WO1998029299A1

WO1998029299A1 - Spar with features against vortex induced vibrations

Info

Publication number: WO1998029299A1
Application number: PCT/EP1997/007326
Authority: WO
Inventors: Donald Wayne Allen; Stephen William Balint; Dean Leroy Henning; David Wayne Mcmillan; Ferdinand Joseph Fischer, Iii; Bobby Eugene Cox; Anders Gustaf Conny Ekvall
Original assignee: Shell Internationale Research Maatschappij B.V.
Priority date: 1996-12-31
Filing date: 1997-12-23
Publication date: 1998-07-09
Also published as: OA11137A; MY119621A; NO317001B1; GB2334919B; NO993187L; BR9714118A; GB2334919A; ID22474A; GB9914252D0; NO993187D0

Abstract

A spar platform comprising a deck (12), a buoyant tank assembly (14) including a first buoyant section (14a) connected to the deck, a second buoyant section (14b) arranged below the first buoyant section and a buoyant spacing structure interconnecting the first and second buoyant sections in a manner providing a horizontally extending gap (30) between the first and second buoyant sections, a counterweight arranged below the buoyant tank assembly and connected to the buoyant tank assembly by a counterweight (18) spacing structure.

Description

SPAR WITH FEATURES AGAINST VORTEX INDUCED VIBRATIONS

The present invention relates to a heave resistant, deepwater platform supporting structure known as a "spar." More particularly, the present invention relates to reducing the susceptibility of spars to drag and vortex induced vibrations ("VIV").

Efforts to economically develop offshore oil and gas fields in ever deeper water create many unique engineering challenges. One of these challenges is providing a suitable surface accessible structure. Spars provide a promising answer for meeting these challenges. Spar designs provide a heave resistant, floating structure characterized by an elongated, vertically disposed hull. Most often this hull is cylindrical, buoyant at the top and with ballast at the base. The hull is anchored to the ocean floor through risers, tethers, and/or mooring lines.

Though resistant to heave, spars are not immune from the rigors of the offshore environment. The typical single column profile of the hull is particularly susceptible to VIV problems in the presence of a passing current. These currents cause vortexes to shed from the sides of the hull, inducing vibrations that can hinder normal drilling and/or production operations and lead to the failure of the anchoring members or other critical structural elements .

Helical strakes and shrouds have been used or proposed for such applications to reduce vortex induced vibrations. Strakes and shrouds can be made to be effective regardless of the orientation of the current to the marine element, but us general shrouds and strakes materially increase the drag on such large marine elements. Thus, there is a clear need for a low drag, VIV reducing system suitable for deployment in protecting the hull of a spar type offshore structure.

In accordance with the invention there is provided a spar platform comprising a deck, a buoyant tank assembly including a first buoyant section connected to the deck, a second buoyant section arranged below the first buoyant section and a buoyant spacing structure interconnecting the first and second buoyant sections in a manner providing a horizontally extending gap between the first and second buoyant sections, a counterweight arranged below the buoyant tank assembly and connected to the buoyant tank assembly by a counterweight spacing structure.

By the provision of the gap between the first and second buoyant sections the correlation of vortex induced vibrations between the individual sections is substantially disrupted so that any remaining vortex induced vibration is substantially reduced compared to the situation in which no gap is present between the buoyant sections.

A further reduction of vortex induced vibration is achieved if said first and second buoyant tank sections have different outer diameters. The different buoyant sections then have different aspect ratios which feature further contributes to disturbing any correlation of vortex induced vibration between the individual buoyant sections. The description above, as well as further advantages of the present invention will be more fully appreciated by reference to the following detailed description of the illustrated embodiments which should be read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which:

FIG. 1 is a side elevational view of an embodiment of a spar platform with spaced buoyancy in accordance with the present invention; FIG. 2 is a cross sectional view of the spar platform of FIG. 1 taken at line 2-2 in FIG. 1;

FIG. 3 is a side elevational view of an alternate embodiment of a spar platform with spaced buoyancy in accordance with the present invention; FIG. 4 is a cross sectional view of the spar platform of FIG. 3 taken at line 4-4 in FIG. 3;

FIG. 5 is a cross sectional view of the spar platform of FIG. 3 taken at line 5-5 in FIG. 3;

FIG. 6 is a cross sectional view of the spar platform of FIG. 3 taken at line 6-6 in FIG. 4 ;

FIG. 7 is a schematically rendered cross sectional view of a riser system useful with embodiments of the present invention;

FIG. 8 is a side elevational view of a riser system deployed in an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 9 is a side elevational view of another embodiment of the present invention; and

FIG. 10 is a side elevational view of a substantially open truss in an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 1 illustrates a spar 10 in accordance with the present invention. Spars are a broad class of floating, moored offshore structure characterized in that they are resistant to heave motions and present an elongated, vertically oriented hull 14 which is buoyant at the top, here buoyant tank assembly 15, and is ballasted at its base, here counterweight 18, which is separated from the top through a middle or counterweight spacing structure 20 .

Such spars may be deployed in a variety of sizes and configuration suited to their intended purpose ranging from drilling alone, drilling and production, or production alone. FIGS. 1 and 2 illustrate a drilling spar, but those skilled in the art may readily adapt appropriate spar configurations in accordance with the present invention for production operations alone or for combined drilling and production operations as well in the development of offshore hydrocarbon reserves.

In the illustrative example of FIGS. 1 and 2, spar 10 supports a deck 12 with a hull 14 having a plurality of spaced buoyancy sections, here first or upper buoyancy section 14A and second or lower buoyancy section 14B. These buoyancy sections are separated by buoyant section spacing structure 28 to provide a substantially open, horizontally extending vertical gap 30 between adjacent buoyancy sections. Here the buoyancy sections have equal diameters and divide the buoyant tank assembly 15 into sections of substantially equal length below the water line 16. Further, the height of gap 30 is substantially equal to 10% of the diameter of buoyant sections 14A and 14B. A counterweight 18 is provided at the base of the spar and the counterweight is spaced from the buoyancy sections by a counterweight spacing structure 20. Counterweight 18 may be in any number of con- figurations, e.g., cylindrical, hexagonal, square, etc., so long as the geometry lends itself to connection to counterweight spacing structure 20. In this embodiment, the counterweight is rectangular and counterweight spacing structure is provided by a substantially open truss framework 20A.

Mooring lines 26 secure the spar platform over the well site at ocean floor 22. In this embodiment the mooring lines are clustered (see FIG. 2) and provide characteristics of both taut and catenary mooring lines with buoys 24 included in the mooring system (see FIG. 1) . The mooring lines terminate at their lower ends at anchor system 32, here piles 32A. The upper end of the mooring lines may extend upward through shoes, pulleys, etc. to winching facilities on deck 12 or the mooring lines may be more permanently attached at their departure from hull 14 at the base of buoyant tank assembly 15.

In FIG. 1, a drilling riser 34 is deployed beneath derrick 36 on deck 12 of spar platform 10. The drilling riser connects drilling equipment at the surface with well 36 at ocean floor 22 through a central moon pool 38, see FIG. 2.

A basic characteristic of the spar type structure is its heave resistance. However, the typical elongated, cylindrical hull elements, whether the single caisson of the "classic" spar or the buoyant tank assembly 15 of a truss-style spar, are very susceptible to vortex induced vibration ("VIV") in the presence of a passing current. These currents cause vortexes to shed from the sides of the hull 14, inducing vibrations that can hinder normal drilling and/or production operations and lead to the failure of the risers, mooring line connections or other critical structural elements. Premature fatigue failure is a particular concern.

Prior efforts at suppressing VIV in spar hulls have centered on strakes and shrouds. However both of these efforts have tended to produce structures with having high drag coefficients, rendering the hull more susceptible to drift. This commits substantial increases in the robustness required in the anchoring system. Further, this is a substantial expense for structures that may have multiple elements extending from near the surface to the ocean floor and which are typically considered for water depths in excess of half a mile or so . The present invention reduces VIV from currents, regardless of their angle of attack, by dividing the aspect ratio of the cylindrical elements in the spar with substantially open, horizontally extending, vertical gaps 30 at select intervals along the length of the cylindrical hull. A gap having a height of 10% or so diameter of the cylindrical element is sufficient to substantially disrupt the correlation of flow about the combined cylindrical elements and this benefit may be maximized with the fewest such gaps by dividing the combined cylindrical elements into sections of roughly equivalent aspect ratios. For typically sized truss- type spars, one such gap through the buoyant tank assembly may be sufficient relief as truss framework 20A forming the counterweight spacing structure 20 contributes little to the VIV response of the spar.

Providing one or more gaps 30 also help reduce the drag effects of current on spar hull 14.

FIGS. 3-5 illustrate a spar 10 in accordance with another embodiment of the present invention. In this illustration, spar 10 is a production spar with a derrick 36 for workover operations. Buoyant tank assembly 15 supports a deck 12 with a hull 14 having two spaced buoyancy sections 14A and 14B, of unequal diameter. A counterweight 18 is provided at the base of the spar and the counterweight is spaced from the buoyancy sections by a substantially open truss framework 20A. Mooring lines 19 secure the spar platform over the well site.

Production risers 34A connect wells or manifolds at the seafloor (not shown) to surface completions at deck 12 to provide a flowline for producing hydrocarbons from subsea reservoirs. Here risers 34A extend through an interior or central moonpool 38 illustrated in the cross sectional views of FIGS. 4 and 5.

Spar platforms characteristically resist, but do not eliminate heave and pitch motions. Further, other dynamic response to environmental forces also contribute to relative motion between risers 34A and spar platform 10. Effective support for the risers which can accommodate this relative motion is critical because a net compressive load can buckle the riser and collapse the pathway within the riser necessary to conduct well fluids to the surface. Similarly, excess tension from uncompensated direct support can seriously damage the riser. FIGS. 7 and 8 illustrate a deepwater riser system 40 which can support the risers without the need for active, motion compensating riser tensioning systems .

FIG. 7 is a cross sectional schematic of a deepwater riser system 40 constructed in accordance with the present invention. Within the spar structure, production risers 34A run concentrically within buoyancy can tubes 42. One or more centralizers 44 secure this positioning. Here centralizer 44 is secured at the lower edge of the buoyancy can tube and is provided with a load transfer connection 46 in the form of an elastomeric flexjoint which takes axial load, but passes some flexure deformation and thereby serves to protect riser 34A from extreme bending moments that would result from a fixed riser to spar connection at the base of spar 10. In this embodiment, the bottom of the buoyancy can tube is otherwise open to the sea.

The top of the buoyancy tube can, however, is provided with an upper seal 48 and a load transfer connection 50. In this embodiment, the seal and load transfer function are separated, provided by inflatable packer 48A and spider 50A, respectively. However, these functions could be combined in a hanger/gasket assembly or otherwise provided. Riser 34A extends through seal 48 and connection 50 to present a Christmastree 52 adjacent production facilities, not shown. These are connected with a flexible conduit, also not shown. In this embodiment, the upper load transfer connection assumes a less axial load than lower load transfer connection 46 which takes the load of the production riser therebeneath . By contrast, the upper load connection only takes the riser load through the length of the spar, and this is only necessary to augment the riser lateral support provided the production riser by the concentric buoyancy can tube surrounding the riser. External buoyancy tanks, here provided by hard tanks 54, are provided about the periphery of the relatively large diameter buoyancy can tube 42 and provide sufficient buoyancy to at least float an unloaded buoyancy can tube. In some applications it may be desirable for the hard tanks or other form of external buoyancy tanks 54 to provide some redundancy in overall riser support.

Additional, load bearing buoyancy is provided to buoyancy can assembly 41 by presence of a gas 56, e.g., air or nitrogen, in the annulus 58 between buoyancy can tube 42 and riser 34A beneath seal 48. A pressure charging system 60 provides this gas and drives water out the bottom of buoyancy can tube 42 to establish the load bearing buoyant force in the riser system.

Load transfer connections 46 and 50 provide a relatively fixed support from buoyancy can assembly 41 to riser 34A. Relative motion between spar 10 and the connected riser/buoyancy assembly is accommodated at riser guide structures 62 which include wear resistant bushings within riser guides tubes 64. The wear interface is between the guide tubes and the large diameter buoyancy can tubes and risers 34A are protected.

FIG. 8 is a side elevational view of a deepwater riser system 40 in a partially cross-sectioned spar 10 having two buoyancy sections 14A and 14B, of unequal diameter, separated by a gap 30. A counterweight 18 is provided at the base of the spar, spaced from the buoyancy sections by a substantially open truss framework 20A.

The relatively small diameter production riser 34A runs through the relatively large diameter buoyancy can tube 42. Hard tanks 54 are attached about buoyancy can tube 42 and a gas injected into annulus 58 drives the water/gas interface 66 within buoyancy can tube 42 far down buoyancy can assembly 41.

Buoyancy can assembly 41 is slidingly received through a plurality of riser guides 62. The riser guide structure provides a guide tube 64 for each deepwater riser system 40, all interconnected in a structural framework connected to hull 14 of the spar. Further, in this embodiment, a significant density of structural conductor framework is provided at such levels to tie conductor guide structures 62 for the entire riser array to the spar hull. Further, this can include a plate 68 across moonpool 38.

The density of conductor framing and/or horizontal plates 68 serve to dampen heave of the spar. Further, the entrapped mass of water impinged by this horizontal structure is useful in otherwise tuning the dynamics of the spar, both in defining harmonics and inertia response. Yet this virtual mass is provided with minimal steel and without significantly increasing the buoyancy requirements of the spar. Horizontal obstructions across the moonpool of a spar with spaced buoyancy section may also improve dynamic response by impeding the passage of dynamic wave pressures through gap 30, up moonpool 38. Other placement levels of the conductor guide framework, horizontal plates, or other horizontal impinging structure 11 may be useful, whether across the moonpool, across substantially open truss 20A, as outward projections from the spar, or even as a component of the relative sizes of the upper and lower buoyancy sections, 14A and 14B, respectively. See FIG. 7.

Further, vertical impinging surfaces such as the additional of vertical plates 69 at various limited levels in open truss ^' framework 20A may similarly enhance pitch dynamics for the spar with effective entrapped mass. Such vertical plates may, on a limited basis, close in the periphery of truss 20A, may crisscross within the truss, or be configured in another multidirectional configuration.

Returning to FIG. 6, another optional feature of this embodiment is the absence of hard tanks 54 adjacent gap 30.

Gap 30 in this spar design controls vortex induced vibration ("VIV") on the cylindrical buoyancy sections 14 by dividing the aspect ratio (diameter to height below the water line) with two, spaced buoyancy sections 14A and 14B having similar volumes and, e.g., a separation of about 10% of the diameter of the upper buoyancy section. Further, the gap reduces drag on the spar, regardless of the direction of current. Both these benefits requires the ability of current to pass through the spar at the gap. Therefore, reducing the outer diameter of a plurality of deepwater riser systems at this gap may facilitate these benefits.

Another benefit of gap 30 is that it allows passage of import and export steel catenary risers 70 mounted exteriorly of lower buoyancy section 14B to the moonpool 38. See FIG.6 and also FIGS. 3-5. This provides the benefits and convenience of hanging these risers exterior to the hull of the spar, but provide the protection of having these inside the moonpool near the water line 16 where collision damage presents the greatest risk and provides a concentration of lines that facilitates efficient processing facilities.

Import and export risers 70 are secured by standoffs and clamps above their major load connection to the spar. Below this connection, they drop in a catenary lie to the seafloor in a manner that accepts vertical motion at the surface more readily than the vertical access production risers 34A.

Supported by hard tanks 54 alone (without a pressure charged source of annular buoyancy) , unsealed and open top buoyancy can tubes 42 can serve much like well conductors on traditional fixed platforms. Thus, the large diameter of the buoyancy can tube allows passage of equipment such as a guide funnel and compact mud mat in preparation for drilling, a drilling riser with an integrated tieback connector for drilling, surface casing with a connection pod, a compact subsea tree or other valve assemblies, a compact wireline lubricator for workover operations, etc. as well as the production riser and its tieback connector. Such other tools may be conventionally supported from a derrick, gantry crane, or the like throughout operations, as is the production riser itself during installation operations . After production riser 34A is run (with centralizer 44 attached) and makes up with the well, seal 48 is established, the annulus is charged with gas and seawater is evacuated, and the load of the production riser is transferred to the buoyancy can assembly 41 as the deballasted assembly rises and load transfer connections at the top and bottom of assembly 41 engage to support riser 34A.

It should be understood that although most of the illustrative embodiments presented here deploy the present invention in spars with interior moon pools 38 and a substantially open truss 20A separating the buoyant sections from the counterweight 18; it is clear that the VIV suppression and drag reduction of present invention is not limited to this sort of spar embodiment. Such measures may be deployed for spars having no moonpool and exteriorly run vertical access production risers 34A or may be deployed in "classic spars" 10 in which the buoyant tank assembly 15, counterweight spacing structure 20, and counterweight 18 are all provided in the profile of a single elongated cylindrical hull disrupted only by the gaps of the present invention. See, for example, FIG. 9 illustrating both these configuration aspects.

It should also be appreciated that dividing the buoyant tank assembly into multiple buoyant sections facilitates a modular approach to building spars in which facility requirements and attendant deck loads can be accommodated by adding or changing one or more of the buoyant sections rather than redesigning the entire spar as an integral cylindrical unit as. e.g., a "classic" spar.

Further, other modifications, changes and sub- stitutions are intended in the foregoing disclosure and in some instances some features of the invention will be employed without a corresponding use of other features. Accordingly, it is appropriate that the appended claims be construed broadly and in the manner consistent with the spirit and scope of the invention herein .

Claims

C L I M S

1. A spar platform comprising: a deck; a buoyant tank assembly including a first buoyant section connected to the deck, a second buoyant section arranged below the first buoyant section and a buoyant spacing structure interconnecting the first and second buoyant sections in a manner providing a horizontally extending gap between the first and second buoyant sections; - a counterweight arranged below the buoyant tank assembly and connected to the buoyant tank assembly by a counterweight spacing structure.

2. The spar platform of claim 1, wherein the height of said gap is about 10% of the width of the first buoyant section.

3. The spar platform of claim 1 or 2, wherein said first and second buoyant tank sections have different outer diameters.

4. The spar platform of claim 3, wherein the difference between the outer diameters of the first and second buoyant sections is between about 40 - 80% of the largest of said diameters.

5. The spar platform of any one of claims 1-4, wherein an open moon-pool extends substantially vertically through the first buoyancy section, and wherein at least one riser extends through said moon-pool to the deck of the spar platform.

6. The spar platform of claim 5, wherein said open moon-pool further extends substantially vertically through the second buoyant section.

7. The spar platform of claim 5 or 6, wherein each riser is connected to the spar platform by a buoyancy can assembly comprising an open ended buoyancy can tube through which the upper end part of the riser extends, a seal arranged in an upper part of the buoyancy can tube and closing the annulus between the riser an the buoyancy can tube, a load transfer connection between the riser and the buoyancy can tube, and a pressure charging system in fluid communication with said annulus below said seal.

8. The spar platform of any one of claims 1-7, wherein the counterweight spacing structure is a substantially open truss framework.

9. The spar platform of claim 8, further comprising a plurality of horizontal impinging structures across the truss framework.

10. The spar platform of claim 10, wherein the horizontal impinging structures are formed by riser guide structures.

11. The spar platform substantially as described hereinbefore with reference to the drawings.