AU2018214541A1 - Molded bristle brushes comprised of helical segments - Google Patents

Molded bristle brushes comprised of helical segments Download PDF

Info

Publication number
AU2018214541A1
AU2018214541A1 AU2018214541A AU2018214541A AU2018214541A1 AU 2018214541 A1 AU2018214541 A1 AU 2018214541A1 AU 2018214541 A AU2018214541 A AU 2018214541A AU 2018214541 A AU2018214541 A AU 2018214541A AU 2018214541 A1 AU2018214541 A1 AU 2018214541A1
Authority
AU
Australia
Prior art keywords
helical
brush head
segments
core
bristle
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Abandoned
Application number
AU2018214541A
Inventor
Herve Bouix
Francis Corbellini
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
ELC Management LLC
Original Assignee
ELC Management LLC
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by ELC Management LLC filed Critical ELC Management LLC
Publication of AU2018214541A1 publication Critical patent/AU2018214541A1/en
Abandoned legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B9/00Arrangements of the bristles in the brush body
    • A46B9/02Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups
    • A46B9/023Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups arranged like in hair brushes, e.g. hair treatment, dyeing, streaking
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B9/00Arrangements of the bristles in the brush body
    • A46B9/02Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups
    • A46B9/021Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups arranged like in cosmetics brushes, e.g. mascara, nail polish, eye shadow
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B9/00Arrangements of the bristles in the brush body
    • A46B9/02Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups
    • A46B9/025Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups the bristles or the tufts being arranged in an angled position relative to each other
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B9/00Arrangements of the bristles in the brush body
    • A46B9/02Position or arrangement of bristles in relation to surface of the brush body, e.g. inclined, in rows, in groups
    • A46B9/028Bristle profile, the end of the bristle defining a surface other than a single plane or deviating from a simple geometric form, e.g. cylinder, sphere or cone
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B2200/00Brushes characterized by their functions, uses or applications
    • A46B2200/10For human or animal care
    • A46B2200/104Hair brush
    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A46BRUSHWARE
    • A46BBRUSHES
    • A46B2200/00Brushes characterized by their functions, uses or applications
    • A46B2200/10For human or animal care
    • A46B2200/1046Brush used for applying cosmetics
    • A46B2200/1053Cosmetics applicator specifically for mascara

Landscapes

  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Geometry (AREA)
  • Brushes (AREA)

Abstract

A molded bristle applicator having a cylindrical core on which are arranged a number of discrete helical bristle segments. Depending on the embodiment, all of the discrete helical segments spiral in the same direction (i.e. clockwise or counterclockwise) around the axis of the core, or some helical segments spiral in one direction and some in the opposite direction.

Description

Molded Bristle Brushes Comprised Of Helical Segments
Field of the Invention
The invention is in the field of cosmetic applicators, and concerns molded brushes whose bristles are arranged in helical segments. The unique bristle arrangements offer new experiences in delivery and grooming of eyelashes and eyebrows.
Background
In the present specification, we treat the terms “helix” and “spiral” as synonymous. The properties of helices are well known in geometry. A spiral or helix is a three-dimensional curve that has a central, longitudinal axis. At any point on the helix, the angle between the tangent line and the axis is constant. We can speak of the cylindrical helix in which the radius of curvature is constant, or conical and spherical helices in which the radius of curvature varies continuously. The pitch of a helix is the height of one complete helix turn, measured parallel to the axis of the helix. A double or triple helix consists of two or three (typically congruent) spirals that share the same axis, differing by a translation along the axis.
A brush head with a cylindrical core has a central, longitudinal axis. Many arrangements of bristles on the cylindrical core are known, including spiral (i.e. helical) arrangements. The most common example of spiral arrangement is the twisted wire core brush. In this classic brush, the bristles typically form one continuous helix from one end of the bristle envelope to the other. (The “bristle envelope” is the three dimensional surface defined by the free ends of all of the bristles in the brush head.) Thus, the brush is made up of exactly one helical segment of bristles which always twists in the same direction, from one end of the brush to the other.
In contrast, US 6,341,913 discloses a twisted wire core brush in which a first portion of the bristles spirals along the core in a clockwise direction, and a second portion of bristles spirals down the core in a counterclockwise direction. The two bristle portions meet in the middle of the wire core to form one continuous arrangement of bristles from one end of the wire core to the other. This is unlike the
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642 present invention in which the bristles emanating from a core are arranged in multiple discrete helical segments.
Each of US 4,600,328 and US 5,611,361 disclose a dual-brush mascara applicator. Each brush comprises a twisted wire core that has a spiral arrangement of bristles, such that the bristles on one brush spiral in the clockwise direction, while the bristles on the second brush spiral in the counterclockwise direction. For each brush, the bristle portion is one continuous spiral that extends from one end of the wire core to the other. This is unlike the present invention in which all of the bristles emanate from a single core, and are arranged in multiple discrete helical segments, some of which spiral in a clockwise direction and some of which spiral in a counterclockwise direction on the single core.
Summary
The invention includes a molded bristle applicator having a cylindrical core on which are arranged a number of discrete helical bristle segments. Depending on the embodiment, all of the discrete helical segments spiral in the same direction (i.e. clockwise or counterclockwise) around the axis of the core, or some helical segments spiral in one direction and some in the opposite direction.
Description of the Figures
Figure 1A is an elevation view of a first embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 1B depicts the brush of figure 1 A, partially constructed.
Figure 2A is an elevation view of a second embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 2B depicts the brush of figure 2A, partially constructed.
Figure 3A is an elevation view of a third embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 3B depicts the brush of figure 3A, partially constructed.
Figure 4A is an elevation view of a fourth embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 4B depicts the brush of figure 4A, partially constructed.
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642
Figure 5A is an elevation view of a fifth embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 5B depicts the brush of figure 5A, partially constructed.
Figure 6A is an elevation view of a sixth embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 6B depicts the brush of figure 6A, partially constructed.
Figure 7A is an elevation view of a seventh embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 7B depicts the brush of figure 7A, partially constructed.
Figure 7C is a perspective view of the brush of figure 7A, partially constructed.
Figure 8A is an elevation view of a eighth embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 8B depicts the brush of figure 8A, partially constructed.
Figure 8C is a perspective view of the brush of figure 8A, partially constructed.
Figure 9A is an elevation view of a ninth embodiment of molded brush comprised of helical segments.
Figure 9B depicts the brush of figure 9A, partially constructed.
Figure 9C is an end view of the brush of figure 9A; the varying bristle heights are evident.
Figures 10A - 10E conceptualize the construction of one embodiment of a brush according to the invention.
Detailed Description of the Invention
In what follows, the distribution of bristles on a cosmetic brush head will be discussed in terms of cylindrical helices, but the principles of the invention may be applied to other types of helices, such as conical or spherical.
Referring to figure 1A, a brush head (10) according to the invention is comprised of a molded core (1) and multiple discrete helical segments (3, 3’) of molded bristles (3a) that arise from the core. The core is comprised of at least one straight section and, optionally, one or more curved sections. The straight section of the core is straight, except for slight deviations due to manufacturing tolerances. The straight section of the core is defined by a longitudinal axis, A-A. This axis is also the
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642 helical axis around which the helical segments of bristles are arranged on the straight section of the core.
Throughout this specification, when describing the direction of a helical segment of bristles (3a), the observer is looking down the longitudinal axis of the brush head, from proximal to distal, i.e. from the end that attaches to an applicator stem toward the free end of the brush head. From this vantage point, each bristle segment may twist (or spiral) in a clockwise direction or a counterclockwise direction, but not both. In the drawings, bristle segments that twist clockwise are labelled (3), and those that twist counter-clockwise are labelled (3’), as shown in figure 1B.
Figures 10A - 10E is a conceptualization of the construction of one embodiment of a brush head according to the invention. Figure 10A shows a core (1) depending from a stem (2). The core is divided in half by an imaginary plane (P1) indicating that the helical bristle segments (3 and 3’) will extend for half the length of the core. Figure 10B shows the imaginary line (1a) which is a helical segment whose axis is the longitudinal axis (A-A) of the core. The line (1 a) indicates the position of a first counter-clockwise helical bristle segment (3’). Figure 10B also shows the imaginary line (1 b) of a second helical bristle segment. The line (1 b) indicates the position of a first clockwise helical bristle segment (3). The bases of the bristles (3a) will lie on these lines. From one end to the other, each helical line (1a) or (1b) makes a 1/3 turn around the core, albeit, in opposite directions, and each line has the same pitch. Thus, in this embodiment, helical lines (1 a) and (1 b) are mirror images of each other through the imaginary plane (P1). In contrast, figure 10C shows the situation when the second helical curve (1b’) makes a % turn around the core. In this case, helical lines (1 a) and (1 b’) are not mirror images of each other. Figure 10D shows bristles (3a) formed along the helical lines (1a) and (1b) of figure 10B. When the process is repeated circumferentially around the core, for a total of 6 times, the result is the brush head shown in figure 10E. The number of variations in the placement of helical bristle segments (3) on a core (1) is unlimited. Some of the fully formed brush heads are shown in figures 1A to 9A. To better see the underlying pattern, figures 1B to 9B show partially constructed brush heads.
Feature 1: Direction of spiral of the helical segments of bristles
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642
Optionally, all of the helical bristle segments in a brush head may twist in the same direction. Alternatively, at least one bristle segment will twist clockwise and one counterclockwise. The clockwise and counterclockwise bristle segments may be arranged in a number of patterns. For example, some bristle arrangements are such that all of the bristles (3a) on a proximal half of the brush head spiral in one direction (i.e. either clockwise or counter-clockwise), and all of the bristles on a distal half of the brush head spiral in the opposite direction (i.e. either counter-clockwise or clockwise, respectively; see figures 1B, 2B and 6B). This arrangement may make it easier for a user to makeup her eyelashes using only her dominant hand, and/or without having to flip the direction of the applicator. Alternatively, figures 3B, 4B, 5B, 7B, 8B and 9B depict embodiments wherein a proximal and/or distal portion of the brush head supports bristles that spiral in both directions. These arrangements may be better at coating all sides of the eyelashes with sufficient quantities of makeup.
Feature 2: The longitudinal extent of a helical segment of bristles
The longitudinal extent of any helical segment (3) may be less than, equal to or greater than half of the length of the bristle envelope. The “bristle envelope” is the three dimensional surface defined by the free ends of all of the bristles in the brush head. The length of the bristle envelope is the distance measured along the longitudinal axis (A-A) from the most proximal to the most distal bristle in the brush head. In some embodiments, every helical segment extends no more than half of the length of the bristle envelope. For example, figures 1B, 2B and 6B depict helical bristle segments that extend longitudinally for a distance equal to half of the length of the bristle envelope, while helical segments that are shorter than half the length of the bristle envelope are depicted in figures 3B, 4B, 5B, 7B, 8B and 9B. And , it is not hard to imagine embodiments of the brush head wherein some of the helical bristle segments extend longitudinally for more than half the length of the bristle envelope.
Feature 3: Pitch of a helical segment of bristles
As noted above, the pitch of a helix is the height of one complete helix turn, measured parallel to the axis of the helix. The present invention includes those arrangements wherein all of the helical segments of bristles have the same pitch, as well as those arrangements in which not all of the bristle segments have the same
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642 pitch. The density of bristles can be varied along a brush head by varying the pitch of the bristle helix. For example, on a section of the core wherein the pitch is relatively greater, the bristles will be more sparse compared to a section of the core wherein the pitch is relatively smaller. The effect can be seen in figure 6A, wherein the bristles on the distal end of the brush head are less densely arranged due to the greater helix pitch.
Feature 4: helical segments of bristles arranged in a mirror image
The arrangement of helical bristles (3a) on some brush heads may be such that the proximal and distal halves of the brush head are mirror images of each other. This can happen when all of the helical segments (3) in the brush head have the same pitch and the twist of the helical segments alternates down the axis. For example, in figures 1A and 2A the clockwise and counterclockwise helical segments alternate, and have the same pitch, while in figure 6A, the clockwise and counterclockwise helical segments alternate, but do not have the same pitch.
Other bristle arrangements included in the present invention are such that clockwise and counter-clockwise helical bristle segments are dispersed among each other along the length of the core. For example, clockwise helical bristle segments (3) may alternate with counter-clockwise helical bristle segments (3’), along the length of the core (figures 7A, 8A, 9A).
In some embodiments, every bristle belongs to either a clockwise helical segment or a counter-clockwise helical segment, but not both. In some embodiments, one or more bristles may belong to both a clockwise helical segment and a counter-clockwise helical segment. No bristle belongs to two or more helical segments of the same orientation (clockwise or counter-clockwise). That is, bristle segments that twist in the same direction (clockwise or counter-clockwise) do not cross each other; preferably, they remain parallel.
As noted above, a common example of a brush head with a spiral arrangement of bristles is the twisted wire core brush, which is made up of exactly one helical segment of bristles. Preferred embodiments of the present invention are made up of 2 - 50 helical segments or portions thereof. For example, the brush head of figure 7A has 48 helical segments or parts thereof; that of figure 8A has 40 helical segments or
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642 parts thereof; that of figure 9A has 28 helical segments; that of figures 1A and 6A have 12 helical segments; that of figure 4A has 32 helical segments; that of figure 2A has 20 helical segments.
In a single brush head according to the invention, all of the bristles (3a) do not need to be the same height or shape. Figures 7A, 8A and 9A depict brush heads with varying height bristles. The brush heads described herein are molded by standard molding methods, such as injection molding in one or more plastic or elastomeric materials. A rigid stem (2) for attaching to a handle can be unitarily molded with the core (1). Alternatively, the proximal end of the core can have a hollowed out section for receiving a rigid stem element.
In some embodiments of the invention, the core (1) may comprise more than one cylindrical section, i.e. the core may be bent. In that case, a number of discrete helical segments may be arranged on one or both cylindrical sections of the core. All of the features described above may be applied to each cylindrical section, individually, thus increasing the number of variations of the invention, and the utility of the brush head (10).
In some embodiments of the invention, the core (1) may comprise a curved section. The principles of the invention can still be applied to the curved section, by using the central longitude of the curved section as a the axis of the helical bristle segments. All of the features described above may be applicable.

Claims (9)

1. A molded brush head (10) comprising:
a cylindrical core (1) that has a longitudinal central axis (A-A); and multiple helical segments (3, 3’) of molded bristles (3a) that arise from the core (1), each helical segment being arranged helically around the longitudinal axis (AA).
2. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein all of the helical bristle segments spiral in the same direction around the longitudinal axis (A-A) of the core (1).
3. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein some of the helical bristle segments (3) spiral in the one direction around the longitudinal axis (A-A) of the core (1), and others of the helical bristle segments (3’) spiral in the opposite direction around the longitudinal axis (A-A) of the core (1).
4. The molded brush head (10) of claim 3 wherein all of the helical bristle segments (3) on a proximal half of the brush head (10) spiral in one direction, and all of the helical bristle segments (3’) on a distal half of the brush head (10) spiral in the opposite direction.
5. The molded brush head (10) of claim 3 wherein a proximal portion of the brush head (10) supports helical bristle segments (3, 3’) that spiral in both directions.
6. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein the longitudinal extent of any helical bristle segment (3, 3’) is less than half of the length of the bristle envelope.
7. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein all of the helical bristle segments have the same pitch.
8. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein all of the helical bristle segments do not have the same pitch.
WO 2018/144259
PCT/US2018/014642
9. The molded brush head (10) of claim 1 wherein the helical bristle segments (3, 3’) are arranged such that the proximal and distal halves of the brush head (10) are mirror images of each other.
AU2018214541A 2017-01-31 2018-01-22 Molded bristle brushes comprised of helical segments Abandoned AU2018214541A1 (en)

Applications Claiming Priority (3)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US201762452459P 2017-01-31 2017-01-31
US62/452,459 2017-01-31
PCT/US2018/014642 WO2018144259A1 (en) 2017-01-31 2018-01-22 Molded bristle brushes comprised of helical segments

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
AU2018214541A1 true AU2018214541A1 (en) 2019-08-01

Family

ID=62976962

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2018214541A Abandoned AU2018214541A1 (en) 2017-01-31 2018-01-22 Molded bristle brushes comprised of helical segments

Country Status (8)

Country Link
US (1) US20180213923A1 (en)
EP (1) EP3576570A4 (en)
JP (1) JP2020505161A (en)
KR (1) KR20190092594A (en)
CN (1) CN110248569A (en)
AU (1) AU2018214541A1 (en)
CA (1) CA3049261A1 (en)
WO (1) WO2018144259A1 (en)

Families Citing this family (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP7191545B2 (en) * 2018-04-27 2022-12-19 小林製薬株式会社 interdental cleaner
WO2020073447A1 (en) * 2018-10-12 2020-04-16 广州达宝文机电设备有限公司 Roller brush having multiple bristle strips wound in spiraling manner, and device
CN108937092A (en) * 2018-10-12 2018-12-07 广州达宝文机电设备有限公司 Multi-brush-strip spiral curling brush roller and device
US20210127821A1 (en) * 2019-11-01 2021-05-06 Melo R&D Llc Twisted cosmetic brush

Family Cites Families (18)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
EP1034722B1 (en) * 1999-03-12 2011-05-04 Avon Products, Inc. Applicator brush
AU5226100A (en) * 1999-07-21 2001-02-05 L'oreal Device for applying a product on keratinous fibres, in particular eyelashes or eyebrows
US6341913B1 (en) * 2001-01-09 2002-01-29 Celeste S. Wilson-Jackson Mascara brush and storage container therefor
WO2004060103A2 (en) * 2002-12-31 2004-07-22 Avon Products, Inc. Applicator brush for a cosmetic product
FR2902984B1 (en) * 2006-06-28 2009-03-20 Oreal DEVICE FOR APPLYING A PRODUCT ON LACQUERS OR EYEILS.
US8485201B2 (en) * 2007-02-21 2013-07-16 The Procter & Gamble Company Cosmetic applicator with torque limiter
WO2009141098A1 (en) * 2008-05-20 2009-11-26 Alcan Packaging Beauty Services Variable pitch mascara brush
FR2935878A1 (en) * 2008-09-17 2010-03-19 Bourjois BRUSH FOR A MASCARA APPLICATOR COMPRISING TEETH FORMING CROSSCUT RANKS.
FR2939618B1 (en) * 2008-12-11 2011-05-20 Oreal APPLICATOR FOR APPLYING A COSMETIC, MAKE-UP OR CARE PRODUCT ON KERATINIC MATERIALS
US20140216497A1 (en) * 2010-06-04 2014-08-07 Zen Design Solutions Limited Cosmetic applicator
WO2011152927A1 (en) * 2010-06-04 2011-12-08 Zen Design Solutions Limited Cosmetic applicator
US8627829B2 (en) * 2010-12-31 2014-01-14 Goody Products, Inc. Water removing hair brush
FR2983044B1 (en) * 2011-11-24 2014-02-07 Chanel Parfums Beaute APPLICATOR FOR APPLYING A PRODUCT TO LACQUERS AND / OR EYCILS COMPRISING HAIR AND TEETH
FR3012021B1 (en) * 2013-10-22 2015-11-06 Albea Services APPLICATOR FOR COSMETIC PRODUCT AND ASSOCIATED APPLICATOR ASSEMBLY
FR3013951B1 (en) * 2013-12-02 2017-01-20 Oreal APPLICATOR OF A COSMETIC, MAKE-UP OR CARE PRODUCT ON LACQUERS OR EYEBROWS
US20150327662A1 (en) * 2014-05-09 2015-11-19 Aa R&D Llc Twisted cosmetic brush
JP2016521193A (en) * 2014-05-09 2016-07-21 エーエー アールアンドディー エルエルシー Cosmetic torsion brush
EP3468412B1 (en) * 2016-06-08 2021-07-28 Société Industrielle de Matières Plastiques Applicator device for applying a fluid or pasty product to keratin fibres

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
JP2020505161A (en) 2020-02-20
CN110248569A (en) 2019-09-17
US20180213923A1 (en) 2018-08-02
CA3049261A1 (en) 2018-08-09
WO2018144259A1 (en) 2018-08-09
EP3576570A1 (en) 2019-12-11
EP3576570A4 (en) 2019-12-25
KR20190092594A (en) 2019-08-07

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US20180213923A1 (en) Molded Bristle Brushes Comprised Of Helical Segments
US8256437B2 (en) Mascara brush including bristles of various diameters
JP5824029B2 (en) Applicator for applying product to eyelashes and / or eyebrows
AU780344B2 (en) Brush applicator with added helix
JP5351396B2 (en) Applicator for applying composition to eyelashes or eyebrows
US9232851B2 (en) Variable pitch mascara brush
JP4206215B2 (en) Brush to apply substance to keratinous fiber
BR0200584B1 (en) DEVICE FOR APPLICATION OF A SUBSTANCE TO CHERATINE FIBERS AND METHOD FOR BRUSHING TO APPLY A SUBSTANCE TO CHERATINE FIBERS
JP5340174B2 (en) Mascara applicator
US8210186B2 (en) Applicator for applying a substance onto keratinous fibers
JP6250532B2 (en) Mascara brush
JP2005279264A (en) Brush for applying material to keratode, a manufacturing method thereof, and makeup instrument having the brush
US20130036565A1 (en) Brush for applying a composition to the eyelashes and/or the eyebrows
BRPI0817798B1 (en) applicator to comb lashes and / or eyebrows and / or to apply a composition to them, and packaging device and applicator to apply a cosmetic or care product to eyelashes and / or eyebrows
JP6587611B2 (en) Device for applying cosmetic products
KR101782312B1 (en) Twisted cosmetic brush
US20210100348A1 (en) Volume and curl enhancing hairbrush
US10188194B2 (en) Twisted cosmetic brush
EP1491112B1 (en) Brush with helical reinforcing element
US20080163885A1 (en) Dual hemisphere cosmetic brush
WO2012137134A1 (en) A brush and a packaging and applicator device including such a brush
US20210127821A1 (en) Twisted cosmetic brush
CN111466702A (en) Spring type eyelash brush head

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
MK5 Application lapsed section 142(2)(e) - patent request and compl. specification not accepted