AU2006255489B2

AU2006255489B2 - Protection of autoclave batten strips

Info

Publication number: AU2006255489B2
Application number: AU2006255489A
Authority: AU
Inventors: Michael Bradbrook
Original assignee: Murrin Murrin Operations Pty Ltd
Current assignee: Murrin Murrin Operations Pty Ltd
Priority date: 2005-06-07
Filing date: 2006-06-07
Publication date: 2010-07-22
Anticipated expiration: 2026-06-07
Also published as: AU2006255489A1

Description

WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 "Protection of Autoclave Batten Strips" Field of the Invention This invention relates to vessels used in chemical processing applications, such as hydro-metallurgical refining of metal ore. More particularly, the invention relates 5 to batten strips (also known as batten straps) used in the fabrication of such vessels. While the invention has been devised particularly in relation to autoclaves, it is not necessarily limited thereto and may find application in other vessels used in chemical processing applications, including pressure vessels, tanks, and heat 10 exchangers. Background Art Autoclaves used in chemical processing applications, such as hydro-metallurgical refining of metal ores, are constructed using titanium owing to its characteristic of corrosion resistance. Typically, the autoclaves are constructed using plates of 15 titanium-clad steel, which can be considerably more cost-effective than solid titanium plate. The titanium provides the corrosion resistance and the steel provides strength as well as a cost-reduction. The plates are positioned one adjacent another and welded together. Autoclaves constructed of titanium-clad steel require particular fabrication 20 techniques because of differences in metallurgical characteristics, thermal expansion, modulus of elasticity and other aspects. Specifically, titanium and steel cannot be directly fusion welded to each other, owing to brittle inter-metallic formation. Fabrication using titanium-clad steel is typically accomplished using batten strips (sometimes also know as batten straps) at junctions between the 25 plates. The process requires that the titanium cladding be removed from the area around all edges where steel welds are to be made, typically about 12 millimeters inwardly from the plate edges. The steel base is prepared and welded using conventional steel fabrication procedures. The junction between adjacent plates WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 -2 is then cleaned and prepared for titanium welding. A filler metal strip is inserted into the space created by removal of the titanium. The batten strip, which is a wider strip of titanium, is then placed in position so as to overlay the filler strip and also bridge the titanium cladding on opposed sides of the filler strip. The batten 5 strip is then welded along the edges thereof with fillet welds. A "tell-tale" system is incorporated for identifying leakage from the autoclave arising from a loss of integrity of the weld strips. In chemical processing applications, the environment in an autoclave is typically harsh. Specifically, slurry flow within the autoclave can erode the batten strip fillet 10 welds, causing them to leak High pressure acid leach (HPAL) autoclaves have had a long history of batten strip failure and problems associated with leakage through the "tell-tale" systems. Indeed, erosion of the batten strips has been identified as the single biggest cause of leakage from such autoclaves. Leakage from batten strips is often the 15 primary reason for unplanned internal inspections and repairs on the autoclaves. Pad welding during planned inspections will minimize failures by erosion, however the risk of introducing a weld defect increases proportionally with each re-weld. The key to reducing erosion and re-welding is to protect the fillet weld from the slurry flow. 20 Erosion, or more correctly erosion corrosion, is the process where the protective metal oxide is mechanically abraded from the surface of a metal thereby exposing a clean metal surface upon which the oxide film reforms. This process occurs repeatedly and consequently leads to progressive removal of the metal. The process of erosion is velocity dependent. For titanium, there exists a critical 25 velocity below which the oxide film remains intact and protective. This critical velocity is dependent upon the chemical environment, the presence of wearing particles (slurry) and temperature. Erosion is exacerbated by turbulence.

WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 -3 For batten strips, erosion is the primary mode of failure. The fillet welds along the batten strips erode until such time as a breach occurs. Typically this is in the form of a longitudinal crack at the point of minimum weld throat thickness. Repeat failures due to grinding and weld repairs can be significant. Further, 5 repeated weld repairs to the batten strips can cause cracking in the liner. There have been various proposals seeking to reduce the rate of erosion of batten strips and therefore increase the time between leaks. One such proposal involved the use of sacrificial wear strips to protect the fillet welds on the sides of batten strips exposed to slurry flow. The wear strips were 10 manufactured from grade 5 titanium to minimize erosion loss and increase the amount of time between batten strip replacements. Wear strips were not, however, entirely satisfactory as they were isolated from the "tell-tale" system by the batten strip weld. Consequently, any erosion or welding defects that resulted in a loss of the seal could cause crevice corrosion in the titanium cladding. The 15 only way that such a leak could be detected was by a dye penetrant testing procedure, which required that the autoclave be offline. Another proposal involved the installation of wear plates to limit erosion within the autoclaves. While the wear plates were successful in preventing erosion, cracking along the fillet welds and lifting of plates introduced susceptibility to 20 crevice corrosion. As the extent of such crevice corrosion could possibly exceed the threat of erosion, the proposal did not prove to be altogether viable. A still further proposal involved a series of boxes affixed to the floor area of the autoclave for the purpose of collecting solids and thereby affording protection of the titanium underneath. This too did not prove to be altogether viable. 25 Yet another proposal involved the use of recessed batten strips. Because such strips were recessed into the internal surface of the autoclave, they were likely to be less prone to erosion. However, the plates from which the autoclave was fabricated were required to have provision for the recesses, thereby limiting the WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 -4 application of recessed batten strips to autoclaves specifically constructed to accommodate them. Thus, recessed batten strips were not an option of retrofitting to autoclaves not having specific provision for them. Notwithstanding the considerable efforts directed to the problem of the batten strip 5 erosion as reflected by the various proposals referred to above, no solution has yet been found. It is against this background, and the problems and difficulties associated therewith, that the present invention has been developed. The preceding discussion to the invention is intended only to facilitate an 10 understanding of the present invention. It should be appreciated that the discussion is not an acknowledgement or an admission that any of the material referred to was or is part of the common general knowledge as at the priority date of the application. Disclosure of the Invention 15 According to a first aspect of the invention there is provided a vessel comprising a plurality of titanium-clad plates welded one to another, batten strips welded to adjacent plates at the junctions therebetween, the batten strips being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges thereof, and a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. 20 Preferably, the coating covers the fillet weld and marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip. The marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip covered by the coating each preferably has a width of at least about 10mm. While the coating can be of any appropriate thickness, a coating thickness of 500 25 microns has been found to be particularly effective.

WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 Preferably, the coating is applied using thermal coating technology, such as flame spraying. Preferably, a sealant is applied to the coating. The sealant may comprise a non volatile, non-flammable sealant 5 It is expected that the coating will significantly increase the service life of the batten strips, perhaps to an extent of more than doubling the service life. Unlike the prior art proposals previously described for limiting erosion within autoclaves, the titanium dioxide coating can be easily removed if necessary. The titanium dioxide coating may provide protection even if damaged. By way of 10 example, it has (somewhat surprisingly) been found that effective protection for the fillet weld may be provided even in circumstances where some of the coating is removed (such as, for example, by accidental bead blasting the coating during a later maintenance procedure being performed in the autoclave). According to a second aspect of the invention there is provided a junction 15 between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, and a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. Preferably, the coating covers the fillet weld and marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip. 20 According to a third aspect of the invention there is provided a junction between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, and a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. 25 Preferably, the coating covers the fillet weld and marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip.

-6 According to a third aspect of the invention there is provided a method of performing reparation work on a vessel (such as an autoclave) fabricated from a plurality of titanium-clad plates welded one to another and having batten strips welded to adjacent plates at the junctions therebetween, the batten strips being 5 welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges thereof, the method comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. Preferably, the method further comprises applying the coating to adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip. In this way, the coating is applied to the fillet 10 weld and also to marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip. Preferably, the coating is applied using thermal coating technology, such as flame spraying. Preferably the method further comprises sealing the coating after its application. Preferably, the area to be coated is cleaned prior to application of the coating. The 15 cleaning process may comprise subjecting the area to a high pressure water spray. Preferably the method further comprises pre-heating the area to be coated. This assists in removal of any remnant moisture that may be present from the cleaning process. An oxy-acetylene torch can be used to heat the batten strip to 20 approximately to 50 0 C. Preferably, the area to be cleaned is prepared to receive the coating. The preparation may comprise subjecting the area to abrasive blasting to achieve the necessary surface roughness for adherence of the coating. The abrasive blasting may utilize grit such as aluminum oxide grit. 25 Where the area has been cleaned by grit blasting, the method preferably further comprises removal of excess grit from the work area, such as by sweeping and/or vacuuming the work area.

-7 The grit blasting and subsequent removal of excess grit are preferably performed immediately prior to application of the coating to minimize potential surface contamination. Preferably, the coating is applied first to the fillet weld, with the angle of incidence 5 of the particle stream in the flame spraying process being perpendicular to the exposed face of the fillet weld being coated. Once the fillet weld has been coated to the desired thickness, the position and angle of the particle stream is changed to be perpendicular to the adjacent surfaces and the coating applied thereto. According to a fourth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of 10 affording erosion protection to a junction between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, the method comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. 15 Preferably, the method further comprises applying the coating to adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip. According to a fifth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of affording erosion protection to a junction between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the 20 plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, the method comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on one of the fillet weld and to the adjacent portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip, the coating being applied first to the fillet weld and thereafter to the adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip. 25 Preferably, the coating is applied by way of a flame spraying process, the coating being first applied to the fillet weld with the angle of incidence of the particle stream in the flame spraying process being perpendicular to the fillet weld being coated, and thereafter the position and angle of the particle stream changed to be -8 perpendicular to the adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip and the coating applied thereto. According to a fourth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of affording erosion protection to a junction between two titanium-clad plates, the 5 junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, the method comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds. Preferably, the method further comprises applying the coating to adjacent portions 10 of the plate and the batten strip. According to a fifth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of affording erosion protection to a junction between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, the method 15 comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on one of the fillet weld and to the adjacent portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip, the coating being applied first to the fillet weld and thereafter to the adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip. Preferably, the coating is applied by way of a flame spraying process, the coating 20 being first applied by way of a flame spraying process, the coating being first applied to the fillet weld with the angle of incidence of the particle stream in the flame spraying process being perpendicular to the fillet weld being coated, and thereafter the position and angle of the particle stream changed to be perpendicular to the adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip and the 25 coating applied thereto.

-9 Brief Description of the Drawings The invention will be better understood by reference to the following description of one specific embodiment thereof, as shown in the accompanying drawings in which: 5 Figure 1 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a junction between two titanium clad plates used in the fabrication of an autoclave; Figure 2 is a schematic view of a coating applied to the junction of figure 1 in accordance with the embodiment; and Figure 3 is a schematic fragmentary view of the coating applied to the junction (on 10 an enlarged scale). Best Mode(s) for Carrying Out the Invention The embodiment is directed to reparation of a high pressure acid leach (HPAL) autoclave. Typically, such an autoclave is about 4.94 meters in diameter and about 33.4 meters long. The autoclave is fabricated using 102mm carbon steel 15 plate which is clad with 6mm (nominal) thick grade 1 titanium. The cladding is applied to the carbon steel by an explosion bonding process. The plates are rectangular and positioned one adjacent another. Adjacent edges of the plates are welded together, producing circumferential and longitudinal welded seams at their junctions. 20 Referring to figure 1, there is shown (in cross-section) a junction 10 between two adjacent titanium-clad steel plates 11, 12. Each titanium-clad steel plate 11, 12 comprises a steel base 13 and a titanium cladding 15. A strip of titanium cladding 15 is removed from the area around all edges at the junction, typically about 12 millimeters inwardly from each edge. The adjacent edge of each steel base 13 is 25 prepared, and the two edges are welded together by a double v-butt weld 17. The junction between adjacent plates is then cleaned and prepared for titanium -10 welding. A filler strip 19 of copper is inserted into the space 21 created by removal of the strips of titanium. A batten strip 23 of grade 2 titanium is then placed in position so as to overlay the filler strip 19 and also bridge the titanium cladding 15 on opposed sides of the filler strip. The batten strip 23 is then welded 5 along the edges with fillet welds 25, 27. A purge hole 29 is provided as a "tell tale" to indicate whether or not there has been a breach of the fillet welds 25, 27. The aspects of the junction 10 described above with reference to figure 1 are of conventional construction. The junction 10 according to the embodiment further comprises a coating 30 of 10 titanium dioxide applied to the particular fillet weld 25 exposed to slurry flow within the autoclave; that is, the coating 30 is applied to the fillet weld 25 that faces the agitator within the autoclave. The coating 30 covers the fillet weld 25, as well as the adjacent marginal portion 31 of the plate 11 and also the adjacent marginal portion 33 of the batten strip 23. 15 With this arrangement, the coating 30 has a central portion 30a covering the fillet weld 25 and two lateral portions 30b covering the marginal portions 31, 33 of the adjacent plate 11 and the batten strip 23, as shown in Figure 2 and 3. The marginal portions 31, 33 of the adjacent plate 11 and the batten strip 23 which are covered by the coating 30 each has a width of at least about 10mm. In other 20 words, each lateral portion 30b of the coating 30 has a width of at least about 10mm. The coating 30 also has a thickness of about 500 microns. The coating 30 is applied using thermal coating technology, which in this embodiment comprises an oxy-acetylene fueled flame spray process. The 25 feedstock for the flame spray process comprises titanium dioxide powder. Specifically, the titanium dioxide powder for this embodiment comprises powder marketed under the trade mark SULZER AMDRY 6505, with the specification -45 + 51im.

-11 The area to be coated is cleaned prior to application of the coating 30. The cleaning process comprises subjecting the area to a high pressure water spray. Preheating is necessary to remove any remnant moisture that may be present from the cleaning process. An oxy-acetylene torch can be used to heat the batten 5 strip to approximately to 50 0 C for this purpose. The flame spray process requires some abrasive blasting to achieve the desired surface roughness for adherence of the coating 30. In this embodiment, the abrasive media 46 is mesh aluminum oxide. The area to be coated is abrasive blasted immediately prior to application of the coating 30 to minimize potential 10 surface contamination. Excess grit material is, however, first removed from the work area, typically by sweeping and/or vacuuming. The coating 30 is applied first to the fillet weld 25, with the angle of incidence of the particle stream being perpendicular to the exposed face 25a of the fillet weld. Once the face 25a of the fillet weld 25 has been coated to the desired thickness, 15 the position and angle of the particle stream is changed to be perpendicular to the marginal portions 31, 33 of the plate 11 and batten strip 23, for application of the coating to approximately 10mm either side of the fillet weld. To improve the performance of the coating, a non-volatile, non-flammable sealants applied to the coating 30. The sealant works by filling interstices within 20 the inherently porous coating, thereby preventing contact between process liquor in the autoclave and the substrate of the coating. Contact between the liquor and substrate can lead to premature debonding and failure of the coating. The coating provides the following characteristics: 0 Not chemically attacked within the autoclave environment 25 e Does not crack due to shell stresses -12 " Has no apparent effect corrosion resistance of the underlying material (titanium) " Is wear resistant to the autoclave slurry " Can be applied in situe 5 9 Can be removed by conventional bead blasting By protecting the batten strip fillet weld 25, erosion damage will reduce and the life of the batten strips 23 will increase dramatically. Increasing the life of batten strips will allow for longer periods between scheduled shut downs of the autoclave and also a reduced risk of leakage. Maintenance costs will be reduced and 10 production capacity of the autoclave increased. Additionally, the amount of repair welding will decrease, reducing the risk of permanently damaging the explosion bonded titanium liner of the autoclave. In addition to batten strips 23, other internal components of the autoclave, such as baffle cleats, drain nozzles and other erosion-prone areas, could be coated. 15 Throughout the specification, unless the context requires otherwise, the word "comprise" or variations such as "comprises" or "comprising", will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated integer or group of integers but not the exclusion of any other integer or group of integers. Furthermore, throughout the specification, unless the context requires otherwise, 20 the word "include" or variations such as "includes" or "including", will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated integer or group of integers but not the exclusion of any other integer or group of integers. Additionally, throughout the specification, unless the context requires otherwise, the words "substantially' or "about" will be understood to not be limited to the 25 value for the range qualified by the terms.

Claims

1. A vessel comprising a plurality of titanium-clad plates welded one to another, batten strips welded to adjacent plates at the junctions therebetween, the batten strips being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the 5 edges thereof, and a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds.

2. A vessel according to claim 1 wherein the coating covers the fillet weld and marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip.

3. A vessel according to claim 2 wherein the marginal portions of the adjacent 10 plate and the batten strip covered by the coating each has a width of at least about 10mm.

4. A vessel according to claim 1, 2 or 3 wherein the coating has a thickness of 500 microns.

5. A vessel according to any one of the preceding claims wherein the coating is 15 applied using thermal coating technology, such as flame spraying.

6. A vessel according to any one of the preceding claims wherein a sealant is applied to the coating.

7. A vessel according to claim 6 wherein the sealant may comprise a non volatile, non-flammable sealant. 20

8. A junction between two titanium-clad plates, the junction comprising a batten strip welded to the plates, the batten strip being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges of the strip, and a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds.

9. A junction according to claim 8 wherein the coating covers the fillet weld and 25 marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip. WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 -14

10. A junction according to claim 9 wherein the marginal portions of the adjacent plate and the batten strip covered by the coating each has a width of at least about 10mm

11. A junction according to claim 8, 9 or 10 wherein the coating has a thickness of 5 500 microns.

12. A junction according to any claims 8 to 11 wherein the coating is applied using thermal coating technology such as flame spraying.

13. A junction according to any one of claims 8 to 12 wherein sealant is applied to the coating. 10

14. A junction according to claim 13 wherein where sealant comprises a non volatile, non-flammable sealant.

15. A method of performing reparation work on a vessel (such as an autoclave) fabricated from a plurality of titanium-clad plates welded one to another and having batten strips welded to adjacent plates at the junctions therebetween, 15 the batten strips being welded to the plates by fillet welds extending along the edges thereof, the method comprising the application of a coating comprising titanium dioxide on at least one of the fillet welds.

16. A method according to claim 15 further comprising applying the coating to adjacent portions of the plate and the batten strip. 20

17. A method according to claim 15 or 16 wherein the coating is applied using thermal coating technology, such as flame spraying.

18. A method according to claim 15, 16 or 17 sealing the coating after its application.

19. A method according to any one of the claims 15 to 18 further comprising 25 cleaning the area to be coated prior to application of the coating. WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 - 15

20. A method according to claim 19 wherein cleaning process comprises subjecting the area to a high pressure water spray.

21. A method according to any one of claims 15 to 20 further comprising pre heating the area to be coated. 5

22. A method according to claim 19, 20 or 21 the area to be cleaned is prepared to receive the coating by preparation comprising subjecting the area to abrasive blasting to achieve the necessary surface roughness for adherence of the coating.

23. A method according to claim 22 wherein the abrasive blasting comprising grit 10 blasting.

24. A method according to claim 23 further comprising removal of excess grit from the work area, such as by sweeping and/or vacuuming the work area.

25. A method according to claim 24 wherein the grit blasting and subsequent removal of excess grit are performed immediately prior to application of the 15 coating.

26. A method according to any one of claims 15 to 25 wherein the coating is applied first to the fillet weld, with the angle of incidence of the coating material being perpendicular to the exposed face of the fillet weld being coating and wherein once the fillet weld has been coated to the desired 20 thickness, the angle of the incidence of the changed to be perpendicular to the adjacent surfaces and the coating applied thereto

27. A method according to claim 17 wherein the coating is applied using a flame spraying process, the coating being applied first to the fillet weld, with the angle of incidence of the particle stream in the flame spraying process being 25 perpendicular to the exposed face of the fillet weld being coated, and once the fillet weld has been coated to the desired thickness, the position and angle of WO 2006/130916 PCT/AU2006/000788 -16 the particle stream being changed to be perpendicular to the adjacent surfaces and the coating applied thereto.

28. A vessel substantially as herein described with reference to the accompanying drawings. 5

29. A junction substantially as herein described with reference to the accompanying drawings.

30. A method of preforming reparation work on a vessel substantially as herein described.