AU2007319495B2

AU2007319495B2 - Distortion compensation for rod piston bore in subsurface safety valves

Info

Publication number: AU2007319495B2
Application number: AU2007319495A
Authority: AU
Inventors: David Z. Anderson; Darren E. Bane; Cliff Beall; Gary LAKE (Ben) B.; Alan N. Wagner
Original assignee: Baker Hughes Inc
Current assignee: Baker Hughes Holdings LLC
Priority date: 2006-11-10
Filing date: 2007-11-06
Publication date: 2012-11-01
Anticipated expiration: 2027-11-06
Also published as: EP2094938A1; NO20091941L; BRPI0718685B1; US20080110631A1; BRPI0718685A2; CN101657604A; US7699108B2; CN101657604B; US20090078423A1; RU2009121639A; WO2008060889A1; EP2094938B1; NO344904B1; AU2007319495A1; US7735560B2; RU2456432C2

Abstract

Piston bore distortions in a sub-surface safety valve are reduced or eliminated when valve body is subjected to high working pressures. In one embodiment, a piston is disposed in a sleeve (24) that is disposed in a piston bore (16). The bore can distort but the sleeve (24) within will not distort to the point of losing sealing pressure around the piston. In another approach additional bore or bores (18, 20) are provided adjacent the piston bore (16) to make the pin end of the connection for the valve housing more uniform in the region of the piston bore (16) so that pressure loading does not result in sufficient distortion of the piston bore to lose the piston sealing relation in its bore.

Description

WO 2008/060889 PCT/US2007/083700 APPLICATION FOR PATENT Title: Distortion Compensation for Rod Piston Bore in Subsurface Safety Valves Inventors: Darren E. Bane; David Z. Anderson; Alan N. Wagner; Clifford H. Beall and Gary B. Lake FIELD OF THE INVENTION [0001] The field of this invention is downhole subsurface safety valves that operate a valve member with control line pressure delivered into a piston bore. BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION [00021 Sub-surface safety valves (SSSV) are used in production tubing to control the well and to close it off to prevent a blowout. Typically, these valves have a disc shaped valve member that is known as a flapper. The flapper pivots over 90 degrees between an open and a closed position. A shiftable tube known as a flow tube is movable between two positions. When shifted down it engages the flapper to rotate it 90 degrees and keeps advancing as the flapper is moved into a position behind the flow tube. In this position the SSSV is open. A closure spring which was compressed as the flow tube opened the SSSV is used to return the flow tube to the original position. When the flow tube rises a pivot spring on the flapper urges it up against a seal surface to close off the production tubing. [00031 Typically, a control line is run adjacent the production tubing from the surface to a piston bore in the SSSV. There are several types of pistons that can be used and they are generally linked to the flow tube such that applied and retained pressure in the control line acts on a piston that is linked to the flow tube to hold the flow tube down against a closure spring and keep the flapper in the open position. One common piston type is a rod piston called that because of its shape. Other piston types can have an annular shape. The rod piston sits in an elongated bore in a main housing component of the SSSV that usually terminates in a two step male thread also known as a pin. The pin is made up to a female thread called a box to fully assemble the SSSV.

[0004] More recently demand has been for SSSVs that have higher and higher internal working pressure ratings. These demanded working pressures have gone as high as 20,000 30,000 PSI. Testing of current designs under these conditions revealed that they could comfortably hold such working pressures but the presence of the piston bore in the pin part of the housing 5 connection experienced dimensional distortion, generally becoming asymmetrical. The reason for this is that the pin is thinner than the box in the thread area. When the pressures get high enough, the pin deflects until a clearance comes out of the two step thread, at which time the pin and box move together. Thus, the problem that is addressed by the present invention is defined as how to keep the piston bore from distorting under high loads. Two approaches are presented. One involves a sleeve 0 inserted into the piston bore so that bore distortions become irrelevant to the continuing ability of the piston to seal because the sleeve does not distort at all or to the point where a pressure seal around the piston is lost. Another approach is the creation of parallel bores to the piston bore so as to make the pin wall more uniform in strength in the vicinity of the piston bore to hold down or eliminate the distortion in the piston bore under loading to the point where the piston seal holds and the flow tube 5 can continue to be powered down against a closure spring. These and other aspects of the present invention will become more apparent to those skilled in the art from a review of the preferred embodiment that is described below along with its associated drawings, recognizing that the full scope of the invention is to be found in the appended claims. [0005] Injection bores in SSSVs have been used to deliver chemicals behind the flow .0 tube as illustrated in USP 6,148,920 and US published application US 2005/0098210. Also relevant to SSSV in general are USP 4,042,023; 4,399,871; 4, 562854; 4,565,215; 5,718,289 and 6,148,920 and US application 2004/0040718. [0005A] Reference to any prior art or background information in this specification is not, and should not be taken as, an acknowledgment or any form of suggestion that this prior art or 25 background information forms part of the common general knowledge in Australia or any other jurisdiction; or that this prior art or background information could reasonably be expected to be ascertained, understood and regarded as relevant by a person skilled in the art. [0005B] As used herein, except where the context requires otherwise, the term "comprise" and variations of the term, such as "comprising", "comprises" and "comprised", are not 30 intended to exclude further additives, components, integers or steps. SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION [0006] In a first aspect of the present invention, a subsurface safety valve is provided comprising a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof. The piston bore 2 extends from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further contains a piston and a closure bias acting on said piston. The subsurface safety valve further comprises at least one additional blind bore axially overlapping and circumferentially spaced within said wall from said piston bore. The at least one additional blind bore contains only fluid and is out of fluid 5 communication from said piston bore. [0006A] In a second aspect of the present invention, a subsurface safety valve is provided comprising a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof. The piston bore extends from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further contains a piston and a closure bias acting on the piston. The subsurface safety valve further comprises at least one .0 additional blind bore within said wall. The at least one additional blind bore contains only fluid and is out of fluid communication from said piston bore, is within 45 degrees of said piston bore, and reduces a tendency of the piston bore to deform when the main bore is pressurized. [0006B] In a third aspect of the present invention, a subsurface safety valve is provided comprising a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof. The piston bore .5 extends from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further contains a piston and a closure bias acting on the piston. The subsurface safety valve further comprises at least one additional blind bore within said wall. The at least one additional blind bore contains only fluid, is out of fluid communication from the piston bore and comprises a plurality of bores, whereupon the presence of the additional bores reduces the tendency for the piston bore to deform to a point of !0 leakage past the piston when the main bore is pressurized. [0006C] In a fourth aspect of the present invention, a subsurface safety valve is provided comprising a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof. The piston bore extends from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further contains a piston and a closure bias acting on the piston. The subsurface safety valve further comprises at least one 25 additional blind bore within said wall. The at least one additional blind bore contains only fluid, is out of fluid communication from the piston bore and reduces a tendency of the piston bore to deform when the main bore is pressurized. [0006D] Piston bore distortions in a sub-surface safety valve are reduced or eliminated when valve body is subjected to high working pressures. In one embodiment, a piston is disposed in 30 a sleeve that is disposed in a piston bore. The bore can distort but the sleeve within will not distort to the point of losing sealing pressure around the piston. In another approach, additional bore or bores are provided adjacent the piston bore to 2A WO 2008/060889 PCT/US2007/083700 make the pin end of the connection for the valve housing more uniform in the region of the piston bore so that pressure loading does not result in sufficient distortion of the piston bore to lose the piston sealing relation in its bore. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS [00071 FIG. 1 is a section view of a sleeve inside a piston bore in the pin portion of a housing for a SSSV; [0008] FIG. 2 is a close up of the lower end of the sleeve of FIG. 1; [0009] FIG.3 is a section view of a prior art upper section of an SSSV; [00101 FIG. 4 is a section view along lines 4-4 of FIG. 3; [0011] FIG. 5 is a section view of the upper portion of an SSSV showing the depth of additional bores adjacent the piston bore; [0012] FIG. 6 is a section along lines 6-6 of FIG. 5; [0013] FIG. 7 is an alternative to FIG. 5 showing fewer but deeper bores; and [0014] FIG. 8 is a view along lines 8-8 of FIG. 7. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT [0015] FIG. 3 shows a section through a prior art SSSV showing the upper body 10 and a connection 12 for a control line from the surface (not shown). At the lower end is a two step male pin thread 14. Running through the wall of the upper body is a piston bore 16. Residing within this bore but not shown is a piston that is responsive to pressure application and removal as described above. Looking at the section view of FIG. 4 the piston bore 16 is located with respect to the longitudinal axis 18. From these two FIGS., it can be seen that the result of very high internal working pressures in the vicinity of 20,000 PSI or more can result in distortion of the piston bore 16 because the wall of the housing 10 is not uniform and has what is essentially a void in one portion of the wall that weakens it in that location and causes a disproportionate amount of deformation 3 WO 2008/060889 PCT/US2007/083700 there. Since the piston seals (not shown) need to maintain a pressure differential across the piston for proper movement of the flow tube (not shown) ovality of the piston bore 16 will reduce or remove the ability of the piston seals to retain pressure differential. The net result of piston seal failure is an inability to operate the valve causing it to go to its fail safe position which is generally closed. [00161 FIGS 5-8 illustrate two solutions to this problem. In FIGS. 5-6 there are additional blind bores 18 that are preferably parallel to piston bore 16. In this solution, the additional holes 18 are uniformly spaced about the circumference starting from one side of the piston bore 16 and going all the way around to the other side of the piston bore 16 to distribute and minimize the distortion in each of the bores including the piston bore 16. In this example, there are 17 such bores 18. [0017] FIGS. 7-8 illustrate a variation where there are fewer blind bores 20 but these holes are disposed close to piston bore 16 and preferably on both sides of piston bore 16 within a 90 degree arc. When fewer holes are used but positioned close to piston bore 16 on either side, the major change in section is moved to the outer holes and away from the piston bore 16 the intent being to concentrate the stresses and thus the distortion at these outer holes and not at the piston bore 16 thus reducing the distortion at the piston bore 16. [0018] Those skilled in the art will appreciate that the goal of the solutions offered is to minimize or eliminate distortion of piston bore 16 due to high internal pressures in main bore 22 which create this distortion because the presence of the piston bore 16 is a weak spot in what is already a fairly thin wall near the pin threads 14. Adding the blind bores has the objective of making the housing 10 wall deflection more uniform in the vicinity of the piston bore 16 so as to share the distortion effects, if any, from very high working pressures. Clearly the solution in FIG. 6 makes the entire wall of housing 10 uniform in the vicinity of the piston bore 16 and is more likely to arrive at the ideal solution of minimal or no bore distortion in piston bore 16 as any tendency to distort is not concentrated in a single bore 16 in the housing 10 as shown in the prior art view of FIG. 4. Instead, FIG. 6 represents the more comprehensive solution of sharing the stress 4 WO 2008/060889 PCT/US2007/083700 from internal pressurization. It is more costly to produce since more blind bores 18 are used than in the FIG. 8 alternative using blind bores 20 despite the fact that the depth of fewer bores is preferably greater than the depth of an array using more blind bores. While the solution which seeks to divert the major portion of the total distortion to the outer holes on each side of the piston bore 16 is considered less effective in reducing the distortion in bore 16 than the solution which seeks to distribute the distortion among the many holes, the economics of using fewer holes is self evident and this second solution is also effective in reducing the distortion in piston bore 16. [0019] Computer controlled milling machines can be employed to produce many variations in number, depth, spacing, shape and angular orientation of the blind bores. The enhanced performance can be predicted in advance using known fmite element method analysis. [0020] The proposed solution encompasses variation of the bore diameter with the larger diameter bores preferably closer to the piston bore 16. While the longitudinal axes of the blind bores are preferably parallel, variations are envisioned where some skewing of the longitudinal axes is envisioned with offsets in the order of 15 degrees or less from adjacent blind bores or of all the blind bores with respect to the longitudinal axis 18 either in the same orientation or differing orientations. For example, the longitudinal axes of all the blind bores can parallel to each other while at the same time skewed with respect to axis 18. The most economical design to machine would be the fewest number of blind bores parallel to each other and to axis 18. Bores can have identical or varying depths. [0021] FIGS. 1-2 illustrate another solution to the same problem. For this solution, the piston bore 16 has an internal sleeve 24 in which the piston (not shown) travels back and forth. As shown in the close up of FIG. 2 a seal 26 held in a groove 28 in housing 10 prevents pressure loss around the outside of sleeve 24. Sleeve 24 is inserted through the lower end of bore 16 and slides in because there is a clearance between its outside dimension and the bore dimension of piston bore 16. The seal 26 spans this clearance to seal it off. Alternatively, sleeve 24 can be pressed in for no clearance and the 5 WO 2008/060889 PCT/US2007/083700 elimination of seal 26. Once the sleeve 24 is fully inserted, a snap ring or other known fastener equivalent 30 is installed in a groove 32 in bore 16 to keep the sleeve 24 from shifting longitudinally. [0022] The objective here is to allow the piston bore 16 to distort while the sleeve 24 remains unaffected due to the clearance between them. [00231 Those skilled in the art will appreciate that the proposed solution in FIGS. 1-2 can be used with the solution in FIGS. 6 or 8 or separately. The desired result in any case is to maintain sealing integrity of the seal around the piston that operates the flow tube in a SSSV or in other applications with high internal working pressures exceeding 20,000 PSI where housings have piston bores regardless of the nature of the downhole device. [0024] The above description is illustrative of the preferred embodiment and many modifications may be made by those skilled in the art without departing from the invention whose scope is to be determined from the literal and equivalent scope of the claims below. 6

Claims

2. A subsurface safety valve, comprising: 10 a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof said piston bore extending from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further containing a piston and a closure bias acting on said piston; at least one additional blind bore within said wall, said at least one additional blind bore containing only fluid and out of fluid communication from said piston bore; t5 said at least one additional blind bore is within 45 degrees of said piston bore; said at least one additional blind bore reduces a tendency of said piston bore to deform when said main bore is pressurized.
3. A subsurface safety valve, comprising: a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof said piston bore 20 extending from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further containing a piston and a closure bias acting on said piston; and at least one additional blind bore within said wall, said at least one additional blind bore containing only fluid and out of fluid communication from said piston bore; said at least one additional bore comprises a plurality of bores, whereupon the presence 25 of said additional bores reduces the tendency for the piston bore to deform to a point of leakage past said piston when said main bore is pressurized.
4. The valve of claim 3, wherein: 7 said additional bores are disposed over substantially the entire circumference of said wall.
5. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores are disposed on both sides of said piston bore within a 90 degree arc. 5 6. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores are all the same diameter.
7. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores are equally spaced from each other about said piston bore.
8. The valve of claim 3, wherein: 0 said additional bores are parallel to each other.
9. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores are parallel to said piston bore.
10. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores vary in diameter or shape. 5 11. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores are randomly spaced.
12. The valve of claim 3, wherein: said additional bores have one of the same depth or different depths.
13. A subsurface safety valve, comprising: 20 a housing having a main bore and a piston bore in a wall thereof said piston bore extending from a connection adapted to receive a control line and further containing a piston and a closure bias acting on said piston; and at least one additional blind bore within said wall, said at least one additional bore containing only fluid and out of fluid communication from said piston bore; 8 said additional bore reduces a tendency of said piston bore to deform when said main bore is pressurized. 9