SEECIEICATIQN
TITANIUM-INDIFFUSION WAVEGUIDES AND METHODS OF FABRICATION
This application is related to: U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 09/157,652 filed
September 21, 1998 in the name of inventor Lee J. Burrows, entitled "Articles Useful As Optical Waveguides and Method for Manufacturing Same"; U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 09/309,361 filed May 11, 1999, in the name of inventor Lee J. Burrows, entitled "Method for Pressurized Annealing of Lithium Niobate and Resulting Lithium Niobate Structures"; U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 09/419,347 filed on October 15, 1999, in the name of inventor Lee J. Burrows, entitled "Ion Exchange Waveguides and Methods of Fabrication", and U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 09/419,349 filed on October 15, 1999 in the name of inventor Lee J. Burrows, entitled 'Titanium-indiffusion Waveguides", all commonly assigned herewith.
The United States Government has certain rights in this invention pursuant to Grant No. F-19628-95-C-0002 awarded by the United States Air Force.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field Of the Invention
The present invention relates to a method for fabricating titanium indiffusion (Ti- indiffusion) waveguides in optical modulators using a deuterium oxide (D2C*) diffusion process and the resulting waveguides and modulators. More particularly, the present invention relates to a method for fabricating lithium niobate or lithium tantalate modulators by bubbling oxygen (O2) through deuterium oxide to create a wet environment for the Ti- indiffusion process.
2. Background
Optoelectronic components can be fabricated on several types of substrates including polymers, glass, semiconductors (e.g., gallium arsenide (GaAs) and indium phosphide (InP)) and inorganic materials (e.g., lithium niobate (LiNbO3) and lithium tantalate (LiTaO3)). Characteristically, an electro-optic material is one in which the index of refraction changes with the application of an electric field. One of the most important components in optoelectronic systems is the modulator. Three competing technologies in this realm are: direct modulation of a semiconductor laser, semiconductor electro-absorption modulators, and the lithium niobate modulator. Currently, lithium niobate modulators are the modulation devices of choice for many systems because they yield high performance, are a relatively
mature technology and other modulation schemes impose limits not faced with lithium niobate modulators.
Lithium niobate has proven to be a suitable medium for components such as amplitude modulators, phase modulators, optical switches, polarization transformers, tunable filters and wavelength-selective optical add/drop filters. Lithium niobate has also been used as the host for solid state lasers using rare earth ions, e.g., erbium. Most current telecommunication and cable television system applications for LiNbO3 modulators involve discrete components for the optical transmitter subsystem. This configuration couples continuous wave lasers, typically diode-pumped YAG or erbium fiber oscillators, with lithium niobate external modulators and various wavelength and power stabilization components.
Lithium niobate is a popular nonlinear optical crystal for several reasons including its large electro-optic coefficients, the ease with which high quality optical waveguides are fabricated and its amenability to conventional integrated circuit processing techniques. High quality optical waveguides are those that possess low loss and relatively high power handling capabilities. Additionally, LiNbO3 is a hard material, thus it is easily polished for optical fiber coupling which makes its use in optical network systems relatively uncomplicated. It is also a relatively inexpensive crystal, due in part to its long history of use in surface-acoustic-wave (SAW) filters for radio frequencies. By comparison, lithium tantalate LiTaO3 is essentially interchangeable with lithium niobate as far as modulator characteristics are concerned, but the use of LiTaO3 is often cost prohibitive because it is not as widely commercially used as LiNbO3. Additionally, other optical crystalline structures having the formula RMO3, where R is an alkaline earth metal, M is a Group IVB or Group VB metal, and O is oxygen can conceivably be used in the fabrication of waveguides and modulators.
For example, one type of modulator incorporating the use of LiNbO3 is a Mach- Zehnder modulator. In a Mach-Zehnder modulator an incoming optical beam is split equally at a Y junction into two parallel waveguides, which then recombine at another Y junction after some distance. Electrodes are used to apply an electric field in the region of the optical waveguides. The electric field causes a relative phase shift between the two branches. If the phase shift in both arms is the same, then the two optical signals will recombine constructively at the second Y branch and no optical power will be lost. If there is a phase difference between the two arms, then there will be destructive interference and some optical power will be lost. The resulting destructive and constructive interference causes the output optical intensity to vary between a minimum and a maximum value.
In other electro-optic applications optical waveguide directional couplers can also be used as electro-optic modulators. In this type of modulator two waveguides are placed on the
lithium niobate substrate in very close proximity to one another. The wave from one guide can "leak" into the other guide. By applying an electric field to the lithium niobate, the amount of "leakage" can be controlled, thus modulating the transfer of power from one guide to the other. Currently, different commercial application requirements favor either directional couplers or Mach-Zehnder modulators.
The advantage of high-speed, large bandwidth, digital or analog communications has led to a demand for the external modulator configuration. The most common approach utilizes a low-noise, high power diode-pumped laser whose signal is sent to the LiNbO3 modulator via optical fiber. The modulator applies either analog or digital information to the optical carrier.
When using lithium niobate in the fabrication of optical waveguides and optical modulators it is desired to avoid having a niobium-rich, lithium-poor and/or oxygen poor composition. When bulk lithium niobate has such niobium rich-compositions, and is then processed at high temperatures (T > 300 degrees Celsius), growth of the LiNb3Og phase in the crystal may occur. This phase is undesirable because it is not optically transparent and leads to high losses in optical waveguides and optical modulators.
Such niobium-rich compositions can occur in two different manners during fabrication of optical waveguides and optical modulators. First, typical ion exchange procedures result in the replacement of lithium atoms in the crystal lattice with a diffusing ion leading to a lithium niobate composition relatively rich in niobium. Second, standard high temperature (temperatures in excess of 300 degrees Celsius) processing of lithium niobate can cause Li2O out-diffusion, and result in niobium-rich, and lithium and oxygen poor compositions.
Ti-indiffusion waveguides are one of the more commonly used optical waveguides currently in existence. The Ti-indiffusion process drives titanium atoms into the crystal structure lattice causing titanium atoms to either disperse interstitially in the lattice or replace niobium atoms. This process results in one or more refractive indices (e.g., the extraordinary and ordinary refractive indices) of the crystal substrate being altered in the region where the titanium indiffusion occurs to create an optical waveguide.
Ti-indiffusion implements high temperature processing (temperatures in the range of 900 to 1100 degrees Celsius). To eliminate the undesired LiNb3Og phase from forming in the crystal during Ti-indiffusion processing it is usually performed in a wet atmosphere of inert carrier gas, such as nitrogen (N2) or argon (Ar2), or in a wet atmosphere of oxygen (O2). This type of indiffusion process involves bubbling the inert carrier gas or oxygen gas through water (H2O). The wet atmosphere has been considered beneficial in the past because the I^O
breaks down into H+ and OH" ions which chemically attack the LiNb3Og phase, and break it back down into LiNbO3. The present inventors have discovered that a drawback of this type of high temperature processing is that the H2O gives off undesirable protons (H+) which are attracted by the lithium niobate and result in an inadvertent proton-exchanged surface layer occurring. These protons remain in the modulators after fabrication and flow relatively freely among the waveguides, the electrodes, the lithium niobate crystal and the buffer layer interface. It is now understood that these free flowing protons can and do adversely affect a modulator's DC-bias stability because they act as charge carriers and are driven by the applied electric fields, causing the response of the final product to drift over time when a bias is applied.
It would therefore be highly advantageous to devise a fabrication method for Ti- indiffusion waveguides that uses an improved flowing, wet atmosphere Ti-indiffusion process that does not introduce significant numbers of free flowing protons into the waveguide construct that adversely affect the waveguide/modulator's DC-bias stability.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
A method for fabricating titanium-indiffusion waveguides in optical modulators and other optical waveguide devices includes disposing titanium strips in a waveguide pattern on the surface of a crystalline substrate, such as lithium niobate or lithium tantalate, and indiffusing the titanium atoms into the crystalline substrate by creating a flowing, wet deuterium oxide (D2O) environment , raising the temperature in the D2O environment to a temperature within the range of 900 degrees Celsius and 1100 degrees Celsius and maintaining the temperature for a period of time that will allow for the necessary indiffusion of titanium to occur within the crystal substrate. The Ti-indiffusion waveguides that result from performing the Ti-indiffusion process in a flowing, wet D2O environment include crystalline substrates, such as hthium niobate or lithium tantalate, titanium strips disposed in a waveguide pattern on the crystalline substrate and a diffusion region resulting from high temperature processing in a flowing, wet D2O environment.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
FIGS. 1 A - 1G are cross-sectional views of various stages in the fabrication of a Ti-indiffusion waveguide in a lithium niobate optical modulator that incorporates wet, flowing D2O atmosphere Ti-indiffusion in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.
FIGS. 2A - 2C are cross-sectional views of an alternative titanium deposition technique that may be used in the fabrication of a Ti-indiffusion waveguide in a lithium niobate optical modulator that incorporates wet, flowing D2O atmosphere Ti-indiffusion in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 3 is a cross-sectional view of a hardware set-up for Ti-indiffusion that incorporates a bubbling apparatus for creating a flowing, wet D2O atmosphere in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 4 is a process flow diagram for a process of fabricating titanium-indiffused substrates in accordance with a presently preferred embodiment of the present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
Those of ordinary skill in the art will realize that the following description of the present invention is illustrative only and is not intended to be in any way limiting. Other embodiments of the invention will readily suggest themselves to such skilled persons from an examination of the within disclosure.
In accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, a method is provided for fabricating a Ti-indiffusion optical waveguide in lithium niobate (LiNbO3) optical modulators whereby the indiffusion environment is created by bubbling oxygen (O2) through deuterium oxide (D2O) to create a flowing, wet environment that is devoid of free protons. Ti- indiffusion optical waveguide fabrication involves altering one or more refractive indices (e.g., the extraordinary and ordinary refractive indices) of the crystal substrate in the region where the titanium indiffusion occurs to create an optical waveguide. The following exemplary description of the modulator fabrication process is intended to limit the introduction of undesirable free protons into the fabrication process. FIGS. 1 A - 1G are cross sectional views of a lithium niobate modulator shown after completion of selected steps in a wet, D2O environment Ti-indiffusion waveguide fabrication process.
The present invention may also be defined as a method for fabricating a Ti-indiffusion waveguide in a lithium tantalate (LiTaO3) optical modulator. Lithium tantalate is closely related in terms of electro-optical properties to LiNbO3 but is not currently widely used in commercial electro-optical modulator applications because to do so would be cost prohibitive. The same or similar indiffusion process as described below for LiNbO3 would be employed in the Ti-indiffusion waveguides fabricated from a LiTaO3 substrate. Additionally, the crystal substrate that is used to form the optical modulator may be formed from a crystalline structure having the formula RMO3, where R is an alkaline earth metal, M is a Group IVB or Group VB metal, and O is oxygen.
Referring to FIG. 1 A, a modulator build 10 is shown after the formation of titanium (Ti) layer 14 over LiNbO3 crystal substrate 12. Ti layer 14 may be formed over LiNbO3 crystal substrate 12 by an electron beam evaporation process or another suitable deposition technique. The use of electron beam evaporation to deposit titanium over the surface of a crystal, such as LiNbO3 crystal substrate 12, is well known by those of ordinary skill in the art. The thickness of Ti layer 14 may range from about 400 angstroms to about 1000 angstroms, and is preferably in a range of about 500 angstroms to about 600 angstroms for a single mode, Z-cut LiNbO3 crystal having an operating optical wavelength of 1.3 microns.
Shown in FIG. IB is modulator build 10 after photo resist layer 16 is disposed in strip formation on the surface of Ti layer 14. A standard photolithography technique is used to place photo resist layer 16 over Ti layer 14. As shown in FIG. IB, the photolithography process which employs the use of a waveguide template will result in the formation of strips of photo resist only in those areas where waveguides are to be fabricated. The use of such photolithography techniques are well known by those of ordinary skill in the art.
Referring to FIG. 1C, a conventional plasma etch or reactive ion etch (RLE) technique is preferably used to etch away Ti layer 14 and expose LiNbO3 crystal substrate 12 in those regions not masked by photo resist layer 16. A plasma etch or R E procedure is chosen so that it selectively etches away the chosen photo resist material. It should be noted that the etch process should preferably not involve wet etching. Wet etching involves the use of acids and thus would generally be likely to introduce free protons into the waveguide structure that would adversely affect the LiNbO3 (unless non-proton-based acids were used). As previously discussed, free protons in the waveguide tend to increase the likelihood of output voltage drift over time.
After the completion of the etch process, the photo resist material is stripped away by subjecting modulator build 10 to an oxygen plasma or by using an acetone wash procedure. As before, the use of acids for stripping purposes should preferably be avoided as they have
a tendency to introduce free protons into the modulator structure and these free protons increase the likelihood of drift in the modulators. The resulting structure is shown in FIG. ID with Ti layer 14 remaining only in the areas above LiNbO3 crystal substrate 12 where waveguides are to be constructed. FIG. ID is representative of modulator build 10 prior to the construct undergoing the flowing, wet D2O atmosphere Ti-indiffusion process of the present invention.
Shown in FIGS. 2A-2C is an alternate "lift off' method for forming titanium waveguide strips on lithium niobate (and similar) crystal structures in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 2A illustrates modulator build 30 having photoresist layer 34 disposed above LiNbO3 crystal substrate 32. A standard photolithography technique is used to place photo resist layer 34 over LiNbO3 crystal substrate 32. As shown in FIG. 2A the photolithography process which employs the use of a reverse waveguide template will result in the formation of strips of photo resist layer 34 only in those areas where no waveguides will be fabricated. The use of such photolithography techniques is well known by those of ordinary skill in the art.
FIG. 2B shows modulator build 30 after Ti layer 36 has been disposed atop photo resist layer 34 and LiNbO3 (or similar) crystal substrate 32. A standard electron deposition techmque may be employed to deposit titanium on to modulator build 30. The thickness of Ti layer 36 may range from about 400 angstroms to about 1000 angstroms, and is preferably in a range of about 500 angstroms to about 600 angstroms for a single mode, Z-cut LiNbO3 having an optical wavelength of 1.3 microns.
FIG. 2C depicts modulator build 30 after photo resist layer 34 has been "lifted off
LiNbO3 crystal substrate 32. The lift off process can be accomplished by subjecting modulator build 30 to an acetone or propenyl wash operation. The "lift off process removes photo resist layer 34 and that portion of Ti layer 36 that is directly above photo resist layer 34. After the "lift of process Ti layer 36 remains only in those regions where waveguides will be formed. FIG. 2C is representative of modulator build 30 prior to the construct undergoing the flowing, wet D2O atmosphere Ti-indiffusion process of the present invention.
The Ti-indiffusion process begins by placing a modulator build in a container that allows for the formation of a flowing, wet environment. By way of example, the container may be a tube-like structure constructed from a quartz material. FIG. 3 illustrates an example of an acceptable set-up for performing Ti-indiffusion in a flowing, wet environment created by bubbling O2 gas through liquid D2O. Modulator build 100 is placed in a quartz tube 102 having an open end 104 and an open end 106 that allow for the free flow of a wet atmosphere. Quartz tube 102 is placed in conventional commercial oven 108. Oven 108
serves as the indiffusion chamber and the use of such ovens is widely known by those of ordinary skill in the art. Open end 106 of quartz tube 102 is connected to a tube-like structure 110 that allows for the free flow of a wet atmosphere between the bubbling apparatus 112 and the quartz tube 102. The bubbling apparatus 112, illustrated as a glass beaker, confines the solution to be bubbled that will form the wet atmosphere inside quartz tube 102. In accordance with the present invention, bubbling apparatus 112 will hold the preferred wet atmosphere component, deuterium oxide 114 (D20). Liquid deuterium oxide can be obtained in pure concentration from the Alfa Aesar Corporation of Ward Hill, Massachusetts and other vendors. The bubbling apparatus 112 has an outlet 116 connected to tube-like structure 110 and an inlet 118 that allows for the carrier gas, such as oxygen, nitrogen, argon, helium, neon or another gas essentially non-reactive with the titanium and the substrate, to flow into the bubbling apparatus 112. Tube 102 preferably includes an outlet 120 to allow spent carrier gas to be exhausted so that it may be replaced by fresh D2O-charged carrier gas. The use of such bubbling devices is well known by those of ordinary skill in the art and other bubbling device configurations may be used that will result in a flowing, wet D2O environment inside quartz tube 102.
The use of D2O as the component that creates the wet atmosphere is preferred over prior art processes that involve H2O. In prior art Ti-indiffusion optical waveguide fabrication, H2O is preferred because it serves to attack the undesirable LiNB3Og phase and breaks it down into LiNbO3. As previously discussed, growth of the LiNB3O8 phase can occur when LiNbO3 is processed at temperatures exceeding 300 degrees Celsius. The LiNB3Og phase is undesirable because it tends to not be optically transparent and it leads to high losses in optical waveguides. However, processing in a wet atmosphere created from H2O has the high-risk potential for creating a proton exchanged surface layer on the waveguide build. These protons remain in the sample after processing and can adversely affect a modulator's DC-bias stability either through mobility in the crystal substrate surface layer, or along the crystal substrate/buffer layer interface.
The deuterium atom has an additional neutron in the presence of a hydrogen atom, and has a mass approximately twice that of a normal hydrogen atom. Since the deuterium is a heavier atom, it possesses a higher activation energy and, therefore, is less likely to move out of the binding site than would be a lighter proton. Additionally, the deuterium atoms are closer in size to the lithium atoms than protons. Protons which differ in size from the replaced lithium atoms, have a tendency to be more mobile in the crystal lattice. As a result of this mobility, the optical waveguides and the refractive index tend to drift over time, which alters the output intensity of the waveguide. However, when deuterium ions diffuse into the lithium niobate crystal structure and replace lithium atoms they tend to "lock down" in the crystal lattice and provide for more overall stability in the lattice. By implanting deuteron
ions instead of protons during the Ti-indiffusion process, a decrease in the DC-bias stability of about 2 should be realized. This decrease is evident because bias drift is perceived to be dependant on ion diffusion proportional to the square root of the ionic mass. Additionally, D2O provides the same benefit as H2O in that it serves to chemically attack the undesirable LiNB3O8 phase and break it down into LiNbO3. It should be noted that tritium (T or 3H) may also be advantageously used instead of deuterium (D or 2H) and should be considered an equivalent. Due to military restrictions, however, tritium is not presently widely commercially available in significant quantities.
Turning now to FIG. 4, a presently preferred method for fabricating titanium- indiffused substrates in accordance with the present invention is illustrated. Deposition of the titanium on the substrate discussed above occurs at block 124. At block 126 the carrier gas is wet with D2O as discussed above.
The Ti-indiffusion process may commence once the modulator build is properly positioned in the indiffusion chamber, either within a quartz tube structure (as shown in FIG. 3) or directly in the indiffusion chamber. The flowing, wet atmosphere is created within the quartz tube structure or directly in the indiffusion chamber by initiating the flow of the carrier gas through the bubbling apparatus (FIG. 4, reference number 128). The flow rate of the carrier gas may preferably be within the range of about 0.2 SCHF (Standard Cubic Feet per Hour) to about 5.0 SCHF with about 1.2 SCHF presently prefened. Once the flowing carrier gas encounters the bubbling apparatus it creates the occurrence of bubbling within the D2O and allows for creation of the flowing, wet D2O atmosphere that is directed into the quartz tube structure or indiffusion chamber. Since D2O is relatively expensive, its use should be minimized. A few ccs should suffice for laboratory operations; more will be required in a commercial production facility. In one embodiment of the invention the flowing, wet D2O environment is created and sustained throughout the duration of the Ti- indiffusion process. It is also feasible and within the inventive concept herein disclosed to regulate and limit the flowing, wet D2O environment at various prescribed stages of the Ti- indiffusion process. Also note that the D2O may be recycled by passing the exhausted heavy wet oxygen through a refrigerator to freeze out the heavy water (D2O). It can then be reliquified periodically and recycled. Since it is undesirable to introduce any !H atoms, care should be taken to avoid contamination of the D2O during the recycling process.
The Ti-indiffusion proceeds by raising the temperature (FIG. 4, reference number
130) to the appropriate level that affects the necessary degree of Ti-indiffusion desired. In general, the temperature can be raised to a value in the range of about 900 degrees Celsius to about 1100 degrees Celsius. A preferred indiffusion temperature of about 1050 degrees
Celsius will generally allow for the occurrence of the requisite titanium indiffusion. The ramp up rate for elevating the temperature in the oven may be in the range of about 0.5 degrees Celsius per minute to about 20.0 degrees Celsius per minute. A presently preferred ramp up rate is about 10.0 degrees Celsius per minute.
The required duration of the indiffusion process will depend upon the thickness of the crystal substrate and the depth of the desired Ti-indiffusion. The indiffusion period (FIG. 4, reference number 132) is measured from the time at which the desired elevated temperature is reached. In general, the substrate will be held at elevated temperature for a period of time in a range of about 1 hour to about 5 hours with 3 to 4 hours being presently most preferred. The desired elevated temperature and elevated pressure should be maintained throughout this period of time.
The indiffusion process is completed by cooling the modulator build structure back down to approximately room temperature (FIG. 4, reference number 134). The ramp down rate for cooling the Ti-indiffusion environment may be in the range of about 0.5 degrees Celsius per minute to about 40.0 degrees Celsius per minute. A presently preferred ramp down rate is about 10.0 degrees Celsius per minute.
Referring again to the modulator build 10, FIG. IE shows the modulator build 10 after completion of the Η-indiffusion process. Titanium has indiffused into the crystal lattice and created the diffusion region or waveguide region 18. Titanium atoms will disperse interstitially throughout the waveguide region 18 and in some instances, replace or niobium atoms in the crystal structure.
As shown in FIG. IF, once the indiffusion process is completed a buffer layer 22 is placed over the entire modulator build 10. Buffer layer 22 serves as insulation and is generally about 500 to about 10,000 angstroms in thickness, preferably about 3000 angstroms. Buffer layer 22 may comprise silicon oxide (SiO2), silicon nitride (Si3N4or other phases), a combination of silicon oxide and silicon nitride, indium tin oxide (ITO) or another suitable insulator material. A conventional deposition technique, such as sputtering, may be used to place buffer layer 22 over modulator build 10. It should be noted that the use of chemical vapor deposition (CVD) techniques should generally be avoided as such processing tends to generate undesirable free protons as discussed above with respect to wet etch processes.
Referring to FIG. 1G, the modulator build 10 is completed by placing electrodes 24 above the buffer layer 22. As shown, electrodes 24 can be placed directly above waveguide regions 18 or they may be placed at other locations atop buffer layer 22. As is known by
those of ordinary skill in the art, "Z" orientation modulators will have electrodes formed directly above the waveguides and "X" or "Y" orientation modulators will have electrodes formed offset from the waveguides. Standard deposition techniques are used to form electrodes 24 above buffer layer 22. A standard deposition technique may include a photoresist process, a conventional plasma deposition, sputtering or thermal evaporation process, a plasma etch process and a strip and acetone or propenyl wash process to eliminate the photoresist. The electrodes may be formed from gold (Au), chromium gold, titanium and gold or other suitable electrode materials. The use of chromium and titanium in combination with gold or as a pure thin layer between buffer layer 22 and electrode 24 is for the purpose of increasing adhesion between the gold and the buffer layer. The electrodes will typically be about 0.1 micron to about 4 microns in thickness.
Once the electrodes have been fabricated, the modulator build 10 undergoes a post build anneal process to relieve stress in the crystal, the electrodes and/or the buffer layer. In some instances, this anneal step may also be performed after the formation of buffer layer 22. This anneal process may be conducted in a flowing, wet D2 O environment to eliminate the likelihood of free protons contaminating the modulator build. Lithium niobate has inherently high stress coefficients and relieving stress is essential to assure that output drift does not occur in the modulators. The preferred anneal temperature is about 300 degrees Celsius. Possible carrier gasses include oxygen, nitrogen, argon, helium, neon, or another gas essentially non-reactive with the substrate to flow into the bubbling apparatus 112 as described above. The flow rate of the carrier gas may preferably be within the range of 0.2 SCFH to about 5.0 SCFH with about 1.2 SCFH presently preferred as above. The preferred anneal duration is about 4 hours to about 6 hours.
FIG. 4 is a process flow diagram summarizing the method of the present invention. At reference number 124 titanium is deposited onto the substrate. At reference number 126 the carrier gas is wet with D2O. At reference number 128 the carrier gas is flowed by the substrate. At reference number 130 the substrate is heated. At reference number 132 the titanium is indiffused into the substrate. At reference number 134 the substrate is cooled.
Alternative Embodiments
Although illustrative presently preferred embodiments and applications of this invention are shown and described herein, many variations and modifications are possible which remain within the concept, scope and spirit of the invention, and these variations would become clear to those skilled in the art after a perusal of this application. The invention, therefore, is not limited except in the spirit of the appended claims.