CA1049287A - Hot water generator and method for shock testing fabricated piping components - Google Patents

Abstract

ABSTRACT

A hot water generator capable of producing a maximum rate of water temperature increase without generation of vapors including a heat exchanger in the form of an annularly shaped helical coil through which the water to be heated is pumped and which is connected to a piping system including a load and a combustor for rapidly providing increased combustion which is controlled in response to the temperature of the water at the out-let of the coil so that the heater can produce a maximum rate of water temperature rise without causing boiling and generating vapors in the coil. The method concerns the shock testing of piping components by producing nearly theoretical maximum heat flux rate very quickly.

Description

1049ZI!37 This invention relates in general to hot water generators and more particularly to a hot water generator operating at high temperatures so the heat exchanger of the generator will produce a maximum rate of heat absorption and therefore temperature rise without nucleation.
Heretofore, hot water generators have operated well below the maximum heat release obtainable because of heat exchange and pressure control systems which would result in generating transient pockets of vapor, some of which might become superheated. Pressure transients produced by these vapor pockets generate "hammer" or load pressure transients in the heat exchanger portion of the generator which is objec-tionable in damage caused to the heat exchanger and audible noise emitted. Superheated vapor pockets localize overheating of heat exchanging surfaces that result in decreased life.
Vaporization of water causes film temperatures at sufficient high levels which may produce scaling and/or corrosion.
Accordingly, it is important that the water heated hy the generator never enter the vapor phase.
A prior known water heating apparatus is shown in ; U. S. Patent 3,282,257, wherein a heat exchange structure similar to that of the present invention is used in connection with a steam drum to produce controlled quality steam. This heater operates at approximately seventy-five percent of the maximum heat release due to variations in load pressure.
A boiler for producing rapid water temperature increases is shown in U. S. Patent 3,651,790, which concerns the use of complex heat transfer structures for increasing the heat exchange surface. Structures of this type are - 1- ~.

.,;, ,~
r ~te 1049Z~37 difficult and expensive to manufacture. Moreover, such struc-tures have non-uniform internal pressure distribution during thermal and flow transients which result in the generation of undesirable vapor pockets.
Another complex type of heat transfer water generator is shown in U. S. Patent 3,773,019. This structure would like-wise be difficult and expensive to manufacture.
The present invention provides a method of thermal shoc~. testing a high performance fabricated piping component by subjecting the component to a rapid water temperature rise with-out nucleation, wherein the method includes use of a hot water generator having a high turndown ratio for rapidly increasing the temperature of hot water to a point of substantially theoretical maximum heat absorption and temperature rise without nucleation, wherein the generator includes a housing defining connected coil and combustor sections, a coil in the coil section with an open central area for receiving combustion gases and defining a water flow path, an inlet and an outlet for said coil, piping connected between the inlet and outlet defining a closed loop water path, a load in the piping, a pump in the piping forcing constant water circulation through the closed loop, a fuel and air induction system including fuel and air controls coacting to deliver the proper mixture of fuel and air to the combustor section, said fuel and air induction system including a fuel line delivering fuel to the combustor section, a combustion air line delivering combustion air to the combustor section, and means continually bleeding air directly into the fuel line to maintain stable combustion in the combustor section at minimum fire conditions, a fast response actuator for said fuel and air controls, and a temperature con-troller providing operating signals to the actuator in response toa set point temperature and the water temperature of the coil outlet to operate the fuel and air controls and cause a rapid rate of temperature rise in the outlet water temperature without nucleation, said method comprising the steps of mounting said component in said piping connected between the inlet and outlet of the coil, operating said generator between low and high firing rates in a short period of time to produce the maximum heat flux absorbable by the load without incurring nucleate boiling, and observing the function of said component.
The present invention utilizes a heat exchanger struc-ture and a combustor similar to that shown in the aforementionedU. S. Patent 3,282,257,~ together with a unique control system for obtaining the maximum rate of water temperature increase without generation of vapor pockets. For example, the system of the in-vention can operate to heat water from a temperature of about 562;
degrees F. and a pressure of about 2282 psig to a temperature of about 627 degrees F. anld a pressure of about 2266 psig in about fifty seconds. This allows the maximum heat flux to be absorbed by the heat exchange structure without moving into the area of nucleate or more advanced stages of boiling corresponding to the pressures involved. Accordingly, the hot water generator of the ~ invention is capable of shock testing high performance fabricated ; piping components such as valves, regulators, heat exchangers and the like, by subjecting a component to a rapid water temperature rise without nucleation or the generation of vapor pockets.
The controls for operating the generator to obtain the rapid temperature rise ln the water heated includes a temperature controller monitoring the outlet temperature of the water heated by the generator and producing a signal for operating a high speed air fuel actuator to provide the maximum permissible combustion rate capable of being handled by the heat exchanger structure of the generator without generating vapor pockets in the water being heated. A blower generating combustion air for the combustor has its output controlled by a damper connected to the actuator.
fuel metering valve delivering fuel to the combustor is also con-trolled by the actuator. A 24-to-1 turndown ratio of the gener-ator permits generation of a "wall of water" which produces rapid increases in the water outlet temperature within accurately con-trolled flow and pressure limits.
The high speed hot water generator used in the method of this invention is capable of producing a high rate of temper-ature increase approaching the theoretical maximum change in wat-er temperature without generating vapor pockets.
The hot water generator and method for shock testing high performance fabricated piping components subject a component to a rapid temperature rise of water without nucleation.
The invention is also concerned with the prov~sion of a high speed hot water generator including controls that are capable of operating the generator to provide the maximum rapid rate of temperature change without generating vapor pockets in the liquid.
The hot water generator has a heat exchanger which may be efficiently and inexpensively manufactured and which has long service life where controlled heat input and extraction produces a maximum rate of heat absorption and therefore temperature rise.
Other features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following detailed disclosure, taken in con-junction with the accompanying sheets of drawings, wherein like reference numerals refer to like parts, in which:
Fig. 1 is a somewhat diagrammatic and~block view of the hot water generator according to the invention together ~, .

with the controls and water flow loop;
Fig. 2 is a somewhat diagrammatic view of a system including a plurality of hot water generators connected in parallel in connection with the shock testing of a piping com-ponent;
Fig. 3 is a graphical illustration of the maximum allowable water temperature at the hot water generator outlet as a function of outlet pressure for a hot water generator according to the present invention;
Fig. 4 is a graphical illustration of the maximum out-let water pressure and temperature of a hot water generator according to the invention as a function of water flow rate for prevention of boiling in the heat exchanger of the generator;
Fig. 5 is a typical boiling curve illustrating boiling regimes for hot water generators;
Fig. 6 is a graphical illustration of the time response plotted against heater water outlet temperature illustrating the low fire to high fire conditions of the generator according to the present invention and the maximum temperature rise without nucleation;
Fig. 7 is a graphical illustration showing the steady state of maximum fire rates allowable for operation between low fire outlet heater temperature and maximum allowable outlet tem-perature without boundary layer boiling;
Fig. 8 is a block diagram of the air fuel control sys-tem of the generator of the present invention;
Fig. 9, 10 and 11 are graphical illustrations of operations pursuant to a change in the set point temperature of the controller in relation to the control signal, the damper and the temperature of the hot water at the outlet of the heat lO9~9Z87 exchanger; and Figs. 12, 13 and 14 show the relationship during the change in load between the temperature of the hot water coming into the heat exchanger of the generator, the hot water leaving the heat exchanger and the flue gases transferred from the com-bustor to the heat exchanger.
Referring now to the drawings, and particularly to Fig.
l, the hot water generator of the invention is diagrammatically illustrated as including a housing 20 enclosing a combustor sec-tion 21 and a coil section 22. A choke 23 is provided within the housing between the combustor section and the coil section to direat the flow of gases from the combustor section to the coil section. Within the coil section 22, a coil or heat exchanger in the form of a coil and designated generally by the numeral 24 includes a plurality of watertubes. The coil is annularly shaped and helical in form and where;`n the watertubes are arranged in radially arranged layers and longitudinally spaced or arranged rows with an inlet 25 at the outermost layer of watertubes and an outlet 26 at 'the innermost layer of watertubes. Combustion or flue gases generated in the combustor section 2~1 flow through thechoke 23 into the central area of the coil 24 outwardly and through a flue gas outlet 27. While the generator is shown diagrammatically, it will be appreciated that this part of the generator is essentialIy of a type shown in the aforementioned U. S. Patent 3,282,257. The helical watertubes define a path for the water which picks up heat from the coil that is absorbed from the flue gases which involves the transfer of heat to the minimum amount of water moving through the coils. It is important that minimum amount of water is involved in the heat transfer process in order to obtain the desired rapid rise in temperature of the .", water.
Combustion gases are generated from an appropriate fossil fuel and air mixture. Fuel may be a natural gas or other suitable fossil fuel which is delivered from a suitable source of supply through a fuel line 30 to the combustor section or the combustion chamber in the combustor section. A metering valve 31 controls the fuel flow in the combustor section.
Primary air or combustion air is generated by a blower 32 and delivered through a duct 33 to the combustor section 21. A
damper 34 is provided in the duct to control the air flow through the duct. In-order to maintain stability of combustion at low fire condition, a small amount of air is bled from the duct 33 ahead of the damper into the fuel line 30 by a bleed line 35 to provide some mixture of air with the fuel that is delivered by the fuel line into the combustor section. This is important in order to provide a high turndown ratio from high fire to low fire.
More specifically, it assists in providing about a 24-to-1 turn-down ratio in order to provide the necessary increase in tempera-ture and obtain the necessary shock testing in connection with the shock testing of fabricated components according to the invention.
A high speed air fuel actuator 38 is mechanically coupled to the metering valve 31 and the damper 34 for control-ling the operation thereof and therefore the air fuel flow into the combustion section 21. This actuator receives a signal from a temperature controller 39 of a suitable type which responds to a set point indicator 40 and the temperature of the hot water at the outlet 26 of the heat exchanger 24 by virtue of a suitable temperature measuring instrument 41.

A pipe or conduit 45 is connected between the inlet end and outlet end of the coil or heat exchanger 24. A pump 46 is provided in the piping 45 to cause constant flow of water through the entire water path or loop at all times at a desired flow rate.
Therefore, forced circulation of water is established through the coil 24. A loa~ 47 is also provide~ in the pipe 45 for loading the system. As shown, the load is in the form of a heat exchanger but may be of any desirable form although it should be such as to provide a continous path in the piping 45. In the event that a fabricated component to be shock tested is a heat exchanger, such can be inserted at the load 47 position. Should the component to be tested be in the form of a valve, a regulator or the like, suc'n can be mounted in the piping 45 at the position 48 ahead of the load 47 or at the position 49 between the load and the pump 46. The load 47 would be matched with the coil capacity of the generator.
As seen in Fig. 2, in the event that the load is of such a magnitude that a single hot water generator would be in-sufficient, a plurality of hot water generators may be connected in parallel, as shown by the hot water generators 20A, 20B and 20C. Suitable manifolds at the inlet and outlet will be provided to facilitate the parallel connecting of such generators. While three generators are shown in Fig. 2, it can be appreciated that any number may he connected in parallel depending on the load.
It can be appreciated that suitable balancing valves may be pro-vided at the outlets of parallel connected generat.ors so that the same temperature and pressure conditions of each generator is de-livered into the outlet manifold.
The generators may use any suitable type of fossil fuel as already mentioned. The water used in the system will be de-aerated, de-mineralized, and perhaps otherwise treated.

104~Z~37 The air fuel actuator 38 may be of any suitable type which provides a fast enough response which is necessary in order to enable the rapid rise in temperature of the liquid in the heat exchanger of the generator and also to pre~ent nuc~eation. ~or example, if the actuator will provide a full stroking time in two seconds or less, it will be able to provide the necessary quick response needed for the generator of the present invention. The response must ~e faster than the heat absorption capacity of the hèat exchanger of the generator.
The typical boiling curve illustrating boiling regimes for hot water generators is shown in Fig. 5. Most hot water systems involve operating in a state of unsteady equilibrium where several of the boiling regimes illustrated in Fig. 5 are traversed. It is preferable that a system operate in the incipi-ent nucleate ~oiling range indicated at 51 which is just below the nucleate boiling point A, where the most efficient heat trans-fer is available. The system of the present invention operates at point B. Overshoot of the maximum heat rate can move the opera-tion of a system into the unstable boiling regions resulting in damage or destruction of the heat exchange surfaces. The curve of Fig. 5 shows the change in temperature plotted along the hori-zontal and the heat flow rate along the vertical.
The rate of rise in temperature is dictated by the maxi-mum heat flux which can be absorbed by the heat exchanger of the generator without moving into the area of nucleate or more ad-vanced stages of boiling corresponding to the pressures involved.
An illustration of the temperature-time response of a generator according to the present invention is shown in Fig. 6 wherein time in seconds is plotted along the horizontal and heater outlet water temperature is plotted along the vertical. As illustrated, ,?;
i~.,~

the time taken to move from low fire to high fire or one hundred percent firing rate of the generator is about forty seconds, where the low-fire temperature is 573 degrees F. and the high-fire temperature is about ~i27 degrees F. Likewise, the rate of drop in temperature is dic~ated by the maximum heat flux absorb-able by the heat exchanger. The "trip" point A and normal opera-ting point B are also shown here.
The curve in Fig. 3 relates to the maximum allowable water temperature at the outlet of the coil as a function of out-let pressure for the generator of the invention to illustrate whattemperature and pressure relationship must be maintained to pre-vent nucleation. The region on the left side of the curve repre-sents no boundary layer boiling for the coil, while the shaded region on the right side of the curve represents the area to be avoided where coil boundary layer boiling does exist. According-i ly, during temperature rise of the water, the relationship be-tween the temperature and the pressure must be in the region to the left of the curve to prevent boiling. The loci of point A
from Fig. 5 is shown for water flow rates from fifty to one hundred percent if the fuel inputs of ~ig. 7 are adhered to.
The curves shown in Fig. 4 represent the limiting hot water generator outlet water pressure and temperature as a func-tion of the water flow rate for the prevention of boiling in the coil boundary layer therein. Heater outlet temperature in degrees Farenheit is plotted along the horizontal, while heater outlet pressure in psia is plotted along the vertical. Numbers 55, 56 and 57 respectively represent fifty percent, ninety percent and one hundred percent water flow rates. Regions of no boiling are to the left of the curves, while regions of boiling are to the right of the curves. The steady state maximum temperatures allow-, .,s7 ~049Z~7 able are reached at approximately 2400 psia at temperatures of630, 638 and 642 degrees F. for the fifty, ninety and one hundred percent water flow rates. Accordingly, the 2400 psia limitation is indicated as a "trip" point which is a pressure that must be maintained or exceeded in order to prevent entering the boiling region which is shown in the shaded portion in Fig. 3.
The operation of the generator of the present invention according to changing from low fire to high fire conditions in-volves raising a nominal or residual temperature at low fire and establishement of the water flow rate at a value corresponding to the amount of heat required. This is illustrated in Fig. 7. The curves in Fig. 7 show heat transfer to the water in btu's per hour times 106 along the horizontal and heater outlet temperature in degrees Farenheit along the vertical. These curves illustrate maximum fuel fire rates allowable for operation between the low fire heater outlet temperature and maximum allowable outlet temp-erature without boundary layer boiling. The percent water flow curves are shown to be fifty, sixty, seventy, eighty, eighty-five, ninety, ninety-five, one hundred. The one hundred percent water flow rate represents the maximum heat output of the system.
These curves concern a generator system with a capability of an output of about twelve million btu's per hour. The maximum fuei firing rate will vary depending upon the water flow rate required.
Rapid application of the correct fuel and air mixture to approxi-mately fifty percent of the rated flow capacity of the generator of the present invention results in a temperature increase along the path of curve 60 where the desired heat flux capability is reached at 627 degrees F. and the associated controls for hand-ling the fuel and air mixture trip and thereby remove the heat input. A temperature higher than 635 degrees F. will cause ~049Z87 boiling at this water flow rate. Further, it is not possible to use a higher maximum fire rate. The time required to meet the 627 degree point is approximately fifty seconds.
It can be appreciated that a definite relationship exists between pressure, tempera-ture and flow rate for water heated at one hundred percent maximum firing rate without creat-ing vapor pockets. Exemplary of flow rate capacity for a genera-tor having the characteristics illustrated in Fig. 7 are as follows:

Water Flow atMinimum Flow VelocityFlow Capacity Maximum FuelInside Tube Inside Tube Firing Rates (~) (ft/sec) (lb/hr) 100 5.8 124,833 5.5 118,591 5.2 112,350 4.9 106,108 4.6 99,866 4.1 87,3~3 ~,5 74,900

2.9 62,417 The block diagram of the system shown in Fig. 8 illustrates the temperature control 39 as receiving the set point~ temperature and delivering a signal to a summing junction 65 which receives a feedback from the temperature of the hot water out (Tho) which is taken at the temperature measuring device 41 in the outlet of the heat exchanger 24. The summation of the feedback signal and the signal from the temperature con-troller is delivered to the servo motor or actuator 38 which con-trols the operation of the gas valve 31 and the damper 34. The operation of the gas valve 31 and the damper 34 results in the weight and temperature of the flue gas in the combustor and the - 17, -heat exchanger 21, 24. Load 47, which removes heat and therefore determines the temperature of the hot water into the heat ex-changer, effects the overall operation of the system.
The response to the change in set point of the tempera-ture controller during an increase in temperature is illustrated in Figs. 9, 10 and 11 as plotted against time. In Fig. 9 the control signal variation of the set point temperature (Tsp) is illustrated as being increased along the full range of temperature increase desired of about 573 to 627 degrees F. The temperature and weight of the flue gases (Tfq and Wfg) are shown in Fig. 10 in relation to the damper and valve operation. The rise in the temperature of the hot water out (Tho) of the heat exchanger is illustrated in Fig. 11. Note the dead zone 68 which is also illustrated at 69 in Fig. 6.
The change in load of the heat exchanger indicated by a decrease in temperature is illustrated with the relationship between the hot water temperature into the heat exchanger, the hot water temperature out of the heat exchanger, and the tempera-ture and weight of the flue gases in the combustor and heat exchanger sections is shown in Figs. 12, 13 and 14.
Accordingly, it will be seen from the foregoing that the hot water generator of the invention may be utilized in the method of shock testing of high performance piping components wherein it is desired to produce maximum heat flux rate without nucleation so as to provide a hot water generator with a heat exchanger of long service life.
It will be understood that modifications and variations may be effected without departing from the scope of the novel con-; cepts of the present invention, but it is understood that this application is to be limited only by the scope of the appended claims.

Claims (4)

THE EMBODIMENTS OF THE INVENTION IN WHICH AN EXCLUSIVE PROPERTY OR PRIVILEGE
IS CLAIMED ARE DEFINED AS FOLLOWS:

1. A method of thermal shock testing a high performance fabricated piping component by subjecting the component to a rapid water temperature rise without nucleation, wherein the method includes use of a hot water generator having a high turndown ratio for rapidly increasing the temperature of hot water to a point of substantially theoretical maximum heat absorption and temperature rise without nucleation, wherein the generator includes a housing defining connected coil and combustor sections, a coil in the coil section with an open central area for receiving combustion gases and defining a water flow path, an inlet and an outlet for said coil, piping connected between the inlet and outlet defining a closed loop water path, a load in the piping, a pump in the piping forcing constant water circulation through the closed loop, a fuel and air induction system including fuel and air controls coacting to deliver the proper mixture of fuel and air to the combustor section, said fuel and air induction system including a fuel line delivering fuel to the combustor section, a combustion sir line delivering combustion air to the combustor section, and means continually bleeding air directly into the fuel line to maintain stable combustion in the combustor section at minimum fire conditions, a fast response actuator for said fuel and air controls, and a temperature controller providing operating signals to the actuator in response to a set point temperature and the water temperature of the coil outlet to operate the fuel and air controls and cause a rapid rate of temperature rise in the outlet water temperature without nucleation, said method comprising the steps of mounting said component in said piping connected between the inlet and outlet of the coil, operating said generator between low and high firing rates in a short period of time to produce the maximum heat flux absorbable by the load without incurring nucleate boiling, and observing the function of said component.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of operating the generator between low and high firing rates includes monitoring the temperature of the water at the coil outlet to control the increase of firing rate between low and high and prevent nucleation at the coil-water interface.

3. The method of claim 1, wherein the step of operating the generator between low and high firing rates includes circulating the water in the closed loop and controlling the flow rate to maintain a pressure related to the water temperature to limit the maximum temperature rise just below the incipient nucleate boiling point of the water.

4. A method of thermal shock testing a high performance fabricated piping component by subjecting the component to a rapid water temperature rise without nucleation, wherein the method includes use of a hot water generator having a housing defining connected coil and combustor sections, a coil axially aligned in the coil section with an open central area for receiving combustion gases and defining a water flow path, an inlet and an outlet for said coil, piping outside the generator connected between the inlet and outlet of the coil to define therewith a continuous closed loop water flow path, a load in the piping, a pump in the piping causing a constant water flow in the flow path, a fuel and air induction system including a fuel burner delivering fuel to the combustor section and a blower for producing and delivering combustion air to the combustor section, a fuel line having a fuel metering valve therein and connected to the burner to deliver fuel thereto, a duct connecting the blower to the combustor section and having means therein for controlling the amount of combustion air to the combustor section, and means for maintaining stable combustion in the combustor section at minimum air-fuel openings comprising a combustion air bleed line ahead of the combustion air controlling means for continually bleeding a small amount of air directly into the fuel line downstream of the fuel metering valve, said method comprising the steps of mounting said component in said piping connected between the inlet and outlet of the coil, operating said generator between low and high firing rates in a short period of time to produce the maximum heat flux absorb-able by the load without incurring nucleate boiling and observing the function of said component.