AU613782B2 - Container sealing compositions - Google Patents

Description

i 7' DPI DATE 23/01/90 APPLN- ID 39675 89 AOJP DATE 22/02/90 6 1 T MB 7 F®/G /00724 XTREA TY (PCT) 1(51) International Patent Classification 5 C09K 3/10, C08L 13/02 (11) International Publication Number: Al (43) international Publication Date: WO 90/00186 11 January 1990 (11.01.90) (21) International Application Number: (22) International Filing Date: PCT/GB89/00724 29 June 1989 (29.06.89) Priority data: 8815489.3 (81) Designated States: AT (European patent), AU, BE (European patent), CH (European patent), DE (European patent), FR (European patent), GB (European patent), IT (European patent), JP, LU (European patent), NL (European patent), SE (European patent), US.

Published With international search report.

Before the expiration of the time limit for amending the claims and to be republished in the event of the receipt of amendments.

29 June 1988 (29.06.88) (71) Applicant (for all designated States except US): W.R. GRACE CO.-CONN. [US/US]; 1114 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10036 (US).

(72) Inventors; and Inventors/Applicants (for US only) BLAKEMAN, Peter, John [GB/GB]; 15 Dove Road, Bedford MK41 7AA JOHNSON, Terence, Richard [GB/GB]; 21 Chaucer Place, Eaton Ford, St. Neots, Huntingdon, Cambs.

PE19 3LS (GB).

(74) Agent: LAWRENCE, Peter, Robin, Broughton; Gill Jennings Every, 53 to 64 Chancery Lane, London WC2A IHN (GB).

(54) Title: CONTAINER SEALING COMPOSITIONS (57) Abstract A container sealing latex composition is formed from a carboxylated styrene butadiene elastomer wherein the carboxyl groups are preferably provided by methacrylic acid, and the composition is substantially free of active cross linking agent and preferably includes latent cross linking agent and stabiliser such as casein, rosin acid, styrene maleic anhydride copolymer or fatty acid.

I i WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 1 Container Sealing Compositions It is well known to form can sealing latex compositions by blending one or more latices of elastomeric material with additives such as tackifier resin, stabiliser and filler. In use, the liquid latex is lined on to, for instance, a can end and dried to form a gasket or other dried deposit.

Numerous synthetic elastomer latices have been proposed. Styrene butadiene rubbers have been widely mentioned and used. Often such rubbers (SBR) have been described as carboxylated. Typical disclosures of latex compositions are in GB 2,084,600 and EP 182674.

It is known that these carboxylated styrene butadiene rubbers have always been copolymers of styrene with butadiene and fumaric acid as the ethylenically unsaturated acid that provides the carboxylic groups.

This is known from, for instance, the submissions that have had to be made by the manufacturers to various governmental agencies for permission to use the latices in connection with food packaging. It appears that no other carboxylic acids have ever been used for carboxylation of the SBR latices used in container sealing compositions.

The use of fumaric-carboxylated latices does, as would be expected, give improvements (relative to the corresponding uncarboxylated latex) in for instance mechanical stability and adhesion. It is of particular importance that the container sealing composition gives good sealing performance in practical use. Tests for this are the biological seal test and the extrusion test, as described in GB 2084600. We have found that the carboxylated latex does not generally give an improvement in these tests and indeed can result in inferior extrusion test results.

L

I WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 2 When the latex is carboxylated, there is the possibility of the elastomer being cross linked by ionic cross linking agents, and this will result in a change of properties. The cross linking can, depending upon conditions, occur either in the liquid latex composition or during or after the drying of the lined gasket or other deposit. If conditions are such that cross linking occurs in the latex it could tend to destabilise the latex and thus increase the viscosity, and possibly even cause coagulation, of the composition. This tendency for viscosification or coagulation can be counteracted by using a sufficiently large amount of certain types of stabiliser. The stabilisers that are effective for this purpose are those that are relatively resistant to cross linking, for instance materials such as sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate or other synthetic surfactants containing sulphonate groups. However the use of such surfactants in the required amounts tends to render the final gasket more hydrophilic, in the sense that it is more receptive to deterioration of its properties in the presence of water. This can be the opposite of the effect that the cross linking is intended to promote.

One such system is described in JP-A-61-145273.

This describes a sealing composition based on a carboxylic-modified styrene butadiene rubber together with 5 to 150 parts tackifier and 0.5 to 130 parts zinc oxide (as cross linking agent), the parts being by weight per 100 parts by weight of the rubber (PHR) The description makes it clear that optimum properties are, for the tests described in that application, achieved when the amount of zinc oxide is relatively high, for instance at least 10 parts and often much more. In most of the examples the amount of zinc oxide is 47.5 parts.

Although various stabilisers are mentioned in the general 4 WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 description, the one that is used in all the examples is sodium dodecyl benzyl sulphonate. As explained above, this is a material that is inert to the cross linker but which renders the gasket relatively hydrophilic.

The latex that is used in all the examples and that is recommended in JP-A-61-145273 is, as is customary in the art, a latex made using fumaric acid as the ethylenically unsaturated carboxylic acid. However the patent also mentions that the acid could be maleic acid, maleic anhydride, acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, crotonic acid, itaconic acid, itaconic anhydride, aconitic acid or tetrahydrophthalic acid or others.

Accordingly this disclosure does not alter the general state of the art, and in particular the use in practice of fumaric acid as the source of the carboxylic groups in the carboxylated styrene butadiene rubber.

It is known to be possible to reduce the hydrophilic properties of gaskets made from a rubber latex by using a stabiliser that becomes cross linked substantially only during or after drying. Thus it is known to use a combination of a stabiliser that contains cross linkable (generally carboxylic) groups and a latent cross linker, a material that causes cross linking in the dried gasket but not in the liquid latex. This latent cross linker is often termed a "waterproofing agent" as it is present to reduce the hydrophilic properties of the gasket. One such material is zinc ammonium benzoate.

The zinc ions are complexed by ammonia so as to be substantially inert in the liquid composition. Upon drying, ammonia is liberated and the zinc becomes available for reaction and cross links the stabiliser.

Presumably the liberated zinc will also cross link the carboxylic groups of carboxylated SBR if that is used as part or all of the rubber. The effect is to increase 4 the water resistance of the dried gasket or other deposit.

It should be appreciated that throughout this specification we use the term "cross link" to refer to two or more molecules becoming linked by reaction with a single polyvalent metal ion or other cross linking agent.

If large amounts of zinc oxide or other active cross linker are included in such compositions (as proposed in JP-A-61-145723) the zinc oxide will naturally tend to cross link the carboxylic-containing stabiliser in the liquid composition, and this will tend to result in additional destabilisation of the liquid latex. This in turn necessitates the addition of further stabiliser (preferably a sulphonate surfactant) and this reduces the water resistance of the gasket.

It would be desirable to be able to provide a latex that retains the advantages of the fumaric-carboxylated latices and which can give better overall sealing performance.

A container sealing latex composition according to the invention comprisesA a latex of carboxylated styrene butadiene elastomer formed by polymerisation with an ethylenically unsaturated acid, and into which has been dispersed additives selected from the group comprising filler, tackifier, stabiliser, active cross linking agent and latent cross linking agent characterised in that the ethylenically unsaturated acid is selected from methacrylic acid, acrylic acid and itaconic acid and the composition is substantially free of active cross linking agent.

Thus in the invention we replace the fumaric acid that has always, so far as we are aware, been used commercially for carboxylation of SBR for container sealing, latex, compositions and we use methacrylic, acrylic or itaconic acid. We have found that (provided i RA4/ -r TV o' af i I I WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 the composition is free of active cross linker) this can lead to surprising improvement in sealing performance.

Although the use of any of the three acids can give improved biological seal properties (relative to the use of the corresponding uncarboxylated or fumaric-carboxylated latex) the use of methacrylic acid gives the best overall performance and so is strongly preferred for use in the invention. The invention is of particular value when the composition includes a cross linkable stabiliser and a latent cross linker.

The defined acids can be used individually or as mixtures with each other or with another carboxylic acid (generally in a lesser amount), but preferably methacrylic acid is used as part (and most preferably all) the carboxylic acid.

Although the amount of methacrylic or other carboxylic acid can be, for instance, 0.5 to 6% by weight of the elastomer, preferably the amount is 0.5 to 3%, most preferably 0.8 to 2%.

The methacrylic or other acid may be copolymerised into the styrene butadiene rubber by techniques that are conventional for the copolymerisation of styrene, butadiene and fumaric acid. Generally it is polymerised in alkali salt form.

The proportions of styrene and butadiene are generally each 30 to 70% (based on 100 parts by weight styrene plus butadiene). Typically the amount of butadiene is 35 to 55% (generally 40 to 49%) and the amount of styrene is 45 to 65% (generally 51 to The rubber typically has a Mooney viscosity of 35 to (1 4 at 125°C) using the standard large rotor.

A blend of elastomer latices may be used in which event the defined carboxylated latex generally provides at least 30%, usually at least 50%, by weight total rubber solids. Other elastomer latices that can be used i~L i

XIA

I

A

II

WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 6 can be selected from those listed in GB 2,084,600 but would preferably be other styrene butadiene rubbers.

These could be carboxylated but are preferably uncarboxylated.

The container sealing composition is provided by dispersing the desired additives into the latex (which can be a mixture of latices, as explained above). The additives can be selected from any of those that are conventional for incorporation in container sealing latex compositions and these include materials such as filler, tackifier, stabiliser, latent cross linking agent, active cross linking agent and other conventional materials.

The composition is preferably substantially free of active cross linking agent. Active cross linking agents are materials that will cause cross linking in the liquid composition of carboxylic groups in the carboxylated SBR and/or in any carboxylated stabiliser that is present, this cross linking then tending to cause instability or other undesirable properties in the latex liquid composition. The active cross linkers are generally ionic materials and are usually polyvalent metal compounds such as zinc oxide or zinc or other metal salts in which the polyvalent metal ion is available in the liquid latex for causing cross linking. Small amounts of active cross linker can be tolerated since they may give no destabilisation of the latex either because they are converted to a latent form by other components of the latex or because the extent of cross linking of the carboxylated SBR and/or carboxylated stabiliser (if present) is sufficiently low that instability and other undesirable properties are not caused. Generally therefore the amount of active cross linker is always well below 5PHR (parts by weight per hundred parts rubber) and usually below 2PHR and most usually below 0.5PHR. If active cross linker is present, its amount

L

i i t murYI;,~ r~ujtwi-:;,: I 1

I.,

WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 is generally in the range 0.1 to 0.4PHR but preferably the amount is zero, it is totally absent.

The composition preferably contains latent cross linking agent, that is to say cross linking agent that does not react with the carboxylic groups of the carboxylated latex and/or carboxylated stabiliser (if present) sufficient to cause significant cross linking in the liquid composition, but will cause cross linking upon drying of a gasket or other deposit formed from the liquid latex.

The latent cross linking agent typically comprises a polyvalent metal compound wherein the polyvalent metal ions are chelated with a volatile chelating agent. This chelating agent substantially prevents the metal ions being available for cross linking in the liquid latex but upon drying of the deposit the chelating agent volatilises thereby liberating the polyvalent metal ions which thus become available as active cross linking agents. Ammonia is a convenient volatile chelating agent but various other volatile amines and volatile amino compounds may be used. The polyvalent metal compound typically is a salt of the polyvalent metal with a carboxylic acid in the presence of the chelating agent.

The carboxylic acid is preferably benzoic or citric acid, but other relatively weak aliphatic or aromatic acids can be used. Preferred materials are zinc ammonium benzoate and zinc ammonium citrate. Typically the materials that are already known as water proofing agents for latices containing carboxylated stabilisers are suitable. The amount of zinc ammonium benzoate or other water proofing agent can be selected to obtain optimum properties in any particular composition, dependent for instance upon the amount and nature of the stabiliser. Generally the amount is in the range 0.2 to 12PHR, often 0.2 to 4PHR (as dry weight of the active cross linker that is formed jt" 1 -i<l i WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 8 from the latent cross linker, the metal carboxylate).

It is possible for the compositions of the invention to include stabilisers that are relatively inert to the latent cross linking agent (during drying). Stabilisers of this type are ethylene oxide ethers and synthetic aromatic sulphonates, for instance sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate. However it is generally desirable to minimise the amounts of such materials since they increase the water sensitivity of the compositions. If such materials are present, they should always be present in very low quantities, generally well below 3PHR and preferably well below 1PHR, most preferably below Preferably such materials are totally absent. It must, however, of course be appreciated that non-carboxylated emulsifiers may have been incorporated during the production of the initial latex of 7-rnoxylated SBR as oil-in-water emulsifiers, and the compositions will generally therefore additionally contain the oil-in-water emulsifier that was required for production of the initial latex.

The stabilisers that are added to the composition during the formulation of the latex with the other additives that are necessary to render it into a container sealing composition preferably therefore include, and most usually consist of, stabilisers that can be cross linked during drying, as a result of the inclusion of latent cross linking agent in the liquid latex. Such stabilisers have free carboxylic groups.

One preferred stabiliser of this type is casein.

Typically this is present in amounts of 10 to 20PHR, in which event the amount of latent cross linker may be up to 12PHR, typically 6 to 12PHR.

Another stabiliser is styrene maleic anhydride copolymer (which may be partially esterified).

r- WO90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 9 Typically this is present in amounts of 3 to 10PHR in which event the amount of latent cross linking agent typically is up to 9PHR, preferably 1 to 9PHR.

Another stabiliser is a resin acid such as rosin acid, and such materials are typically present in amounts of 1 to 6PHR in which event the amount of latent cross linking agent is usually up to 2PHR, preferably 0.2 to 2PHR.

Another stabiliser is a fatty acid or a water soluble salt thereof, for instance sodium or ammonium salt, typical acids being oleic acid, stearic acid, palmitic acid, lauric acid or myristic acid. The amount of fatty acid is typically 1 to 8PHR in which event the amount of latent cross linking agent is typically up to 3PHR, preferably 0.2 to 3PHR. All these amounts are calculated on the dry weight of the final cross linker compound, zinc benzoate.

The optimum amount of stabiliser in any particular instance depends also on the amount of filler, with higher amounts of filler tending to require the use of higher amounts of stabiliser. The amount must therefore be selected to impart the desired storage stability and lining characteristics to the liquid latex and, in particular, to ensure that the liquid latex does not coagulate or thicken undesirably upon storage.

The preferred fillers are kaolin or china clay but others that can be used include colloidal silica and other silicic fillers, synthetic silicates, calcium carbonate, talc or dolomite. Glass beads can be used.

The filler typically has a particle size up to 50 microns but some or all of the filler can be of pigmentary grade, having a particle size below 5 microns. For instance carbon black may be incorporated.

The compositions may include tackifier resins and/or other conventional additives. Suitable materials, and k WO 90/00186 PCT/G B89/00724 suitable amounts of all the components, are described in GB 2,084,600.

The latex compositions of the invention can be formulated and then used as can or other container sealing compositions in known manner, for instance as descibed in GB 2,084,600.

The invention includes can or other container ends that are lined with the dried composition, sealed containers in which the dried composition serves as a gasket, methods of making the container ends by lining them with the composition and then drying it, and methods of sealing the containers using an end carrying a gasket of the dried composition.

As explained, the invention requires the use of the specified acid, rather than fumaric acid, as the unsaturated acid that is used in the manufacture of the carboxylated SBR. The use of the resultant latex in container sealing compositions containing conventional additives but which are free or substantially free of active cross linking agent gives performance benefits, including water resistance, that are not obtainable when using fumaric acid as the acid in all such compositions and that are not obtainable when using the specified acid in compositions containing large amounts of active cross linking agent. The invention is of particular value when, as is preferred, the composition includes stabilisers that can be cross linked by latent cross linking agent, which is also present in the composition.

The performance benefits that are obtained include improved water resistance and include sealing performance both when exposed to wholly aqueous compositions and when exposed to oil or fat-containing compositions.

The following are examples of the invention.

Example 1 WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 11 Three latex compositions were formed by blending 100 parts by weight of a latex of sty.rene butadiene rubber based on the dry rubber content of the latex, filler, 17.5pbw aqueous thickeners, 25pbw tackifier resin, Ipbw rosin acid as hydrophilic stabiliser, 2pbw of a 19% aqueous solution of zinc ammonium benzoate (providing about 0.4pbw dry weight zinc benzoate) waterproofing agent, pH adjuster to pH1O and minor amounts of conventional additives.

Can ends were lined with the compositions in conventional manner. They were subjected to compound extrusion and biological seal tests, both with and without fat, to determine their effectiveness as gaskets.

In composition A the rubber was conventional, non-carboxylated butadiene styrene rubber of about 52% styrene and 48% butadiene. In composition B, the rubber was a conventional copolymer with fumaric acid of about 58% styrene, 39% butadiene and 3% fumaric acid.

In composition C, the rubber was about 52.5% styrene, 46% butadiene and 1.5% methacrylic acid.

In composition D, the rubber was the same as in C except that itaconic acid was used instead of methacrylic acid. In composition E, the carboxylated latex is believed to have been formed using 3% acrylic acid as the carboxylic acid.

The results are given in the table I. The tests are described in GB 2,084,600. CF stands for chicken fat and SF stands for steam flow.

PCT/GB89/00724 WO 90/00186 12 Table 1 Sealing Performance Compound Latex Bio Bio CF Bio SF Extrusion A 125 150 420 0.0 B 150 160 405 2..4 C 10 60 150 0.8 D 10 35 170 2.3 E 30 30 150 This clearly demonstrates the greatly improved overall sealing performance obtained using composition C, in which the unsaturated acid is methacrylic acid, compared to composition A (uncarboxylated) and composition B, in which the acid is fumaric acid. It also shows that compositions D and E give improved biological seal performance compared to A and B, but that the extrusion performance of D and E is less satisfactory than C and A.

Example 2 Compositions as described in Example 1C were formulated with amounts of 19% aqueous zinc ammonium benzoate solution ranging from zero to 10PHR (0 to 2PHR dry weight). The degree of swelling of the resultant dried gasket after exposure to toluene under standard conditions was recorded. The same test was also applied to a composition in which zinc benzoate was omitted and zinc oxide was included. The results are as follows.

I I h 1 WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 13 Table 2 Zinc Ammonium Viscosity Benzoate after 8 days Swelling 0 low 69% 2 low 4 low 72% 6 low 69% low 58% ZnO high 58% It is apparent from this table that significant instability is created when the amount of zinc oxide is whereas the liquid composition is stable at aqueous latent cross linking agent (2PHR dry weight) What is particularly interesting is that the swelling performance in oil is substantially the same using the lOPr{R aqueous latent cross linking agent (that gives a stable liquid composition) and the 5PHR zinc oxide (that gives an unstable composition) Example 3 In order to demonstrate the effect of various polyvalent metal compounds on the carboxylated SBR latex alone (in the absence of added stabiliser), the latex used in Example IC was formulated with amounts of zinc oxide ranging from 1 to 5OP-R, or with amounts of barium sulphate ranging from 1 to 35PHR or with various amounts of zinc ammonium benzoate. There is no sign of latex instability when using barium sulphate. When using higher amounts of zinc benzoate viscositN, increase tended to occur upon storage. In those tests using zinc oxide alone, slight coagulation occurred substantially immediately when using 1PHR zinc oxide and, the extent of WO 90/00186 PCT/G B9/00724 14 coagulation increased as the amount of zinc oxide increased.

This is further confirmation that although trivially low amounts of zinc oxide may not cause significant cross linking and destabilisation (and minor amounts of destabilisation can be compensated for by minor additions of surfactant) larger amounts of zinc oxide are highly detrimental to stability and could only be compensated for by increasing the amount of surfactant, with the consequential disadvantages of this.

Example 4 In order to observe the water resistance of compositions made using a latent cross linker and a cross linkable or non cross linkable stabiliser, compositions were prepared using a carbcxylated SBR latex made using methacrylic acid. Films were cast from the compositions and dried at 105'C for 45 minutes, stored over phosphorus pentoxide for 24 hours, and then exposed to 100% relative himidity for 3 hours. The increase in weight at different times during the exposure was recorded.

The compositions (expressed in PHR) and the weight increase are shown in Table 3.

I

extrusion test results.

i WO 90/00186 PCF/GB89/00724 Table 3 Composition latex 100 100 China clay 85 19% aq. Zinc.

amm. benzoate 2 2 Rosin acid 1 0 Dodecyl benzene sulphonate 0 1 weight increase 1 hour 0.85 1.66 2 hours 1.03 1.72 3 hours 1.11 1.50 This clearly demonstrates the reduced water absorption in the presence of a cross linkable stabiliser rather than a sulphonate surfactant.

It- r

Claims (14)

1. A container sealing latex composition comprising 4 a latex of rubbery polymer that is carboxylated styrene butadiene elastomer formed by copolymerisation with an ethylenically unsaturated acid and into which has been dispersed additives selected from the group comprising filler, tackifier, stabiliser, and latent cross linking agent characterised in that the ethylenically unsaturated acid is selected from methacrylic acid, acrylic acid and itaconic acid and the composition contains active cross linking agent in an amount sufficiently low that instability is not caused. ii i EJD I .n L. I L q_ .1 WO 90/00186 PCT/GB89/00724 16 'CLAIMS- 1. A container sealing latex composition comprising a latex of rubbery polymer that is a carboxylated srene butadiene elastomer formed by copolymerisa *on with an ethylenically unsaturated acid and ot which has been dispersed additives selected fm the group comprising filler, tackifier, stabi er, active cross linking agent and latent cross ing agent characterised in that the ethylenical unsaturated acid is selected from meth ylic acid, acrylic acid and itaconic acid and the mposition is substantially free of active cross linking agent.

2. A composition according to claim 1 in which the acid is methacrylic acid.

3. A composition according to claim 1 in which the amount of active cross linking agent is zero.

4. A composition according to claim 1 in which the composition includes stabiliser that can be cross linked by polyvalent metal compound.

5. A composition according to claim 4 including latent cross linking agent.

6. A composition according to claim 1 in which the acid is methacrylic acid and the composition inclv es stabiliser that can be cross linked by polyvalent metal compound and the composition includes latent cross linking agent that causes cross linking of the stabiliser subatan-tially only upon drying of the composition.

7. A composition according to claim 6 that includes stabiliser selected from casein, resin acids, styrene maleic anhydride copolymers, and fatty acids or salts thereof.

8. A composition according to claim 6 in which the latent cross linking agent comprises a polyvalent metal salt of a carboxylic acid wherein the polyvalent metal is complexed with a volatile chelating agent. \tMvS Z ifo-' WO 90/00186 PC/GB89/00724 17

9. A composition according to claim 6 in which the latent cross linking agent comprises zinc ammonium benzoate or citrate.

A composition according to claim 1 in which the amount of the said acid is 0.5 to 3% by weight of the elastomer.

11. A composition according to claim 1 in which the acid is methacrylic acid and its amount is 0.8 to 2% by weight of the elastomer.

12. A composition according to claim 1 in which the amount of butadiene in the elastomer is 35 to 55% and the amount of styrene is 45 to 65% and the rubber has a Mooney viscosity of 35 to

13. A container closure lined with a gasket formed by applying a composition according to any preceding claim and drying the composition.

14. A sealed container closed by a closure according to claim 13. 1 1 J U. Denh. ir active cross linker is present, its amount aa 'Maw- 1 18 A container sealing latex composition substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of Examples 1C, 2, 3 or 4. DATED: 23 January 1991 PHILLIPS ORMONDE FITZPATRICK Attorneys for: W.R. GRACE CO.-CONN 0 0 0 0 *0. 00 0 0 0 0 0000 0000 SO 0 0 00 00 00 0 0 0 0 00. 0 00 0 *00 0 0 0 0 0 00* I EJD A' I L INTERNATIONAL SEARCH REPORT International Application No PCT/GB 89 00724 1. CLASSIFICATION OF SUBJECT MATTER (if several classification symools apply, indicate all) According to International Patent Classification (IPC) or to both National Classification and IPC IPC 5 C 09 K 3/10, C 08 L 13/02 II. FIELDS SEARCHED Minimum Documentation Searched 7 Classification System j Classification Symbols C 09 K, C 08 L Documentation Searched other than Minimum Documentation to the Extent that such Documents are Included In the Fields Searched 6 Ill. DOCUMENTS CONSIDERED TO BE RELEVANT' Category* Citation of Document, it with indication, where appropriate, of the relevant passagest l I Relevant to Clam No. Y EP, A, 0182674 (GRACE) 28 May 1986, 1-7,11-14 see claims 1,3,5; page 5, line page 6,lines 23-31 (cited in the application) Y EP, A, 0099792 (RHONE-POULENC) 1-7,11-14 1 February 1984, see claims 1-7 P,X Patent Abstracts of Japan, vol. 12, no. 496 1-14 (C-555)(3343), 23 December 1988; JP, A, 63207816 (UBE IND LTD) 29 August 1988, see the abstract A Patent Abstracts of Japan, vol. 12, no. 139 1-14 (C-491)(2986), 27 April 1988; JP, A, 62256885 (HOKKAI CAN CO LTD) 9 November 1987, see the abstract A US, A, 4544690 (LADISH) 1 October 1985 Special categories of cited documents: 'o later document published after the International filing date document defining the eneral at of the art which is not or priority date and not in conflict with the application but "oumnstder g tob e o rar ae tcited to understand the principle or theory underlying the considered to be of particular rc:evance invention earlier document but published on or after the international document of particular relevance; the claimed invention Scannot be considered novel or cannot be considered to document which may throw doubts on priority claim(s) or involve an inventive step which is cited to estabish the publication dte of another document of particular relevance;' the claimed invention citation or other special reason (as speciied) cannot be considered to involve an inventive step when the document referring to an oral disclosure, use, exhibition or document is combined with one or more other such docu- other means ments, such comoination being obvious to a person skilled document oublished prior to the international filing date but in the art. later than the priority date claimed document member of the same patent family IV. CERTIFICATION :1 Vi Date of the Actual Completion of the International Search 13th October 1989 International Searching Authority EUROPEAN PATENT OFFICE Date of Mailing of this International Search Report 2 3 1' 9 h. Signature ol Aulh T.K. WILLIS- Form PCT/ISA/210 Isecond sheet) (January 1985) .1 ANNEX TO THE INTERNATIONAL SEARCH REPORT ON INTERNATIONAL PATENT APPLICATION NO. GB 8900724 SA 29805 This annex lists the patent family members relating to the patent documents cited in the above-mentioned international search report. The members are as contained in the European Patent Office EDP file on 14/11/89 The European Patent Office is in no way liable for these particulars which are merely given for the purpose of information. EP-A- 0182674 28-05-86 JP-A- 61185511 19-08-86 EP-A- 0099792 01-02-84 FR-A,B 2529899 13-01-84 JP-A- 59062653 10-04-84 US-A- 4503184 .05-03-85 US-A- 4544690 01-10-85 None SFor more details about this annex :see Official Journal of the European P~atent Office, N'o. 12/82 -Ii'