AU2003277958B2 - Cooling helmet - Google Patents

Cooling helmet Download PDF

Info

Publication number
AU2003277958B2
AU2003277958B2 AU2003277958A AU2003277958A AU2003277958B2 AU 2003277958 B2 AU2003277958 B2 AU 2003277958B2 AU 2003277958 A AU2003277958 A AU 2003277958A AU 2003277958 A AU2003277958 A AU 2003277958A AU 2003277958 B2 AU2003277958 B2 AU 2003277958B2
Authority
AU
Australia
Prior art keywords
headwear
article
crown
shape
rim
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Fee Related
Application number
AU2003277958A
Other versions
AU2003277958A2 (en
AU2003277958A1 (en
Inventor
Nicholas Bedford
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Individual
Original Assignee
Individual
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Priority claimed from AU2002953193A external-priority patent/AU2002953193A0/en
Application filed by Individual filed Critical Individual
Priority to AU2003277958A priority Critical patent/AU2003277958B2/en
Publication of AU2003277958A1 publication Critical patent/AU2003277958A1/en
Publication of AU2003277958A2 publication Critical patent/AU2003277958A2/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of AU2003277958B2 publication Critical patent/AU2003277958B2/en
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical
Expired - Fee Related legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • AHUMAN NECESSITIES
    • A42HEADWEAR
    • A42BHATS; HEAD COVERINGS
    • A42B3/00Helmets; Helmet covers ; Other protective head coverings
    • A42B3/04Parts, details or accessories of helmets
    • A42B3/28Ventilating arrangements
    • A42B3/285Ventilating arrangements with additional heating or cooling means

Description

COOLING HELMET This invention relates to headwear particularly suited to be worn by persons IN requiring headwear that will provide impact protection for the wearer.
(N
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION o00 O 5 It has been known to use ice held close to the head of a person to provide cooling for medical purposes.
For instance, it is known to cover the head with a pliable material adapted to hold N frozen liquid so that the surface of the head is kept cold. This process is used to reduce damage to hair follicles for those who might be taking cancer drugs where they might otherwise lose their hair.
In practical headwear that provides impact protection which also includes temperature modifying materials, there is one prior art example published as a mere paper publication where there is a helmet with an arrangement to support a bladder with a breakable pouch of an encapsulated ammonium salt within a body of water. The bladder is shown as fitting against an inner side of the helmet and is arranged to be held in this position by hook and loop fastener pads (often referred to by the Registered Trade Mark Velcro). Unfortunately the use of a breakable pouch within a bladder in this disclosure is used to replace soft padding and is shown so that the liquid bladder will bear directly against the head of a wearer.
This has the disadvantage that the bladder will result in heat transfer from a users head directly by conduction to the bladder and is not conducive to cooling any other areas of the head. This leads implicitly to significant temperature differences against the head and is somewhat akin to having an ice pack held against the skin where this becomes very uncomfortable after a modest period.
By replacing some of the padding the advantage is that the helmet itself is not integrally compromised but the padding is altered so that it will still need separate testing.
A further difficulty with direct contact is that the temperature modifying material will be directly contacting a head of the user with the result that any retained heat 2 O differential will be compromised relatively quickly. In other words by having direct contact the cooling effect may for instance only last a relatively short time.
A problem to which this invention is directed is to provide an impact protective N article of headwear that allows for a more comfortable arrangement where heat modifying means are involved and also to assist in increasing time that a cooling of 0 heating effect may be sustained in a headwear item.
BRIEF DISCLOSURE OF THIS INVENTION In one form of this invention there is proposed an article of headwear including an impact resistant outer part of crown shape, and an impact resistant inner part of crown shape of a size and shape adapted to nest with the outer part and at least one intermediate part which is positioned to be intermediate the said outer and inner crown shaped parts and which outer and inner parts are together adapted to support in removable fashion the intermediate part, and where the intermediate part is comprised of at least in the main a fluid.
In a further form, the invention may be said to lie in an article of headwear including an impact resistant outer part of crown shape, and an impact resistant inner part of crown shape of a size and shape adapted to nest with the outer part so as to define a cavity between the two parts, wherein said cavity is adapted to receive at least one intermediate part which is positioned to be intermediate the said outer and inner crown shaped parts and which outer and inner parts are together adapted to support in removable fashion the intermediate part, and where the intermediate part is comprised of at least in the main a fluid.
In preference the fluid is held in one or more pliable pouches which can be removable and replaceable with other pouches.
Preferably the fluid is a freezable gel so that there can be a plurality of such pouches which can be used to replace one another so that as one is warmed another from a freezer can replace this to maintain a preferred extent of cooling.
By structurally separating the crown of a headwear item into at least two parts with an intermediate part in between, provides an opportunity to control within a contained space arrangements for airflow and cooling effect and distribution of cooling air from this.
QAlso, where there is an outer and inner part of an impact resistant material, this then
CN
allows for improved impact resistance by reason of a double wall characteristic which can then also mean that lighter materials may be used for the individual parts which is to say lighter than would have been ordinarily needed for a single c, 5 thickness crown to get a similar protective effect. This can assist in keeping an all up weight of a helmet within acceptable limits.
00 Preferably, there is a further part positioned between the intermediate part and the outer part which is comprised of at least in the main an insulating material.
Preferably, the further part is a pliable and insulating material.
Preferably, the intermediate part includes a pliable plastics material sheet holding there within a freezable gel.
Preferably, there is a peak extending outwardly from the outer part of the crown from a rim of the crown shape of the outer part.
In a further form of the invention, there is a further outermost part of a size and shape which is adapted to nest within it the outer part.
Preferably, there is a further innermost part, which is a cradle or harness having a lower rim interengaging with either the outer or outermost part and supporting at least one strap extending from one side of the rim portion to an opposite side of the rim portion.
Preferably, the impact resistant material is a plastics material.
Preferably, the impact resistant material is a polycarbonate plastics material.
Preferably, the impact resistant material is a glass fibre-reinforced polyester plastics material.
Preferably, the hat further includes a protective face frame.
Preferably, there is extending over the outer part a woven fabric.
In the alternative it is a stretch fabric.
Preferably, the outer part and the inner part are held together by a central joining member.
Preferably, the inner part has a portion which is bulbous and is centrally located N and the intermediate part has a central aperture through which the bulbous portion of the inner part extends.
00oo O For a better understanding of this invention it will now be described with relation to one embodiment which shall now be described with the assistance of drawings wherein:
O
Figure 1 is an exploded perspective view of a first embodiment, Figure 2 is a cross-sectional view of the embodiment shown in Figure 1, Figure 3 is an exploded perspective view of a second embodiment, Figure 4 is a cross-sectional view of the embodiment shown in Figure 3, Figure 5 is an exploded perspective view of a third embodiment, Figure 6 is a cross-sectional view of the embodiment shown in Figure DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION Now referring to the drawings, and to Figure 1 in particular, this illustrates an impact protective helmet of a type intended to be worn by a person batting in the traditional game of cricket.
Accordingly, the helmet 1 has an inner part 2 of crown shape which is moulded from an impact resistant plastics material this being glass fibre reinforced polyester in this case. This provides for further parts including a brim 19 and sides to be joined from two parts as a part of the lower part 2.
There is provided an impact resistant outer part 6 of crown shape which is of a dome shape and which arranged to generally have an outer lower edge which conforms to a periphery 7 of the lower part 2 so as to define a cavity 8 between the two.
This cavity 8 is shaped so as to be adapted as to receive within it a pack 9 which is provided by two sheets of pliable plastic material welded together along inner and outer seems 10 and 11 so as to define a pouch 12 with a central hole 13 passing through it.
(N
Within the pouch 12 there is a freezing gel which is adapted to be frozen at colder 00 temperatures typically zero degrees centigrade or below and which will therefore once frozen, be available to melt and provide thereby cooling effect.
The outer part 6 is held in position by a bolt 15 embedded within the inner part 2 at a central location and projects upwardly so as to pass through aperture 16 and N 10 to be held in position by nut 17.
Apertures 18 are positioned in distributed fashion in the inner part 2 so as to allow for airflow from the frozen gel into an air space beneath the inner part 2.
A brim 19 projects forwardly from the inner part 2 and there is a strap 19a to hold the helmet onto the head of a user.
What is not shown specifically however but which is included as is traditionally used is the means to support the helmet on the head namely in one case a set of straps which go from side to side and therefore pass over a top of the head of the user and hold the lower surface of the helmet namely the inner part significantly above the head or hair or skin of the user. In another case discrete blocks of padding 21 are placed around a periphery on the inside of the inner part 2 these being spaced apart to allow for air to access and flow to the surface of the head of the user in each case.
In practice, this arrangement then provides for a very convenient facility in which the outer part 6 will fit with the lower shell or crown shape of the inner part 2 so that the outermost shape will look to be very similar to a conventional helmet shape.
The pack 9 can be removed from time to time by simply undoing the nut 17 and lifting the outer part away and replacing the pack with a further frozen pack so that a person wearing the hat may be able to be kept cool over periods of typically an hour or so according to tests thus far conducted.
The pack 9 may be left out of the helmet altogether in instances where no heating or cooling effect is required, its omission leaving only the cavity defined by the impact resistant inner and outer parts. This arrangement provides some significant impact absorbing characteristics, as the impact absorbing outer part can in an instance where it is impacted upon by an object, deflect into the cavity left by the N 5 omission of the pack.
00 As can now be seen the arrangement provides herein a double wall of an outer s and inner part which implicitly results in a protection which is more likely to provide better protection than a single wall arrangement with a similar wall thickness and type of plastics material. Also by having a freezing gel held within a structurally self supporting arrangement means that normal protective features of this type of 1 helmet can be maintained for instance the structure of the helmet can be supported by the conventional discrete padding or by strapping and there is no direct engagement needed of the freezing pouch against the head or skin of the user.
Various other users require participants to wear protective headwear which also have a potential problem when it is hot. These include, amongst others, those participating in cycling, baseball, lacrosse and American football.
In each case, specialized helmets have been developed according to the requirements of each of these uses. It will be understood by persons skilled in the relevant art that it would be a relatively straightforward matter to adapt the arrangement outlined above to each of these differing helmet arrangements.
Referring now to Figures 3 and 4, this illustrates a helmet of the type intended to be worn by a construction worker working on a building site which are often referred to as a hard hat.
The helmet 20 has an outermost shell which forms there by an outer part 22 which is moulded from an appropriate impact resistant plastics material as per a conventional construction helmet such as a polycarbonate plastics material.
There is also provided an insulating material 24 which is of a dome shape, and which is adapted to generally conform to the periphery 26 of an inner part 28 so as to define a cavity 30 between the two which is to say the outer part 22 and the inner part 28 both of which are of dome shape and which provide for the inner part 28 to nest within the outer part 22.
This cavity 30 is adapted to receive within it a pack 32 which contains a freezable gel, which is provided by two sheets of pliable plastic material welded together along inner and outer seams 34 and 36 so as to define a pouch 38.
N Within the pouch 38 there is the freezing gel which is adapted to be frozen at colder temperatures of typically zero degrees centigrade or below, and which will 00oo therefore once frozen, melt and provide thereby cooling effect.
The insulating material 24 and inner part 28 are held together, and then collectively secured to the outer shell, via the helmet webbing 40 (represented by the dashed lines), which is of a type conventionally found in such construction helmets, S 10 which in this case as is conventional is removably attached to the outer shell via means of clips 42 adapted to engage the outer shell 22.
The brim 43 is in this case now a part of the outer part 22 which provides for the inner part to in this case fit or nest within the outer part 22.
Such an arrangement of helmet webbing is removable therefore relatively easily, in order to facilitate replacement of the pouch 38 once for instance it is no longer frozen with a further frozen pack as before.
Once again therefore it will be seen that the cooling materials are arranged to be held above and out of direct contact with the head or skin of a user and this then allows for air to circulate and also for better insulation and control of air flow past the frozen materials to be achieved.
A further advantage of this arrangement is that it allows for a conventional hard hat of a type which is already being manufactured in large numbers and economically to be relatively simply modified to allow for cooling to be available. This is considered to be of great advantage especially where those who are constrained to work outside may not continue work in higher temperatures but may now be persuaded to continue to work for longer periods in higher temperatures.
As hard hats are compulsory on a number of factory, building and construction sites and their design has been the subject of significant development the advantage therefore of a simple adaption will be readily appreciated to allow for cooling.
Various other occupations require protective headwear. These include, amongst others, firefighters and welders. In each case, specialized helmets have been developed according to the exact requirements of each of these occupations. It would be easily understood by a person skilled in the art that it would be a N 5 relatively straightforward matter to adapt the arrangement outlined above to each of these differing helmet arrangements.
00 1 Referring now to Figures 5 and 6, these illustrate a hat 50 made primarily of a cloth material of the type commonly referred to as a baseball cap. In this case the cap includes gores 51 which define a crown 52 and there is a peak 53 projecting from one side of the periphery of the crown. Further however this cap uses a multi size Cfit design in which the gores 51 are a spandex material which allows for the crown to expand to allow for different head sizes to be fitted comfortably and there is also an elastic inner sleeve 53a which in one case which is not specifically shown is surrounded by a toweling sleeve. This allows for further comfortable expansion.
Inside the crown there is now provided an outer part 54 made from an appropriate impact resistant plastics material in a dome shape, and which is adapted to generally conform to the periphery 56 of an inner part 58 so as to define a cavity 60 between the two where the inner part 58 nests therefore with the outer part 54, and both of these nest within the outermost part, which is the crown 52 of the hat 50. These parts 54 and 58 are held in place simply by friction between the expandable crown material and the outer edges of the respective parts.
This cavity 60 is arranged to receive within it a pack 62 as before, which is provided by two sheets of pliable plastic material welded together along inner and outer seems 64 and 66 so as to define a pouch 68.
Within the pouch 68 there is a freezing gel which is adapted to be frozen at colder temperatures typically 0 degrees centigrade or below and which will therefore once frozen, melt and provide thereby cooling effect.
The shells 54 and 58 are held together as stated and then collectively secured to the hat, by a screw 70 with a button 76 of the type commonly found on the crown of such caps for a head, adapted to be received within the lowermost shell at a central location.
Such an arrangement allows for the pouch 68 to be removable therefore, in order to facilitate replacement of a further frozen pouch 68.
This design allows for applications such as golf to be accommodated with some cimpact protection from golf balls as well as cooling. In this design this allows for the elastic sleeve to engage arrange a head of a user so that the crown itself stands 0 proud of the actual top of the head. In practise this means that there is again an air space and even with the several parts and a gel pouch there is still left room for and air space above the head of a wearer and the inner part lower surface.
In each case embodiment the design has been provided with an inner part and an S 10 outer part and in each case there are apertures to be provided through the parts which have not been shown specifically but which will be able to be placed in position and be judged as to size and location to best balance the need for maintaining of insulation as compared to allowing for a cooling effect with air passage.
There are other styles of articles of headwear. It will be easily understood by a person skilled in the art that it would be a relatively straight forward matter to adapt the arrangement and principals outlined above to each of other styles.
Articles such as those described herein have now proven themselves to be of considerable benefit both for comfort for users while maintaining and probably improving safety and convenience to those who must use hats and hard caps for protective purposes, especially where being subjected to higher temperature working conditions.
Results of testing of helmets made in accordance with this invention have shown that very substantial benefits can be obtained from this by for instance keeping the temperature above the head of a user in a cool state over a longer period without undue disadvantage.
Here are some examples of test results for the helmet generally shown as the second embodiment.
Example 1 Temperature in the shade 29deg.cel. Direct sunlight temp. 37.5 Deg. C. The gel pack is placed in position in a frozen state.
Constant temperature reading inside helmet after 30min. 20.5 Deg.C.
21.5 Deg.C.
22. Deg.C.
Based on 5 overs being bowled in 20mins, equates to Replacement for SCricketers at Drinks Break (20 overs) Average drinks break per match is 17- overs.
cN Example 2 oo Temp. in shade 39 Deg.C. Direct Sunlight 47.5Deg.C. Gel pack started in the 0 frozen state Temperature in helmet after39min.24.Deg.C after 70min.25Deg.C 0 after 75min.26Deg.C Example 3 Test under Cricket Match conditions Temp. In shade was 36Deg. Gel pack lasted 75 Mins and changed at drinks.
Packs Temp in helmet was 20deg at start of play and 29deg. at the finish.
Humidity was 86% (it was a Muggy day).
Based on Medical Doctors statements a best temp range is between 18- 22Deg.C. for the human brain to function best.
Example 4 Tests on Equestrian Helmet at Darwin In 34 Deg Temp. shade. Direct sunlight temp.42.5Deg.
3 hr cross Country Ride resulted inside helmet pack Temp 29DegC at end.
Example Temperature Tests Done on Cricket helmet without Cooling were Temp. 28 Deg.C.in the shade and 36.5Deg.C. Direct sunlight Results inside helmet 16min. 36 Deg.C.
30min 39Deg.C.
These results illustrate the advantage of the invention.

Claims (19)

1. An article of headwear including an impact resistant outer part of crown c-i shape, and an impact resistant inner part of crown shape of a size and shape adapted to nest with the outer part, and at least one intermediate 00 5 part which is positioned so as to be intermediate the said outer and inner crown shaped parts, and where the outer and inner parts are together adapted to support in removable fashion the intermediate part, and where the intermediate part is comprised of at least in the main a fluid. O N
2. An article of headwear including an impact resistant outer part of crown shape, and an impact resistant inner part of crown shape of a size and shape adapted to nest with the outer part so as to define a cavity between the two parts, wherein said cavity is adapted to receive at least one intermediate part which can be positioned so as to be intermediate the said outer and inner crown shaped parts, and where the outer and inner parts are together adapted to support in removable fashion the intermediate part, and where the intermediate part is comprised of at least in the main a fluid.
3. The article of headwear as in either one of the immediately preceding claims further characterized in that the fluid is held in one or more pliable pouches, which are arranged to be removable and replaceable.
4. The article of headwear as in the immediately preceding claim further characterized in that the fluid is a freezable gel.
The article of headwear as in any one of the immediately preceding claims further characterized in that there is a further part which is comprised of at least in the main an insulating material which is positioned between the intermediate part and the outer part.
6. The article of headwear as in the immediately preceding claim further characterized in that the further part is a pliable and insulating material.
7. The article of headwear as in any one of the immediately preceding claims Nfuther characterized in that the intermediate part includes pliable plastics material sheet holding there within a freezable gel. c-
8. The article of headwear as in any one of the immediately preceding claims further characterized in that there is a peak or brim extending outwardly 00 from the outer part, from a rim of the crown shape of the outer part.
9. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further c-I characterized in that there is a further outermost part of a size and shape, which is adapted to nest within it the outer part.
10. The article of headwear as the immediately preceding claims further characterized in that there is a further innermost part, which is a cradle or harness having a lower rim interengaging with either the outer or outermost part and supporting at least one strap extending from one side of the rim portion to an opposite side of the rim portion.
11. An article of headwear having a crown which has an impact resistant outer part of crown shape, an impact resistant inner part of a size and shape adapted to nest with the outer part and at least one intermediate part which is positioned to be intermediate the said outer and inner crown parts and which outer and inner parts are together adapted to support in removable fashion the intermediate part, and where the intermediate part is comprised of at least in the main a frozen gel.
12. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further characterized in that there is attached to the outermost part a peak extending outwardly from a rim of the crown shape of the outermost part.
13. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further characterized in that there is attached to the outer part a peak or brim extending outwardly from a rim of the crown shape of the outer part.
14. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims in which there is attached to the inner part a peak or brim extending outwardly from a rim of the outer part.
The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further CN characterised in that the innermost part is a cradle having a lower rim Sinterengaging with the outer part and supporting at least one strap extending from one side of the rim portion to an opposite side of the rim \O portion and following the path defining a crown shape nesting within the outer part. 00oo
16. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further characterised in that the outermost part is comprised of a woven fabric. O
17. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims further C 10 characterised in that the outermost part is made of an impact resistant material.
18. The article of headwear as in any one of the preceding claims except the last claim further characterised in that outermost part is comprised of a stretch fabric.
19. An article of headwear as described in the specification with reference to and as illustrated by the accompanying illustrations.
AU2003277958A 2002-11-01 2003-10-31 Cooling helmet Expired - Fee Related AU2003277958B2 (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
AU2003277958A AU2003277958B2 (en) 2002-11-01 2003-10-31 Cooling helmet

Applications Claiming Priority (4)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
AU2002953193 2002-11-01
AU2002953193A AU2002953193A0 (en) 2002-11-01 2002-11-01 Cooling helmet
PCT/AU2003/001437 WO2004039191A1 (en) 2002-11-01 2003-10-31 Cooling helmet
AU2003277958A AU2003277958B2 (en) 2002-11-01 2003-10-31 Cooling helmet

Publications (3)

Publication Number Publication Date
AU2003277958A1 AU2003277958A1 (en) 2004-05-25
AU2003277958A2 AU2003277958A2 (en) 2005-08-25
AU2003277958B2 true AU2003277958B2 (en) 2008-01-03

Family

ID=34394701

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
AU2003277958A Expired - Fee Related AU2003277958B2 (en) 2002-11-01 2003-10-31 Cooling helmet

Country Status (1)

Country Link
AU (1) AU2003277958B2 (en)

Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US4551858A (en) * 1983-01-28 1985-11-12 Dragerwerk Aktiengesellschaft Protective helmet having a cooling harness
US5469579A (en) * 1993-01-27 1995-11-28 Tremblay; Ronaldo Head cooling device
US5557807A (en) * 1994-10-25 1996-09-24 Hujar; Jerry Headwear including coolant means

Patent Citations (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US4551858A (en) * 1983-01-28 1985-11-12 Dragerwerk Aktiengesellschaft Protective helmet having a cooling harness
US5469579A (en) * 1993-01-27 1995-11-28 Tremblay; Ronaldo Head cooling device
US5557807A (en) * 1994-10-25 1996-09-24 Hujar; Jerry Headwear including coolant means

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
AU2003277958A1 (en) 2004-05-25

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US20060005291A1 (en) Cooling helmet
US8468613B2 (en) Modular neck protection device
US5327585A (en) Cool cap
US7861326B2 (en) Modular neck protection device
US20170105461A1 (en) Impact reduction apparel and impact absorbing liner for apparel
US4425917A (en) Heat exchange system for body skin
US6678896B2 (en) Sports towel
US20140007324A1 (en) Soft helmet incorporating rigid panels
US20060070171A1 (en) Shock absorbing structure
US6185750B1 (en) Portable cooling device
US11266193B2 (en) Headwear with temperature control apparatus
US20120073031A1 (en) Ice Cap Or Ice Hat
US11247115B2 (en) Fluid-based exoskeletal body armor with climate control
US20210315306A1 (en) Impact protection system
US7971282B2 (en) Helmet earmuffs/covers
AU2003277958B2 (en) Cooling helmet
AU2003277958A2 (en) Cooling helmet
US6976276B2 (en) Carotid cooling jacket
US20220346485A1 (en) Head safety device
KR101655784B1 (en) Equipped with a removable cooling pad vest
US20140303699A1 (en) Unibody Head Gear Personal Temperature Moderating Device
GB2390797A (en) A safety hat
JP3112744U (en) hat
CN207836860U (en) A kind of comfort type safety cap of Winter-summer dual purpose
US20060185054A1 (en) Carotid comfort control jacket

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
DA3 Amendments made section 104

Free format text: THE NATURE OF THE AMENDMENT IS AS SHOWN IN THE STATEMENT(S) FILED 26 MAY 2005

MK25 Application lapsed reg. 22.2i(2) - failure to pay acceptance fee