JP2019197381A - Decree database creation method, decree database retrieval method, sentence creation method, decree database creation device, decree database retrieval device, sentence creation device, decree database creation program, decree database retrieval program, and sentence creation program - Google Patents

Abstract

To provide techniques for properly chaptering decrees into short sentences and itemizing and classifying the short sentences, techniques for retrieving, on the basis of the itemized or classified short sentences, short sentences such as annotations and short sentences of other decrees associated with the decrees, and techniques for creating, from the itemized or classified short sentences, sentences such as a written complaint.SOLUTION: A decree database creation method comprises: a sentence receiving step for receiving first writing and second writing from a computer; a chaptering step for chaptering sentences included in the first writing into multiple first short sentences, and chaptering sentences included in the second writing into second short sentences; itemizing step for itemizing the chaptered first short sentences into predetermined multiple first items, and itemizing the chaptered second short sentences into predetermined multiple second items; and a storing step for storing the first writing, the first short sentences and the first items in association with each other, storing the second writing, the second short sentences and the second items in association with each other, and storing the first writing and the second writing in association with each other.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2

Description

  The present invention relates to a judgment sentence database creation method, a judgment sentence database retrieval method, a sentence creation method, a judgment sentence database creation apparatus, a judgment sentence database retrieval apparatus, a sentence creation apparatus, a judgment sentence database creation program, and a judgment sentence database This invention relates to a search program and a sentence creation program.

  A technique is widely known in which a plurality of judgment sentences are distributed into a plurality of classifications so that a user who wants to search and refer to judgment sentences can be easily searched. In such a case, a label is assigned to each judgment sentence, and the user performs a search based on this label.

  For example, Patent Document 1 (particularly paragraph 0004) is parsed in order to extract the legal concepts of a plurality of training documents (case law documents) that have been input, and “features” (terms, laws) of each legal concept. And embedded quotes) are extracted, and the extracted “features” are attached to a plurality of training sentences. Relevance scores are calculated for these “features”, and the calculation results are also attached to a plurality of training sentences and stored in the database.

  More specifically, in Patent Document 1 (particularly paragraph 0006), the training text is parsed and divided into paragraphs to identify the paragraphs containing the legal concept. Each legal concept is then stored along with one or more topics associated with that legal concept. Based on this topic, “features (“ concept ”in FIG. 2 of Patent Document 1)” of the training text is extracted.

Special table 2003-526140 gazette

  However, in the classification of the training texts disclosed in Patent Document 1, a topic or “feature” is assigned to each text. As a result of parsing the whole text, the topic or “feature” is found in the whole text. Is granted.

  Usually, a judgment sentence etc. consists of many items, such as a reason, a claim, and a claim. Therefore, the features (types) of the features of each item differ depending on the case, and adding a label to one judgment sentence by averaging these multiple characteristics reduces the accuracy of the judgment sentence search by the user. There is a fear. In the first place, it can be said that deriving one label by averaging the features of a plurality of items itself is a low-accuracy labeling technique.

  Furthermore, in many judgment sentences, a commentary called a comment which explains the judgment sentence in detail is prepared, and the understanding of the judgment sentence is deepened by reading this comment against the judgment sentence. However, there is no other way for the reader to find out the correspondence between the sentence of the judgment and the comment, making it difficult to understand the sentence and the comment.

  In addition, the judgment text is created in contrast to the content of the complaint described in the complaint. If you are familiar with the judgment text, you do not need to read it against the complaint when reading the judgment text. . In other words, despite the correspondence between the complaint and the judgment sentence, it usually takes a lot of time and money to create a complaint, which may be a hindrance to the general public. There is.

  Therefore, the present invention has been made in view of the above circumstances, and a technique for appropriately categorizing a judgment sentence into small sentences and classifying or classifying the small sentences, and this item classification or classification. Providing technology to search for small sentences such as small sentences and commentary of other judgment sentences related to the judgment sentence from a small sentence, and to create a sentence such as a complaint from this itemized or classified small sentence For the purpose.

  (1) A first aspect of the present invention relates to a method for creating a judgment sentence database. A method for creating a judgment sentence database includes: a sentence receiving step for receiving a first sentence and a second sentence from a computer; a sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences; A chaptering step for chaptering a sentence contained in a sentence into a second sub-sentence, a first sub-sentence for which a chapter is prepared is divided into a plurality of predetermined first items, and the second An item classification step for classifying a sentence into a plurality of predetermined second items, a first sentence, a first small sentence, and a first item stored in association with each other, a second sentence, a second small Storing the sentence and the second item in association with each other, and further storing the first sentence and the second sentence in association with each other.

  (2) In (1) above, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the second small sentence is classified into any of the plurality of second types in the second item The method further includes a classification step for classifying whether or not the information belongs, and the storing step is similar or identical to the second item and the second type of the plurality of second small sentences in which the first item and the first type of the plurality of first small sentences In this case, the first sentence and the second sentence may be stored in association with each other.

  (3) In the second aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and The present invention relates to a method for searching a judgment sentence database stored in association with a first type. The method for searching the judgment sentence database includes a request receiving step for receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from a user terminal device, and a first item similar or identical to the first item or the first type included in the search request. An extraction step for extracting a first sentence associated with the other first small sentence including one item or the first type or the other first small sentence from the judgment sentence database, and the other first small sentence extracted Transmitting a first sentence associated with the sentence or the other first small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (4) In the above (3), when the request receiving step receives the first item and the first type as a search request, the extraction step includes the first item and another first small sentence including the first type or You may extract the 1st sentence matched with the said other 1st small sentence.

  (5) In the above (3) or (4), when the extraction step extracts another first sentence stored in association with the first small sentence, the other first small sentence is the first It may further include a screen generation step of generating a display screen indicating where the sentence is located, and the transmission step may transmit the display screen to the user terminal device.

  (6) In any one of the above (3) to (5), the receiving step may receive a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. .

  (7) In the above (6), the receiving step may receive the first item or the first type included in the selected first small sentence as a search request.

  (8) In any one of the above (3) to (7), in the extraction step, the first item included in the search request or another first small sentence associated with the first type is extracted from the plurality of judgment sentence databases. In such a case, the transmitting step may transmit the plurality of other extracted first small sentences to the user terminal device.

  (9) In the third aspect of the present invention, sentences included in the first sentence are chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and a plurality of first sentences in which the chaptered first small sentences are predetermined. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a method for searching a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The judgment sentence database search method includes a request receiving step of receiving a search request including a first item from a user terminal device, and a second small item including a second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request. An extraction step for extracting a sentence, and a transmission step for transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (10) In the above (9), the plurality of first items into which the first small sentence is divided and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentence is divided may have the same item. Good.

  (11) In the above (9) or (10), the method further includes a screen generation step of generating a display screen on which an arbitrary first sentence is displayed on the user terminal device, and the transmission step includes the display screen as the user terminal The screen generation step may generate a display screen that displays the second small sentence extracted in the extraction step together with the first sentence.

  (12) In any of (9) to (11) above, when the extraction step extracts the second sentence stored in association with the second small sentence, the second small sentence is the second sentence. The display generation step may further include a screen generation step of generating a display screen indicating the position of the display screen, and the transmission step may transmit the display screen to the user terminal device.

  (13) In the above (9) to (12), the receiving step may receive a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter.

  (14) In the above (13), the receiving step may receive the first item included in the selected first small sentence as a search request.

  (15) According to a fourth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a sentence creation method for creating a third sentence from a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The sentence creation method includes a request reception step of receiving a search request including a plurality of first items from a user terminal device, and a plurality of second items including a second item similar or identical to the plurality of first items included in the search request. An extraction step for extracting two small sentences, a sentence generation step for combining the plurality of extracted second small sentences to generate a third sentence, and transmission for transmitting the generated third sentence to the user's terminal device Steps.

  (16) In the above (15), a screen generation step of generating a display screen that prompts selection of the first small sentence until the second small sentence necessary for generating the third sentence is prepared may be further included.

  (17) In the above (15) or (16), the method further includes a correction reception step of receiving a second type of correction in which the second item of the extracted second small sentence is classified, and the sentence generation step includes the reception A third sentence may be generated based on the correction made.

  (18) In any one of the above (15) to (17), the plurality of first items into which the first small sentence is divided and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentence is divided are the same. You may have the item of.

  (19) In any of the above (15) to (18), the receiving step may receive a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. .

  (20) In the reception step, the first item included in the first small sentence selected and input in (19) may be received as a search request.

  (21) According to the fifth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is associated with the first item and the first type. The sentences included in the second sentence other than the first sentence are chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentences chaptered are a plurality of second Each item is divided into items, the second small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of second types in the second item, and the second small sentence is associated with the second item and the second type A sentence creation method for creating a third sentence from a stored judgment sentence database. The sentence creation method includes a request reception step for receiving a search request including a plurality of first items or first types from a user terminal device, and a plurality of first items or first types included in the search requests. An extraction step of extracting a plurality of second small sentences including the second item or the second type, an extraction step, and a sentence generation step of combining the plurality of extracted second small sentences to generate a third sentence; Transmitting the generated third sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (22) In the above (21), it may further include a screen generation step of generating a display screen that prompts selection of the first small sentence until the second small sentence necessary for generating the third sentence is prepared.

  (23) In the above (21) or (22), the method further includes a correction reception step of receiving a second type of correction of the extracted second small sentence, wherein the sentence generation step is based on the received correction. May be generated.

  (24) In any one of the above (21) to (23), the plurality of first items into which the first small sentence is divided and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentence is divided are the same. The plurality of first types in which the first small sentence is classified and the plurality of second types in which the second small sentence is classified may each have the same type.

  (25) In any one of the above (21) to (24), when the first item and the first type are received as a search request in the request reception step, the extraction step includes the first item and the first type. The second sentence or the second sentence associated with the second sentence may be extracted.

  (26) In any one of the above (21) to (25), the receiving step may receive a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. .

  (27) In the above (26), the receiving step may receive the first item or the first type included in the first inputted small text as a search request.

  (28) A sixth aspect of the present invention relates to a judgment sentence database creation device. An apparatus for creating a judgment sentence database includes sentence receiving means for receiving a first sentence and a second sentence from a computer, chaptering sentences included in the first sentence into a plurality of first small sentences, A chaptering means for chaptering a sentence contained in a sentence into a second sub-sentence, and a first sub-sentence for which a chapter is prepared is divided into a plurality of predetermined first items, and a second sub-part is prepared. Item classification means for classifying the sentence into a plurality of predetermined second items, the first sentence, the first small sentence, and the first item are stored in association with each other, the second sentence, the second small Storage means for storing the sentence and the second item in association with each other, and further storing the first sentence and the second sentence in association with each other.

  (29) According to the seventh aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and The present invention relates to a retrieval apparatus for a judgment sentence database stored in association with a first type. The judgment sentence database search device includes a request receiving means for receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from a user terminal device, and a first item similar to or identical to the first item or the first type included in the search request. Extraction means for extracting the first sentence associated with the other first small sentence including one item or the first type or the other first small sentence from the judgment sentence database, and the other extracted first small sentence Transmitting means for transmitting the first sentence associated with the sentence or the other first small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (30) In the eighth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a search apparatus for a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The judgment sentence database search device includes a request receiving means for receiving a search request including a first item from a user terminal device, and a second small item including a second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request. Extraction means for extracting a sentence, and transmission means for transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (31) According to the ninth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a sentence creation device that creates a third sentence from a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The sentence creation device includes: a request receiving unit that receives a search request including a plurality of first items from a user terminal device; and a plurality of second items that are similar or identical to the plurality of first items included in the search request. Extraction means for extracting two small sentences, sentence generation means for combining the plurality of extracted second small sentences to generate a third sentence, and transmission for transmitting the generated third sentence to the user's terminal device Means.

  (32) In the tenth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is associated with the first item and the first type. The sentences included in the second sentence other than the first sentence are chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentences chaptered are a plurality of second Each item is divided into items, the second small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of second types in the second item, and the second small sentence is associated with the second item and the second type The present invention relates to a sentence creation device that creates a third sentence from a stored judgment sentence database. The sentence creating device is similar to or identical to request receiving means for receiving a search request including a plurality of first items or first types from a user terminal device, and a plurality of first items or first types included in the search requests. Extraction means for extracting a plurality of second small sentences including the second item or the second type, extraction means, and sentence generation means for generating a third sentence by combining the extracted second small sentences; Transmitting means for transmitting the generated third sentence to the user terminal device.

  (33) An eleventh aspect of the present invention relates to a judgment sentence database creation program. A judgment sentence database creation program includes a sentence receiving function for receiving a first sentence and a second sentence from another computer, and a sentence included in the first sentence in a plurality of first sub-sentences. The chaptering function for chaptering the sentence contained in the second sentence into the second sub-sentence, and the chapter substituting the first sub-sentence into a plurality of predetermined first items, An item classification function that divides the second small sentence that has been made into a plurality of predetermined second items, a first sentence, a first small sentence, and a first item that are stored in association with each other. A storage function for storing a sentence, a second small sentence, and a second item in association with each other and further storing a first sentence and a second sentence in association with each other is realized.

  (34) In the twelfth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and The present invention relates to a search program for a judgment sentence database stored in association with a first type. The judgment sentence database search program is similar to the request reception function for receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from the user terminal device, and the first item or the first type included in the search request. An extraction function for extracting a first sentence associated with the other first small sentence including the same first item or first type or the other first small sentence from the judgment sentence database; And a transmission function for transmitting a first sentence associated with the first small sentence or the other first small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (35) In the thirteenth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the plurality of first sentences in which the chaptered first small sentences are predetermined. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a search program for a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The judgment sentence database search program includes a request receiving function for receiving a search request including a first item from a user terminal device, and a second item including a second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request. And an extraction function for extracting the second small sentence and a transmission function for transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the user's terminal device.

  (36) In the fourteenth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the plurality of first sentences in which the chaptered first small sentences are predetermined. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and is included in the second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentence that is chaptered is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are The present invention relates to a sentence creation program for creating a third sentence from a judgment sentence database stored in association with each other. The sentence creation program includes a request receiving function for receiving a search request including a plurality of first items from a user terminal device, and a second item similar or identical to the plurality of first items included in the search request. An extraction function that extracts a plurality of second small sentences, a sentence generation function that combines the plurality of extracted second small sentences to generate a third sentence, and the generated third sentence to the user's terminal device And a transmission function for transmission.

  (37) In the fifteenth aspect of the present invention, the sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the first sentences that are chaptered are determined in advance. Each item is divided into items, the first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is associated with the first item and the first type. The sentences included in the second sentence other than the first sentence are chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and the second small sentences chaptered are a plurality of second Each item is divided into items, the second small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of second types in the second item, and the second small sentence is associated with the second item and the second type And a sentence creation program for creating a third sentence from the stored judgment sentence database. The sentence creation program is similar or identical to the request reception function for receiving a search request including a plurality of first items or first types from a user terminal device, and the plurality of first items or first types included in the search requests. An extraction function for extracting a plurality of second small sentences including the second item or the second type, an extraction function, and a sentence generation function for generating a third sentence by combining the extracted second small sentences; And a transmission function for transmitting the generated third sentence to the user's terminal device.

  According to the present invention, a technique for appropriately categorizing a judgment sentence into small sentences and classifying or classifying the small sentences, and other judgments related to the judgment sentences from the itemized or classified small sentences. It is possible to provide a technique for searching a small sentence such as a small sentence or a comment, or a technique for creating a sentence such as a complaint from the itemized or classified small sentences.

It is a schematic diagram for demonstrating an example of the process by the judgment sentence management system. It is a figure which shows an example of schematic structure of a judgment sentence management system. It is a figure which shows an example of schematic structure of a server. It is a figure which shows an example of the data structure of a judgment sentence database. It is a figure which shows an example of the data structure of a comment database. It is a figure which shows an example of the data structure of a complaint database. It is an example of the data structure of the optimal extraction conditions of the several tea leaves memorize | stored in a memory | storage part It is a figure which shows an example of the sequence which produces a judgment sentence database. It is a figure which shows an example of the sequence which produces a comment database. It is a figure which shows an example of the sequence which produces a complaint database. It is a figure which shows an example of schematic structure of a terminal device. It is a figure which shows an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display part of a terminal device. It is an example of the operation | movement sequence which concerns on preparation of the complaint by the judgment sentence management system concerning Example 1. FIG. It is a figure which shows an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display part of a terminal device. It is an example of the operation | movement sequence which concerns on preparation of the complaint by the judgment sentence management system concerning Example 2. FIG. 10 is an example of a sentence creation screen according to Example 3; It is an example of the sentence creation screen after the screen transition concerning Example 3. FIG. It is an example of the operation | movement sequence which concerns on preparation of the complaint by the judgment sentence management system concerning Example 3. FIG. It is an example of the complaint preparation process by the judgment sentence management system concerning Example 3. It is a figure which shows an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display part of the terminal device concerning the modification 4 of Example 1. FIG.

  Hereinafter, a control method, a server, and a control program according to an aspect of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. However, it should be noted that the technical scope of the present disclosure is not limited to the embodiments, and extends to the invention described in the claims and equivalents thereof.

(Outline of processing by judgment sentence management system 1)
FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram for explaining an example of processing by the judgment sentence management system 1.

  The judgment sentence management system 1 receives a plurality of judgment sentences, comments, and complaints from one or more computers 2, stores them in the server 3, and judges sentences, comments, And provide complaints. Judgment sentences, commentaries, and complaints are sentences related to the trial and usually consist of text data. The judgment sentence may be image data (moving image, still image) or audio data in addition to text data.

  The server 3 stores a judgment sentence database 311, a comment database 312, and a complaint database 313. The judgment sentence database 311 stores a plurality of judgment sentences together with judgment sentence identification information (judgment sentence ID). The comment database 312 stores a plurality of comments together with comment identification information (remark ID). In the lawsuit database 313, a plurality of complaints are stored together with complaint identification information (a complaint ID). The judgment sentence database 311, the comment database 312, and the complaint database 313 store respective relationships among the judgment sentence identification information, the comment identification information, and the complaint identification information. This relationship may be stored in another database. In addition, the judgment sentence database 311, the comment database 312, and the complaint database 313 are composed of the same server in the present embodiment, but may be composed of a plurality of different servers. May exist outside of.

  The user transmits a search request to the server 3 using the terminal device 4 when searching for a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint stored in the server 3. In response to the received search request, the server 3 extracts the judgment sentence, the comment, and the complaint from the judgment sentence database 311, the comment database 312, and the complaint database 313 of the server 3, and transmits them to the user terminal device 4.

  The description of FIG. 1 described above is merely an explanation for deepening the understanding of the contents of the present invention. The present invention is specifically implemented in each embodiment described below, and may be implemented in various modifications without substantially exceeding the principle of the present invention. All such variations are within the scope of the present disclosure and the specification. For example, in the present embodiment, a configuration has been described in which a comment or complaint is searched for mainly on a judgment text. However, a configuration in which a judgment text is searched based on a comment or a complaint may be used. Furthermore, the sentence according to the present embodiment need not be interpreted as being limited to a judgment sentence, a comment, or a complaint. That is, it can be used for searching for sentences that are related to each other. Further, the sentence of the present invention is not limited to a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint, but can be applied to other sentences such as a written answer. For example, it can be applied to laws and regulations. When a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint are associated with the civil law, the first sentence, the first chapter, the first article, and the like are associated with the sentences of the judgment sentence, the comment, and the complaint as the corresponding sentences. In the present invention, regardless of the type of judgment, comment, or complaint, any one of the sentences other than the first sentence is the second sentence.

(Schematic configuration of the management system 1)
FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a schematic configuration of the judgment sentence management system 1.

  The judgment sentence management system 1 includes a plurality of computers 2, 2, 2..., A server 3, and a user terminal device 4. Hereinafter, the plurality of computers 2 may be simply referred to as computers 2. The computers 2, 2,... And the server 3 are connected to each other via a communication network such as the Internet 5, for example. Further, the user terminal device 4 and the server 3 are connected to each other via a communication network such as the Internet 5, for example. In addition, one Internet 5 is illustrated here, but when the Internet 5 is composed of a plurality of networks, a gateway (not shown) may be appropriately provided between the respective networks. A program executed by the computer 2 (for example, a browsing program) and a program executed by the server 3 (for example, a management program) communicate using a communication protocol such as a hypertext transfer protocol (HTTP).

(Schematic configuration of computer 2)
The computer 2 is a computer that transmits a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint to the server 3. The computer 2 is a personal computer, for example, and is connected to the server 3. The computer 2 transmits judgment sentence, comment, and complaint data to the server 3 in response to a request from the server 3, or judges sentence, comment, and complaint from the computer 2 to the server 3 in response to the operation of the computer 2. Are sent to the server 3. The acquisition request for the judgment sentence, the comment, and the complaint data may be made by an administrator terminal (not shown) of the server 3 or may be received from the terminal device 4.

(Schematic configuration of server 3)
FIG. 3 is a diagram illustrating an example of a schematic configuration of the server 3.

  The server 3 stores a database that stores a plurality of judgment sentences, a comment database that stores a plurality of comments, and a complaint database that stores a plurality of complaints. The judgment sentence database 311 stores a plurality of judgment sentences together with judgment sentence identification information (judgment sentence ID). The comment database 312 stores a plurality of comments together with comment identification information (remark ID). In the lawsuit database 313, a plurality of complaints are stored together with complaint identification information (a complaint ID). The judgment sentence database 311, the comment database 312, and the complaint database 313 store respective relationships among the judgment sentence identification information, the comment identification information, and the complaint identification information. These judgment sentence, comment and complaint are received from the computer 2 by the server 3 and searched by the terminal device 4. Then, the server 3 searches for a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint based on the search condition input by the terminal device 4, and transmits it to the terminal device 4. In order to implement the functions as described above, the server 3 further includes a server communication unit 314, a server storage unit 315, and a server processing unit 316.

  The server communication unit 314 has a communication interface circuit for connecting the server 3 to the Internet 5. The server communication unit 314 receives sentences such as a judgment sentence, a comment, and a complaint from the computer 2. In some cases, the server communication unit transmits an acquisition request for a sentence such as a judgment sentence, a comment, or a complaint to the computer 2. Further, the server communication unit 314 transmits data such as search conditions received from the terminal device 4 to the server processing unit 316. Then, the server communication unit 314 transmits the extraction result obtained from the server processing unit 316 and the generated screen configuration to the terminal device 4. The server communication unit 314 can transmit or receive information other than those described above to the computer 2 or the terminal device 4.

  The server storage unit 315 includes, for example, at least one of a semiconductor memory, a magnetic disk device, and an optical disk device, and is connected to the server 3 via a bus. The server storage unit 315 stores a driver program, an operating system program, an application program, data, and the like used for processing by the server processing unit 316. For example, the server storage unit 315 stores a communication device driver program that controls the server communication unit 314 as a driver program. The computer program may be installed in the server storage unit 315 using a known setup program or the like from a computer-readable portable recording medium such as a CD-ROM or DVD-ROM. The server storage unit 315 stores a judgment sentence database 311, a comment database 312, a complaint database 313, and the like.

  The server processing unit 316 creates chapters, categorizes items, and categorizes sentences received from the computer 2, and stores the sentences, small sentences, items, and types in the server storage unit 315 in association with each other. . Further, the server processing unit 316 extracts a search result in response to various search requests received from the user terminal device 4, generates a screen configuration to transmit the extracted search result to the user terminal device 4, and generates The transmitted screen configuration is sent to the server communication unit 314. These functions are function modules realized by a program executed by a processor included in the server processing unit 316. Alternatively, each of these units may be mounted on the server 3 as an independent integrated circuit, a microprocessor, or firmware. The processing content of the server processing unit 316 will be described later.

(Data structure of the database)
4A to 4C are diagrams illustrating examples of data structures of various databases.

  Note that the server storage unit 315 does not store various databases, but another device (such as a database) having a storage unit that can be connected to the server 3 may store these various databases. In this case, when using the information stored in these various databases, the server 3 accesses another device that stores the database and acquires the information stored in the database. Each information included in each database may be stored in a format other than the database, for example, may be stored independently.

  FIG. 4A is a table for explaining the configuration of the judgment sentence database 311. The judgment sentence database 311 includes the aforementioned judgment sentence identification information, the first small sentence in which the judgment sentence is chaptered, the first small sentence identification information (first small sentence ID), and a plurality of predetermined first small sentences. The first item identification information (first item ID) divided into items for each of the first items and the type of whether the first small sentence divided into items belongs to which of the plurality of first types in each first item The divided first type identification information (first type ID) is stored in association with each other. In the judgment sentence database 311, two or more of the judgment sentence identification information, the first small sentence identification information, the first item identification information, and the first type identification information may be stored in association with each other. That is, identification information to be stored can be set as appropriate according to the usage of the judgment sentence database 311.

  The judgment sentence database 311 receives a judgment sentence from the computer 2 that exists separately from the server 3, and is chaptered by the server processing unit 316. The server processing unit 316 gives the judgment sentence identification information to the judgment sentence, further gives the first small sentence identification information to the first small sentence made in the chapter, and associates these identification information with each other in the judgment sentence database 311. Remember. Further, the judgment sentence database 311 stores correspondence between judgment sentence identification information and judgment sentence identification information in the comment database 312 described later and complaint identification information in the complaint database 313. This association may be stored in the comment database 312 or the complaint database 313, or may be stored in another storage unit.

  FIG. 4B is a table for explaining the structure of the comment database 312. The comment database 312 includes the above-described comment identification information, the second small sentence in which the comment is set as a chapter, the second small sentence identification information (second small sentence ID), and a plurality of second texts in which the second small sentence is predetermined. The second item identification information (second item ID) divided into items for each item, and the second small sentence divided into items are classified into which of the plurality of second types in each second item Second type identification information (second type ID) is stored in association with each other. The comment database 312 may store two or more of the comment identification information, the second small sentence identification information, the second item identification information, and the second type identification information in association with each other. That is, the identification information to be stored can be set as appropriate according to the intended use of the comment database 312.

  The comment database 312 receives comments from the computer 2 that exists separately from the server 3 and is chaptered by the server processing unit 316. The server processing unit 316 assigns the comment identification information to the comment, further assigns the second small sentence identification information to the second small sentence in the chapter, and stores the identification information in association with each other in the comment database 312. The comment database 312 stores correspondence between the comment identification information and the judgment sentence identification information of the judgment sentence database 311 and the complaint identification information of the complaint database 313 described later. This association may be stored in the judgment sentence database 311 or the complaint database 313, or may be stored in another storage unit.

  FIG. 4C is a table for explaining the configuration of the complaint database 313. The complaint database 313 includes the above-mentioned complaint identification information, the third small sentence in which the complaint is presented as a chapter, the third small sentence identification information (third small sentence ID), and a plurality of third numbers in which the third small sentence is predetermined. The third item identification information (third item ID) divided into items for each item, and the type of which the third small sentence divided into items belongs to which of the plurality of third types in each third item Third type identification information (third type ID) is stored in association with each other. The complaint database 313 may store two or more of the complaint identification information, the third small sentence identification information, the third item identification information, and the third type identification information in association with each other. That is, identification information to be stored can be set as appropriate according to the intended use of the complaint database 313.

  The complaint database 313 receives complaints from the computer 2 that exists separately from the server 3 and is chaptered by the server processing unit 316. The server processing unit 316 assigns the complaint identification information to the complaint, further adds the third small sentence identification information to the third small sentence in the chapter, and stores the identification information in association with each other in the complaint database 313. The complaint database 313 stores correspondence between complaint identification information and judgment sentence identification information in the judgment sentence database 311 and comment identification information in the comment database 312. This association may be stored in the judgment sentence database 311 or the comment database 312 or may be stored in another storage unit. In the present invention, regardless of the type of judgment sentence, comment, or complaint, a small sentence of any one sentence is referred to as a first small sentence, and a small sentence of any other sentence is referred to as a second small sentence. Call. The same applies to items and types.

(How to create a judgment text database)
A method for creating the judgment sentence database 311 shown in FIG. 4A will be described. Judgment sentence database creation processing is performed by the server processing unit 316, and processing is appropriately performed at the timing when the judgment sentence is received from the computer 2. In addition, when the judgment sentence received from the computer 2 is chaptered in advance, divided into items, or classified, the server 3 only needs to store the received judgment sentence as appropriate.

  FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sequence for creating the judgment sentence database 311 performed by the server processing unit 316.

  First, the server processing unit 316 determines whether the file received by the computer 2 is other than a text file and it is difficult to create a chapter. If it is determined that the file is not a text file (NO in S501), the judgment text received as error processing is not stored in the judgment text database 311.

  On the other hand, if the file received from the computer 2 is a text file (YES in S501), judgment sentence identification information is assigned in S502. Note that the judgment sentence identification number may be a file name when received from the computer 2, so that the server processing unit 316 does not necessarily need to give it.

  Next, the server processing unit 316 performs chaptering processing in S503. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 sets a chapter in the first small sentence and assigns first small sentence identification information to each first small sentence.

  Here, chaptering is to divide a sentence into chapters and sections and list the titles in those chapters and sections. Normally, chaptering is performed before a sentence is created, but in the present embodiment, the created sentence is a chapter that is later created. Specifically, the sentence received by the server processing unit 316 is added with a title according to a word that appears for each paragraph, or a word that appears at a predetermined position of the sentence is identified as a title. In the present embodiment, the title is intended for an item or type. In addition to the appearance word, the chaptering method can be performed by extracting a specific character string, or by using the length of the sentence or the number of sentences.

  In subsequent S504, the server processing unit 316 performs item classification for each of the plurality of first items determined in advance in each of the judgment sentences chaptered in the first small sentence in S503. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 gives first item identification information indicating which item each of the first small sentences is divided into. In addition to using the appearance word for each first small sentence, the item division can be performed by extracting a specific character string, or depending on the length of the sentence or the number of sentences. Here, the item is composed of a main sentence, a reason, an outline of facts, a point of issue, a judgment on a point of issue, a conclusion, etc., which are components of a judgment sentence. In addition, for example, an issue is usually composed of multiple issues. Therefore, an item with a large amount of text such as an issue may be divided into items such as issue 1, issue 2,. The item classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration. That is, it can be assumed that the judgment sentence has a tree structure as shown in FIG.

  Further, the server processing unit 316 can create a table of contents by displaying the items as a list on the user terminal device 4. The present invention can also be realized by displaying this table of contents instead of the first small sentence, or displaying both the table of contents and the first small sentence. The table of contents is sometimes called TOC (Table of Contents) by those skilled in the art. As usage of the table of contents, by selecting a table of contents, a small sentence corresponding to the selected table of contents can be displayed, or a table of contents corresponding to the small sentence being displayed or selected can be displayed. An example in which a table of contents is added to the present invention and an example in which a table of contents is applied instead of a small sentence will be described later as a modification.

  In subsequent S505, the server processing unit 316 classifies which of the plurality of first types belongs to the itemized first small sentence. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 gives first type identification information indicating which first type each of the first items belongs to. This step 505 is a process necessary for associating the itemized first small sentence with a small sentence of another sentence, and can be omitted in the case of a process only for the chapter preparation. Furthermore, this step S505 can be omitted when the sentence received by the computer 2 is associated with another sentence. In other words, when the items of the judgment sentence and other sentences match, it can be assumed that the types of the small sentences match. The classification is performed by extracting a character string or a numerical value in a specific item. Here, the type can be arbitrarily set, and is, for example, at least one of whether the judgment is affirmative or negative, the type of law used for the issue, the amount of the lawsuit, and the like. The classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration.

  In step S506, the server processing unit 316 associates the judgment sentence identification information that is the identification information of the received judgment sentence with the first small sentence identification information, the first term identification information, and the first type identification information. And stored in the judgment sentence database 311. Furthermore, when there is another sentence associated with the judgment sentence, the server processing unit 316 stores the judgment identification information and the complaint identification information in association with each other. S506 associates the judgment sentence identification information, the first small sentence identification information, and the first item identification information in a case where the itemized first small sentence identification information is not associated with the small sentence of another sentence. Just remember.

(How to create a comment database)
A method for creating the comment database 312 shown in FIG. 4B will be described. The creation process of the comment database is performed by the server processing unit 316 and is appropriately performed at the timing when the comment is received from the computer 2. In addition, when the comment received from the computer 2 is chaptered in advance, divided into items, or classified, the server 3 only needs to store the received comment appropriately.

  FIG. 7 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sequence for creating the comment database 312 performed by the server processing unit 316.

  First, the server processing unit 316 determines whether the file received by the computer 2 is other than a text file and it is difficult to create a chapter. If it is determined that the file is not a text file (NO in S701), the comment received as error processing is not stored in the comment database 312.

  On the other hand, if the file received from the computer 2 is a text file (YES in S701), comment identification information is assigned in S702. Note that the comment identification number may be a file name when received from the computer 2, and therefore the server processing unit 316 does not necessarily need to give it.

  Next, the server processing unit 316 performs chaptering processing in S703. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 sets a comment for the second small sentence and assigns the second small sentence identification information to each second small sentence. If the received file is other than a text file and it is difficult to create a chapter, the received comment is not stored in the comment database 312 as error processing.

  Here, chaptering is to divide a sentence into chapters and sections and list the titles in those chapters and sections. Normally, chaptering is performed before a sentence is created, but in the present embodiment, the created sentence is a chapter that is later created. Specifically, the sentence received by the server processing unit 316 is added with a title according to a word that appears for each paragraph, or a word that appears at a predetermined position of the sentence is identified as a title. In the present embodiment, the title is intended for an item or type. In addition to the appearance word, the chaptering method can be performed by extracting a specific character string, or by using the length of the sentence or the number of sentences.

  In subsequent S704, the server processing unit 316 performs item classification for each of a plurality of second items determined in advance in each comment set in the second small sentence in S704. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 gives second item identification information indicating which item each of the second small sentences is divided into. In addition to using the appearance word for each second small sentence, the item division can be performed by extracting a specific character string, or by using the length of the sentence or the number of sentences. Here, the item is composed of the main components, reason, summary of facts, issues, judgments on issues, conclusions, etc., which are components of commentary. In addition, for example, an issue is usually composed of multiple issues. Therefore, an item with a large amount of text such as an issue may be divided into items such as issue 1, issue 2,. The item classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration. Moreover, it can be assumed that the comment has a tree structure as shown in FIG.

  Further, the server processing unit 316 can create a table of contents by displaying the items as a list on the user terminal device 4. The present invention can also be realized by displaying this table of contents in place of the second small sentence, or displaying the table of contents together with the second small sentence. The table of contents is sometimes called TOC (Table of Contents) by those skilled in the art. As usage of the table of contents, by selecting a table of contents, a small sentence corresponding to the selected table of contents can be displayed, or a table of contents corresponding to the small sentence being displayed or selected can be displayed. An example in which a table of contents is added to the present invention and an example in which a table of contents is applied instead of a small sentence will be described later as a modification.

  In subsequent S705, the server processing unit 316 classifies which of the plurality of second types belongs to the itemized second small sentence. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 gives second type identification information indicating which second type each of the second items belongs to. This step S705 is a process necessary for associating the second small sentence divided into items with a small sentence of another sentence, and can be omitted in the case of a process only for the chapter preparation. Further, this step S705 can be omitted when another sentence is associated with the comment received by the computer 2. That is, when the items of comment and other sentences match, it can be assumed that the types of small sentences match. The classification is performed by extracting a character string or a numerical value in a specific item. Here, the type can be arbitrarily set, and is, for example, at least one of whether the judgment is affirmative or negative, the type of law used for the issue, the amount of the lawsuit, and the like. The classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration.

  In step S706, the server processing unit 316 associates the comment identification information that is the identification information of the received comment with the second small sentence identification information, the second term identification information, and the second type identification information. Store in database 312. Further, when there is another sentence associated with the comment, the server processing unit 316 associates and stores the sentence identification information and the complaint identification information with the comment identification information. S706 stores the comment identification information, the second small sentence identification information, and the second item identification information in association with each other when the itemized second small sentence identification information is not associated with the small sentence of another sentence. do it.

(How to create a complaint database)
A method for creating the complaint database 313 shown in FIG. 4C will be described. The process for creating the complaint database is performed by the server processing unit 316 and is appropriately performed at the timing when the complaint is received from the computer 2. In addition, when the complaint received from the computer 2 is chaptered in advance, divided into items, or classified, the server 3 only needs to store the received complaint appropriately.

  FIG. 8 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sequence for creating the complaint database 313 performed by the server processing unit 316.

  First, the server processing unit 316 determines whether the file received by the computer 2 is other than a text file and it is difficult to create a chapter. If it is determined that the file is not a text file (NO in S801), the complaint received as error processing is not stored in the complaint database 313.

  On the other hand, when the file received from the computer 2 is a text file (YES in S801), the complaint identification information is assigned in S802. Since the complaint identification number may be a file name when received from the computer 2, the server processing unit 316 may not necessarily give it.

  Next, the server processing unit 316 performs chaptering processing in S803. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 sets a chapter for the third small sentence and gives third small sentence identification information to each third small sentence. When the received file is other than a text file and it is difficult to create a chapter, the complaint received as error processing is not stored in the complaint database 313.

  Here, chaptering is to divide a sentence into chapters and sections and list the titles in those chapters and sections. Normally, chaptering is performed before a sentence is created, but in the present embodiment, the created sentence is a chapter that is later created. Specifically, the sentence received by the server processing unit 316 is added with a title according to a word that appears for each paragraph, or a word that appears at a predetermined position of the sentence is identified as a title. In the present embodiment, the title is intended for an item or type. In addition to the appearance word, the chaptering method can be performed by extracting a specific character string, or by using the length of the sentence or the number of sentences.

  In subsequent S804, the server processing unit 316 classifies each complaint complained in the third small sentence in S804 into a plurality of predetermined third items. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 gives third item identification information indicating which item each of the third small sentences is divided into. The item division can be performed by extracting a specific character string for each third small sentence in addition to using an appearance word, or by using a sentence length or the number of sentences. Here, the item is composed of the purpose, cause, summary of facts, issue, judgment on issue, conclusion, etc., which are the components of the complaint. In addition, for example, an issue is usually composed of multiple issues. Therefore, an item with a large amount of text such as an issue may be divided into items such as issue 1, issue 2,. The item classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration. Moreover, it can be assumed that the complaint has a tree structure as shown in FIG.

  Further, the server processing unit 316 can create a table of contents by displaying the items as a list on the user terminal device 4. The present invention can also be realized by displaying this table of contents instead of the third small sentence, or displaying the table of contents together with the third small sentence. The table of contents is sometimes called TOC (Table of Contents) by those skilled in the art. As usage of the table of contents, by selecting a table of contents, a small sentence corresponding to the selected table of contents can be displayed, or a table of contents corresponding to the small sentence being displayed or selected can be displayed. An example in which a table of contents is added to the present invention and an example in which a table of contents is applied instead of a small sentence will be described later as a modification.

  In subsequent S805, the server processing unit 316 classifies which of the plurality of third types belongs to the itemized third small sentence. Specifically, the server processing unit 316 assigns third type identification information indicating which third type each of the third items belongs to. This step S805 is a process necessary for associating the itemized third small sentence with a small sentence of another sentence, and can be omitted in the case of a process only for the chapter preparation. Further, this step S805 can be omitted when it is associated with a small sentence of another sentence associated with the complaint received by the computer 2. Furthermore, this step S805 can be omitted when another sentence is associated with the comment received by the computer 2. The classification is performed by extracting a character string or a numerical value in a specific item. Here, the type can be arbitrarily set, and is, for example, at least one of whether the judgment is affirmative or negative, the type of law used for the issue, the amount of the lawsuit, and the like. The classification method of the present invention is not limited to this configuration.

  In step S806, the server processing unit 316 associates the complaint identification information that is identification information of the received complaint with the third small sentence identification information, the third term identification information, and the third type identification information. Store in database 313. Further, when there is another sentence associated with the complaint, the server processing unit 316 associates and stores the judgment sentence identification information and the comment identification information with the complaint identification information. S806 stores the complaint identification information, the third small sentence identification information, and the third item identification information in association with each other when the itemized third small sentence identification information is not associated with the small sentence of another sentence. do it.

(Schematic configuration of the terminal device 4)
FIG. 9 is a diagram illustrating an example of a schematic configuration of the terminal device 4.

  The terminal device 4 executes connection to a wireless communication network, Web access, and the like. Therefore, the terminal device 4 includes a terminal communication unit 411, a terminal storage unit 412, a terminal operation unit 413, a terminal display unit 414, and a terminal processing unit 415.

  The terminal device 4 is assumed to be a tablet PC or a notebook PC, but the present invention is not limited to this. The terminal device 4 only needs to be applicable to the present invention. For example, a multi-function mobile phone (so-called “smart phone”), a mobile phone (so-called “feature phone”), a personal digital assistant (PDA), a mobile game machine, a mobile phone, etc. A music player, a tablet terminal, etc. may be sufficient.

  The terminal communication unit 411 includes a communication interface circuit and connects the terminal device 4 to the Internet 5. The terminal communication unit 411 transmits the data supplied from the terminal processing unit 415 via the network to the server 3 or the like. Further, the terminal communication unit 411 supplies data received from the server 3 or the like via the network to the terminal processing unit 415.

  The terminal storage unit 412 includes, for example, a semiconductor memory device. The terminal storage unit 412 stores an operating system program, a driver program, an application program, data, and the like used for processing in the terminal processing unit 415. For example, the terminal storage unit 412 stores an input device driver program that controls the terminal operation unit 413, an output device driver program that controls the terminal display unit 414, and the like as driver programs. In addition, the terminal storage unit 412 displays a registration screen for registering the search conditions, feature information, feature images, and the like input by operating the terminal operation unit 413 as the application program in the server 3. The browsing program etc. are memorized. Various programs may be installed in the terminal storage unit 412 using a known setup program or the like from a computer-readable portable recording medium such as a CD-ROM or a DVD-ROM. Further, the terminal storage unit 412 may temporarily store temporary data related to a predetermined process.

  The terminal operation unit 413 may be any device that can operate the terminal device 4, and is, for example, a mouse, a touch panel, or a key button. The user can use the terminal operation unit 413 to select and cancel information, and input characters and numbers. When operated by the user, the terminal operation unit 413 generates a signal corresponding to the operation. Then, the generated signal is transmitted to the terminal processing unit 415.

  The terminal display unit 414 may be any device as long as it can display video, images, and the like, such as a liquid crystal display or an organic EL (Electro-Luminescence) display. The terminal display unit 414 displays a video corresponding to the video data supplied from the terminal processing unit 415, an image corresponding to the image data, and the like.

  The terminal processing unit 415 includes one or a plurality of processors and their peripheral circuits. The terminal processing unit 415 controls the overall operation of the terminal device 4 and is, for example, a CPU. The terminal processing unit 415 includes a terminal communication unit 411 and a terminal so that various processes of the terminal device 4 are executed in an appropriate procedure based on a program stored in the terminal storage unit 412 and an operation of the terminal operation unit 413. The operation of the display unit 414 and the like is controlled. The terminal processing unit 415 executes processing based on programs (operating system program, driver program, application program, etc.) stored in the terminal storage unit 412. Further, the terminal processing unit 415 can execute a plurality of programs (such as application programs) in parallel.

  The terminal processing unit 415 performs processing based on the function of processing the screen display information received from the outside of the terminal device 4 as screen display that can be viewed by the user, and processing based on the operation content of the terminal operation unit 413 from the user. A function of converting to a signal that can be transmitted to the outside and sending the signal to the terminal transmission unit 411 is provided. These functions are function modules realized by a program executed by a processor included in the terminal processing unit 415. Alternatively, each of these units may be mounted on the terminal device 4 as an independent integrated circuit, a microprocessor, or firmware.

(Example 1)
A feature of the judgment sentence management system 1 will be described as a first embodiment. Note that in this embodiment mode, the first embodiment can be combined with another embodiment. However, the description of the detailed combination is omitted.

(Function of terminal device 4)
FIG. 10 is a diagram illustrating an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display unit 414 of the terminal device 4.

  FIG. 10 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sentence search screen 400 displayed on the terminal device 4. The sentence search screen 400 is a screen that is displayed when the user accesses a website for searching sentences such as a judgment sentence, a comment, or a complaint using the terminal device 4. In the present embodiment, a configuration in which similar judgment sentences are searched from small sentences of arbitrary judgment sentences is illustrated. In this embodiment, in addition to searching for judgment sentences, it is also possible to search for comments, search for complaints, and further search for a comment similar to a small sentence of a judgment sentence. The sentence search screen 400 includes a judgment sentence display area 401 that is an area for displaying an arbitrary judgment sentence, a search result display area 402 that is an area for displaying a search result, and a mouse pointer 403 that is moved by a user's mouse operation. Etc. are displayed.

  In the judgment sentence display area 401, a first small sentence in which a judgment sentence is chaptered is displayed. Specifically, each item is displayed so as to be identifiable to the user. In the example of FIG. 10, the judgment sentence is divided into a small sentence 1 404, a small sentence 2 405, a small sentence 3 406, and a small sentence 4 407.

  The mouse pointer 403 allows the user to select an arbitrary first small sentence displayed in the judgment sentence display area 401 by a mouse operation. Here, selection means an operation of clicking a mouse, an operation of selecting an area while holding down a mouse button, an operation of moving the pointer position of the mouse (so-called mouse over), and the like. In this embodiment, a mouse over will be described as an example.

  In the search result display area 402, a judgment sentence or a first small sentence including a first small sentence similar to the first small sentence selected by the user is displayed. In the example of FIG. 10, since the mouse pointer selects the small sentence 2 405 by mouse over, the search result display area 402 displays the first small sentences 408 a, 408 b, and 408 c similar to the small sentence 2 405. ing. When there are a plurality of judgment sentences or first small sentences similar to the small sentence 2 405, a plurality of judgment sentences or first small sentences are displayed as shown in FIG. 10, and similar judgment sentences or first small sentences are extracted. If not, nothing is displayed in the search result display area 402.

(Search for small sentences that are similar to the small sentence of the judgment sentence)
FIG. 11 is a diagram illustrating an example of an operation sequence related to retrieval of a judgment text by the judgment text management system 1 according to the first embodiment.

  The operation sequence described below is executed mainly by the server processing unit 316 in cooperation with each element of the server 3 based on a program stored in the server storage unit 315 in advance. The operation sequence described below cooperates with each element of the terminal device 4 mainly by the terminal processing unit 415 of the terminal device 4 based on a program stored in advance in the terminal storage unit 412 of the terminal device 4. And executed. In the operation sequence described below, the server 3 transmits and receives various types of information to and from the terminal device 4 via the server communication unit 314.

  First, the server 3 accepts a selection input of a judgment text to be displayed from the terminal device 4 of the user, extracts a judgment text corresponding to the judgment text identification information selected and input from the judgment text database 311, and stores the judgment text in the terminal device. 4 (S1101).

  Next, the server processing unit 316 receives a selection input of an arbitrary first small sentence from the displayed chaptered judgment sentences (S1102). The first small sentence selected and input here is a search condition desired by the user. This selection input may be any one first small sentence, or two or more selection inputs may be accepted. When multiple selection inputs are accepted, multiple search results are displayed by displaying individual search results for each input, or results that match multiple search conditions are displayed after performing an AND search. Or

  Then, the server processing unit 316 refers to the judgment sentence database 311, and first item identification information and first type identification associated with the first small sentence identification information which is identification information of the first small sentence selected and inputted. Information is extracted (S1103).

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 extracts first short sentence identification information having the same first item identification information and first type identification information as the extracted first item identification information and first type identification information (S1104). ). As described above, the server processing unit 316 may extract the second item identification information or the second type identification information identical to the first item identification information and the first type identification information from the comment database 312 in S1104. Item identification information or third type identification information may be extracted from the complaint database 313. In the present embodiment, first short sentence identification information having the same first item identification information or first type identification information as either of the first item identification information and the first type identification information may be extracted. Furthermore, in this embodiment, first short sentence identification information having first item identification information and first type identification information similar to the first item identification information and the first type identification information may be extracted.

  That is, when the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is selected and input by the user in the example of FIG. 4A, the first item identification information included in the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is 01-K004, Since the one type identification information is 01-S005, the first small sentence identification information 01-B005 having the same item identification information and type identification information is extracted. Then, at least one of the sentence corresponding to the first small sentence identification information 01-B005 or the judgment sentence identification information 01-002 including the first small sentence or the judgment sentence is transmitted to the terminal device 4.

  In this embodiment, a similar judgment sentence is searched from the first small sentence of an arbitrary judgment sentence, but a sentence other than the similar judgment sentence can also be searched. For example, when searching for the second small sentence of the comment from the first small sentence of the judgment sentence, the server processing unit 316 uses the second item identification information or the second type identification identical to the first item identification information and the first type identification information. Information is extracted from the comment database 312. In this case, it is preferable that the first item identification information and the second item identification information are related or have the same (common) item classification. Furthermore, it is preferable that the first type identification information and the second type identification information are related or have the same (common) type classification. For example, in the example of FIG. 4B, when the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is selected and input by the user, the first item identification information included in the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is 01-K004, Since the first type identification information is 01-S005, the second small sentence identification information 02-B002 and 02-B005 having the same item identification information and type identification information are extracted from the comment database 312. Then, at least one of the second small sentence identification information 02-B002 and 02-B005 or the second small sentence corresponding to the comment identification information 02-001 and 02-002 including the second small sentence or the comment is stored in the terminal device 4. Sent.

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 determines whether there is an extraction result corresponding to the judgment sentence database 311 (S1105). If there is no extraction result (NO in S1105), this process ends because there is no result to be displayed.

  On the other hand, when the extraction result exists (YES in S1105), the server processing unit 316 generates a judgment sentence including the first small sentence or a screen configuration for displaying the first small sentence as the extraction result, and the terminal device 4 Transmit (S1106).

  As described above, the judgment sentence management system 1 according to the first embodiment can extract a judgment sentence, a comment, a complaint and the like having a small sentence similar or identical to the first small sentence selected and input by the user with the terminal device 4. As an extraction result, a similar or identical small sentence or a sentence including the small sentence can be displayed. Therefore, the user can easily search and browse similar judgment sentences, comments, complaints, and the like.

(Example 2)
A feature of the judgment sentence management system 1 will be described as a second embodiment. In the present embodiment, Example 2 can be combined with other examples. However, the description of the detailed combination is omitted.

(Function of terminal device 4)
FIG. 12 is a diagram illustrating an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display unit 414 of the terminal device 4.

  FIG. 12 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sentence search screen 500 displayed on the terminal device 4. The sentence search screen 500 is a screen that is displayed when the user accesses a website for searching sentences such as a judgment sentence, a comment, or a complaint using the terminal device 4. In the present embodiment, a configuration in which a comment associated with a judgment sentence is searched from a small sentence of an arbitrary judgment sentence is illustrated. In the present embodiment, as long as the sentence is associated with the judgment sentence, it is also possible to search for a complaint other than the comment. The sentence search screen 500 includes a judgment sentence display area 501 that displays an arbitrary judgment sentence, a search result display area 502 that displays a search result, and a mouse pointer 503 that is moved by a user's mouse operation. Etc. are displayed.

  In the judgment sentence display area 501, a first small sentence in which a judgment sentence is chaptered is displayed. Specifically, each item is displayed so as to be identifiable to the user. In the example of FIG. 12, the judgment sentence is displayed as a plurality of first small sentences divided into a small sentence 1 504, a small sentence 2 505, a small sentence 3 506, and a small sentence 4 507.

  The mouse pointer 503 allows the user to select an arbitrary first small sentence displayed in the judgment sentence display area 501 by a mouse operation. Here, selection means an operation of clicking a mouse, an operation of selecting an area while holding down a mouse button, an operation of moving the pointer position of the mouse (so-called mouse over), and the like. In this embodiment, a mouse over will be described as an example.

  In the search result display area 502, the comment or the second small sentence including the second small sentence of the comment corresponding to the judgment sentence associated with the first small sentence selected by the user is displayed. In the example of FIG. 12, since the mouse pointer selects the small sentence 2 505 by mouse over, the search result display area 502 displays the second small sentence 508 corresponding to the small sentence 2 505. If no comment or second small sentence corresponding to the small sentence 2 505 is extracted, nothing is displayed in the search result display area 502. When the second small sentence corresponding to the small sentence 2 505 is displayed in the search result display area 502, the user is selected by extracting the second small sentence having the same item as the item of the small sentence 2 505. You can read the comment on the first item (second small sentence). Furthermore, in the present embodiment, the correspondence between the judgment sentence and the corresponding comment is stored in the judgment sentence database 311 or the comment database 312 or a storage unit other than these. In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 4B, the comment database 312 stores the comments corresponding to the judgment sentences. Therefore, the judgment sentence database 311 and the comment database 312 need not store the types of the first small sentence and the second small sentence.

(Small text search of other sentences corresponding to the judgment sentence)
FIG. 13 is a diagram illustrating an example of an operation sequence related to retrieval of a judgment text by the judgment text management system 1 according to the second embodiment.

  The operation sequence described below is executed mainly by the server processing unit 316 in cooperation with each element of the server 3 based on a program stored in the server storage unit 315 in advance. The operation sequence described below cooperates with each element of the terminal device 4 mainly by the terminal processing unit 415 of the terminal device 4 based on a program stored in advance in the terminal storage unit 412 of the terminal device 4. And executed. In the operation sequence described below, the server 3 transmits and receives various types of information to and from the terminal device 4 via the server communication unit 314.

  First, the server 3 accepts a selection input of a judgment text to be displayed from the terminal device 4 of the user, extracts a judgment text corresponding to the judgment text identification information selected and input from the judgment text database 311, and stores the judgment text in the terminal device. 4 (S1301).

  Next, the server processing unit 316 receives a selection input of an arbitrary first small sentence from the displayed chaptered judgment sentences (S1302). The first small sentence selected and input here is a search condition desired by the user. This selection input may be any one first small sentence, or two or more selection inputs may be accepted. When a plurality of selection inputs are accepted, individual search results can be displayed for each input.

  Then, the server processing unit 316 refers to the judgment sentence database 311 and extracts the first item identification information associated with the first small sentence identification information that is the identification information of the first small sentence selected and inputted (S1303). ).

  Next, the server processing unit 316 determines whether there is comment identification information associated with the judgment sentence identification information selected and input in S1301 (S1304). Here, if there is no comment identification information associated with the judgment sentence identification information (NO in S1304), this process is terminated.

  On the other hand, if there is comment identification information associated with the judgment sentence identification information (YES in S1304), the server processing unit 316 has second item identification information that is similar or identical to the extracted first item identification information. Second small sentence identification information is extracted (S1305). As described above, in S1305, the third item identification information associated with the first item identification information may be extracted from the complaint database 313. In this embodiment, the server processing unit 316 extracts second small sentence identification information having the second item identification information that is the same as the first item identification information. Further, it is preferable that the first item identification information and the second item identification information have the same (common) item classification.

  That is, in the example of FIG. 4A, since the first item identification information included in the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is 01-K004, when the first small sentence identification information 01-B002 is selected and input by the user, 4B, the second small sentence identification information 02-B002 having the related sentence identification number and the same item identification information is extracted. Then, at least one of the sentence corresponding to the second small sentence identification information 02-B002 or the comment identification information 02-001 including the second small sentence or the comment is transmitted to the terminal device 4.

  In the present embodiment, it is configured to search for the comment associated with the first small sentence of any judgment sentence, but sentences other than the combination of the judgment sentence and the comment can also be applied. For example, when applied to a combination of a comment and a complaint, the comment identification information and the complaint identification information may be associated with each other in the comment database 312 or the complaint database 313. Then, the server processing unit 316 extracts a third small sentence having the same third item identification information as the second item identification information. Also in the present embodiment, it is preferable that the second item identification information and the third item identification information have the same (common) item classification. For example, when the second small sentence identification information 02-B008 is selected and input by the user in the example of FIG. 4B, the server processing unit 316 first determines whether the complaint identification information associated with the comment identification information 03-003 exists. to decide. In this case, since the corresponding complaint identification information 03-001 exists, the server processing unit extracts third small sentence identification information having the same item identification information as the second item identification information. In this example, since it is the second item identification information 02-K009 of the second small sentence identification information 02-B008, the third small sentence identification information 03 having the same item identification information from the complaint database 313 shown in FIG. 4C. -B002 is extracted. Then, at least one of the third small sentence identification information 03-B002 or the third small sentence corresponding to the comment identification information 03-001 including the third small sentence or the complaint is transmitted to the terminal device 4.

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 determines whether an extraction result corresponding to the comment database 312 exists (S1306). If there is no extraction result (S1306: NO), this process ends because there is no result to display.

  On the other hand, when the extraction result exists (YES in S1306), the server processing unit 316 generates a comment including the second small sentence or a screen configuration for displaying the second small sentence as the extraction result, and transmits it to the terminal device 4. (S1307).

  As described above, the judgment sentence management system 1 according to the second embodiment is the same as the first small sentence selected and input by the user on the terminal device 4 when there is a comment or complaint associated with the judgment sentence. It is possible to extract small sentences such as comments and complaints that have the following items. In addition, as shown in FIG. 12, since the second small sentence of the comment corresponding to the first small sentence of the judgment sentence can be displayed side by side, the user can read the judgment sentence with reference to the comment.

  In the example of FIG. 12, only the second small text corresponding to the first small text selected and input by the user is displayed in the search result display area 502, but a plurality of second small texts or comments are displayed in the full text search result display area. It may be displayed in 502. In this case, when the user scrolls the judgment sentence, the comment displayed in the search result display area 502 may be scrolled in the same manner. For this purpose, it is necessary to embed information that serves as a mark of the position of a sentence such as a hash tag in a judgment sentence and a comment.

  Furthermore, when this embodiment is implemented on a small screen such as a smartphone, the display area is narrow, so the second small sentence of the corresponding comment is popped up only when the user presses and holds the first small sentence of the judgment sentence. Display or float display is recommended.

(Example 3)
A feature of the judgment sentence management system 1 will be described as a third embodiment. In the present embodiment, Example 3 can be combined with other examples. However, the description of the detailed combination is omitted.

(Function of terminal device 4)
FIG. 14 is a diagram illustrating an example of each display screen displayed by the terminal display unit 414 of the terminal device 4.

  FIG. 14 is a diagram illustrating an example of a sentence creation screen 600 displayed on the terminal device 4. The sentence creation screen 600 is a screen that is displayed when the user accesses a website using the terminal device 4 to create another sentence from a judgment sentence or a comment. In the present embodiment, a configuration in which a complaint is created by extracting a third minor sentence of a related complaint from a second minor sentence of an arbitrary comment is illustrated. In the present embodiment, any sentence other than the comment may be used as long as the information necessary for preparing the complaint can be obtained. For example, a complaint can be made from a judgment sentence. In addition to the complaint, a sentence such as a comment may be used for the prepared sentence. Furthermore, the related complaint may not be an actual complaint but may be a template. In this case, a third small sentence can be created by inserting a third type corresponding to the second type into the template. The sentence creation screen 600 is moved by a comment display area 601 which is an area for displaying an arbitrary comment, a small sentence display area 602 which is an area for displaying a list of selected small sentences, and a user's mouse operation. A mouse pointer 603 and the like are displayed.

  In the comment display area 601, a second small sentence in which a comment is presented is displayed. Specifically, each item is displayed so as to be identifiable to the user. In the example of FIG. 14, the comment is displayed as a plurality of second small sentences divided into a small sentence 1 604, a small sentence 2 605, a small sentence 3 606, and a small sentence 4 607.

  The mouse pointer 603 allows the user to select an arbitrary second small sentence displayed in the comment display area 601 by operating the mouse. Here, selection includes an operation of selecting an arbitrary second small sentence by a click operation of the mouse, and an operation of dragging and dropping the selected second small sentence to the small sentence display area 602.

  The small text display area 602 displays a plurality of second small texts selected by the user. The user may select a plurality of second small sentences from one comment and drop them in the small sentence display area 602, or select a plurality of second small sentences from a plurality of different comments and display the small sentence display area 602. You may drop it. The small text display area 602 is provided with a plurality of input frames so that a plurality of second small texts can be dropped. In FIG. 14, a small text selection field 1 608, a small text selection field 2 609, and a small text selection field 3 610 are provided. Here, the second small text is selected in the small text selection field 1 608 and the small text selection field 2 609, and the second small text is not yet selected in the small text selection field 3 610. . When a comment is selected in the comment display area 601, the second small text that can be selected in the next selected small text selection field 3 610 may be highlighted in the comment display area 601. Moreover, the small text selection column may be selected in any order. In the example of FIG. 14, the mouse pointer selects the small sentence 3 606, and the user drags the selected small sentence 3 606 to the small sentence selection field 3 610 and drops it, thereby the small sentence 3 606. Is selected in the small text selection field 3 610.

  Further, in the small text display area 602, a type correction button 611 and a sentence creation button 612 are provided. The type correction button 611 is a button for changing the second type of the small text 2 selected in the small text selection field 1 608, the small text selection field 2 609, and the small text selection field 3 610. The user transitions to a screen for changing the second type of the second small sentence by clicking this button.

  FIG. 15 shows an example of the sentence creation screen 600 after the screen transition when the user clicks the type correction button 611. As a difference from FIG. 14, each of the small sentence selection column 1 608, the small sentence selection column 2 609, and the small sentence selection column 3 610 on which the selected second small sentence is displayed is displayed on the sentence creation screen 600. As input fields for correcting the type, a small text correction field 1 613, a small text correction field 2 614, and a small text correction field 3 615 are displayed. A text input box for inputting correction information is displayed in the small text correction field 1 613 and the small text correction field 2 614, and the user inputs desired correction content here. Note that the input mode of the correction information may be selection from a pull-down or selection from a check box other than text input. In the small text correction column 1613 where the second small text is not selected, “unselected” is displayed so that correction information cannot be input. The type correction button 611 is also changed to a return button 616. When the second type of correction is completed, the user can return to the screen of FIG. 14 by clicking this return button 616. When returning to the screen of FIG. 14, the user can select the second small sentence again or change the selected second small sentence. In the screen after returning, the second small sentence after the second type is corrected may be displayed in the small sentence display area 602.

  Returning to FIG. 14, the sentence creation button 612 creates a complaint based on the third small sentence of the complaint associated with the small sentence selection field 1 608, the small sentence selection field 2 609, and the small sentence selection field 3 610. It is a button to do. This complaint creation process is performed by a server processing unit 316 described later.

(Create a complaint from the decision)
FIG. 16 is a diagram illustrating an example of an operation sequence related to creation of a complaint by the judgment sentence management system 1 according to the third embodiment.

  The operation sequence described below is executed mainly by the server processing unit 316 in cooperation with each element of the server 3 based on a program stored in the server storage unit 315 in advance. The operation sequence described below cooperates with each element of the terminal device 4 mainly by the terminal processing unit 415 of the terminal device 4 based on a program stored in the terminal storage unit 414 of the terminal device 4 in advance. And executed. In the operation sequence described below, the server 3 transmits and receives various types of information to and from the terminal device 4 via the server communication unit 314.

  First, the server 3 receives a selection input of a comment to be displayed from the terminal device 4 of the user, extracts a comment corresponding to the comment identification information selected and input from the comment database 311, and transmits the comment to the terminal device 4 ( S1601).

  Next, the server processing unit 316 receives a selection input of an arbitrary second small sentence among the displayed chapter comments (S1602). Here, the selection input is a drag-and-drop operation of the second small sentence from the comment display area 601 to the small sentence display area 602 as described above. Here, the selection input of the second small sentence is assumed one by one, but a plurality of selection inputs may be made simultaneously.

  Then, the server processing unit 316 determines whether or not the second small text has been selected and input to the small text selection field 1 608, the small text selection field 2 609, and the small text selection field 3 610 (S1603). Here, it is determined whether or not the second small text has been selected and input in all the small text selection fields, but it is determined whether or not the second small text has been selected and input more than a predetermined number in the small text selection field. May be. If it is determined that the second small text has not been selected and input in all the small text selection fields (NO in S1603), the process returns to S1601, and further a process of selecting a comment is performed. It should be noted that the sentence creation button 612 is not clickable (for example, grayscale display) until the second small sentence is selected and input in all the small sentence selection fields, and a screen configuration that prompts selection of the second small sentence is displayed. May be.

  On the other hand, when it is determined that the second small text is selected and input in all the small text selection fields (YES in S1603), the server processing unit 316 selects the second type of the plurality of second small texts that are selected and input. It is determined whether the user makes corrections (S1604). Note that the second type of correction input may be accepted at a stage where no second small text is selected and input in all the small text selection fields in S1603. If the user does not desire the second type of correction (S1604 is NO), the process proceeds to S1606. Here, the server processing unit 316 may be configured to accept corrections for all the selected second small sentences. When the user does not desire correction, the correction completion process may be performed as it is without correcting the second type.

  On the other hand, when the user desires the second type of correction (YES in S1604), the server processing unit 316 receives the second type of correction of the second small sentence from the user (S1605). This type of amendment includes revisions to the underlying figures of the complaint and selection of the underlying law.

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 determines whether or not the sentence creation button 612 is clicked (S1606). That is, the user selects and inputs the second small sentence in all the small sentence selection fields, and clicks the sentence creation button 612 in a state where the correction necessary for the second type is input. If the click on the sentence creation button 612 cannot be confirmed, the process returns to S1604. Note that the processing is not limited to S1604, and S1606 may be repeated.

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 creates a complaint (S1607). The complaint creation flow will be described with reference to FIG. The operation sequence described below is executed mainly by the server processing unit 316 in cooperation with each element of the server 3 based on a program stored in the server storage unit 315 in advance.

  First, the server processing unit 316 extracts the second item of the second small sentence selected and input (S1701).

  Subsequently, the server processing unit 316 extracts the comment identification information associated with the extracted second item, extracts the complaint identification information associated with the comment identification information, and corresponds to the complaint identification information. A third small sentence having the same third item as the second item extracted from the plurality of attached third small sentences is extracted (S1702).

  Then, the server processing unit 316 determines whether or not the third small sentences associated with all the selected and inputted second small sentences have been extracted (S1703). Here, when the third small sentences associated with all the selected and inputted second small sentences have not been extracted (NO in S1703), the process returns to S1701.

  On the other hand, when the third small sentences associated with all the selected and inputted second small sentences have been extracted (YES in S1703), the server processing unit 316 combines the extracted third small sentences and complains. Is created (S1704). The created complaint is referred to as a third sentence in the present invention.

  The processing by the server processing unit 316 is an example. For example, as in the first embodiment, the third item having the same third item and third type as the second item and second type is extracted from the complaint database 313. You can also. In this case, it is not necessary to associate a comment and a complaint, and the storage capacity of the database can be reduced.

  Returning to FIG. 16, the server processing unit 316 generates a screen configuration for displaying the created complaint and transmits the screen configuration to the terminal device 4 (S <b> 1608).

  As described above, the judgment sentence management system 1 according to the third embodiment extracts the third small sentence corresponding to the second small sentence selected and input by the user using the terminal device 4, and the extracted third small sentence. Complaints can be created easily by combining. In addition, when the user corrects the second type of the second small sentence, even if there is no chapter 2 sentence including the second type desired by the user, the third small sentence including the appropriate third type Can be created, and a complaint containing this third sub-text can be created.

(Modification 1)
In the judgment sentence management system 1 according to the present embodiment, for example, the server 3 has received a comment or complaint corresponding to the judgment sentence from the computer 2, but the server 3 may determine the correspondence between the sentences. . More specifically, since the server 3 categorizes the chaptered sentences into items and types and stores these items and types in association with each small sentence, the sentences (several small sentences) are stored. ) May be stored in the server storage unit 315 as related sentences, which are composed of similar or identical items and types. According to this structure, the judgment sentence and the comment which exist individually can be easily matched and memorize | stored by the judgment sentence management system 1. FIG.

(Modification 2)
In the present embodiment, the items and types of small text are configured to be used for processing in the server 3, but even if these items and types are displayed on the terminal display unit 414 of the user terminal device 4. Good. According to this configuration, the user can grasp what item each small sentence belongs to and what kind of item it does not have to decode the entire small sentence.

(Modification 3)
In the present embodiment, the server processing unit 316 performs chapter preparation processing in S503, and performs item classification of the first small sentence for each of the plurality of first items in S504. Further, the server processing unit 316 performs chapter preparation processing in S703, and performs item classification of the second small sentence for each of a plurality of second items in S704. The server processing unit 316 performed the chaptering process in S803, and classified the third small sentence into a plurality of third items in S804. However, the present invention is not limited to this configuration.

  For example, morphological analysis is performed on text included in various sentences, converted into a token string, and labeling (item classification of the present application) is first performed on the token string by a machine learning base method. Here, for the feature, the surface layer of the token, the coordinates of the part of speech in the document, or the like may be used, or other methods may be used. The machine learning portion may use a technique called conditional random field (CRF), or may use another technique such as a neural network base technique. At this point, if you match the previously labeled item list with the token string, you can find out which part of the text is the item name. The rule-based approach says for each heading: "This item is a child element of the section starting from the previous item, or whether the previous section ends before this, or how many sections are ended. Can be determined.

  (Modification 4) As described above, the server processing unit 316 can create a table of contents by displaying items as a list on the terminal device 4 of the user. The present invention can also be realized by displaying this table of contents in place of small sentences or displaying both the table of contents and the first small sentences. Here, an example in which the present configuration is applied to the first embodiment will be described, but a similar configuration can be applied to the second and third embodiments. In addition, description may be omitted about the part which overlaps with the above-mentioned Example 1. FIG.

  As shown in FIG. 18, the first small sentence is chaptered, and a table of contents of the first small sentence chaptered is displayed in the judgment sentence display area 401. More specifically, the judgment sentences are collectively displayed in the table of contents 404a of the small sentence 1, the table of contents 405a of the small sentence 2, the table of contents 406a of the small sentence 3, and the table of contents 407a of the small sentence 4. Then, the user can display the first small sentence similar to the small sentence by clicking or mouse over these small sentences with the mouse pointer 403. Specifically, since the mouse pointer 403 selects the table of contents of the small sentence 3, small sentences 408a, 408b, and 408c similar to the small sentence 3 can be displayed in the search result display area 402. With this configuration, the judgment sentence display area 401 can be compactly collected, and therefore the number of small sentences that can be displayed in the judgment sentence display area 401 can be increased. Since the specific processing by the server 3 is substantially the same as the processing shown in FIG. 11, the description thereof is omitted here.

  Further, when the user moves the mouse pointer 403 over the table of contents 406a of the small sentence 3, details of the small sentence 3 are displayed in a pop-up window (not shown), and when the table of contents 406a of the small sentence 3 is clicked. The small sentences 408a, 408b, and 408c similar to the small sentence 3 may be displayed. According to this configuration, it is possible to confirm the details of the small text by displaying the table of contents in a limited screen space and hovering over the table of contents only when the user needs it.

In this modification, the table of contents is displayed in the judgment sentence display area 401, but small sentences can also be displayed in addition to the table of contents. In this case, the user can search for similar small sentences by mouse over or clicking on the table of contents, but it is also possible to search for similar small sentences by mouse over or clicking on small sentences. Can do. Further, when the user scrolls the small text and moves the mouse over, the display form may be changed and displayed so that the table of contents corresponding to the small text on which the mouse pointer 403 is placed can be known. For example, the text of the table of contents can be changed, the font can be changed to bold, or the flash can be displayed.
In this modification, the sentence search screen 400 may be configured to display only the table of contents and the first small sentence as the judgment sentence display area 401 without displaying the search result display area 402. And when selection of the 1st small sentence is received, it is good also as changing to the search result display area 402. FIG. According to this configuration, when there is no desire to search for similar small sentences, the judgment sentence can be referred to together with the table of contents, and the search result display area 402 can be displayed only when similar small sentences are searched. .

  It should be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes, substitutions and modifications can be made thereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention.

DESCRIPTION OF SYMBOLS 1 Judgment management system 2 Computer 3 Server 311 Judgment sentence database 312 Comment database 313 Complaint database 314 Server communication part 315 Server storage part 316 Server processing part 4 Terminal device 411 Terminal communication part 412 Terminal storage part 413 Terminal operation part 414 Terminal display part 415 Terminal processing unit

Claims (37)

A sentence receiving step of receiving the first sentence and the second sentence from the computer;
A chaptering step of chaptering sentences included in the first sentence into a plurality of first small sentences, and chaptering sentences included in the second sentence into second small sentences;
The chaptered first small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined first items, and the chaptered second small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items. Item classification step,
Storing the first sentence, the first small sentence, and the first item in association with each other, storing the second sentence, the second small sentence, and the second item in association with each other; A storage step of storing the first sentence and the second sentence in association with each other;
A method for creating a judgment sentence database characterized by including: Classifying whether the first small sentence belongs to a plurality of first types in the first item, and classifying whether the second small sentence belongs to a plurality of second types in the second item Further including a classification step,
The storing step includes the first item when the first item of the plurality of first small sentences and the first type are similar to or the same as the second item of the plurality of second small sentences and the second type. The sentence and the second sentence are stored in association with each other. The method for creating a judgment sentence database according to claim 1. The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and the first type. In the search method of the judgment sentence database stored in association with
A request receiving step of receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from a user terminal device;
Corresponding to the first item or other first subtext including the first item or the first type similar to or the same as the first item or the first type included in the search request An extraction step for extracting the first sentence from the judgment sentence database;
A transmitting step of transmitting the extracted first sentence corresponding to the other first small sentence or the other first small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A method for searching a judgment sentence database characterized by including: In the request reception step, when the first item and the first type are received as a search request, the extraction step includes the other first small sentence including the first item and the first type, or the other The method according to claim 3, wherein the first sentence associated with the first small sentence is extracted. When the extraction step extracts the other first sentence stored in association with the first small sentence, the other first small sentence is present at any position in the first sentence. A screen generation step for generating a display screen indicating
The method according to claim 3 or 4, wherein in the transmission step, the display screen is transmitted to the terminal device of the user. The receiving step receives a search request by selecting and inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. 6. Search method of judgment sentence database. The method for searching a judgment sentence database according to claim 6, wherein the receiving step receives the first item or the first type included in the first small sentence selected and input as a search request. . In the extraction step, when the plurality of other first small sentences associated with the first item or the first type included in the search request are extracted from the judgment sentence database, the transmission step includes: The method of searching a judgment sentence database according to any one of claims 3 to 7, wherein the plurality of the extracted other first small sentences are transmitted to the terminal device of the user. The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. A method for searching a judgment sentence database stored with
A request receiving step of receiving a search request including the first item from a user terminal device;
An extraction step of extracting the second small sentence including the second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request;
A transmission step of transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A method for searching a judgment sentence database characterized by including: The plurality of first items into which the first small sentences are divided into items and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentences are divided into items have the same items, respectively. How to search the judgment sentence database described in 1. A screen generation step of generating a display screen on which an arbitrary first sentence is displayed on the user terminal device;
The transmitting step transmits the display screen to the user terminal device,
11. The judgment sentence database search according to claim 9, wherein the screen generation step generates a display screen that displays the second small sentence extracted in the extraction step together with the first sentence. Method. Display indicating where the second small sentence exists in the second sentence when the extraction step extracts the second sentence stored in association with the second small sentence A screen generating step for generating a screen;
The method for searching a judgment sentence database according to any one of claims 9 to 11, wherein the transmission step transmits the display screen to the terminal device of the user. The receiving step receives a search request by selecting and inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. 13. Search method of judgment sentence database. The method for searching a judgment sentence database according to claim 13, wherein the receiving step receives the first item included in the first small sentence selected and input as a search request. The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. A sentence creation method for creating a third sentence from a stored judgment sentence database,
A request receiving step of receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items from a user terminal device;
An extraction step of extracting a plurality of the second small sentences including the second item similar or identical to the plurality of the first items included in the search request;
A sentence generation step of generating the third sentence by combining the extracted second small sentences;
A transmission step of transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
The sentence creation method characterized by including. The screen generation step of generating a display screen for prompting selection of the first small sentence until the second small sentence necessary for generating the third sentence is prepared. Sentence creation method. A correction receiving step of receiving a second type of correction in which the second item of the extracted second small sentence is classified;
The sentence creation method according to claim 15 or 16, wherein the sentence generation step generates the third sentence based on the received correction. 16. The plurality of first items into which the first small sentences are classified and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentences are classified have the same items, respectively. The search method of the judgment sentence database as described in any one of -17. The receiving step receives a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence arranged in an arbitrary chapter. 19. Search method of judgment sentence database. The method for searching a judgment sentence database according to claim 19, wherein the receiving step receives the first item included in the first small sentence selected and input as a search request. The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first sub-text is stored in association with the first item and the first type. A sentence included in a second sentence other than the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and a plurality of second items in which the chaptered second small sentences are predetermined. The second sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of second types the second sub-text belongs to the second item, and the second sub-text is classified into the second item and the second Create the third sentence from the judgment sentence database stored in association with the type A statement creation method,
A request receiving step of receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items or the first type from a user terminal device;
An extraction step of extracting the plurality of second small sentences including the second item or the second type similar or identical to the first item or the first type included in the search request; and an extraction step; ,
A sentence generation step of generating the third sentence by combining the extracted second small sentences;
A transmission step of transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
The sentence creation method characterized by including. The screen generation step of generating a display screen for prompting selection of the first small sentence until the second small sentence necessary for generating the third sentence is prepared. Sentence creation method. A correction receiving step of receiving the second type of correction of the extracted second small sentence;
The sentence creation method according to claim 21 or 22, wherein the sentence generation step generates the third sentence based on the received correction. The plurality of first items into which the first small sentences are itemized and the plurality of second items into which the second small sentences are itemized have the same items, respectively.
The plurality of first types into which the first small sentences are classified and the plurality of second types into which the second small sentences are classified have the same type, respectively. The search method of the judgment sentence database as described in any one of -23. In the request reception step, when the first item and the first type are received as a search request, the extraction step includes the second small sentence including the first item and the first type or the second small sentence. 25. The method of searching a judgment sentence database according to any one of claims 21 to 24, wherein the second sentence associated with a sentence is extracted. 26. The reception step receives a search request by selectively inputting a first small sentence of a first sentence in an arbitrary chapter. 26. Search method of judgment sentence database. 27. The method for searching a judgment sentence database according to claim 26, wherein the receiving step receives the first item or the first type included in the first small sentence selected and input as a search request. . Sentence receiving means for receiving a first sentence and a second sentence from a computer;
Chaptering means for chaptering sentences contained in the first sentence into a plurality of first small sentences, and chaptering sentences contained in the second sentence into second small sentences;
The chaptered first small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined first items, and the chaptered second small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items. Item classification means,
Storing the first sentence, the first small sentence, and the first item in association with each other, storing the second sentence, the second small sentence, and the second item in association with each other; Storage means for storing one sentence and the second sentence in association with each other;
An apparatus for creating a judgment sentence database characterized by including: The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and the first type. In the search apparatus for the judgment sentence database stored in association with
Request receiving means for receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from a user terminal device;
Corresponding to the first item or other first subtext including the first item or the first type similar to or the same as the first item or the first type included in the search request Extraction means for extracting the first sentence from the judgment sentence database;
Transmitting means for transmitting the extracted first small sentence or the first sentence associated with the other first small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A judgment sentence database search device characterized by comprising: The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. It is a search device for a judgment sentence database that is attached and stored,
Request receiving means for receiving a search request including the first item from a user terminal device;
Extracting means for extracting the second small sentence including the second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request;
Transmitting means for transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A judgment sentence database search device characterized by comprising: The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. A sentence creation device for creating a third sentence from a stored judgment sentence database,
Request receiving means for receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items from a user terminal device;
Extracting means for extracting a plurality of the second small sentences including the second item similar or identical to the plurality of the first items included in the search request;
Sentence generation means for combining the extracted second small sentences to generate the third sentence;
Transmitting means for transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A sentence creating device characterized by including: The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first sub-text is stored in association with the first item and the first type. A sentence included in a second sentence other than the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and a plurality of second items in which the chaptered second small sentences are predetermined. The second sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of second types the second sub-text belongs to the second item, and the second sub-text is classified into the second item and the second Create the third sentence from the judgment sentence database stored in association with the type A statement creation device,
Request receiving means for receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items or the first type from a user terminal device;
Extracting means for extracting the plurality of second items or the second item containing the second item similar to or identical to the first item or the first type included in the search request; and ,
Sentence generation means for combining the extracted second small sentences to generate the third sentence;
Transmitting means for transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A sentence creating device characterized by including: On the computer,
A sentence receiving function for receiving the first sentence and the second sentence from another computer;
A chaptering function for chaptering sentences included in the first sentence into a plurality of first small sentences, and chaptering sentences included in the second sentence into second small sentences;
The chaptered first small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined first items, and the chaptered second small sentence is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items. Item classification function,
Storing the first sentence, the first small sentence, and the first item in association with each other, storing the second sentence, the second small sentence, and the second item in association with each other; A storage function for storing one sentence and the second sentence in association with each other;
Judgment database creation program characterized by realizing The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first small sentence is classified into the first sentence, the first item, and the first type. In the search program of the judgment sentence database stored in association with
On the computer,
A request receiving function for receiving a search request including the first item or the first type from a user terminal device;
Corresponding to the first item or other first subtext including the first item or the first type similar to or the same as the first item or the first type included in the search request An extraction function for extracting the first sentence from the judgment sentence database;
A transmission function for transmitting the extracted first sentence associated with the other first small sentence or the other first small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
Judgment database search program characterized by realizing The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. In the search program of the judgment sentence database memorized with,
On the computer,
A request receiving function for receiving a search request including the first item from a user terminal device;
An extraction function for extracting the second small sentence including the second item similar or identical to the first item included in the search request;
A transmission function for transmitting the extracted second small sentence or the second sentence associated with the second small sentence to the terminal device of the user;
Judgment database search program characterized by realizing The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first small sentence is stored in association with the first sentence and the first item, and there are a plurality of sentences included in a second sentence other than the first sentence related to the first sentence. The chapter is divided into two sub-sentences, and the second sub-sentence prepared as a chapter is divided into a plurality of predetermined second items, and the first sentence and the second sentence are associated with each other. In the sentence creation program that creates the third sentence from the stored judgment sentence database,
On the computer,
A request receiving function for receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items from a user terminal device;
An extraction function for extracting a plurality of the second small sentences including the second item similar or identical to the plurality of the first items included in the search request;
A sentence generation function for generating the third sentence by combining the plurality of the extracted second small sentences;
A transmission function for transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A sentence creation program characterized by realizing The sentence included in the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of first small sentences, and the chaptered first small sentence is classified into a plurality of predetermined first items, The first sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of first types in the first item, and the first sub-text is stored in association with the first item and the first type. A sentence included in a second sentence other than the first sentence is chaptered into a plurality of second small sentences, and a plurality of second items in which the chaptered second small sentences are predetermined. The second sub-text is classified into which of the plurality of second types the second sub-text belongs to the second item, and the second sub-text is classified into the second item and the second Create the third sentence from the judgment sentence database stored in association with the type In a statement creation program,
A request receiving function for receiving a search request including a plurality of the first items or the first type from a user terminal device;
An extraction function for extracting the plurality of second small sentences including the second item or the second type similar to or the same as the plurality of first items or the first type included in the search request; ,
A sentence generation function for generating the third sentence by combining the plurality of the extracted second small sentences;
A transmission function for transmitting the generated third sentence to the terminal device of the user;
A sentence creation program characterized by realizing

Images