copolymer with the ethylene being from 90-100 wt.%. The preferred alkene groups are those of 3-8 carbon atoms. Thus the individual polymers of the blends of this invention are well known materials.
The three component blends of this invention produce a synergistic eEfect with relation to the impact strength and ESCR properties of the resin in that the overall effect is greater than that which would be expected by the addltive properties of the individual components.

~ g~J ;~ a~

The preferred ethylene-propylene copolymer and ethylene- -propylene-diene terpolymer for the three component blend are the same as descri~ed above ~or the two component blend. The preferred ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer should contain at least ;

5% vinyl acetate with an MI of 0.1 or above. ~he blend properties are shown to improve with increasïng vinyl acetate concentration up to the preferred range disclosed herein. The processability of the blend on rotational molding machines improves when the polyethylene and the EVA copolymer components have a good match of melt viscosities.
Specific Examples :
Example 1 -A blend of 15% ethylene-propylene-diene terpolymer having a Mooney viscosity of about 50 (ML1+4/250F.) and 85%
of ethylene-hexene-l copolymer of 0.955 density and 18 MI was produced on a Banbury mixer. The mixing times was 3-1/2 minutes, ;
achieving a drop temperature of approximately 320F. The mixture was dropped into an extruder and pelletized. The resulting blend has a nominal MI of 6.5 and 0.942 dens:ity. A comparison of parts rotomolded from this blend and other commercial rotomolding resins under the same molding conditions show that the blend of this example is characterized by excellent impact strength and dimen-sional stability (very low warpage) plus smooth glass-like interior surfaces and an unusually wide range of molding tempera-ture and cycle times.
Example 2 A nominal 0.96+ density and 6.0 MI blend of high density polyethylene was made under similar conditions as in Example 1.
The rotomolded parts from this resin show very poor dimensional stability (warpage was so bad that the part was useless), very rough interior surface, and very low resistance to tear.

.. ", ': '.

~2 Example 3 A comparison between the phy-sïcal properties of roto-molded parts from the blend ïn Example 1 and a direct synthesis copolymer rotomolding resin is shown in Chart I.

CHART I
Physical Propertie_ of Rotomolded Parts ~ .
Blend in HDPE Copolymer Ex. 1 Rotomolding Resin MI (g/10 min) 7.1 4.5 Density (g/cc) 0.936 0.935 Tensile Impa~t (ft-lbs/in') 64 21 Notched Izod (ft-lbs/in wid h) 4.6(P~ 0.81 (C) Bell ESCR F50 (hrs) 4-3 break on bending The above results indicate that the blend of this invention has significantly better properties on rotomolded structures than that of HDPE copolymer resins with similar MI and density properties but produced by direct synthesis.
Examples 4-8 The effect of EPDM rubber concentration on the physical properties of the plaques compression molded from these blends is shown in Chart II. The materials and mixing conditions are the same as in Example 1.

CHART II
Effect of EPDM Concentration Tensile Notched Impact Izod EPDM MI Density ft-lbs? ~ft-lbs Ex. Conc. (g/10 min) (g/cc) in2 ~in width 4 0 18 0.955 35 0.8(C) 5% 14 0.951 37 0.83(C)

6 10~ 9.6 0.948 47 1.2(C)

7 12.5% 9.0 0O944 46 2.0(H)

8 15% 5.6-6.7 0.941-3 61-80 4.4-NB
" . '.

. : ,:
' ~ ~ .

The above results indicated improved impact properties as the EPD~ content of the blend was increased.
Example 9 A blend of 10% ethylene-propylene-diene terpolymer with 20~ 0.950 density, 2.5 MI, 27.6% vinyl acetate content EVA
copolymer plus 70% of a 0.964 densïty, 12 MI homopolymer poly-ethylene was produced on a sanbury mixer and pelletized as in Example 1. Rotomolded parts from this nominal 5.5 MI, 0.953 density blend were characterized by excellent impact resistance and superior ESCR (about 60 hours). The impact strength and especially the ESCR are the result of a synergistic effect be-tween the EPDM and the EVA copolymer. Chart III shows this effect for compression molded samples.
Example 10 A blend of 30% EPDM and 70~ homopolymer is prepared using the same materials and procedures as in Example 9.
Physical properties of compression mo]ded plaques are shown in Chart III.
Example 11 A blend of 30~ EVA copolymer and 70~ homopolymer polyethylene is prepared using the same materials and procedures as in Example 9. Physical properties of compression molded plaques are shown in Chart III hereinafter.
Examples 12-20 The effect of EPDM and EVA concentration on the physical properties of compression molded plaques from the resulting blends is shown in Chart IV hereinafter. The materials and mixing conditions are the same as in Example 9 except that the hexene copolymer used in Example 1 was used in place of the homopolymer used in Example 9. This data also shows the synergistic effect of the E~A-EPDM combination.
.
_ 9 _ '` ~,v c) u~
~ ~ ~r co o r~ 1 ~ r~
,~ o ~ ,~ o G) Ln ~ u~
m~ m ~ ~ ~

~ ~ .~J ~ . ' OtN O N
d ~ ~i k -1 H ~ H ~ o o u~ u~ o u~ oo co n O ~ /~ a) Q U~ r- Irl I O O
r-l r-l r~ ~ ~ r~
rl I ri i U~ I`
Ia ~ U~ ~ :
_ a.~--~ ~ :,, ~a ~
O ~1 O rl N ~ N ~
H _ _ H m ' o ~ ~ ~ ~~ æ ~~
.,, ~ m m o ,1 ~.,, _ _, . . . . ~ ~ ~ a: ~i ~ ~ m ~ m -O Z Z ~ ~ o ~
~1 ~ Q O rl ~ -1 Z Zi Z
O rl ~) O rl U~ ~ ~ U~ ~
4~ O ~ 4 .) _ ~ C) _~
O
~1 O 4~
H ~i H ¦ ~ O ~ ~1 ~, ^ ~ ri ~ ~_ ~ ~
,$ u~ ~ ~ + ~ o o ,~ ~ In ~ O u~ ) o o ~C rl rl ~ ~D u7 ~r ~ (1~ ri rl O ISl ~r ~ It~
O tr u~ ~ c5~ 5 U~ ~ ~) cn /S~
~1 ~ t~ ~ ~ ti ~I) Q)--~ O O O O C~ a~ ID-- O O O O C:~ O O
~: a ~ ~ a ~ r~
U~ ~ U~

.~ D .~ ¦
O ~ ~ ~ ~1 l-l o CO ~ ~ rl ~i ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ .
~, _ ~ ~r ¦ I C ~ ~ ~ r l ¦ t~
f~ ~ N ~ ' O ~i . . ~ :
ri'' : ' " ' ' , ~ .. ',~'' .
s-~ o~o ~1 o o ~'O~o ~1 , o U~ I o I O
~) ~ ~4 I r-l ~ I ~ ~ P I --I--I
~ ~ ~ ~ ' '~',, oooo ~. ooIn In O O
O ~-~1 0 r~ r~ 1~ 0 ~1 cn CD coco ~ r~

., .~ . .
ri h X
I~i ~ o ~1 ~i ,-1 ,i ,-i rl r-l r~
C.) .' -10 ,,,~ . , .

.

~-o u~
- ~ o ~l ~ o ~ o o~ o a~ n ~
m ~ ~ :

o~
~ . ..
~.~
~ ., ~n O Q ~1 ~ . .
~1 ~1 C~ ~ ' ,1 ~ :,, E~ ~... .. .

~ ,.,. ,., . .,~ .
O O-rl rl N 3 .
i~
~ ~ ~rl .. ~ ~ ~ O a ;~ U~ ~
' '~ ~.> O ~ ~ Z
. o a~ ~ ,.
~- ~ y l 4-1 E~ ~ _ O IY O
.) ~ ~
~ U~
E~ a a) .,, c) u~
P; ~ ~ U~
,¢ ~ ~ ~ ~
~:q u~ a~ ~ o o c~ o a W ~~
4~ ~
., E~ o .'. ''':' ~ . .. . .
.;
o ~ :
s~ 0~O a , O
8~
o ~ 1 o o , .. ';.
~, ~ I 1` '` ' ' ":
,......
.......
. .
~C ~ o ~ ,~

.. . ...

~Q7 Exam~le 21 66.5% of a 0.964, 12 MI homopolymer polyekhylene is blended with 28~5~ of a 1 MI, 0.930 density, 9~ vinyl acetate content EVA copolymer and 5% of an ethylene/propylene/1,4-hexa-diene monomer rubber using the same conditions as in Example 1.
Rotomolded parts from this resin show improved impact strength over rotomolded parts from the blend in Example 1.
In the rotational molding process of this inventioII
the mold may be rotated at from about 2-12 rpm about the malor axis and about 5-40 rpm about the minor axis although the conditions for rotomolding any blend of polymers within the method of this invention can be easily determined by those skilled in the art of rotational molding. Thus, for example, in the rotomolding of the resins of Chart.I above the mold was rotated for 13 minutes at 10 rpm about the major axis and 11.4 rpm about the minor axis while the mold was heated at about 650P. At the end of the 13 minutes the mold and contents was transferred to a cooling chamber that was cooled by water and air for 7 minutes to approximately room temperature and the 20 resulting molded article was then removed from the mold. As ~ ' a general statement it can be noted that a practical range of ,, temperatures may be from 400-900F.
All parts and percentages herein are by weight.
Abbreviations EPDM - ethylene propylene diene monomer ESCR - environmental stress crack resistance '; , EVA - ethylene-vinyl acetate HDPE - high density polyethylene MI - melt index MWD - molecular weight distribution Having described our invention as related to the embodi-, ments,set out herein, it is,our intention that the invention be ~ ' ' ' '. ' . .
-12- ' , , ' , not limited hy any of the details of description, unless otherwise specified, but rather be construed broadly within its .
spirit and scope as set out in the appended claims.

, .. ... .

. ,", .

'".

,"'.

.: .
:.` ':: ' ~'.

.

: . . `
'; ,.

'' '; , , , . ~; ~ .: .
:~ . . .. . . .
,

Claims (5)

The embodiments of the invention in which an exclusive property or privilege is claimed are defined as follows:

1. The method of rotationally molding articles of high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, with smooth surfaces and an absence of excessive warpage, comprising:
placing in a rotational mold a blend comprising a three component blend of (1) 60-80 wt.% of a member of a first class consisting of high density polyethylene and high density ethylene-alkene copolymers containing 4 to 6 carbon atoms in the alkene group blended with (2) 5-20 wt.% of a member of a second class consisting of ethylene-propylene essentially random copolymer and an essentially random terpolymer of ethylene-propylene-monomer in which the monomer is selected from the group consisting of 1,4-hexadiene, 5-ethylidine-2-norbornene and 5-methylene-2-norbornene, and (3) 5-30 wt.% of a copolymer of ethylene-vinyl acetate for a total of 100%;
biaxially rotating the mold about two perpendicular axes while heating the mold and contents within the range of about 400-900°F.;
cooling said mold to about room temperature while maintaining said coaxial rotation; and removing the resulting rotationally molded article.

2. The method of Claim 1 wherein said component (2) consists essentially of a said ethylene-propylene co-polymer containing 40-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5-60 wt.% of propylene for a total of 100%, and said component (3) contains 65-95 wt% of ethylene and 5-35 wt.% of vinyl acetate for a total of 100%.

3. The method of Claim 1 wherein component (2) consists essentially of a said terpolymer containing 40-95 wt.%
of ethylene, 5-60 wt.% of propylene and 1-8 wt.% of said group monomer for a total of 100%, and said ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer contains 65-95 wt.% of ethylene and 5-35 wt.% of vinyl acetate for a total of 100%.

4. A method of rotationally molding articles of high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, with smooth surfaces and an absence of excessive warpage, comprising:
placing in a rotational mold a blend comprising a three component blend of (1) 70 wt.% of high density polyethylene as a first component, (2) 10 wt.% of ethylene-propylene essentially random copolymer as a second component, and (3) 20 wt.% of ethylene-vinyl acetate as a third component;
biaxially rotating the mold about two perpendicular axes while heating the mold and contents within the range of about 400-900°F,;
cooling said mold to about room temperature while maintaining said coaxial rotation; and removing the resulting rotationally molded article.

5. A method of rotationally molding articles of high impact resistance, high stress crack resistance, with smooth surfaces and an absence of excessive warpage, comprising:
placing in a rotational mold a blend comprising a three component blend of (1) 70 wt.% of high density polyethylene as a first component, (2) 10 wt.% of ethylene-propylene-monomer essentially random terpolymer as a second component in which the monomer is selected from the group consisting of 1,4-hexadiene,5-ethylidine-2-norbornene and 5-methylene-2-norbornene, and (3) 20 wt.% of ethylene-vinyl acetate as a third component;
biaxially rotating the mold about two perpendicular axes while heating the mold and contents within the range of about 400-900°F.;
cooling said mold to about room temperature while maintaining said coaxial rotation; and removing the resulting rotationally molded article.