EP1884166B1 - Soft-solid food product - Google Patents
Soft-solid food product Download PDFInfo
- Publication number
- EP1884166B1 EP1884166B1 EP06076516.1A EP06076516A EP1884166B1 EP 1884166 B1 EP1884166 B1 EP 1884166B1 EP 06076516 A EP06076516 A EP 06076516A EP 1884166 B1 EP1884166 B1 EP 1884166B1
- Authority
- EP
- European Patent Office
- Prior art keywords
- product
- fat
- cheese
- gel
- protein
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Not-in-force
Links
Images
Classifications
-
- A—HUMAN NECESSITIES
- A23—FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
- A23C—DAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING THEREOF
- A23C19/00—Cheese; Cheese preparations; Making thereof
- A23C19/06—Treating cheese curd after whey separation; Products obtained thereby
- A23C19/068—Particular types of cheese
- A23C19/08—Process cheese preparations; Making thereof, e.g. melting, emulsifying, sterilizing
- A23C19/082—Adding substances to the curd before or during melting; Melting salts
-
- A—HUMAN NECESSITIES
- A23—FOODS OR FOODSTUFFS; TREATMENT THEREOF, NOT COVERED BY OTHER CLASSES
- A23C—DAIRY PRODUCTS, e.g. MILK, BUTTER OR CHEESE; MILK OR CHEESE SUBSTITUTES; MAKING THEREOF
- A23C20/00—Cheese substitutes
Definitions
- the invention relates to a method for preparing a food product, in particular a soft-solid food product.
- a soft-solid food product is a food product that primarily exhibits elastic deformation (elastic deformation: G'>G") upon applying a stress, and in which a relatively small stress is needed to obtain a substantial deformation, either due to low elastic modulus or small yield stress. Further details on soft-solid food products are described in : P. Walstra (2003) Physical Chemistry of Foods; Chapter 17: Soft-solids; Marcel Dekker, New York , which chapter contains a further description of soft-solid food products. In particular a stress of up to 10 000 Pa is considered a small stress.
- a well-known soft-solid food product is cheese.
- Other soft-solid food products include those exhibiting elastic deformation upon applying a stress similar to a stress needed to elastically deform a cheese.
- cheese making is a process wherein milk ingredients are concentrated in order to preserve the ingredients for a long, or at least a prolonged period of time.
- various cheeses, cheese analogues and cheese-related specialties are known, which differ in their composition from natural cheeses.
- Natural cheeses are defined herein as cheeses made directly from milk.
- the CODEX GENERAL STANDARD FOR CHEESE (CODEX STAN A-6-1978, Rev.1-1999, Amended 2003) provides the following definition: cheese is the ripened or un-ripened soft or semi-hard, hard and extra hard product, which may be coated, and in which the whey protein/casein ratio does not exceed that of milk, obtained by: (a) coagulating wholly or partly the following raw materials: milk and/or products obtained from milk, through the action of rennet or other suitable coagulating agents, and by partially draining the whey resulting from such coagulation; and/or (b) processing techniques involving coagulation of milk and/or products obtained from milk which give an end-product with similar physical, chemical and organoleptic characteristics as the product defined under (a). It is noted that such cheeses generally meet the above definition of a soft-solid food product (i.e. not only a soft cheese, but also semi-hard, hard or extra hard cheese
- Cheese products or cheese-analogue products may be made by (partially) replacing traditional raw materials (in particular milk) for other raw materials, such as different protein sources or fat substitutes.
- non-dairy proteins e.g. vegetable proteins
- US-A-2004/0018292 soybean protein concentrates and isolates applied in process cheese products
- US-B-6,495,187 synthetic protein isolates in fresh unripened cheese analogues and cheese analogues
- fat substitutes e.g. polysaccharides
- a non-fat cream cheese type product having the appearance, taste and consistency of fat-containing cream cheese is provided in U.S. Patent 5,079,024 .
- Concentrated skim milk is heated together with an emulsifier salt.
- the resulting mixture is transferred to a second agitating mixer, then combined with a gum to provide a thickened skim milk.
- After homogenization the resulting mixture is transferred to a third agitating mixer, and a suitable bulking agent and an additional gum are added while heating with agitation.
- the mixture is then homogenized again to provide the cream cheese product.
- the manufacture of this cream cheese product requires both an emulsifier salt and a bulking agent, as well as a complex process, including multiple heating, agitation, and homogenization steps.
- a soft-solid food product such as a cheese product, which may be shaped, or cheese analogue product, which may be shaped, with a good mouth feel and mouth sensation, in particular a mouth feel and sensation similar to a traditionally produced cheese.
- inhomogeneities in the structure of natural cheese especially inhomogeneities in the spatial distribution of the dispersed phase, are responsible for the desired in-mouth sensory behaviour.
- Natural cheese manufactured from non-homogenized milk, can be considered as a soft-solid multi-phase food product consisting of an aqueous para-casein phase and a dispersed fat phase.
- the inventors have realised that in natural cheeses such as in semi-hard Gouda type cheeses, in particular those containing about 48 weight % fat or more in dry matter, the fat droplets (2 - 8 micron in diameter) show a characteristic inhomogeneous spatial distribution, typically providing chain-like arrangements, over the continuous hydrophilic casein matrix.
- the indication used below for a product comprising about 48wt.% fat is "48+”.
- "x+" means that the percentage of fat is about x wt. %.
- 30+ and 20+ cheese have about 30 or 20 weight % fat or more in dry matter, respectively).
- FIG. 2 schematically shows the structure of a traditionally prepared Gouda cheese.
- Sections 1 and 2 form the matrix wherein section 1 is more hydrophobic and has a lower water/ionic content than section 2.
- Section 1 also has stiffer mechanical properties than section 2.
- the fat globules 3 have weaker mechanical properties than sections 1 and 2 of the matrix.
- the ring-like area around globules 3 represent a capillary space between the fat globule and the protein matrix. Generally, fat globules are not tightly surrounded by the matrix. It has been found that this capillary space plays an important role in the uptake of saliva by the product when chewed. As a result of the high degree of connectivity of the fat globules, the individual capillary spaces are also interconnected.
- saliva can penetrate into the cheese (or a soft-solid food according to the invention) much quicker than in homogenised soft-solid food products.
- the diffusion of saliva into the protein matrix may also be improved.
- the protein matrix swells, mechanically destabilises, which facilitates the disintegration of the food during oral processing.
- the heterogeneity of such bi-continuous structure can be described as a spatial arrangement of protein rich, and especially casein rich domains separated by enclosing fat connective areas.
- the casein domains In Gouda cheese and the like, the casein domains have a typical length scale of 30 - 100 micrometers.
- the fat phase is comprised of globules still containing their fat globular membrane preventing direct interactions between the continuous protein phase and the oil content of the fat globules.
- the fat globular membrane acts as spacer and can be considered as an interruption in the matrix structure. Due to the history of structure development of the cheese during manufacturing and storage/ripening these connective fat areas play a crucial role in the structure disintegration during oral processing.
- the solid piece of cheese shows a preference to fall apart along these connective fat areas and converts into a dispersion of fragments in the saliva.
- the fragments consist of the casein rich domains enclosed by and exposing the fat phase. This typical fracture behaviour also facilitates the release of the flavours that have their highest concentrations in these fat rich areas. This conversion into fragments gives rise to the characteristic, malleable, creamy attributes appreciated by the consumers, and is considered as a main quality attribute.
- the connectivity in the fat phase can be revealed using a non-invasive imaging technique allowing visualization of the three-dimensional structure of the material with sufficient spatial resolution.
- the characteristic fracture behaviour of Gouda type cheeses, containing 48 weight % fat in dry matter, along the fat connective areas can be described by double compression measurements and using the triple-point geometry in fracture measurements. Suitable ways to carry this out are, e.g., described in J.F.C. Meullenet, J.Gross (1999) Instrumental single and double compression tests to predict sensory texture characteristics of foods, Journal of Texture Studies 30, 167-180 and in IDF Bulletin: Rheological and Fracture properties of cheese (chapter 3), No 268/1991 .
- Imaging techniques applied to these freshly created fracture surfaces can prove the preferential fracture of the material through the fat connective phases and domains rich in fat globules.
- the fracture surfaces contain more fat globules than one might expect from the fat/protein volume ratio indicating preferential fracture through fat rich domains.
- the present invention relates to a method for preparing a food product, in particular a soft-solid dairy food product such as a cheese product or a cheese analogue product comprising
- Figure 1 schematically shows the "exclusion principle" which may be used in order to prepare a product in accordance with the invention.
- Figure 2 schematically shows the connectivity of fat globules in a product of the invention.
- Figure 3 shows a curve representing the amount of extractable fat as a function of total fat in natural cheeses.
- Figure 4 shows the relation between extractable fat and the mean number of globules per string in natural cheeses.
- Figure 5 shows the intercept length vs. the number of fat globules in several cheeses.
- Figure 6 the total intercept length distributions of natural Gouda cheeses of 30+ and 48+ and a 20+ soft-solid multi-phase food product of the invention (20*), relative to a natural Gouda cheese of 20+ (horizontal line).
- Figure 7 shows a characteristic connectivity of fat globules visualised by an analysis using a non-invasive imaging technique.
- Figure 8 shows a PCA plot comparing sensory performance of a product of the invention and known products.
- the invention further relates to a method for altering the sensory performance of a food product which method comprises inhomogeneously distributing fat globules in the food product.
- the performance may in particular be altered with respect to one or more of the following attributes:
- one or more other attributes may be altered, in particular one ore more attributes selected from elasticity, hardness, dryness, graininess, smoothness, remainings, fracturability and fatty impression.
- Elasticity is a manual attribute, indicating the degree of return to original size/shape after compression/release between thump and finger.
- the mouthfeel hardness i.e. the hardness perceived in the mouth (from soft to hard, may be altered.
- dryness in particular the (afterfeel) dryness perceived in the mouth after swallowing, such as thirsty sensation after swallowing, may be altered.
- the mouthfeel graininess i.e. the perception of particles in the mouth may be altered.
- the mouthfeel smoothness i.e. smooth texture perceived in the mouth may be improved.
- Fatty impression is a manual attribute, relating to the presence of a coating on fingertips after sweeping a sample's surface 3 times.
- Remainings is related to the after-feel the product leaves in the mouth, after swallowing the product.
- Fracturability is an attribute regarding how fast a product breaks after the appearance of a first tear in the product, when held in both hands and bent.
- the sensory performance may be assessed by trained sensory panels (QDA panels), which are capable of determining an attribute as described above.
- QDA panels trained sensory panels
- the attribute's alteration may be perceived statically (at a specific moment in time) and/or dynamically (intensity over time).
- the attribute's alteration may be perceived statically (at a specific moment in time) and/or dynamically (intensity over time).
- any food product wherein fat globules can be distributed inhomogeneously, may be prepared in accordance with the invention.
- the food product may be a solid product or a pourable product (such as a thick viscous liquid, e.g. liquid yoghurt, "vla" -a custard-like dessert, popular in the Netherlands - or a product having a similar viscosity).
- a pourable product such as a thick viscous liquid, e.g. liquid yoghurt, "vla" -a custard-like dessert, popular in the Netherlands - or a product having a similar viscosity).
- the food product may a pourable product, preferably a thick viscous liquid.
- a product is considered pourable if it can be poured from a filled package, when held diagonally and the outflow opening is held downward.
- a product is considered a thick viscous liquid if the viscosity, as measured with a Brookfield viscometer (spindel 5, 10 rpm, 7°C), is 10 to 70 Pa.s, in particular at least 15 Pa.s, preferably at least 30 Pa.s.
- Preferred pourable products in particular include liquid yoghurt., liquid yoghurt-based products, custard, "vla” (Dutch), a custard-like dessert popular in the Netherlands which is available in a range of different tastes, e.g. in vanilla, chocolate, caramel and in various fruit flavours, or a product having a similar viscosity to any one of these.
- the product may be spoonable, which means that the product can easily be spooned from a plate or a bowl.
- a spoonable product may be a pourable product or a non-pourable (slightly) gelled product, usually with a short texture.
- examples of spoonable products in addition to the above mentioned pourable products are mousses and creams, in particular sour cream, whipped cream, ice-cream, and soft curd cheese.
- the soft-solid food product may in particular be a product exhibiting elastic deformation upon applying a stress similar to a stress needed to elastically deform a cheese.
- Preferred soft-solid food products include processed cheese products and cheese-analogue products.
- a sensory property may be altered in particular include set yoghurts, set desserts, cottage/cream cheeses, (dairy) bars, (dairy) snacks, sauces, pastes and sausages.
- the food product is a food product other than naturally prepared cheese. However, it may resemble a natural cheese, in particular with respect to the texture, mouthfeel and/or taste. In an embodiment, the food product does not substantially ripen during storage, or at least less than a natural product of the same chemical composition.
- the invention may be used to create a texture which resembles the texture of a natural product -in particular a natural cheese - of a specific age, as a result of the production process, comprising creating an inhomogeneous distribution of the fat globules, resembling a product that has the specific age.
- a product having a texture of a mature or old product can be obtained without needing to store (ripen) the product, or at least achieving such texture within a reduced ripening time.
- the shaping may in particular comprise extruding the mixture.
- the product may be directly shaped when leaving extruder into the final shape of the end-product. It is also possible to extrude the mixture and bring it into a mould.
- the invention further relates to a food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product - obtainable by a method according to the invention.
- a food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product - obtainable by a method according to the invention.
- the invention further relates to a food product - in particular a (processed) soft-solid dairy food product, such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product -comprising a gel phase comprising a protein, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a fat phase formed by a plurality of fat globules, wherein the fat globules are spatially inhomogeneously distributed, as determinable by determining the intercept length profile of the fat phase.
- a food product in particular a (processed) soft-solid dairy food product, such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product -comprising a gel phase comprising a protein, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a fat phase formed by a plurality of fat globules, wherein the fat globules are spatially inhomogeneously distributed, as determinable by determining the intercept length profile of the fat phase.
- the gelled protein phase can usually be regarded as a conglomerate of gelled protein domains (conglomerated particles/fragments) that are interconnected.
- the gelled protein phase may usually be regarded as a substantially continuous phase, wherein the fat phase is dispersed.
- the average size of these domains should at least be about 20 ⁇ m, as determined by the intercept length method, discussed in more detail below.
- the size of the gel domains, the viscosity of the gel phase and the deformability of the gel domains play a role in the mouthfeel.
- the mouthfeel is experienced as smoother when the size of the domains is decreased, the viscosity is increased and/or the deformability is increased.
- At least the majority of the domains preferably have a size of 500 ⁇ m or less, more preferably 300 ⁇ m or less, even more preferably 150 ⁇ m or less.
- the invention aims to allow the manufacture of low fat products that provide full fat performance.
- the invention provides a method to prepare a processed (shaped) cheese or cheese analogue product having a desirable mouth sensation, also, or better; even, at a relatively low fat content.
- the inventions also allows the use of health beneficial ingredients e.g. vegetable unsaturated oils.
- the invention further offers one or more processing advantages. Due to the possibility to use low cost ingredients and to the fact that a product according to the invention can be prepared without a maturation step and/or a brining step, which steps are time consuming, a method according to the invention is simplified and costs can be saved compared to natural cheese making.
- a method of the invention is highly flexible and allows good tuning of manufacturing volumes to market requirements, without needing large storage capacity.
- textural properties and/or flavour properties can be fine-tuned independently from each other, in a method according to the invention.
- This is an advantage over naturally prepared products.
- it has been found possible to provide a product with a textural appearance of a relatively young product (such as young cheese) and a flavour appearance of a relatively mature product (such as old cheese), or vice versa.
- fat is generally used herein as a generic term for carboxylate esters of glycerine (glycerides); in particular triglycerides are fats.
- glycerides carboxylate esters of glycerine
- triglycerides are fats.
- fat includes compounds that are solid and compounds that are liquid at room temperature.
- the term "oil” is used to describe that the fat is liquid.
- the oil in the oil in water emulsion comprises one or more fats which form a liquid phase at the processing temperature during at least part of the method.
- the oil may have partially or fully solidified.
- the fat globules comprise one or more fats that are liquid at the temperature in the oral cavity of a human (about 35-37°C).
- a gel may be made comprising water and a protein (which typically acts as a gellator), in particular or preferably a milk protein.
- the gel is mixed with an oil in water emulsion.
- the gel may be made in the form of gel particles or the gel may be fragmented after formation to create gel particles.
- shapeing shapeing; aging
- fragmented after formation to create gel particles.
- the particles/fragments are allowed to become interconnected, which may be accomplished by aging.
- the oil phase is kept substantially out of the gel phase.
- the gel particles impose a heterogeneous spatial distribution of the emulsion enclosing and separating the gel particles, and excluding the presence of fat globules at the locations of the gel particles self ("exclusion principle"). It should be noted that the fragmenting of the gel may take place prior and/or during mixing with the emulsion. Further, it is in principle possible to mix gel (particles), oil phase and water phase simultaneously, thereby forming the emulsion during the mixing with the gel.
- one or more other ingredients such as one or more flavours and/or aromas
- one or more other ingredients are premixed with the emulsion prior to mixing with the gel, to obtain compartmentalization of these ingredients in the fat-rich domains.
- these compartments are exposed facilitating the proper release of the ingredients.
- This design provides a fracture behaviour, through the fat containing domains, and oral performance comparable to natural full fat cheeses may thereby be achievable.
- the exclusion principle further allows the full or partial replacement of the protein (casein) matrix in, for instance, the cheese or cheese analogue product. Thereby a considerable reduction of the fat content can be realised. Still a product may be prepared that is capable of providing a sensory appreciation - in particular a good mouth sensation such as good taste and/or mouthfeel - that is comparable to a natural cheese product.
- the engineered structure provides effective use of a large portion, and possibly essentially all, fat present in the product through maximal exposure of the fat for sensory perception.
- the fat content may be chosen within wide limits. Usually, the fat content in the food product is at least 0.5 wt. % based upon dry weight. Usually the fat content is up to 60 wt.% based upon dry weight.
- the invention may suitably be employed to prepare a product with an engineered structure having a creamy performance, similar to 48+ Gouda type, but generally having a lower fat content. If desired, a cheese or analogue product with a creamy performance similar to Gouda (like) cheese having a different fat content (such as a 30+ cheese, a 20+ cheese, or a 10+ cheese) can be obtained.
- the characteristic connectivity of fat globules may be visualised by an analysis using a non-invasive imaging technique such as confocal scanning laser microscopy (see Figure 7 ).
- the percentage of extractable fat is higher than in a product wherein the fat is homogenously distributed, and usually also higher than in a comparable naturally prepared cheese (based on the same ingredients in the same amounts).
- the percentage of extractable fat can be determined by the Soxhlet extraction according Weibull in combination with a modified version of the Weibull method (methods IDF 126A (1988) Milk products and milk-based foods (special cases), Determination of fat content Weibull-Bentrop gravimetrix method.)
- the protein degradation is omitted.
- the Weibull method allows the total fat extraction.
- the modified version allows the extraction of fat in the connective fat phase only and in connection with the outer-surface of the cheese.
- the percentage of extractable fat according to the modified method is a measure for the degree of fat exposure for sensory perception.
- the connective (fat/matrix) interfaces are one of the underlying structural features. The larger the connectivity is the more fat will be extracted.
- Table 1 shows the amount of total fat (Weibull) and extractable fat as a percentage of the total fat (Weibull modified) for some naturally prepared Gouda cheeses and low fat variants thereof.
- Table 1 Sample total fat content (weight % of total) extractable fat (weight % of total fat) 48+, 4 weeks 29.8 90.7 48+, 7 months 32.6 95.2 30+, 4 weeks 18.4 24.4 30+, 4 months 17.7 29.8 20+ 4 weeks 11.7 11.8
- Figure 3 shows a curve representing the fraction of extractable fat as a function of total fat in these cheeses.
- the values on the x-axis (total fat) are values in volume percentages, obtained by image analysis.
- the values on the y-axis (extractable fat) are weight percentages, obtained by chemical analysis.
- a product according to the invention typically has a higher extractable fat percentage than a comparable naturally prepared product.
- the value for a Gouda-like cheese product according to the invention would typically have an extractable fat content in the hatched area of Figure 3 .
- a cheese product according to the invention having the same composition as a naturally prepared 20+ cheese, has a substantially higher amount of extractable fat.
- a conventionally prepared shaped cheese product with a homogenous fat globule distribution will display a lower percentage of extractable fat.
- the relationship between the total fat content of the product (TL) and the fraction of the total fats extractable by the modified Weibull method (EL) without protein degradation is preferably such that the amount of extractable fat as a percentage of the total fat content of the product is higher than for a comparable natural product (cheese), i.e. a product having the same composition (in particular having the same total fat content and the same protein content) and preferably the same age. More preferably, the extractable fat percentage is at least 1 percentile point higher.
- a product according to the invention in particular a Gouda-like cheese product, the following values preferably apply.
- Table 2 Sample preferred minimum extractable fat (weight % of total fat) more preferred minimum extractable fat (weight % of total fat) 48* 4 weeks 91.0 92.0 48* 7 months 96.0 97.0 30* 4 weeks 25.0 26.0 30* 4 months 30.0 31.0 20* 4 weeks 12.0 13.0 * marks product of the invention; the age referred to is the apparent age, i.e. referring to the age of a natural cheese the product resembles (even though it has not been ripened for such a long period)
- a preferred product, in particular a Gouda-like cheese product, according to the invention has an extractable fat content that can be described by the following function: EL > A + 45 * TANH ⁇ 0.2 * TL - 20.5 % wherein A is 48, 49, or 50.
- the dissector method is also of use to determine the inhomogeneity of a product according to the invention is. This is a stereology based Image Analysis approach ( John C Russ, Robert T. Dehoff, Practical Stereology, second edition, ISMN 0-306-46476-4, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers , which publication describes the said method).
- the dissector method allows the determination of the degree of connectivity in the fat phase. It provides a relative number (of fat globules) indicating this connective length, as shown in Table 3.
- Table 3 Type of Gouda cheese Mean number of globules per string 48+, 4 weeks 11.80 48+, 7 months 14.10 30+, 4 weeks 6.71 30+, 4 months 7.88 20+, 4 weeks 4.80
- Figure 4 shows the relation between extractable fat and the mean number of globules per string.
- the fat compartments between the gel particles can be seen as a string of fat globule beads.
- a product according to the invention has a higher mean number of fat globules per string than a naturally prepared product (for instance natural cheese) having the same amount of protein, fat and water, especially of such a product of the same age.
- the mean number of fat globules per string is at least 0.5 higher.
- a conventionally prepared shaped cheese product with a homogenous fat globule distribution typically displays a lower mean number of fat globules per string than a naturally prepared cheese having the same amount of protein, fat and water.
- the mean number of globules per string is preferably as indicated in Table 4.
- the relationship between the mean number of fat globules per string of the product (LGS) and the fraction of fat extractable by the modified Weibull method (EL) may be described by the following function: LGS > 0.0887 * EL + 4.643 or LGS > 0.0887 * EL + 4.8
- Figure 5 shows the intercept length vs. the number of fat globules.
- the abundance of different intercept lengths is graphically shown for three natural cheeses. It can be seen that the distribution of intercepts is rather broad for a 20+ cheese, compared to a 30+ and a 48+ cheese. The latter two have a much more pronounced peak in abundance at an intercept length of about 10 ⁇ m. This is an indication that 20+ cheese is more homogenous than 30+ cheese and 48+ cheese. In general, it is concluded that low-fat natural cheeses are more homogenous than high-fat natural cheeses.
- the abundance of the various intercept lengths can be compared with a comparative product (such as an essentially homogenous product).
- FIG. 6 the total intercept length distributions of natural Gouda cheeses of 30+ and 48+ and a 20+ soft-solid multi-phase food product with the designed inhomogeneous structure (20*), are compared with a natural Gouda cheese of 20+ (horizontal line).
- a graphical representation as shown in Figure 6 is suitable to visualise a difference in fat globule distribution of a product according to the invention compared to a more homogenous product (like natural 20+ cheese or homogenous processed cheese-like products known in the art) and compared to inhomogeneous natural cheese products (such as 30+ or 48+ Gouda-cheese).
- the comparative product is represented by the horizontal line.
- a product according to the invention is characterised by having an increased number of small intercept lengths, in particular for a cheese, preferably an increased number of intercept lengths with a value of 0 to about 5 ⁇ m (section a in Figure 6 ).
- the increase in such intercept lengths can be understood from the fact that the presence of gelled protein domains (essentially free of fat globules) in a product according to the invention forces the fat globules in a relatively small volume. In this volume, the fat globules are relatively close to each other, resulting in an increased number of small intercept lengths, compared to a homogenous processed product or naturally prepared cheese having the same fat, protein and water content.
- a product according to the invention further typically has an increased abundance of intercept lengths of a relatively large size (section d in Figure 6 ), compared to a homogenous product and/or compared to a naturally prepared inhomogeneous product (such as 30+ or 48+ cheese).
- This is the result of the presence of relatively large gelled protein domains, which are usually essentially free of fat globules.
- the dimensions of the gelled protein domains determine the lower limit at which intercept length the abundancy of intercept lengths is increased. This limit is represented by the intersection between the product of the invention and the comparative product (intersection point c in Figure 6 ). This point is a measure for the length-scale of the inhomogeneities. The higher the intersection c is, the more inhomogeneous the product is.
- intersection c depends upon the exact nature of the product and may be fine-tuned by selecting gelling conditions, shearing of the gel and the like. Generally, the intersection c will have a value of at least 30 ⁇ m, preferably of at least 40 ⁇ m, in particular order to realise a desirable level of inhomogeneity that contributes to an advantageous structure disintegration during oral processing.
- the upper threshold found is typically of length scales of 300 microns and more.
- Engelen found for crystalline particles an upper limit at 150 microns. This lower limit is due to the non-deformable character of crystalline particles (Thesis Lina Engelen, Wageningen University, 2004, chapter 4: Oral size perception of particles: effect of size, type, viscosity and method).
- the upper limit for the section d (section with increased number of intercept lengths), also referred to as the upper limit for the length scale of inhomogeneities, depends on the type of product. A suitable upper limit is determined by the desired sensory performance.
- the abundance of intercept lengths in a product according to the invention is increased up to a value of 500 ⁇ m or less, in particular up to 300 ⁇ m or less, more in particular up to 200 ⁇ m or less.
- the upper limit for increased intercept lengths is preferably 150 ⁇ m or less, in particular if the viscosity of the gel phase is relatively low and/or the deformability of the gel-domains is relatively low.
- gelled protein domains usually have a size of up to 500 ⁇ m (in at least one dimension).
- size (in at least one dimension) of the gelled protein domains is 300 ⁇ m or less.
- at least the majority of the gelled protein domains has a size (in at least one dimension) of 150 ⁇ m or less.
- a product of the invention is characterised by having an increased number of relatively small intercept lengths (for instance less than about 5 ⁇ m, in a 20* cheese product), a decreased number of medium sized intercept lengths (for instance of about 20 ⁇ m, in a 20* cheese product), and an increased number of relatively long intercept lengths (for instance of more than about 40 ⁇ m, in a 20* cheese product), compared to a naturally prepared cheese having the same quantitative and qualitative chemical composition (same amount of water, same fat and same protein in the same concentration) .
- rheological measurements double compression, fracture behaviour in triple-point geometry
- rheological measurements double compression, fracture behaviour in triple-point geometry
- rheological measurements may be used to compare the mechanical properties of a cheese (analogue) product according to the invention with a naturally prepared cheese or a homogeneous shaped cheese (analogue) product.
- Further evaluation by trained sensory panels may be used to demonstrate that a product according to the invention shows similar behaviour as known from natural cheeses. Such methods are generally known in the art.
- the gelled protein may be prepared in any way suitable for the specific protein that is acceptable for a foodgrade product. Suitable proteins in particular include milk proteins (caseins and whey proteins), especially caseins and whey proteins from cow milk.
- the gel comprises casein (which may be wholly or partially in the form of a caseinate).
- casein which may be wholly or partially in the form of a caseinate.
- a mixture of proteins may be used.
- skimmed milk powder sodium caseinates
- WPC powder whey protein concentrates
- whey permeates (modified) starch (corn, tapioca, potato, rice, wheat, or mixtures thereof)
- gums such as microbial gums (gellan gum), ionically neutral gums (e.g. konjac), anionic gums (e.g. carrageenan, agar, alginate) to prepare the gel
- Concentrated skim milk may also be used.
- whey protein can be used as a protein source to provide the protein matrix.
- the inability of whey proteins to be retained in the coagulum is an important factor contributing to a lack of efficiency in production of cheese curds, and to a reduction in overall yield relating to the incorporation of all the protein solids that are present in the starting dairy liquids into resulting cheese curds.
- one or more other ingredients may be present in the gel, such as at least one ingredient selected from fillers and pH-adjusting agents.
- Preferred fillers include polysaccharides, in particular polysaccharides selected from the group consisting of starches, agar and gellan. Polysaccharides are preferred in view of their good water binding capacity and/or their positive contribution to the mechanical properties of the product.
- Preferred pH adjusting agent are inter alia phosphates.
- the concentration of fat in the protein gel is usually less than 48+, preferably less than 30+, even more preferably less than 20+ or 10+.
- the gel is preferably essentially free of fat.
- the gel may be formed as particles or as a monolithic structure which structure is fragmented as part of the method of the invention. Suitable ways of forming particles directly or by fragmentation are known in the art. Suitable fragmentation techniques include shearing and grating. Usually particles are provided with a size to provide gelled protein domains with a size as described above.
- the oil in water emulsion may be provided by mixing a suitable fat above its melting point (or melt range in case of a mixture) with water or an aqueous solution, in the presence of a suitable emulsifier, such as cream serum powder containing the natural composition of the fat globular membrane.
- a suitable emulsifier such as cream serum powder containing the natural composition of the fat globular membrane.
- the emulsion may comprise one or more additives, in particular one or more additives selected from the group consisting of flavours, additional nutritional ingredients, ingredients for benefiting health, and colorants (e.g. anatto).
- the colorant can also be added to the pre-gel mixture (see below). By adding one or more appropriate flavourings and/or colorants the desired taste and/or appearance can be obtained.
- the content of emulsifier, in particular protein, in the emulsion is preferably comparable to a concentration characteristic for dairy cream.
- the oil in water emulsion is preferably selected from oil in water emulsions other than cheese milk, in particular other than full fat milk.
- Suitable fats include vegetable fats and animal fats.
- Preferred animal fats include in particular milk fat, especially cow milk fat.
- Preferred vegetable fats include sunflower fat, soybean fat, rapeseed fat, corn/maize fat and mixtures thereof.
- a fat is used with an increased ratio polyunsaturated fat to saturated fat (pufa/safa) compared to dairy fat, and optional blends.
- the emulsion is a dairy cream, especially a cream made from cow milk.
- the fat content in the emulsion is preferably in the range of 35 to 44 wt. % based on the weight of the emulsion.
- the ratio fat to protein gel phase is preferably chosen such that a product is obtained with a fat content in the range of 5+ to 48+, more preferably 5+ to 30+, even more preferably 5+ to 20+ or 5+ to 10+.
- an extruder use is made of an extruder.
- the gelled protein particles and the oil in emulsion are preferably mixed in an extruder.
- the shaping preferably is performed by extrusion.
- the emulsion is combined with the gelled protein relatively near towards the outlet of the extruder and/or that the extruder is operated at a relatively low flow rate (i.e. at a relatively low rotation speed of the screw(s)).
- Extrusion is also eminently suited to manufacture a wide range of product shapes (e.g. slices, bars, pillows) and filled products.
- the shaped product may be used (sold) directly. There is no need to subject the shaped product to brining. The preferred absence of a brining step is highly beneficial for environmental reasons.
- the product may be sold and consumed without having been matured, although this is in principle possible.
- the invention provides the advantageous possibility to provide a relatively young product with the appearance of a more mature product.
- the provision of the mixture of gelled protein, and oil in water emulsion may be formed in several ways. In particular suitable are the following approaches.
- the mixture may be formed by using the exclusion principle wherein a gelled phase in used in combination with an emulsion phase.
- the gelled phase is obtained from a meltable gel by heating (first part of extruder) followed by cooling (re-gelling) and subsequent addition of the fat emulsion in the part of an extruder where re-gelling takes place. Cooling rate, rotation speed, and zone of addition determine the size of the exclusion domains (see Example 1).
- the gelled phase is obtained by the use of cold set gellation.
- a pre-gel is prepared (heated and stirred vessel) and fed into an extruder. Following the heating zones of the extruder the sheared pre-gel enters the cooling zone which initiates gel formation. Gelling under shear provides gelled domains that provide the exclusion condition needed to obtain the inhomogeneous fat distribution.
- the fat emulsion is added to the extruder at or behind the cooling zone to obtain the exclusion conditions (see Example 2).
- the fat emulsion in the form of a gelled fat emulsion. Addition of the fat emulsion is also possible to divide the fat emulsion over the pre-gel mixture and the gelled fat emulsion (see Example 3).
- the forming of the mixture may further be accomplished by feeding an extruder with a mixture containing both the pre-gel mixture and the fat emulsion (optionally in gelled form).
- the first part of the extruder is usually heated, followed by a cooling zone, which is also the zone of addition.
- phase separation approach As a possible alternative for the exclusion principle a phase separation approach can be applied.
- the phase separation approach the incompatibility of a protein phase, a hydrocolloid phase, or a mixture of both, with a fat phase under conditions of heating and an applied shear is used to create the spatial inhomogeneities of the fat and protein phase providing the above described engineered structures.
- gel and emulsion are formed essentially simultaneously.
- a fat free casein gel was made by mixing 67.8 kg of frozen standard fat free rennet curd (having a moisture content of about 63 wt %) with 24.2 kg of Sodium Caseinate and 1 kg of polyphosphate (Joha C; supplier: Joha) mixture. This mixture was melted by heating with, life steam (direct steam injection). to about 96 °C under vigorous agitation, during which about 7 kg of steam condensed and was incorporated as water in the mixture. The resulting molten fat free casein gel was left to cool to about 4 °C over night. Next the casein gel was grated to chips of about 5x2x1 mm.
- the grated fat free casein gel was continuously fed to a co-rotating twin screw extruder, at ambient temperature by means of a feed hopper.
- the feed rate of the casein gel was set at 15 kg/hr.
- the set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows zone 1:: 20, zone 2: 50, zone 3: 60, zone 4: 100, zone 5: 100, zone 6: 30, zone 7: 25, zone 8: 20, zone 9: 20 °C.
- the extruder screw rotation speed was set at 100 rpm.
- the cream had a fat content of 35 wt %.
- the cream was fed to the extruder by means of a positive displacement pump at the end of zone 3.
- the feed rate was set at 6.5 kg/hr.
- the resulting heterogeneous fat/casein product left the extruder through a die with a length of 0.1 m.
- the experiment was repeated with a die having a length of 1 m.
- the product is ready as such. Optionally it may be cut or shaped further.
- the sensoric properties were evaluated for texture and flavour.
- the product was appreciated as having the texture and flavour in between a young and a old semi-hard cheese.
- An aqueous suspension was made of 30 wt% skim milk powder, 20 wt% starch and 3.0 wt% agar, at ambient temperatures. This mixture had a total solids content of 53 wt%. It was continuously fed at ambient temperature to a co-rotating twin screw extruder at a feed rate of 15 kg/hr.
- the set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows: 60, 100, 120, 120, 90, 40, 20, 10, 10 °C.
- Temperature measurements in the barrel wall of the extruder indicated deviations to these set point temperatures of up to 3 °C.
- the extruder screw rotation speed was set at 150 rpm.
- the extruder screw profile contained only positive displacement screw elements.
- the elements were arranged in 2 sets in series with a pitch decreasing from 1 D to 1 ⁇ 4 D to assure sufficient filling of the extruder.
- Cream with a fat content of about 35wt. % was added at a flow rate of 2.5 kg/hr in the zone where the mixture was cooled to about 90 °C.
- the heterogeneous mix was further cooled to temperatures between 10 and 20 °C after which the mix left the extruder through a die with a length of 0.50 m and a diameter of 0.010 m.
- An aqueous suspension comprising 18 wt% skim milk powder, 4.5 wt% starch, 9.0 wt % sodium caseinate, 0.9 wt % gellan and 23 wt% cream containing 43 % fat was made at ambient temperature.
- This mixture having a total solids content of 55 wt%, was continuously fed at ambient temperature to a co-rotating twin screw extruder at a feed rate of 11 kg/hr.
- the extruder having a length over diameter ratio of 36 and a diameter of 36 mm, consisted of 9 zones with individual cooling and heating facilities.
- the set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows: 30, 100, 100, 95, 60, 50, 40, 20, 10 °C. Temperature measurements in the barrel wall of the extruder indicated deviations to these set point temperatures of up to 3 °C.
- the extruder screw rotation speed was set at 100 rpm.
- the extruder screw profile contained only positive displacement screw elements.
- the elements were arranged in 2 sets in series with a pitch decreasing from 1 D to % D to assure sufficient filling of the extruder.
- cheese cubes were added of about 5 mm is size.
- the cheese a Gouda foil cheese 4 weeks of age, was added at a flow rate of 9.6 kg/hr.
- Images were made with a Leica inverted Confocal Scanning Laser Microscope (TCS SP2, DM IRE2) with a 63x water objective, zoom 1.
- Image size 1024 x 1024 pixels, scansize 238.1 ⁇ m x 238.1 ⁇ m.
- the images were analysed using the image analysis program Fovea Pro and PhotoShop. Methods were developped to determine the intercept length, and the connectivity of the fat globules.
- the intercept length method measures the size distribution of the spaces between the fat globules.
- the connectivity of the fat globules is determined with the disector method.
- the end points of chains of fat globules are determined in a 3D stack of images.
- the connectivity can be calculated from this number of endpoints and the number of fat globules, present in the milk of which the cheese is made.
- Figure 8 shows a PCA plot, wherein the products appear as points (• for prior art products, ⁇ for products of the invention, y, m and o in the prior art products referring to "young", “mature” and “old”, respectively. The products of the invention were tested without being aged).
- the attributes (product properties: "cheese oral texture”, “fatty oral texture”, “meltability”, “firmness”, “crumbliness”, “rubberiness”) appear as vectors passing through the origin. A vector only gives a direction and has no beginning or ending. One can see how high a product scores on an attribute by drawing a line from the product perpendicular to the vector of that attribute and looking at the distance between the intersection and the origin ( Lawless, H.T. & H. Heymann (1999), Sensory Evaluation of Food - Principles and Practices, Aspen Publishers, Inc., Maryland, USA .).
- the 20+ cheeses give a crumbly, rubbery and firm oral texture when eaten and do not score particularly high on a typical cheese oral texture. However, especially young 48+ cheeses score higher on the latter and are less crumbly, rubbery and firm when consumed. By contrast, these give a fattier oral texture and melt (solve) better in the mouth.
- the products of the invention have similar scores as the 48+ cheeses on fatty perception and meltability. These may be slightly more rubbery and they have a less typical cheesy oral texture.
Landscapes
- Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
- Chemical & Material Sciences (AREA)
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Food Science & Technology (AREA)
- Polymers & Plastics (AREA)
- Dairy Products (AREA)
Description
- The invention relates to a method for preparing a food product, in particular a soft-solid food product.
- As defined herein, a soft-solid food product is a food product that primarily exhibits elastic deformation (elastic deformation: G'>G") upon applying a stress, and in which a relatively small stress is needed to obtain a substantial deformation, either due to low elastic modulus or small yield stress. Further details on soft-solid food products are described in :P. Walstra (2003) Physical Chemistry of Foods; Chapter 17: Soft-solids; Marcel Dekker, New York, which chapter contains a further description of soft-solid food products. In particular a stress of up to 10 000 Pa is considered a small stress.
- A well-known soft-solid food product is cheese. Other soft-solid food products include those exhibiting elastic deformation upon applying a stress similar to a stress needed to elastically deform a cheese.
- Traditionally, cheese making is a process wherein milk ingredients are concentrated in order to preserve the ingredients for a long, or at least a prolonged period of time. At present, various cheeses, cheese analogues and cheese-related specialties are known, which differ in their composition from natural cheeses.
- Natural cheeses are defined herein as cheeses made directly from milk. The CODEX GENERAL STANDARD FOR CHEESE (CODEX STAN A-6-1978, Rev.1-1999, Amended 2003) provides the following definition: cheese is the ripened or un-ripened soft or semi-hard, hard and extra hard product, which may be coated, and in which the whey protein/casein ratio does not exceed that of milk, obtained by: (a) coagulating wholly or partly the following raw materials: milk and/or products obtained from milk, through the action of rennet or other suitable coagulating agents, and by partially draining the whey resulting from such coagulation; and/or (b) processing techniques involving coagulation of milk and/or products obtained from milk which give an end-product with similar physical, chemical and organoleptic characteristics as the product defined under (a). It is noted that such cheeses generally meet the above definition of a soft-solid food product (i.e. not only a soft cheese, but also semi-hard, hard or extra hard cheese is generally a soft-solid food product).
- Cheese products or cheese-analogue products may be made by (partially) replacing traditional raw materials (in particular milk) for other raw materials, such as different protein sources or fat substitutes.
- The motivation for the use of non-dairy proteins, e.g. vegetable proteins, is to obtain a cheaper high protein food than natural cheese. Examples of documents illustrating the use of non-dairy proteins are:
US-A-2004/0018292 (soy protein concentrates and isolates applied in process cheese products), andUS-B-6,495,187 (soy protein isolates in fresh unripened cheese analogues and cheese analogues). - The use of fat substitutes, e.g. polysaccharides, is mainly a way to yield a low fat cheese product.
- Commonly, the preparation of processed cheese products with non-traditional additives such as alternative proteins and/or fat substitutes involves making a blend of a dairy material and the other raw materials. Examples of methods for preparing such products are described in
EP 1 123 658 A2US-B-6,322,841 . - A non-fat cream cheese type product having the appearance, taste and consistency of fat-containing cream cheese is provided in
U.S. Patent 5,079,024 . Concentrated skim milk is heated together with an emulsifier salt. The resulting mixture is transferred to a second agitating mixer, then combined with a gum to provide a thickened skim milk. After homogenization, the resulting mixture is transferred to a third agitating mixer, and a suitable bulking agent and an additional gum are added while heating with agitation. The mixture is then homogenized again to provide the cream cheese product. The manufacture of this cream cheese product requires both an emulsifier salt and a bulking agent, as well as a complex process, including multiple heating, agitation, and homogenization steps. - Conventional methods to make processed cheese products involve process steps such as intimate mixing and homogenizing with the aim to achieve a homogeneous blend and a homogeneous product structure. This degree of homogeneity is thought to be necessary to obtain a product behaviour similar to that of natural cheese as it is assumed that the structure of natural cheeses is homogeneous. This aim for optimal maximum mixing in order to obtain homogeneous structures is common in the art. E.g.
US 5,103,773 describes the manufacture of a non-fat cream-cheese product, wherein a slurry of microcrystalline and skim-milk in prepared, which slurry is sheared in a high shear zone. However, the present inventors have realised that this aim is a shortcoming caused by lack in insight in the structure of cheese. - Based upon new insights, the present inventors have found that it is possible to prepare a soft-solid food product, such as a cheese product, which may be shaped, or cheese analogue product, which may be shaped, with a good mouth feel and mouth sensation, in particular a mouth feel and sensation similar to a traditionally produced cheese.
- The inventors have discovered that inhomogeneities in the structure of natural cheese, especially inhomogeneities in the spatial distribution of the dispersed phase, are responsible for the desired in-mouth sensory behaviour.
- Natural cheese, manufactured from non-homogenized milk, can be considered as a soft-solid multi-phase food product consisting of an aqueous para-casein phase and a dispersed fat phase.
- The inventors have realised that in natural cheeses such as in semi-hard Gouda type cheeses, in particular those containing about 48 weight % fat or more in dry matter, the fat droplets (2 - 8 micron in diameter) show a characteristic inhomogeneous spatial distribution, typically providing chain-like arrangements, over the continuous hydrophilic casein matrix. The indication used below for a product comprising about 48wt.% fat is "48+". In general, "x+" means that the percentage of fat is about x wt. %. For
instance 30+ and 20+ cheese have about 30 or 20 weight % fat or more in dry matter, respectively). -
Figure 2 schematically shows the structure of a traditionally prepared Gouda cheese.Sections section 1 is more hydrophobic and has a lower water/ionic content thansection 2.Section 1 also has stiffer mechanical properties thansection 2. The fat globules 3 have weaker mechanical properties thansections - The heterogeneity of such bi-continuous structure can be described as a spatial arrangement of protein rich, and especially casein rich domains separated by enclosing fat connective areas. In Gouda cheese and the like, the casein domains have a typical length scale of 30 - 100 micrometers. The fat phase is comprised of globules still containing their fat globular membrane preventing direct interactions between the continuous protein phase and the oil content of the fat globules. The fat globular membrane acts as spacer and can be considered as an interruption in the matrix structure. Due to the history of structure development of the cheese during manufacturing and storage/ripening these connective fat areas play a crucial role in the structure disintegration during oral processing. During consumption, the solid piece of cheese shows a preference to fall apart along these connective fat areas and converts into a dispersion of fragments in the saliva. The fragments consist of the casein rich domains enclosed by and exposing the fat phase. This typical fracture behaviour also facilitates the release of the flavours that have their highest concentrations in these fat rich areas. This conversion into fragments gives rise to the characteristic, malleable, creamy attributes appreciated by the consumers, and is considered as a main quality attribute.
- The connectivity in the fat phase can be revealed using a non-invasive imaging technique allowing visualization of the three-dimensional structure of the material with sufficient spatial resolution. The characteristic fracture behaviour of Gouda type cheeses, containing 48 weight % fat in dry matter, along the fat connective areas can be described by double compression measurements and using the triple-point geometry in fracture measurements. Suitable ways to carry this out are, e.g., described in J.F.C. Meullenet, J.Gross (1999) Instrumental single and double compression tests to predict sensory texture characteristics of foods, Journal of Texture Studies 30, 167-180 and in IDF Bulletin: Rheological and Fracture properties of cheese (chapter 3), No 268/1991.
- Imaging techniques applied to these freshly created fracture surfaces can prove the preferential fracture of the material through the fat connective phases and domains rich in fat globules. The fracture surfaces contain more fat globules than one might expect from the fat/protein volume ratio indicating preferential fracture through fat rich domains.
- It has been found possible, and this is an important aspect of the present invention, to make improved effective use of the fat phase by inhomogeneously distributing the fat phase in the product. This allows to preparation of e.g. a processed cheese or cheese-like product, which resembles at least to an extent the spatial distribution of the fat phase in a natural cheese.
- Accordingly, the present invention relates to a method for preparing a food product, in particular a soft-solid dairy food product such as a cheese product or a cheese analogue product comprising
- providing a mixture comprising an oil in water emulsion and a gel, said gel comprising a protein, preferably a dairy protein;
- fragmenting the gel;
- regenerating the gel; and
- shaping a product from the mixture, wherein the product comprises a gel phase comprising the (dairy) protein, said gel phase having a relatively low fat content, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a plurality of fat globules formed from the oil in water emulsion, said globules forming a phase having a relatively high fat content.
-
Figure 1 schematically shows the "exclusion principle" which may be used in order to prepare a product in accordance with the invention. -
Figure 2 schematically shows the connectivity of fat globules in a product of the invention. -
Figure 3 shows a curve representing the amount of extractable fat as a function of total fat in natural cheeses. -
Figure 4 shows the relation between extractable fat and the mean number of globules per string in natural cheeses. -
Figure 5 shows the intercept length vs. the number of fat globules in several cheeses. -
Figure 6 , the total intercept length distributions of natural Gouda cheeses of 30+ and 48+ and a 20+ soft-solid multi-phase food product of the invention (20*), relative to a natural Gouda cheese of 20+ (horizontal line). -
Figure 7 shows a characteristic connectivity of fat globules visualised by an analysis using a non-invasive imaging technique. -
Figure 8 shows a PCA plot comparing sensory performance of a product of the invention and known products. - The invention further relates to a method for altering the sensory performance of a food product which method comprises inhomogeneously distributing fat globules in the food product. The performance may in particular be altered with respect to one or more of the following attributes:
- "cheese oral texture", i.e. the similarity to yellow cheese in the mouth of the product;
- "crumbliness": the amount of particles, without taking crystals into account (crumbliness may be divided in "direct crumbliness": i.e. after chewing briefly and "later crumbliness", i.e. just before swallowing);
- "fatty oral texture": an indication of how fatty the oral texture is perceived
- "firmness": a measure for how the product feels when biting through (a product being more firm the higher resistance when biting through);
- "meltability": ease with which the product solves/falls apart in the mouth;
- "rubberiness:": the extent to which the product has a rubber-like oral texture during chewing;
- "stickiness": the extent to which the product tends to stick to palate and teeth;
- "creamy mouthfeel" .
- In addition or alternatively one or more other attributes may be altered, in particular one ore more attributes selected from elasticity, hardness, dryness, graininess, smoothness, remainings, fracturability and fatty impression.
- Elasticity is a manual attribute, indicating the degree of return to original size/shape after compression/release between thump and finger.
- With respect to hardness, in particular the mouthfeel hardness., i.e. the hardness perceived in the mouth (from soft to hard, may be altered.
- With respect to dryness, in particular the (afterfeel) dryness perceived in the mouth after swallowing, such as thirsty sensation after swallowing, may be altered.
- With respect to graininess, in particular the mouthfeel graininess, i.e. the perception of particles in the mouth may be altered.
- With respect to smoothness, in particular the mouthfeel smoothness, i.e. smooth texture perceived in the mouth may be improved.
- Fatty impression is a manual attribute, relating to the presence of a coating on fingertips after sweeping a sample's surface 3 times.
- Remainings is related to the after-feel the product leaves in the mouth, after swallowing the product.
- Fracturability is an attribute regarding how fast a product breaks after the appearance of a first tear in the product, when held in both hands and bent.
- The sensory performance may be assessed by trained sensory panels (QDA panels), which are capable of determining an attribute as described above.
- The attribute's alteration may be perceived statically (at a specific moment in time) and/or dynamically (intensity over time).
- The attribute's alteration may be perceived statically (at a specific moment in time) and/or dynamically (intensity over time).
- In principle, any food product, wherein fat globules can be distributed inhomogeneously, may be prepared in accordance with the invention.
- In principle, the food product may be a solid product or a pourable product (such as a thick viscous liquid, e.g. liquid yoghurt, "vla" -a custard-like dessert, popular in the Netherlands - or a product having a similar viscosity).
- The food product may a pourable product, preferably a thick viscous liquid. A product is considered pourable if it can be poured from a filled package, when held diagonally and the outflow opening is held downward. In particular, a product is considered a thick viscous liquid if the viscosity, as measured with a Brookfield viscometer (
spindel 5, 10 rpm, 7°C), is 10 to 70 Pa.s, in particular at least 15 Pa.s, preferably at least 30 Pa.s. - Preferred pourable products in particular include liquid yoghurt., liquid yoghurt-based products, custard, "vla" (Dutch), a custard-like dessert popular in the Netherlands which is available in a range of different tastes, e.g. in vanilla, chocolate, caramel and in various fruit flavours, or a product having a similar viscosity to any one of these.
- The product may be spoonable, which means that the product can easily be spooned from a plate or a bowl. A spoonable product may be a pourable product or a non-pourable (slightly) gelled product, usually with a short texture. In particular, examples of spoonable products, in addition to the above mentioned pourable products are mousses and creams, in particular sour cream, whipped cream, ice-cream, and soft curd cheese.
- The soft-solid food product may in particular be a product exhibiting elastic deformation upon applying a stress similar to a stress needed to elastically deform a cheese.
- Preferred soft-solid food products include processed cheese products and cheese-analogue products.
- Other preferred soft-solid products of which a sensory property may be altered in particular include set yoghurts, set desserts, cottage/cream cheeses, (dairy) bars, (dairy) snacks, sauces, pastes and sausages.
- Typically, the food product is a food product other than naturally prepared cheese. However, it may resemble a natural cheese, in particular with respect to the texture, mouthfeel and/or taste. In an embodiment, the food product does not substantially ripen during storage, or at least less than a natural product of the same chemical composition.
- If desired, the invention may be used to create a texture which resembles the texture of a natural product -in particular a natural cheese - of a specific age, as a result of the production process, comprising creating an inhomogeneous distribution of the fat globules, resembling a product that has the specific age. Thus, e.g., a product having a texture of a mature or old product (such as mature or old cheese) can be obtained without needing to store (ripen) the product, or at least achieving such texture within a reduced ripening time.
- The shaping may in particular comprise extruding the mixture. The product may be directly shaped when leaving extruder into the final shape of the end-product. It is also possible to extrude the mixture and bring it into a mould.
- The invention further relates to a food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product - obtainable by a method according to the invention.
- The invention further relates to a food product - in particular a (processed) soft-solid dairy food product, such as a (processed) cheese or (processed) cheese analogue product -comprising a gel phase comprising a protein, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a fat phase formed by a plurality of fat globules, wherein the fat globules are spatially inhomogeneously distributed, as determinable by determining the intercept length profile of the fat phase.
- The gelled protein phase can usually be regarded as a conglomerate of gelled protein domains (conglomerated particles/fragments) that are interconnected. In particular, the gelled protein phase may usually be regarded as a substantially continuous phase, wherein the fat phase is dispersed.
- For a desirable inhomogeneity of the product, at the average size of these domains should at least be about 20 µm, as determined by the intercept length method, discussed in more detail below. A preferred upper limit for the size depends on the mechanical properties of the gelled protein. The upper limit can suitably be determined by a QDA panel (QDA= qualitative descriptive analysis).
- The size of the gel domains, the viscosity of the gel phase and the deformability of the gel domains play a role in the mouthfeel. In general, the mouthfeel is experienced as smoother when the size of the domains is decreased, the viscosity is increased and/or the deformability is increased.
- For a smooth mouth-feel, at least the majority of the domains preferably have a size of 500 µm or less, more preferably 300 µm or less, even more preferably 150 µm or less.
- The invention aims to allow the manufacture of low fat products that provide full fat performance. In particular, the invention provides a method to prepare a processed (shaped) cheese or cheese analogue product having a desirable mouth sensation, also, or better; even, at a relatively low fat content.
- The inventions also allows the use of health beneficial ingredients e.g. vegetable unsaturated oils.
- The invention further offers one or more processing advantages. Due to the possibility to use low cost ingredients and to the fact that a product according to the invention can be prepared without a maturation step and/or a brining step, which steps are time consuming, a method according to the invention is simplified and costs can be saved compared to natural cheese making.
- In addition, a method of the invention is highly flexible and allows good tuning of manufacturing volumes to market requirements, without needing large storage capacity.
- In particular, textural properties and/or flavour properties can be fine-tuned independently from each other, in a method according to the invention. This is an advantage over naturally prepared products. Thus, it has been found possible to provide a product with a textural appearance of a relatively young product (such as young cheese) and a flavour appearance of a relatively mature product (such as old cheese), or vice versa.
- The term "fat" is generally used herein as a generic term for carboxylate esters of glycerine (glycerides); in particular triglycerides are fats. The term "fat" includes compounds that are solid and compounds that are liquid at room temperature.
- The term "oil" is used to describe that the fat is liquid. For instance, the oil in the oil in water emulsion comprises one or more fats which form a liquid phase at the processing temperature during at least part of the method. In the final product (at room temperature), the oil may have partially or fully solidified. Preferably, the fat globules comprise one or more fats that are liquid at the temperature in the oral cavity of a human (about 35-37°C).
- In accordance with the present invention use may be made of the "exclusion principle". A preferred example thereof is schematically shown in
Figure 1 . In accordance with this principle a gel may be made comprising water and a protein (which typically acts as a gellator), in particular or preferably a milk protein. - After the gel has been made, the gel is mixed with an oil in water emulsion. The gel may be made in the form of gel particles or the gel may be fragmented after formation to create gel particles. In the course of processing (shaping; aging) the particles/fragments are allowed to become interconnected, which may be accomplished by aging.
- By mixing the emulsion with the gel after the gel has formed, the oil phase is kept substantially out of the gel phase. Thus the gel particles impose a heterogeneous spatial distribution of the emulsion enclosing and separating the gel particles, and excluding the presence of fat globules at the locations of the gel particles self ("exclusion principle"). It should be noted that the fragmenting of the gel may take place prior and/or during mixing with the emulsion. Further, it is in principle possible to mix gel (particles), oil phase and water phase simultaneously, thereby forming the emulsion during the mixing with the gel.
- Preferably, one or more other ingredients, such as one or more flavours and/or aromas, are premixed with the emulsion prior to mixing with the gel, to obtain compartmentalization of these ingredients in the fat-rich domains. During oral processing, these compartments are exposed facilitating the proper release of the ingredients. This design provides a fracture behaviour, through the fat containing domains, and oral performance comparable to natural full fat cheeses may thereby be achievable.
- The exclusion principle further allows the full or partial replacement of the protein (casein) matrix in, for instance, the cheese or cheese analogue product. Thereby a considerable reduction of the fat content can be realised. Still a product may be prepared that is capable of providing a sensory appreciation
- in particular a good mouth sensation such as good taste and/or mouthfeel - that is comparable to a natural cheese product. - In accordance with the invention, it is contemplated that the engineered structure provides effective use of a large portion, and possibly essentially all, fat present in the product through maximal exposure of the fat for sensory perception.
- The fat content may be chosen within wide limits. Usually, the fat content in the food product is at least 0.5 wt. % based upon dry weight. Usually the fat content is up to 60 wt.% based upon dry weight. Thus, the invention may suitably be employed to prepare a product with an engineered structure having a creamy performance, similar to 48+ Gouda type, but generally having a lower fat content. If desired, a cheese or analogue product with a creamy performance similar to Gouda (like) cheese having a different fat content (such as a 30+ cheese, a 20+ cheese, or a 10+ cheese) can be obtained.
- The determination of the presence of spatially inhomogeneously distributed fat globules will now be discussed, exemplified by making use of a shaped product according to the invention, prepared while making use of protein gel of casein or skimmed milk powder and a dairy product (in particular a dairy cream) as the oil in water emulsion in comparison with traditionally prepared Gouda-type cheeses and low-fat varieties thereof as comparator.
- The characteristic connectivity of fat globules (see also
Figure 2 ) may be visualised by an analysis using a non-invasive imaging technique such as confocal scanning laser microscopy (seeFigure 7 ). - In a product according to the invention, the percentage of extractable fat is higher than in a product wherein the fat is homogenously distributed, and usually also higher than in a comparable naturally prepared cheese (based on the same ingredients in the same amounts). The percentage of extractable fat can be determined by the Soxhlet extraction according Weibull in combination with a modified version of the Weibull method (methods IDF 126A (1988) Milk products and milk-based foods (special cases), Determination of fat content Weibull-Bentrop gravimetrix method.)
- In the modified version of the Weibull method, the protein degradation is omitted. The Weibull method allows the total fat extraction. The modified version allows the extraction of fat in the connective fat phase only and in connection with the outer-surface of the cheese. The percentage of extractable fat according to the modified method is a measure for the degree of fat exposure for sensory perception. The connective (fat/matrix) interfaces are one of the underlying structural features. The larger the connectivity is the more fat will be extracted.
- Table 1 shows the amount of total fat (Weibull) and extractable fat as a percentage of the total fat (Weibull modified) for some naturally prepared Gouda cheeses and low fat variants thereof.
Table 1 Sample total fat content (weight % of total) extractable fat (weight % of total fat) 48+, 4 weeks 29.8 90.7 48+, 7 months 32.6 95.2 30+, 4 weeks 18.4 24.4 30+, 4 months 17.7 29.8 20+ 4 weeks 11.7 11.8 -
Figure 3 shows a curve representing the fraction of extractable fat as a function of total fat in these cheeses. The values on the x-axis (total fat) are values in volume percentages, obtained by image analysis. The values on the y-axis (extractable fat) are weight percentages, obtained by chemical analysis. - A product according to the invention typically has a higher extractable fat percentage than a comparable naturally prepared product.
- In particular, the value for a Gouda-like cheese product according to the invention would typically have an extractable fat content in the hatched area of
Figure 3 . For instance, a cheese product according to the invention having the same composition (same amount of protein (casein), fat, water) as a naturally prepared 20+ cheese, has a substantially higher amount of extractable fat. In contrast, a conventionally prepared shaped cheese product with a homogenous fat globule distribution will display a lower percentage of extractable fat. - For a product according to the invention, in particular for a cheese or cheese like product, more in particular for a Gouda-like cheese product according to the invention the relationship between the total fat content of the product (TL) and the fraction of the total fats extractable by the modified Weibull method (EL) without protein degradation is preferably such that the amount of extractable fat as a percentage of the total fat content of the product is higher than for a comparable natural product (cheese), i.e. a product having the same composition (in particular having the same total fat content and the same protein content) and preferably the same age. More preferably, the extractable fat percentage is at least 1 percentile point higher.
- Thus, for a product according to the invention, in particular a Gouda-like cheese product, the following values preferably apply.
Table 2 Sample preferred minimum extractable fat (weight % of total fat) more preferred minimum extractable fat (weight % of total fat) 48* 4 weeks 91.0 92.0 48* 7 months 96.0 97.0 30* 4 weeks 25.0 26.0 30* 4 months 30.0 31.0 20* 4 weeks 12.0 13.0 * marks product of the invention; the age referred to is the apparent age, i.e. referring to the age of a natural cheese the product resembles (even though it has not been ripened for such a long period) - The skilled person will be able to routinely determine extractable fat percentages for different products, having a different fat content and/or age and prepare a product according to the invention having a higher extractable fat content than a comparable natural product (cheese) based upon the present description and claims.
-
- The dissector method is also of use to determine the inhomogeneity of a product according to the invention is. This is a stereology based Image Analysis approach (John C Russ, Robert T. Dehoff, Practical Stereology, second edition, ISMN 0-306-46476-4, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, which publication describes the said method).
- The dissector method allows the determination of the degree of connectivity in the fat phase. It provides a relative number (of fat globules) indicating this connective length, as shown in Table 3.
Table 3 Type of Gouda cheese Mean number of globules per string 48+, 4 weeks 11.80 48+, 7 months 14.10 30+, 4 weeks 6.71 30+, 4 months 7.88 20+, 4 weeks 4.80 - As the product ripens, the connectivity in the fat phase increases. The higher the fat content the stronger, this effect.
-
Figure 4 shows the relation between extractable fat and the mean number of globules per string. The fat compartments between the gel particles can be seen as a string of fat globule beads. A product according to the invention has a higher mean number of fat globules per string than a naturally prepared product (for instance natural cheese) having the same amount of protein, fat and water, especially of such a product of the same age. Preferably, the mean number of fat globules per string is at least 0.5 higher. - In contrast, a conventionally prepared shaped cheese product with a homogenous fat globule distribution typically displays a lower mean number of fat globules per string than a naturally prepared cheese having the same amount of protein, fat and water.
- In a product according to the invention, in particular for a Gouda-like cheese, the mean number of globules per string is preferably as indicated in Table 4.
Table 4 total fat content (wt % of total): preferred type of product preferred min. mean number of globules per string more preferred min. mean number of globules per string 30 48*, 4 weeks 12.0 12.3 33 48*, 7 months 14.3 14.6 18 30*, 4 weeks 7.0 7.2 18 30*, 4 months 8.0 8.4 12 20* 4 weeks 5.0 5.3 * marks product of the invention; the age referred to is the apparent age, i.e. referring to the age of a natural cheese the product resembles (even though it has not been ripened for such a long period) -
- A measure for the typical minimal size for effective inhomogeneities is provided by the Intercept Length method (John C Russ, Robert T. Dehoff, Practical Stereology, second edition, ISMN 0-306-46476-4, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers). This method is particularly suitable to characterise a product according to the invention. The principle of this method is as follows: a screen of parallel lines is transposed on a microscopic picture of the product. Along the lines the distance between subsequent fat globules (the intercept lengths) is determined and counted.
-
Figure 5 shows the intercept length vs. the number of fat globules. InFigure 5 , the abundance of different intercept lengths is graphically shown for three natural cheeses. It can be seen that the distribution of intercepts is rather broad for a 20+ cheese, compared to a 30+ and a 48+ cheese. The latter two have a much more pronounced peak in abundance at an intercept length of about 10 µm. This is an indication that 20+ cheese is more homogenous than 30+ cheese and 48+ cheese. In general, it is concluded that low-fat natural cheeses are more homogenous than high-fat natural cheeses. - The abundance of the various intercept lengths can be compared with a comparative product (such as an essentially homogenous product).
- In
Figure 6 , the total intercept length distributions of natural Gouda cheeses of 30+ and 48+ and a 20+ soft-solid multi-phase food product with the designed inhomogeneous structure (20*), are compared with a natural Gouda cheese of 20+ (horizontal line). A graphical representation as shown inFigure 6 is suitable to visualise a difference in fat globule distribution of a product according to the invention compared to a more homogenous product (like natural 20+ cheese or homogenous processed cheese-like products known in the art) and compared to inhomogeneous natural cheese products (such as 30+ or 48+ Gouda-cheese). The comparative product is represented by the horizontal line. - Compared to a relatively homogenous conventional product of essentially the same composition (in particular having the same fat, protein and water content), a product according to the invention is characterised by having an increased number of small intercept lengths, in particular for a cheese, preferably an increased number of intercept lengths with a value of 0 to about 5 µm (section a in
Figure 6 ). The increase in such intercept lengths can be understood from the fact that the presence of gelled protein domains (essentially free of fat globules) in a product according to the invention forces the fat globules in a relatively small volume. In this volume, the fat globules are relatively close to each other, resulting in an increased number of small intercept lengths, compared to a homogenous processed product or naturally prepared cheese having the same fat, protein and water content. - A product according to the invention further typically has an increased abundance of intercept lengths of a relatively large size (section d in
Figure 6 ), compared to a homogenous product and/or compared to a naturally prepared inhomogeneous product (such as 30+ or 48+ cheese). This is the result of the presence of relatively large gelled protein domains, which are usually essentially free of fat globules. The dimensions of the gelled protein domains determine the lower limit at which intercept length the abundancy of intercept lengths is increased. This limit is represented by the intersection between the product of the invention and the comparative product (intersection point c inFigure 6 ). This point is a measure for the length-scale of the inhomogeneities. The higher the intersection c is, the more inhomogeneous the product is. The value of intersection c depends upon the exact nature of the product and may be fine-tuned by selecting gelling conditions, shearing of the gel and the like. Generally, the intersection c will have a value of at least 30 µm, preferably of at least 40 µm, in particular order to realise a desirable level of inhomogeneity that contributes to an advantageous structure disintegration during oral processing. - If the inhomogeneities in length scale go beyond this threshold the viscosity of the matrix during oral processing allows resolving the undesired non-smooth character of the (virtual) fat free domains which is responsible for the drop in sensorial performance. The upper threshold found is typically of length scales of 300 microns and more. Engelen found for crystalline particles an upper limit at 150 microns. This lower limit is due to the non-deformable character of crystalline particles (Thesis Lina Engelen, Wageningen University, 2004, chapter 4: Oral size perception of particles: effect of size, type, viscosity and method).
- The upper limit for the section d (section with increased number of intercept lengths), also referred to as the upper limit for the length scale of inhomogeneities, depends on the type of product. A suitable upper limit is determined by the desired sensory performance.
- Usually, the abundance of intercept lengths in a product according to the invention (such as a cheese product or cheese-like product) is increased up to a value of 500 µm or less, in particular up to 300 µm or less, more in particular up to 200 µm or less. For a particularly smooth mouthfeel, the upper limit for increased intercept lengths is preferably 150 µm or less, in particular if the viscosity of the gel phase is relatively low and/or the deformability of the gel-domains is relatively low.
- In practice, this means that usually essentially all gelled protein domains usually have a size of up to 500 µm (in at least one dimension). For a pleasant mouth feel it is preferred that the size (in at least one dimension) of the gelled protein domains is 300 µm or less. In particular it is preferred that at least the majority of the gelled protein domains has a size (in at least one dimension) of 150 µm or less.
- As a consequence of the high number of both relatively small intercept lengths and relatively large intercept lengths, the number of intercept lengths of intermediate size (section b in
figure 6 ) is decreased compared to a more homogenous product. - Taking the above into consideration, in an embodiment a product of the invention is characterised by having an increased number of relatively small intercept lengths (for instance less than about 5 µm, in a 20* cheese product), a decreased number of medium sized intercept lengths (for instance of about 20 µm, in a 20* cheese product), and an increased number of relatively long intercept lengths (for instance of more than about 40 µm, in a 20* cheese product), compared to a naturally prepared cheese having the same quantitative and qualitative chemical composition (same amount of water, same fat and same protein in the same concentration) .
- Besides techniques to determine inhomogeneity, rheological measurements (double compression, fracture behaviour in triple-point geometry) may be used to compare the mechanical properties of a cheese (analogue) product according to the invention with a naturally prepared cheese or a homogeneous shaped cheese (analogue) product. Further evaluation by trained sensory panels may be used to demonstrate that a product according to the invention shows similar behaviour as known from natural cheeses. Such methods are generally known in the art.
- Above, a suitable method for preparing a product according to the invention has already been described in general terms. Suitable embodiments will now be discussed in more detail.
- The gelled protein may be prepared in any way suitable for the specific protein that is acceptable for a foodgrade product. Suitable proteins in particular include milk proteins (caseins and whey proteins), especially caseins and whey proteins from cow milk.
- In a preferred embodiment the gel comprises casein (which may be wholly or partially in the form of a caseinate). A mixture of proteins may be used.
- The use of one ore more ingredients selected from the group consisting of skimmed milk powder, sodium caseinates, whey protein concentrates (WPC powder), whey permeates, (modified) starch (corn, tapioca, potato, rice, wheat, or mixtures thereof), and gums such as microbial gums (gellan gum), ionically neutral gums (e.g. konjac), anionic gums (e.g. carrageenan, agar, alginate) to prepare the gel is particularly preferred. Concentrated skim milk may also be used.
- It is an advantage over naturally prepared cheese that in accordance with the invention, whey protein can be used as a protein source to provide the protein matrix. In natural cheese making, the inability of whey proteins to be retained in the coagulum is an important factor contributing to a lack of efficiency in production of cheese curds, and to a reduction in overall yield relating to the incorporation of all the protein solids that are present in the starting dairy liquids into resulting cheese curds.
- It is noted that in conventional processes subsequent processing may be utilized to recover useful components such as whey protein from the byproduct whey, the whey produced in conventional cheese making nevertheless represents a significant environmental disposal issue.
- In addition to protein (and water) one or more other ingredients may be present in the gel, such as at least one ingredient selected from fillers and pH-adjusting agents.
- Preferred fillers include polysaccharides, in particular polysaccharides selected from the group consisting of starches, agar and gellan. Polysaccharides are preferred in view of their good water binding capacity and/or their positive contribution to the mechanical properties of the product.
- Preferred pH adjusting agent are inter alia phosphates.
- If present, the concentration of fat in the protein gel is usually less than 48+, preferably less than 30+, even more preferably less than 20+ or 10+. The gel is preferably essentially free of fat.
- The gel may be formed as particles or as a monolithic structure which structure is fragmented as part of the method of the invention. Suitable ways of forming particles directly or by fragmentation are known in the art. Suitable fragmentation techniques include shearing and grating. Usually particles are provided with a size to provide gelled protein domains with a size as described above.
- The oil in water emulsion may be provided by mixing a suitable fat above its melting point (or melt range in case of a mixture) with water or an aqueous solution, in the presence of a suitable emulsifier, such as cream serum powder containing the natural composition of the fat globular membrane. The emulsion may comprise one or more additives, in particular one or more additives selected from the group consisting of flavours, additional nutritional ingredients, ingredients for benefiting health, and colorants (e.g. anatto). The colorant can also be added to the pre-gel mixture (see below). By adding one or more appropriate flavourings and/or colorants the desired taste and/or appearance can be obtained.
- The content of emulsifier, in particular protein, in the emulsion is preferably comparable to a concentration characteristic for dairy cream.
- The oil in water emulsion is preferably selected from oil in water emulsions other than cheese milk, in particular other than full fat milk.
- Suitable fats include vegetable fats and animal fats. Preferred animal fats include in particular milk fat, especially cow milk fat. Preferred vegetable fats include sunflower fat, soybean fat, rapeseed fat, corn/maize fat and mixtures thereof. Preferably a fat is used with an increased ratio polyunsaturated fat to saturated fat (pufa/safa) compared to dairy fat, and optional blends. In a preferred embodiment the emulsion is a dairy cream, especially a cream made from cow milk.
- The fat content in the emulsion is preferably in the range of 35 to 44 wt. % based on the weight of the emulsion.
- The ratio fat to protein gel phase is preferably chosen such that a product is obtained with a fat content in the range of 5+ to 48+, more preferably 5+ to 30+, even more preferably 5+ to 20+ or 5+ to 10+.
- In a preferred embodiment, use is made of an extruder. The gelled protein particles and the oil in emulsion are preferably mixed in an extruder. In particular, the shaping preferably is performed by extrusion. For a high degree of homogeneity it is preferred that the emulsion is combined with the gelled protein relatively near towards the outlet of the extruder and/or that the extruder is operated at a relatively low flow rate (i.e. at a relatively low rotation speed of the screw(s)).
- Extrusion is also eminently suited to manufacture a wide range of product shapes (e.g. slices, bars, pillows) and filled products.
- After extrusion, the shaped product may be used (sold) directly. There is no need to subject the shaped product to brining. The preferred absence of a brining step is highly beneficial for environmental reasons. The product may be sold and consumed without having been matured, although this is in principle possible.
- As a product according to the invention usually has properties that are associated with more mature naturally prepared products (such as higher percentage of extractable fat, higher interconnectivity of the fat globules, and/or more fat globules per string), the invention provides the advantageous possibility to provide a relatively young product with the appearance of a more mature product.
- As described above, the provision of the mixture of gelled protein, and oil in water emulsion may be formed in several ways. In particular suitable are the following approaches.
- The mixture may be formed by using the exclusion principle wherein a gelled phase in used in combination with an emulsion phase.
- In an embodiment, the gelled phase is obtained from a meltable gel by heating (first part of extruder) followed by cooling (re-gelling) and subsequent addition of the fat emulsion in the part of an extruder where re-gelling takes place. Cooling rate, rotation speed, and zone of addition determine the size of the exclusion domains (see Example 1).
- In an embodiment, the gelled phase is obtained by the use of cold set gellation. Herein, a pre-gel is prepared (heated and stirred vessel) and fed into an extruder. Following the heating zones of the extruder the sheared pre-gel enters the cooling zone which initiates gel formation. Gelling under shear provides gelled domains that provide the exclusion condition needed to obtain the inhomogeneous fat distribution. In this embodiment, the fat emulsion is added to the extruder at or behind the cooling zone to obtain the exclusion conditions (see Example 2).
- It is also possible to add the fat emulsion in the form of a gelled fat emulsion. Addition of the fat emulsion is also possible to divide the fat emulsion over the pre-gel mixture and the gelled fat emulsion (see Example 3).
- Addition of a fat emulsion containing pre-gel mixture to a gelled fat emulsion is also possible.
- The forming of the mixture may further be accomplished by feeding an extruder with a mixture containing both the pre-gel mixture and the fat emulsion (optionally in gelled form).
- When use is made of an extruder in a method of the invention, the first part of the extruder is usually heated, followed by a cooling zone, which is also the zone of addition.
- Further principles for providing the gelling phase are:
- * reversible gelling. (Melting of an exiting gel by heating followed by gelling as a function of cooling).
- * cold set gelling (gelling by heating followed by cooling).
- * gelling in the presence of Ca++
- * enzymatic gelling (e.g. using transglutaminase, rennet)
- * gelling by acidification
- As a possible alternative for the exclusion principle a phase separation approach can be applied. In the phase separation approach the incompatibility of a protein phase, a hydrocolloid phase, or a mixture of both, with a fat phase under conditions of heating and an applied shear is used to create the spatial inhomogeneities of the fat and protein phase providing the above described engineered structures. In this approach gel and emulsion are formed essentially simultaneously.
- The invention will now be illustrated by the following examples.
- About 100 kg of a fat free casein gel was made by mixing 67.8 kg of frozen standard fat free rennet curd (having a moisture content of about 63 wt %) with 24.2 kg of Sodium Caseinate and 1 kg of polyphosphate (Joha C; supplier: Joha) mixture. This mixture was melted by heating with, life steam (direct steam injection). to about 96 °C under vigorous agitation, during which about 7 kg of steam condensed and was incorporated as water in the mixture. The resulting molten fat free casein gel was left to cool to about 4 °C over night. Next the casein gel was grated to chips of about 5x2x1 mm.
- The grated fat free casein gel was continuously fed to a co-rotating twin screw extruder, at ambient temperature by means of a feed hopper. The feed rate of the casein gel was set at 15 kg/hr.
- The extruder, with a length over diameter ratio of L/D=36 and a diameter of 32 mm, consisted of 9 zones with individual cooling and heating facilities. The set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows zone 1:: 20, zone 2: 50, zone 3: 60, zone 4: 100, zone 5: 100, zone 6: 30, zone 7: 25, zone 8: 20, zone 9: 20 °C. The extruder screw rotation speed was set at 100 rpm.
- About 40 kg of cream was separated from raw milk by centrifugation. The cream had a fat content of 35 wt %. The cream was fed to the extruder by means of a positive displacement pump at the end of zone 3. The feed rate was set at 6.5 kg/hr.
The resulting heterogeneous fat/casein product left the extruder through a die with a length of 0.1 m. The experiment was repeated with a die having a length of 1 m. - The product is ready as such. Optionally it may be cut or shaped further. The sensoric properties were evaluated for texture and flavour. The product was appreciated as having the texture and flavour in between a young and a old semi-hard cheese.
- An aqueous suspension was made of 30 wt% skim milk powder, 20 wt% starch and 3.0 wt% agar, at ambient temperatures. This mixture had a total solids content of 53 wt%. It was continuously fed at ambient temperature to a co-rotating twin screw extruder at a feed rate of 15 kg/hr.
- The extruder, having a length over diameter ratio of L/D=36 and a diameter of 36 mm, consisted of 9 zones with individual cooling and heating facilities. The set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows: 60, 100, 120, 120, 90, 40, 20, 10, 10 °C. Temperature measurements in the barrel wall of the extruder indicated deviations to these set point temperatures of up to 3 °C.
- The extruder screw rotation speed was set at 150 rpm.
- The extruder screw profile contained only positive displacement screw elements. The elements were arranged in 2 sets in series with a pitch decreasing from 1 D to ¼ D to assure sufficient filling of the extruder.
- Cream with a fat content of about 35wt. % was added at a flow rate of 2.5 kg/hr in the zone where the mixture was cooled to about 90 °C.
- The heterogeneous mix was further cooled to temperatures between 10 and 20 °C after which the mix left the extruder through a die with a length of 0.50 m and a diameter of 0.010 m.
- An aqueous suspension comprising 18 wt% skim milk powder, 4.5 wt% starch, 9.0 wt % sodium caseinate, 0.9 wt % gellan and 23 wt% cream containing 43 % fat was made at ambient temperature. This mixture, having a total solids content of 55 wt%, was continuously fed at ambient temperature to a co-rotating twin screw extruder at a feed rate of 11 kg/hr.
- The extruder, having a length over diameter ratio of 36 and a diameter of 36 mm, consisted of 9 zones with individual cooling and heating facilities. The set point temperatures for each of the zones were as follows: 30, 100, 100, 95, 60, 50, 40, 20, 10 °C. Temperature measurements in the barrel wall of the extruder indicated deviations to these set point temperatures of up to 3 °C.
- The extruder screw rotation speed was set at 100 rpm.
- The extruder screw profile contained only positive displacement screw elements. The elements were arranged in 2 sets in series with a pitch decreasing from 1 D to % D to assure sufficient filling of the extruder. In the fifth zone, half way in the extruder, cheese cubes were added of about 5 mm is size. The cheese, a
Gouda foil cheese 4 weeks of age, was added at a flow rate of 9.6 kg/hr. - Cheese samples were stained for 30 minutes with fluoresceinisothiocyanate and nile red (0.1%/0.01%) in polyethyleneglycol, glycerol and water (50%/45%/5%).
- Images were made with a Leica inverted Confocal Scanning Laser Microscope (TCS SP2, DM IRE2) with a 63x water objective,
zoom 1. Image size: 1024 x 1024 pixels, scansize 238.1 µm x 238.1 µm. - The images were analysed using the image analysis program Fovea Pro and PhotoShop. Methods were developped to determine the intercept length, and the connectivity of the fat globules. The intercept length method measures the size distribution of the spaces between the fat globules.
- The connectivity of the fat globules is determined with the disector method. In this method the end points of chains of fat globules are determined in a 3D stack of images. The connectivity can be calculated from this number of endpoints and the number of fat globules, present in the milk of which the cheese is made.
- The sensory performance of several 20+ and 30+ products of the invention and several known cheeses having the same fat content were compared with several 48+ cheeses.
-
Figure 8 shows a PCA plot, wherein the products appear as points (• for prior art products, ◆ for products of the invention, y, m and o in the prior art products referring to "young", "mature" and "old", respectively. The products of the invention were tested without being aged). - The attributes (product properties: "cheese oral texture", "fatty oral texture", "meltability", "firmness", "crumbliness", "rubberiness") appear as vectors passing through the origin. A vector only gives a direction and has no beginning or ending. One can see how high a product scores on an attribute by drawing a line from the product perpendicular to the vector of that attribute and looking at the distance between the intersection and the origin (Lawless, H.T. & H. Heymann (1999), Sensory Evaluation of Food - Principles and Practices, Aspen Publishers, Inc., Maryland, USA.).
- The 20+ cheeses give a crumbly, rubbery and firm oral texture when eaten and do not score particularly high on a typical cheese oral texture. However, especially young 48+ cheeses score higher on the latter and are less crumbly, rubbery and firm when consumed. By contrast, these give a fattier oral texture and melt (solve) better in the mouth. The products of the invention, have similar scores as the 48+ cheeses on fatty perception and meltability. These may be slightly more rubbery and they have a less typical cheesy oral texture.
Claims (16)
- Method for preparing a soft-solid food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a cheese product or a cheese analogue product - comprising- providing a mixture comprising an oil in water emulsion and a gel, said gel comprising a protein;- fragmenting the gel;- regenerating the gel; and- shaping a product from the mixture, wherein the product comprises a gel phase comprising the protein, said gel phase having a relatively low fat content, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a plurality of fat globules formed from the oil in water emulsion, said globules forming a phase having a relatively high fat content.
- Method according to claim 1, wherein the gel is subjected to fragmenting before or as part of mixing the gelled protein with the oil in water emulsion.
- Method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the fragmenting involves subjecting the gelled protein to grating or shearing.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the fragmenting of the gel takes place at a temperature below the gelling temperature and the regeneration of the gel is allowed to take place above the gelling temperature.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the mixture is extruded.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the protein is a dairy protein, in particular a dairy protein selected from caseins, including caseinates, and whey proteins.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the oil in water emulsion comprises a protein.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the oil in water emulsion is a dairy cream, optionally comprising additional ingredients.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the ratio of the gel to oil in water emulsion is chosen such that the fat content in the food product is in the range of 0.5 to 60 wt.% based upon dry weight.
- Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the product is a cheese product or a cheese analogue product.
- Soft-solid food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a cheese product or cheese analogue product - obtainable by a method according to any one of the preceding claims.
- Soft-solid food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a cheese product or cheese analogue product - according to claim 11, comprising a gel phase comprising a protein, and inhomogeneously distributed outside the gel phase a fat phase formed by a plurality of fat globules, wherein the fat globules are spatially inhomogeneously distributed, as determinable by determining the intercept length profile of the fat phase.
- Soft-solid food product, according to claim 12 wherein compared to a homogenous soft-solid food product of the same chemical composition, the number of relatively small intercept lengths is increased, the number of medium sized intercept lengths is decreased, and the number of relatively large intercept lengths is increased.
- Food product according to claim 13 wherein the relatively small intercept lengths have a value of 10 µm or less and/or the relatively large intercept lengths a value of at least 30 µm.
- Soft-solid food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a cheese product or cheese analogue product - according to any one of the claims 11 -14, comprising a gel phase, said gel comprising a protein and fat globules distributed outside the gel, wherein the relationship between the total fat content of the product (TL) and the fraction of fat extractable by a modified Weibull method (EL), which is modified in that protein degradation is omitted, can be described by the following function:
- Soft-solid food product - in particular a soft-solid dairy food product, such as a cheese product or cheese analogue product - according to any one of the claims 11-14, comprising a gel comprising a protein, said gel having a relatively low fat content, and fat globules distributed outside the gel, wherein the relationship between the mean number of fat globules per string of the product (LGS) and the fraction of fat extractable by a modified Weibull method (EL), modified by omitting protein degradation, can be described by the following function:
Priority Applications (4)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
HUE06076516A HUE026129T2 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | Soft-solid food product |
DK06076516.1T DK1884166T3 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | SOFT-FAST FOOD PRODUCT |
EP06076516.1A EP1884166B1 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | Soft-solid food product |
ES06076516.1T ES2557293T3 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | Soft Solid Food Product |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
---|---|---|---|
EP06076516.1A EP1884166B1 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | Soft-solid food product |
Publications (2)
Publication Number | Publication Date |
---|---|
EP1884166A1 EP1884166A1 (en) | 2008-02-06 |
EP1884166B1 true EP1884166B1 (en) | 2015-10-14 |
Family
ID=37192326
Family Applications (1)
Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
---|---|---|---|
EP06076516.1A Not-in-force EP1884166B1 (en) | 2006-08-01 | 2006-08-01 | Soft-solid food product |
Country Status (4)
Country | Link |
---|---|
EP (1) | EP1884166B1 (en) |
DK (1) | DK1884166T3 (en) |
ES (1) | ES2557293T3 (en) |
HU (1) | HUE026129T2 (en) |
Families Citing this family (3)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
US20100104712A1 (en) * | 2008-10-29 | 2010-04-29 | Conopco, Inc., D/B/A Unilever | Method of producing intact particles creating an appearance of cheese particulates in a shelf stable pasteurized sauce |
NL2004533C2 (en) | 2010-04-09 | 2011-10-11 | Friesland Brands Bv | Particle preparation by centrifugal dispersing. |
CA3124908A1 (en) | 2019-01-18 | 2020-07-23 | Frieslandcampina Nederland B.V. | Shaped cheese product |
Family Cites Families (3)
Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
---|---|---|---|---|
US5108773A (en) * | 1991-02-19 | 1992-04-28 | Kraft General Foods, Inc. | Method of making a non-fat cream cheese product |
US5532018A (en) * | 1994-02-14 | 1996-07-02 | Kraft Foods, Inc. | Method for manufacture of low fat natural cheese |
US6322841B1 (en) * | 2000-02-09 | 2001-11-27 | Kraft Foods, Inc. | Cheese-like dairy gels |
-
2006
- 2006-08-01 DK DK06076516.1T patent/DK1884166T3/en active
- 2006-08-01 EP EP06076516.1A patent/EP1884166B1/en not_active Not-in-force
- 2006-08-01 HU HUE06076516A patent/HUE026129T2/en unknown
- 2006-08-01 ES ES06076516.1T patent/ES2557293T3/en active Active
Also Published As
Publication number | Publication date |
---|---|
ES2557293T3 (en) | 2016-01-25 |
HUE026129T2 (en) | 2016-05-30 |
DK1884166T3 (en) | 2016-01-04 |
EP1884166A1 (en) | 2008-02-06 |
Similar Documents
Publication | Publication Date | Title |
---|---|---|
JP2620989B2 (en) | Use of mesophases in food | |
AU2014213517B2 (en) | Fine textured dairy product and process for its preparation | |
Truong et al. | Effect of milk fat globule size on the physical functionality of dairy products | |
JP2006254742A (en) | Cheese and/or cheese-like food | |
AU624900B2 (en) | Cheese product and process for preparing such | |
JP6738753B2 (en) | Cheese and method for producing the same | |
EP1884166B1 (en) | Soft-solid food product | |
El-Bakry et al. | Overview of processed cheese and its products | |
Truong et al. | Effect of milk fat globule size on functionalities and sensory qualities of dairy products | |
JP2017029022A (en) | Emulsification material for oil-in-water type emulsified fat | |
EP0800769B1 (en) | Packed diary spread with heterogeneous texture | |
JP7497593B2 (en) | Acetylated starch for cheese-like foods and cheese-like foods | |
JPH07255376A (en) | O/w-type emulsified oil and fat composition for acidic dessert | |
EP1688043B1 (en) | Low-fat cheese | |
JP4347660B2 (en) | Oil-in-water emulsified oil and fat composition | |
JP6774216B2 (en) | Edible foaming cream and edible whipped cream | |
JP6909348B2 (en) | Moisture-containing foam chocolate | |
JP7265346B2 (en) | Processed cheese and method for producing the same | |
JP2021112148A (en) | Acidic oil-in-water type emulsified food product and production method thereof | |
Sala et al. | Oral Processing of Dairy Products | |
Gallegos | Effects of Milk Protein Concentrate and Stabilizer Type on Shrinkage in Low Fat Ice Creams | |
JPS60110245A (en) | Production of natural cheeselike food | |
JP2020150931A (en) | Frozen dessert, and method for producing frozen dessert | |
JP2005058084A (en) | Frozen dessert and method for producing the same | |
JP2004321038A (en) | Oil-in-water emulsified composition and method for producing the same |
Legal Events
Date | Code | Title | Description |
---|---|---|---|
PUAI | Public reference made under article 153(3) epc to a published international application that has entered the european phase |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: 0009012 |
|
AK | Designated contracting states |
Kind code of ref document: A1 Designated state(s): AT BE BG CH CY CZ DE DK EE ES FI FR GB GR HU IE IS IT LI LT LU LV MC NL PL PT RO SE SI SK TR |
|
AX | Request for extension of the european patent |
Extension state: AL BA HR MK YU |
|
17P | Request for examination filed |
Effective date: 20080804 |
|
17Q | First examination report despatched |
Effective date: 20080912 |
|
AKX | Designation fees paid |
Designated state(s): AT BE BG CH CY CZ DE DK EE ES FI FR GB GR HU IE IS IT LI LT LU LV MC NL PL PT RO SE SI SK TR |
|
RAP1 | Party data changed (applicant data changed or rights of an application transferred) |
Owner name: FRIESLAND BRANDS B.V. |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DE Ref legal event code: R079 Ref document number: 602006046906 Country of ref document: DE Free format text: PREVIOUS MAIN CLASS: A23C0020000000 Ipc: A23C0019082000 |
|
GRAP | Despatch of communication of intention to grant a patent |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR1 |
|
RIC1 | Information provided on ipc code assigned before grant |
Ipc: A23C 20/00 20060101ALI20150116BHEP Ipc: A23C 19/082 20060101AFI20150116BHEP |
|
INTG | Intention to grant announced |
Effective date: 20150206 |
|
GRAP | Despatch of communication of intention to grant a patent |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR1 |
|
INTG | Intention to grant announced |
Effective date: 20150724 |
|
GRAS | Grant fee paid |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: EPIDOSNIGR3 |
|
GRAA | (expected) grant |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: 0009210 |
|
AK | Designated contracting states |
Kind code of ref document: B1 Designated state(s): AT BE BG CH CY CZ DE DK EE ES FI FR GB GR HU IE IS IT LI LT LU LV MC NL PL PT RO SE SI SK TR |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: GB Ref legal event code: FG4D |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: AT Ref legal event code: REF Ref document number: 754422 Country of ref document: AT Kind code of ref document: T Effective date: 20151015 Ref country code: CH Ref legal event code: EP |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: IE Ref legal event code: FG4D |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DE Ref legal event code: R096 Ref document number: 602006046906 Country of ref document: DE |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: RO Ref legal event code: EPE |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DK Ref legal event code: T3 Effective date: 20160103 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: ES Ref legal event code: FG2A Ref document number: 2557293 Country of ref document: ES Kind code of ref document: T3 Effective date: 20160125 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: LT Ref legal event code: MG4D |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: NL Ref legal event code: FP |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: AT Ref legal event code: MK05 Ref document number: 754422 Country of ref document: AT Kind code of ref document: T Effective date: 20151014 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: LT Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: IS Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20160214 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: HU Ref legal event code: AG4A Ref document number: E026129 Country of ref document: HU |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: PL Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: PT Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20160215 Ref country code: LV Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: AT Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: SE Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: GR Ref legal event code: EP Ref document number: 20160400012 Country of ref document: GR Effective date: 20160414 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DE Ref legal event code: R097 Ref document number: 602006046906 Country of ref document: DE |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: CZ Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
PLBE | No opposition filed within time limit |
Free format text: ORIGINAL CODE: 0009261 |
|
STAA | Information on the status of an ep patent application or granted ep patent |
Free format text: STATUS: NO OPPOSITION FILED WITHIN TIME LIMIT |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: FR Ref legal event code: PLFP Year of fee payment: 11 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: EE Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: SK Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
26N | No opposition filed |
Effective date: 20160715 |
|
PGFP | Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: NL Payment date: 20160729 Year of fee payment: 11 |
|
PGFP | Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: GB Payment date: 20160819 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: FI Payment date: 20160811 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: DE Payment date: 20160822 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: DK Payment date: 20160819 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: IT Payment date: 20160825 Year of fee payment: 11 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: SI Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
PGFP | Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: FR Payment date: 20160822 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: RO Payment date: 20160729 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: HU Payment date: 20160823 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: GR Payment date: 20160822 Year of fee payment: 11 |
|
PGFP | Annual fee paid to national office [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: ES Payment date: 20160810 Year of fee payment: 11 Ref country code: BE Payment date: 20160819 Year of fee payment: 11 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: MC Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: CH Ref legal event code: PL |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: CH Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20160831 Ref country code: LI Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20160831 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: IE Ref legal event code: MM4A |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: IE Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20160801 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: LU Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20160801 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DE Ref legal event code: R119 Ref document number: 602006046906 Country of ref document: DE |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: DK Ref legal event code: EBP Effective date: 20170831 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: NL Ref legal event code: MM Effective date: 20170901 |
|
GBPC | Gb: european patent ceased through non-payment of renewal fee |
Effective date: 20170801 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: FI Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170801 Ref country code: RO Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170801 Ref country code: HU Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170802 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: FR Ref legal event code: ST Effective date: 20180430 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: CY Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 Ref country code: GR Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20180305 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: BE Ref legal event code: FP Effective date: 20160108 Ref country code: BE Ref legal event code: MM Effective date: 20170831 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: NL Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170901 Ref country code: TR Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: GB Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170801 Ref country code: DE Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20180301 Ref country code: DK Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170831 Ref country code: BG Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF FAILURE TO SUBMIT A TRANSLATION OF THE DESCRIPTION OR TO PAY THE FEE WITHIN THE PRESCRIBED TIME-LIMIT Effective date: 20151014 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: BE Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170831 Ref country code: FR Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170831 Ref country code: IT Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170801 |
|
REG | Reference to a national code |
Ref country code: ES Ref legal event code: FD2A Effective date: 20181030 |
|
PG25 | Lapsed in a contracting state [announced via postgrant information from national office to epo] |
Ref country code: ES Free format text: LAPSE BECAUSE OF NON-PAYMENT OF DUE FEES Effective date: 20170802 |