WO2007031796A2

WO2007031796A2 - Control of rodents

Info

Publication number: WO2007031796A2
Application number: PCT/GB2006/050289
Authority: WO
Inventors: Sharon Hughes; Roland Twydell
Original assignee: Sorex Limited
Priority date: 2005-09-15
Filing date: 2006-09-15
Publication date: 2007-03-22
Also published as: EP1954125B1; EP1954125A2; NO20081817L; WO2007031796A3; US20080317801A1; GB0518813D0

Abstract

Control of Rodents A particulate mixture for use in the control of rodents which comprises a mixture of a plurality of bait particles and a plurality of non-bait particles, wherein each bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and a rodenticide and wherein each non-bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and has a flavour different from the flavour of a bait particle and wherein the non-bait particles are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture. A non-bait particulate food for rodents as use in the control of rodents, when presented in admixture with bait particles to rodents, to encourage consumption of the bait particles. Such non-bait particulate food comprises dry extruded pellets of cereal meal and dried powdered crustacean.

Description

CONTROL OF RODENTS

The present invention is concerned with the control of rodents, particularly infestations of rats or mice. It is, further, concerned with non-bait particulate food for rodents for use in mixtures with particulate bait and with such mixtures which may be used in rodent control.

It is in the nature of rats and mice to forage for food, i.e. to roam in search of food which is palatable and/or which offers a desirable 'chew' or 'bite' texture. Although a rat or a mouse may show an initial interest in a palatable bait which has been placed in its run, it may, because of its natural behaviour, lose interest in the bait, after taking only a small amount, in favour of looking for something different.

Some currently-available rodenticides are effective because their lethal dose is achieved by accumulation inside the body of the rodent over a period of time such as where the rodent has taken bait on several occasions. Such rodenticides have been developed to overcome 'bait-shyness', which term is used to describe the avoidance by rodents of food sources which have made them sick.

It is desirable, in methods of rodent control, to encourage a rodent to take a greater amount of bait in a sitting. This has been attempted, for instance, by improving the palatability, to the rodent, of the bait. However, attempts to encourage a greater take of the bait are frustrated by the natural desire of the rodent to forage for, and investigate, alternative and potentially more interesting sources of food.

The technical problem faced by the inventors is to provide a bait- system for rodents wherein the bait retains its initial attraction to the rodents but which system is adapted to provide ongoing interest for the rodents such that their natural desire to forage is satisfied. This technical problem is solved by the present invention.

Accordingly, the present invention provides a particulate mixture for use in the control of rodents which comprises a mixture of a plurality of bait particles and a plurality of non-bait particles, wherein each bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and a rodenticide and wherein each non- bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and has a flavour different from the flavour of a bait particle and wherein the non-bait particles are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture.

The present invention also provides a method of increasing the consumption of bait particles by a rodent which bait particles comprise matter edible by a rodent and a rodenticide comprising mixing the bait particles to be presented to the rodent with non-bait particles which comprise matter edible by a rodent and having a flavour different from the flavour of the bait particles and wherein the non-bait particles are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture.

From their research, the inventors have discovered that, surprisingly, the palatability and efficacy of a bait, provided in the form of a plurality of bait particles, is increased by including, in admixture with the plurality of bait particles, a plurality of non-bait particles which have a flavour different from the flavour provided on the bait particle and which are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture. It has been discovered that this provision of a different flavour and, for instance, different shape or texture, in the bait- containing mixture encourages the natural foraging behaviour of the rodents but acts as an arrestant in that it provides ongoing interest for the feeding rodents such that interest in the bait itself is stimulated with the result that more bait is taken at one sitting by the rodents. We have found that the use of the present invention not only helps to overcome neophobia in rodents (i.e. their wariness or distrust of new food sources, such as when a bait is introduced into their area of activity) but also leads the rodents to consume a lethal dose of bait more quickly.

As used herein, the term "bait" means matter edible by a rodent which includes or contains at least one rodenticide. The term "non-bait", as used herein, means matter edible by a rodent and which does not include or contain any rodenticide. With no compromise of the definitions of "bait" and "non-bait" given above intended, the words "comprises" and "comprising", as used herein, are intended to mean "includes" and "including", respectively, to the extent that the presence of one or more other materials is not excluded.

As described above, the present invention provides, in one aspect, a mixture of a plurality of bait particles and a plurality of non-bait particles. Typically, the non-bait particles are present in the mixture in an amount in the range of from 2.5 to 10% by weight based on the combined weight of the bait particles and non-bait particles. As the amount of non-bait particles in the mixture decreases below 2.5% by weight, the amount of bait particles consumed by a rodent in a sitting tends to fall and eventually approaches the 'take' that would be expected in the case where no non-bait particles are present. The amount of non-bait particles in the mixture should, preferably, therefore, not be lower than 2.5% by weight, based on the combined weight of bait particles and non-bait particles, in order that the non-bait achieves a good arrestant effect. As the amount of non-bait particles in the mixture increases above 10% by weight, the amount of bait particles consumed by a rodent in a sitting tends to fall, presumably because, as the non-bait becomes more plentiful in the mixture, its ability to stimulate interest in the bait starts to fall. We have found that better results are obtained if the amount of the non-bait particles in the mixture is in the range of from 3 to 7% by weight, based on the combined weight of the bait particles and non-bait particles in the mixture. Optimum take by a rodent has been found to occur when the amount of non- bait particles in the mixture is about 5% by weight, based on the combined weight of the bait particles and non-bait particles in the mixture.

The bait particles may be granular, for instance, based on natural grain, for example whole wheat grain, cut wheat grain, oats or canary seed, or may, alternatively, be extruded pellets formed by extruding a paste or meal containing ground or comminuted food, such as cereal, and water and then cutting the extrudate into pellets followed by drying. Such granular or pelleted material is treated with one or more rodenticidally-active agent in accordance with conventional procedures. According to a preferred embodiment, the bait particles are cut wheat grain (typically having a size of approximately 1.5-2mm by 1.5-2mm) which is treated with one or more rodenticidally-active agent. Any rodenticidally-active material may be used in the bait particles of the particulate mixture of the invention. The rodenticidally- active material may be an anticoagulant rodenticide or may be a non- anticoagulant rodenticide. Examples of anticoagulant rodenticides that may be used in the bait particles include one or more of difenacoum, brodifacoum, flocoumafen, bromadiolone, difethialone, warfarin, coumatetralyl, chlorophacinone, diphacinone, coumachlor, coumafuryl and pindone. A preferred anticoagulant rodenticide for use in the present invention is difenacoum. Examples of non-anticoagulant rodenticides that may be used in the bait particles of the particulate mixture according to the invention include vitamin D (ergocalciferol or cholecalciferol) and alphachlorolose. Preferably, the non-anticoagulant rodenticide is ergocalciferol or chlolecalciferol or a mixture thereof. Preferably, the bait particles are selected from whole grain wheat, cut wheat grain and extruded pellets of ground wheat which bait particles are treated with a rodenticide which, preferably, is difenacoum or vitamin D (ergocalciferol or cholecalciferol). Typically, the rodenticide used in the invention will be used in the form of a concentrate which additionally contains a human taste deterrent, e.g. denatonium benzoate. In such a case, it will be apparent that, ignoring any addition of extra flavouring agent to the non-bait particles, there will always be a difference in flavour between bait particles containing a human taste deterrent and the non-bait particles not containing this.

The non-bait particles, as described above, do not contain rodenticidally-active agent. They provide a flavour different from the flavour of the bait particles used in the mixture. In one embodiment, the non-bait particles are prepared by extruding a paste comprising ground cereal, preferably ground wheat, water and flavouring agent, cutting the extruded paste into pellets and subjecting the pellets to drying. Preferably, the cereal paste will also contain dextrose since this not only sweetens the pellet and, therefore, itself provides a flavour component to the pellet but also acts as a binder for the ground cereal such that the pellets retain integrity and resist crumbling. More preferably, the extruded pellets comprise, after drying, approximately 95% ground wheat and approximately 5% dextrose.

The flavouring agent will typically be one that also provides the non- bait particles with an odour, in addition to a flavour, different from that of the bait particles. We have found that good results are obtained using, as the flavouring agent for the non-bait particles, berries, e.g. a wildberry mixture; fruit, e.g. apple, banana, pear; meat, e.g. comminuted meat or a meat extract; faeces or a constituent of faeces, such as skatole; peppermint; vanilla; fish meal; yeast; chocolate and dried powdered crustacean. Preferably, the flavouring agent is chocolate or dried, powdered crustacean or their mixtures. Dried, powdered, crustacean is especially preferred.

The non-bait particles used in the particulate mixture of the invention will contain an amount of flavouring agent which is sufficient to achieve interest from the rodents and to confer, on the non-bait particles in the mixture, an arrestant effect. In general, the non-bait particles will contain from 5 to 4000 ppm of flavouring agent depending on the actual flavouring agent used. We have found that the optimum level of flavouring agent content in the non-bait particles does depend on the actual flavouring agent used since different flavouring agents provide different levels of flavour sensation and olfactory stimulation in rodents. The optimum content levels of some of the flavouring agents that may be used in the non-bait particles are as follows:-

It will be apparent, from the above, that the typical practical range of flavouring agent content of the non-bait particles depends on the actual flavouring agent used. For instance, it is possible to identify a typical practical range of flavouring agent content wherein the lower limit of the content range is the content which is sufficient to achieve a strong interest from the rodents and the upper limit of the content range is the point above which no significant further increase in arrestant effect is achieved. Thus, a typical content of skatole will be in the range of from 5 to 50 ppm, with about 10ppm being preferred. A typical content of wildberries will be in the range of from 10 to 150 ppm, with about 25 ppm being preferred. A typical content of meat extract will be in the range of from 100 to 700 ppm, with about 200 ppm being preferred. A typical content of dried powdered crustacean is in the range of from 150 to 900 ppm, with about 300 ppm being preferred. A typical content of chocolate will be in the range of from 500 to 4000 ppm, with about 2000 ppm being preferred.

As stated above, we have found that not only must the non-bait particles have a flavour different from the bait particles in the mixture but also that the non-bait particles must be distinguishable from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture. This distinction is essential so that the mixture of edible particles provides the rodents with variety to maintain their interest. Our research suggests that the rodents' natural desire to forage can substantially be satisfied if the non-bait particles used in the mixture of the invention have an appeal to all of the senses of taste, touch and sight and, preferably, also the sense of smell. Since rodents appear to investigate potential food by touch, for instance by picking up the food using their front paws, as well as by taste and/or odour, the non-bait particles will preferably be distinguishable from the bait particles by their shape and/or size and/or surface texture. Rodents are known to like a hard multi-edge shape to gnaw at and, thus, hardness, as well as shape and/or size and/or surface texture, should preferably also be taken into account in the non-bait particle design. If the bait particles comprise extruded pellets, and the non-bait particles also comprise extruded pellets, the shape and/or size of the bait particles and the shape and/or size of the non-bait particles should be different such that the rodents can distinguish between the bait particles and the non-bait particles. According to a preferred embodiment of the invention, the non-bait particles will be distinguishable from the bait particles because of their different size. We have found that we have obtained good results using non-bait particles in the form of extruded pellets having roughly a circular cross-section and having a length of from 8 to 12 mm and a diameter of about 4 mm which are distinguishable from bait particles based on whole wheat grain, cut wheat grain, oats, canary seed, or extruded pellets having similar dimensions to such whole or cut grains.

We have found that excellent results are obtained by using, in the control of rodents, a mixture of bait particles, selected from whole wheat grains and cut wheat grains treated with difenacoum, with a plurality of non- bait particles wherein the amount of non-bait particles in the mixture is from 3 to 7% by weight, preferably about 5% by weight, based on the total weight of the bait particles and non-bait particles and wherein the non-bait particles comprise dried, pelletted, extruded ground wheat and from 150 to 900 ppm, preferably about 300 ppm, of dried, powdered crustacean or from 500 to 4000 ppm, preferably about 2000 ppm, of chocolate. Preferably, the flavouring agent will, however, be dried powdered crustacean. Accordingly, this composition and the method of using it form preferred embodiments of the invention.

It has, further, been discovered by the inventors, to their surprise, that rodents, particularly rats, show a preference for non-bait particles flavoured with dried, powdered crustacean compared to non-bait particles flavoured with other flavouring agents. To the knowledge of the inventors, this has not been disclosed in the prior art. According to a further aspect, the present invention also provides a non-bait particulate food for rodents for admixture with bait particles in the control of rodents which non-bait particulate food comprises dry extruded pellets of cereal meal, preferably ground wheat, and dried, powdered crustacean, said non-bait particulate food, when presented in admixture with bait particles to rodents, encourages consumption of the bait particles by the rodents. Especially advantageous results may be achieved when the flavoured non-bait particulate food has at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, external surface texture and internal texture which is different from that of the particulate bait with which it is to be admixed. Preferably, the non-bait particulate food will be distinguishable from the particulate bait with which it is to be admixed by virtue of particle size. The use of such a flavoured non-bait particulate food in admixture with baited wheat grain has been found, in tests carried out on rats, to double the palatability of the bait particles.

DESCRIPTION OF EXPERIMENTS

A series of laboratory pen trials were carried out. In these trials, semi- wild rats (Ratius novegicus) and, separately, semi-wild mice (Mus domesticus) were used in a semi-wild environment.

In each case, the following test diets were provided for consumption by the rodents and, in all cases, a control diet is also provided. The amount of take by the rodents of the test diets and the control diet was monitored and rodent death was also monitored.

In the experiments, the palatability ratio of the diets under test was determined. The palatability ratio is defined as follows:- palatability ratio = total test bait eaten total control diet eaten

We prefer, for effective control in the field to be achieved, that the palatability ratio is at least 0.3 for rats and is at least 0.1 for mice.

EXPERIMENT 1 Test Diet 1

Cut cereal bait treated with difenacoum (Neosorexa Cut Wheat bait, Sorex Limited). Test Diet 2

A mixture of cut cereal bait treated with difenacoum (Neosorexa Cut Wheat bait, Sorex Limited) and non-bait pellets (5% by weight based on total weight of bait pellets and non-bait pellets). The non-bait pellets comprised dried, extruded pellets (length about 1cm, diameter about 4mm) containing about 95% by weight ground wheat, about 5% by weight dextrose and 300 ppm dried, powdered crustacean.

In the feeding experiments, the palatability of the test diets was assessed. This was done by determining the amount of test diet taken by the rodent and also the amount of control diet taken by the rodent. The palatability ratio of the test diet was determined as the amount of test diet taken divided by the amount of control diet taken. The results shown below are the average of ten tests.

Rat

Test Diet No. Palatabihtv Ratio

1 1.42

2 3.61

Mice

Test Diet No. Palatabilitv Ratio

1 0.67 2 1.52

The results obtained demonstrate that the palatability was increased (more than doubled) for both the rats and the mice by including non-bait particles flavoured with dried, powdered crustacean with the bait particles.

After the rodents had finished eating the Test Diet 2, it was found that the content of the non-bait particles in the mixture had been reduced from 5% by weight to less than 1% by weight. This was found for both the rats and the mice in the tests. However, in eating the Test Diet 2, the rodents had consumed double the amount of bait particles compared to Test Diet 1. EXPERIMENT 2

In this experiment, tests were carried out to investigate whether the increase in palatability demonstrated in EXPERIMENT 1 above is merely the result of the use of the flavouring agent. The palatability ratios shown in the results below were averaged from ten tests. Test Diet 1

Cut cereal bait treated with difenacoum (Neosorexa Cut Wheat bait, Sorex Limited) identical to that used in Test Diet 1 in EXPERIMENT 1 except that it additionally contains 300 ppm dried, powdered crustacean. Test Diet 2

This was identical to the Test Diet 2 used in EXPERIMENT 1 above.

The results show that the bait particles containing the dried powdered crustacean flavour are not as palatable to rats and mice as non-flavoured bait particles but used in admixture with non-bait particles flavoured with the dried powdered crustacean. Thus, the conclusion is that the crustacean flavour should be provided on a non-bait particle (used together with bait) rather than simply on the bait in order to increase the palatability of the bait significantly.

EXPERIMENT 3

In this experiment, tests were carried out to investigate whether the increase in palatability demonstrated in the earlier experiments is a result of merely mixing bait particles with non-bait particles (neither the bait particles nor the non-bait particles have added flavour) or the use of a different flavour on the non-bait particles. The palatability ratios shown below were averaged from ten tests. Test Diet 1

A mixture of cut cereal bait treated with difenacoum (Neosorexa Cut Wheat bait, Sorex Limited) with dried extruded pellets (length about 1cm; diameter about 4mm) containing about 95% by weight of ground wheat and about 5% by weight of dextrose with no added flavouring agent. The amount of non-bait pellets in the mixture was 5% by weight based on the total weight of the bait pellets and non-bait pellets. Test Diet 2

This was the same as the Test Diet 2 used in EXPERIMENT 1 above.

The results show that, especially in rats, the crustacean flavour provided on the non-bait particles is essential to increase palatability of the bait particles.

EXPERIMENT 4

This experiment was carried out to study the effect of using a particulate mixture in palatability tests on rats and mice in which the non-bait particles which contain dextrose but no additional flavouring agent have approximately the same size as the bait particles (although they do have a slightly different shape compared to the bait particles). The test diets used in this experiment were as follows:- Test Diet 1

This was identical to Test Diet 1 in EXPERIMENT 1 above. Test Diet 2

A mixture of cut cereal bait treated with difenacoum (Neosorexa cut wheat bait, Sorex Limited) and non-bait pellets which had been ground to approximately the same size as the cut cereal bait (2.5% by weight based on the total weight of the cut wheat bait and the ground non-bait pellets). The non-bait pellets were produced as described in Test Diet 2 of EXPERIMENT 1 except that no dried, powdered crustacean was included. After the pellets had been dried, they were subjected to grinding to reduce the pellet size such that it was approximately the same as that of the cut cereal bait. Test diet 3

A mixture of cut cereal bait and ground non-bait pellets as described above in Test Diet 2 of this experiment except that the mixture contained 5% of the ground non-bait pellets (based on the total weight of cut cereal bait and ground non-bait particles).

In the feeding experiments carried out using rats and mice, the palatability of the test diets was assessed. This was done by determining the amount of test diet taken by the rodent and also the amount of control diet taken by the rodent. The palatability ratio of the test diet was determined as the amount of test diet taken divided by the amount of control diet taken. The palatability ratios shown in the table below were averaged from ten tests. The results were also subjected to statistical analysis.

The results obtained in this experiment indicate that the presence of the ground non-bait particles in the mixture with the cut cereal bait did slightly increase palatability in the 5% addition level for rats and in both the 2.5% and 5% addition levels for mice. Statistical analysis of these results, however, indicates that the incorporation of the ground non-bait pellets did not give rise to significantly increased palatability. EXPERIMENT 5

This experiment was carried out on mice only using canary seed bait particles and using 'mini' non-bait particles. The test diets used in this experiment were as follows:- Test Diet 1

Canary seed treated with calciferol (as rodentically-active agent). Test Diet 2

Canary seed treated with calciferol (as rodentically-active agent) and 300 ppm dried, powdered crustacean. Test Diet 3

A mixture of canary seed treated with calciferol with 'mini' dried and extruded non-bait pellets (5% by weight based on the total weight of the canary seed bait and 'mini' non-bait pellets).

The 'mini' non-bait pellets comprised 95% by weight ground wheat, about 5% by weight dextrose and 300 ppm dried, powdered crustacean. The mean length of the "mini" pellets, taken from a random sample of ten "mini" pellets ranging from 2.4mm to 4.2mm in length, was 3.67mm. The mean diameter of the "mini" pellets, taken from a random sample of ten "mini" pellets ranging from 2.3mm to 2.4mm in diameter, was 2.33 mm.

The palatability ratios were determined in accordance with the procedure described in EXPERIMENT 4. The results shown below are, in each case, the average of ten tests.

Statistical Analysis

Study 1 vs Study 2, P = 0.93

Study 1 vs Study 3, P = 0.14

Study 3 vs Study 2, P = 0.20 The results obtained demonstrate that although palatability was not increased by incorporating the flavouring agent into the canary seed bait particles, palatability was increased using TEST DIET 3, a mixture of bait particles and flavoured non-bait particles.

EXPERIMENT 6

The test diets used in this experiment were:- Test Diet 1

A mixture of bait (Test Diet 1 , as described above) and non-bait pellets. The amount of non-bait pellets in the mixture was 5% by weight (based on the combined weight of the bait and the non-bait pellets). The non-bait pellets comprised dried, extruded pellets (length of about 1cm, diameter of about 4mm) containing about 95% by weight ground wheat, about 5% by weight dextrose and 300 ppm dried, powdered crustacean.

The feeding experiment involved 20 rats. 10 rats were provided access to Test Diet 1 and 10 rats were provided access to Test Diet 2. The daily take of the diets by the rats was measured and the amount of active ingredient ingested per rat was calculated. The number of rats that had ingested a lethal dose (2 x LD50 dose) by each day was also calculated. The results are shown in the following table.

The results are also shown graphically in Figure 1.

As indicated above, both baits resulted in all rats consuming a lethal dose. However, the time taken for the rats to eat a lethal dose (2 x LD50) of the bait was much quicker with Test Diet 2 (containing the flavoured non-bait pellets) than with Test Diet 1 (bait only). The use of particulate mixtures of bait and non-bait pellets according to the invention is expected to lead to quicker control in the field.

Claims

1. A particulate mixture for use in the control of rodents which comprises a mixture of a plurality of bait particles and a plurality of non-bait particles, wherein each bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and a rodenticide and wherein each non-bait particle comprises matter edible by a rodent and has a flavour different from the flavour of a bait particle and wherein the non-bait particles are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture.

2. A particulate mixture according to claim 1 , wherein the non-bait particles are present in the mixture in an amount in the range of from 2.5 to 10% by weight, preferably in the range of from 3 to 7% by weight, based on the combined weight of the bait particles and non-bait particles.

3. A particulate mixture according to claim 2, wherein the amount of non- bait particles in the mixture is about 5% by weight based on the combined weight of bait particles and non-bait particles.

4. A particulate mixture according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the bait particles are cereal based, typically selected from whole wheat grain, cut wheat grain, oats, canary seed and cereal based pellets treated with a rodenticide.

5. A particulate mixture according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the rodenticide is difenacoum or vitamin D.

6. A particulate mixture according to any one of claims 1 to 5, wherein the non-bait particles are extruded pellets comprising ground wheat.

7. A particulate mixture according to claim 6, wherein the extruded pellets have a length of from 8 to 12 mm and a diameter of about 4 mm.

8. A particulate mixture according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein the non-bait particles comprise a flavour component selected from chocolate, dried powdered crustacean, yeast, faeces, fish meal, meat, berries and mixtures of two or more of these.

9. A particulate mixture according to claim 8, wherein the flavour component is selected from chocolate, dried powdered crustacean and mixtures thereof.

10. A particulate mixture according to claim 9, wherein the flavour component comprises dried powdered crustacean.

11. A particulate mixture according to claim 9, wherein the flavour component is present at a concentration in the range of from 150 to 900 ppm based on the weight of the non-bait particles.

12. A particulate mixture according to claim 11 , wherein the flavour component is present at a concentration of about 300 ppm based on the weight of the non-bait particles.

13. A method of increasing the consumption of bait particles by a rodent which bait particles comprise matter edible by a rodent and a rodenticide comprising mixing the bait particles to be presented to the rodent with non-bait particles which comprise matter edible by a rodent and having a flavour different from the flavour of the bait particles and wherein the non-bait particles are distinguished from the bait particles by at least one physical characteristic selected from size, shape, surface texture and internal texture.

14. A non-bait particulate food for rodents for admixture with bait particles in the control of rodents which non-bait particulate food comprises dry extruded pellets of cereal meal and dried powdered crustacean, said non-bait particulate food, when presented in admixture with bait particles to rodents, encourages consumption of bait particles.