AN ANTIMICROBIALLY ACTIVE WET WIPER BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The present invention relates to wet wipers and, more particularly, to an antimicrobially active wet wiper, to a meth¬ od of making the wiper, and to a method of enhancing the anti¬ microbial activity of the wet wiper.
Wet wiper products require antimicrobial properties to destroy or inhibit the growth of various microorganisms, bacte¬ ria, yeasts, and molds. The most universally common method of achieving this control is by the use of chemical antimicrobial agents dispersed or dissolved in the liquid phase of the wet wiper. This method is generally satisfactory from an antimicrobial efficacy standpoint, but has some inherent disad¬ vantages•
Namely, the nature of the chemicals used to achieve antimicrobial control often necessitates the use of various alcohols, surfactants, or other solubilizing agents to get suf¬ ficient quantities of the antimicrobial agents into solution and to allow a sufficient range of chemicals so as to impart a broad spectrum of antimicrobial control. The nature of the required chemicals and the complexity of the final liquid phase formula¬ tions inevitably result in residues being left behind on the skin of the user. Such residues may often prove harsh or irritating, thereby impeding the enjoyable use of the wet wiper produc .
It has already been shown by Michael P. Bouchette in U.S. Patent Application Serial Number 722,845, filed on September 5, 1985 entitled "Antimicrobially Active, Non-Woven Web used in a Wet Wiper," and issued as U.S. Patent No. 4,615,937, that a wet wiper product can be produced in which an antimicrobial is substantive to the wiper fabric or web and binder.
Although a recognized standard acceptable level of antimicrobial protection is associated with meeting the criteria set forth in the United States Pharmacopeia (U.S.P.) XIX 28 day challenge test, it is nonetheless advantageous to increase antimicrobial protection whenever it can be readily done without significantly affecting the product cost and/or the potential adverse consumer reaction. This potential adverse reaction can
be due to any number of factors, including both perceived com¬ plexity of the chemical formulation and actual allergic response to the chemicals. Although a wet wiper cannot be protected against all organisms, while still providing a viable product for consumer use, it is desirable to expand the scope of antimicrobial protection such that potentially harmful user con¬ tamination due to unforeseen microbial contamination may be re¬ duced or minimized. This results in an increase in the antimicrobial spectrum of resistance within the product.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
The present invention achieves these goals and pro¬ vides advantages over previous wet wipers. The present inven¬ tion is an antimicrobially active wiper that overcomes the sig¬ nificant and inherent disadvantages present in previous wet wipers.
The wet wiper of the present invention has an anti¬ microbial agent that is substantive to the fibers and the binder of the non-woven web when the web is either wet or dry. This antimicrobial agent will not leave harmful residues on the user's skin. The wet wiper of the present invention is main¬ tained in a liquid containing a second antimicrobial agent that acts as a preservative.
More particularly, the antimicrobially active wet wiper of the present invention has an antimicrobially active non-woven web. The web comprises (i) bonded fiber, (ii) a binder in an amount effective to bind the fibers, and (iii) a first antimicrobial agent that is substantive to the fibers and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry. This web is maintained in a wet condition in a liquid containing a second antimicrobial agent until use.
The present invention also provides a method for mak¬ ing an antimicrobially active, wet wiper. In the method, an unbonded fibrous web is formed. An uncured binder and a first antimicrobial agent are then applied throughout the unbonded fibrous web. The first antimicrobial agent is substantive to the fibers of the web and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry. The binder is cured to bind the fibers together to form an antimicrobially active, non-woven web. The web is
stored in a liquid containing a second antimicrobial agent to maintain the web in a wet condition until use.
Preferably, the substantive or first antimicrobial agent is an organo-silicon quaternary ammonium salt, such as a silyl-quaternary ammonium salt. Particularly preferred substan¬ tive antimicrobial agents are 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyldidecyl- ethyl ammonium salt and 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyl- octadecyldimethyl ammonium salt. Preferably, the second antimicrobial agent that is present in the liquid is a naturally occurring organic acid capable of exhibiting antimicrobial prop¬ erties, such as sorbic acid, citric acid, malic acid, or combi¬ nations thereof.
The foregoing and other features and advantages of the present invention will be made more apparent from the following description of the preferred embodiments.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
In accordance with the present invention, the wet wiper has an antimicrobially active non-woven web. This non-woven web includes bonded fibers and a binder in an amount effective to bind the fibers. Although various synthetic and natural fibers known in the art can be effectively used, the preferred fibers are cellulosic fibers and, more preferably, wood pulp fibers. The cellulosic fibers, such as wood pulp fibers, can be chemically treated prior to the formation of the web or fabric, if desired. Examples of wood pulp fibers include various mechanical and chemical pulp fibers, such as cedar fibers, Southern pine fibers, spruce fibers, and hemlock fibers. The particular fibers may be specifically selected to enhance properties such as texture (soft, wooly or fluffy), porosity, caliper, brightness, strength, and so on. Alternatively, the fibers can be a combination of natural and synthetic fibers, or synthetic fibers alone, depending upon the final attributes sought and the method of forming the web.
The weight of the fibers, such as cellulosic fibers, used to form the unbonded fibrous web can vary depending upon the ultimate non-woven web that is produced. Typically, the weight of the fibers forming the web will vary within the range of about 5 lbs. per 3000 ft2 to about 60 lbs. per 3000 ft2.
Various web or fabric forming techniques known in the art can be effectively used to form the unbonded fibers. The web can be formed by nonwoven techniques, such as air-laying the web or wet-laying the web. One type of apparatus for air forming fibers is shown in U.S. Patent No. 4,292,271 to Buob et al. Other non-woven manufacturing techniques, such as melt blown, spunbonded, needle punched, and spun laced, may also be used.
Various binders known in the art can be used to bind the fibers together. A preferred binder is a polymeric binder, such as a latex binder. Acceptable latex binders include aerylate emulsions, butadiene-styrene emulsions, ethylene vinyl acetate emulsions and acrylonitrile-butadiene emulsions. An especially effective latex binder is ethylene vinyl acetate, which is sold under the trademark AIRFLEX A-410 by Air Products, Inc. of Allentown, Pennsylvania. The binder can also include a mixture of anionic and nonionic binders, such as the ethylene vinyl acetate binder sold under the trademark AIRFLEX A-106 by Air Products, Inc. and the ethylene acetate binder sold under the trademark HA-8 by Rohm & Haas of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
The amount of the binder that is to be applied to the fibers depends, in part, upon the type of fibers, such as cellu¬ losic, and the type of the first antimicrobial agent being used in the non-woven web. Typically, the amount of the binder applied to the fibers varies within the range of about 5% to about 30% of total web weight. Similarly, the amount of solids in the binder, as applied to the web, especially in a latex binder, depends, inter alia, on the weight of the fibers in the non-woven web. Generally, latex binders having from about 5% to about 25% application solids content are used. Of course, one of ordinary skill in the art can select the particular binder, the amount of the binder used, and the amount of solids present in the binder, depending upon, in part, the type of fibers that are to be bound and the first antimicrobial agent being used. The binder is applied to the fibers by various techniques known in the art, such as spraying, foaming, or padding.
In accordance with the present invention, the non-woven web of the wet wiper has a first antimicrobial agent
that is substantive to the fibers and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry. The first antimicrobial agent is prefer¬ ably uniformly distributed on the fibers. The first or substan¬ tive antimicrobial agent is selected to be substantive to both the fibers of the web and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry. As used herein, an antimicrobial agent is substan¬ tive to the fibers and the binder if the antimicrobial agent attaches directly to the fibers of the web and to the binder without the need for an adhesive substance. Consequently, sub¬ stantive antimicrobial agents do not substantially diffuse from either the fibers or the binder used to bind the fibers together.
The first antimicrobial agent is selected to be sub¬ stantive to the binder in addition to being substantive to the fibers of the non-woven web. Hence, such an antimicrobial agent attaches directly to the binder and the fibers of the non-woven web without the need for an adhesive substance. Likewise, the ionic character of the binder is carefully chosen so that the antimicrobial active agent is usually substantially inert with respect to the binder to prevent ionic interaction of the anti¬ microbial agent and the binder.
Preferred first or substantive antimicrobial agents to be applied to the fibers and binder of the non-woven web are organo-silicon quaternary ammonium salts, such as a silyl- quaternary ammonium salt. Preferred organo-silicon quaternary ammonium salts are 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyldidecylmethyl ammo¬ nium salts, such as 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyldidecylmethyl ammonium chloride, and 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyloctadecyl- dimethyl ammonium salts, such as 3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyl- octadecyldimethyl ammonium chloride.
Examples of commercially available organo-silicon quaternary ammonium salts useful as the first or substantive antimicrobial agent in the present invention are sold under the trademarks SIQUAT 1977 by Sanitized, Inc. and DOW CORNING 5700 by the Dow Chemical Co. Another substantive antimicrobial agent that is not an organo-silicon quaternary ammonium salt is N-(2-methyl-l-napthyl maleimide) sold under the trademark Vinyzene 129 by Morton Thioxol, Ventron Division.
The first antimicrobial agent is preferably applied to thes fibers of the non-woven web prior to or simultaneously with the application of the binder. Although various amounts of the first antimicrobial agent are applied to the non-woven web depending upon, in part, the fibers selected and the particular binder used, the amount of the first antimicrobial active agent is typically in the range of about 0.25% to about 3% of the total web weight. A particularly preferred amount of the sub¬ stantive or first antimicrobial agent is about 1% to about 2% of the total web weight. When the first antimicrobial agent is applied to the non-woven web simultaneously with the binder, the first antimicrobial agent is preferably about 0.5% to about 10% of the binder volume and, most preferably, about 3.5% of the binder volume.
The first antimicrobial agents can be prepared by var¬ ious techniques known in the art. For example, U.S. Patent Nos. 4,406,892 to Eudy, 4,282,366 to Eudy, 4,394,378 to Klein, and 4,408,996 to Baldwin describe various organo-silicon quaternary ammonium compounds, especially silyl quaternary ammonium com¬ pounds, and methods of preparing these compounds. Likewise, articles in the scientific literature, such as Walters et al., Algicidal Activity of a Surface-Bonded Organosilicon Quaternary Ammonium Chloride, 25 Applied Microbiology, 253-256 (1972) and Isquith et al., Surface-Bonded Antimicrobial Activity of an Organosilicon Quaternary Ammonium Chloride, 24 Applied Microbiology, 859-863 (1972), also disclose methods of making various organosilicon quaternary ammonium compounds. Thus, the skilled artisan can readily select a method of preparing the desired first antimicrobial agent, such as an organosilicon quaternary ammonium compound.
The uncured binder and the first antimicrobial agent are applied to the unbonded fibers in a manner that allows the binder and the first antimicrobial agent to be present throughout the unbonded fibrous web and, hence, substantially uniformly distributed on the fibers. Accordingly, substantially all of the unbonded fibers of the web are to be contacted with the uncured binder and the first antimicrobial agent during this application process.
Various application methods and apparatus, known in the art, can be readily selected by the skilled artisan. For example, the uncured binder and the first antimicrobial agent are sprayed onto unbound fibers, such as cellulosic fibers, that have been airlaid on a foraminous support. Similarly, the uncured binder and the first antimicrobial agent can be con¬ tained in a bath through which the unbonded fibers pass. Other methods and apparatus include foaming and printing.
The binder material is then cured to bind the fibers together to form an antimicrobial, non-woven web. Various cur¬ ing? techniques known in the art, such as infra-red radiation, electron beam, and forced hot air, can be effectively selected and used by the skilled artisan to achieve the proper degree of binder cure.
As a result, an antimicrobially active, non-woven web is provided. The non-woven web has bonded fibers; a binder sub¬ stantially uniformly distributed on the fibers, the binder being present in an amount effective to bind the fibers; and a first antimicrobial agent being substantive to the fibers and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry.
In accordance with the present invention, the anti¬ microbially active, non-woven web is stored in a liquid contain¬ ing a second antimicrobial agent to maintain the web in a wet condition in the liquid until use. The liquid has a second antimicrobial agent in it, typically mild, naturally occurring selected organic acids.
The storage liquid for the wet wiper preferably is water and, most preferably, pure water having as its only ingre¬ dient the second antimicrobial agent. Such a storage liquid containing the second antimicrobial agent is safe for skin con¬ tact and a highly effective antimicrobial control that kills a broad spectrum of microorganisms. In addition, the preferred mild naturally occurring organic acids are edible and, typi¬ cally, are found in or extracted from foodstuffs, thereby also decreasing any likelihood of adverse allergenic skin reaction of the user.
The second antimicrobial agent is preferably an organ¬ ic acid that is capable of exhibiting antimicrobial properties.
SUBSTITUTESHEET
The skilled artisan can select appropriate antimicrobial organic acids that are compatible with the first or substantive anti¬ microbial agent and that can be safely used in the liquid stor¬ age of the wet wiper without providing an irritating or harmful residue on the user's skin. Preferred naturally occurring or¬ ganic acids include citric acid, sorbic acid, malic acid, and combinations thereof. An additional mild, but not naturally oc¬ curring, organic acid that may be used is ethylenediamine- tetraacetiσ acid. Preferably, the organic acid is present in the liquid in the range of about 0.05 wt% to about 2.0 wt% of the; tσta5L liquid and, most preferably, in the range of about 0.3 wt% to about 1.5 wt% of the total liquid.
An especially preferred antimicrobial agent for the storage liquid is a mixture of sorbic acid and citric acid. Preferably, this mixture has about 0.01% to about 0.20% weight sorbic acid and about 0.1% to about 0.5% weight citric acid, the weight percents being based upon the liquid. An example of an especially effective second antimicrobial agent mixture is 0.075% weight sorbic acid and 0.375% weight citric acid.
In the case of the non-woven web, the criteria for proper selection of the antimicrobial agent include substantivity, antimicrobial activity, and safety, such that the wet wiper is safe for use on human skin and eyes. In the case of the antimicrobial agents in the liquid load, the criteria are antimicrobial activity and mild so as to be safe for use on human skin and eyes and, preferably, naturally occurring. It may also be desirable that the liquid load antimicrobial agents are edible, in case the wet wiper is used for wiping the face or mouth.
The method of the present invention produces an anti¬ microbially active, wet wiper. Initially, the present method forms an unbonded fibrous web. An uncured binder and a first antimicrobial agent are then applied throughout the unbonded fibrous web, with the first antimicrobial agent being substan¬ tive to both the fibers of the web and to the binder when the web is either wet or dry. After application of the binder and the first antimicrobial agent, the binder is cured to bind the fibers together to form an antimicrobially active, non-woven
SUBSTITUTESHEET
web. The web is then stored in a liquid containing a second antimicrobial agent to maintain the web in a wet condition until use.
The following is an example of the present invention, and it is intended to be merely exemplary.
EXAMPLE
An antimicrobially active, non-woven web was prepared. Unbonded cellulosic fibers were air-laid to produce an unbonded cellulosic fiber web of 30 pounds per ream. An uncured latex binder having 4.2% of antimicrobial agent based on latex solids was applied throughout the cellulosic web to bring the final, bonded, treated web basis weight to 45 pounds per ream. The binder was then cured to bind the cellulosic fibers together to form an antimicrobial active, non-woven web. The web was then cut into several pieces that were stored in different storage liquids.
Web A was stored in a liquid consisting of water that did not contain any antimicrobial agent. Web B was stored in a liquid consisting of water containing 0.075% weight sorbic acid. Web.C was stored in a liquid of water containing 0.375% weight citric acid. Web D was stored in a liquid of water containing 0.075% weight sorbic acid and 0.375% weight citric acid.
The resulting air-laid, non-woven wet wipers were tested to determine their antimicrobial activity. Specifically, each wet wiper was tested to determine its effect on reduction and inhibition of five United States Pharmacopeia (U.S.P.) anti¬ microbial preservative effectiveness challenge organisms, plus the addition of Pseudomonas capacia, a likely contaminant in wet wipers.
Each wet wiper was subjected to Aspergillus niger, Candida albicans, Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coliformi Ca, and (LPseudomonas _c__e___p__a__c__i__a__ with total inoc- ulation levels of 10 to 10 microorganisms/ml. Subsequent total plate counts were taken at intervals of 10, 30, 60, and 120 minutes for bacteria, and 1, 4, 8, and 24 hours for fungi. The results are provided in Table 1.
TABLE NO . 1
Wet Wiper Lotion Additives Time E. coli S. aureus aeruginosa P. cepacia
10 min. 1.3 X 10' 1.2 X 10 1.7 X 1046.2 X 1
30 min. 2.4 X 10! 9.1 X 10 2.0 X 1045.4 X 1
60 min. 2.3 X 10! 9.1 X 10 1.6 X 1044.4 X 1
120 min. 2.6 X 10" 5.0 X 10 4 3.0 X 10* 7.0 X 10'
10 min. 2.2 X 10s 2.0 X 10J 1.3 X 10' 6.8 X 10*
B sorbic 30 min. 1.8 X 10' 8.0 X 10 4.5 X 10 6.2 X 10 acid 60 min. 1.7 X 10J 1.9 X 10J 3.5 X 10 5.2 X 10
120 min. 1.7 X 10 2.5 X 10 8.5 X 10* 1.0 X 10
10 min. 2.5 X 10' 1.6 X 10' 5.8 X 10' 30 citric 30 min. 4.7 X 10 8.0 X 10 30 10 acid 60 min. 1.0 X 10 8.4 X 10' 10 10
120 min. 4.2 X 10" 9.6 X 10' 10 10
D sorbic 10 min. 2.0 X 10 2.4 X 10' 10 10 acid & 30 min. 2.5 X 10* 1.6 X 10' 10 10 citric 60 min. 1.1 X 10* 10 10 acid 120 min. 2.0 X 102 2.2 X 10' 10 10
SUBSTITUTE SHEET
Wet Wiper
Lotion Additives TIME C. . albicans A. niger
1 hr. 10 4.7 X 103
A 4 hrs. 10 6.2 X 102
8 hrs. 10 2.1 X 102
24 hrs . 10 1.8 X 103
1 hr. 50 6.0 X 103
B 4 hrs. 10 3.8 X 103 sorbic acid 8 hrs. 10 3.1 X 103
24 hrs. 10 3.0 X 102
1 hr. 3. ,8 X 102 1.2 X 104
C 4 hrs. 10 2.4 X 103 citric acid 8 hrs. 10 3.2 X 102
24 hrs. 10 4.2 X 102
1 hr. 8. .7 X 102 1.5 X 104
D 4 hrs. 10 1.0 X 103 sorbic acid & 8 hrs. 10 5.5 X 102 citric acid 24 hrs. 10 30
Especially excellent antimicrobial results were obtained for web D that was stored in a liquid of water contain¬ ing both sorbic acid and citric acid. Such a wet wiper was especially effective in attacking E. coli, P. aeruginosa, and A. niger microorganisms for both the rate of kill and demonstrating superior microorganisms count reduction per unit time in comparision to a wiper consisting of a web treated with a sub¬ stantive antimicrobial plus pure water as the wetting solution, or a web treated with the substantive antimicrobial plus water and citric acid as the antimicrobial wetting solution. In addi¬ tion, sample D offered superior numerical microorganism plate count reduction for E. coli, and A. niger when compared to any of the other test systems.
Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to one skilled in the art from a consideration of the specification or with the practice of the invention disclosed herein. It is intended that the specification and example be considered as
ET
exemplary only with the true scope and spirit of the invention being indicated by the claims.
TT TESHEET