JP2005250583A - Health degree estimation system, reliability information storage device, and health degree estimation method - Google Patents

Abstract

<P>PROBLEM TO BE SOLVED: To estimate health degree with high reliability. <P>SOLUTION: Information from an information source 200 and the like is received by an information input device 2. The information gathered by the information input device is inputted to this health degree estimation system 1. The health degree estimation system 1 is provided with an information reliability determination device 3, a health degree estimation device 4, a basic attribute information database 51, a health degree estimation basic information database 52, and a health degree estimation result database 53. To the information inputted from the information source, information about respective information sources is added. The information reliability determination device 3 determines reliability of the information about the health from the information about the information source. The health degree estimation device 4 estimates a health degree by taking reliability of the information into consideration. <P>COPYRIGHT: (C)2005,JPO&NCIPI

Description

  The present invention relates to a system related to health management such as health maintenance and promotion, and further relates to a system having a reliability determination function of health degree estimation information used in this system.

Conventionally, as a system related to health management, insurance premiums are calculated based on the health level calculated from information about each person's health, such as health history, health diagnosis data, and lifestyle habits as described in Patent Document 1. A health target management system has been proposed that calculates the generation value of each person, such as the discount rate, the total amount of insurance premiums, refunds, and dividends.
JP 2000-276525 A

However, in such a health goal management system,
(1) The practitioner must regularly provide health information at a reliable health promotion facility.
(2) Each data collected must be certified as a public health nurse.
The precondition is that the information is reliable.

For this reason,
(1) The accuracy included in the information itself is not taken into account, and objective information and subjective information are mixed, or the output of a low-precision measurement device and the output of a high-precision measurement device are the same. It will be evaluated.
(2) When an information evaluator is present, the reliability of the information evaluator itself is not taken into account, and the concept of information correction regarding the health estimation method is not reflected.
(3) In order to maintain accuracy, it is indispensable to use a specific facility, and data can be collected only discretely (that is, when a specific facility is visited).
There was a problem such as.

  The present invention has been made to solve the problems of the prior art, and is intended to enable highly reliable health estimation.

  In order to achieve the above object, the present invention provides an information input unit that receives information for estimating a health level, a health level estimation unit that estimates a health level based on the information for estimating the health level, Information reliability determination means for determining reliability of information for estimating the health degree based on information on an information source that provides the information input means with information for estimating the health degree, The health level estimation unit is a health level estimation system having a function of estimating the health level in consideration of the reliability determined by the information reliability level determination unit.

  Here, the information for estimating the health level includes at least one of information on health and information on information sources.

  In this way, it is possible to estimate the health level with high reliability. Further, according to the present invention, it is not necessary to limit the collection of information to only the chance that the information can be trusted in order to estimate the health level, so the chance of collecting the information can be increased according to the level of reliability.

  The health estimation system according to the present invention can be configured by connecting a plurality of computer devices via a communication network, but can also be configured as a single computer device.

  The information source that provides information for estimating the health level to the information input unit evaluates the reliability of the primary information source that provides information for estimating the health level, and the evaluation result is used as the information input unit. The information reliability determination means has a function of determining reliability of information for estimating the health level based on at least information related to the intermediate evaluation means, and the health The degree estimating means preferably has a function of estimating the health degree in consideration of the evaluation result by the intermediate evaluation means and the reliability determined by the information reliability determining means.

  In this way, the health estimation result can be corrected according to the reliability of the intermediate evaluation means.

  The information reliability determination unit has a function of determining the reliability of information for estimating the health level based on at least information regarding an evaluation unit that evaluates the reliability level regarding the information source, and the health level estimation The means preferably has a function of estimating the health degree in consideration of the evaluation result by the evaluation means and the reliability determined by the information reliability determination means.

  It is preferable to include information source information adding means for adding information related to the information source to information for estimating the health level and providing the information to the information input means.

  It is preferable to include primary information source information adding means for adding information related to the primary information source to information for estimating the health level and providing the information to the intermediate evaluation means and the information input means.

  It is preferable to provide a database storing information for estimating the health level.

  It is preferable to provide a database storing results of estimating past health levels.

  The present invention also relates to a reliability information storage device used in a system for estimating health based on information for estimating health, and relates to an information source that outputs information for estimating health. This is a reliability information storage device that stores information and the reliability of information for estimating the health level output from the information source in association with each other.

  In addition, the present invention provides a step of obtaining information on health, a step of obtaining information on an information source for outputting information on health, and a reliability of information output from the information source based on the information on the information source. And a step of estimating the health level by adding the determined reliability to the information on the health.

  In addition, the present invention provides a computer for obtaining information relating to health, obtaining information relating to an information source for outputting information relating to health, and information output from the information source based on the information relating to the information source. And a step of estimating the health level by adding the determined reliability to the information on the health.

In addition, the present invention provides a computer for obtaining information relating to health, obtaining information relating to an information source for outputting information relating to health, and information output from the information source based on the information relating to the information source. A computer-readable recording medium having recorded thereon a program for executing a step of determining a degree of reliability, and a step of estimating the degree of health by adding the determined reliability to the information on health .

  Here, the computer-readable recording medium includes a built-in storage medium such as a hard disk and a semiconductor memory, a portable storage medium such as a CD-ROM, a flexible disk, a DVD disk, a magneto-optical disk, and an IC card, It includes a database holding computer programs, or other computers and their databases.

  According to the present invention, highly reliable health estimation can be realized.

  FIG. 1 is a diagram showing a basic configuration of a health level estimation system 1 according to an embodiment of the present invention. The health level estimation system 1 is based on information on an information input device (information input means) 2 that receives the health level related information of the user 100 and information on the information source 200 included in the input health related information. Information reliability determination device (information reliability determination means) 3 for determining the reliability of the user 100, the health degree estimation for estimating the health degree of the user 100 in consideration of the reliability of the determined information to the input health related information Device (health level estimation means) 4, input health related information, reliability of determined information, estimated health level of user 100, and data necessary for determination of reliability of information and estimation of health level The basic configuration includes a storage device (reliability information storage device) 5 that stores the information, and an output device 6 that outputs the estimated health level and the like.

  The information source 200 for the health-related information of the user 100 is for outputting the health-related information of the user 100 to the health level estimation system 1. Use of facilities 201 such as medical institutions and health institutions that receive disease treatment and various examinations, health examinations, fitness facilities that exercise for health maintenance and promotion, pharmacies that purchase prescription-based medications and health foods, etc. The information source 200 corresponds to the measuring device 202 or the like in which the person himself / herself measures his / her biological information (blood pressure value, blood sugar level, etc.), exercise information (step count, calorie consumption, etc.) and the like. The information source 200 includes a terminal device 211 provided in the facility 201, a data output unit 212 provided in the measurement device 202, and the like as means for outputting the health-related information of the user 100 to the health estimation system 1. It can be set as the structure provided. In addition, when the information source 200 does not include means for outputting the health-related information of the user 100 to the health level estimation system 1, the user 100 himself / herself uses the information transmission device 220 such as a personal computer, a mobile phone, or a facsimile machine. It is also possible to operate and directly output health related information to the health level estimation system 1.

  Here, the information reliability determination device 3 and the health level estimation device 4 specifically have a RAM (Random Access Memory), a data, and a program in which a program is developed, data is temporarily stored, and a work area is formed. A CPU (Central Processing Unit) having a function of performing information processing such as a predetermined calculation according to a program.

  In addition, the storage device 5 includes a basic attribute information database 51 that stores basic attribute information of users and information sources, and a health estimation base that stores information collected for information reliability determination and health estimation. An information database 52 and a health degree estimation result database 53 in which information reliability determination results and health degree estimation results are accumulated are constructed.

(Health-related information)
The health-related information input to the health level estimation system 1 is configured as information related to health for estimating the health level of the user and information related to the information source. As information about health, for example,
・ Results and results of various tests at medical institutions / health institutions ・ Medical records (records of medical examinations, treatments, etc.)
・ Interview results (interviews on lifestyle, subjective symptoms, mental information, past history, etc.)
・ Health behavior information (history of use of fitness facilities, purchase of health foods, etc.)
・ Measurement results of biometric information, etc., by home-use measuring devices ・ Compliance information (visit status, medication status based on prescription, program execution status under the management of experts, etc.)
・ User's own information input (existence of exercise, lifestyle, etc.)
However, it is not limited to these.

  Examples of the information on the information source include, but are not limited to, a person to be measured ID, an installation location ID, an operator ID, a device ID, an information type ID, and an intermediate evaluator ID.

  The to-be-measured person ID is information for indicating a confirmation result by an information source that information on health is measured from a correct to-be-measured person. Means for confirming the correct person to be measured include a personal identification number, an ID card, a radio wave tag, biometric authentication, etc., and an appropriate means corresponding to the information source may be appropriately selected. For example, medical institutions, health institutions, fitness facilities, etc. can use radio wave tags in the facility to identify each time an inspection, exercise, etc., and the measuring device asks for a PIN at the start of measurement. Confirming that the person being measured is correct by identifying the biological information being measured, the physical features such as fingerprints and vein patterns that are in contact during measurement, and the DNA contained in the body fluid. it can.

  The installation location ID is information for indicating where the measurement device as an information source is installed. For example, measuring equipment is roughly classified into fixed type or mobile type. If it is fixed type, the installation location corresponds to a special facility / medical institution / private facility / home, etc. Information such as whether it is classified as professional use (assumed to be used by professional operators in mobile examinations, health examinations, nursing care, etc.) or personal use. Moreover, not only the information indicating the classification of the installation location as described above, but also information indicating the unique name of the installation location may be used.

  The operator ID is information for indicating who is the person who directly operates the measuring device as the information source. For example, it includes information about which category, such as a user himself / herself, a family member, a health institution staff, a medical institution staff, a fitness facility instructor, and a care helper. Further, not only the information indicating the operator classification as described above, but also information indicating the individual operator may be used.

The device ID is information for indicating the characteristics of the measuring device as an information source, and includes, for example, the following sub ID.
・ Manufacturer ID (Manufacturer name)
・ Model ID (product model)
・ Production number ID (Production number)
The information type ID is information for indicating the type of health-related information itself. For example, the information type ID includes information about which category, such as biometric information / diagnosis result / professional result / user's own information input, etc. included. Further, the ID indicating biometric information is set so as to include information indicating more detailed measurement item categories.

The intermediate evaluator ID is evaluated / corrected (preliminary evaluation) by an external intermediate evaluator (intermediate evaluation means or evaluation means) before the health-related information is input from the information source to the health level estimation system 1 In this case, it is information for indicating who the intermediate evaluator is, and is added to the health-related information at the stage of prior assessment of the information on health. Prior evaluation is performed also on information related to information sources included in the health-related information (each ID described above), but may be performed on information related to health in addition to this. The intermediate evaluator ID includes, for example, information indicating which category corresponds to, for example, an external organization that evaluates a medical institution or a certification institution of a fitness instructor. The prior evaluation will be described later as a modified example.

(Information input device)
Such health-related information is transmitted to the health level estimation system 1 from various information sources 200 such as a computer device installed in each facility, a measurement device used by the user 100, a terminal, and the like via a network. In this case, the transmission / reception unit of the health estimation system 1 for the network corresponds to the information input device 2. The transmission and input of health-related information is not limited to the above-described method. For example, the health-related information sent by a document or a storage medium is read by a scanner or a medium reading device (disk drive) as the information input device 2. It may be read and input to the health level estimation system 1, or data may be input using a keyboard or the like. The input health-related information is stored in the basic information database 52 for estimating the health level. Here, the computer device installed in each facility, the measuring device used by the user 100, the terminal, and the like correspond to the information source information adding means or the primary information source information adding means in the modification described later. Thus, the present invention is not limited to the case where it is connected to the health level estimation system 1 via a network, and may be configured to be included in the health level estimation system 1.

(Information reliability judgment device)
The information reliability determination apparatus 3 mainly has a reliability determination function and a reliability correction function.

  The reliability determination function is a function for determining the reliability of health-related information based on information on information sources included in the health-related information. The definition of the reliability may be, for example, pre-assigned as a table a reliability coefficient for each ID as information related to the information source in the basic information database 52 for estimating the health level, or an evaluation outside the health level estimation system 1 You may make it use what was defined outside by reading the evaluation result by an organization etc.

  Specifically, the determination of the reliability is a process of adding the reliability of health-related information (defined reliability coefficient, etc.) to the health-related information based on information about the information source, and the determination result is health It is stored in the degree estimation result database 53. As a result, if the health-related information is sourced from a facility that has contracted with a specific health management program, such as a test result or record of a specialized institution such as a medical institution, the reliability is high and the measuring device of a specific manufacturer Measurement results, interview results, and user's own information input can be defined and determined as having low reliability, and the reliability of health related information is taken into account in the estimation of health level described later. User's health level can be estimated.

  The reliability correction function calculates the reliability of defined information based on statistical analysis of the basic information database 52 for health level estimation and the health level estimation result database 53, information from outside the health level estimation system 1, and the like. This is a function to correct or correct. For example, if a medical institution or doctor causes a medical error, the medical institution or doctor may make corrections such as resetting the defined reliability to a lower level, or the specified data may be When it is found that the compliance is low (does not take medicine as instructed, does not go to the hospital, etc.), the user (measured person) is reconfigured to set the reliability level low. Thereby, determination of the reliability of health-related information is performed more objectively.

(Basic attribute information database)
The basic attribute information database 51 constructed in the storage device 5 stores basic information on users, information on work environments, information on living conditions, information on external environments, basic information on information sources, and the like.

  The basic information of the user includes, for example, name, address, date of birth, family composition, basic resident register number, and the like.

  Examples of information related to a user's job environment include a workplace, an insurer number, an insured number, a job title, and a work style.

  Examples of information related to the life status of the user include a non-life insurance number, a life insurance number, an annual income, a family doctor, and a fitness facility member number.

  Information related to the user's external environment includes information on medical institutions used by the user (eg, facility characteristics, treatment results, strengths, levels, etc.), and bias data of residential areas and workplaces (eg, air pollution) Local companies, companies that are enthusiastic about health care, etc.). Among these, for example, information on medical institutions is information on information sources of health related information.

  As described above, the basic attribute information is information that can be determined almost uniquely by the external environment regardless of the health condition of the user, or information on the external environment itself. The basic attribute information includes information obtained by dynamically combining external systems, and information uniquely calculated from information stored in each database in the health level estimation system 1. For example, in the information about medical institutions, the evaluation results by the external evaluation institutions correspond to the information obtained from the external system, and are based on information such as medical records and medical remuneration statements accumulated in the basic information database 52 for estimating the health level. The estimated evaluation result corresponds to information uniquely calculated in the health level estimation system 1.

(Basic information database for health estimation)
The basic information database 52 for health degree estimation constructed in the storage device 5 stores information collected for determining the reliability of information and estimating the health degree. Specifically, the user's health-related information input to the information input device 2 from the information source, the reliability coefficient table assigned to each ID as information related to the information source, definition information regarding each measuring device, health described later This is a health coefficient table or the like to be referred to when the degree is estimated.

(Health level estimation result database)
The health degree estimation result database 53 constructed in the storage device 5 stores information reliability judgment results and health degree estimation results. Specifically, the determination result of the reliability of the health-related information by the information reliability determination device 3, the estimation result of the health of the user by the health estimation device 4 described later, and the like.

(Health level estimation device)
The health level estimation device 4 mainly has a health level estimation function and an estimated health level output function.

  The health level estimation function reads the health related information from the health level estimation basic information database 52 and the reliability level of the information determined by the information reliability level determination device 3 from the health level estimation result database 53, and the basic attribute information database 51 is a function for estimating the health level of the user while inquiring 51 and the basic information database 52 for estimating the health level. The health degree estimation result is stored in the health degree estimation result database 53.

The estimated health level output function is a function for outputting the health level estimation result stored in the health level estimation result database 53 according to the usage method. The estimated health level can be used in, for example, insurance management systems, medical management systems, health guidance systems, and so-called call center systems related to these systems, and output the health level estimation results according to the purpose of use. Output as a form.

  The use form of the health level will be described in detail. In the insurance management system, the health level can be used for health insurance benefits, public or private medical insurance benefits, rate correction, and the like. For example, it is possible to automate the rate calculation, insurance benefits, false report detection function, etc. for various insurance products that use health. Moreover, it can be used not only for insurance products but also for the elimination of false declarations when implementing a prize using health.

  In the medical management system, the health level can be used in the construction and evaluation of a disease management program for a specific risk group, the electronic medical record system that manages various data during treatment, and the like. For example, by improving the accuracy of the health estimation results, it is possible to detect false declarations and overtreatment on the health care provider side, clarify high-risk groups, select priority management targets, and perform preliminary treatment and health promotion programs. As a result, it is possible to more reliably carry out the management such as the execution of medical care and to control medical costs.

  In the health guidance system, the health level can be used in an information processing system related to health promotion and disease prevention. For example, if the user himself / herself takes medication, exercise, meals, measurements, etc. in accordance with the guidance of a doctor or the like for health management, the doctor etc., if reliability is added to the information for health management In addition, it is possible to determine based on the reliability whether or not the medicine is being taken as instructed, and the home health management information can be effectively used in medical treatment. Further, not only for medical treatment, but also for businesses that aim at health management of fitness facilities and the like, management can be performed based on highly reliable information, and management efficiency can be improved.

(Example of processing)
Next, the health level estimation process in the present embodiment of the health level estimation system 1 will be described. Here, as an example, a process for estimating the health level for the past month from the measurement result of the biological information (blood pressure value) by the measuring device at home of the user 100 will be described. FIG. 2 shows a flowchart of this process.

  First, in step (hereinafter referred to as ST) 1 in FIG. 2, the information input device 2 receives the health-related information transmitted from the home measurement device (blood pressure monitor) owned by the user 100 as the information source 200 via the network. It is received and stored in the basic information database 52 for health degree estimation of the storage device 5. FIG. 3 shows a data example of the health related information. Here, the measurement result (measurement data and measurement date and time) is information about the health of the user 100, and the other is information about the information source. In addition, although 2 items of a to-be-measured person ID and apparatus ID are included as information regarding an information source, each other ID is not included as an item. This is because the manufacturer name of the measurement device and the product type of the measurement device can be grasped from the device ID, and the classifications regarding the other IDs can be grasped, so that no data is required for the other IDs. For example, here, the measurement device is an upper arm type sphygmomanometer for home use, and the classifications regarding other IDs are: installation location ID = “mobile / personal use”, operator ID = “user himself”, information type ID = “biological information / blood pressure value” and intermediate evaluator ID = “none” are stored in advance as definition information of each measuring device in the basic information database 52 for health degree estimation.

Next, in ST2, the information reliability determination device 3 determines the reliability of the health related information. FIG. 4 shows a flowchart of the reliability determination process. The information reliability determination apparatus 3 uses the health-related information stored in the health-estimation basic information database 52 in ST11 based on the information on the information sources included in the health-related information in ST12. The reliability definition table for each ID stored in the basic information database 52 is read out. FIG. 5 shows an example of the reliability definition table relating to the measuring device used here. Here, the reliability is 0.0
It is defined between -1.0, and a larger value means higher reliability.

  Then, the information reliability determination device 3 determines the reliability of the health-related information based on the definition contents of the table in ST13, and writes the determination result in the health estimation result database in ST14. FIG. 6 shows an example of the write data of the reliability determination result.

  Next, in ST3, the health level estimation device 4 estimates the health level of the user 100 based on the health related information. FIG. 7 shows a flowchart of the health level estimation process. The health level estimation device 4 uses the health related information stored in the health level estimation basic information database 52 in ST21 as the reliability determination result of the health related information stored in the health level estimation result database 53 in ST22. The health degree definition table stored in the health degree estimation basic information database 52 based on the information on the health of the user 100 included in the health related information in ST23, and the health degree estimation basic information in ST24 The measurement results relating to the blood pressure of the user for the past month stored in the database 52 are read out. FIG. 8 shows an example of a health level definition table relating to blood pressure used here. In the table, SYS indicates the maximum blood pressure, and DIA indicates the minimum blood pressure (unit is mmHg). Here, the health level is defined between 0.0 and 1.0, and the larger the value, the higher the health level.

  Then, in ST25, the health level estimation device 4 estimates the health level of the user 100 from the health related information based on the determination result of the reliability level and the definition contents of the table. FIG. 9 shows the progress of estimating the health level from each data. Here, the health level of each health-related information is estimated by multiplying the defined health level by the reliability coefficient of the information source, and the average value of the health level of the health-related information for the relevant period (the past month) is calculated. The health level for the period.

  In ST26, the estimation result is written in the health degree estimation result database. FIG. 10 shows an example of writing data of the health degree estimation result.

  Here, the health level is estimated using only the measurement result of the blood pressure value. However, as shown in FIG. It is also possible to estimate the health level related to blood pressure. The analysis results such as compliance and transition are used for correction of the reliability definition table stored in the basic information database 52 for health degree estimation by the reliability correction function of the information reliability determination device 3.

  The health degree of the user 100 estimated in consideration of the reliability of the information in this way can be appropriately output in the form of an image, a document, electronic data, etc. by the output device 6 and used in the external system as described above. it can.

  The definition and calculation method of reliability and health are not limited to those described in this processing example, and other definitions and calculation methods may be used. Further, in the health level estimation system 1 according to the present embodiment, a database is constructed in the storage device 5 in order to cope with a plurality of measurement items, time-series analysis, and the like. It is also possible to configure a system for estimating the health level taking into account the reliability of the information without constructing a database by limiting the function so as to estimate the health level of only information.

(Modification)
FIG. 11 is a diagram illustrating a basic configuration of a health level estimation system 11 according to a modification example of the embodiment of the present invention. The same code | symbol is attached | subjected about the same structure as the health estimation system 1 by the above-mentioned embodiment, and the description similar to the above-mentioned embodiment is abbreviate | omitted.

  A feature of the health level estimation system 11 according to the modification is that a reliability level definition table relating to an intermediate evaluator ID as shown in FIG. 12 is stored in the health level estimation basic information database 521. Between the information source 200 of the health-related information of the user 100 and the information input device 2, an intermediate evaluator 300 that intermediately evaluates the reliability related to the information source is interposed. For example, the medical institution that is the information source 200 transmits health-related information including the examination result of the user 100 to the intermediate evaluator 300, and the intermediate evaluator 300 trusts the health-related information regarding the medical institution that is the information source 200. For example, the evaluation result of the degree is added and transmitted to the health degree estimation system 11. Then, the health-related information is added with the reliability evaluation result regarding the information source by the intermediate evaluator 300 and the intermediate evaluator ID, and is sent to the information input device 2. The health level estimation system 11 reads the reliability level definition table related to the intermediate evaluator ID from the health level estimation basic information database 521 when the information reliability level determination device 3 determines the information reliability level, and the reliability coefficient related to the intermediate evaluator is also obtained. It is taken into account.

  FIG. 13 shows an example of a course in which a certain user has received treatment from a medical institution for hypertension found in a health examination at work, and the health level is estimated from health-related information at that time. Here, the health level of each health-related information is estimated by multiplying the evaluation result of the defined health level, the reliability coefficient regarding the information source, the reliability coefficient regarding the intermediate evaluator, and the reliability level regarding the information source by the intermediate evaluator. Yes.

  As described above, according to the health level estimation system 11 according to the modified example, when estimating the health level from the user's health related information, in addition to the reliability regarding the information source defined in advance, the information source by the intermediate evaluator is related. Since the reliability regarding the intermediate evaluation of the reliability and the reliability regarding the intermediate evaluator itself are also taken into consideration, the reliability of the estimation of the health is further improved.

  Here, the configuration in which the reliability relating to the information source is defined in advance in the health estimation system 11 has been described. However, for example, when the reliability relating to the information source is not defined in the health estimation system 11 in advance, an intermediate evaluation is performed. The health degree may be estimated from the health related information of the user using the intermediate evaluation of the reliability regarding the information source by the person, or the information by the intermediate evaluator is added to the health related information input to the health degree estimation system 11. If the reliability of the source is included, only the reliability evaluation result of the information source by the intermediate evaluator is used without estimating the reliability of the information source defined in the health estimation basic information database. You may make it use.

  In addition, when a user who is not registered in advance in the health estimation system 11 uses this system for the first time, the user applies to the intermediate evaluator 300 for registration of system use, and the intermediate evaluator 300 May collect information on the new user including the ID of the person to be measured, and transmit the information to the health estimation system 11 together with the health related information of the user. When information on the user is not defined in the health level estimation system 11, such as when the user has directly transmitted health related information to the health level estimation system 11 without going through the intermediate evaluator 300, The degree estimation system 11 may request the intermediate evaluator to collect information about the user and define information about the user based on the information collection result. In this case, information collection regarding the user may be performed by an intermediate evaluator 300 that intermediately evaluates information sources of health-related information, or may be performed by another intermediate evaluator 301 as shown in FIG. Absent.

It is a figure which shows the basic composition of the health degree estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a flowchart of the whole process in the health estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of data of the health relevant information input into the health estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a flowchart of the reliability determination process of the information in the health estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of the reliability definition table regarding the measuring device in the health estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of the write data of the reliability determination result in the health estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a flowchart of the health level estimation process in the health level estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of the health level definition table regarding the blood pressure in the health level estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the progress which estimated the health level from each data in the health level estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of the write-in data of the health level estimation result in the health level estimation system which concerns on embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the basic composition of the health level estimation system by the modification of embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the example of the reliability definition table regarding the middle evaluator in the health estimation system by the modification of embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows the process which estimated the health level from each data in the health level estimation system by the modification of embodiment of this invention. It is a figure which shows another structure of the health level estimation system by the modification of embodiment of this invention.

Explanation of symbols

DESCRIPTION OF SYMBOLS 1,11 Health degree estimation system 2 Information input device 3 Information reliability determination apparatus 4 Health degree estimation device 5 Storage device 6 Output device 51 Basic attribute information database 52, 521 Basic information database 53 for health degree estimation Health degree estimation result database 100 User 200 Information source 201 Facility 202 Measuring device 211 Terminal device 212 Data output unit 220 Information transmission device

Claims (11)

An information input means for receiving information for estimating the health level;
Based on the information on the information source that provides the information input means with the information for estimating the health degree, the health degree estimating means for estimating the health degree based on the information for estimating the health degree, the health Information reliability determination means for determining the reliability of information for estimating the degree,
With
The health level estimation unit has a function of estimating the health level in consideration of the reliability determined by the information reliability level determination unit. The information source that provides information for estimating the health level to the information input unit evaluates the reliability of the primary information source that provides information for estimating the health level, and the evaluation result is used as the information input unit. Including intermediate assessment means to provide
The information reliability determination means has a function of determining the reliability of information for estimating the health level based on at least information related to the intermediate evaluation means,
The health degree according to claim 1, wherein the health degree estimating means has a function of estimating the health degree in consideration of the evaluation result by the intermediate evaluation means and the reliability determined by the information reliability determining means. Estimation system. The information reliability determination means has a function of determining the reliability of information for estimating the health degree based on at least information relating to the evaluation means for evaluating the reliability related to the information source,
The health level estimation unit according to claim 1, wherein the health level estimation unit has a function of estimating the health level in consideration of an evaluation result by the evaluation unit and a reliability level determined by the information reliability level determination unit. system. The health degree estimation system according to claim 1, further comprising information source information addition means for adding information related to the information source to information for estimating the health degree and providing the information input means. The health degree according to claim 2, further comprising primary information source information adding means for adding information on the primary information source to information for estimating the health degree and providing the information to the intermediate evaluation means and the information input means. Estimation system. 6. The health level estimation system according to claim 1, further comprising a database storing information for estimating the health level. The health level estimation system according to any one of claims 1 to 6, further comprising a database storing results of estimating past health levels. A reliability information storage device used in a system for estimating health based on information for estimating health,
A reliability information storage device that stores information related to an information source that outputs information for estimating a health level and the reliability of information for estimating the health level output from the information source in association with each other. Obtaining information about health,
Obtaining information about an information source that outputs information about health;
Determining the reliability of information output from the information source based on information about the information source;
Estimating the health level by adding the determined reliability to the health information; and
Health degree estimation method including On the computer,
Obtaining information about health,
Obtaining information about an information source that outputs information about health;
Determining the reliability of information output from the information source based on information about the information source;
Estimating the health level by adding the determined reliability to the health information; and
A program for running On the computer,
Obtaining information about health,
Obtaining information about an information source for outputting information about health;
Determining the reliability of information output from the information source based on information about the information source;
Estimating the health level by adding the determined reliability to the health information; and
The computer-readable recording medium which recorded the program for performing this.

Images