US20160044195A1 - Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type - Google Patents

Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type Download PDF

Info

Publication number
US20160044195A1
US20160044195A1 US14/295,838 US201414295838A US2016044195A1 US 20160044195 A1 US20160044195 A1 US 20160044195A1 US 201414295838 A US201414295838 A US 201414295838A US 2016044195 A1 US2016044195 A1 US 2016044195A1
Authority
US
United States
Prior art keywords
media
media type
variables
circumflex over
operational
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Abandoned
Application number
US14/295,838
Inventor
Niko Jay Murrell
Julie Ann Gordon Whitney
Ryan Thomas Bradley
Nikhil Bajaj
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
Lexmark International Inc
Original Assignee
Lexmark International Inc
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by Lexmark International Inc filed Critical Lexmark International Inc
Priority to US14/295,851 priority Critical patent/US9367005B2/en
Priority to US14/295,838 priority patent/US20160044195A1/en
Assigned to LEXMARK INTERNATIONAL, INC. reassignment LEXMARK INTERNATIONAL, INC. ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: BRADLEY, RYAN THOMAS, MURRELL, NIKO JAY, WHITNEY, JULIE ANN GORDON
Publication of US20160044195A1 publication Critical patent/US20160044195A1/en
Abandoned legal-status Critical Current

Links

Images

Classifications

    • GPHYSICS
    • G03PHOTOGRAPHY; CINEMATOGRAPHY; ANALOGOUS TECHNIQUES USING WAVES OTHER THAN OPTICAL WAVES; ELECTROGRAPHY; HOLOGRAPHY
    • G03GELECTROGRAPHY; ELECTROPHOTOGRAPHY; MAGNETOGRAPHY
    • G03G15/00Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern
    • G03G15/20Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern for fixing, e.g. by using heat
    • G03G15/2003Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern for fixing, e.g. by using heat using heat
    • G03G15/2014Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern for fixing, e.g. by using heat using heat using contact heat
    • G03G15/2039Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern for fixing, e.g. by using heat using heat using contact heat with means for controlling the fixing temperature
    • G03G15/205Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern for fixing, e.g. by using heat using heat using contact heat with means for controlling the fixing temperature specially for the mode of operation, e.g. standby, warming-up, error
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N1/00Scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, e.g. facsimile transmission; Details thereof
    • H04N1/00681Detecting the presence, position or size of a sheet or correcting its position before scanning
    • H04N1/00684Object of the detection
    • H04N1/00724Type of sheet, e.g. colour of paper or transparency
    • GPHYSICS
    • G03PHOTOGRAPHY; CINEMATOGRAPHY; ANALOGOUS TECHNIQUES USING WAVES OTHER THAN OPTICAL WAVES; ELECTROGRAPHY; HOLOGRAPHY
    • G03GELECTROGRAPHY; ELECTROPHOTOGRAPHY; MAGNETOGRAPHY
    • G03G15/00Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern
    • G03G15/50Machine control of apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern, e.g. regulating differents parts of the machine, multimode copiers, microprocessor control
    • GPHYSICS
    • G03PHOTOGRAPHY; CINEMATOGRAPHY; ANALOGOUS TECHNIQUES USING WAVES OTHER THAN OPTICAL WAVES; ELECTROGRAPHY; HOLOGRAPHY
    • G03GELECTROGRAPHY; ELECTROPHOTOGRAPHY; MAGNETOGRAPHY
    • G03G15/00Apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern
    • G03G15/50Machine control of apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern, e.g. regulating differents parts of the machine, multimode copiers, microprocessor control
    • G03G15/5029Machine control of apparatus for electrographic processes using a charge pattern, e.g. regulating differents parts of the machine, multimode copiers, microprocessor control by measuring the copy material characteristics, e.g. weight, thickness
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06KGRAPHICAL DATA READING; PRESENTATION OF DATA; RECORD CARRIERS; HANDLING RECORD CARRIERS
    • G06K15/00Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers
    • G06K15/02Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers
    • G06K15/021Adaptations for printing on specific media
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06KGRAPHICAL DATA READING; PRESENTATION OF DATA; RECORD CARRIERS; HANDLING RECORD CARRIERS
    • G06K15/00Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers
    • G06K15/02Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers
    • G06K15/10Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers by matrix printers
    • G06K15/102Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers by matrix printers using ink jet print heads
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06KGRAPHICAL DATA READING; PRESENTATION OF DATA; RECORD CARRIERS; HANDLING RECORD CARRIERS
    • G06K15/00Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers
    • G06K15/02Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers
    • G06K15/14Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers using printers by electrographic printing, e.g. xerography; by magnetographic printing
    • GPHYSICS
    • G06COMPUTING; CALCULATING OR COUNTING
    • G06KGRAPHICAL DATA READING; PRESENTATION OF DATA; RECORD CARRIERS; HANDLING RECORD CARRIERS
    • G06K15/00Arrangements for producing a permanent visual presentation of the output data, e.g. computer output printers
    • G06K15/40Details not directly involved in printing, e.g. machine management, management of the arrangement as a whole or of its constitutive parts
    • G06K15/4065Managing print media, e.g. determining available sheet sizes
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N1/00Scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, e.g. facsimile transmission; Details thereof
    • H04N1/00681Detecting the presence, position or size of a sheet or correcting its position before scanning
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N1/00Scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, e.g. facsimile transmission; Details thereof
    • H04N1/00681Detecting the presence, position or size of a sheet or correcting its position before scanning
    • H04N1/00684Object of the detection
    • H04N1/00708Size or dimensions
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N1/00Scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, e.g. facsimile transmission; Details thereof
    • H04N1/00681Detecting the presence, position or size of a sheet or correcting its position before scanning
    • H04N1/00729Detection means
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N2201/00Indexing scheme relating to scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, and to details thereof
    • H04N2201/0077Types of the still picture apparatus
    • H04N2201/0081Image reader
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N2201/00Indexing scheme relating to scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, and to details thereof
    • H04N2201/0077Types of the still picture apparatus
    • H04N2201/0082Image hardcopy reproducer
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H04ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
    • H04NPICTORIAL COMMUNICATION, e.g. TELEVISION
    • H04N2201/00Indexing scheme relating to scanning, transmission or reproduction of documents or the like, and to details thereof
    • H04N2201/0077Types of the still picture apparatus
    • H04N2201/0094Multifunctional device, i.e. a device capable of all of reading, reproducing, copying, facsimile transception, file transception

Definitions

  • the present disclosure relates generally to imaging devices, and, more particularly, to those systems and methods for sensing types or classes of media.
  • the imaging device relies upon media type settings to control media handling, transfer, fusing, and finishing operations.
  • Common failures related to improper media type settings include poor print quality, poor fusing, hot or cold offset, paper jams, media damage, component wear, and wrapping of the fuser by the media. This leads to user dissatisfaction.
  • Prior art sensor implementations describe devices that measure a single media property, or at most, a few specific properties, such as optical transmission and impedance, to provide limited media identification.
  • Prior art control schemes are limited in scope and are based upon an incomplete characterization of the media.
  • Such prior art systems still rely upon user input and lack a holistic approach.
  • An idealized, fully-featured sensing scheme would take a single, direct measurement of all relevant intrinsic media properties and use this information to model and control the imaging device.
  • the number of intrinsic property measurements required to adequately control an imaging device, such as an electrophotographic printer, without user input is prohibitive as this approach is neither cost nor space efficient and requires a large number of sensors.
  • Prior art sensing schemes have been incomplete because they have failed to measure some number intrinsic properties of the media needed to more accurately determine the media type.
  • the method comprises in one aspect: establishing a media set comprising a plurality of media types M to be used in the operational imaging device; determining a number of variables N needed to determine each media type in the media set; providing a training sensor set for measuring each of the N variables and providing corresponding output signal therefor; using the training sensor set to measure the N variables with a known sample of each media type in the media set and a training imaging device to create a corresponding training data set for each media type in the media set, wherein the measuring includes taking multiple measurements of each of the N variables; inputting each training data set for each media type into a classifier training engine; and generating, using the classifier training engine, a media type determining equation for each media type incorporating corresponding N variable terms to create a set of M media type determining equations for use with an operational set of sensors corresponding to the training set sensors.
  • the method in another aspect, in an operational imaging device comprises: storing in a memory the set of M media type determining equations; providing an operational sensor set for operable communication with the operational imaging device, the operational sensor set measuring a value of each variable in the set of N variables and providing corresponding output signals for the measured N variables for a sheet of media to be processed; converting the received output signals into the N measured normalized variable values; solving the set of M media type determining equations using the N measured normalized variable values to determine a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed; and, selecting, based upon the determined media type, from a look up table at least one operational parameter for the operational imaging device.
  • the method in another aspect includes the measuring of multiple measurements of each of the N variables by the training sensor set occurs at a plurality of predetermined temperature and relative humidity combinations.
  • the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: electrical impedance magnitude, electrical impedance phase, contact resistance, capacitance, optical transmission mean, optical transmission deviation, optical spectral reflectance, optical diffuse reflectance, bending stiffness, acoustic transmission, temperature, media size, relative humidity, media feed motor current, fuser temperature, transfer current, transfer voltage, media holes, preprinted areas, media color, multilayer media, RFID signal, magnetic field, MICR, and further wherein the operational sensor set includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
  • FIG. 1 is a schematic representation of a training system used with the presently disclosed system and methods.
  • FIG. 2 is an illustration of training data sets.
  • FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of an operational device employing the presently disclosed system and methods.
  • FIGS. 4-5 illustrate two types of operational parameter ranges schemes.
  • FIG. 6 illustrates the use of a matrix of media type determining equation sets to handle faulty sensors.
  • FIG. 7 is a simplified block diagram of the present method of using media type determining equation sets in an operational imaging device to determine a media type.
  • FIGS. 8A-8B are simplified block diagrams of the present method providing for operation in the event of a faulty sensor in an operational imaging device.
  • embodiments of the present disclosure include both hardware and electronic components or modules that, for purposes of discussion, may be illustrated and described as if the majority of the components were implemented solely in hardware.
  • the electronic based aspects of the invention may be implemented in software.
  • a plurality of hardware and software-based devices, as well as a plurality of different structural components may be utilized to implement the invention.
  • the specific mechanical configurations illustrated in the drawings are intended to exemplify embodiments of the present disclosure and that other alternative mechanical configurations are possible.
  • each block of the diagrams, and combinations of blocks in the diagrams, respectively, may be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions may be loaded onto a general purpose computer, special purpose computer, or other programmable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such that the instructions which execute on the computer or other programmable data processing apparatus may create means for implementing the functionality of each block or combinations of blocks in the diagrams discussed in detail in the descriptions below.
  • Computer program instructions may also be stored in a non-transitory, tangible, computer readable storage medium that may direct a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to function in a particular manner, such that the instructions stored in the computer readable storage medium may produce an article of manufacture including an instruction means that implements the function specified in the block or blocks.
  • Computer readable storage medium includes, for example, disks, CD-ROMS, Flash ROMS, nonvolatile ROM and RAM.
  • the computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer or other programmable apparatus to produce a computer implemented process such that the instructions that execute on the computer or other programmable apparatus implement the functions specified in the block or blocks.
  • Output of the computer program instructions such as the process models and the combined process models, as will be described in greater detail below, may be displayed in a user interface or computer display of the computer or other programmable apparatus that implements the functions or the computer program instructions.
  • image encompasses any printed or digital form of text, graphic, or combination thereof.
  • output encompasses output from any printing device such as color and black-and-white copiers, color and black-and-white printers, and multifunction devices that incorporate multiple functions such as scanning, copying, and printing capabilities in one device.
  • printing devices may utilize ink jet, dot matrix, dye sublimation, laser, and any other suitable print formats.
  • button as used herein means any component, whether a physical component or graphic user interface icon, that is engaged to initiate an action or event.
  • training system 10 used with present media type sensing system is illustrated.
  • trainer 12 that provides firmware that will be incorporated into one or more operational imaging devices, generally indicated 50 , operational imaging devices 50 - 1 through 50 -K as shown.
  • training sensor set 14 Also included in training system 10 is a training sensor set 14 , a training media set 16 comprised of M different media types, 16 - 1 - 16 -M, a robot 18 , a training imaging device 22 , and imaging device subsystems 24 .
  • a robot 18 or robotic job processor 18 is simply a machine designed to perform a function of an operational imaging device 50 .
  • training system 10 may use a fuser robot that performs fusing, a transfer station robot that performs toned image transfer to a media sheet, or a media feed robot that emulates feeding media sheets.
  • Training sensor set 14 is used to measure N different variables related to each media type in the training media set 16 or related to the traning imaging device 22 or its subsystems 24 to form training data sets for each media type.
  • the training imaging device 24 would be an imaging device that is substantially the same as an operational imaging device 50 that would be used by a customer. However, the training imaging device 22 would be used in a laboratory or test enclosure so that environmental conditions could be controlled when making measurements as described herein.
  • a training sensor set 14 consisting of a predetermined collection of sensors, provides data measurement points to trainer 12 .
  • the types and number of sensors used will be described below and will vary dependent upon the media types included in training media set 16 , the ambient conditions 20 to be measured, the type of robots 18 and training imaging device 22 used, and functional requirements and customer requirements for the operational imaging devices 50 .
  • the training sensor set 14 is used in conjunction with the training media set 16 , comprised of samples of M different media types and provides multiple data points for each variable in a predetermined set of N variables.
  • training sensor set 14 measures are those relevant to each media type M in the media set 16 ; ambient conditions, indicated by cloud 20 , such as temperature and relative humidity where the training media set 16 is located, and variables relevant to the operational imaging device 50 such as electrical, thermal and mechanical properties measured using the robots 18 or training imaging device 22 .
  • An operational imaging device designer chooses variables that will provide a resolution sufficient to determine each media type M within the training media set 16 .
  • the chosen variables N relevant to the distinguishing the media types in the training media set 16 are empirically determined and verified. For a given family of operational imaging devices 50 , the chosen N variables to be measured using subsystems equivalent to subsystems common to each member of a given family of operational imaging devices 50 .
  • subsystems may be provided in a training imaging device 22 or may be individually provided subsystems, generally indicated 24 , such a transfer station 24 - 1 , fuser 24 - 2 or media feed system 24 - 3 , etc. It will be noted that each media type M is tested with each robot 18 , the training imaging device 22 , if present, or subsystems 24 at several different ambient conditions and measurements are also taken at a plurality of locations within the borders of the media sheet. The use of robots 18 and/or subsystems 24 may obviate the need to use a training imaging device 22 .
  • Training sensor set 14 comprises direct sensors 14 - 1 , indirect sensors 14 - 2 and subsystem response sensors 14 - 3 for one or more subsystems that will be present within the operational imaging device 50 .
  • subsystems include a fuser, a toner transfer station, a media feed system, and a finisher, which may also be termed a processing device.
  • Direct sensor measurements are of a characteristic of the media. These direct measurements include, but are not limited to, optical, electrical impedance, reflectance, thermal capacitance, etc. A more extensive list of direct sensor measurements that may be used with the present system 10 and operational imaging devices 50 - 1 - 50 -K is provided in Table 3 below.
  • Indirect measurements include, but are not limited to, temperature, relative humidity, and/or the desired machine state, e.g., process speed.
  • each media type in the media set and each imaging device subsystem are measured at the desired indirect measurement points.
  • each media type in the training media set 16 and each imaging device subsystem 24 are measured at several different temperature and humidity points, such as, for example, 22° C. at 50% relative humidity, 25.6° C. at 80% relative humidity, and 15° C. at 8% relative humidity.
  • These temperature and humidity points are environments in which operational imaging devices 50 may be placed. Multiple samples of each media type are measured in these different environments to generate the training data set 26 . Other temperature and humidity conditions may also be measured.
  • Subsystem response measurements include change of fuser temperature occurring for each media type in the training media set 16 as they are fed through the fuser, change in transfer nip voltage or current occurring for each media type as they are fed through the transfer nip of the transfer station, media feed motor current for each media type as they are fed through the media path, and/or media location within the media path. Again these measurements may be taken at several different temperatures and relative humidity values and are included in the training data set 26 .
  • a single sensor in the training sensor set 14 may provide data for two or more variables in the set of N variables.
  • an impedance sensor may provide both magnitude and phase data points.
  • the output of each sensor in the training sensor set 14 may be conditioned and normalized by trainer 12 so that M data training sets 26 contain normalized data points. This helps to improve performance of training system 10 .
  • the data for the N variables for each media type M in the training media set 16 is collected in a data set, generally designated 26 , for each media type M, training data sets 26 - 1 through 26 -M as shown.
  • the media type or class to which that data belongs is known.
  • three data sets 26 - 1 - 26 - 3 would be collected. It will be appreciated that the number of data points within each data set 26 will number in the thousands. In general, as the media types M to be sensed in operational imaging devices 50 increases in number, the number of variables N measured increases so that each media type M may be determined.
  • the measurements taken for the training data sets 26 may also account for sensor aging, sensor variability, media variability, imaging device subsystem variability to achieve a robust set of media type determining equations flexible enough to handle variability in the operational sensor set 52 , in the media types and the operational imaging devices 50 . Further, multiple instances of the same sensor and multiple instances of the same type of media sheet may be used when populating the training data sets 26 .
  • each data set 26 for each media type M includes the variables types previously described such as temperature, relative humidity and corresponding imaging device variables, all as selected for inclusion in the predetermined set of N variables.
  • FIG. 2 illustrates a 4 ⁇ 4 matrix of three data sets 26 - 1 - 26 - 3 for three media types—polyvinyl M 1 , cardstock M 2 and plain paper M 3 . Note that the data in FIG. 2 has not been normalized. The data points for polyvinyl M 1 are indicated by a star, those for cardstock M 2 by a triangle, and those for plain media M 3 by a cross.
  • the four variables chosen by the imaging device designer to be measured are bending N 1 in Watts, impedance magnitude N 2 in ohms, impedance phase N 3 in degrees and reflectance or gloss N 4 in Volts. Clustering of the data points for each of the media types M 1 -M 3 can readily be seen.
  • These three data sets 26 - 1 - 26 - 3 would be processed by trainer 12 to produce a media type determining equation set 40 having three media type determining equations.
  • the measured sensor values are normalized prior to training. This is because units of Ohms have no physical comparison to units of optical transmission, degrees of temperature, or percent relative humidity, etc. The goal is to compare how the media is changing with respect to its physical properties and by normalizing the inputs to the same order of magnitude this can be more easily achieved. Before training, these input values are normalized such that the magnitudes of each of the inputs are roughly equivalent over the range expected by the operational imaging devices 50 , the media types expected to be used, expected environments of use, and one or more desired machine states, for example, 40 page per minute (ppm) process speed or 70 ppm process speed.
  • the measured values provided by the operational sensor sets 52 would also be normalized prior to controllers 51 solving the media type determining equations sets 40 .
  • the M data sets 26 of N variables each are fed into a classifier training engine 30 .
  • classifier training engine 30 produces as an output a media type determining equation set 40 containing M media type determining equations, where M is the number of media types and N is the number of variables. It should be understood that the number of variables N does not have to equal the number of media types M.
  • the media type determining equation set 40 will be replicated, 40 - 1 through 40 -K as shown, and installed into each corresponding operational imaging device 50 - 1 - 50 -K.
  • Classifier training engine 30 uses a supervised machine learning algorithm used to map inputs (sensed media variables or properties like bending stiffness, electrical impedance, acoustic transmittance, optical reflectance, etc.) to a media type or class.
  • inputs sensed media variables or properties like bending stiffness, electrical impedance, acoustic transmittance, optical reflectance, etc.
  • supervised learning for a given input data set, the correct output is known.
  • For data in the training data sets 26 the media type or class to which that data belongs is known.
  • results are predicted in a discrete output and input variables are mapped to discrete classes or type—here discrete media types. Once the media type determining equations are formed, these equations, when placed in the operational imaging devices 50 , take measured variable values from the operational sensor set 52 as inputs and use them to determine the best class (i.e.
  • Classification into one of the several media types may be done by multiclass classification or by combining multiple binary classifiers that deal with only two classes at a time.
  • a classification scheme is advantageous since programs in many existing imaging device controllers are based upon a discrete categorization of media into type, weight, and roughness.
  • Classifier training engine 30 may be one of well known classification engines as known in the art that analyze data and recognize patterns for classification. These include a support vector engine 30 - 1 , a neural network 30 - 2 , a quadratic classifier 30 - 3 , a Bayesian network 30 - 4 , or a learning vector quantizer 30 - 5 . Classifier training engine 30 operates on the data sets 26 - 1 - 26 -M to produce the multi-variable media type determining equation set 40 .
  • the media type determining equation set 40 may be constructed many different ways. In one embodiment (created using regression techniques), it resembles a higher order multivariable polynomial. In another embodiment (created using neural networks), it resembles two theta matrices. The form of the media type determining equation will be determined by the type of classifier training engine used in trainer 12 . Note that, once determined, the media type determining equation may be manipulated to take any convenient mathematical form.
  • FIG. 1 Two optional elements are shown in FIG. 1 . These are a polynomial consolidator 32 and expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 . Where the equation set 40 comprises polynomial equations, an optional polynomial consolidator 32 may also be provided to operate on each of the M equations in the set of media determining equations 40 to reduce the number of terms in each equation M. Using a polynomial consolidator 32 reduces the number of terms in each polynomial equation in the media type determining media set 40 , and, in turn, the memory and processing power needed by controllers 53 in operational imagining devices 50 .
  • polynomial consolidator 32 An example implementation of polynomial consolidator 32 will now be described.
  • the following nomenclature is a representative notation for when classifier training engine 30 is a support vector machine, which include examples such as Least-Squares Support Vector Machines (LS-SVM) and Fast Support Vector Machines (FSVM) and many others.
  • LS-SVM Least-Squares Support Vector Machines
  • FSVM Fast Support Vector Machines
  • x current set of measurements to be classified, a vector of length p;
  • m k measurement vector from the training data set, with length p, associated with the kth training data point;
  • ⁇ k weight associated with the kth training data point
  • y k true classification (usually coded +1 or ⁇ 1, but could be another form) associated of the kth training data point;
  • N number of training data points.
  • the weights ⁇ k are arrived at through a training process, which differs somewhat for different classification algorithms, and, for the purposes of polynomial consolidation, the method by which they are attained is not important.
  • the resulting classification function, C(x) may also depend to some degree on the particular classification algorithm.
  • the polynomial consolidation methodology applies to any classification function that one might apply in this manner as long as it is continuous on a bounded interval of interest.
  • Weierstrass approximation theorem it is well known that any function that meets this criteria can be arbitrarily closely approximated by a polynomial function.
  • many implementations of neural network classifiers utilize continuous functions such as the sigmoid function or alternatively the hyperbolic tangent as a key component.
  • d is an integer that provides the degree of the polynomial, and the other terms are as described previously.
  • each of the N terms would contribute a different function.
  • each of the N terms would contribute a term as shown in Eq. 2:
  • the result is a list of multivariate polynomials where the coefficients are related to ⁇ k , y k , b, d and m k , and the variables are the features or measurements of the data point to be classified, namely x 1 , x 2 , . . . , x p , with the number of multivariate polynomials being the number of data points used in the classification (the support vectors).
  • the expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 may be employed to adjust the weighting of the coefficients in the M media type determining equation set 40 .
  • trainer 12 generally a cost/value function that is being optimized—that is, starting with some initial “guess” of the best weightings for the function, a cost function is evaluated and properties that are uncovered during this evaluation are used to refine the “guesses” of the weight values until an optimal classifier training engine for that form is found.
  • the cost/value function lends itself well to optimization, and properties such as convexity of the cost function are very desirable as it leads to a well-studied set of optimization solution methodologies. In some instances some “allowable” confusion between categories (i.e. media types) may exist, depending on certain conditions.
  • polynomial consolidator 32 may be employed, and the form of polynomial consolidator used should not be considered a limitation of the presently disclosed method.
  • other forms of an expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 may be employed, and the form of the expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 used should not be considered a limitation of the presently disclosed method.
  • a test data set may be used to validate media type determining equation set 40 . This is done by separating the entire training data sets 26 - 1 - 26 -M into two subsets. A training data set comprising about 2 ⁇ 3 of the entire data sets 26 - 1 - 26 -M is randomly selected and is used to develop the media type determining equations. A test data set comprising the remaining 1 ⁇ 3 of the entire data sets 26 - 1 - 26 -M is used to empirically evaluate the media type determining equations generated from the 2 ⁇ 3 training data set. This validation technique is well known to one of skill in the art.
  • Media type determining equation set 40 is replicated, indicated as 40 - 1 - 40 -K, in firmware, generally indicated 53 , to be used in each of the operational imaging devices 50 .
  • media type determining equation sets 40 - 1 - 40 -K are provided in firmware 53 - 1 - 53 -K of operational devices 50 - 1 through 50 -K, respectively.
  • a single media type determining equation is produced for each type of media M in the training media set 16 so that there are M number of equations in the media type determining equation set 40 .
  • each media type determining equation is comprised of multiple terms with corresponding constant coefficients for each variable of the N variables.
  • the media type determining equations are polynomial equations
  • Consolidated equations mean a more rapid determination of media type providing real time response in each operational imaging device 50 - 1 - 50 -K to changing media types being processed.
  • the media type determining equations may be represented in any convenient mathematical manner that closely approximates the solution, for example a Taylor polynomial.
  • classifier training engine 30 produces a function, comprised of the M media type determining higher order polynomial equations comprising the media type determining equation sets 40 - 1 - 40 -K, that will be used in each operational imaging device 50 - 1 - 50 -K to be used for a given application.
  • Variable measurement values taken by the operational sensor set 52 - 1 - 52 -K in each operational imaging device 50 - 1 - 50 -K are then input to the function (i.e., the M media type determining equations) to determine the type of media sensed.
  • Training system 10 uses training system 10 to develop the coefficient matrix for each of the M media type determining equations in the media type determining equation set 40 to control the imaging device 50 easily allows for the inclusion of additional sensors. Training system 10 therefore allows for expansion and/or changes of the selected variables N that may be needed with other imaging products to work optimally. Training system 10 is easily expandable and adaptable to future imaging devices and future media types.
  • Operational imaging devices 50 are those that would be provided to users for a specific application, such as a retail application, an office application, or a general purpose application, etc. Operational imaging devices 50 - 1 - 50 -K would be distributed to different locations for use by various end users. Operational imaging devices 50 - 1 - 50 -K would have the same processing devices, e.g., the same fuser types, transfer stations, media feed systems and firmware. Should the processing device hardware or the customer requirements change, then the media type determining equation set 40 would have to be redetermined for the new hardware configuration. Operational devices 50 - 1 - 50 -K include controllers 51 - 1 - 51 -K and an operational sensor set 52 - 1 - 52 -K.
  • Media sheets 60 - 1 - 60 -K are readied to be processed by their corresponding operational imaging devices 50 - 1 - 50 -K.
  • Operational sensor sets 52 - 1 - 52 -K measure the values of the same N variables that were used in the set of N variables that were measured by the training sensor set 14 and provide those measured data values to controllers 51 - 1 - 51 -K.
  • the individual sensors in each of operational sensor sets 52 - 1 - 52 -K may be the same as or similar to those used in training sensor set 14 .
  • Controllers 51 - 1 - 51 -K utilize the measured N variable values provided by the operational sensor sets 52 - 1 - 52 -K to solve the media type determining equation sets 40 - 1 - 40 -K stored in firmware 53 - 1 - 53 -K to determine a media type.
  • operational sensor set 52 - 1 provides measured values for the set of N variables as a sheet of media 60 - 1 is readied for processing.
  • Controller 51 - 1 uses the measured N variable values to solve the media type determining equation set 40 - 1 , to produce a determined media type 54 - 1 which is the highest valued media type determining equation solution found using the variable values measured by operational sensor set 52 - 1 .
  • controller 51 - 1 uses the determined media type 54 - 1 to utilizes lookup table 55 - 1 to select a one or more operational parameters 56 - 1 to be used by operational imaging device 50 - 1 or a subsystem therein to process the readied media sheet 60 - 1 to produce a processed media sheet 61 - 1 .
  • a similar process would be occurring in each of operational imaging devices 50 - 2 - 50 -K to create processed sheets 61 - 2 - 61 -K.
  • the operational parameter or parameters selected in those operational imaging devices 50 - 2 - 50 -K will depend on which media type was the determined media type sheets 60 - 2 - 60 -K.
  • the extrinsic properties to be measured are selected to closely relate to operational imaging device 50 functions. This increases success in sensing media types and reduces the number of required sensors.
  • the operational imaging device 50 is an electrophotographic printer
  • media interacts with three major printer subsystems: media handling, toner transfer, and fusing. It follows that sensed variables or characteristics may be closely related to the fundamental operation of these subsystems.
  • the present media type determining method may also use as a variable one or more of the following variables or characteristics: lumped electrical time response (toner transfer), lumped thermal time response (fusing), mechanical composition (media handling), and other characteristics (e.g., size, temperature, relative humidity).
  • an electric field is generated to move charged toner particles from a donor substrate to the media.
  • Electrical characteristics of the media dictate how quickly the electric field will build and what the field strength will be for an applied voltage. Functionally, it is important to know the time response of media to a given voltage input. Appropriate intrinsic measurements for lumped electrical time response may include one or more of a volumetric measure of impedance (magnitude and phase angle), electrical time constant (resistance and capacitance), or some other similar metric.
  • thermal mass mass and specific heat
  • thermal time constant heat transfer coefficient, specific heat, density, and thickness
  • thermal diffusivity density, specific heat, and thermal conductivity
  • media is conveyed through the system via driven rollers.
  • Mechanical characteristics of the media dictate how much drag the media generates in the media path and how much torque the system must provide to transport the media.
  • Appropriate intrinsic measurements might include bending stiffness (elastic modulus and area moment of inertia), coefficient of friction, or some other similar metric.
  • Media acclimation temperature and relative humidity
  • process speed may also affect each of these three media characteristics. For example at high ambient temperature and relative humidity one media type containing more moisture than at standard temperature and relative humidity conditions, may be better processed using settings for another media type.
  • Media properties may be sensed using a wide variety of possible measurement techniques. Using the fundamental media characteristics just discussed as a guidepost helps limit the set of possibilities. Additionally, the measurement technique or sensing methods would be safe, unobtrusive, compact, energy efficient, inexpensive, and sample rapidly. Measurements should avoid containing redundant information. The sensing methods should be sufficiently independent or be decoupled from one another. This general design guideline provides the classifier training engine 30 with better performance and reduces the number of required sensors and/or measured variables N.
  • Sensors include those that measure electrical impedance, bending stiffness, optical reflectance, optical transmission, and acoustic transmission.
  • extrinsic measurement techniques were selected because they enable the system 10 and operational imaging devices 50 to take measurements that closely correlate to the fundamental media properties listed above.
  • Impedance phase angle and magnitude are derived from media response to an AC voltage applied across the thickness of the sheet while it is staged in a pair of metal rollers. From this, media resistance or capacitance may be calculated. In one embodiment, a 10 KHz wave of 1 volt was sufficient excitation for characterization. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped electrical time response (electrical impedance or resistance and capacitance).
  • Media bending stiffness is measured as a function of a sheet resistance to deformation.
  • the motor current (torque) required to drive a bar that bends a staged sheet is measured.
  • This torque directly correlates to the media modulus of elasticity and area moment of inertia.
  • This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to mechanical composition (bending stiffness).
  • An example of a media stiffness sensor may be found in copending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/145,601, entitled “Media Stiffness Sensor Assembly For An Imaging Device,” and Ser. No. 14/145,661, entitled “Method Of Using An Imaging Device Having A Media Stiffness Sensor Assembly” both filed Dec. 31, 2013.
  • a pair of photodiodes is used to measure the ratio of specular and diffuse light emitted by an LED and reflected off the surface of a media sheet.
  • the ratio serves as a relative measure of roughness.
  • This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to mechanical composition (coefficient of friction) and loosely correlates to lumped electrical time response and lumped thermal time response (contact resistance).
  • An acoustic wave is generated using a piezoelectric transducer or a speaker.
  • the energy content in the wave is dampened as it propagates through the media sheet.
  • the amount of transmitted acoustic energy correlates to the mass of the system.
  • This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped thermal time response (thermal mass).
  • An optical transmission sensor measures an amount of light transmitted through a media sheet.
  • the optical transmittance sensor is an infrared LED and a photodetector pair.
  • the infrared LED emits light on one side of the sheet.
  • the photodetector is positioned on the other side of the sheet and measures the quantity of light that is transmitted through the sheet. Several measurements are taken as the sheet is moved by the sensor and an optical average and optical standard deviation are calculated.
  • the transmitted energy is a function of the opacity of the media sheet which correlates to thickness or mass of the media sheet. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped thermal time response (thermal mass).
  • a purpose of the present media sensing system is to use the minimal number of independent extrinsic measurements necessary to develop the media type determining equation set 40 capable of training an operational imaging device 50 that meets the user application.
  • Applications which use limited sets of known media types or that can accept misclassifications of media types without a significant negative impact can be successfully controlled with fewer sensors.
  • additional measurements and/or sensors may be added to improve accuracy and robustness.
  • Table 3 provides example operational sensor sets that would meet several different levels of performance requirements.
  • Table 3 outlines several sensor sets that provide varying degrees of functionality and, in turn, resolution to discern various media types. It should be noted that optical transmission and optical transmision variation may also be listed as being lumped thermal response variables in that media thickness affects both thermal properties and mechanical properties. Optical transmission may also be referred to as optical transmission.
  • sensor set 3 would result in the ability to classify plain paper, cardstock, and polyvinyl labels at ambient environmental conditions.
  • a more fully-featured control scheme may incorporate impedance phase, optical spectral reflectance, media feed motor current, and acoustic transmission sensors in addition to a temperature and humidity sensor (sensor set 2 ). Sensor set 2 would provide the ability to additionally discern light weight, heavy weight, glossy, and bond paper across class B environmental conditions.
  • Sensor set 1 may, for example, be used to distinguish media having holes or perforations, media having preprinted portions, multiweb media, media having magnetic ink or RFID tags, light cardstock, cardstock, heavy cardstock, paper labels, heavy paper labels, vinyl labels, heavy vinyl labels, transparencies, light glossy media, glossy media, heavy glossy media, rough/cotton media, envelopes, heavy envelopes, and polymeric film.
  • Optical sensors may be used to detect holes.
  • Image capture may be done by use of charge coupled imaging device. Magnetic field may be detected by use of a Hall effect sensor.
  • An RFID reader may be used to sense RFID tags.
  • controller 51 -K is operatively coupled to operational sensor set 52 -K having a plurality of output signals provided to controller 51 -K via communication link 100 .
  • operational sensor set 52 -K consists of a base sensor set 52 -K 1 consisting of temperature, relative humidity, impedance and optical transmission sensors S 1 -S 4 , respectively, and additional sensor set elements consisting of reflectance, media feed motor current, media stiffness sensors S 5 -S 7 , respectively, through sensor SX where sensor SX is any additional sensor selected by the designer.
  • the composition of the base sensor set 52 -K 1 is a matter of design choice and the intended application of operational imaging device 50 -K.
  • another base sensor set may be comprised of sensors S 3 -S 7 .
  • the types of sensors in the base sensor set 52 K- 1 and the additional sensor set elements are meant only to be illustrative, and are not intended to be limited to only those sensors shown. Because one sensor may provide data values for two or more of the variables in the set of N variables, the number of sensors SX may be less than the number of variables N that are measured.
  • the N signal outputs, designated NSO, from operational sensor set 52 -K are provided to controller 51 -K via communications link 100 .
  • the NSO are measured values of each variable in the set of N variables.
  • NSO are provided to signal conditioning circuit 51 -K 1 and signal normalization circuit 51 -K 2 for conditioning and range normalization to produce an input set of N measured variable values 51 -K 3 .
  • signal conditioning and normalization steps may also be performed by firmware.
  • firmware 53 -K the set of N measured inputs variables are processed by controller 51 -K to solve media type determining equation set 40 -K to produce a determined media type 54 -K.
  • one or more operational parameters 56 -K are selected by processor 51 K.
  • lookup tables 55 -K 1 through 55 -KP are provided to select operational parameters 56 -K 1 - 56 -KP.
  • the number and type of operational parameters 56 -K 1 - 56 -KP selected are a matter of design choice and the set of N measured input variable values 51 -K 3 .
  • the operational parameters 56 -K 1 - 56 -KP are provided to processing device PDK.
  • the media sheet 60 -K which is to be processed is provided to processing device PDK which produces processed media sheet 61 -K.
  • Media sheet 60 -K may be media to be printed 60 -K 1 or images to be scanned 60 -K 2 .
  • Processing device PDK may, in one form, be a printer or print engine PDK 1 or, in another form, a scanner system PDK 2 .
  • Printer PDK 1 may be an electrophotographic printer or an ink jet printer or other printer types as known in the art.
  • Printer PDK 1 is illustrated as an electrophotographic printer having a fuser F, a toner transfer station TTS, a finisher unit FU providing hole punching and stapling, and media feed system MFS.
  • Scanner system PDK 2 is illustrated as having a media feed system SMFS, an automatic document feeder ADF, a scan bar SB 1 , and a flatbed scan bar SB 2 . Where automatic document feeding or duplex scanning are not needed, the ADF and scan bar SB 1 are not used.
  • operational parameters 56 -K may be provided, for example, to fuser F, toner transfer station TTS, finisher unit FU, and media feed system MFS of printer device PDK 1 .
  • operational parameters 56 -K may be provided, for example, to media feed system SMFS, ADF scan bar SB 1 and flatbed scan bar SB 2 .
  • Controller 51 -K includes a processor unit and associated memory 57 -K, and may be formed as one or more Application Specific Integrated Circuits (ASIC).
  • Memory 57 -K may be, for example, random access memory (RAM), read only memory (ROM), and/or non-volatile RAM (NVRAM).
  • RAM random access memory
  • ROM read only memory
  • NVRAM non-volatile RAM
  • memory 57 -K may be in the form of a separate electronic memory (e.g., RAM, ROM, and/or NVRAM), a hard drive, a CD or DVD drive, or any memory device convenient for use with controller 51 -K.
  • Firmware 53 -K may reside in memory 57 -K.
  • Controller 51 -K may be, for example, a combined printer and scanner controller.
  • FIG. 3 Also illustrated in FIG. 3 is an alternative approach to determining media type.
  • the solution of two or more of the equations in the media type determining equation set 40 -K may be within a predetermined range of one another. Should this arise, a comparator 58 may be used to determine when two or more of the solutions are within a given range of each other, and, based on the equations involved, a lookup table 59 in memory 53 -K may be used select one solution-one media type.
  • FIGS. 4-5 illustrate two arrangements for the various operational parameters 56 -K 1 through 56 -KP that are chosen.
  • the abscissa is the range of an operational parameter and the ordinate is a media type.
  • three media types M 1 , M 2 , M 3 are shown in rectangles, the width of which indicates the range of a given operational parameter P.
  • the range of operational parameter P for media type M 1 does not overlap range of operational parameter P used for media type M 2 , and, similarly, between the operational ranges of operational parameter P and media types M 2 and M 3 .
  • FIG. 4 illustrate two arrangements for the various operational parameters 56 -K 1 through 56 -KP that are chosen.
  • the abscissa is the range of an operational parameter and the ordinate is a media type.
  • three media types M 1 , M 2 , M 3 are shown in rectangles, the width of which indicates the range of a given operational parameter P.
  • the range of operational parameter P for media type M 1 does not overlap range of operational parameter P used
  • the range of operational parameter P for media type M 2 overlaps that for media type M 1 at one end and that of media type M 3 at the other as indicated by RO. While the method shown in FIG. 4 would be more desirable, hardware limitations sometimes preclude setting operational parameters in this manner.
  • the operational imaging device 50 should be able to provide acceptable output for either setting for media classified in either type. This may be seen as a simpler form of expert weighting.
  • FIG. 6 illustrates a further structure that may be used for the media type determining equation set 40 .
  • a sensor within the operational sensor set 52 may fail.
  • the sensor may stop working entirely or the output signal of the sensor may drift outside of an expected range. In either case this may be addressed by providing additional sets of media determining type equation sets.
  • media type determining equation set 40 would be replaced with media type determining equation set matrix 40 ′ comprised of a total of S!+1 media type determining equation sets where S is the total number of sensors in operational sensor set 52 .
  • the first set operational sensor set SS 1 would be one in which all S sensors are functioning.
  • the second operational sensor set SS 2 would be one in which sensor 51 is faulty, the third set SS 3 is one where sensor S 2 is faulty, and so on where sensor set SSS! is the penultimate faulty sensor set and sensor set SSS!+1 is the final faulty sensor set.
  • training system 10 would use only that data within each of the training data sets 26 - 1 - 26 -M that corresponds to the remaining functioning sensors within operational sensor set 52 .
  • the media type determining equation set within matrix 40 ′ of media type determining equation sets selected for use would be that where the data supplied by sensors 1 and 3 would not be used in developing the media type determining equations in that media type determining equation set.
  • the operational sensor set contains a number of sensors known to be reliable
  • the number of sensor sets in matrix 40 ′ may be reduced to eliminate the reliable sensors when creating matrix 40 ′.
  • operational imaging device 50 would declare itself to be non-functional and issue a service request.
  • FIG. 7 provides a simplified flow chart of the present method.
  • Method M 100 the actions of blocks B 10 -B 50 would occur using the training system 10 while those of blocks B 60 -B 120 would occur in each operational imaging device 50 .
  • Method M 100 starts at block B 10 and proceeds to block B 20 where the media set containing M types of media is determined.
  • a training sensor set for measuring values of a set of N predetermined variables is provided.
  • normalized training data sets for each media type in the media set is collected.
  • a media type determining equation set having M media type determining equations is formed.
  • the media type determining equation set 40 is stored in memory 53 of each operational imaging device 50 .
  • an operational sensor set 52 for measuring the values of the set of N variables is provided for each operational imaging device 50 .
  • the values of the set of N variables is measured for a media sheet about to be processed and the values normalized.
  • the media type determining equation set is solved using the normalized values of the set of N variables to determine a media type.
  • an operational parameter of the operational imaging device is chosen.
  • the media sheet to be processed is processed by the operational imaging device using the selected operational parameter.
  • method M 100 ends.
  • FIGS. 8A-8B provide a simplified flow chart of another form of the present method.
  • Method M 200 the actions of blocks B 220 -B 260 would occur using the training system 10 while those of blocks B 260 -B 400 would occur in each operational imaging device 50 .
  • Method M 200 starts at block B 210 and proceeds to block B 220 where the media set containing M types of media is determined.
  • a training sensor set 14 for measuring values of a set of N predetermined variables is provided.
  • normalized training data sets for each media type in the media set is collected.
  • a first media type determining equation set having M media type determining equations is formed where all of the variables in the set of N variables are being measured by the training sensor set 14 .
  • the media type determining equation set produced will be selected when all of the sensors in the operational imaging device are functioning properly.
  • a number of additional media type determining equation sets are formed from the normalized training data sets 26 that have been modified to remove data values associated with a faulty sensor.
  • the number of modified additional media type determining equation sets will be S! where S is the number of sensors in the training and operational sensor sets 14 , 52 . For example, if the impedance sensor was determined to be faulty, then the impedance magnitude and phase data values would not be used.
  • the impedance sensor and bending or stiffness sensor were both faulty, then the impedance magnitude and phase data and the stiffness data would not be used. This process will be repeated for all of the combinations of sensors in the training sensor set 14 . As the number of faulty sensors increases, it may still be possible to operate the operational imaging device 50 . However, there will be a point at which the operational imaging device 50 will no longer be able to determine a media type. This may be taken into account as described with the operations given in blocks B 290 , and B 320 -B 350 .
  • the S!+1 media type determining equation sets where the +1 represents the first media type determining equation set having all sensors functioning, are stored in memory 53 of each operational imaging device 50 .
  • an operational sensor set 52 for measuring the values of the set of N variables is provided for each operational imaging device 50 .
  • method 200 selects the first media type determining equation set where all sensor are functioning. Thereafter, at block B 310 , method 200 solves the first media type determining equation set using the measured values for the set of N variables. Method M 200 then proceeds to block B 370 .
  • the faulty sensors outputs are flagged by controller 51 which then proceeds to select, based on the combination of the remaining functioning sensors or on the combination of the malfunctioning sensors in the operational sensor set 52 , the appropriate additional media type determining equation set from the S! media type determining equations sets that have been stored in memory 53 .
  • the confidence level of the selected additional media type determining equation set is checked. The confidence check determines that the appropriate equations are present in firmware 53 .
  • the confidence threshold is not met, i.e., an equation is missing
  • method M 200 declares a fault at block 350 and may issue a service request.
  • method M 200 proceeds to block B 360 , the selected additional media type determining equation set is solved using the normalized values of the set of variables that are measured by the remaining functioning sensors in operational sensor set 52 to determine a media type.
  • the solutions provided by the selected additional media type determining equation set or those provided by the first media type determining equation set are checked to determine whether or not two or more of the equation solutions are within a predetermined range of one another.
  • a determined media type is selected from lookup table (LUT) 59 stored in memory 53 based on the combination of which equations in the additional media type determining equation set are within a predetermined range of one another. For example, say the solutions for equations 1, 2 and 3 in a set of six equations return values within an empirically predetermined range of one another, then based on this combination of equations, a determined media type has been empirically determined using expert knowledge. These empirical determinations of media type are stored in the LUT 59 .
  • an operational parameter of the operational imaging device is chosen.
  • the media sheet to be processed is processed by the operational imaging device using the selected operational parameter.
  • method M 200 ends. After completion the process M 200 may return to block B 290 to recheck for faulty sensors prior to the processing of the next sheet of media.
  • the operations of block B 290 may also be performed periodically, such as, prior to beginning a new media processing job.
  • Example cases using the operational imaging devices 50 which are electrophotographic printers will now be described to illustrate the present method and the high degree of flexibility that may be used when developing and implementing the media type determining equations by use of different variables and sensor sets.
  • the term “A” is a linear offset term in the media type determining equation.
  • the media type determining equation set uses polynomial equation form, the number of terms is a function of the polynomial order and the number of variables, or roughly of the number of sensors in each of the sensor sets 52 - 1 - 52 -K assuming each sensor is measuring a single variable.
  • the polynomial order is one
  • the decision surface is a constant
  • thresholding is used.
  • the order of polynomial equations when used will generally have an order between first and fifth.
  • the number of M media type determining equations in the media type determining equation set 40 would be the M number of media types to be classified.
  • each media type determining equation will be a function of the range normalization as well as the actual design of the hardware in the operational imaging device 50 .
  • Several things about the present system are universal. One of those is that certain sensor term combinations are more important than others in making the media type classification. The number of terms kept in the media type determining equation determines the resolution of the system, but each decreasingly important term makes less of a difference to the media type determination. Another is that while characteristic media properties determine differences between media type, the particular set of sensors chosen will determine which features are used to separate media.
  • the measured values of the set of N values are fed into each media type determining equation.
  • the value and sign of the number calculated determines whether the controller 53 believes the media tested to be of the type measured. Generally, if the sign of the number is positive, then the tested media is classified as “of that type” and if it is negative the media is classified as “not of that type”. If more than one type have a positive sign, the type with the highest positive value is the determined type or as previously discussed the determined type may be found in the LUT 59 .
  • each term is given in the coefficient columns, and the sensor input combination in the equation variable column.
  • the first term X1 is multiplied by polymer coefficient ⁇ 0.026359
  • the second term X2 is multiplied by the coefficient 1.217574 and so on.
  • each term is added to the previous terms. If the coefficients are considered a vector ⁇ , and the terms a vector of X, then the resultant number is the resultant sum of terms which can be written in vector notation as ⁇ T X.
  • media type determining equation set 40 would be generated and solved as previously described.
  • media type determining equation set 40 would have 17 media type determining equations.
  • variations of a given type may be combined if desired.
  • the three plain paper types can be reduced to a single type covering weights of 60-120 g/m 2 or two types plain paper light and plain paper heavier covering weights 75-120 g/m 2 that combines plain paper standard and heavy into one type.
  • Plain paper may also be referred to as office paper or copier paper.
  • Cases 1A-1C provide for media type determination for operational imaging devices 50 used in a typical retail environment.
  • the media set 16 used in a retail environment generally includes three media types—plain office paper—all weights, a polymeric media, such as, outdoor signage or vinyl labels—all thicknesses, and a thicker media such as cardstock—all weights.
  • the training sensor set 14 and each operational sensor set 52 - 1 - 52 -K used for this three member media set varies in each of the cases 1A-1C.
  • Cases 1A-1C illustrate various example combinations of measurements and sensors that may be used to determine the media types in this three member media set. Of course, other sets of sensors may also be used to the same effect.
  • Case 1A uses direct and subsystem response sensors to produce three 3 rd order polynomial equations which form media type determining set 40 .
  • the set of N variables comprises two measured variables-media feed motor current and optical average.
  • the former being provided by a subsystem response sensor (a motor current sensor) and the latter being provided by a direct sensor (optical sensor).
  • Case 1B uses two direct sensors to produce three 1 st order polynomial equations having two measured variables—bending or stiffness and gloss or reflectance.
  • Case 1C uses two direct sensors to produce three fifth order polynomial equations having three variables—impedance magnitude, impedance phase, and acoustic pressure. Based on empirical results, additional sensors may be used but would only increase the cost of the operational imaging devices 50 used in a retail environment without providing any significant increase in more accurately resolving the three media types.
  • Tables 4-6 provide the coefficients for each term in each of the respective media type determining equations sets where one set comprises 3rd order equations, one set comprises first order equations and the last provides fifth order equations. Cases 1A-1C help to illustrate the flexibility of the present system where choice of variables measured and selection of corresponding sensors provides a variety of media type determining equation solution sets to determine a media type within a common set of media.
  • the second, third, fourth, and eighth terms are greater contributors to the solution.
  • a similar trend may also be seen in Tables 5 and 6 (where A is the first term).
  • These larger contributing terms may be empirically determined to be sufficient in determining the three media types and each equation in the media type determining set 40 may be truncated to use only the larger contributing terms. Here that would be terms whose absolute values are about 1 or greater. Other threshold values may be used. Truncation would reduce the memory and processing requirements needed in controller 51 .
  • Case 2 illustrates the use of direct indirect measurement values and subsystem responses values for determining a second media set consisting of polyvinyl labels, cardstock—all weights, plain paper and lightweight media.
  • Light paper is in the range of 60-75 g/m 2 while plain paper is in the range of 75-120 g/m 2 (combines standard and heavy plain paper).
  • the measured variables for this case are: Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Media Feed Motor Current (X3), Optical Average (X4) and Optical Deviation (X5).
  • third order equations comprise the media type determining equation set for this case. Again truncation may be applied if desired.
  • Case 3 represents a media set that would be important to corporate “office” usage: plain paper—all weights, bond paper, cardstock—all weights, polyvinyl labels—all thicknesses, paper labels—all thicknesses, envelopes—all types and transparencies.
  • plain paper all weights
  • bond paper bond paper
  • cardstock all weights
  • polyvinyl labels all thicknesses
  • paper labels all thicknesses
  • envelopes all types and transparencies.
  • Table 8 an example of coefficients for each media type and the corresponding sensor term are given.
  • there is a separate equation for each media type there is a separate equation for each media type. The number of terms is a function of the number of sensors whereas the number of equations is the number of media types to be classified.
  • the variables represent Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Impedance Magnitude (X3), Impedance Phase (X4), Reflectance (X5), Optical transmission Average (X6), and Optical transmission variation (X7). Reflectance sensing was added to increase the resolution of the system.
  • Case 4 illustrates an imaging device which is designed to be useful for a wide variety of tasks.
  • This system will classify the following paper types: plain paper light; plain paper standard; plain paper heavy; cardstock light; cardstock heavier weight—165-300 g/m 2 (combined standard and heavy weight cardstock); glossy paper—all weights; paper labels—all thicknesses; polymer (vinyl) labels—all thicknesses; envelopes—all types; polymer signage; transparencies; and bond paper.
  • the training sensor set includes: Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Impedance Magnitude (X3), Impedance Phase (X4), Reflectance (X5), Media Feed Motor Current (X6), Optical transmission Average (X7), and Optical transmission Variation (X8).
  • Temperature X1
  • Relative Humidity X2
  • Impedance Magnitude X3
  • Impedance Phase X4
  • Reflectance X5
  • Media Feed Motor Current X6
  • Optical transmission Average Optical transmission Variation
  • Case 5 illustrates a further facet of the present system in its ability to empirically provide for unique but measureable characteristics.
  • the media type is one of Current Tray Setting or Not Current Tray Setting.
  • the sensors are: temperature (X1), relative humidity (X2), bending stiffness (X3), impedance magnitude (X4), impedance phase (X5), piezoelectric (X6), gloss (X7), media feed motor current (X8), optical average (X9), and optical deviation (X10).
  • the use of this media type determining equation set is to confirm that the media type present in the tray is actually the media type that the imagining device has been set to expect via a default setting or by user input.
  • Types are not limited to different types of media.
  • a type may be media color, the presence of perforations in the media, the presence of an RFID strip on the media, the presence of a magnetic strip on the media, the presence of holes, preprinted media such as a form, media size.
  • a type can be any distinguishing feature or characteristic provided that there is a corresponding sensor within the sensor sets 14 and 52 to detect these features or characteristics.

Landscapes

  • Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
  • Multimedia (AREA)
  • Signal Processing (AREA)
  • General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
  • Theoretical Computer Science (AREA)
  • Microelectronics & Electronic Packaging (AREA)
  • Mathematical Physics (AREA)
  • Control Or Security For Electrophotography (AREA)

Abstract

An operational imaging device and method for sensing a media type in a predetermined media set using a predetermined set of media type determining equations solved using measured values for a set of N variables measured by an operational sensor set in the operational imaging device. The solution of the equation set determines a media type. After a media type is determined, one or more operational parameters of the imaging device is selected for processing of a sheet of the determined media type. The equation set is generated by a training system using a classifier training engine. A plurality of training data sets containing measured variable values for each media type is collected under various conditions by a training sensor set that measures the set of N variables. After generation, the media type determining equation set is stored in memory of the operational imaging device.

Description

    CROSS REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
  • This patent application is related to the U.S. patent application Ser. No. ______, filed June DAY, 2014, entitled “Imaging Device And Method For Determining Operating Parameters” (docket no. P611-US2) and assigned to the assignee of the present application.
  • STATEMENT REGARDING FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH OR DEVELOPMENT
  • None.
  • REFERENCE TO SEQUENTIAL LISTING, ETC.
  • None.
  • BACKGROUND
  • 1. Field of the Disclosure
  • The present disclosure relates generally to imaging devices, and, more particularly, to those systems and methods for sensing types or classes of media.
  • 2. Description of the Related Art
  • Incorrectly setting media type is a well-documented problem for users of imaging devices, such as electrophotographic printers. Setting media properties correctly is difficult for three primary reasons. First, properly identifying media is a subjective decision. Second, paper setting menus are sometimes difficult to locate and navigate. Third, classification of equivalent media is inconsistent. Additionally, media moisture content and environmental factors may invalidate correctly chosen settings. As a consequence of this, it is common for imaging devices to operate suboptimally.
  • There are consequences to improperly selected media type settings. The imaging device relies upon media type settings to control media handling, transfer, fusing, and finishing operations. Common failures related to improper media type settings include poor print quality, poor fusing, hot or cold offset, paper jams, media damage, component wear, and wrapping of the fuser by the media. This leads to user dissatisfaction.
  • To address this problem, several solutions that incorporate some form of printer control based upon sensed media properties have been developed. Prior art sensor implementations describe devices that measure a single media property, or at most, a few specific properties, such as optical transmission and impedance, to provide limited media identification. Prior art control schemes are limited in scope and are based upon an incomplete characterization of the media. Such prior art systems still rely upon user input and lack a holistic approach. An idealized, fully-featured sensing scheme would take a single, direct measurement of all relevant intrinsic media properties and use this information to model and control the imaging device. However, the number of intrinsic property measurements required to adequately control an imaging device, such as an electrophotographic printer, without user input is prohibitive as this approach is neither cost nor space efficient and requires a large number of sensors. Prior art sensing schemes have been incomplete because they have failed to measure some number intrinsic properties of the media needed to more accurately determine the media type.
  • It would be advantageous to be able to select a minimum set of sensors for an imaging device based on its intended application, such as retail use, office use, or a general purpose device suitable for a wide range of tasks; measure an extrinsic media property in lieu of several independent intrinsic media properties, and, then determine media type without the need for user intervention.
  • SUMMARY
  • Disclosed is a method of media type sensing for use in an operational imaging device such as an electrophotographic printer. The method comprises in one aspect: establishing a media set comprising a plurality of media types M to be used in the operational imaging device; determining a number of variables N needed to determine each media type in the media set; providing a training sensor set for measuring each of the N variables and providing corresponding output signal therefor; using the training sensor set to measure the N variables with a known sample of each media type in the media set and a training imaging device to create a corresponding training data set for each media type in the media set, wherein the measuring includes taking multiple measurements of each of the N variables; inputting each training data set for each media type into a classifier training engine; and generating, using the classifier training engine, a media type determining equation for each media type incorporating corresponding N variable terms to create a set of M media type determining equations for use with an operational set of sensors corresponding to the training set sensors.
  • The method in another aspect, in an operational imaging device, comprises: storing in a memory the set of M media type determining equations; providing an operational sensor set for operable communication with the operational imaging device, the operational sensor set measuring a value of each variable in the set of N variables and providing corresponding output signals for the measured N variables for a sheet of media to be processed; converting the received output signals into the N measured normalized variable values; solving the set of M media type determining equations using the N measured normalized variable values to determine a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed; and, selecting, based upon the determined media type, from a look up table at least one operational parameter for the operational imaging device.
  • The method in another aspect includes the measuring of multiple measurements of each of the N variables by the training sensor set occurs at a plurality of predetermined temperature and relative humidity combinations. The set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: electrical impedance magnitude, electrical impedance phase, contact resistance, capacitance, optical transmission mean, optical transmission deviation, optical spectral reflectance, optical diffuse reflectance, bending stiffness, acoustic transmission, temperature, media size, relative humidity, media feed motor current, fuser temperature, transfer current, transfer voltage, media holes, preprinted areas, media color, multilayer media, RFID signal, magnetic field, MICR, and further wherein the operational sensor set includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
  • BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
  • The above-mentioned and other features and advantages of the disclosed embodiments, and the manner of attaining them, will become more apparent and will be better understood by reference to the following description of the disclosed embodiments in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
  • FIG. 1 is a schematic representation of a training system used with the presently disclosed system and methods.
  • FIG. 2 is an illustration of training data sets.
  • FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of an operational device employing the presently disclosed system and methods.
  • FIGS. 4-5 illustrate two types of operational parameter ranges schemes.
  • FIG. 6 illustrates the use of a matrix of media type determining equation sets to handle faulty sensors.
  • FIG. 7 is a simplified block diagram of the present method of using media type determining equation sets in an operational imaging device to determine a media type.
  • FIGS. 8A-8B are simplified block diagrams of the present method providing for operation in the event of a faulty sensor in an operational imaging device.
  • DETAILED DESCRIPTION
  • It is to be understood that the present disclosure is not limited in its application to the details of construction and the arrangement of components set forth in the following description or illustrated in the drawings. The present disclosure is capable of other embodiments and of being practiced or of being carried out in various ways. Also, it is to be understood that the phraseology and terminology used herein is for the purpose of description and should not be regarded as limiting. The use of “including,” “comprising,” or “having” and variations thereof herein is meant to encompass the items listed thereafter and equivalents thereof as well as additional items. Unless limited otherwise, the terms “connected,” “coupled,” and “mounted,” and variations thereof herein are used broadly and encompass direct and indirect connections, couplings, and mountings. In addition, the terms “connected” and “coupled” and variations thereof are not restricted to physical or mechanical connections or couplings.
  • Spatially relative terms such as “top”, “bottom”, “front”, “back”, “rear”, “side” “under”, “below”, “lower”, “over”, “upper”, and the like, are used for ease of description to explain the positioning of one element relative to a second element. These terms are intended to encompass different orientations of the device in addition to different orientations than those depicted in the figures. Further, terms such as “first”, “second”, and the like, are also used to describe various elements, regions, sections, etc. and are also not intended to be limiting. Like terms refer to like elements throughout the description.
  • As used herein, the terms “having”, “containing”, “including”, “comprising”, and the like are open ended terms that indicate the presence of stated elements or features, but do not preclude additional elements or features. The articles “a”, “an” and “the” are intended to include the plural as well as the singular, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise.
  • In addition, it should be understood that embodiments of the present disclosure include both hardware and electronic components or modules that, for purposes of discussion, may be illustrated and described as if the majority of the components were implemented solely in hardware. However, one of ordinary skill in the art, and based on a reading of this detailed description, would recognize that, in at least one embodiment, the electronic based aspects of the invention may be implemented in software. As such, it should be noted that a plurality of hardware and software-based devices, as well as a plurality of different structural components may be utilized to implement the invention. Furthermore, and as described in subsequent paragraphs, the specific mechanical configurations illustrated in the drawings are intended to exemplify embodiments of the present disclosure and that other alternative mechanical configurations are possible.
  • It will be further understood that each block of the diagrams, and combinations of blocks in the diagrams, respectively, may be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions may be loaded onto a general purpose computer, special purpose computer, or other programmable data processing apparatus to produce a machine, such that the instructions which execute on the computer or other programmable data processing apparatus may create means for implementing the functionality of each block or combinations of blocks in the diagrams discussed in detail in the descriptions below.
  • These computer program instructions may also be stored in a non-transitory, tangible, computer readable storage medium that may direct a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to function in a particular manner, such that the instructions stored in the computer readable storage medium may produce an article of manufacture including an instruction means that implements the function specified in the block or blocks. Computer readable storage medium includes, for example, disks, CD-ROMS, Flash ROMS, nonvolatile ROM and RAM. The computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing apparatus to cause a series of operational steps to be performed on the computer or other programmable apparatus to produce a computer implemented process such that the instructions that execute on the computer or other programmable apparatus implement the functions specified in the block or blocks. Output of the computer program instructions, such as the process models and the combined process models, as will be described in greater detail below, may be displayed in a user interface or computer display of the computer or other programmable apparatus that implements the functions or the computer program instructions.
  • The term “image” as used herein encompasses any printed or digital form of text, graphic, or combination thereof. The term “output” as used herein encompasses output from any printing device such as color and black-and-white copiers, color and black-and-white printers, and multifunction devices that incorporate multiple functions such as scanning, copying, and printing capabilities in one device. Such printing devices may utilize ink jet, dot matrix, dye sublimation, laser, and any other suitable print formats. The term button as used herein means any component, whether a physical component or graphic user interface icon, that is engaged to initiate an action or event.
  • Referring now to FIG. 1, a schematic representation of a training system 10 used with present media type sensing system is illustrated. Included in training system 10 is a trainer 12 that provides firmware that will be incorporated into one or more operational imaging devices, generally indicated 50, operational imaging devices 50-1 through 50-K as shown. Also included in training system 10 is a training sensor set 14, a training media set 16 comprised of M different media types, 16-1-16-M, a robot 18, a training imaging device 22, and imaging device subsystems 24. A robot 18 or robotic job processor 18 is simply a machine designed to perform a function of an operational imaging device 50. For example, where the operational imaging device 50 is an electrophotographic printer, training system 10 may use a fuser robot that performs fusing, a transfer station robot that performs toned image transfer to a media sheet, or a media feed robot that emulates feeding media sheets. Training sensor set 14 is used to measure N different variables related to each media type in the training media set 16 or related to the traning imaging device 22 or its subsystems 24 to form training data sets for each media type. The training imaging device 24 would be an imaging device that is substantially the same as an operational imaging device 50 that would be used by a customer. However, the training imaging device 22 would be used in a laboratory or test enclosure so that environmental conditions could be controlled when making measurements as described herein.
  • A training sensor set 14, consisting of a predetermined collection of sensors, provides data measurement points to trainer 12. The types and number of sensors used will be described below and will vary dependent upon the media types included in training media set 16, the ambient conditions 20 to be measured, the type of robots 18 and training imaging device 22 used, and functional requirements and customer requirements for the operational imaging devices 50. The training sensor set 14 is used in conjunction with the training media set 16, comprised of samples of M different media types and provides multiple data points for each variable in a predetermined set of N variables. Possibly included in the set of N variables that training sensor set 14 measures, as illustrated by the reflecting arrows, are those relevant to each media type M in the media set 16; ambient conditions, indicated by cloud 20, such as temperature and relative humidity where the training media set 16 is located, and variables relevant to the operational imaging device 50 such as electrical, thermal and mechanical properties measured using the robots 18 or training imaging device 22. An operational imaging device designer chooses variables that will provide a resolution sufficient to determine each media type M within the training media set 16. The chosen variables N relevant to the distinguishing the media types in the training media set 16 are empirically determined and verified. For a given family of operational imaging devices 50, the chosen N variables to be measured using subsystems equivalent to subsystems common to each member of a given family of operational imaging devices 50. These subsystems may be provided in a training imaging device 22 or may be individually provided subsystems, generally indicated 24, such a transfer station 24-1, fuser 24-2 or media feed system 24-3, etc. It will be noted that each media type M is tested with each robot 18, the training imaging device 22, if present, or subsystems 24 at several different ambient conditions and measurements are also taken at a plurality of locations within the borders of the media sheet. The use of robots 18 and/or subsystems 24 may obviate the need to use a training imaging device 22.
  • Training sensor set 14 comprises direct sensors 14-1, indirect sensors 14-2 and subsystem response sensors 14-3 for one or more subsystems that will be present within the operational imaging device 50. Such subsystems include a fuser, a toner transfer station, a media feed system, and a finisher, which may also be termed a processing device.
  • Direct sensor measurements are of a characteristic of the media. These direct measurements include, but are not limited to, optical, electrical impedance, reflectance, thermal capacitance, etc. A more extensive list of direct sensor measurements that may be used with the present system 10 and operational imaging devices 50-1-50-K is provided in Table 3 below.
  • Indirect measurements include, but are not limited to, temperature, relative humidity, and/or the desired machine state, e.g., process speed. When such indirect measurements are made, each media type in the media set and each imaging device subsystem are measured at the desired indirect measurement points. For example, when temperature and relative humidity are being measured, each media type in the training media set 16 and each imaging device subsystem 24 are measured at several different temperature and humidity points, such as, for example, 22° C. at 50% relative humidity, 25.6° C. at 80% relative humidity, and 15° C. at 8% relative humidity. These temperature and humidity points are environments in which operational imaging devices 50 may be placed. Multiple samples of each media type are measured in these different environments to generate the training data set 26. Other temperature and humidity conditions may also be measured.
  • Subsystem response measurements include change of fuser temperature occurring for each media type in the training media set 16 as they are fed through the fuser, change in transfer nip voltage or current occurring for each media type as they are fed through the transfer nip of the transfer station, media feed motor current for each media type as they are fed through the media path, and/or media location within the media path. Again these measurements may be taken at several different temperatures and relative humidity values and are included in the training data set 26.
  • A single sensor in the training sensor set 14 may provide data for two or more variables in the set of N variables. For example, an impedance sensor may provide both magnitude and phase data points. The output of each sensor in the training sensor set 14 may be conditioned and normalized by trainer 12 so that M data training sets 26 contain normalized data points. This helps to improve performance of training system 10.
  • The data for the N variables for each media type M in the training media set 16 is collected in a data set, generally designated 26, for each media type M, training data sets 26-1 through 26-M as shown. For data in the training data sets 26 the media type or class to which that data belongs is known. For example, should training media set 16 have three media types 16-1-16-3, three data sets 26-1-26-3 would be collected. It will be appreciated that the number of data points within each data set 26 will number in the thousands. In general, as the media types M to be sensed in operational imaging devices 50 increases in number, the number of variables N measured increases so that each media type M may be determined. The measurements taken for the training data sets 26 may also account for sensor aging, sensor variability, media variability, imaging device subsystem variability to achieve a robust set of media type determining equations flexible enough to handle variability in the operational sensor set 52, in the media types and the operational imaging devices 50. Further, multiple instances of the same sensor and multiple instances of the same type of media sheet may be used when populating the training data sets 26.
  • As used herein, the N variables in each data set 26 for each media type M includes the variables types previously described such as temperature, relative humidity and corresponding imaging device variables, all as selected for inclusion in the predetermined set of N variables. FIG. 2 illustrates a 4×4 matrix of three data sets 26-1-26-3 for three media types—polyvinyl M1, cardstock M2 and plain paper M3. Note that the data in FIG. 2 has not been normalized. The data points for polyvinyl M1 are indicated by a star, those for cardstock M2 by a triangle, and those for plain media M3 by a cross. For the data sets 26-1-26-3, the four variables chosen by the imaging device designer to be measured are bending N1 in Watts, impedance magnitude N2 in ohms, impedance phase N3 in degrees and reflectance or gloss N4 in Volts. Clustering of the data points for each of the media types M1-M3 can readily be seen. These three data sets 26-1-26-3 would be processed by trainer 12 to produce a media type determining equation set 40 having three media type determining equations.
  • For the purposes of developing a media type determining equation that can successfully classify media type given the different variable input magnitudes, the measured sensor values are normalized prior to training. This is because units of Ohms have no physical comparison to units of optical transmission, degrees of temperature, or percent relative humidity, etc. The goal is to compare how the media is changing with respect to its physical properties and by normalizing the inputs to the same order of magnitude this can be more easily achieved. Before training, these input values are normalized such that the magnitudes of each of the inputs are roughly equivalent over the range expected by the operational imaging devices 50, the media types expected to be used, expected environments of use, and one or more desired machine states, for example, 40 page per minute (ppm) process speed or 70 ppm process speed. The measured values provided by the operational sensor sets 52 would also be normalized prior to controllers 51 solving the media type determining equations sets 40.
  • The M data sets 26 of N variables each are fed into a classifier training engine 30. Using the M data sets 26, classifier training engine 30 produces as an output a media type determining equation set 40 containing M media type determining equations, where M is the number of media types and N is the number of variables. It should be understood that the number of variables N does not have to equal the number of media types M. The media type determining equation set 40 will be replicated, 40-1 through 40-K as shown, and installed into each corresponding operational imaging device 50-1-50-K.
  • Classifier training engine 30 uses a supervised machine learning algorithm used to map inputs (sensed media variables or properties like bending stiffness, electrical impedance, acoustic transmittance, optical reflectance, etc.) to a media type or class. In supervised learning, for a given input data set, the correct output is known. For data in the training data sets 26 the media type or class to which that data belongs is known. With a classifier training engine 30, results are predicted in a discrete output and input variables are mapped to discrete classes or type—here discrete media types. Once the media type determining equations are formed, these equations, when placed in the operational imaging devices 50, take measured variable values from the operational sensor set 52 as inputs and use them to determine the best class (i.e. media type). The measured variable values are also termed instances. Classification into one of the several media types may be done by multiclass classification or by combining multiple binary classifiers that deal with only two classes at a time. A classification scheme is advantageous since programs in many existing imaging device controllers are based upon a discrete categorization of media into type, weight, and roughness.
  • Classifier training engine 30 may be one of well known classification engines as known in the art that analyze data and recognize patterns for classification. These include a support vector engine 30-1, a neural network 30-2, a quadratic classifier 30-3, a Bayesian network 30-4, or a learning vector quantizer 30-5. Classifier training engine 30 operates on the data sets 26-1-26-M to produce the multi-variable media type determining equation set 40. The media type determining equation set 40 may be constructed many different ways. In one embodiment (created using regression techniques), it resembles a higher order multivariable polynomial. In another embodiment (created using neural networks), it resembles two theta matrices. The form of the media type determining equation will be determined by the type of classifier training engine used in trainer 12. Note that, once determined, the media type determining equation may be manipulated to take any convenient mathematical form.
  • Two optional elements are shown in FIG. 1. These are a polynomial consolidator 32 and expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34. Where the equation set 40 comprises polynomial equations, an optional polynomial consolidator 32 may also be provided to operate on each of the M equations in the set of media determining equations 40 to reduce the number of terms in each equation M. Using a polynomial consolidator 32 reduces the number of terms in each polynomial equation in the media type determining media set 40, and, in turn, the memory and processing power needed by controllers 53 in operational imagining devices 50.
  • An example implementation of polynomial consolidator 32 will now be described. The following nomenclature is a representative notation for when classifier training engine 30 is a support vector machine, which include examples such as Least-Squares Support Vector Machines (LS-SVM) and Fast Support Vector Machines (FSVM) and many others. For the purposes of this illustration of the polynomial consolidator 32 for use in embedded classification systems to be employed in operational imaging devices 50, a LS-SVM is shown the illustrated implementation where:
  • p: number of variables;
  • x: current set of measurements to be classified, a vector of length p;
  • mk: measurement vector from the training data set, with length p, associated with the kth training data point;
  • αk: weight associated with the kth training data point;
  • yk: true classification (usually coded +1 or −1, but could be another form) associated of the kth training data point;
  • b: linear bias offset term; and
  • N: number of training data points.
  • The method of arriving at these quantities is as follows: generally, the set of N vectors mk, k=1, . . . , N and their corresponding true classifications yk are arrived at through experimentation or other means of creating example data points that characterize the categories, i.e., the media types, that are to be used in the classification. For example, if one were trying to distinguish a class A and a class B, one might measure the characteristics of examples from class A, and also measure the characteristics of examples from class B. For each example, the characteristic features, or measurements, are aggregated in a corresponding vector mk. N would then be the sum of the number of examples from class A and class B. The weights αk are arrived at through a training process, which differs somewhat for different classification algorithms, and, for the purposes of polynomial consolidation, the method by which they are attained is not important.
  • The resulting classification function, C(x), may also depend to some degree on the particular classification algorithm. The polynomial consolidation methodology applies to any classification function that one might apply in this manner as long as it is continuous on a bounded interval of interest. By the Weierstrass approximation theorem, it is well known that any function that meets this criteria can be arbitrarily closely approximated by a polynomial function. For example, many implementations of neural network classifiers utilize continuous functions such as the sigmoid function or alternatively the hyperbolic tangent as a key component.
  • In the LS-SVM with a polynomial kernel implementation the classification function is set for in Eq. 1:

  • C(x)=sign[Σ i=1 Nαk y k(m k T x+b)d]  Eq. 1
  • In this form, d is an integer that provides the degree of the polynomial, and the other terms are as described previously. This form of classifier can have very high performance depending on the characteristics of the system in which it is operating. However, the level of performance increases as the value of N increases. If the performance desired is obtained only after using N=1000 or more examples, then in order to compute C(x), 1000 sums must be performed. In addition, the values of αk, yk, b and mk must be stored in memory in order to compute the classification function.
  • For embedded systems the computational complexity and memory requirement is a significant disadvantage and in many implementations could force the addition of significant cost to a product in order to incorporate the computational power and memory needed to accommodate the classification function. Polynomial consolidation addresses this problem of computational complexity and memory footprint. Instead of evaluating potentially thousands of terms, the function can be represented by a polynomial.
  • Certainly, each of the N terms would contribute a different function. In the case of the polynomial form mentioned above, in a LS-SVM classifier training engine 30, each of the N terms would contribute a term as shown in Eq. 2:

  • αk y k(m k T x+b)d  Eq. 2
  • Considering the transposed vector multiplied by another vector is an inner product and assuming the components of mk are [ak, bk, ck, . . . ]T the result is the expression shown in Eq. 3:

  • αk y kk x 1 +b k x 2 +c k x 3 +d k x 4 . . . +b)d  Eq. 3
  • This can be expanded via the multinomial theorem's formula, shown in Eq. 4:
  • ( s 1 + s 2 + + s q ) d = k 1 + k 2 + + k q = d ( d k 1 , k 2 , , k q ) 1 j q x j k j where ( d k 1 , k 2 , , k q ) = n ! k 1 ! k 2 ! k q ! , Eq . 4
  • a binomial coefficient
  • Once terms are expanded out for each data point, the result is a list of multivariate polynomials where the coefficients are related to αk, yk, b, d and mk, and the variables are the features or measurements of the data point to be classified, namely x1, x2, . . . , xp, with the number of multivariate polynomials being the number of data points used in the classification (the support vectors).
  • As an example, consider a system with a second order polynomial classifier where there is one sensor, whose value to be classified is x, and three data points m1, m2, m3 that were used to train the classifier. Since it has already been trained, we also have the corresponding weights α1, α2, α3, corresponding true values y1, y2, y3, and corresponding offset number T. The classifier would then have the form shown in Eq. 5:

  • y=sign [α 1 y 1(m 1 x+τ)22 y 2(m 2 x+τ)23 y 3(m 3 x+τ)2]  Eq. 5
  • If we consider the portion within the brackets Eq. 6 results:

  • α1 y 1(m 1 x+τ)22 y 2(m 2 x+τ)23 y 3(m 3 x+τ)21 y 1(m 1 2 x 2+2m 1 τX+τ 2)+α2 y 2(m 2 2 x 2+2m 2 τx+τ 2)+α3 y 3(m 3 2 x 2+2m 3 τX+τ 2)  Eq.6
  • Due to the multinomial theorem as discussed above, we can then collect like terms in x, resulting in an expression of the form c1x2+c2x+c3. In this case, c11y1m1 22y2m2 23y3m3 2, and similarly the terms can be collected to develop expressions for c2 and c3 and any other constants for the expression.
  • In this example, in the final product implementation only c1, c2, and c3 need to be stored in order to classify the new data point, and the savings in both memory footprint and computational complexity are significant, decreasing the potential cost of implementing the classification system in operational imaging device 50. While this becomes a complicated process for more training data points and more variables, the method illustrated is a framework for solving the problem, which can be automated using computer algebra systems.
  • The expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 may be employed to adjust the weighting of the coefficients in the M media type determining equation set 40. In trainer 12, generally a cost/value function that is being optimized—that is, starting with some initial “guess” of the best weightings for the function, a cost function is evaluated and properties that are uncovered during this evaluation are used to refine the “guesses” of the weight values until an optimal classifier training engine for that form is found. Generally, the cost/value function lends itself well to optimization, and properties such as convexity of the cost function are very desirable as it leads to a well-studied set of optimization solution methodologies. In some instances some “allowable” confusion between categories (i.e. media types) may exist, depending on certain conditions. These conditions could be based on areas or ranges of features, or any other sensor or condition for which an expert may have intrinsic knowledge. This may also be referred to as expert knowledge. When an error between two categories is allowable (i.e., a particular type of mistake made may not invalidate the results of the multiclass classification) then the idea is not to penalize that error as harshly. Extending this further, if under different conditions, the importance of correctness differs, then penalties can be adjusted accordingly. This may be implemented using an expert weighting term ck (q) that comes from an expert weighting matrix, Cq, which codifies the expert knowledge and is specific to the ith classifier.
  • An example of expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 for a simplified media set will now be described. The set of q weighting matrices, as an example with media types A, B, and C, might look like the form (the value in the table is what ck (q) would be):
  • For q=1
  • TABLE 1
    Matrix 1
    A B C
    A
    1 0.1 0.5
    B 0.1 1 1
    C 0.5 1 1
  • For q=2
  • TABLE 2
    Matrix 2
    A B C
    A
    1 1 0.1
    B 1 1 1
    C 0.1 1 1
  • There will be a matrix for each q until q=N, with N being the total number of variables. Rows indicate the current classifier, and columns correspond to the true class of a given training data point. In this case, for variable 1 (when q=1,) it is acceptable to confuse A and B, so if we are looking at point k from the perspective of the classifier for media types A or B, the corresponding ck (1)=ck (2)=0.1. Similarly, it is less acceptable to confuse media types A and C, so for either of those classifiers, the corresponding classifier will weight that error with ck (1)=ck (3)=0.5. For an error that is unacceptable it can be weighted as ck (q)=1 or even higher. It is only the relative values of these terms that matter, so it is general practice to normalize all of them to 1. Condition 2 (when q=2) has A and C with acceptable confusion, so that is codified ck (1)=ck (3)=0.1 but the rest of the cases are deemed unacceptable. The number of different weights is only limited by designer choice, and could also be a continuous or discontinuous function of the variable. The example here is a simple one to make illustration clear.
  • Other forms of a polynomial consolidator 32 may be employed, and the form of polynomial consolidator used should not be considered a limitation of the presently disclosed method. Also other forms of an expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 may be employed, and the form of the expert knowledge cost/value weighter 34 used should not be considered a limitation of the presently disclosed method.
  • As part of the training process, a test data set may be used to validate media type determining equation set 40. This is done by separating the entire training data sets 26-1-26-M into two subsets. A training data set comprising about ⅔ of the entire data sets 26-1-26-M is randomly selected and is used to develop the media type determining equations. A test data set comprising the remaining ⅓ of the entire data sets 26-1-26-M is used to empirically evaluate the media type determining equations generated from the ⅔ training data set. This validation technique is well known to one of skill in the art.
  • Media type determining equation set 40 is replicated, indicated as 40-1-40-K, in firmware, generally indicated 53, to be used in each of the operational imaging devices 50. As shown, media type determining equation sets 40-1-40-K are provided in firmware 53-1-53-K of operational devices 50-1 through 50-K, respectively. A single media type determining equation is produced for each type of media M in the training media set 16 so that there are M number of equations in the media type determining equation set 40.
  • As the number of variables N increases, the complexity and number of terms in each media type determining equation increases. Each media type determining equation is comprised of multiple terms with corresponding constant coefficients for each variable of the N variables. However, where the media type determining equations are polynomial equations, by use of polynomial consolidation techniques such as the one discussed previously, the number of terms and coefficients needed in these equations may be reduced and these consolidated equations form media determining equation sets 40-1-40-K used by each controller 51-1-51-K to determine media type. Consolidated equations mean a more rapid determination of media type providing real time response in each operational imaging device 50-1-50-K to changing media types being processed. As is known in the art, the media type determining equations may be represented in any convenient mathematical manner that closely approximates the solution, for example a Taylor polynomial. In one form classifier training engine 30 produces a function, comprised of the M media type determining higher order polynomial equations comprising the media type determining equation sets 40-1-40-K, that will be used in each operational imaging device 50-1-50-K to be used for a given application. Variable measurement values taken by the operational sensor set 52-1-52-K in each operational imaging device 50-1-50-K are then input to the function (i.e., the M media type determining equations) to determine the type of media sensed.
  • Using training system 10 to develop the coefficient matrix for each of the M media type determining equations in the media type determining equation set 40 to control the imaging device 50 easily allows for the inclusion of additional sensors. Training system 10 therefore allows for expansion and/or changes of the selected variables N that may be needed with other imaging products to work optimally. Training system 10 is easily expandable and adaptable to future imaging devices and future media types.
  • Operational imaging devices 50 are those that would be provided to users for a specific application, such as a retail application, an office application, or a general purpose application, etc. Operational imaging devices 50-1-50-K would be distributed to different locations for use by various end users. Operational imaging devices 50-1-50-K would have the same processing devices, e.g., the same fuser types, transfer stations, media feed systems and firmware. Should the processing device hardware or the customer requirements change, then the media type determining equation set 40 would have to be redetermined for the new hardware configuration. Operational devices 50-1-50-K include controllers 51-1-51-K and an operational sensor set 52-1-52-K. Media sheets 60-1-60-K are readied to be processed by their corresponding operational imaging devices 50-1-50-K. Operational sensor sets 52-1-52-K measure the values of the same N variables that were used in the set of N variables that were measured by the training sensor set 14 and provide those measured data values to controllers 51-1-51-K. The individual sensors in each of operational sensor sets 52-1-52-K may be the same as or similar to those used in training sensor set 14. Controllers 51-1-51-K utilize the measured N variable values provided by the operational sensor sets 52-1-52-K to solve the media type determining equation sets 40-1-40-K stored in firmware 53-1-53-K to determine a media type. For example, in operational imaging device 50-1, operational sensor set 52-1 provides measured values for the set of N variables as a sheet of media 60-1 is readied for processing. Controller 51-1 uses the measured N variable values to solve the media type determining equation set 40-1, to produce a determined media type 54-1 which is the highest valued media type determining equation solution found using the variable values measured by operational sensor set 52-1.
  • Using the determined media type 54-1, controller 51-1 then utilizes lookup table 55-1 to select a one or more operational parameters 56-1 to be used by operational imaging device 50-1 or a subsystem therein to process the readied media sheet 60-1 to produce a processed media sheet 61-1. A similar process would be occurring in each of operational imaging devices 50-2-50-K to create processed sheets 61-2-61-K. However, the operational parameter or parameters selected in those operational imaging devices 50-2-50-K will depend on which media type was the determined media type sheets 60-2-60-K.
  • During training, the extrinsic properties to be measured are selected to closely relate to operational imaging device 50 functions. This increases success in sensing media types and reduces the number of required sensors. Where the operational imaging device 50 is an electrophotographic printer, media interacts with three major printer subsystems: media handling, toner transfer, and fusing. It follows that sensed variables or characteristics may be closely related to the fundamental operation of these subsystems. The present media type determining method may also use as a variable one or more of the following variables or characteristics: lumped electrical time response (toner transfer), lumped thermal time response (fusing), mechanical composition (media handling), and other characteristics (e.g., size, temperature, relative humidity).
  • At a transfer station, an electric field is generated to move charged toner particles from a donor substrate to the media. Electrical characteristics of the media dictate how quickly the electric field will build and what the field strength will be for an applied voltage. Functionally, it is important to know the time response of media to a given voltage input. Appropriate intrinsic measurements for lumped electrical time response may include one or more of a volumetric measure of impedance (magnitude and phase angle), electrical time constant (resistance and capacitance), or some other similar metric.
  • In the fuser, temperature and pressure are applied to transfer heat to the media, melt toner, and affix it to the media. The lumped thermal characteristics of the media dictate how quickly heat will transfer into the sheet and how much heat must be transferred to adequately melt toner. Appropriate intrinsic measurements may include a bulk measurement of thermal mass (mass and specific heat), thermal time constant (heat transfer coefficient, specific heat, density, and thickness), thermal diffusivity (density, specific heat, and thermal conductivity), or some other similar metric.
  • Within the operational imaging device 50, media is conveyed through the system via driven rollers. Mechanical characteristics of the media dictate how much drag the media generates in the media path and how much torque the system must provide to transport the media. Appropriate intrinsic measurements might include bending stiffness (elastic modulus and area moment of inertia), coefficient of friction, or some other similar metric.
  • Media acclimation (temperature and relative humidity) and the desired machine state (process speed) may also affect each of these three media characteristics. For example at high ambient temperature and relative humidity one media type containing more moisture than at standard temperature and relative humidity conditions, may be better processed using settings for another media type.
  • An understanding of these three media characteristics (lumped electrical time response, lumped thermal time response, and mechanical composition) is necessary to sufficiently control print processes. If sensors are chosen to closely map to functionally-relevant extrinsic properties that relate to printer function, adding additional sensors to measure additional characteristics only slightly increases performance of the system. Other measurements that loosely correlate to these intrinsic properties may also be of value. An example would be the imaging device subsystem responses.
  • Media properties may be sensed using a wide variety of possible measurement techniques. Using the fundamental media characteristics just discussed as a guidepost helps limit the set of possibilities. Additionally, the measurement technique or sensing methods would be safe, unobtrusive, compact, energy efficient, inexpensive, and sample rapidly. Measurements should avoid containing redundant information. The sensing methods should be sufficiently independent or be decoupled from one another. This general design guideline provides the classifier training engine 30 with better performance and reduces the number of required sensors and/or measured variables N.
  • The following describes a variety of sensor types that may be used to make the measurements for the selected variables in the set of N variables. Sensors include those that measure electrical impedance, bending stiffness, optical reflectance, optical transmission, and acoustic transmission. The following extrinsic measurement techniques were selected because they enable the system 10 and operational imaging devices 50 to take measurements that closely correlate to the fundamental media properties listed above.
  • Impedance phase angle and magnitude are derived from media response to an AC voltage applied across the thickness of the sheet while it is staged in a pair of metal rollers. From this, media resistance or capacitance may be calculated. In one embodiment, a 10 KHz wave of 1 volt was sufficient excitation for characterization. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped electrical time response (electrical impedance or resistance and capacitance).
  • Media bending stiffness is measured as a function of a sheet resistance to deformation. The motor current (torque) required to drive a bar that bends a staged sheet is measured. This torque directly correlates to the media modulus of elasticity and area moment of inertia. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to mechanical composition (bending stiffness). An example of a media stiffness sensor may be found in copending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/145,601, entitled “Media Stiffness Sensor Assembly For An Imaging Device,” and Ser. No. 14/145,661, entitled “Method Of Using An Imaging Device Having A Media Stiffness Sensor Assembly” both filed Dec. 31, 2013.
  • A pair of photodiodes is used to measure the ratio of specular and diffuse light emitted by an LED and reflected off the surface of a media sheet. The ratio serves as a relative measure of roughness. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to mechanical composition (coefficient of friction) and loosely correlates to lumped electrical time response and lumped thermal time response (contact resistance).
  • An acoustic wave is generated using a piezoelectric transducer or a speaker. The energy content in the wave is dampened as it propagates through the media sheet. The amount of transmitted acoustic energy correlates to the mass of the system. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped thermal time response (thermal mass).
  • An optical transmission sensor measures an amount of light transmitted through a media sheet. The optical transmittance sensor is an infrared LED and a photodetector pair. The infrared LED emits light on one side of the sheet. The photodetector is positioned on the other side of the sheet and measures the quantity of light that is transmitted through the sheet. Several measurements are taken as the sheet is moved by the sensor and an optical average and optical standard deviation are calculated. The transmitted energy is a function of the opacity of the media sheet which correlates to thickness or mass of the media sheet. This sensor provides an output that closely correlates to lumped thermal time response (thermal mass).
  • A purpose of the present media sensing system is to use the minimal number of independent extrinsic measurements necessary to develop the media type determining equation set 40 capable of training an operational imaging device 50 that meets the user application. Applications which use limited sets of known media types or that can accept misclassifications of media types without a significant negative impact can be successfully controlled with fewer sensors. Alternatively, additional measurements and/or sensors may be added to improve accuracy and robustness. Table 3 provides example operational sensor sets that would meet several different levels of performance requirements.
  • TABLE 3
    Operational Sensor Sets Of Varying Cost And Complexity
    Sensor Set 1: Sensor Set 2 Sensor Set 3
    Media High Intermediate Low
    Property Resolution Resolution Resolution
    Lumped Thermal Diffusivity Acoustic N/A
    Thermal Acoustic Transmission Transmission
    Time Microwave
    Response Transmission
    Heat Capacity
    Lumped Impedance Phase Impedance Phase Impedance
    Electrical Impedance Magnitude Impedance Magnitude
    Time Resistance Magnitude
    Response Capacitance
    Contact resistance
    Dielectric constant
    Mechanical Bending Stiffness Optical Optical
    Composition Thickness Transmission Transmission
    Acoustic Absorption Mean Mean
    X-Ray Optical Optical
    Optical Transmission Transmission Transmission
    Mean Deviation Deviation
    Optical Transmission Optical
    Deviation Spectral
    Optical Spectral Reflectance
    Reflectance
    Optical Diffuse
    Reflectance
    Image Capture/Process
    Laser Profilometry
    Other Temperature Temperature N/A
    Variables Relative Humidity Relative
    Media Size Humidity
    Transfer Current Media Feed Motor
    Transfer Voltage Current
    Fuser Temperature
    Media Feed Motor
    Current
    RFID
    Magnetic Field
    Media Holes
    MICR
    Preprinted Areas
    Media Color
    Multilayer Media
  • Table 3 outlines several sensor sets that provide varying degrees of functionality and, in turn, resolution to discern various media types. It should be noted that optical transmission and optical transmision variation may also be listed as being lumped thermal response variables in that media thickness affects both thermal properties and mechanical properties. Optical transmission may also be referred to as optical transmission. For example, sensor set 3 would result in the ability to classify plain paper, cardstock, and polyvinyl labels at ambient environmental conditions. A more fully-featured control scheme may incorporate impedance phase, optical spectral reflectance, media feed motor current, and acoustic transmission sensors in addition to a temperature and humidity sensor (sensor set 2). Sensor set 2 would provide the ability to additionally discern light weight, heavy weight, glossy, and bond paper across class B environmental conditions. Sensor set 1 may, for example, be used to distinguish media having holes or perforations, media having preprinted portions, multiweb media, media having magnetic ink or RFID tags, light cardstock, cardstock, heavy cardstock, paper labels, heavy paper labels, vinyl labels, heavy vinyl labels, transparencies, light glossy media, glossy media, heavy glossy media, rough/cotton media, envelopes, heavy envelopes, and polymeric film.
  • Use of the image capture, for example, would provide some of the additional capabilities such as recognizing media having holes or preprinted portions. Optical sensors may be used to detect holes. Image capture may be done by use of charge coupled imaging device. Magnetic field may be detected by use of a Hall effect sensor. An RFID reader may be used to sense RFID tags.
  • Referring now to FIG. 3, there is shown a diagrammatic depiction of an example operational imaging device 50-K. Controller 51-K is operatively coupled to operational sensor set 52-K having a plurality of output signals provided to controller 51-K via communication link 100. In one form, operational sensor set 52-K consists of a base sensor set 52-K1 consisting of temperature, relative humidity, impedance and optical transmission sensors S1-S4, respectively, and additional sensor set elements consisting of reflectance, media feed motor current, media stiffness sensors S5-S7, respectively, through sensor SX where sensor SX is any additional sensor selected by the designer. The composition of the base sensor set 52-K1 is a matter of design choice and the intended application of operational imaging device 50-K. For example, another base sensor set may be comprised of sensors S3-S7. The types of sensors in the base sensor set 52K-1 and the additional sensor set elements are meant only to be illustrative, and are not intended to be limited to only those sensors shown. Because one sensor may provide data values for two or more of the variables in the set of N variables, the number of sensors SX may be less than the number of variables N that are measured.
  • The N signal outputs, designated NSO, from operational sensor set 52-K are provided to controller 51-K via communications link 100. The NSO are measured values of each variable in the set of N variables. As shown, NSO are provided to signal conditioning circuit 51-K1 and signal normalization circuit 51-K2 for conditioning and range normalization to produce an input set of N measured variable values 51-K3. Note that signal conditioning and normalization steps may also be performed by firmware. At firmware 53-K, the set of N measured inputs variables are processed by controller 51-K to solve media type determining equation set 40-K to produce a determined media type 54-K. Using determined media type 54K as a selector for lookup tables 55-K, one or more operational parameters 56-K are selected by processor 51K. As shown, lookup tables 55-K1 through 55-KP are provided to select operational parameters 56-K1-56-KP. The number and type of operational parameters 56-K1-56-KP selected are a matter of design choice and the set of N measured input variable values 51-K3. Using communication link 100, the operational parameters 56-K1-56-KP are provided to processing device PDK.
  • The media sheet 60-K which is to be processed is provided to processing device PDK which produces processed media sheet 61-K. Media sheet 60-K may be media to be printed 60-K1 or images to be scanned 60-K2. Processing device PDK may, in one form, be a printer or print engine PDK1 or, in another form, a scanner system PDK2. Printer PDK1 may be an electrophotographic printer or an ink jet printer or other printer types as known in the art. Printer PDK1 is illustrated as an electrophotographic printer having a fuser F, a toner transfer station TTS, a finisher unit FU providing hole punching and stapling, and media feed system MFS. Scanner system PDK2 is illustrated as having a media feed system SMFS, an automatic document feeder ADF, a scan bar SB1, and a flatbed scan bar SB2. Where automatic document feeding or duplex scanning are not needed, the ADF and scan bar SB1 are not used. When processing device PDK is printer PDK1, operational parameters 56-K may be provided, for example, to fuser F, toner transfer station TTS, finisher unit FU, and media feed system MFS of printer device PDK1. When processing device PDK is scanner PDK2, operational parameters 56-K may be provided, for example, to media feed system SMFS, ADF scan bar SB1 and flatbed scan bar SB2.
  • As used herein, the term “communications link” is used to generally refer to structure that facilitates electronic communication between multiple components, and may operate using wired or wireless technology. Controller 51-K includes a processor unit and associated memory 57-K, and may be formed as one or more Application Specific Integrated Circuits (ASIC). Memory 57-K may be, for example, random access memory (RAM), read only memory (ROM), and/or non-volatile RAM (NVRAM). Alternatively, memory 57-K may be in the form of a separate electronic memory (e.g., RAM, ROM, and/or NVRAM), a hard drive, a CD or DVD drive, or any memory device convenient for use with controller 51-K. Firmware 53-K may reside in memory 57-K. Controller 51-K may be, for example, a combined printer and scanner controller.
  • Also illustrated in FIG. 3 is an alternative approach to determining media type. When the media type determining equation set 40-K is being solved by controller 51-K, the solution of two or more of the equations in the media type determining equation set 40-K may be within a predetermined range of one another. Should this arise, a comparator 58 may be used to determine when two or more of the solutions are within a given range of each other, and, based on the equations involved, a lookup table 59 in memory 53-K may be used select one solution-one media type. For example, should media type determining equation set have eight equations and equations 2, 4, and 5 be within a predetermined percentage of one another, then the combination of equations 2, 4, and 5 would be used as the pointer into the lookup table 59 to select which empirically determined one of the three solutions should be used.
  • FIGS. 4-5 illustrate two arrangements for the various operational parameters 56-K1 through 56-KP that are chosen. In both figures, the abscissa is the range of an operational parameter and the ordinate is a media type. In both figures, three media types M1, M2, M3 are shown in rectangles, the width of which indicates the range of a given operational parameter P. In FIG. 4, the range of operational parameter P for media type M1 does not overlap range of operational parameter P used for media type M2, and, similarly, between the operational ranges of operational parameter P and media types M2 and M3. In FIG. 5, the range of operational parameter P for media type M2 overlaps that for media type M1 at one end and that of media type M3 at the other as indicated by RO. While the method shown in FIG. 4 would be more desirable, hardware limitations sometimes preclude setting operational parameters in this manner. When operational parameter range overlap is used, the operational imaging device 50 should be able to provide acceptable output for either setting for media classified in either type. This may be seen as a simpler form of expert weighting.
  • FIG. 6 illustrates a further structure that may be used for the media type determining equation set 40. Occasionally, a sensor within the operational sensor set 52 may fail. The sensor may stop working entirely or the output signal of the sensor may drift outside of an expected range. In either case this may be addressed by providing additional sets of media determining type equation sets. Assuming that all combinations of malfunctioning sensors are detectable, media type determining equation set 40 would be replaced with media type determining equation set matrix 40′ comprised of a total of S!+1 media type determining equation sets where S is the total number of sensors in operational sensor set 52. The first set operational sensor set SS1 would be one in which all S sensors are functioning. The second operational sensor set SS2 would be one in which sensor 51 is faulty, the third set SS3 is one where sensor S2 is faulty, and so on where sensor set SSS! is the penultimate faulty sensor set and sensor set SSS!+1 is the final faulty sensor set. In creating the media type determining equation sets for the various combinations of faulty sensors (or conversely for the various combinations of remaining functional sensors), training system 10 would use only that data within each of the training data sets 26-1-26-M that corresponds to the remaining functioning sensors within operational sensor set 52. For example, suppose sensor 1 and sensor 3 were faulty in operational imaging device 50-K, the media type determining equation set within matrix 40′ of media type determining equation sets selected for use would be that where the data supplied by sensors 1 and 3 would not be used in developing the media type determining equations in that media type determining equation set. Where the operational sensor set contains a number of sensors known to be reliable, the number of sensor sets in matrix 40′ may be reduced to eliminate the reliable sensors when creating matrix 40′. Further, if the total number of faulty sensors exceeds a predetermined number, or the expected performance of the system drops below a predetermined acceptable failure threshold, operational imaging device 50 would declare itself to be non-functional and issue a service request.
  • FIG. 7 provides a simplified flow chart of the present method. For method M100, the actions of blocks B10-B50 would occur using the training system 10 while those of blocks B60-B120 would occur in each operational imaging device 50. Method M100 starts at block B10 and proceeds to block B20 where the media set containing M types of media is determined. Next at block B30, a training sensor set for measuring values of a set of N predetermined variables is provided. At block B40, using the training sensor set, normalized training data sets for each media type in the media set is collected. At block B50, a media type determining equation set having M media type determining equations is formed. Thereafter at block B60, the media type determining equation set 40 is stored in memory 53 of each operational imaging device 50. At block B70, an operational sensor set 52 for measuring the values of the set of N variables is provided for each operational imaging device 50. At block B80, the values of the set of N variables is measured for a media sheet about to be processed and the values normalized. At block B90, the media type determining equation set is solved using the normalized values of the set of N variables to determine a media type. At block B100, using the determined media type, an operational parameter of the operational imaging device is chosen. At block B110, the media sheet to be processed is processed by the operational imaging device using the selected operational parameter. At block B120, method M100 ends.
  • FIGS. 8A-8B provide a simplified flow chart of another form of the present method. For method M200, the actions of blocks B220-B260 would occur using the training system 10 while those of blocks B260-B400 would occur in each operational imaging device 50. Method M200 starts at block B210 and proceeds to block B220 where the media set containing M types of media is determined. Next at block B230, a training sensor set 14 for measuring values of a set of N predetermined variables is provided. At block B240, using the training sensor set 14, normalized training data sets for each media type in the media set is collected. At block B250, a first media type determining equation set having M media type determining equations is formed where all of the variables in the set of N variables are being measured by the training sensor set 14. The media type determining equation set produced will be selected when all of the sensors in the operational imaging device are functioning properly. At block B260, a number of additional media type determining equation sets are formed from the normalized training data sets 26 that have been modified to remove data values associated with a faulty sensor. The number of modified additional media type determining equation sets will be S! where S is the number of sensors in the training and operational sensor sets 14, 52. For example, if the impedance sensor was determined to be faulty, then the impedance magnitude and phase data values would not be used. If the impedance sensor and bending or stiffness sensor were both faulty, then the impedance magnitude and phase data and the stiffness data would not be used. This process will be repeated for all of the combinations of sensors in the training sensor set 14. As the number of faulty sensors increases, it may still be possible to operate the operational imaging device 50. However, there will be a point at which the operational imaging device 50 will no longer be able to determine a media type. This may be taken into account as described with the operations given in blocks B290, and B320-B350.
  • At block B270, the S!+1 media type determining equation sets, where the +1 represents the first media type determining equation set having all sensors functioning, are stored in memory 53 of each operational imaging device 50. At block B280 an operational sensor set 52 for measuring the values of the set of N variables is provided for each operational imaging device 50. At block B290 a determination is made to see whether or not any faulty sensor outputs are detected. When it is determined that all of the sensors S in the operational sensor set 52 are functioning, at block B300, method 200 selects the first media type determining equation set where all sensor are functioning. Thereafter, at block B310, method 200 solves the first media type determining equation set using the measured values for the set of N variables. Method M200 then proceeds to block B370.
  • When it is determined that faulty sensor outputs are presented, the faulty sensors outputs are flagged by controller 51 which then proceeds to select, based on the combination of the remaining functioning sensors or on the combination of the malfunctioning sensors in the operational sensor set 52, the appropriate additional media type determining equation set from the S! media type determining equations sets that have been stored in memory 53. At block B330 the confidence level of the selected additional media type determining equation set is checked. The confidence check determines that the appropriate equations are present in firmware 53. When the confidence threshold is not met, i.e., an equation is missing, method M200 declares a fault at block 350 and may issue a service request. When it is determined that the confidence threshold has been met, method M200 proceeds to block B360, the selected additional media type determining equation set is solved using the normalized values of the set of variables that are measured by the remaining functioning sensors in operational sensor set 52 to determine a media type.
  • At block B370, the solutions provided by the selected additional media type determining equation set or those provided by the first media type determining equation set are checked to determine whether or not two or more of the equation solutions are within a predetermined range of one another. When it is determined that this condition is present, at block B380, a determined media type is selected from lookup table (LUT) 59 stored in memory 53 based on the combination of which equations in the additional media type determining equation set are within a predetermined range of one another. For example, say the solutions for equations 1, 2 and 3 in a set of six equations return values within an empirically predetermined range of one another, then based on this combination of equations, a determined media type has been empirically determined using expert knowledge. These empirical determinations of media type are stored in the LUT 59.
  • At block B390, using the determined media type, an operational parameter of the operational imaging device is chosen. At block B400, the media sheet to be processed is processed by the operational imaging device using the selected operational parameter. At block B410, method M200 ends. After completion the process M200 may return to block B290 to recheck for faulty sensors prior to the processing of the next sheet of media. The operations of block B290 may also be performed periodically, such as, prior to beginning a new media processing job.
  • Example cases using the operational imaging devices 50 which are electrophotographic printers will now be described to illustrate the present method and the high degree of flexibility that may be used when developing and implementing the media type determining equations by use of different variables and sensor sets. In each of Tables 4-8, 10-11 and 13, the term “A” is a linear offset term in the media type determining equation. When the media type determining equation set uses polynomial equation form, the number of terms is a function of the polynomial order and the number of variables, or roughly of the number of sensors in each of the sensor sets 52-1-52-K assuming each sensor is measuring a single variable. In the simplest case, the polynomial order is one, the decision surface is a constant, and thresholding is used. In the most complex case having a media set having a large number of media types and the form of the equation is a polynomial, a higher order polynomial would be used. However, as the equation order increases, a concern of overfitting of the data may arise if the training data sets do not contain a sufficient number of values. For these reasons, the order of polynomial equations when used will generally have an order between first and fifth. The number of M media type determining equations in the media type determining equation set 40 would be the M number of media types to be classified. Some sensors may be used to make multiple measurements, e.g., impedance magnitude and phase.
  • The coefficients used for each media type determining equation will be a function of the range normalization as well as the actual design of the hardware in the operational imaging device 50. Several things about the present system are universal. One of those is that certain sensor term combinations are more important than others in making the media type classification. The number of terms kept in the media type determining equation determines the resolution of the system, but each decreasingly important term makes less of a difference to the media type determination. Another is that while characteristic media properties determine differences between media type, the particular set of sensors chosen will determine which features are used to separate media.
  • After conditioning and normalization, the measured values of the set of N values are fed into each media type determining equation. The value and sign of the number calculated determines whether the controller 53 believes the media tested to be of the type measured. Generally, if the sign of the number is positive, then the tested media is classified as “of that type” and if it is negative the media is classified as “not of that type”. If more than one type have a positive sign, the type with the highest positive value is the determined type or as previously discussed the determined type may be found in the LUT 59.
  • For the following examples the coefficients of each term are given in the coefficient columns, and the sensor input combination in the equation variable column. For example, in Case 1A, for the media type determining equation for polymer, the first term X1 is multiplied by polymer coefficient −0.026359, the second term X2 is multiplied by the coefficient 1.217574 and so on. In each media type determining equation, each term is added to the previous terms. If the coefficients are considered a vector Θ, and the terms a vector of X, then the resultant number is the resultant sum of terms which can be written in vector notation as ΘTX.
  • The following nomenclature is used to describe media types that may be sensed using the present methods. The media types include, but are not limited to: plain paper light—60-75 g/m2; plain paper standard—>75-90 g/m2; plain paper heavy->90-120 g/m2; cardstock light 120-165 g/m2; cardstock standard—>165-220 g/m2; cardstock heavy—220-300 g/m2; glossy paper light—105-165 g/m2; glossy paper standard—>165-220 g/m2; glossy paper heavy->220-300 g/m2; paper labels—<=5 mil; paper label heavy >5 mil; plastic label <=5 mil; plastic label heavy >5 mil; polymer (vinyl) labels; envelope standard—<=sub 24; envelope heavy >sub 24; synthetic polymer—polymer signage 4-7 mil and transparencies-4-7 mil; and rough/cotton paper—90-120 g/m2 (100% cotton or parchment style). Where each of these media types is to be sensed in a single type of operational imaging device 50, a corresponding media type determining equation set 40 would be generated and solved as previously described. For the listed examples, media type determining equation set 40 would have 17 media type determining equations. It should also be recognized that variations of a given type may be combined if desired. For example, the three plain paper types can be reduced to a single type covering weights of 60-120 g/m2 or two types plain paper light and plain paper heavier covering weights 75-120 g/m2 that combines plain paper standard and heavy into one type. Plain paper may also be referred to as office paper or copier paper.
  • Cases 1A-1C provide for media type determination for operational imaging devices 50 used in a typical retail environment. The media set 16 used in a retail environment generally includes three media types—plain office paper—all weights, a polymeric media, such as, outdoor signage or vinyl labels—all thicknesses, and a thicker media such as cardstock—all weights. The training sensor set 14 and each operational sensor set 52-1-52-K used for this three member media set varies in each of the cases 1A-1C. Cases 1A-1C illustrate various example combinations of measurements and sensors that may be used to determine the media types in this three member media set. Of course, other sets of sensors may also be used to the same effect. Case 1A uses direct and subsystem response sensors to produce three 3rd order polynomial equations which form media type determining set 40. In this example the set of N variables comprises two measured variables-media feed motor current and optical average. The former being provided by a subsystem response sensor (a motor current sensor) and the latter being provided by a direct sensor (optical sensor). Case 1B uses two direct sensors to produce three 1st order polynomial equations having two measured variables—bending or stiffness and gloss or reflectance. Case 1C uses two direct sensors to produce three fifth order polynomial equations having three variables—impedance magnitude, impedance phase, and acoustic pressure. Based on empirical results, additional sensors may be used but would only increase the cost of the operational imaging devices 50 used in a retail environment without providing any significant increase in more accurately resolving the three media types.
  • Tables 4-6 provide the coefficients for each term in each of the respective media type determining equations sets where one set comprises 3rd order equations, one set comprises first order equations and the last provides fifth order equations. Cases 1A-1C help to illustrate the flexibility of the present system where choice of variables measured and selection of corresponding sensors provides a variety of media type determining equation solution sets to determine a media type within a common set of media.
  • TABLE 4
    Case 1A Media Type Determining Equation Set - 3 Media Types
    Equations Coefficients for Media Type in Media Set Equation
    Polymer Cardstock Plain Paper Variables
    −0.26359 0.674147 −0.41055 X1
    1.217574 0.324479 −1.54205 X2
    −2.23855 2.852548 −0.614 X1*X2
    −0.95171 0.68555 0.266161 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.49302 0.243864 0.24916 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2
    −0.214 −0.034 0.248008 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.435317 −0.48451 0.049195 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    1.972594 −0.64922 −1.32337 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.677691 −0.63346 −0.04423 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    1.25E−15 −2.5E−15 2.39E−16 A
    X1 = media feed motor current
    X2 = optical average
  • TABLE 5
    Case 1B Media Type Determining Equation Set - 3 Media Types
    Equations Coefficients for Media Type in Media Set Equation
    Polymer Cardstock Plain Paper Variables
    −0.94122 2.550474 −1.60925 X1
    2.842086 −1.73038 −1.11171 X2
    −2E−15 −6.2E−15 4.07E−15 A
    X1 = Stiffness
    X2 = Reflectance
  • TABLE 6
    Case 1C Media Type Determining Equation Set - 3 Media Types
    Equations Coefficients for Media Type in Media Set Equation
    Polymer Cardstock Plain Paper Variables
    0.521816 0.1541 −0.67592 X1
    −0.64239 0.749393 −0.107 X2
    −1.1612 0.695437 0.46576 X3
    −1.26453 1.679798 −0.41526 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.1172 0.143002 −0.0258 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.090567 0.018989 −0.10956 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.29926 0.425474 −0.12621 X1{circumflex over ( )}3*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    1.001712 −1.03542 0.03371 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.124537 −0.13386 0.009324 X1{circumflex over ( )}3*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.259456 0.015051 −0.27451 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.076292 0.01834 −0.09463 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.045954 0.00624 −0.05219 X2{circumflex over ( )}3*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −1.41847 2.231076 −0.8126 X1*X2
    −2.1302 2.285888 −0.15569 X1*X3
    −0.6697 0.614604 0.055097 X2*X3
    −1.31056 1.433568 −0.12301 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.78187 2.459673 −1.6778 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2
    −0.0319 −0.06375 0.095647 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.65689 −0.01726 0.674151 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −1.46065 2.601674 −1.14103 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.334875 0.562891 −0.89777 X1{circumflex over ( )}3*X2
    0.048487 −0.08137 0.032886 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}4
    1.795706 −2.09925 0.303547 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.915608 −0.98512 0.069512 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.44722 0.752981 −0.30576 X1{circumflex over ( )}3*X3
    −0.11733 0.410803 −0.29347 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.231317 −0.08636 −0.14496 X1{circumflex over ( )}4*X2
    0.567364 −0.55563 −0.01173 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}4
    0.873347 −0.78357 −0.08977 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.11993 0.021361 0.098573 X1{circumflex over ( )}4*X3
    0.183484 −0.10309 −0.08039 X2{circumflex over ( )}3*X3
    0.173374 −0.11658 −0.0568 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}4
    0.050166 −0.07365 0.023488 X2{circumflex over ( )}4*X3
    1.040249 0.202081 −1.24233 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.431391 −0.04736 −0.38403 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.44561 0.599931 −0.15432 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.32854 0.049625 0.278914 X1{circumflex over ( )}4
    0.094454 −0.07046 −0.02399 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.97987 0.341256 0.638617 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.20286 0.065434 0.137428 X1{circumflex over ( )}5
    0.103064 −0.15184 0.048777 X2{circumflex over ( )}4
    0.300238 −0.35632 0.056081 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.019829 −0.0389 0.019072 X2{circumflex over ( )}5
    0.242616 0.002065 −0.24468 X3{circumflex over ( )}4
    0.011345 0.079402 −0.09075 X3{circumflex over ( )}5
    1.886901 −2.18008 0.293184 X1*X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.30617 0.10599 0.20018 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    −0.53504 1.959913 −1.42487 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2*X3
    0.878716 −1.0035 0.12478 X1*X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.135789 −0.23757 0.101777 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}3*X3
    0.1232 0.324937 −0.44814 X1{circumflex over ( )}3*X2*X3
    0.30541 −0.45386 0.148451 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.708467 −0.43527 −0.2732 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.36158 0.519538 −0.15796 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    −1.03613 1.398758 −0.36263 X1*X2*X3
    −4.3E−15 −4.9E−15 1.17E−15 A
    X1 = Impedance Magnitude
    X2 = Impedance Phase
    X3 = Acoustic Energy
  • As can be seen from Tables 4-6, the number of terms in the equations forming each of the respective media type determining set of equations 40 differs but when solved will determine one of the three media types in the three member media set of plain, cardstock, and polyvinyl. For example for Case 1A the form of the equation for polyvinyl would be as set forth in Eq. 7.

  • (sign of the number determined by): 1.25E−15−0.26359X1+1.217574X2−2.23855X1*X2−0.95171X1*X2̂2−0.49302X1̂2*X2−0.214X1̂2+0.435317X1̂3+1.972594X2̂2+0.677691X2̂3  Eq. 7
  • As can be seen, excluding the offset term A, the second, third, fourth, and eighth terms are greater contributors to the solution. A similar trend may also be seen in Tables 5 and 6 (where A is the first term). These larger contributing terms may be empirically determined to be sufficient in determining the three media types and each equation in the media type determining set 40 may be truncated to use only the larger contributing terms. Here that would be terms whose absolute values are about 1 or greater. Other threshold values may be used. Truncation would reduce the memory and processing requirements needed in controller 51.
  • Case 2 illustrates the use of direct indirect measurement values and subsystem responses values for determining a second media set consisting of polyvinyl labels, cardstock—all weights, plain paper and lightweight media. Light paper is in the range of 60-75 g/m2 while plain paper is in the range of 75-120 g/m2 (combines standard and heavy plain paper). The measured variables for this case are: Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Media Feed Motor Current (X3), Optical Average (X4) and Optical Deviation (X5).
  • TABLE 7
    Case 2 Media Type Determining Set - 4 Media Types
    Equations Coefficients for
    Media Type in Media Set
    Polyvinyl Plain Light Equation
    Labels Cardstock Paper Paper Variables
    0.225062 −1.42402 1.069768 0.129193 X1
    −0.15618 0.934353 −0.54642 −0.23175 X2
    −0.35749 1.124621 −0.30012 −0.46701 X3
    −0.23404 0.142778 2.510928 −2.41967 X4
    0.247742 0.121015 −2.16172 1.792964 X5
    0.013711 −0.02611 0.213334 −0.20093 X1*X2
    −0.03757 −0.1457 0.708307 −0.52503 X1*X3
    0.029382 −0.98702 1.502796 −0.54515 X1*X4
    −0.22486 1.111549 −1.02779 0.141101 X2*X3
    0.376093 −0.55781 −1.23348 1.4152 X1*X5
    −0.32806 0.719974 0.003087 −0.395 X2*X4
    −0.00795 0.41247 −0.44329 0.038769 X2*X5
    −0.18676 0.869611 −0.44871 −0.23414 X3*X4
    0.074733 0.602568 −0.44446 −0.23284 X3*X5
    −1.15319 0.672746 1.66255 −1.18211 X4*X5
    0.057141 −0.30656 0.316332 −0.06691 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.022902 −0.1148 0.150146 −0.05825 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2
    −0.00492 0.006678 −0.06264 0.060885 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.35556 1.318364 −0.66739 −0.29541 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.578065 −0.23992 −1.05918 0.721037 X1*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.10378 0.385121 −0.34058 0.059233 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.30339 1.307525 −0.90682 −0.09732 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    0.009997 −0.33628 0.069833 0.256447 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.128141 −0.09628 −0.37517 0.343309 X1*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.166336 0.214759 −0.86698 0.485889 X2*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.041753 0.26703 −0.71493 0.406152 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    0.194437 −0.45359 0.034794 0.224355 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    0.006733 0.163825 −0.12819 −0.04237 X2*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.633982 −0.41982 −0.87551 0.661349 X3*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.07855 −0.01776 0.205488 −0.10917 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.18097 0.219188 −0.28608 0.247858 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    0.117892 −0.17781 0.155455 −0.09554 X3*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00973 0.333001 −0.13092 −0.19235 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.13255 −0.08775 0.249897 −0.0296 X4*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.37573 0.32157 0.598336 −0.54418 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.22778 1.115435 −0.83106 −0.0566 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.11009 0.561379 −0.42405 −0.02724 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.047593 −0.24015 0.309609 −0.11705 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.035723 −0.19568 0.18612 −0.02616 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.41602 0.962193 −0.5507 0.004526 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.10718 0.167984 −0.12611 0.065301 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    1.632011 −0.36961 −1.49115 0.228747 X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    1.026741 −0.38294 −1.39262 0.748819 X4{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.273458 −0.34669 −0.78042 0.853651 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.023698 −0.15596 0.148829 −0.01657 X5{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.00028 −0.15674 −0.09303 0.250049 X1*X2*X3
    0.100456 −0.4077 0.207944 0.099301 X1*X2*X4
    −0.04225 0.019812 0.088199 −0.06576 X1*X2*X5
    −0.16898 −0.08951 −0.00523 0.263717 X1*X3*X4
    0.275793 −0.33318 0.396509 −0.33912 X1*X3*X5
    −0.34118 0.70765 −0.70225 0.335783 X2*X3*X4
    −0.24481 −0.30138 0.804439 −0.25825 X1*X4*X5
    0.092109 −0.0826 0.209463 −0.21897 X2*X3*X5
    −0.14553 −0.11924 0.773938 −0.50917 X2*X4*X5
    −0.40228 0.740575 0.235175 −0.57347 X3*X4*X5
    1.49E−16 7.24E−16 2.06E−16 2.89E−16 A
  • As can be seen, four third order equations comprise the media type determining equation set for this case. Again truncation may be applied if desired.
  • Case 3 represents a media set that would be important to corporate “office” usage: plain paper—all weights, bond paper, cardstock—all weights, polyvinyl labels—all thicknesses, paper labels—all thicknesses, envelopes—all types and transparencies. In this case an extra sensor type, a reflectance sensor has been added such that more information is available to the classifier algorithm to separate the greater number of media types in this case. In Table 8 below, an example of coefficients for each media type and the corresponding sensor term are given. As in the previous case, there is a separate equation for each media type. The number of terms is a function of the number of sensors whereas the number of equations is the number of media types to be classified. The variables (normalized) represent Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Impedance Magnitude (X3), Impedance Phase (X4), Reflectance (X5), Optical transmission Average (X6), and Optical transmission variation (X7). Reflectance sensing was added to increase the resolution of the system.
  • TABLE 8
    Case 3 Media Type Determining Equation Set - 7 Media Types
    Equation Coefficients
    Polyvinyl Paper Bond Equation
    Envelopes Labels Transparencies Plain Paper Cardstock Labels Paper Terms
    0.242808151 −0.3022667 −0.0491579 0.654057468 −0.97351965 0.168457672 0.259620957 X1
    −0.01330176 0.84585723 −0.120025 −1.22077225 −0.33500161 −0.553407974 1.396651357 X2
    −1.37489733 −0.1298633 0.15315162 −4.07078138 1.47210184 0.150420275 3.799868243 X3
    0.159805392 −0.4530109 −0.0328607 0.007380524 −0.37329899 0.337221897 0.354762809 X4
    −0.03137718 −0.7627554 0.48495245 0.68890323 0.456535275 0.50658056 −1.34283896 X5
    −0.23703325 1.25760707 −0.1833756 −0.00038332 0.292820153 −1.699788598 0.570153552 X6
    −0.08842941 −0.0659294 −0.1038132 0.691897028 0.756912349 0.386522154 −1.57715955 X7
    −0.03774966 0.2083204 −0.0408547 −0.38572795 −0.32021909 −0.085178173 0.661409181 X1 * X2
    −0.46825036 −0.0416872 −0.0059438 −1.17095757 −0.4726776 0.205245122 1.954271358 X1 * X3
    0.090469474 −0.3713271 0.04878452 0.657499323 0.367081558 −0.00901844 −0.78348931 X1 * X4
    0.6267451 0.55035809 0.02516059 −0.45452791 −1.08095652 −0.610545198 0.943765848 X2 * X3
    −0.10970869 −0.584089 −0.0792134 0.76115018 0.116950171 0.555621583 −0.6607109 X1 * X5
    0.036304219 0.166694 0.00240912 −0.58742405 0.204803565 −0.013396524 0.190609669 X2 * X4
    −0.19386352 0.20576049 0.18077901 0.35145225 −0.36387624 −0.535897777 0.355645785 X1 * X6
    −0.16572491 −0.1069755 −0.0516899 0.015388638 0.532614986 0.210944798 −0.43455809 X2 * X5
    −0.3828572 0.006038 −0.018257 −0.50987861 0.619603254 0.197328854 0.088022667 X3 * X4
    −0.01038755 −0.3310865 0.02464473 0.170773931 0.121501059 0.54130573 −0.51675144 X1 * X7
    0.087358187 2.13665827 0.06906835 −1.42352942 −0.18670512 −1.746199137 1.06334887 X2 * X6
    −1.13859457 −0.5354781 0.41314087 −1.3457852 3.642512513 0.37668805 −1.41248355 X3 * X5
    0.214018404 −0.0602839 −0.0463747 −0.33748569 −0.2677048 −0.080954315 0.578784994 X2 * X7
    0.008227289 −0.6078817 −0.1542212 −1.93635588 1.261053994 0.022504261 1.4066732 X3 * X6
    −0.10772428 0.33797076 −0.1912707 0.506630077 0.499212018 −0.186427521 −0.85839036 X4 * X5
    −1.11533626 0.72260049 −0.1025189 −0.9098379 2.238050338 0.059829784 −0.89278759 X3 * X7
    0.623613057 −1.2446447 0.08504447 0.27708983 −1.02386944 0.752172688 0.530594112 X4 * X6
    −0.33746245 −0.1676835 0.05569619 −0.6716702 −0.0349193 0.462651255 0.693387976 X4 * X7
    0.198677045 −1.7136494 −1.1122608 2.707697972 −0.49570898 0.530774916 −0.11553077 X5 * X6
    −0.44830534 0.37979146 −0.477535 0.169566611 1.754798417 −0.216351379 −1.16196479 X5 * X7
    0.060861078 −0.9303548 0.26464063 −0.42059107 0.59975339 0.159996521 0.265694281 X6 * X7
    −0.06642697 −0.400875 0.07595577 0.427777369 0.216408286 0.316872893 −0.5697124 X1 * X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.03033115 −0.1089005 0.02039878 0.0884261 0.023469737 0.099593952 −0.0926569 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X2
    1.104164442 −0.1375385 0.01430879 0.910564031 −0.36090926 0.065321852 −1.59591135 X1 * X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.28610152 0.32555398 −0.0215696 −0.40451992 0.722334335 −0.28029139 −0.05540585 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X3
    −0.05679468 0.29508389 0.01500337 0.065384349 0.306876345 −0.380851788 −0.24470148 X1 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.968134856 −0.0875256 0.00368472 1.047335379 −0.68055834 −0.417423169 −0.83364785 X2 * X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.106984082 −0.0273801 −0.0038711 0.536250953 −0.02571888 −0.092027394 −0.49423754 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    −0.46911341 −0.6210633 −0.0262951 −0.02215315 0.742307301 0.551758423 −0.15544073 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X3
    0.029959315 0.30676346 −0.0018093 0.004508407 0.062845066 −0.221896672 −0.18037031 X1 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02495464 0.53998496 −0.0539299 0.091485987 0.130652518 −0.524101755 −0.15913714 X2 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.03221472 −0.0367792 −0.0204677 −0.13394671 −0.08007686 −0.011930464 0.315415614 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.218460659 0.19533822 −0.0288234 0.484929557 −0.37665004 −0.104732257 −0.38852272 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    −0.31298873 −0.0796939 −0.0110477 0.05870185 0.093799545 0.759061335 −0.50783245 X1 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.023256249 −0.1369177 0.13074052 0.444100204 0.036162466 0.017104908 −0.51444669 X2 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.13532985 0.17431111 0.01702134 0.168393669 0.287371468 −0.128914797 −0.38285294 X3 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.05764968 0.25950249 −0.1055292 −0.02277384 0.64040572 −0.2961302 −0.41782531 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    0.144736128 0.20520264 0.01876379 0.075086074 −0.26439205 −0.277476654 0.098080074 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    −0.01295648 0.21266324 −0.0062756 0.291283396 0.358857085 −0.177690646 −0.66588097 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    0.315586948 0.18030758 0.00016429 0.19996937 −0.79907586 −0.293808336 0.396856013 X1 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.218973731 0.22531613 0.08264195 0.316699388 −0.31314516 −0.050307601 −0.48017844 X2 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00244836 0.48193641 0.24934533 −0.37691143 0.338010386 −0.388013626 −0.30191871 X3 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.35227415 0.05331815 0.03809078 −0.13670761 0.802073614 0.109739074 −0.51423985 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    −0.52443353 −1.3907833 −0.1651325 0.744962068 0.961085722 1.17244877 −0.79814722 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.2566956 −0.0365632 0.07185654 −0.32597867 1.622202025 −0.041289211 −1.03353191 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.150880012 0.02016158 0.01913804 0.0932972 −0.29390751 −0.276697418 0.287128093 X2 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.715717405 −0.6505444 0.04942693 0.460706029 −1.05818782 1.312283869 −0.82940203 X3 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06172227 0.24009602 −0.0287398 −0.18907301 0.009040378 −0.162248061 0.192646726 X4 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.25833591 0.02168096 0.04734084 0.193850486 0.858138335 −0.100312335 −0.76236239 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    2.048616532 −0.4801869 −0.0381019 2.19872312 −1.81707289 −0.468959887 −1.44301803 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.06147092 0.22879508 0.02734446 0.026662595 0.237054069 −0.211083078 −0.2473022 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.019018286 0.35534086 −0.0293189 0.327874074 −0.47389923 0.011003144 −0.21001828 X3 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.263794229 −1.2885052 0.11419223 −0.03300695 −0.80374925 1.333696103 0.413578835 X4 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.27963138 0.24083357 −0.0534372 −0.12149756 −0.13741223 −0.023846008 −0.18427194 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.044749075 0.02489239 0.0432358 0.447757539 0.164636166 −0.297332654 −0.42793831 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.02399799 −0.0855735 0.0283726 −0.02278462 −0.20840843 −0.020831413 0.33322337 X4 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.05329374 −1.6061004 −0.0509634 0.193624208 −0.85812634 1.534707715 0.733564474 X5 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.20329684 −0.1136408 0.00892198 −0.8077009 0.085471081 0.238507852 0.791737606 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.249965119 0.99639693 −0.6997549 0.938787384 −0.58629349 −1.088674948 0.189573854 X5{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.05624124 0.05621629 −0.0382949 −0.11591467 0.041698835 −0.032089637 0.144625319 X5 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00839996 0.26646453 −0.1639763 0.026170868 0.084923933 −0.2049962 −0.00018684 X5{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.28163397 −0.087712 0.06309944 0.402808555 −0.90243212 0.065790681 0.176811511 X6 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.386273884 −0.519215 0.08960004 −0.20972974 −0.40100835 −0.131217004 0.785296176 X6{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.142529438 0.33749117 −0.0080187 −0.44783953 0.126016081 −0.28859151 0.138413088 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.036334313 0.12216315 0.00910985 −0.18454767 0.169883929 −0.104638169 −0.04830541 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.07066936 −0.284715 0.05589571 0.252305977 0.117436606 0.247913939 −0.31816788 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.0398291 −0.2773847 0.05271931 0.309902861 0.167959018 0.212456695 −0.42582404 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.909644173 0.08440005 0.03466067 −0.0260951 0.240063123 −0.535929951 −0.70674296 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    1.068296553 0.13004595 −0.0123454 1.347391959 −1.03492607 −0.458305795 −1.04015724 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.17521611 0.17517023 0.06231885 −0.21474491 0.373652076 −0.251374791 0.030194659 X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06605909 0.0723524 0.00328255 −0.13066688 0.106342931 −0.083581399 0.098329478 X4{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.312102004 0.80158207 0.96882362 −0.91623853 −1.02160195 −0.562009997 0.417342786 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.123171561 0.15007733 0.48102528 −0.5519628 −0.50960591 −0.050435888 0.357730429 X5{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.53887541 1.61379721 0.10504467 −0.31556109 0.488544753 0.266720262 −1.61967039 X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.25639983 0.35075975 0.07883228 −0.32546733 −0.28205864 1.239843522 −0.80550975 X6{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.367050626 0.16798992 0.05675556 0.69868854 −1.06549399 −0.18297778 −0.04201288 X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.162316766 −0.0089132 0.02342981 −0.00583392 −0.53889923 −0.103534971 0.471434709 X7{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.10779052 −0.3436667 −0.0149956 −0.05648475 0.016226244 0.280247575 0.226463781 X1 * X2 * X3
    0.162739258 0.18592952 −0.0146728 0.163175444 −0.16835845 −0.082884162 −0.24592884 X1 * X2 * X4
    0.053107567 0.1009162 −0.0243086 0.126345382 −0.027035 −0.108823967 −0.12020157 X1 * X2 * X5
    −0.54721799 −0.1107567 −0.0090108 −0.28058423 0.920530688 0.238391661 −0.21135254 X1 * X3 * X4
    −0.3689005 −0.4467775 −0.0637423 0.152615471 0.526974547 0.395448384 −0.19561819 X1 * X2 * X6
    −0.38771626 −0.0542216 0.07289316 −0.34806928 0.78396724 0.082003032 −0.14885628 X1 * X3 * X5
    −0.45089733 0.01311599 0.01066731 −0.67449927 0.957117362 0.343771508 −0.19927557 X2 * X3 * X4
    −0.07334702 −0.0386646 0.0216881 0.05110817 0.427787692 −0.081419426 −0.30715292 X1 * X2 * X7
    0.693727149 −0.8897513 −0.0614786 0.261172037 −0.42403462 0.798914114 −0.37854884 X1 * X3 * X6
    −0.12759699 0.21168643 −0.0413005 0.330100921 0.775088044 −0.144140058 −1.00383785 X1 * X4 * X5
    0.134162986 0.17267197 0.05671629 −0.24113209 0.289122875 −0.117606636 −0.29393541 X2 * X3 * X5
    −0.60536881 0.67849644 −0.0388384 0.623385535 0.880769098 −0.502027315 −1.03641659 X1 * X3 * X7
    0.128413047 −0.9850029 0.13365049 0.490639439 0.019561605 0.343550075 −0.13081176 X1 * X4 * X6
    1.185281201 −0.0519245 −0.0176642 1.049481512 −0.68351136 −0.653399454 −0.82826321 X2 * X3 * X6
    −0.1563354 0.47360594 −0.0499928 0.219737277 0.878147712 −0.330207418 −1.03495531 X2 * X4 * X5
    −0.18197796 0.03153822 −0.0091941 −0.46035895 0.110668281 0.209663912 0.299660627 X1 * X4 * X7
    −0.25557672 −1.2530535 0.2945048 −0.54476269 0.194645313 1.224383089 0.339859741 X1 * X5 * X6
    0.32911471 0.58463128 0.01280195 0.911020371 −0.22261648 −0.533906046 −1.08104578 X2 * X3 * X7
    0.243204546 −1.036637 0.08133881 −0.24571052 −0.41147512 0.595739638 0.77353967 X2 * X4 * X6
    −0.13276077 0.19299011 −0.0956321 0.180770017 0.696891148 −0.038718484 −0.80353996 X3 * X4 * X5
    −0.19839175 0.11970146 −0.1294672 −0.46678533 0.561396374 0.002562748 0.110983683 X1 * X5 * X7
    −0.42659867 0.1628119 −0.0940231 −0.5472644 0.595759866 0.277665679 0.031648729 X2 * X4 * X7
    −0.06960141 0.60321056 0.01119979 −1.86649281 0.481986914 −0.15435873 0.994055683 X2 * X5 * X6
    0.083469304 −0.8463705 0.03634371 −0.00261979 −0.1789313 0.866965472 0.041143097 X3 * X4 * X6
    0.000404245 −0.4776174 0.072095 0.194514726 −0.24542735 0.218205362 0.237825398 X1 * X6 * X7
    −0.01372983 −0.0524225 −0.1602315 −0.35306244 0.123927487 0.17980322 0.275715526 X2 * X5 * X7
    −0.46966518 0.58347487 0.01063821 0.067900488 1.130370871 −0.188545099 −1.13417416 X3 * X4 * X7
    −0.47015211 −1.3645586 −0.2574877 −0.31219992 1.906092833 0.918031528 −0.41972609 X3 * X5 * X6
    0.282659953 0.16435012 0.03221158 0.031144009 −0.44180809 −0.025267221 −0.04329036 X2 * X6 * X7
    −0.60137204 0.49042391 −0.1294754 −0.13264599 2.083689039 −0.296493343 −1.41412616 X3 * X5 * X7
    0.25694826 0.10016521 −0.2401126 0.81570113 −0.22345036 −0.133936214 −0.57531541 X4 * X5 * X6
    0.561703289 −0.3617383 0.00757938 −0.46358326 −0.33602152 −0.367632643 0.959693056 X3 * X6 * X7
    −0.06207154 0.10055074 −0.0140666 −0.28123819 0.027665815 0.045761125 0.183398653 X4 * X5 * X7
    −0.28564421 0.10939144 0.05276535 −0.64976654 0.562086993 0.234468818 −0.02330185 X4 * X6 * X7
    −0.19245128 0.01241731 −0.125598 0.027315036 1.196398231 −0.214711911 −0.70336938 X5 * X6 * X7
    4.57465E−14 −6.748E−14 −2.509E−15 −7.0855E−15 −1.1269E−13 −4.98299E−14 1.02708E−13 A
  • This set of terms is handled exactly like the terms in the Case 2. There are more terms in this model (120) because a sensing method (reflectance) has been added.
  • As with the equations in the prior cases, certain terms are more significant than others, and it is possible to either expand or contract the number of terms depending on the resolution desired. In this case the empirically determined higher contributing terms are set out in Table 9.
  • TABLE 9
    Higher Contributing Terms For Case 3
    X2 X3 X6 X1*X3 X2*X3
    X2*X6 X3*X5 X3*X6 X3*X7 X4*X6
    X5*X6 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X6 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    X3*X6{circumflex over ( )}2 X4*X6{circumflex over ( )}2 X5*X6{circumflex over ( )}2 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X6 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    X3{circumflex over ( )}2 X6{circumflex over ( )}2 X7{circumflex over ( )}2 X1*X4*X5 X1*X3*X7
    X2*X3*X6 X2*X4*X5 X1*X5*X6 X2*X3*X7 X2*X4*X6
    X3*X4*X7 X3*X5*X6 X3*X5*X7 X5*X6*X7
  • While information about the temperature and relative humidity did not factor in significantly to a limited set of media types, as the media types that need to be separated becomes larger in number, the environmental measurements linked with electrical properties (example: X1*X3 and X2*X3) become more important in helping make the media type determination.
  • Case 4 illustrates an imaging device which is designed to be useful for a wide variety of tasks. This system will classify the following paper types: plain paper light; plain paper standard; plain paper heavy; cardstock light; cardstock heavier weight—165-300 g/m2 (combined standard and heavy weight cardstock); glossy paper—all weights; paper labels—all thicknesses; polymer (vinyl) labels—all thicknesses; envelopes—all types; polymer signage; transparencies; and bond paper.
  • For Case 4 the training sensor set includes: Temperature (X1), Relative Humidity (X2), Impedance Magnitude (X3), Impedance Phase (X4), Reflectance (X5), Media Feed Motor Current (X6), Optical transmission Average (X7), and Optical transmission Variation (X8). As in earlier cases each media type to be classified has an equation. Here there are 165 terms in each equation and eleven equations in the media type determining equation set 40. These equations are broken into Table 10 and Table 11 due to the large number of terms.
  • TABLE 10
    Case 4 Media Type Determining Equation Set - 11 Media Types (Part 1)
    Equation Coefficients
    Lighter Heavier
    Weight Weight Paper Bond Equation
    Cardstock Cardstock Labels Paper Envelopes Terms
    −0.10215 −0.96693 0.359736 0.363189 0.1646867 X1
    −0.00735 0.726339 −0.46402 0.293542 −0.173118 X2
    −0.50142 0.257461 0.156373 4.016341 −0.6041163 X3
    −0.39654 0.397066 0.115222 −0.24473 0.0732896 X4
    0.204041 −0.2667 0.235262 −1.19166 0.2337414 X5
    −0.38159 0.435812 −0.08037 −0.964 0.2995665 X6
    0.260921 −0.053 −1.37083 1.283396 −0.4634386 X7
    −0.32533 0.500724 0.39651 −1.26373 0.225797 X8
    −0.06565 0.033339 −0.08807 0.24662 −0.0307321 X1*X2
    −0.13495 −0.76728 0.087931 2.654338 −0.3326146 X1*X3
    −0.36356 −0.05836 −0.13407 −0.24047 0.3409796 X1*X4
    −0.05893 0.52864 −0.43036 0.634368 0.1450806 X2*X3
    0.070669 −0.45792 0.44908 0.187372 0.1620274 X1*X5
    −0.12211 0.123223 −0.06857 −0.1776 −0.0373728 X2*X4
    −0.02833 −0.25859 −0.35674 −0.8934 −0.0380259 X1*X6
    0.062907 0.265196 0.271402 −0.39663 −0.0026142 X2*X5
    0.909783 −0.43324 0.372216 1.2813 −0.0811195 X3*X4
    0.272906 −0.73372 −0.68953 0.642533 −0.181046 X1*X7
    −0.30487 0.84623 −0.50478 −0.20065 −0.0324242 X2*X6
    −0.28482 −0.08269 0.035914 −1.76024 −0.6419247 X3*X5
    −0.50572 −0.03866 0.565644 −0.02227 0.2127391 X1*X8
    −0.0795 0.695273 −0.74671 0.890684 −0.2712677 X2*X7
    1.762335 0.14588 −0.28552 0.825141 −1.3209074 X3*X6
    −0.28597 0.443505 −0.11064 −0.53588 0.0163182 X4*X5
    0.33312 −0.00724 −0.12219 0.233576 −0.0586616 X2*X8
    −0.94669 1.302532 −0.44448 0.924754 0.4573673 X3*X7
    1.015426 0.082229 0.151306 −1.45905 −0.0372243 X4*X6
    0.930716 −0.39203 0.458681 0.431552 −0.1594392 X3*X8
    −0.45028 −0.03084 1.133179 0.750633 0.3492999 X4*X7
    −0.31051 0.295385 0.116376 −0.1335 0.1778553 X5*X6
    0.547048 −0.54746 0.014396 0.32587 −0.2449667 X4*X8
    0.226614 −0.61915 0.372392 0.05312 0.0077516 X5*X7
    0.108459 0.355198 −0.1466 −0.29784 0.1623835 X5*X8
    −0.39451 0.247612 0.150887 −0.06514 −0.1133357 X6*X7
    0.457813 −0.14817 −0.03302 −0.95241 −0.0531792 X6*X8
    −0.55816 1.133495 0.277864 0.782589 0.2767174 X7*X8
    −0.00515 −0.22679 0.175352 −0.26889 0.0622672 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.01301 −0.07598 0.048155 −0.05488 0.0171917 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2
    0.079203 −0.36796 −0.18077 −1.21195 1.0751652 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.238941 0.491853 −0.18625 0.065917 −0.4338321 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.045677 −0.00292 −0.34546 −0.21611 −0.0315138 X1*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.283617 0.055458 −0.27218 −1.18334 0.4441188 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.15339 0.131654 0.028356 −0.03497 0.2354653 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    −0.02984 −0.35992 0.27291 −0.07621 −0.3547497 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.050466 0.094552 0.06311 0.251497 −0.037331 X1*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.160558 −0.00512 −0.36186 0.010888 −0.0582474 X2*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.35751 0.638837 −0.4005 −0.1836 0.1813197 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.00668 0.072938 0.161304 0.011111 0.1833463 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    −0.24437 0.76841 −0.44347 −0.00191 0.0889477 X1*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06228 0.260589 −0.00207 0.089108 −0.0937767 X2*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.343692 −0.48027 −0.20402 −0.21273 −0.0598696 X3*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.28517 1.887516 −0.07392 −0.7279 −0.2333632 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.084384 −0.15658 −0.22951 0.10896 0.0828668 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    0.675777 −0.33885 0.172613 0.160238 0.0892832 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    0.027775 −0.39694 0.862114 −0.39186 −0.0011708 X1*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.45755 1.329883 −0.32686 −0.22937 0.2083025 X2*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02147 −0.00847 −0.24347 −0.79733 −0.1234555 X3*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.17592 0.72296 0.809169 −0.16073 −0.2975119 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    −0.32326 −0.11596 0.107446 −0.03323 0.0322397 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.083391 −0.20866 −0.05538 −1.05817 −0.2742538 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.20365 −0.04443 0.051339 0.167066 −0.1248242 X1*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.181533 −0.09063 0.167089 −0.53324 0.1843593 X2*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.337674 0.389601 −0.11578 0.117904 −0.2955719 X3*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12465 0.021421 0.120407 0.451322 −0.2821513 X4*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.710402 −0.08486 −0.56394 −0.41194 −0.1154069 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.069376 −0.37973 0.661899 −0.21212 −0.2148755 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    1.477739 −0.69285 −0.18726 −0.19059 −0.5402833 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.078293 −0.16992 0.045211 −0.00863 −0.2433564 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.02801 −0.03375 −0.27549 0.482277 0.0558407 X2*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.51609 0.330651 0.554524 −1.79683 0.6795722 X3*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.374891 0.277379 0.127821 −0.41041 0.0139804 X4*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.028317 0.135954 0.077471 −0.11418 −0.0061094 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.45718 0.443713 −0.20604 −2.26695 1.4871733 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.382353 −0.43679 −0.29453 −0.59778 −0.0753872 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.547306 −0.85813 0.159545 −0.59204 −0.2305444 X3*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.40737 −0.20638 1.286032 0.502435 0.2459154 X4*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.49848 0.966306 −0.20128 0.087834 0.147961 X5*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.803535 −0.55223 0.21879 −0.22361 0.158234 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.082115 −0.13336 −0.59163 −0.65502 −0.0609128 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.315409 −0.51715 0.056125 0.538094 −0.0209327 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    −0.05057 0.056377 −0.20692 0.431149 0.0259592 X4*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.13122 −0.34741 0.668695 0.737777 0.1328341 X5*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12 0.190068 0.361689 0.793499 −0.003278 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.47021 −0.01416 −0.59154 −0.18966 −0.1802951 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.110789 −0.15229 −0.12374 0.003351 −0.0324989 X5*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02503 −1.46202 2.115192 0.842059 −0.1288026 X6*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.0313 0.045946 −0.03697 0.193474 −0.0168117 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.53931 0.053701 0.66336 0.519137 0.2487398 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.345938 −0.96856 0.231235 −0.36603 −0.0527204 X6*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.265951 −0.11526 −0.48219 −0.3034 −0.0189186 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.206863 −0.52847 0.182014 −0.4704 −0.1333772 X7*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.67686 0.9898 −0.22295 0.563122 0.2116338 X7{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.188171 0.791867 −0.30372 −0.90642 −0.1022968 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.090529 0.390991 −0.13762 −0.44375 −0.0496673 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.01882 −0.16481 0.11995 −0.18406 0.0422425 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.002369 −0.14932 0.120972 −0.19565 0.0429012 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.355354 −0.49245 −0.06932 −0.27671 0.9429658 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.155078 −0.32116 −0.13668 −1.26564 0.7533977 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.10408 0.057916 −0.22639 −0.21782 −0.1307067 X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.04858 0.141545 −0.02966 0.121084 −0.0309203 X4{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.080835 0.085359 −0.27947 0.351041 0.070428 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00531 0.096888 0.062116 0.532437 0.0385223 X5{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.54744 0.966933 −0.3685 −0.83533 0.5047912 X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.30219 0.105289 0.024698 −0.11067 0.1926124 X6{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.33342 −0.22375 −0.65974 −1.44193 −0.2861917 X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.280755 −0.59172 0.588902 −1.07438 −0.1014826 X7{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.32083 −0.13641 −0.22931 −0.78865 −0.0244664 X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.28887 0.161116 −0.13442 0.178944 −0.0048997 X8{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.07031 −0.25978 0.101222 0.228322 −0.166292 X1*X2*X3
    −0.03949 0.0539 0.079318 −0.05521 0.1205788 X1*X2*X4
    0.135352 −0.16249 0.0041 0.046921 0.0411474 X1*X2*X5
    0.578589 −0.49445 0.156758 0.835545 −0.1344985 X1*X3*X4
    −0.28539 −0.1429 −0.09598 −0.02693 0.0341592 X1*X2*X6
    −0.00595 −0.3858 0.044057 −0.21352 −0.4854171 X1*X3*X5
    0.512641 −0.56394 0.117315 0.334152 −0.0941368 X2*X3*X4
    0.069186 −0.24225 0.132578 0.154435 −0.20241 X1*X2*X7
    1.127602 −0.12103 −0.27445 −0.28795 −0.5877396 X1*X3*X6
    0.046281 0.081032 −0.16733 −0.00978 0.0411183 X1*X4*X5
    −0.01015 −0.25057 0.243957 −0.55575 0.2706885 X2*X3*X5
    −0.01464 0.090724 0.141612 0.092853 0.0055111 X1*X2*X8
    −0.53849 0.208679 0.519656 −0.67111 0.9142973 X1*X3*X7
    0.815422 −0.84809 −0.45894 −0.88413 0.0181859 X1*X4*X6
    0.493878 0.203547 −0.2528 −0.43569 −0.1958555 X2*X3*X6
    0.256557 −0.06237 −0.25877 −0.0125 −0.2319322 X2*X4*X5
    0.220871 −0.61282 −0.2669 −0.02175 0.0929956 X1*X3*X8
    0.064053 −0.1714 −0.30714 −0.05011 0.3667094 X1*X4*X7
    −0.29289 0.039687 −0.23128 0.180217 −0.0177572 X1*X5*X6
    0.078293 0.408937 −0.12917 −1.16226 0.6496404 X2*X3*X7
    0.898708 −1.03228 −0.48039 −0.78522 −0.0401139 X2*X4*X6
    0.0915 0.310086 −0.27633 −0.62971 0.3183238 X3*X4*X5
    −0.04935 −0.21242 0.415688 0.466658 −0.1247571 X1*X4*X8
    0.0159 −0.00464 −0.14939 0.896552 0.0378157 X1*X5*X7
    0.30737 −0.07851 −0.4287 −0.73647 0.1885984 X2*X3*X8
    0.0024 0.024689 −0.34584 0.093854 0.2585262 X2*X4*X7
    −0.31307 0.301737 −0.04528 −0.18058 0.0528011 X2*X5*X6
    1.402584 −0.09761 0.49176 −0.40266 −0.2453313 X3*X4*X6
    −0.18872 0.235094 0.048899 0.625176 0.0348824 X1*X5*X8
    −0.32083 −0.07229 0.938313 0.455732 −0.0572186 X1*X6*X7
    0.080238 −0.22238 0.599487 0.489494 −0.178889 X2*X4*X8
    0.072749 −0.59915 0.596198 1.112758 −0.3587823 X2*X5*X7
    0.252546 −0.38424 1.430512 1.112136 0.3324322 X3*X4*X7
    −0.25503 0.888144 −0.19559 −0.54327 −0.4024524 X3*X5*X6
    0.724351 −0.69733 −0.21961 0.047505 −0.4312239 X1*X6*X8
    0.036301 0.042267 0.155748 0.27004 −0.0609612 X2*X5*X8
    −0.58043 0.010051 0.814339 1.055985 0.0129246 X2*X6*X7
    1.348292 −1.13073 −0.30939 −0.40764 −0.2969597 X3*X4*X8
    −0.35205 −0.1986 0.428399 −0.84829 −0.3945412 X3*X5*X7
    0.131113 0.220836 −0.21382 −0.34778 0.0344171 X4*X5*X6
    −0.27941 0.033886 −0.11227 −0.08138 0.4043953 X1*X7*X8
    0.780671 −0.27468 −0.30045 −0.12618 −0.310726 X2*X6*X8
    0.154203 0.367461 −0.34601 −0.32021 0.0957328 X3*X5*X8
    0.400996 0.238667 0.874774 0.761336 −0.7695738 X3*X6*X7
    −0.12892 0.050188 0.010194 0.006645 0.2199706 X4*X5*X7
    −0.09432 0.302933 0.062928 −0.52523 0.218943 X2*X7*X8
    2.373327 −1.48476 −0.53495 −0.11611 −0.6172811 X3*X6*X8
    0.086311 −0.11863 0.131575 0.058383 −0.0353397 X4*X5*X8
    0.277093 −0.26721 1.421102 0.10983 0.0088814 X4*X6*X7
    −0.18165 0.969705 −0.03391 0.753953 0.3524887 X3*X7*X8
    1.218325 −0.77491 −0.13311 −0.51012 −0.297565 X4*X6*X8
    −0.71351 1.069155 −0.20616 0.182572 0.0452514 X5*X6*X7
    0.807241 −0.7179 0.15679 −0.14507 −0.2137711 X4*X7*X8
    −0.10985 0.735279 −0.40728 −0.19674 0.0527789 X5*X6*X8
    −0.33354 0.669541 −0.18949 0.303635 0.3290144 X5*X7*X8
    0.362289 0.386427 −0.96376 0.404961 −0.2324204 X6*X7*X8
    4.27E−15 4.12E−13 −1.4E−13 1.36E−13 −3.866E−14 A
  • TABLE 11
    Case 4 Media Type Determining Equation Set (Part 2)
    Equation Coefficients
    Plain
    Paper Plain Paper Plain Paper
    Vinyl Light Standard Heavy Equation
    Glossy Labels Transparency weight Weight Weight Variables
    0.008334 −0.26056 −0.07356 0.483513 0.099907 −0.16058 X1
    −0.15216 0.381826 −0.05868 0.328938 −0.87234 −0.15998 X2
    −0.21507 −0.33809 0.324886 −1.78166 −1.38446 −0.01608 X3
    0.065257 −0.31483 −0.1304 −1.27301 1.951628 0.003238 X4
    0.143846 −0.42946 0.626293 −0.80779 0.226054 0.831227 X5
    −0.01532 −0.2415 −0.02236 −0.47534 0.460518 1.080084 X6
    0.22925 1.26534 −0.27918 −2.3858 1.271585 0.526066 X7
    0.032057 −0.3214 −0.13438 2.017673 −0.89928 −0.45866 X8
    −0.05885 0.10932 −0.01756 0.13558 −0.27366 −0.09209 X1 * X2
    0.249592 −0.27014 −0.014 −1.00513 −0.42268 −0.01302 X1 * X3
    −0.32841 −0.32345 0.060776 −1.16952 1.647236 0.590506 X1 * X4
    0.31468 −0.14485 0.05872 −0.41512 −0.61973 −0.22517 X2 * X3
    0.101336 −0.5882 −0.03299 −0.24967 0.737523 −0.2588 X1 * X5
    −0.12249 0.845214 0.017806 1.967854 −1.30142 −1.10405 X2 * X4
    0.037748 0.219486 −0.0124 0.150201 −0.13297 1.073289 X1 * X6
    −0.25424 −0.46771 −0.0121 −0.17734 0.584121 0.197559 X2 * X5
    0.163602 −1.49172 −0.01524 −0.78121 −0.18121 0.36917 X3 * X4
    0.05025 0.428918 0.147655 −0.66706 0.529668 0.154754 X1 * X7
    −3.8E−05 0.592474 0.008519 0.143424 −0.42899 −0.09884 X2 * X6
    −2.16129 2.095748 0.802578 −0.22818 0.513063 1.602894 X3 * X5
    −0.03415 −0.11482 0.014012 0.748159 −0.07097 −0.71833 X1 * X8
    −0.20669 0.448149 0.10001 −0.28985 −0.19341 −0.42956 X2 * X7
    0.00677 1.538433 −0.01333 −0.4441 −0.75426 −1.3176 X3 * X6
    0.056374 0.379234 −0.19786 0.109105 −0.13145 0.199614 X4 * X5
    −0.19214 0.037302 −0.01236 0.710697 −1.09759 0.187459 X2 * X8
    −0.05303 0.128428 −0.33012 −0.19522 −1.06511 0.237839 X3 * X7
    −0.0511 −0.18173 −0.08708 0.29394 −0.9022 0.949176 X4 * X6
    0.211277 −0.80354 −0.14112 −0.8314 −0.13327 0.261181 X3 * X8
    −0.05405 −1.96166 0.15335 −0.43197 0.451299 0.446387 X4 * X7
    0.223471 −0.40578 0.011947 −0.05765 0.009363 0.018909 X5 * X6
    0.194725 0.22561 0.022762 −1.5557 1.672419 −0.62536 X4 * X8
    1.266961 −0.45986 −1.37587 0.03446 −0.03855 0.437501 X5 * X7
    0.205098 −0.34798 −0.50868 1.285024 −1.46681 0.475909 X5 * X8
    0.05542 −0.30394 −0.04178 −0.21152 −0.38779 1.038434 X6 * X7
    0.039114 0.273978 −0.01833 0.137346 1.018175 −0.97071 X6 * X8
    −0.24973 −1.66504 0.355351 0.324745 0.580843 −0.70371 X7 * X8
    0.063588 −0.12122 0.054512 −0.27418 0.414275 0.149677 X1 * X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.012887 −0.02506 0.016639 −0.07566 0.102618 0.038228 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X2
    −0.02061 −0.20967 0.014708 0.049554 0.641834 0.143778 X1 * X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.18344 0.464822 0.001586 0.235528 −0.41629 −0.22781 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X3
    −0.14428 0.410198 0.051384 −0.45615 0.200308 0.320078 X1 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.15409 0.047776 0.016326 0.069817 0.454578 −0.12246 X2 * X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.031268 −0.73471 −0.00025 −1.26533 1.15006 0.663161 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    −0.31814 0.563877 −0.00529 0.242756 −0.06576 0.170893 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X3
    0.035858 0.066749 −0.09848 0.503014 −0.29418 −0.50306 X1 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.057447 0.294363 −0.01279 −0.65789 0.099669 0.269076 X2 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.05231 0.11786 0.068118 −0.17303 −0.38447 0.417128 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.31291 −0.565 −0.04447 −0.21447 0.162069 −0.02296 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    −0.06061 −0.32829 0.043306 −0.12123 0.216557 −0.04844 X1 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12999 −0.17929 0.009317 −0.06933 0.151816 0.175465 X2 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.084364 0.431634 −0.01714 0.220313 −0.4163 0.344879 X3 * X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02618 −0.25743 −0.01656 0.386359 −0.50979 −0.17594 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    0.459398 0.190069 0.065599 −0.00811 −0.42418 −0.20331 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.111737 −0.73338 0.009857 −0.0407 0.133934 −0.26779 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X4
    −0.02604 −0.15869 0.055637 0.135586 −0.05356 0.072599 X1 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.08806 −0.22499 0.081568 −0.25256 0.561151 −0.58836 X2 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −1.00914 0.606562 0.284071 0.046102 0.41409 0.873323 X3 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.01178 −0.44601 −0.05595 0.391251 −0.32461 −0.41315 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.106834 −0.12442 −0.05607 0.028828 0.004795 0.457357 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.52803 1.651051 0.058907 0.309708 0.281509 −0.24423 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    −0.00389 0.201007 −0.00094 −0.20202 −0.13431 0.354544 X1 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.015187 −0.34769 0.08246 0.06451 0.168016 0.228432 X2 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.025258 0.087945 −0.0199 0.185455 −0.1782 −0.50353 X3 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.134832 0.483539 −0.09509 0.093434 −0.54972 −0.26446 X4 * X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.099871 0.45514 0.006394 −0.49104 0.28598 0.126216 X1{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    0.149625 −0.24469 −0.21991 0.101241 0.099611 0.223656 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.19227 1.058495 −0.06144 0.363287 −0.27438 −1.13555 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    −0.27758 0.548618 0.051733 0.143376 0.006174 −0.17219 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X5
    0.007275 −0.0924 −0.00598 0.239579 −0.63768 0.493799 X2 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.05416 −0.13084 0.005373 1.114014 0.091439 −0.41398 X3 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00549 −0.21343 0.018918 0.140419 −0.13873 −0.22254 X4 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.057689 −0.27348 −0.00569 −0.31628 0.310727 0.195745 X2{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    0.145137 −0.77182 −0.07505 1.084537 0.625498 −0.01611 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    −0.05073 0.581663 −0.00916 0.428506 −0.77022 0.678208 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    0.024305 0.626202 −0.04456 −0.48323 0.609525 0.162889 X3 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.0503 −1.54554 0.162741 0.647692 −0.76602 0.1703 X4 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.112733 −0.36342 0.050533 0.004786 −0.00474 −0.30701 X5 * X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.095975 −0.28424 −0.08675 −0.36332 −0.22922 0.374847 X3{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    −0.13475 0.882325 0.052756 0.383859 −0.42301 0.595427 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.332893 0.017863 −0.13432 0.125973 −0.16843 −0.63801 X5{circumflex over ( )}2 * X6
    0.069911 −0.18661 0.016286 −0.83682 0.260991 0.414219 X4 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.05127 −1.19265 0.225417 0.090162 0.143798 −0.21253 X5 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.090659 −0.66751 0.022032 −0.47209 −0.12008 −0.1908 X4{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    0.998142 1.054438 −1.18461 1.04276 −1.06041 −0.48463 X5{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    −0.05968 0.151483 −0.03563 0.339599 −0.51738 0.269677 X5 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.15425 −0.91742 0.153801 0.440071 0.040726 −1.02964 X6 * X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.3314 0.063172 −0.25876 0.163682 −0.52787 0.026504 X5{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    −0.02894 −1.41937 0.070566 0.020657 0.199328 0.154472 X6{circumflex over ( )}2 * X7
    0.005695 0.376493 0.021879 −0.35252 0.694648 −0.14486 X6 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.004863 0.480603 −0.00331 −0.13929 0.073886 0.152801 X6{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    −0.10047 0.386874 0.067126 0.661709 −0.22279 0.017461 X7 * X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06321 −0.54661 0.144013 −0.60518 0.102708 0.35643 X7{circumflex over ( )}2 * X8
    −0.03717 0.194313 0.003083 0.009743 −0.27426 0.314884 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00768 0.086649 0.012692 −0.06566 −0.07393 0.161754 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.038819 −0.0695 0.044076 −0.21003 0.282245 0.112001 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.046229 −0.08778 0.03684 −0.18937 0.291741 0.104975 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.213497 −0.34489 0.080422 −0.25713 0.058924 −0.37002 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.095259 −0.28107 −0.00637 0.364989 0.377389 0.201308 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.09989 0.53888 0.043301 −0.46934 0.395873 0.081419 X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.04436 −0.08594 0.018229 −0.34727 0.073934 0.093728 X4{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.787932 −0.06127 0.749871 −0.69131 −0.57711 −0.61321 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.316445 −0.43198 0.332211 −0.26148 −0.07632 −0.54564 X5{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.02888 −0.8167 0.031787 −0.24029 0.200737 1.087402 X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.01576 −0.35017 0.003052 −0.03722 −0.01958 0.473513 X6{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.04754 2.19229 0.189532 −0.38815 −0.3681 0.408095 X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.03171 0.751564 0.067412 0.58956 −0.28391 −0.45187 X7{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.04099 0.712215 0.069639 −0.54337 0.556039 0.481705 X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.00864 0.059843 0.032812 −0.86241 0.715074 0.112728 X8{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.08322 0.298577 0.000794 −0.0088 −0.16956 0.091655 X1 * X2 * X3
    0.160214 −0.07112 −0.01747 0.580289 −0.37512 −0.40644 X1 * X2 * X4
    0.263306 −0.05903 0.009309 −0.02912 −0.02022 −0.20826 X1 * X2 * X5
    0.193875 −0.60161 −0.05888 −0.5636 −0.33581 0.459821 X1 * X3 * X4
    0.088528 0.158979 −0.0375 0.040853 −0.08436 0.399633 X1 * X2 * X6
    −0.26512 0.763972 −0.03223 −0.34436 1.088783 −0.06016 X1 * X3 * X5
    −0.00742 0.349736 −0.0529 0.615873 −0.86956 −0.26218 X2 * X3 * X4
    0.046114 0.014618 −0.10225 −0.04571 0.064741 0.090462 X1 * X2 * X7
    0.063517 0.517846 −0.03157 0.006537 0.322928 −0.66546 X1 * X3 * X6
    −0.23607 0.172301 0.035039 0.290442 −0.19931 −0.06287 X1 * X4 * X5
    −0.20104 −0.47338 −0.11842 0.4372 0.414599 0.322441 X2 * X3 * X5
    −0.03576 −0.26087 −0.00283 0.051125 −0.12461 0.137984 X1 * X2 * X8
    −0.03923 −0.71525 −0.10156 0.439384 0.182428 −0.01363 X1 * X3 * X7
    −0.114 0.465199 −0.01425 0.32004 −0.99512 1.390954 X1 * X4 * X6
    0.230703 0.667971 −0.01642 −0.37826 0.837159 −0.97283 X2 * X3 * X6
    0.129692 0.727401 0.038007 0.263506 −0.55616 −0.33523 X2 * X4 * X5
    0.140268 0.230195 −0.04605 −0.27446 0.173738 0.398033 X1 * X3 * X8
    −0.16733 −0.62232 0.177315 −0.47542 −0.24262 1.317815 X1 * X4 * X7
    0.156772 0.64452 0.031884 −0.01695 0.242023 −0.76439 X1 * X5 * X6
    0.033416 −0.56853 −0.05077 0.271349 0.473032 0.12496 X2 * X3 * X7
    −0.12838 0.87972 −0.04811 0.654619 −1.1611 1.006712 X2 * X4 * X6
    −0.20147 −0.39774 0.010047 0.08196 −0.21442 0.744706 X3 * X4 * X5
    0.003435 −0.01086 0.012796 −0.4701 0.58065 −0.5819 X1 * X4 * X8
    0.576581 −0.00706 0.016747 0.154406 −0.61813 −0.81063 X1 * X5 * X7
    0.180499 0.34086 0.009898 −0.24055 0.529418 −0.1564 X2 * X3 * X8
    −0.03514 0.293551 0.081938 0.171135 −0.51066 −0.1078 X2 * X4 * X7
    −0.30396 0.203527 0.031144 −0.00716 0.311411 0.022828 X2 * X5 * X6
    0.05101 −0.39829 −0.02456 0.135604 −0.20543 −0.69227 X3 * X4 * X6
    −0.04741 −0.09161 −0.09508 0.132019 −0.19861 −0.41266 X1 * X5 * X8
    −0.0819 −1.07915 0.048662 0.164458 −0.29504 0.191655 X1 * X6 * X7
    0.046107 −0.22552 −0.06191 1.723596 −1.88341 −0.34188 X2 * X4 * X8
    −0.43232 −0.1591 −0.10727 0.162957 −0.00579 −0.18417 X2 * X5 * X7
    0.135992 −2.58045 0.034051 0.342312 −0.51695 −0.06008 X3 * X4 * X7
    −0.59868 1.111615 0.08758 0.287463 0.003834 −0.18646 X3 * X5 * X6
    −0.07846 0.681727 −0.01024 0.069342 0.382232 −0.45796 X1 * X6 * X8
    −0.26168 −0.12156 −0.06269 0.001624 0.125841 −0.10503 X2 * X5 * X8
    −0.16413 −0.37255 0.073576 −0.28546 0.443843 −0.88881 X2 * X6 * X7
    0.154197 0.810208 −0.01472 −0.75301 0.900955 −0.23687 X3 * X4 * X8
    −0.77757 1.312509 −0.55074 0.704606 0.268034 0.41796 X3 * X5 * X7
    −0.18703 0.138185 −0.05783 0.209536 −0.41074 0.32196 X4 * X5 * X6
    −0.14313 −0.33643 0.140057 0.004691 1.02762 −0.64629 X1 * X7 * X8
    −0.05905 0.660023 −0.02037 0.040803 0.281258 −0.62077 X2 * X6 * X8
    −0.10889 −0.15184 −0.09955 0.164032 −0.34715 0.4481 X3 * X5 * X8
    0.069664 0.261902 −0.1005 0.613685 −0.20535 −1.95732 X3 * X6 * X7
    −0.12915 −0.23787 0.046583 0.207981 −0.38276 0.401301 X4 * X5 * X7
    0.028585 0.128449 0.096828 0.36848 0.297074 −0.98261 X2 * X7 * X8
    0.089988 0.792047 −0.07317 −0.22195 −0.25763 −0.134 X3 * X6 * X8
    0.012718 0.0203 −0.01428 0.257937 −0.07241 −0.34114 X4 * X5 * X8
    −0.12118 −1.20935 0.095071 0.900399 −1.15467 −0.03173 X4 * X6 * X7
    −0.01389 −1.23558 0.039361 −0.55595 −0.60764 0.760828 X3 * X7 * X8
    0.036954 0.675967 −0.00634 −0.44508 0.52597 −0.38792 X4 * X6 * X8
    0.284669 −0.53585 −0.11066 0.244735 0.190827 −0.59387 X5 * X6 * X7
    0.038589 0.559155 0.0745 −0.3852 1.094862 −1.06848 X4 * X7 * X8
    0.095748 0.038007 −0.11768 0.04489 −0.05278 −0.17255 X5 * X6 * X8
    0.179035 −0.85389 −0.01738 −0.10464 0.084094 −0.01803 X5 * X7 * X8
    −0.10711 0.275223 0.112764 −0.14654 −0.40869 0.532016 X6 * X7 * X8
    3.22E−14 −5.1E−13 −1.7E−14 −5.6E−14 −1.4E−13 2.28E−13 A
  • Because there are so many cross-identifications that need to be made, the number of significant terms increases substantially with the number of media types which need to be differentiated. It is not necessary, however, to have the same terms in each equation. The following table shows the most significant terms for each media type. These are organized into terms for which increased sensor output is a positive indicator, and those for which increased sensor signal is a negative indicator.
  • TABLE 12
    Case 4 Highest Contributing Terms For Each Media Type
    Media Type Positive Equation Terms Negative Equation Terms
    Glossy X5*X7 X3*X5, X3*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    Vinyl Labels X7, X3*X5, X3*X6, X7*X8, X3*X4*X7, X3*X7*X8,
    X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X6, X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7, X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X4*X6*X7
    X3*X5*X6, X3*X5*X7
    Transparency X3*X5 X5*X7, X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    Plain Paper, Light X8, X2*X4, X2*X4*X8, X7, X4*X8, X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X4, X1*X4,
    X3*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X7, X1*X3, X3, X4
    X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7, X5*X8
    Plain Paper, Medium X4, X7, X1*X4, X4*X8, X3, X2*X4, X2*X8, X3*X7,
    X6*X8, X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X4, X5*X8, X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7, X2*X4*X6,
    X1*X7*X8, X4*X7*X8 X2*X4*X8, X4*X6*X7
    Plain Paper, Heavy X6, X1*X6, X3*X5, X6*X7, X2*X4, X3*X6, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X6,
    X1*X4*X6, X2*X4*X6 X6*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X4*X7*X8
    Cardstock, lighter X3*X6, X4*X6, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X6, X3*X7, X5*X6*X7
    X1*X3*X6, X3*X4*X6,
    X3*X4*X8, X3*X6*X8,
    X4*X6*X8
    Cardstock, heavier X3*X7, X7*X8, X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X6, X6*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X2*X4*X6, X3*X4*X8,
    X2*X6{circumflex over ( )}2, X5*X6*X7 X3*X6*X8
    Paper Labels X4*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X6*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X7
    X3*X4*X7, X4*X6*X7
    Bond X3, X7, X1*X3, X2*X5*X7, X5, X8, X3*X5, X4*X6,
    X3*X4*X7, X2*X6*X7 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2, X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X5,
    X3*X7{circumflex over ( )}2, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X7, X3{circumflex over ( )}2,,
    X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    Envelopes X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2, X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X7 X3*X6
  • Case 5 illustrates a further facet of the present system in its ability to empirically provide for unique but measureable characteristics. Here the media type is one of Current Tray Setting or Not Current Tray Setting. The sensors are: temperature (X1), relative humidity (X2), bending stiffness (X3), impedance magnitude (X4), impedance phase (X5), piezoelectric (X6), gloss (X7), media feed motor current (X8), optical average (X9), and optical deviation (X10). The use of this media type determining equation set is to confirm that the media type present in the tray is actually the media type that the imagining device has been set to expect via a default setting or by user input.
  • TABLE 13
    Case 5 Media Type Determining Equation Terms and Coefficients
    Equation Coefficients
    Not
    Media Media
    Tray Tray Equation
    Setting Setting Terms
    0.392198 −0.3922 X1
    −0.21532 0.215322 X2
    −0.34959 0.349589 X3
    −1.61869 1.618695 X4
    0.649465 −0.64947 X5
    −0.20153 0.201533 X6
    0.095659 −0.09566 X7
    0.41543 −0.41543 X8
    0.74879 −0.74879 X9
    −0.66235 0.662346 X10
    −0.09979 0.099786 X1*X2
    −0.32922 0.329224 X1*X3
    −0.11913 0.119131 X1*X4
    0.037662 −0.03766 X2*X3
    0.593923 −0.59392 X1*X5
    −0.39819 0.398186 X2*X4
    −0.03036 0.030365 X1*X6
    0.227733 −0.22773 X2*X5
    0.714031 −0.71403 X3*X4
    0.351761 −0.35176 X1*X7
    −0.52856 0.528565 X2*X6
    −0.45134 0.451339 X3*X5
    0.152689 −0.15269 X1*X8
    0.471173 −0.47117 X2*X7
    −0.38101 0.381006 X3*X6
    −0.5 0.499997 X4*X5
    0.166312 −0.16631 X1*X9
    −0.28433 0.284328 X2*X8
    −0.40146 0.401462 X3*X7
    −0.82183 0.821829 X4*X6
    −0.11683 0.116833 X1*X10
    0.029629 −0.02963 X2*X9
    −0.4343 0.434298 X3*X8
    0.823381 −0.82338 X4*X7
    0.404232 −0.40423 X5*X6
    0.034223 −0.03422 X2*X10
    −0.03628 0.036278 X3*X9
    −0.08499 0.084995 X4*X8
    0.10603 −0.10603 X5*X7
    0.387408 −0.38741 X3*X10
    −1.57542 1.575417 X4*X9
    0.174785 −0.17478 X5*X8
    −0.17738 0.177377 X6*X7
    −0.12492 0.124916 X4*X10
    0.422478 −0.42248 X5*X9
    0.955331 −0.95533 X6*X8
    −0.67126 0.671263 X5*X10
    1.642136 −1.64214 X6*X9
    −0.19022 0.190223 X7*X8
    −1.07103 1.071031 X6*X10
    −0.09467 0.094671 X7*X9
    0.585393 −0.58539 X7*X10
    0.350863 −0.35086 X8*X9
    −0.20693 0.206927 X8*X10
    −0.24222 0.24222 X9*X10
    −0.00424 0.004238 X1*X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.01849 0.018489 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X2
    −0.07571 0.075706 X1*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.16202 0.162018 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    0.023809 −0.02381 X1*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06483 0.064831 X2*X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.143068 −0.14307 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    0.017994 −0.01799 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X3
    −0.14988 0.149876 X1*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.07459 0.074586 X2*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.248391 −0.24839 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    0.559786 −0.55979 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    −0.43422 0.434218 X1*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.23801 0.238015 X2*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.765897 −0.7659 X3*X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.04636 0.046359 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.16869 −0.16869 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    0.206799 −0.2068 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X4
    −0.39389 0.393892 X1*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12102 0.121018 X2*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12624 0.126241 X3*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.33551 0.335508 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.034876 −0.03488 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    −0.1061 0.106103 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.07525 0.075246 X1*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.299633 −0.29963 X2*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.050744 −0.05074 X3*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.043682 −0.04368 X4*X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.005082 −0.00508 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.65839 0.658391 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    −0.15007 0.15007 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    −0.44138 0.441375 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X5
    −0.2356 0.235603 X1*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.09121 0.091206 X2*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.014659 −0.01466 X3*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.144011 −0.14401 X4*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.2481 0.248105 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    −0.03678 0.036785 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.18586 0.185861 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    −0.29367 0.293665 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.26522 −0.26522 X1*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.11792 0.117918 X2*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.28022 0.280216 X3*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.569179 −0.56918 X4*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12589 0.125893 X5*X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.049607 −0.04961 X1{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.139017 −0.13902 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    −0.27999 0.279991 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.400057 −0.40006 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    −0.40352 0.403516 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X6
    0.272747 −0.27275 X2*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.125748 −0.12575 X3*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.04443 0.044431 X4*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.38804 0.388044 X5*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.010946 −0.01095 X2{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.026099 −0.0261 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    0.128374 −0.12837 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.0977 0.097698 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.112268 −0.11227 X3*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.57072 0.570721 X4*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02157 0.021574 X5*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −1.17249 1.172486 X6*X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.177258 −0.17726 X3{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    −0.48689 0.48689 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    −0.02917 0.02917 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.351264 −0.35126 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X7
    0.172658 −0.17266 X4*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.21287 0.212866 X5*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.02781 0.027815 X6*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.191457 −0.19146 X4{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.053537 −0.05354 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    0.394465 −0.39447 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    −0.01713 0.017129 X5*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.504408 −0.50441 X6*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.16856 0.168563 X7*X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.54755 0.547553 X5{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.589201 −0.5892 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    −0.3931 0.393102 X7{circumflex over ( )}2*X8
    0.325506 −0.32551 X6*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.027363 −0.02736 X7*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.45764 0.45764 X6{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    −0.66756 0.667563 X7{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    0.232242 −0.23224 X7*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.12155 0.121549 X8*X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.03118 0.031175 X7{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.087035 −0.08704 X8{circumflex over ( )}2*X9
    −0.05629 0.056286 X8*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.17974 0.179739 X8{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    −0.26172 0.261719 X9*X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.237149 −0.23715 X9{circumflex over ( )}2*X10
    0.068742 −0.06874 X1{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.001726 −0.00173 X1{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.03659 0.036588 X2{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.005717 −0.00572 X2{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.22425 0.224245 X3{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.11607 0.116067 X3{circumflex over ( )}3
    −1.08999 1.089989 X4{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.004207 −0.00421 X4{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.15123 0.151232 X5{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.26763 0.267628 X5{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.72407 0.724066 X6{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.45835 0.458355 X6{circumflex over ( )}3
    −1.1929 1.192896 X7{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.42005 0.420047 X7{circumflex over ( )}3
    −0.04523 0.045227 X8{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.06928 0.069284 X8{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.033054 −0.03305 X9{circumflex over ( )}2
    −0.26327 0.263266 X9{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.073182 −0.07318 X10{circumflex over ( )}2
    0.264724 −0.26472 X10{circumflex over ( )}3
    0.031831 −0.03183 X1*X2*X3
    0.325466 −0.32547 X1*X2*X4
    0.19262 −0.19262 X1*X2*X5
    0.360998 −0.361 X1*X3*X4
    −0.1275 0.127503 X1*X2*X6
    −0.22275 0.222751 X1*X3*X5
    0.356181 −0.35618 X2*X3*X4
    −0.27042 0.270415 X1*X2*X7
    0.146347 −0.14635 X1*X3*X6
    0.054064 −0.05406 X1*X4*X5
    −0.23348 0.233479 X2*X3*X5
    −0.1187 0.118696 X1*X2*X8
    −0.11296 0.112962 X1*X3*X7
    0.30988 −0.30988 X1*X4*X6
    0.109666 −0.10967 X2*X3*X6
    0.180193 −0.18019 X2*X4*X5
    0.138588 −0.13859 X1*X2*X9
    −0.16146 0.161457 X1*X3*X8
    0.618789 −0.61879 X1*X4*X7
    0.041566 −0.04157 X1*X5*X6
    0.335233 −0.33523 X2*X3*X7
    −0.40252 0.40252 X2*X4*X6
    −0.09183 0.09183 X3*X4*X5
    0.025335 −0.02533 X1*X2*X10
    −0.18679 0.186789 X1*X3*X9
    0.077534 −0.07753 X1*X4*X8
    −0.06461 0.064615 X1*X5*X7
    −0.08829 0.088292 X2*X3*X8
    0.864694 −0.86469 X2*X4*X7
    −0.02159 0.021592 X2*X5*X6
    0.182978 −0.18298 X3*X4*X6
    0.218334 −0.21833 X1*X3*X10
    −0.34019 0.340194 X1*X4*X9
    −0.00043 0.000427 X1*X5*X8
    0.10574 −0.10574 X1*X6*X7
    0.004416 −0.00442 X2*X3*X9
    0.00611 −0.00611 X2*X4*X8
    −0.58429 0.584295 X2*X5*X7
    0.371243 −0.37124 X3*X4*X7
    −0.04809 0.048086 X3*X5*X6
    0.428082 −0.42808 X1*X4*X10
    0.115725 −0.11573 X1*X5*X9
    0.303479 −0.30348 X1*X6*X8
    −0.02667 0.026671 X2*X3*X10
    0.054578 −0.05458 X2*X4*X9
    −0.12133 0.121326 X2*X5*X8
    0.074864 −0.07486 X2*X6*X7
    0.256921 −0.25692 X3*X4*X8
    −0.30341 0.303408 X3*X5*X7
    0.007407 −0.00741 X4*X5*X6
    −0.44697 0.446969 X1*X5*X10
    0.122725 −0.12272 X1*X6*X9
    −0.01008 0.010077 X1*X7*X8
    0.318501 −0.3185 X2*X4*X10
    −0.19568 0.195683 X2*X5*X9
    0.022128 −0.02213 X2*X6*X8
    0.859187 −0.85919 X3*X4*X9
    −0.21601 0.216007 X3*X5*X8
    −0.55128 0.551277 X3*X6*X7
    0.078494 −0.07849 X4*X5*X7
    −0.17216 0.172155 X1*X6*X10
    −0.25009 0.250095 X1*X7*X9
    −0.36721 0.367207 X2*X5*X10
    −0.23975 0.239747 X2*X6*X9
    0.094702 −0.0947 X2*X7*X8
    0.662477 −0.66248 X3*X4*X10
    −0.36267 0.362669 X3*X5*X9
    −0.44733 0.447328 X3*X6*X8
    −0.14987 0.149866 X4*X5*X8
    −0.19691 0.196906 X4*X6*X7
    0.497398 −0.4974 X1*X7*X10
    −0.14898 0.148985 X1*X8*X9
    0.342745 −0.34274 X2*X6*X10
    −0.16357 0.163575 X2*X7*X9
    −0.04455 0.044553 X3*X5*X10
    −0.33785 0.337846 X3*X6*X9
    −0.32596 0.325962 X3*X7*X8
    −0.64484 0.644836 X4*X5*X9
    0.174275 −0.17428 X4*X6*X8
    0.029496 −0.0295 X5*X6*X7
    0.070413 −0.07041 X1*X8*X10
    0.415767 −0.41577 X2*X7*X10
    −0.54171 0.541714 X2*X8*X9
    0.263033 −0.26303 X3*X6*X10
    0.079443 −0.07944 X3*X7*X9
    0.021509 −0.02151 X4*X5*X10
    −0.45956 0.459559 X4*X6*X9
    0.227948 −0.22795 X4*X7*X8
    0.264222 −0.26422 X5*X6*X8
    −0.08646 0.086464 X1*X9*X10
    0.173404 −0.1734 X2*X8*X10
    −0.11982 0.119819 X3*X7*X10
    0.099572 −0.09957 X3*X8*X9
    0.079014 −0.07901 X4*X6*X10
    0.854689 −0.85469 X4*X7*X9
    0.371977 −0.37198 X5*X6*X9
    −0.03903 0.039028 X5*X7*X8
    0.087049 −0.08705 X2*X9*X10
    0.066701 −0.0667 X3*X8*X10
    0.169131 −0.16913 X4*X7*X10
    0.011573 −0.01157 X4*X8*X9
    −0.37003 0.370029 X5*X6*X10
    −0.26829 0.268288 X5*X7*X9
    −0.27338 0.273379 X6*X7*X8
    0.289892 −0.28989 X3*X9*X10
    0.137863 −0.13786 X4*X8*X10
    −0.00124 0.001243 X5*X7*X10
    −0.26242 0.262417 X5*X8*X9
    −0.70348 0.70348 X6*X7*X9
    −0.0233 0.023298 X4*X9*X10
    −0.03544 0.035437 X5*X8*X10
    0.749406 −0.74941 X6*X7*X10
    0.569549 −0.56955 X6*X8*X9
    −0.16385 0.163854 X5*X9*X10
    −0.2438 0.243799 X6*X8*X10
    −0.03367 0.033668 X7*X8*X9
    −0.4882 0.488196 X6*X9*X10
    −0.06464 0.064645 X7*X8*X10
    0.029627 −0.02963 X7*X9*X10
    0.063429 −0.06343 X8*X9*X10
    −2.1E−14 −7.8E−14 A
  • It is possible to either expand or contract the number of terms used in each equation depending on the resolution desired in discerning different media types by adjusting the selection criteria used for the coefficients. The media type determining equations may be condensed when certain terms are found to be insignificant contributors to the solution. This would be empirically determined. This is a matter of design choice and the number of terms chosen is influenced by processing power of the controller, memory available, sensor cost, space within the operational device to accommodate the sensor set.
  • Types are not limited to different types of media. A type may be media color, the presence of perforations in the media, the presence of an RFID strip on the media, the presence of a magnetic strip on the media, the presence of holes, preprinted media such as a form, media size. A type can be any distinguishing feature or characteristic provided that there is a corresponding sensor within the sensor sets 14 and 52 to detect these features or characteristics.
  • The foregoing description of several methods and an embodiment of the invention has been presented for purposes of illustration. It is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise steps and/or forms disclosed, and obviously many modifications and variations are possible in light of the above teaching. It is intended that the scope of the invention be defined by the claims appended hereto.

Claims (33)

What is claimed is:
1. In an operational imaging device having a media set consisting of M types of media and an operational sensor set for measuring values of a predetermined set of N variables related to a media sheet and the processing thereof by a processing device of the operational imaging device, a method of determining a media type from the M types of media for a media sheet to be processed by the processing device in the imaging device, the method comprising:
storing in memory of the imaging device a predetermined media type determining equation set incorporating the predetermined set of N variables wherein each equation corresponds to one media type of the M types of media in the media set;
measuring, using the operational sensor set, a value of each variable in the set of N variables, the operational sensor set providing corresponding output signals representative of the measured values for the set of N variables, the operational sensor set being in operative communication with a controller; and
at the controller:
converting the output signals received from the operational sensor set into measured normalized variable values for the set of N variables;
solving the media type determining equation set using the measured normalized variable values to determine a media type for the media sheet to be processed; and,
selecting, based upon the determined media type, at least one operational parameter for the processing device for processing the media sheet.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein solving further comprises determining whether or not the solutions of at least two of the media types determining equations are within a predetermined range of one another, and, when it is determined that the at least two solutions are within the predetermined range, using a lookup table to select the determined media type based on the combinations of the at least two media type determining equations.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein the selecting the at least one operational parameter is performed using a look up table.
4. The method of claim 1, wherein each equation in the media type determining equation set is a polynomial equation.
5. The method of claim 4, wherein an order of each polynomial equation is selected to be in the range of a first order through a fifth order.
6. The method of claim 1, wherein each equation in the media type determining equation set is a Taylor polynomial.
7. The method of claim 1, wherein the operational sensor set includes one or more direct sensors.
8. The method of claim 1, wherein the operational sensor set includes one or more indirect sensors.
9. The method of claim 1, wherein the operational sensor set includes one or more imaging subsystem response sensors.
10. The method of claim 1, wherein the processing device is an electrophotographic printer and the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: electrical impedance magnitude, electrical impedance phase, contact resistance, capacitance, optical transmission mean, optical transmission deviation, optical spectral reflectance, optical diffuse reflectance, bending stiffness, acoustic transmission, temperature, media size, relative humidity, media feed motor current, fuser temperature, transfer current, transfer voltage, media holes, preprinted areas, media color, multilayer media, RFID signal, magnetic field, MICR, and, further wherein, the operational sensor set includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
11. The method of claim 1, wherein the processing device is an electrophotographic printer and the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: impedance phase, impedance magnitude, optical spectral reflection mean, optical spectral reflection deviation, optical transmission mean, optical transmission deviation, temperature, relative humidity, media feed motor current, and, further wherein, the operational sensor sets includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
12. The method of claim 11, wherein the M media types comprise a plain paper light type, a plain paper standard type, a plain paper heavy type, a cardstock light type, a cardstock standard type, a cardstock heavy type, a glossy paper light type, a glossy paper standard type, a glossy paper heavy type, a paper label type, a paper label heavy type, a plastic label type, a plastic label heavy type, a polymer label type, an envelope standard type, an envelope heavy type, a synthetic polymer type, and a rough/cotton paper type, and, further wherein, the at least two variables comprise at least four variables.
13. The method of claim 12, wherein for each of the M media types, the media type determining equation set contains a media type determining equation corresponding to each of the M media types.
14. The method of claim 11, wherein the M media types comprise a polymeric media type, a cardstock media type and a plain paper media type.
15. The method of claim 14, wherein the set of M media determining equations comprises a polymeric media type determining equation, a cardstock media type determining equation and a plain paper media type determining equation.
16. The method of claim 1, wherein the processing device is an electrophotographic printer and the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: optical transmission mean, optical transmission deviation, temperature, relative humidity, media feed motor current, and, further wherein, the operational sensor sets includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
17. The method of claim 16, wherein the M media types comprise a polymeric media type, a cardstock media type, a plain paper media type, and a light plain paper media type.
18. The method of claim 17, wherein the set of M media determining equations comprises a polymeric media type determining equation, a cardstock media type determining equation, a plain paper media type determining equation and a light plain paper media type determining equation.
19. The method of claim 1, wherein each equation in the set of M media type determining equations comprises a plurality of terms with each term having a coefficient wherein the coefficients of a larger absolute value in comparison to the other coefficients in each equation have a greater weight in determining the media type.
20. The method of claim 19, wherein each equation of the media type determining equation set is truncated so that the remaining terms in each equation of the media type detrmining equation set have coefficients of a larger absolute value when compared to the coefficients of the truncated terms from that equation.
21. The method of claim 1, wherein the media type determining equation set stored in memory is generated by:
determining the M media types forming the media set to be used in the operational imaging device;
determining the number of variables in the set of N variables needed to determine each media type in the media set;
providing a training sensor set for measuring the set of the N variables and providing corresponding output signals therefor;
using the training set of sensors to measure the set of N variables with a known sample of each media type in the media set and a training imaging device to create a corresponding training data set for each media type in the media set;
inputting each training data set for each media type into a classifier training engine; and
generating, using the classifier training engine, the media type determining equation for each media type in the media set forming the media type determining equation set.
22. The method of claim 21, wherein the classifier training engine is one of a support vector engine, a neural network, a quadratic classifier, a Bayesian network, and a learning vector quantizer.
23. The method of claim 22, wherein when the media type determining equation set consists of polynomial equations.
24. The method of claim 23, wherein the number of terms in each equation in the set of M media type determining equations is reduced using a polynomial consolidator.
25. The method of claim 23, further comprising weighting the terms of each equation in the media type determining equation set using an expert knowledge cost/value weighter.
26. A method of media type sensing for use in an operational imaging device, the method comprising:
establishing a media set comprising a plurality of media types M to be used in the operational imaging device;
determining a number of variables N needed to determine each media type in the media set;
providing a training sensor set for measuring each of the N variables and providing corresponding output signal therefor;
using the training sensor set to measure the N variables with a known sample of each media type in the media set and a training imaging device to create a corresponding training data set for each media type in the media set, wherein the measuring includes taking multiple measurements of each of the N variables;
inputting each training data set for each media type into a classifier training engine;
generating, using the classifier training engine and each training data set for each media type, a media type determining equation for each media type incorporating corresponding N variable terms to create a set of M media type determining equations for use with an operational set of sensors corresponding to the training set sensors; and
in an operational imaging device:
storing in a memory the set of M media type determining equations;
providing the operational sensor set in operable communication with the operational imaging device, the operational sensor set measuring a value of each variable in the set of N variables and providing corresponding output signals for the measured N variables for a sheet of media to be processed;
converting the received output signals into the N measured normalized variable values;
solving the set of M media type determining equations using the N measured normalized variable values to determine a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed; and,
selecting, based upon the determined media type, from a look up table at least one operational parameter for the operational imaging device.
27. The method of claim 26, wherein the measuring of multiple measurements of each of the N variables by the training sensor set occurs at a plurality of predetermined temperature and relative humidity combinations.
28. The method of claim 26, wherein the operational imaging device is an electrophotographic printer and the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: electrical impedance magnitude, electrical impedance phase, contact resistance, capacitance, optical transmission mean; optical transmission deviation, optical spectral reflectance, optical diffuse reflectance, bending stiffness, acoustic transmission, temperature, media size, relative humidity, media feed motor current, fuser temperature, transfer current, transfer voltage, media holes, preprinted areas, media color, multilayer media, RFID signal, magnetic field, MICR, and, further wherein, the operational sensor set includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
29. In an operational imaging device having a media set consisting of M types of media and an operational sensor set having S number of sensors for measuring a value for each variable in a set of N variables related to a media sheet and the processing thereof by a processing device of the operational imaging device, a controller in operative communication with the operational sensor set and receiving the corresponding output signals representative of the measured values for the set of N variables, a method of determining a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed by the processing device in the operational imaging device, the method comprising:
storing in memory of the imaging device a predetermined matrix consisting of a first media type determining equation set and S! additional sets of media type determining equation sets, wherein the first media type determining equation set in the matrix comprises M media type determining equations using measured variable values from the S number of sensors and the remaining S! additional media type determining equation sets each comprise a plurality of media type determining equations where one or more variables in the set of N variables is missing; and,
determining whether or not all S number of sensors in the operational sensor set are functioning and, when it is determined that all S number of sensors are functioning:
converting the received output signals into the N measured normalized variable values;
solving the first media type determining equation set using the received N measured normalized variable values to determine a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed; and
selecting, based upon the determined media type, at least one operational parameter for the processing device for processing the media sheet.
30. The method of claim 29, wherein, when it is determined that one or more of the S number of sensors are non-functioning:
selecting from the S! additional media type determining equation sets a corresponding media type determining equation set having media type determining equations that use measured variable values from the remaining functioning sensors in the operational sensor set;
converting the received output signals from the remaining functioning sensors into measured normalized variable values;
solving the selected additional media type determining equation set using the measured normalized variable values to determine a media type from the media set for the media sheet to be processed; and,
selecting, based upon the determined media type, at least one operational parameter for the processing device for processing the media sheet.
31. An imaging device comprising:
a controller;
a fuser;
an image transfer station
an input area having a media set consisting of M types of media;
an output area for receiving processed a media sheet;
a media feed system for conveying a media sheet to be processed from the input area past the image transfer station and the fuser to the output area;
an operational sensor set for measuring values of a predetermined set of N variables related to the media sheet to be processed and the processing thereof and providing corresponding output signals representative of the measured set of N variables;
a memory containing a predetermined media set of M media type determining equations incorporating the predetermined set of N variables wherein each media type determining equation corresponds to one media type in the media set; and
the fuser, the image transfer station, the media feed system, the operational sensor set and the memory in operative communication with the controller with the controller being configured to:
receive the output signals of the operational sensor set and convert the received output signals into corresponding normalized values for each variable in the set of N variables;
solve the M media equations using the received values for the set of N variables to determine a type of media for the media sheet to be processed;
select, based upon the determined media type, at least one operational parameter for the processing device; and
process the media sheet to be processed using the at least one operational parameter.
32. The imaging device of claim 31, wherein the set of N variables comprises at least two variables selected from the group comprising: electrical impedance magnitude, electrical impedance phase, contact resistance, capacitance, optical transmission mean; optical transmission deviation, optical spectral reflectance, optical diffuse reflectance, bending stiffness, acoustic transmission, temperature, media size, relative humidity, media feed motor current, fuser temperature, transfer current, transfer voltage, media holes, preprinted areas, media color, multilayer media, RFID signal, magnetic field, MICR, and, further wherein, the operational sensor set includes sensors for measuring the at least two selected variables.
33. The imaging device of claim 31 wherein the at least one operational parameter is one of a transfer voltage, a fuser temperature, a media process speed, and a combination of two or more of foregoing operational parameters.
US14/295,838 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type Abandoned US20160044195A1 (en)

Priority Applications (2)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US14/295,851 US9367005B2 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging device and method for determining operating parameters
US14/295,838 US20160044195A1 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
US14/295,838 US20160044195A1 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type

Publications (1)

Publication Number Publication Date
US20160044195A1 true US20160044195A1 (en) 2016-02-11

Family

ID=55268372

Family Applications (2)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
US14/295,851 Expired - Fee Related US9367005B2 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging device and method for determining operating parameters
US14/295,838 Abandoned US20160044195A1 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type

Family Applications Before (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
US14/295,851 Expired - Fee Related US9367005B2 (en) 2014-06-04 2014-06-04 Imaging device and method for determining operating parameters

Country Status (1)

Country Link
US (2) US9367005B2 (en)

Cited By (14)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US9451111B1 (en) * 2015-08-24 2016-09-20 Lexmark International, Inc. Method of determining a media class in an imaging device using an optical translucence sensor
US20180150012A1 (en) * 2016-11-28 2018-05-31 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Image forming apparatus and system
US20180260501A1 (en) * 2017-03-10 2018-09-13 General Electric Company Systems and methods for overlaying and integrating computer aided design (cad) drawings with fluid models
US10331985B2 (en) * 2016-08-31 2019-06-25 Konica Minolta Laboratory U.S.A., Inc. Method and system for verification of print media within a tray
JP2020121503A (en) * 2019-01-31 2020-08-13 セイコーエプソン株式会社 Printer, machine learning device, machine learning method and printing control program
EP3702968A1 (en) * 2019-02-28 2020-09-02 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Information processing apparatus, printing apparatus, and information processing method
US10803211B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2020-10-13 General Electric Company Multiple fluid model tool for interdisciplinary fluid modeling
US10963599B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-03-30 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for utilizing a 3D CAD point-cloud to automatically create a fluid model
US10977397B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-04-13 Altair Engineering, Inc. Optimization of prototype and machine design within a 3D fluid modeling environment
JP2021062565A (en) * 2019-10-16 2021-04-22 セイコーエプソン株式会社 Information processor, leaning device, control method of information processor, and program
US11004568B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-05-11 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for multi-dimensional fluid modeling of an organism or organ
US11025791B2 (en) * 2019-03-28 2021-06-01 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Information processing apparatus, printing apparatus, information processing method, and program, providing accurate identification of the type of a printing medium by increasing the opportunity to improve the accuracy of determining the type of printing medium based on measurement results
EP4009110A1 (en) * 2020-12-04 2022-06-08 Konica Minolta, Inc. Parameter determination apparatus, image forming apparatus, post-processing apparatus, sheet feeding apparatus, and creation method of determination model
US11752783B2 (en) 2018-12-06 2023-09-12 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Print media modes

Families Citing this family (9)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP6684145B2 (en) * 2016-04-28 2020-04-22 キヤノン株式会社 Image forming device
JP2019060952A (en) * 2017-09-25 2019-04-18 コニカミノルタ株式会社 Image forming device
US10310790B1 (en) * 2017-11-29 2019-06-04 Lexmark International, Inc. System and methods for reducing component wear in an imaging device
US11560279B2 (en) * 2019-07-02 2023-01-24 Kyocera Document Solutions Inc. Systems and methods for classifying sheets of a printing device
JP7232161B2 (en) * 2019-09-24 2023-03-02 株式会社リコー image forming device
JP7287266B2 (en) * 2019-12-20 2023-06-06 沖電気工業株式会社 Machine learning device, data processing system, machine learning method, and data processing method
JP7375575B2 (en) * 2020-01-27 2023-11-08 セイコーエプソン株式会社 Printing device and its control method
JP7434999B2 (en) * 2020-02-14 2024-02-21 コニカミノルタ株式会社 Image forming apparatus, image forming system, paper processing method, and program
JP7449122B2 (en) * 2020-03-05 2024-03-13 キヤノン株式会社 Image forming device

Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6163662A (en) * 1999-07-06 2000-12-19 Hewlett-Packard Company Image forming devices, fusing assemblies, and methods of forming an image using control circuitry to control fusing operations
US20020156754A1 (en) * 2001-04-23 2002-10-24 Swimm Richard S. Media selection using a neural network
US20030090727A1 (en) * 2001-11-13 2003-05-15 Scitex Digital Printing, Inc. Simplified tone scale correction
US20030132366A1 (en) * 2002-01-15 2003-07-17 Jun Gao Cluster-weighted modeling for media classification
US20050087010A1 (en) * 2001-08-21 2005-04-28 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Signal output apparatus, image forming apparatus and information output apparatus
US20080003001A1 (en) * 2006-06-09 2008-01-03 Jouni Marttila Methods for controlling print quality
US20140368846A1 (en) * 2011-12-27 2014-12-18 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Press color state estimator

Family Cites Families (11)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6816686B2 (en) * 2003-02-25 2004-11-09 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Electrophotographic imaging and fusing apparatus and methods
KR100524026B1 (en) * 2003-06-20 2005-10-26 삼성전자주식회사 Printer which comprises Series-model supporting firmware and series-model supporting method
US7113718B2 (en) * 2004-04-30 2006-09-26 Eastman Kodak Company Method and apparatus for reducing image artifacts caused by release fluid in an electrophotographic machine
JP5317439B2 (en) * 2007-07-10 2013-10-16 キヤノン株式会社 Image forming apparatus
US7877028B2 (en) * 2007-12-10 2011-01-25 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Apparatus and a method for forming an image on a sheet
US8095226B2 (en) * 2009-02-02 2012-01-10 Xerox Corporation Methods and systems to schedule gains in process control loops
JP2011191569A (en) * 2010-03-15 2011-09-29 Ricoh Co Ltd Printing device and image forming apparatus
JP5310691B2 (en) * 2010-10-01 2013-10-09 コニカミノルタ株式会社 Fixing apparatus and image forming apparatus
JP5871515B2 (en) * 2011-08-16 2016-03-01 キヤノン株式会社 Image forming apparatus and density information acquisition method
JP2014167612A (en) * 2013-01-31 2014-09-11 Toshiba Corp Image forming apparatus
JP5915866B2 (en) * 2013-12-11 2016-05-11 コニカミノルタ株式会社 Image forming apparatus

Patent Citations (7)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US6163662A (en) * 1999-07-06 2000-12-19 Hewlett-Packard Company Image forming devices, fusing assemblies, and methods of forming an image using control circuitry to control fusing operations
US20020156754A1 (en) * 2001-04-23 2002-10-24 Swimm Richard S. Media selection using a neural network
US20050087010A1 (en) * 2001-08-21 2005-04-28 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Signal output apparatus, image forming apparatus and information output apparatus
US20030090727A1 (en) * 2001-11-13 2003-05-15 Scitex Digital Printing, Inc. Simplified tone scale correction
US20030132366A1 (en) * 2002-01-15 2003-07-17 Jun Gao Cluster-weighted modeling for media classification
US20080003001A1 (en) * 2006-06-09 2008-01-03 Jouni Marttila Methods for controlling print quality
US20140368846A1 (en) * 2011-12-27 2014-12-18 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Press color state estimator

Cited By (23)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US9451111B1 (en) * 2015-08-24 2016-09-20 Lexmark International, Inc. Method of determining a media class in an imaging device using an optical translucence sensor
US10331985B2 (en) * 2016-08-31 2019-06-25 Konica Minolta Laboratory U.S.A., Inc. Method and system for verification of print media within a tray
US20180150012A1 (en) * 2016-11-28 2018-05-31 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Image forming apparatus and system
US10274884B2 (en) * 2016-11-28 2019-04-30 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Image forming apparatus and system that determine type of recording material based on detecting results obtained from multiple image forming apparatuses
US10867085B2 (en) * 2017-03-10 2020-12-15 General Electric Company Systems and methods for overlaying and integrating computer aided design (CAD) drawings with fluid models
US20180260501A1 (en) * 2017-03-10 2018-09-13 General Electric Company Systems and methods for overlaying and integrating computer aided design (cad) drawings with fluid models
US11967434B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2024-04-23 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for multi-dimensional fluid modeling of an organism or organ
US10803211B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2020-10-13 General Electric Company Multiple fluid model tool for interdisciplinary fluid modeling
US11379630B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2022-07-05 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for utilizing a 3D CAD point-cloud to automatically create a fluid model
US11947882B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2024-04-02 Altair Engineering, Inc. Optimization of prototype and machine design within a 3D fluid modeling environment
US10963599B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-03-30 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for utilizing a 3D CAD point-cloud to automatically create a fluid model
US10977397B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-04-13 Altair Engineering, Inc. Optimization of prototype and machine design within a 3D fluid modeling environment
US11004568B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2021-05-11 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for multi-dimensional fluid modeling of an organism or organ
US11714933B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2023-08-01 Altair Engineering, Inc. Systems and methods for utilizing a 3D CAD point-cloud to automatically create a fluid model
US11538591B2 (en) 2017-03-10 2022-12-27 Altair Engineering, Inc. Training and refining fluid models using disparate and aggregated machine data
US11752783B2 (en) 2018-12-06 2023-09-12 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. Print media modes
JP2020121503A (en) * 2019-01-31 2020-08-13 セイコーエプソン株式会社 Printer, machine learning device, machine learning method and printing control program
US11161357B2 (en) 2019-02-28 2021-11-02 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Information processing apparatus, printing apparatus, information processing method, and storage medium
RU2741511C1 (en) * 2019-02-28 2021-01-26 Кэнон Кабусики Кайся Information processing device, printing device and information processing method
EP3702968A1 (en) * 2019-02-28 2020-09-02 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Information processing apparatus, printing apparatus, and information processing method
US11025791B2 (en) * 2019-03-28 2021-06-01 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Information processing apparatus, printing apparatus, information processing method, and program, providing accurate identification of the type of a printing medium by increasing the opportunity to improve the accuracy of determining the type of printing medium based on measurement results
JP2021062565A (en) * 2019-10-16 2021-04-22 セイコーエプソン株式会社 Information processor, leaning device, control method of information processor, and program
EP4009110A1 (en) * 2020-12-04 2022-06-08 Konica Minolta, Inc. Parameter determination apparatus, image forming apparatus, post-processing apparatus, sheet feeding apparatus, and creation method of determination model

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
US9367005B2 (en) 2016-06-14
US20160004193A1 (en) 2016-01-07

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US20160044195A1 (en) Imaging Device and Method for Sensing Media Type
US8132049B2 (en) Failure diagnosis method, failure diagnosis apparatus, conveyance device, image forming apparatus, program, and storage medium
US9696947B1 (en) Fault identification for a printing system
US20050240376A1 (en) Failure diagnosis method, failure diagnosis apparatus, image forming apparatus, program, and storage medium
JP2019057062A (en) Failure prediction system, server, and program
US9300823B1 (en) Maintenance necessity estimation apparatus and non-transitory computer readable medium
US11022925B2 (en) Post-processing apparatus
US11470212B2 (en) Information processing apparatus and image forming system
US11200472B2 (en) Identification apparatus, processing method, and non-transitory computer-readable storage medium
JP4844606B2 (en) Image classification apparatus and program
US9604478B1 (en) Print media beam strength sensor
US20040100016A1 (en) Media qualification accessory and method
US8804215B2 (en) Image input terminal having weighing platen
US9870102B2 (en) Input device and electronic device
US10551781B2 (en) Image forming apparatus and recording medium
US11991325B2 (en) Image processing apparatus, control method, and storage medium to detect a sheet edge based on marks printed on an adjustment chart and acquired regions of interest images
US8437034B2 (en) Dynamically adapted reprographic system to current operating environment based on probabilistic network
US11307809B2 (en) Information processing device, learning device, and storage medium storing learnt model
JP7287266B2 (en) Machine learning device, data processing system, machine learning method, and data processing method
US11934712B2 (en) System and method for automatically diagnosing media handling defects in a printing device
JP2022089499A (en) Conversion device, media detection system, image formation device, and control program
US9451111B1 (en) Method of determining a media class in an imaging device using an optical translucence sensor
JP2021070168A (en) Image processing system and server
US11776111B2 (en) Information processing apparatus, control method for information processing apparatus, image forming system, and non-transitory computer-readable storage medium for detection of malfunction of conveying device that conveys medium to print engine of image forming apparatus and correction of amount of conveyance performed by the conveying device based on the detection
JP7439459B2 (en) Machine learning device, conveyance device, image forming device, machine learning method, and program

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
AS Assignment

Owner name: LEXMARK INTERNATIONAL, INC., KENTUCKY

Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:MURRELL, NIKO JAY;WHITNEY, JULIE ANN GORDON;BRADLEY, RYAN THOMAS;SIGNING DATES FROM 20140604 TO 20140605;REEL/FRAME:033368/0572

STCB Information on status: application discontinuation

Free format text: ABANDONED -- FAILURE TO RESPOND TO AN OFFICE ACTION