CN102323571B - Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter - Google Patents

Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter Download PDF

Info

Publication number
CN102323571B
CN102323571B CN 201110145054 CN201110145054A CN102323571B CN 102323571 B CN102323571 B CN 102323571B CN 201110145054 CN201110145054 CN 201110145054 CN 201110145054 A CN201110145054 A CN 201110145054A CN 102323571 B CN102323571 B CN 102323571B
Authority
CN
China
Prior art keywords
satellite
scaler
coordinate system
aiming point
antenna
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Expired - Fee Related
Application number
CN 201110145054
Other languages
Chinese (zh)
Other versions
CN102323571A (en
Inventor
徐华平
冯亮
李春升
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Beihang University
Original Assignee
Beihang University
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Beihang University filed Critical Beihang University
Priority to CN 201110145054 priority Critical patent/CN102323571B/en
Publication of CN102323571A publication Critical patent/CN102323571A/en
Application granted granted Critical
Publication of CN102323571B publication Critical patent/CN102323571B/en
Expired - Fee Related legal-status Critical Current
Anticipated expiration legal-status Critical

Links

Images

Landscapes

  • Position Fixing By Use Of Radio Waves (AREA)

Abstract

The invention discloses a distribution method of a satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with a comprehensive overall parameter. Based on interferometric sensitivity matrix analysis, a given satellite orbit, an SAR radar system and other parameter information in an overall design are sufficiently utilized, the constraint condition of the full column rank of a sensitivity matrix to the distribution of the calibrator and the distribution rule of the calibrator are given. In the invention, satellite-borne SAR coverage performance analysis and interferometric sensitivity matrix analysis are combined so that the formulation of the distribution rule of the interferometric calibrator can be considered at an overall design stage, and important guidance is provided for the following calibration work; parameters such as satellite orbit elements and the like are utilized, therefore, analysis for the distribution rule of the calibrator in each latitude region within the global range is realized, a decision basis is provided for the realization of global DEM (Dynamic Effect Model) data measurement engineering, and the distribution method has important theoretical significance and engineering practical value.

Description

The spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive population parameter interferes scaler to lay method
Technical field
The present invention relates to a kind of spaceborne double antenna interference synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) ground calibration device and lay method, belong to the signal processing technology field.
Background technology
Space-borne interference synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) is the comparatively active technology of in recent years synthetic-aperture radar development field development, has round-the-clock, round-the-clock feature, is widely used in topographical height measurement.There are spaceborne double antenna SAR and Distributed Spaceborne SAR in more typical spaceborne InSAR system, and the former realizes that difficulty is little because system is relatively simple, and cost is lower, has obtained larger development.
Interferometric parameter is the key concept of interfering height-finding system, comprises satellite altitude, oblique distance, base length, baseline inclination angle and interferometric phase.Interferometric parameter is determining the interference performance of InSAR system, and its precision directly has influence on the earth's surface elevation of final extraction or the precision of deformation, and therefore accurate interferometric parameter calibration is very important and essential.
The at present calibration of interferometric parameter mainly contains two kinds of methods: based on the interferometric parameter calibration of phase correction; Interferometric parameter calibration based on Sensitivity equation.
First method is based on the interferometric parameter calibration of phase correction, utilize Sensitivity equation to set up the relation of the difference of interferometric parameter error and interferometric phase and fixed phase, the method of employing solving equations is obtained the estimated value of interferometric parameter error, utilize this estimated value that the interferometric parameter error is proofreaied and correct, and the interferometric parameter after use proofreading and correct interferes height reconstruction, and then improves and interfere altimetry precision.Second method is utilized Sensitivity equation to set up the interferometric parameter error and is interfered relation between measurement of higher degree error, on this basis, adopt the method for solving equations that the interferometric parameter error is estimated, and then utilize the parameter error estimated value that interferometric parameter is proofreaied and correct.Research majority based on these two kinds of methods is applied to airborne interference SAR system now, that calibrates is regional smaller, geometric relationship is fairly simple, and spaceborne double antenna interference SAR is along earth orbital operation, zone to be calibrated relates to global a plurality of latitude zone, and satellite altitude, mapping swath width and substar place earth radius all can change when satellite worked in different latitude.In order in overall design process, Accurate Analysis to interfere calibration system to be interfered the impact of performance, be convenient in the world each latitude zone population parameter still to be tested is interfered calibration analysis, the Parameter of Overall Design such as satellite orbit parameter, SAR systematic parameter need to be incorporated into and interfere in the calibration process.
Summary of the invention
Purpose of the present invention: overcome the deficiencies in the prior art, provide a kind of spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive Parameter of Overall Design to interfere scaler to lay method, the method makes overall design and interferes calibration closely to connect, can and interfere calibration to carry out l-G simulation test as unified integral body with overall design, SAR imaging processing, interference processing, both improved interference SAR system overall design quality, and given from overall angle again and interfere calibration that important references is provided.
Technical solution of the present invention: a kind of spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive Parameter of Overall Design interferes scaler to lay method, to analyze borne SAR to the coverage condition on ground according to population parameter, the method of recycling sensitivity matrix analysis draws the ground calibration device and lays rule, and obtain the latitude and longitude information of each scaler by coordinates transformation method, can analyze for each latitude zone, the whole world, realize the interference calibration analysis for global range.
Principle of the present invention is: the ultimate principle that the spaceborne double antenna SAR of given first interferes calibration.Figure 1 shows that the principle of interference figure of spaceborne double antenna InSAR, h InSARThe earth's core distance for the terrain object place can obtain following expression according to geometric relationship among the figure:
Figure BDA0000065297450000021
Wherein, f () is the height conversion relation; X is interferometric parameter, comprises satellite altitude H, oblique distance r 1, base length B, baseline inclination angle theta bAnd interferometric phase
Figure BDA0000065297450000022
In the interferometry process, above-mentioned parameter can affect the precision of digital elevation model (DEM) data all with error, usually will utilize ground control point (GCP:Grond Control Point) that these parameters are calibrated, and namely interferes calibration.
Figure 2 shows that the InSAR system interferes the schematic diagram of calibration, establishes the parameter error in the data acquisition
Figure BDA0000065297450000023
Figure BDA0000065297450000024
The interferometric parameter that then obtains is expressed as
X ^ = X + ΔX - - - ( 2 )
For certain impact point in the mapping band, the linearization error model of its height reconstruction error is
Figure BDA0000065297450000026
In the mapping band, lay L scaler, and the elevation of known each scaler is h i, i=1,2 ..., L can obtain the poor of the reconstruction elevation of each scaling point and actual elevation, and matrix equation can be expressed as
Δ=F·ΔX+M (4)
Wherein,
Figure BDA0000065297450000027
Figure BDA0000065297450000028
Be the vertical error of i scaling point, i=1,2 ..., L; M is the linearization error matrix;
Figure BDA0000065297450000029
Be sensitivity matrix, the concrete form of sensitivity matrix is suc as formula shown in (5),
Figure BDA0000065297450000031
The interferometric parameter error can be obtained by the finding the solution of system of linear equations of formula (4), is expressed as: Δ X=F +Δ.Wherein, F +Generalized inverse for sensitivity matrix F.Can realize thus the interference calibration of spaceborne double antenna InSAR system.Fig. 2 has provided concrete realization flow.
In the interferometry of reality, the position of ground calibration device can't accurately be known, all with certain error, and interferometric parameter is also with certain stochastic error, therefore observation data Δ band is made an uproar, when finding the solution overdetermined equation (4), error can pass to by certain weight interferometric parameter X, the degree of propagation of error depends on the conditional number of sensitivity matrix F, and the situation that lays of the conditional number of sensitivity matrix and ground calibration device has much relations, must carry out scaler by certain constraint condition for this reason and lay, just can guarantee the calibration precision of interferometric parameter.Namely meeting under certain geometrical constraint condition, making conditional number C (F) minimum of sensitivity matrix F.C (F) computing method are suc as formula (6),
C(F)=||F|| 2·||F +|| 2 (6)
Wherein || F|| 2With || F +|| 2Difference representing matrix F and F +2 norms.
The present invention introduces population parameter and interferes calibration, can carry out the analysis that scaler lays rule for each latitude area of global range, will based on the wave beam covering analyzing of satellite orbit parameter and unified based on the interference calibration of sensitivity matrix analysis in same set of coordinate system, be the key point that realizes the method.Used coordinate system should reflect the physical process of spaceborne double antenna InSAR work in overall design analysis and the digital emulation, therefore needs comparatively complete coordinate system framework, so that interfere sensitivity matrix also can represent in this coordinate frame.
Fig. 3 has provided the space geometry graph of a relation of spaceborne double antenna interference SAR, has clearly reflected the inner link between ellipsoid earth model, satellite orbit, major-minor SAR antenna and the ground scene, can provide being defined as follows of each coordinate system accordingly:
(1) earth inertial coordinates system E O: true origin is at the earth centre of sphere, and X-axis in the plane, is pointed to the first point of Aries under the line, and Z axis points to the positive arctic along the axis of rotation of the earth, and Y-axis in the plane, meets right-hand rule relation with X, Z axis under the line.
(2) body-fixed coordinate system E G: true origin is at the earth centre of sphere, and in the plane, by first branch of Greenwich meridian, Z axis points to the positive arctic along the axis of rotation of the earth to X-axis under the line, and Y-axis in the plane, meets right-hand rule relation with X, Z axis under the line.
(3) satellite orbit coordinate system E V: true origin is the earth centre of sphere (being positioned at the satellite orbit plane), and X-axis is in the satellite orbit plane, and forward points to pericenter, Z axis is perpendicular to the satellite orbit plane, forward points to the angular-momentum vector direction of satellite, and Y-axis is in the satellite orbit plane, and direction is determined by the right-hand rule.
(4) satellite platform coordinate system E R: true origin is at centroid of satellite, and X-axis is in the satellite orbit plane, and forward points to the design heading of satellite, and Z axis is perpendicular to the satellite orbit plane, and forward points to the angular-momentum vector direction of satellite, and Y-axis is in the satellite orbit plane, and direction is determined by the right-hand rule.
(5) satellite celestial body coordinate system E E: true origin is at centroid of satellite, and X-axis is along satellite celestial body y direction, and forward points to the Live Flying direction of satellite, and Y-axis and Z axis are respectively along two other principal axis of inertia direction of satellite celestial body.
(6) main antenna coordinate system E A: true origin is at the antenna phase center point, and the X-axis forward points to the Live Flying direction of satellite, and Y-axis is along antenna boresight, and forward points to the ground direction of bowl.
(7) satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SS: as shown in Figure 4, true origin is the ground aiming point of main antenna beam center, and XOY plane and earth's spheroid are tangential on the O point, the X-axis positive dirction is pointed to the satellite flight direction, the normal that Z axis is ordered at O along earth's spheroid, forward deviate from the ground direction of bowl, and Y direction is determined by the right-hand rule.
(8) earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SE: as shown in Figure 4, true origin is the ground aiming point of main antenna beam center, and XOY plane and earth's spheroid are tangential on the O point, the X-axis forward points to the due east direction, the Y-axis positive dirction is pointed to direct north, and the normal that Z axis is ordered at O along earth's spheroid, forward deviate from the ground direction of bowl.As we know from the figure, earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SeRotate to an angle around Z axis and can obtain satellite synchronization scene coordinate system Ess.
Performing step of the present invention is as follows:
The first step is found the solution satellite Covering time t 0:
Can set up following system of equations according to geometric relationship shown in Figure 5,
t 0 = τ + a 3 μ ( E - e sin E ) - - - ( 7 )
E = 2 arctan [ tan φ 2 / ( 1 + e 1 - e ) 1 2 ] - - - ( 8 )
δ=arcsin[sin(ω+φ)sini] (9)
λ=Ω+arctan[tan(ω+φ)cosi]-[G 0e(t 0-t p)] (10)
Λ P-λ=arccos[(cosψ-sinδsinΦ P)/cosδcosΦ P] (11)
Wherein τ is the moment of satellite process pericenter, and a represents the major semi-axis of elliptical orbit, and e represents orbital eccentricity, ω is argument of perigee, and i is orbit inclination, and Ω represents the red footpath of ascending node, above six parameter general name satellite orbit six key elements will have overall design to provide.μ represents gravitational field gravitational constant, ω eBe earth spin rotating speed, ω e=7.2921158 * 10 -5Rad/s, G 0Be t pThe sidereal hour angle of moment Greenwich, Λ P, Φ PRepresent respectively geocentric longitude and geocentric latitude that terrain object P is ordered, above-mentioned parameter is known quantity.δ, λ represent respectively t 0Geocentric latitude and the geocentric latitude of moment substar, ψ is substar N SAnd the earth's core angle between the impact point P, E represent inclined to one side pericenter angle, and φ represents true pericenter angle, and these parameters are unknown quantity, can find the solution by above-mentioned system of equations.Formula (7) is for describing the Kepler's equation of satellite position and time relationship, and formula (8) represents the relation at very near heart angle and partially near heart angle, and formula (9-11) is set up according to the spherical trigonometry relation, specifically can be referring to Fig. 5.O represents the earth centre of sphere among the figure, and N represents the earth's axis arctic, and G represents Greenwich meridian and equatorial node, and D represents the perigee, S mBe satellite position, P is t 0The ground aiming point at moment antenna beam center, N SBe substar.
Utilize numerical computation method can find the solution above-mentioned system of equations, obtain satellite Covering time t 0
Substar N SAnd the earth's core angle ψ computing method between the impact point P are as follows:
ψ = arcsin ( a R e sin θ A ) - - - ( 12 )
R wherein eRepresent local earth radius, θ AExpression antenna beam centre visual angle.
Second step calculates the main antenna wave beam at the coverage condition on ground, obtains the longitude and latitude of the ground aiming point of beam center, near-end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line, and calculates mapping swath width, specifically is calculated as:
If the main antenna centre visual angle is θ A, distance is Δ θ to beam angle Ar,
(2.1) the longitude Λ of calculating main antenna beam center aiming point 0With latitude Φ 0
At first utilize following formula Calculation of Satellite pole of orbit radius vector r:
r = a ( 1 - e 2 ) 1 - e cos φ - - - ( 13 )
Can calculate t thus 0Satellite is at earth inertial coordinates system E constantly OIn position (x Os, y Os, z Os), shown in (14):
x os y os z os = A OV · r cos φ r sin φ 0 - - - ( 14 )
A wherein OVBe satellite orbit coordinate system E VTo earth inertial coordinates system E OTransition matrix.
Then set up main antenna coordinate system E AMiddle any point (x a, y a, z a) at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate.Because the Y-axis of antenna coordinate system overlaps with antenna boresight, so the main antenna aiming point is at coordinate system E AIn coordinate be (0, y, 0), aiming point is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate (x Go, y Go, z Go) be:
x go y go z go = A GO A OV A VR A RE A EA 0 y 0 + A GO x os y os z os + A GO A OV A VR A RE x e y e z e - - - ( 15 )
(x wherein e, y e, z e) be that antenna phase center is with respect to satellite celestial body coordinate system E EPosition vector, (x Os, y Os, z Os) for satellite at earth inertial coordinates system E OIn position vector, A GOEarth inertial coordinates system E OTo body-fixed coordinate system E GTransition matrix, A OVSatellite orbit coordinate system E VTo earth inertial coordinates system E OTransition matrix, A VRSatellite platform coordinate system E RTo satellite orbit coordinate system E VTransition matrix, A RESatellite celestial body coordinate system E ETo satellite platform coordinate system E RSatellite platform coordinate system E RTransition matrix, A EATo be θ by the main antenna centre visual angle AThe antenna coordinate of determining is tied to satellite celestial body coordinate system E ETransition matrix.With (x Go, y gO, z Go) substitution ellipsoid model of globe equation:
x go 2 E a 2 + y go 2 E a 2 + z go 2 E b 2 = 1 - - - ( 16 )
E wherein aAnd E bBe respectively major semi-axis and the minor semi-axis of earth's spheroid.Solve an equation and to try to achieve y (get less in two solutions, cast out larger solution), can obtain aiming point at body-fixed coordinate system E simultaneously GIn coordinate (x Go, y Go, z Go), aiming point longitude Λ is then arranged 0For:
tan Λ 0 = y go x go - - - ( 17 )
Aiming point latitude Φ 0For:
sin Φ 0 = z go x go 2 + y go 2 + z go 2 - - - ( 18 )
(2.2) longitude and latitude (Λ of the ground aiming point of calculating main antenna near-end wave beam line N, Φ N), the longitude and latitude (Λ of the ground aiming point of far-end wave beam line F, Φ F);
The longitude of near-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
tan Λ N = y go N x go N - - - ( 19 )
The latitude of near-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
sin Φ N = z go N ( x go N ) 2 + ( y go N ) 2 + ( z go N ) 2 - - - ( 20 )
Wherein
Figure BDA0000065297450000073
That the ground aiming point of main antenna near-end wave beam line is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate vector, the computation process of its computation process and main antenna beam center aiming point is similar, difference is for calculating transition matrix A EAAntenna look angle, use main antenna centre visual angle θ in the step (2.1) A, use the near-end view angle theta herein AN, θ as shown in Figure 6 ANA-Δ θ Ar/ 2.
The longitude of far-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
tan Λ F = y go F x go F - - - ( 21 )
The latitude of far-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
sin Φ F = z go F ( x go F ) 2 + ( y go F ) 2 + ( z go F ) 2 - - - ( 22 )
Wherein That the ground aiming point of main antenna far-end wave beam line is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate vector, the computation process of its computation process and main antenna beam center aiming point is similar, difference is for calculating transition matrix A EAAntenna look angle, use main antenna centre visual angle θ in the step (2.1) A, use the far-end view angle theta herein AF, θ as shown in Figure 6 AFA+ Δ θ Ar/ 2.
(2.3) cross the width W that the constantly calculation of longitude ﹠ latitude mapping of the ground aiming point of corresponding antenna proximal end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line of top is with according to satellite:
W=ψ NF·R e (23)
ψ wherein NFCorresponding the earth's core angle between the ground aiming point for antenna proximal end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line.
Can obtain ψ according to spherical trigonometry relation among Fig. 5 NFComputing formula:
ψ NF=arccos[sin(Φ N)sin(Φ F)+cos(Φ N)cos(Φ F)cos(Λ FN)] (24)
The 3rd step, utilize mapping swath width W that second step tries to achieve and satellite system parameter for InSAR system made sensitivity matrix, described satellite system parameter comprises satellite altitude H, base length B, baseline inclination angle theta bAccording to the constraint condition that scaler is laid, to try to achieve scaler and lay parameter, the described parameter that lays comprises distance d between scaler number L, first scaler and the substar 1And the distance interval delta d between the scaler, it is as follows that scaler lays the calculation of parameter step:
(3.1) set up the sensitivity matrix F of spaceborne double antenna interference SAR:
Wherein
Figure BDA0000065297450000082
The ground elevation f at expression the i scaler place is to the susceptibility of interferometric parameter X, and described interferometric parameter X comprises satellite altitude H, main antenna oblique distance r 1, base length B, baseline inclination angle theta bAnd interferometric phase
Figure BDA0000065297450000083
(illustrate: In follow-up formula, be not used for calculating, only be used for
Figure BDA0000065297450000085
The expression of this symbol.)
∂ f ∂ H = H + R e - r 1 cos θ ( H + R e ) 2 + r 1 2 - 2 ( H + R e ) r 1 cos θ - - - ( 26 )
∂ f ∂ r 1 = 1 R e + h { ( R e + H ) · [ ( Δr 2 - B 2 ) sin θ 2 Br 1 cos ( θ - θ b ) - cos θ ] + r 1 } - - - ( 27 )
∂ f ∂ B = ( H + R e ) · ( B 2 + 2 r 1 · Δr + Δr 2 ) sin θ 2 ( R e + h ) B 2 cos ( θ - θ b ) - - - ( 28 )
∂ f ∂ θ b = ( H + R e ) · r 1 sin θ R e + h - - - ( 29 )
Figure BDA00000652974500000810
Wherein Re is local earth radius, and h is the height that scaler place terrain object arrives the earth ellipsoid face, and θ is main antenna visual angle corresponding to scaler place, and Δ r is that the major-minor antenna is poor to the oblique distance of terrain object.
(3.2) be located at the interior edge of mapping band distance to uniformly-spaced laying L scaler, change the distance d between first scaler and the substar 1And the distance interval delta d between each scaler, adopt numerical analysis method to calculate (L, d 1, Δ d), under the condition that satisfies formula (31), make conditional number C (F) minimum of sensitivity matrix F.
D N &le; d 1 < D N + W / 2 max ( D F + D N - 2 d 1 2 ( L - 1 ) , &Delta;d min ) < &Delta;d &le; D F - d 1 L - 1 - - - ( 31 )
D wherein NExpression mapping band near-end distance, D FExpression mapping band distal end distance, Δ d MinHave at least in the expression (26-30) one can not carry out at the scaling point place that linearization represents minimally apart from the interval.
The 4th goes on foot, and calculates the longitude and latitude of each scaler;
(4.1) according to the 3rd distance d that goes on foot between scaler number L, first scaler and the substar of obtaining 1And the distance interval delta d between the scaler, calculate each scaler at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector;
If the distance of L scaler is respectively d i, i=1 ..., L, i.e. i scaler shown in Fig. 7 and substar N SBetween arc length, then each scaler is at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector be V SS=(0, d i-d 0, 0), i=1 ..., L, wherein d 0Be the ground aiming point of main antenna beam center and the distance between the substar, i.e. P shown in Fig. 7 and N SBetween arc length, computation process is as follows:
d 0=ψ 0·R e (32)
ψ wherein 0Be the earth's core angle between beam center ground aiming point and the substar, can do following calculating according to the spherical trigonometry relation:
ψ 0=arccos[sin(Φ 0)sin(δ)+cos(Φ 0)cosδcos(Λ 0-λ)] (33)
(4.2) with scaler at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector be transformed into earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SEIn,
V SE=A ESV SS (34)
A wherein ESFor by satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSTo earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SETransition matrix.
(4.3) each scaler position coordinates is transformed into body-fixed coordinate system E GIn, and then calculate the longitude and latitude of each scaler, process is as follows,
x gi y gi z gi = A GS x ss , i y ss , i z ss , i , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 35 )
A GSBe corresponding transition matrix, the longitude of i scaler and latitude are respectively suc as formula (36) and (37):
tan &Lambda; GCP , i = y gi x gi , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 36 )
sin &Phi; GCP , i = z gi x gi 2 + y gi 2 + z gi 2 , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 37 )
The present invention's advantage compared with prior art is:
(1) the present invention combines the overall system design parameter with the sensitivity matrix analysis, makes the overall design of spaceborne double antenna interference SAR and interferes calibration to combine and study, can the sophisticated systems performance evaluation, and the optimization system design.
(2) the present invention is based on satellite orbit parameter and SAR systematic parameter to interfering calibration to be analyzed, adopted ellipsoid earth model and perfect coordinate-system, can carry out calibration analysis for each latitude zone, the whole world, and obtain the concrete latitude and longitude information of scaler.
(3) the present invention carries out satellite beams covering and calibration analysis under perfect coordinate system framework, overall design, interfere that processing, interference are calibrated etc. can be carried out comprehensive simulating and verify.
Description of drawings
Fig. 1 is the geometric relationship figure of spaceborne interferometric SAR system;
Fig. 2 is for interfering the theory diagram of calibration;
Fig. 3 is spaceborne double antenna interference SAR space geometry graph of a relation;
Fig. 4 is the graph of a relation of earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system and satellite synchronization scene coordinate system;
Fig. 5 is that satellite covers and the comprehensive schematic diagram of orbital elements;
Fig. 6 is satellite-borne SAR wave beam coverage diagram;
Fig. 7 is that scaler lays schematic diagram;
Fig. 8 is the realization flow figure of the inventive method;
Fig. 9 a-Fig. 9 e is the curve map that each interferometric parameter susceptibility changes with distance;
Figure 10 is d 1Interfere the sensitivity matrix conditional number with the curve map of adjacent scaler interval variation under the fixing situation;
Figure 11 interferes the minimal condition number of sensitivity matrix with d in the certain situation of scaler number 1The curve map that changes;
Figure 12 is the curve map that sensitivity matrix minimal condition number changes with the scaler number.
Symbolic representation is as follows among the figure: S among Fig. 1 m, S sRepresent respectively two SAR antennas on the satellite, S mBe main antenna, S sBe slave antenna, B represents the length of baseline, θ bBe the baseline inclination angle, θ is antenna look angle corresponding to terrain object point, and H is satellite altitude, R eBe local earth radius, r 1, r 2Represent that respectively two antenna phase centers are to the oblique distance of terrain object point, h InSARThe earth's core distance for impact point.V among Fig. 3 sBe satellite velocity vector, camber line T 1T 2T 3Be the ground trace of sub-satellite point, A, B are respectively far-end and the near-end of observation band.N represents the earth's axis arctic among Fig. 5, and G represents Greenwich meridian and equatorial node, S mBe satellite position, P is the ground aiming point at antenna beam center, N SBe substar, Λ P, Φ PRepresent respectively longitude and latitude that P is ordered, δ represents the latitude of sub-satellite point, and E represents inclined to one side pericenter angle, and φ represents true pericenter angle, and Ω represents the red footpath of ascending node, and ω is argument of perigee.Δ θ among Fig. 6 ArRepresent the main antenna distance to beam angle, R nBe mapping band near-end oblique distance, R fBe far-end oblique distance, R MidBe the oblique distance at beam center place, W is mapping swath width, Λ 0, Φ 0Be respectively longitude and the latitude of ground aiming point.D among Fig. 7 iBe i the distance that scaler is corresponding.
Embodiment
The below utilizes concrete spaceborne double antenna InSAR parameter to test to verify that the spaceborne double antenna InSAR of comprehensive population parameter interferes scaler to lay the validity of method.
Table 1 has provided the orbit parameter of satellite, and table 2 has provided main SAR systematic parameter.
Table 1 satellite orbit parameter
Satellite orbit parameter Numerical value
Semi-major axis of orbit a/km 6886.856
Orbital eccentricity e 0.000726
Orbit inclination i/ ° 97.63898
Argument of pericentre ω/° 209.6589
The red footpath Ω of ascending node/° 218.8837
Time of pericenter passage τ/s 0.0
Table 2 SAR systematic parameter
Systematic parameter Numerical value
Signal wavelength lambda/m 0.03
The main antenna view angle theta A 28.4
Beam angle/° 7.3
Base length B/m 200.0
The baseline inclination angle theta b 45.0
As shown in Figure 8, the present invention's step when the spaceborne double antenna InSAR of analysis interferes scaler to lay rule is as follows:
Step (1): zone to be analyzed is equator, and establishing latitude is north latitude 0.25 degree, can be 1347.26 seconds in the hope of the satellite Covering time according to formula (7)-(11).
Step (2.1): according to the satellite Covering time, orbital elements, SAR systematic parameter are tried to achieve the aiming point longitude and latitude of main antenna beam center on ground according to formula (13-18) and are (0.248088 ° ,-64.158359 °);
Step (2.2): distance is to beam angle Δ θ Ar=7.3 °, near-end antenna look angle θ AN=24.75 °, far-end antenna look angle θ AF=32.05 °, calculate the intersection point longitude and latitude on antenna beam near-end and far-end and ground according to formula (19-22), be respectively:
N,Φ N)=(-64.366509°,0.285488°)
F,Φ F)=(-63.933913°,0.207757°)
Step (2.3): with the above results substitution formula (23) and (24), calculating mapping swath width W is 48.9275Km.
Step 3: the susceptibility of at first analyzing spaceborne double antenna interference SAR according to formula (26-30), provide its sensitivity curve, shown in Fig. 9 a-Fig. 9 e, select accordingly main interferometric parameter and carry out calibration analysis, can find out that by the sensitivity curve that Fig. 9 a-Fig. 9 e provides the interference survey is high very little to the satellite altitude susceptibility, main interferometric parameter is main antenna oblique distance, base length, baseline inclination angle and interferometric phase.
To different scaler numbers (here from L=2), utilize formula (25-30) to set up sensitivity matrix, be optimized calculating according to formula (31), try to achieve minimal condition corresponding to each L value and count C L(F), L=2 ..., 30 and corresponding d 1With Δ d value.Figure 10 and Figure 11 have provided respectively the sensitivity matrix conditional number with Δ d and d 1Change curve, can draw accordingly in the situation that the scaler number is certain, scaler distributes overstepping the bounds of propriety loose along mapping band, the sensitivity matrix conditional number is less, namely near the low coverage end, each scaler is evenly distributed in the whole mapping band first scaler as far as possible as far as possible.
Choose C L(F), L=2 ..., the minimum value C in 30 Min(F), its corresponding scaler number is L Opt, L OptCorresponding allocation optimum is d 1, optWith Δ d Opt, the scaler that obtains thus optimum lays and is configured to (L Opt, d 1, opt, Δ d Opt).Figure 12 has provided the change curve of sensitivity matrix minimal condition number with the scaler number, and can draw the scaler number by figure is that 8 o'clock sensitivity matrix conditional numbers are minimum, so L Opt=8.This moment d 1Be 134.474Km, Δ d is 6115.9m.Can get allocation optimum is:
L opt=8
d 1,opt=134.474Km
Δd opt=6115.9m
Step (4.1): the distance that can be calculated main antenna beam center ground aiming point place by population parameter and coordinate system translation operation is 158.0162Km, i.e. d 0=158.0162km, then the position vector of each scaling point in satellite synchronization scene coordinate system is as shown in table 3.
Table 3 scaling point is position vector in satellite synchronization scene coordinate system
The scaling point sequence number Position vector/m
1 (0,-23542.10,0)
2 (0,-16552.47,0)
3 (0,-9562.84,0)
4 (0,-2573.21,0)
5 (0,4416.41,0)
6 (0,11406.04,0)
7 (0,18395.67,0)
8 (0,25385.30,0)
Step (4.2) and (4.3): the angle of Calculation of Satellite velocity and due east direction, and then try to achieve the transition matrix A that arrives earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system in the satellite synchronization scene coordinate system ES, recycling formula (34-37) is calculated the latitude and longitude information of each scaler, and is as shown in table 4.
Table 4 scaler latitude and longitude information
The scaling point sequence number (longitude/°, latitude/°)
1 (-64.366509,0.255488)
2 (-64.304710,0.248669)
3 (-64.242910,0.241851)
4 (-64.181111,0.235032)
5 (-64.119311,0.228213)
6 (-64.057512,0.221394)
7 (-63.995712,0.214576)
8 (-63.933913,0.207757)
In a word, the present invention combines the design of the population parameters such as satellite orbit parameter and radar system parameter with interference calibrating method based on the sensitivity matrix analysis, provided spaceborne double antenna interference SAR scaler and laid method.Carry out the satellite covering analyzing based on population parameter, give and interfere calibration that necessary data message is provided, and then set up spaceborne double antenna interference SAR sensitivity matrix, lay scheme according to interfering the high constraint condition analysis to the sensitivity matrix conditional number of survey to obtain optimum scaler.The present invention combines overall design and interference calibration, and can in overall design, take into full account and interfere calibration to the improvement of system performance, and for interfering the Project Realization of calibrating that reference is provided.By above-mentioned test, can obtain optimum scaler number, lay the interval and specifically lay the position, validity of the present invention has been described.
The non-elaborated part of the present invention belongs to techniques well known.

Claims (3)

1. the spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive population parameter interferes scaler to lay method, it is characterized in that performing step is as follows:
The first step is found the solution satellite and is crossed constantly t of top 0
Second step calculates the main antenna wave beam at the coverage condition on ground, obtains the longitude and latitude of the ground aiming point of beam center, near-end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line, and calculates mapping swath width, specifically is calculated as:
(2.1) the longitude Λ of calculating main antenna beam center aiming point 0With latitude Φ 0
Aiming point longitude Λ 0For:
tan &Lambda; 0 = y go x go - - - ( 17 )
Aiming point latitude Φ 0For:
sin &Phi; 0 = z go x go 2 + y go 2 + z go 2 - - - ( 18 )
(x wherein Go, y Go, z Go) be that aiming point is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate;
(2.2) longitude and latitude (Λ of the ground aiming point of calculating main antenna near-end wave beam line N, Φ N), the longitude and latitude (Λ of the ground aiming point of far-end wave beam line F, Φ F);
The longitude of near-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
tan &Lambda; N = y go N x go N - - - ( 19 )
The latitude of near-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
sin &Phi; N = z go N ( x go N ) 2 + ( y go N ) 2 + ( z go N ) 2 - - - ( 20 )
Wherein
Figure FDA00002490507000015
That the ground aiming point of main antenna near-end wave beam line is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate vector;
The longitude of far-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
tan &Lambda; F = y go F x go F - - - ( 21 )
The latitude of far-end wave beam line ground aiming point is:
sin &Phi; F = z go F ( x go F ) 2 + ( y go F ) 2 + ( z go F ) 2 - - - ( 22 )
Wherein That the ground aiming point of main antenna far-end wave beam line is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate vector;
(2.3) cross the calculation of longitude ﹠ latitude that pushes up constantly corresponding antenna proximal end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line ground aiming point according to satellite and survey and draw the width W of being with,
W=Ψ NF·R e (23)
R wherein eRepresent local earth radius; Ψ NFCorresponding the earth's core angle between the ground aiming point for antenna proximal end wave beam line and far-end wave beam line:
Ψ NF=arccos[sin(Φ N)sin(Φ F)+cos(Φ N)cos(Φ F)cos(Λ FN)] (24)
In the 3rd step, mapping swath width W and the satellite system parameter of utilizing second step to try to achieve are set up sensitivity matrix for spaceborne double antenna SAR, and described satellite system parameter comprises satellite altitude H, base length B, baseline inclination angle theta bAccording to the constraint condition that scaler is laid, to try to achieve scaler and lay parameter, the described parameter that lays comprises distance d between scaler number L, first scaler and the substar 1And the distance interval delta d between the scaler, it is as follows that scaler lays the calculation of parameter step:
(3.1) set up the sensitivity matrix F of spaceborne double antenna SAR,
Figure FDA00002490507000024
Wherein
Figure FDA00002490507000025
The ground elevation f at expression the i scaler place is to the susceptibility of interferometric parameter X, and described interferometric parameter X comprises satellite altitude H, main antenna oblique distance r 1, base length B, baseline inclination angle theta bAnd interferometric phase
Figure FDA00002490507000031
&PartialD; f &PartialD; H = H + R e - r 1 cos &theta; ( H + R e ) 2 + r 1 2 - 2 ( H + R e ) r 1 cos &theta; - - - ( 26 )
&PartialD; f &PartialD; r 1 = 1 R e + h { ( R e + H ) &CenterDot; [ ( &Delta;r 2 - B 2 ) sin &theta; 2 Br 1 cos ( &theta; - &theta; b ) - cos &theta; ] + r 1 } - - - ( 27 )
&PartialD; f &PartialD; B = ( H + R e ) &CenterDot; ( B 2 + 2 r 1 &CenterDot; &Delta;r + &Delta; r 2 ) sin &theta; 2 ( R e + h ) B 2 cos ( &theta; - &theta; b ) - - - ( 28 )
&PartialD; f &PartialD; &theta; b = ( H + R e ) &CenterDot; r 1 sin &theta; R e + h - - - ( 29 )
Figure FDA00002490507000036
Wherein R e + h = ( H + R e ) 2 + r 1 2 - 2 ( H + R e ) r 1 cos &theta; , R eBe local earth radius, h is the height that scaler place terrain object arrives the earth ellipsoid face, and θ is main antenna visual angle corresponding to scaler place, and Δ r is that the major-minor antenna is poor to the oblique distance of terrain object, and B is base length, θ bBe the baseline inclination angle, H is satellite altitude, r 1Be the main antenna oblique distance;
(3.2) be located at the interior edge of mapping band distance to uniformly-spaced laying L scaler, change the distance d between first scaler and the substar 1And the distance interval delta d between each scaler, adopt numerical analysis method to calculate (L, d 1, Δ d), under the condition that satisfies formula (31), make conditional number C (F) minimum of sensitivity matrix F;
D N &le; d 1 < D N + W / 2 max ( D F + D N - 2 d 1 2 ( L - 1 ) , &Delta; d min ) < &Delta;d < D F - d 1 L - 1 - - - ( 31 )
D wherein NExpression mapping band near-end distance, D FExpression mapping band distal end distance, Δ d MinHave at least in expression (26)-(30) one can not carry out at the scaling point place that linearization represents minimally apart from the interval;
The 4th goes on foot, and calculates the longitude and latitude of each scaler;
The longitude of scaler:
tan &Lambda; GCP , i = y gi x gi , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 36 )
The latitude of scaler:
sin &Phi; GCP , i = z gi x gi 2 + y gi 2 + z gi 2 , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 37 )
(x wherein Gi, y Gi, z Gi) be that i scaler is at body-fixed coordinate system E GUnder coordinate vector.
2. the spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive population parameter according to claim 1 interferes scaler to lay method, it is characterized in that: (x in the described step (2.1) Go, y Go, z Go) be calculated as follows:
(1) calculates t 0Satellite is at earth inertial coordinates system E constantly OIn position (x Os, y Os, z Os);
Utilize following formula Calculation of Satellite pole of orbit radius vector r:
r = a ( 1 - e 2 ) 1 - e cos &phi; - - - ( 13 )
Wherein a represents the major semi-axis of elliptical orbit, and e represents orbital eccentricity, and φ represents t 0The true pericenter angle of moment satellite;
Can calculate t thus 0Satellite is at earth inertial coordinates system E constantly OIn position (x Os, y Os, z Os), as the formula (14):
x os y os z os = A OV &CenterDot; r cos &phi; r sin &phi; 0 - - - ( 14 )
A wherein OVBe satellite orbit coordinate system E VTo earth inertial coordinates system E OTransition matrix;
(2) calculate ground aiming point at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate (x Go, y Go, z Go);
Set up main antenna coordinate system E AMiddle any point (x a, y a, z a) at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate because the Y-axis of antenna coordinate system overlaps with antenna boresight, so the main antenna aiming point is at coordinate system E AIn coordinate be (0, y, 0), aiming point is at body-fixed coordinate system E GIn coordinate (x Go, y Go, z Go) be:
x go y go z go = A GO A OV A VR A RE A EA 0 y 0 + A GO x os y os z os + A GO A OV A VR A RE x e y e z e - - - ( 15 )
Wherein ( xE, y e, z e) be that antenna phase center is with respect to satellite celestial body coordinate system E EPosition vector, (x Os, y Os, z Os) be that satellite is at earth inertial coordinates system E OIn position vector, A GOEarth inertial coordinates system E OTo body-fixed coordinate system E GTransition matrix, A OVSatellite orbit coordinate system E VTo earth inertial coordinates system E OTransition matrix, A VRSatellite platform coordinate system E RTo satellite orbit coordinate system E VTransition matrix, A RESatellite celestial body coordinate system E ETo satellite platform coordinate system E RTransition matrix, A EABy main antenna centre visual angle θ AThe antenna coordinate of determining is E ATo satellite celestial body coordinate system E ETransition matrix;
With (x Go, y Go, z Go) substitution ellipsoid model of globe equation:
x go 2 E a 2 + y go 2 E a 2 + z go 2 E b 2 = 1 - - - ( 16 )
E wherein aAnd E bBe respectively major semi-axis and the minor semi-axis of earth's spheroid, solve an equation and to try to achieve y, can obtain aiming point at body-fixed coordinate system E simultaneously GIn coordinate (x Go, y Go, z Go).
3. the spaceborne double antenna SAR of comprehensive population parameter according to claim 1 interferes scaler to lay method, it is characterized in that: (x in described the 4th step Gi, y Gi, z Gi) be calculated as follows:
(1) according to the 3rd distance d that goes on foot between scaler number L, first scaler and the substar of obtaining 1And the distance interval delta d between the scaler, calculate each scaler at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector;
If the distance of L scaler is respectively d i, i=1 ..., L, then each scaler is at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector be V SS=(0, d i-d 0, 0), i=1 ..., L, wherein d 0Be the ground aiming point of main antenna beam center and the distance between the substar, computation process is as follows:
d 0=Ψ 0·R e (32)
R wherein eRepresent local earth radius, Ψ oBe the earth's core angle between beam center ground aiming point and the substar, can do following calculating according to the spherical trigonometry relation:
Ψ 0=arccos[sin(Φ 0)sin(δ)+cos(Φ 0)cosδcos(Λ 0-λ)] (33)
δ wherein, λ represents respectively t 0Geocentric latitude and the geocentric longitude of moment substar;
(2) with scaler at satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSIn position vector be transformed into earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SEIn:
V SE=A ESV SS (34)
A wherein ESFor by satellite synchronization scene coordinate system E SSTo earth synchronization scenarios coordinate system E SETransition matrix;
(3) each scaler position coordinates is transformed into body-fixed coordinate system E GIn, process is as follows:
x gi y gi z gi = A GS x ss , i y ss , i z ss , i , i = 1 , &CenterDot; &CenterDot; &CenterDot; , L - - - ( 35 )
A wherein GSBe corresponding transition matrix.
CN 201110145054 2011-05-31 2011-05-31 Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter Expired - Fee Related CN102323571B (en)

Priority Applications (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN 201110145054 CN102323571B (en) 2011-05-31 2011-05-31 Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
CN 201110145054 CN102323571B (en) 2011-05-31 2011-05-31 Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
CN102323571A CN102323571A (en) 2012-01-18
CN102323571B true CN102323571B (en) 2013-04-17

Family

ID=45451351

Family Applications (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
CN 201110145054 Expired - Fee Related CN102323571B (en) 2011-05-31 2011-05-31 Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter

Country Status (1)

Country Link
CN (1) CN102323571B (en)

Families Citing this family (10)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
CN103135098B (en) * 2013-02-06 2014-03-26 中国科学院电子学研究所 High-accuracy interference specific absorption rate (SAR) system performance analysis method
CN103207388B (en) * 2013-03-26 2014-02-12 中国科学院电子学研究所 Method for calibrating airborne interference synthesis aperture radar (SAR) under squint condition
CN107323689B (en) * 2017-04-20 2019-11-05 中国人民解放军63789部队 The orbit maneuver method that satellite in orbit is reconnoitred over the ground
CN107238824B (en) * 2017-05-24 2019-11-22 西安电子科技大学 Satellite-borne SAR image geometric accurate correction method based on priori dem data
CN107678018B (en) * 2017-09-25 2021-04-27 上海卫星工程研究所 Multi-satellite ultra-close-range following flying space-based radar system
CN108007476B (en) * 2017-11-20 2020-05-01 中国科学院空间应用工程与技术中心 Interference calibration method and system for space-based interference imaging radar altimeter
CN109782280B (en) * 2019-03-06 2020-10-27 中国科学院电子学研究所 Method for measuring distance direction directional diagram of medium and high orbit SAR antenna based on calibration satellite
CN110146858B (en) * 2019-05-24 2021-10-29 北京航空航天大学 High-precision full-link spaceborne SAR radiometric calibration simulation method
CN110823191B (en) * 2019-10-08 2021-12-07 北京空间飞行器总体设计部 Method and system for determining ocean current measurement performance of mixed baseline dual-antenna squint interference SAR
CN112085812B (en) * 2020-08-11 2024-04-02 中国科学院力学研究所 Ultra-large scale satellite constellation networking communication dynamic node determination method

Family Cites Families (3)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6731236B1 (en) * 2003-06-11 2004-05-04 Honeywell International Inc. Methods and apparatus for optimizing interferometric radar altimeter cross track accuracy
EP1959270A1 (en) * 2007-02-15 2008-08-20 Selex Sensors and Airborne Systems Limited Improved synthetic aperture radar technique
CN101881823B (en) * 2010-06-24 2012-10-17 中国人民解放军信息工程大学 InSAR (Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar) block adjustment interferometric parameter calibration and control point densification method

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
CN102323571A (en) 2012-01-18

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
CN102323571B (en) Distribution method of satellite-borne dual-antenna SAR (Synthetic Aperture Radar) interferometric calibrator with comprehensive overall parameter
CN103323026B (en) The attitude reference estimation of deviation of star sensor and useful load and modification method
CN102998690B (en) Attitude angle direct resolving method based on global position system (GPS) carrier wave double-difference equation
CN109613583B (en) Passive target positioning method based on single star and ground station direction finding and combined time difference
Wu et al. Integration of Chang'E-2 imagery and LRO laser altimeter data with a combined block adjustment for precision lunar topographic modeling
CN102654576B (en) Image registration method based on synthetic aperture radar (SAR) image and digital elevation model (DEM) data
CN105548976A (en) Shipborne radar offshore precision identification method
CN105737858B (en) A kind of Airborne Inertial Navigation System attitude parameter calibration method and device
CN104764443B (en) A kind of tight imaging geometry model building method of Optical remote satellite
CN109633724B (en) Passive target positioning method based on single-satellite and multi-ground-station combined measurement
CN105928518A (en) Indoor pedestrian UWB/INS tightly combined navigation system and method adopting pseudo range and position information
CN106871932A (en) The in-orbit sensing calibration method of satellite borne laser based on Pyramidal search terrain match
CN107490364A (en) A kind of wide-angle tilt is imaged aerial camera object positioning method
CN106840212A (en) The in-orbit geometry calibration method of satellite borne laser based on ground laser facula centroid position
CN104655135A (en) Landmark-recognition-based aircraft visual navigation method
CN105444778A (en) Star sensor in-orbit attitude determination error obtaining method based on imaging geometric inversion
Kuang et al. Analysis of orbital configurations for geocenter determination with GPS and low-Earth orbiters
US6594582B1 (en) GPS compound eye attitude and navigation sensor and method
CN103344958B (en) Based on the satellite-borne SAR high-order Doppler parameter evaluation method of almanac data
Andreev et al. Development of methods for navigational referencing of circumlunar spacecrafts to the selenocentric dynamic coordinate system
CN105527639A (en) Satellite positioning method based on smoothness and extrapolation
CN102519454B (en) Selenocentric direction correction method for sun-earth-moon navigation
CN107764268A (en) A kind of method and apparatus of airborne distributed POS Transfer Alignments
CN103245948B (en) Image match navigation method for double-area image formation synthetic aperture radars
CN104391311B (en) Passive location method on star based on GPS broadcast datas

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
C06 Publication
PB01 Publication
C10 Entry into substantive examination
SE01 Entry into force of request for substantive examination
C14 Grant of patent or utility model
GR01 Patent grant
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee
CF01 Termination of patent right due to non-payment of annual fee

Granted publication date: 20130417

Termination date: 20180531