GB2545962A - Electrical grounding of bearing seal - Google Patents

Electrical grounding of bearing seal Download PDF

Info

Publication number
GB2545962A
GB2545962A GB1618488.9A GB201618488A GB2545962A GB 2545962 A GB2545962 A GB 2545962A GB 201618488 A GB201618488 A GB 201618488A GB 2545962 A GB2545962 A GB 2545962A
Authority
GB
United Kingdom
Prior art keywords
seal
bearing
equipment
stator
rotor
Prior art date
Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
Withdrawn
Application number
GB1618488.9A
Other versions
GB201618488D0 (en
Inventor
Stephenson Heath
Smiddy John
Harte Paul
Current Assignee (The listed assignees may be inaccurate. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the list.)
AES Engineering Ltd
Original Assignee
AES Engineering Ltd
Priority date (The priority date is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the date listed.)
Filing date
Publication date
Application filed by AES Engineering Ltd filed Critical AES Engineering Ltd
Publication of GB201618488D0 publication Critical patent/GB201618488D0/en
Publication of GB2545962A publication Critical patent/GB2545962A/en
Withdrawn legal-status Critical Current

Links

Classifications

    • HELECTRICITY
    • H01ELECTRIC ELEMENTS
    • H01RELECTRICALLY-CONDUCTIVE CONNECTIONS; STRUCTURAL ASSOCIATIONS OF A PLURALITY OF MUTUALLY-INSULATED ELECTRICAL CONNECTING ELEMENTS; COUPLING DEVICES; CURRENT COLLECTORS
    • H01R39/00Rotary current collectors, distributors or interrupters
    • H01R39/64Devices for uninterrupted current collection
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16CSHAFTS; FLEXIBLE SHAFTS; ELEMENTS OR CRANKSHAFT MECHANISMS; ROTARY BODIES OTHER THAN GEARING ELEMENTS; BEARINGS
    • F16C33/00Parts of bearings; Special methods for making bearings or parts thereof
    • F16C33/72Sealings
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16CSHAFTS; FLEXIBLE SHAFTS; ELEMENTS OR CRANKSHAFT MECHANISMS; ROTARY BODIES OTHER THAN GEARING ELEMENTS; BEARINGS
    • F16C33/00Parts of bearings; Special methods for making bearings or parts thereof
    • F16C33/72Sealings
    • F16C33/76Sealings of ball or roller bearings
    • F16C33/80Labyrinth sealings
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16JPISTONS; CYLINDERS; SEALINGS
    • F16J15/00Sealings
    • F16J15/02Sealings between relatively-stationary surfaces
    • F16J15/06Sealings between relatively-stationary surfaces with solid packing compressed between sealing surfaces
    • F16J15/064Sealings between relatively-stationary surfaces with solid packing compressed between sealing surfaces the packing combining the sealing function with other functions
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16JPISTONS; CYLINDERS; SEALINGS
    • F16J15/00Sealings
    • F16J15/44Free-space packings
    • F16J15/447Labyrinth packings
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16JPISTONS; CYLINDERS; SEALINGS
    • F16J15/00Sealings
    • F16J15/44Free-space packings
    • F16J15/447Labyrinth packings
    • F16J15/4476Labyrinth packings with radial path
    • F16J15/4478Pre-assembled packings
    • FMECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
    • F16ENGINEERING ELEMENTS AND UNITS; GENERAL MEASURES FOR PRODUCING AND MAINTAINING EFFECTIVE FUNCTIONING OF MACHINES OR INSTALLATIONS; THERMAL INSULATION IN GENERAL
    • F16JPISTONS; CYLINDERS; SEALINGS
    • F16J15/00Sealings
    • F16J15/44Free-space packings
    • F16J15/447Labyrinth packings
    • F16J15/453Labyrinth packings characterised by the use of particular materials
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H01ELECTRIC ELEMENTS
    • H01RELECTRICALLY-CONDUCTIVE CONNECTIONS; STRUCTURAL ASSOCIATIONS OF A PLURALITY OF MUTUALLY-INSULATED ELECTRICAL CONNECTING ELEMENTS; COUPLING DEVICES; CURRENT COLLECTORS
    • H01R13/00Details of coupling devices of the kinds covered by groups H01R12/70 or H01R24/00 - H01R33/00
    • H01R13/02Contact members
    • H01R13/22Contacts for co-operating by abutting
    • H01R13/24Contacts for co-operating by abutting resilient; resiliently-mounted
    • H01R13/2407Contacts for co-operating by abutting resilient; resiliently-mounted characterized by the resilient means
    • H01R13/2414Contacts for co-operating by abutting resilient; resiliently-mounted characterized by the resilient means conductive elastomers
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H01ELECTRIC ELEMENTS
    • H01RELECTRICALLY-CONDUCTIVE CONNECTIONS; STRUCTURAL ASSOCIATIONS OF A PLURALITY OF MUTUALLY-INSULATED ELECTRICAL CONNECTING ELEMENTS; COUPLING DEVICES; CURRENT COLLECTORS
    • H01R13/00Details of coupling devices of the kinds covered by groups H01R12/70 or H01R24/00 - H01R33/00
    • H01R13/46Bases; Cases
    • H01R13/52Dustproof, splashproof, drip-proof, waterproof, or flameproof cases
    • H01R13/5219Sealing means between coupling parts, e.g. interfacial seal
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H01ELECTRIC ELEMENTS
    • H01RELECTRICALLY-CONDUCTIVE CONNECTIONS; STRUCTURAL ASSOCIATIONS OF A PLURALITY OF MUTUALLY-INSULATED ELECTRICAL CONNECTING ELEMENTS; COUPLING DEVICES; CURRENT COLLECTORS
    • H01R39/00Rotary current collectors, distributors or interrupters
    • H01R39/02Details for dynamo electric machines
    • H01R39/022Details for dynamo electric machines characterised by the materials used, e.g. ceramics
    • H01R39/025Conductive materials
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H02GENERATION; CONVERSION OR DISTRIBUTION OF ELECTRIC POWER
    • H02KDYNAMO-ELECTRIC MACHINES
    • H02K11/00Structural association of dynamo-electric machines with electric components or with devices for shielding, monitoring or protection
    • H02K11/40Structural association with grounding devices
    • HELECTRICITY
    • H02GENERATION; CONVERSION OR DISTRIBUTION OF ELECTRIC POWER
    • H02KDYNAMO-ELECTRIC MACHINES
    • H02K5/00Casings; Enclosures; Supports
    • H02K5/04Casings or enclosures characterised by the shape, form or construction thereof
    • H02K5/10Casings or enclosures characterised by the shape, form or construction thereof with arrangements for protection from ingress, e.g. water or fingers

Abstract

A bearing seal includes a rotor 14 and a stator 16 and at least one electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member 17. When the seal is installed in equipment and is providing sealing between the rotor and the stator, an electrical grounding path is provided therebetween, the path extending through the toroidal member. The seal may comprise additional conductive toroidal members 15 or 18 for sealing between the rotor and stator. A shutoff device may be incorporated in the seal which may also include an electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member. At least one said toroidal member may be made of a silicone rubber or may constitute a two component material.

Description

ELECTRICAL GROUNDING OF BEARING SEAL Field of the Invention
This invention relates to bearing protectors, specifically of the non-contacting labyrinth seal type, and their use in rotating equipment, especially equipment which has the potential of creating electric shaft voltages.
Background of the Invention
An example of a piece of rotating equipment which has the potential of creating electric shaft voltages caused by variable frequency drives (VFD) is an electric motor with bearing assemblies supporting the rotating shaft.
In such equipment, each bearing assembly typically consists of at least one bearing housed in a bearing chamber. The bearing is lubricated and is sealed between the rotor to stator interface to prevent the ingress or egress of fluid or solid to the bearing cavity, since such unwanted material results in the deterioration of equipment life.
Bearing seals are often also referred to as bearing protectors or bearing isolators. However, such seals have uses other than the protection of a bearing in rotating equipment. While reference will be made below to bearing protectors, it should be understood that this term is used, as far as the invention is concerned, in connection with such other uses of the seals.
During electric motor operation, the motor bearings may deteriorate as a result of transient shaft voltages generated by the equipment, these voltages being transmitted from the shaft through the equipment bearings into the grounded bearing/motor housing. Such voltages lead to equipment bearing pitting and fluting damage.
The purpose of a bearing protector is to prevent the ingress of fluid, solids and/or debris from entering a bearing chamber. Equally, bearing protectors are employed to prevent the egress of fluid or solids from a bearing chamber. Essentially, their purpose is to prevent the premature failure of the bearing.
Non-contacting bearing protectors can be of repeller or labyrinth configuration. Reference is made to our co-pending labyrinth seal bearing protection application GB0415548.7 which describes a substantially noncontacting bearing protector with a static shut off device.
In a non-contacting bearing protector, the rotating component typically has a complex outer profile which is located adjacent and in close radial and longitudinal proximity to a complex inner profile of the stationary component. Together these complex profiles provide a tortuous path preventing or at least hindering the passage of the unwanted materials or fluids.
Non-contacting bearing protectors offer specific advantages over contacting designs, specifically in low/marginal bearing lubrication applications involving high shaft speeds, as commonly found in electric motors.
Conventional electrical voltage dissipating labyrinth seal technology involves a contacting element in the form of a series of wire brushes or spring loaded carbon bushes acting on the primary rotating shaft. Such a conventional contacting element is located adjacent to the lubrication fluid and, when contacted by this fluid, the fluid acts as an insulator and prevents the effective dissipation of the electric voltage from the rotating to stationary elements.
Because the conventional counter rotational contacting and dissipating surfaces are positioned directly on the equipment shaft, they cause wear to the equipment shaft, causing extensive damage and debris which is costly to replace and/or repair. As the abraded/worn particles are also adjacent to the bearing lubrication media, they can work their way into the counter rotational surfaces of the bearing leading to damage and bearing failure.
Furthermore, some known arrangements compromise fundamental elements of bearing seal technology, in order to incorporate voltage dissipating contacting elements into the bearing seal. Often the inboard velocity reducing cavity is excluded, which means the lubricant is more likely to leak through the bearing seal. The contacting elements may be positioned to provide a leak path between the atmospheric side and the lubricated side of the lubricated inner surfaces of the bearing chamber, thereby negating any benefit that the user expects when using a bearing seal.
Known arrangements include a first counter-rotational contacting element, in the form of a bush, which engages a second rotating part of the equipment, namely, a shaft, via a third member such as a spring. This arrangement compromises the equipment efficiency in that the contact biasing force is constant for any given operational speed of the equipment. As frictional heat generated is proportional to the material co-efficient of friction of the counter rotational surfaces multiplied by the contacting force, it is clear that a constant force creates considerable heat even in applications which do not require such a contact force.
There is a difference in both probability and magnitude of a stray voltage occurring with an item of rotating equipment rotating at 0.1 m/s compared to that expected when the equipment rotates at 20m/s or 30m/s. Furthermore all conventional voltage dissipating means rely on sliding friction between counter rotational surfaces. Sliding friction consumes considerable power for any given application and thus generates considerable heat. Rolling friction, on the other hand, provides less power and less heat generation; the fundamental reason why 95% of the world’s bearings roll rather than slide.
Statements of the Invention
According to the present invention there is provided a bearing seal having a rotor and a stator and at least one electrically conducting elastomeric toroidal member whereby, in use with the seal installed in equipment and providing sealing between equipment rotor and stator, an electrical grounding path is provided between said equipment rotor and said equipment stator, said path extending through said toroidal member.
Preferably, the seal includes a first electrically conducting elastomeric toroidal member which, in use, provides sealing between the equipment rotor and the rotor of the seal.
Preferably, a second electrically conducting elastomeric toroidal member provides, in use, sealing between the equipment stator and the stator of the seal.
Preferably, the bearing seal incorporates a static shut-off device such as a seal or a valve. More preferably, the shut-off device includes at least one further electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member which provides electrical conduction between the rotor and the stator of the seal.
Preferably, the grounding arrangement of a seal of the present invention is longitudinally and/or radially separated from the lubrication fluid being sealed. In this way, the lubrication medium is not able to reduce the efficiency of the electrical dissipation.
Brief description of the drawing
The accompanying drawing is a longitudinal section of one half of a labyrinth seal bearing protector of the invention in a rotationally static position.
Detailed description of the Invention
The invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawing.
Rotating equipment assembly 11 includes a rotating shaft 12 and stationary equipment housing 13. The equipment housing 13 typically contains a bearing (not shown) mounted in the radial space between the shaft 12 and housing 13.
Area “X”, adjacent to the bearing (not shown) and one axial end of the bearing protector assembly 10, typically contains bearing lubrication fluid, but could also contain solid and/or foreign debris and/or atmosphere. It will be referred to herein as “product substance”, being used to described the single or mixed medium.
Area Ύ” at the other end of the bearing protector assembly 10 can also partially contain fluid, typically sprayed moisture and/or solids and/or foreign debris and/or atmosphere. It will herein be termed “atmospheric substance” being used to describe a single or mixed medium.
The bearing protector assembly 10 includes a rotor member 14 which is radially and longitudinally adjacent to stator member 16.
The stator member 16 is preferably rotationally attached to the equipment housing 13 by means of elastomeric toroidal member (O-ring) 17.
Rotor 14 is radially mounted in sealing engagement with shaft 12 by O-ring 18. A further O-ring 15 is also provided. The frictional squeeze on O-ring 15 is typically sufficient to transmit the rotational drive from the shaft 12 to rotor 14. However, a separate drive mechanism could be employed to transmit the drive if so required..
The static shut-off device 23 which seals the rotor to the stator when the shaft is at rest/idle and provides a non-contact seal when the shaft is in operation, is described in our co-pending labyrinth seal bearing protection application GB0415548.7 and will not be further described here.
Stator 16 incorporates a radially extending groove 28 which extends longitudinally from the innermost circumference, and substantially adjacent to the rotor or shaft 12, as shown. The groove is postioned adjacent to area “X” and the sealed media in the equipment bearing chamber 11. The groove 28 is circumferentially discontinued at the 6 o’clock position by an orifice (not show) which communicates between area “X” and the outermost radial surface of the groove 28. The outermost surface of the radial stator 16 is circumferentially discontinued at the 6 o’clock position by an orifice (not shown) which communicates between area Ύ” and the innermost radial surface of the stator 16.
At least one of the two O-rings 15 and 18 is made of electrically conductive material. The O-ring 31 of the shut-off valve is also made of electrically conductive material. Furthermore O-ring 17 is similarly made of electrically conductive material. As a result an electrical path is provided between shaft 12 and housing 13. This path extends through one or both O-rings 15 and 18, through the rotor 14, then through O-ring 31 of the shut-off valve through the stator 16 and finally through O-ring 17 before entering housing 13.
The above-mentioned electrically conducting O-rings are made of an electrically conducting HCR silicone rubber such as Elastosil R Plus 573/ 70 A/ B made by Wacker Silicones. This material, which is a two component silicone rubber, provides good mechanical and electrical properties. It has high conductivity, low volume resistivity good heat resistance and good rheological properties. It has previously being proposed for use in such applications as EMI-gaskets, ignition cables(core) and band electrodes.
The general principle of rotary seals in accordance with the present invention may be used not only in the case where the shaft is a rotary member and the housing is a stationary member but also the reverse situation, that is to say, in which the shaft is stationary and the housing is rotary.
Furthermore, the invention may be embodied in both rotary and stationary arrangements, cartridge and component seals with metallic components as well as non-metallic components.

Claims (9)

Claims
1. A bearing seal having a rotor and a stator and at least one electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member whereby, in use with the seal installed in equipment and providing sealing between equipment rotor and stator, an electrical grounding path is provided between said equipment rotor and said equipment stator, said path extending through said toroidal member.
2. A seal according to claim 1, wherein an electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member is provided between the equipment rotor and the rotor of the seal.
3. A seal according to claim 1 or claim 2, wherein an electrically conductive elastormeric toroidal member is provided between the equipment stator and stator of the seal.
4. A seal according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the seal is provided with a shut-off device.
5. A seal according to claim 4 wherein the shut-off device includes at least one electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member which provides electrical conduction between the rotor and stator of the seal.
6. A seal according to any of the preceding claims wherein at least one electrically conductive elastomeric toroidal member is made of a silicone rubber.
7. A seal according to claim 6 wherein the silicone rubber is a two component material.
8. A seal according to claim 1 and substantially as herein described.
9. A bearing seal substantially as described herein with reference to the accompanying drawings.
GB1618488.9A 2015-11-02 2016-11-02 Electrical grounding of bearing seal Withdrawn GB2545962A (en)

Applications Claiming Priority (1)

Application Number Priority Date Filing Date Title
GBGB1519362.6A GB201519362D0 (en) 2015-11-02 2015-11-02 Electrical grounding of bearing seal

Publications (2)

Publication Number Publication Date
GB201618488D0 GB201618488D0 (en) 2016-12-14
GB2545962A true GB2545962A (en) 2017-07-05

Family

ID=55130566

Family Applications (2)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
GBGB1519362.6A Ceased GB201519362D0 (en) 2015-11-02 2015-11-02 Electrical grounding of bearing seal
GB1618488.9A Withdrawn GB2545962A (en) 2015-11-02 2016-11-02 Electrical grounding of bearing seal

Family Applications Before (1)

Application Number Title Priority Date Filing Date
GBGB1519362.6A Ceased GB201519362D0 (en) 2015-11-02 2015-11-02 Electrical grounding of bearing seal

Country Status (2)

Country Link
US (1) US20170125960A1 (en)
GB (2) GB201519362D0 (en)

Families Citing this family (1)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
GB201509927D0 (en) * 2015-06-08 2015-07-22 Aes Eng Ltd Electrical grounding - labyrinth bearing protector

Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2006145002A (en) * 2004-11-24 2006-06-08 Yaskawa Electric Corp Motor bearing and motor using the same
WO2007001525A2 (en) * 2005-06-25 2007-01-04 Isotech Of Illinois, Inc. Motor grounding seal
WO2013019353A2 (en) * 2011-08-01 2013-02-07 Garlock Sealing Technologies Llc Method of securing a sealing device to a housing with a limited bore diameter
US20160372987A1 (en) * 2012-06-18 2016-12-22 Inpro/Seal Llc Explosion-proof current diverting device

Family Cites Families (12)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
US3783173A (en) * 1972-05-19 1974-01-01 Us Army Gasket-electrically conductive
US5498644A (en) * 1993-09-10 1996-03-12 Specialty Silicone Products, Inc. Silcone elastomer incorporating electrically conductive microballoons and method for producing same
CN100434775C (en) * 2002-07-08 2008-11-19 Aes工程有限公司 Rotary seal
US20100187946A1 (en) * 2005-06-25 2010-07-29 Orlowski David C Current Diverter Ring
US8664812B2 (en) * 2006-03-17 2014-03-04 Inpro/Seal Llc Current diverter ring
US8604653B2 (en) * 2005-06-25 2013-12-10 Inpro/Seal, LLC Current diverter ring
US20110204734A1 (en) * 2005-06-25 2011-08-25 Orlowski David C Motor Grounding Seal
GB0607513D0 (en) * 2006-04-18 2006-05-24 Aes Eng Ltd Bearing protector for axial shaft movement
GB0607623D0 (en) * 2006-04-19 2006-05-31 Aes Eng Ltd Bearing protector with air pumps
US8186686B2 (en) * 2009-04-29 2012-05-29 GM Global Technology Operations LLC Electrically-conductive seal assembly
DE102013000982B4 (en) * 2013-01-22 2015-10-29 Carl Freudenberg Kg Sealing ring and seal assembly so
DE102014010269B4 (en) * 2014-07-11 2020-06-18 Carl Freudenberg Kg Ballast seal, ballast seal arrangement and sealing ring, comprising the ballast seal

Patent Citations (4)

* Cited by examiner, † Cited by third party
Publication number Priority date Publication date Assignee Title
JP2006145002A (en) * 2004-11-24 2006-06-08 Yaskawa Electric Corp Motor bearing and motor using the same
WO2007001525A2 (en) * 2005-06-25 2007-01-04 Isotech Of Illinois, Inc. Motor grounding seal
WO2013019353A2 (en) * 2011-08-01 2013-02-07 Garlock Sealing Technologies Llc Method of securing a sealing device to a housing with a limited bore diameter
US20160372987A1 (en) * 2012-06-18 2016-12-22 Inpro/Seal Llc Explosion-proof current diverting device

Also Published As

Publication number Publication date
US20170125960A1 (en) 2017-05-04
GB201519362D0 (en) 2015-12-16
GB201618488D0 (en) 2016-12-14

Similar Documents

Publication Publication Date Title
US9790995B2 (en) Bearing seal with integrated grounding brush
WO2018139232A1 (en) Sliding component
AU2012357713B2 (en) Earth and/or sealing assembly for electric motors
US7722050B2 (en) Mechanical seal bearing protector
WO2009040519A1 (en) Isolator sealing device
US20070222158A1 (en) Bearing alignment device and seal arrangement
US20070241513A1 (en) Bearing protector for axial shaft movement
CN109642676B (en) Dry running end face mechanical sealing element
US11002362B2 (en) Shaft seal assembly
CN102588287B (en) Mechanical sealing parts of Roots blower and lubricating method thereof
CN108603602B (en) Sealing device
GB2517573A (en) Dynamically non contacting seal
US20170125960A1 (en) Electrical grounding of bearing seal
US20140319773A1 (en) Rotary seal device
WO2016198823A1 (en) Bearing isolator
US20230025528A1 (en) Electric motor
GB2438022A (en) A bearing protector
US20170175894A1 (en) Seal assembly
US20130229075A1 (en) Motor having a seal assembly
NO341168B1 (en) Seal assembly
JP2015195668A (en) Electric motor including seal member and manufacturing method of the same
CN216691893U (en) Bearing box with mechanical seal
GB2519286A (en) Single face bearing protector
JP2008106874A (en) Ball bearing and brushless motor using the same
CN114811054A (en) Upstream pumping strong lubrication type mechanical sealing device

Legal Events

Date Code Title Description
WAP Application withdrawn, taken to be withdrawn or refused ** after publication under section 16(1)